Author Archives: SHG

What Juries Can Never Know

Norm Pattis posts about a letter he received from a jury foreman a few weeks after the trial, complaining that the jury convicted because it was unaware of its authority to nullify.  Norm muses, what would they have done if they realized that the defendant, acquitted of the top count but convicted of the lessers, would have to do at least 2 years in the can.


Of course, no one ever told this juror that there is a two-year mandatory minimum sentence in this case. Thus, a lenient judge sends my client to prison for two years. I wonder whether the jury would have convicted if they had known the truth?

Other than a capital case, the sentence is never (except in Texas, apparently) a subject for the jury.  Lawyers are prohibited from raising it, mentioning, suggesting it, so that we don’t taint the jury and “divert” them from their job, the determination of guilt.  After all, guilt is guilt, regardless of what sentence the legislature, sentencing commission, judge decides to impose.  To argue sentence is to plead for mercy, without regard to guilt or innocence.

And what’s wrong with that? 

The question of whether the jury, in reaching a verdict, should be aware of the seriousness (or lack thereof) of their decision has been decided against the defendant.  But in doing so, it has removed from the jury one of the fundamental purposes to the right to be tried by a jury of one’s peers.  They are the conscience of the community.  If not for this, it would be nuts to have ordinary people sit in chairs for days, weeks or months on end (except in Texas, where jury trials take 3 hours).  This takes them away from their lives, bores them to tears and requires them to listen to a foreign language (legalese) that means nothing to them.  That’s crazy.

We do all this, and make ordinary people suffer their civic duty, because we need them.  We need them desperately to serve as the buffer to a government that has all the power and all the answers, and who would happily let their agents lock people away without a second thought because, well, they can.

We, the People, can stop them.  The defendant is not on trial. The government is on trial.  You are not here to decide the defendant’s guilty.  You are here to decide whether the government can PROVE the defendant’s guilt.  They already have decided, which is why we are all sitting in this room.  But we have you, the jury, to stop them from locking people away at will.  You are the last hope of society to keep the government honest. 

But then we conceal a critical piece of information from the jury.  We cannot tell them what will become of a defendant should they find one way or the other.  The law says that should not matter.  But it does.

First, the jury always possesses the power to nullify a prosecution.  A dirty little secret that we also prohibited from mentioning, the jury never has to explain its verdict.  If it decides it doesn’t support what the government is doing, it can just say no.  Jurors don’t often know that they have this power, and are instructed that they cannot do this, but they can.  And no one, ever, can stop them.

But finding guilt is a relative process.  The more serious the consequences, the more seriously we take the responsibility.  We can decide whether, and how, to trade off our gut feelings for a life in prison.  When the jury thinks that a conviction, especially a lesser offense as in Norm’s case, won’t have particularly serious ramifications, they may be far more inclined to go for a compromise verdict.  Will they do the same when they realize that it is no laughing matter?  Will they do the same when they realize that their casual compromise means a person goes to jail for years?

If the answer to the question is yes, then there’s no harm in letting the jury know.  If the answer is no, then the legitimacy of the verdict is in doubt.  Either way, the ramification of a decision is part of the mix, something that jurors think about but lack the necessary information to make anything beyond a blind guess.  And too often, they miss the mark by quite a bit, leading them to wrongly assume that a conviction on a crime that they don’t take too seriously is just no big deal.  Bad decision by the jury?  So what, it’s not like it’s murder.  But it may result in the same sentence.

For all those who argue about the jury knowing the “truth”, I submit that this is a critical part of the truth that the jury is now denied.  You want a legitimate verdict?  Then let the jury give some thought to the consequences of their decision.  There’s just no sound reason to deny the conscience of the community the ability to make its decision based on the full panoply of influences, and with full knowledge of its power.

Graced with Another New Blawg, And One Previously Unmentioned

Sometimes I catch on to things right away.  Sometimes it takes me a while.  Today, it’s a little of both.  Sometime last August, a criminal law blawg arrived without much fanfare called Woman in Black.  Another anonymous blawger, I believe that she is a public defender, though not having read everything she’s posts, I admit to basing this on some assumption.

Woman in Black reminds me a great deal of Blond Justice, with a greater emphasis on the life of the Woman in Black as a criminal defense lawyer than criminal law itself.  Just a different perspective than here, and one that suits many people who seek to share their feelings about the job.

I supposed that if I parsed all the back posts, I could provide more information about Woman in Black, and might even find that my description isn’t sufficiently precise, but maybe she will stop by here and give us some greater insight into why she blawgs and let me know whether my brief description is accurate or not.

And the newest new kid on the block is yet another anonymous blawger at The Underblawg, not to be confused with Jon Katz’s brilliant The Underdog Blog (and not to mean that the Underblawg isn’t brilliant, but that The Underdog Blog is).  The Underblawger, as he calls himself, is definitely a public defender, as he tells us so, and explains his reasoning for going anon thusly:


I have chosen to remain anonymous for these reasons: First, I value my privacy. Second, I’m more inclined to tell the truth. Third, I don’t want to hurt any body’s feelings. One day I’ll probably unmask myself, but not today. Until then, please respect my desire to remain anonymous. Thank you.

Is he saying that those of us who blawg under our own name are inclined to lie?  Nah, I don’t think that’s his point at all.  His style is quite interesting, making his point through dialog rather than narrative.  He also shows a fine command of quotations, which are always interesting to me.   This is definitely a blawg to watch.

So I welcome both Woman in Black and  The Underblawg to the neighborhood, and look forward to reading more from them.

The Great Divide: China Edition

Dan Harris at  China Law Blog has a great post about why Chinese companies have such a hard time cracking the American market.  Who cares, you ask?  Ah, ye of little vision.  Dan’s points may be directed toward businesses, but they reflect a cultural divide that has the same impact when you represent Chinese nationals in criminal prosecutions.  His observations are highly relevant to criminal defense.

Having had the pleasure of representing many Chinese nationals (note for the hard of hearing: This is about Chinese nationals, not Americans of Chinese descent), dealing with differences in attitude and understanding is crucial to ethical and proper representation. 

Yes, this is America.  When someone from another country decides to step foot on American soil, they subject themselves to our way of doing things, our law, our assumptions.  This is a fine attitude, provided you’re a government agent or prosecutor.  As a criminal defense lawyer, this is fundamentally wrong.  We stand at the cross-roads where two cultures meet.  When those cultures have some fundamental differences, making one inconsistent with the other, it’s our job to reconcile the two.

The Chinese do not have a history that involves love of democracy and appreciation of abstract concepts of fairness.  There are a lot of people over there, struggling to survive and, if at all possible, thrive.  But their vision is limited to the here and now, not some wonderful long-term aspirations for the future. 

Survival to Chinese nationals can be summed up in one word:  Money.  They are extremely sensitive to the accumulation and retention of immediate wealth.  This means that they have difficulty appreciating why anyone would put off a dollar today to gain two dollars next week.  Who knows what will happen in the meantime, and they aren’t taking any chances.  It seems perfectly reasonable to do whatever you have to do to make money now, and have great difficulty understanding why we see this as a problem. 

This presents a problem in retaining counsel in a criminal case.  While they may understand that there are differences in lawyers, some being better than others, they remain very fee sensitive.  Essentially, they want good legal services, but there’s only so far they are willing to go to pay for them.  There reaches a point where the cost exceeds their interest in being well represented, and will not hesitate to walk away and take the hit when the cost gets too high.

Similarly, they tend to view lawyers as plumbers, hired to stop the leak.  They aren’t interested in the nuances of American law, just the result.  They want the problem fixed, and really don’t care about how we do it or what problems they face. Just stop the leak.

This presents numerous problems, and we need to recognize them and address them.  Under our system, there are decisions a defendant must make in the course of a criminal prosecution.  Explaining the nuances of the decisions across the cultural divide is often difficult, and sometimes impossible.  They’ve often told me to just make the decision for them, even though it’s not my decision to make.  It’s not so much that they repose such great trust in their lawyer, but that they expect their lawyer to know better, and that’s what they are paying for.  They have no belief in “justice” American-style, and just want to get out of the middle for the least possible cost.

And then, there are the “hard” differences, such as language and purpose.  We attribute intent to actions in America based upon a shared cultural understanding of values and norms.  We have notions of right and wrong, good and evil.  But these don’t necessarily apply across the cultural divide, where our priorities and relative values are not theirs.  As much as we hate to admit it, we still adhere to the Puritan ethic, and we view it as being a given that everyone thinks the same way.  The rest of the world has never shared our view, and to a large measure views it as silly, immature and just plain wrong. 

Finally, a short war story.  A long time ago, I represented a Chinese defendant in a narcotics conspiracy in the Southern District of New York.  After he was arrested, one of the agents who spoke so- Cantonese gave the defendant his Miranda warnings.  The problem was that the defendant didn’t speak Cantonese.  He was from the Fuchan province, and aside from his native dialect, spoke fairly good Mandarin.  But the agent didn’t speak Mandarin, only Cantonese.

We ultimately had an evidentiary hearing before a district court judge.  I put an acknowledged expert interpreter on the witness stand to explain the differences in the Miranda warning between Cantonese and Mandarin, and why the defendant would not have understood what he was being told.  The federal judge’s initial reaction, in light of testimony that not all the words were different, was whether a defendant needed to understand ALL the words in the Miranda warning, or whether some of them were enough.

After argument as to why all the words mattered, the judge, in frustration, asked the interpreter-witness to say the warnings, first in Cantonese and then in Mandarin.  The witness did as he was told.  After listening intently, the judge smiled, sat back and announced, “They sound the same to me.  Motion denied!”  That’s the sort of justice that Chinese nationals expect from American courts.  It can be a very tough battle.

The Great Equalizer

Over at Kevin’s Real Lawyers Have Blogs, the boy-wonder, Rob La Gatta, has been doing a series of interviews with bloggers of interest (as well as some that  aren’t very interesting at all).  Rob does some great work.  His  latest interview of Mike Dillon, the general counsel of Sun Microsystems, really made me think about what’s happening in the blawgosphere.

They say the Colt .45 was the Great Equalizer, but it doesn’t hold a candle to the blawgosphere.  We have lawyers and law professors, from the youngest to the oldest, the rookie to the very experienced, the person at the top of the food chain and the new-hire, all in the same space.

As Mike Dillon noted, there aren’t a lot of general counsels blogging out there at the moment, largely because they come from a time when this technology wasn’t part of their life rather than any disinclination to do so.  But companies and Biglaw are starting to blog.  Sure, they do it poorly, but it’s a start.

Online, we all look the same.  No one is black or white.  No one is male or female.  No one has a beautifully-made bespoke suit to dazzle all comers when contrasted with the pajama-clad home officer lawyer.  Before the blawgosphere existed, there was little chance that a solo criminal defense lawyer would cross paths with the general counsel of Sun Micro.  Other than having tables near each other at Bouley, we existed in different spheres.  Today, we’re cyberneighbors, and I can knock on his door anytime I please.  He can ignore me, but at least I know where he lives.

And today I know more about Harris County, Texas than I ever would have believed possible (or needed to know).  I have met a core group of lawyers around the country to whom I can refer cases, ask questions, and enjoy a camaraderie of my choosing.  This is nothing like the old days of NACDL meetings, where the closest we came was comparing the size of genitalia to see who was the most important lawyer in the room.

Even non-lawyers can get into the game.  Comments by lay-people can be informative, insightful, or just plain dumb, even though they think they’re brilliant.  But, for better or worse, they can access lawyers around the world who they would never have a chance to meet or question otherwise.

While I have a tendency to get a bit snarky with the lawprofs, the fact is that some of these guys are brilliant and offer true scholarship in their fields.  And I get to read their stuff and sometimes engage them in conversation!  Note  this comment by “Frank”, none other than  Co-Ops‘ own  Frank Pasquale, one of the best and brightest there is on health care law.  But here, he’s just Frank.  How cool is that?

Granted, some blawgers have a pompous tone, bespeaking the self-importance of the blawger.  I guess that’s their way of trying to show the rest of us that they are important and serious, even though they carry no greater weight around here than anyone else.  Whenever I get too big for my “breeches”, I have  Gideon to give me a smack.  I’ve occasionally posted a  snarky post or comment for others to do the same.  Some get it.   Others are just too self-absorbed to learn anything.  No matter, since they will survive or not on their own merit, regardless of how self-important they are.  In the blawgosphere, even the lowest on the totem pole can tell the highest to get lost.

But this is a world where people spend far more effort getting along, learning from each other, engaging in communication, rather than trying to be a “show off” in a new venue.  Who knows if the woman who just commented that she liked your post is the managing partner of some Biglaw firm, or general counsel of some major corporation.  Online, we all look the same.  The only thing that distinguished one from another is the content of our message. 

Thanks to Kevin and Rob for allowing me to realize just how revolutionary the blawgosphere can be.  How cool is that?  Very cool.

Car Searches: Supremes Take On Arizona v. Gant

The Supreme Court has granted cert in Arizona v. Gant, per  ScotusBlog and How Appealing.  This should prove to be an interesting case, where the issue is whether the police can search a defendant’s car after the defendant has been handcuffed, taken into custody and the scene is secured. 

In this case, the defendant, sought by police, drove up to the scene, got out of his car and walked over to a police officer, who promptly arrested him.  He was placed inside the police car.  But there was still the matter of what, if anything, might be inside his car, which was lawfully parked and otherwise wholly unrelated to the cause for arrest.  The police then searched the car, and found a gun and cocaine.

This case will test whether the old fallback, that the car may contain something of “imminent danger” to the cops, giving them a right to search for weapons.  Of course, it poses the question under circumstances where the potential for harm was non-existent, since the defendant was already cuffed and in the police cruiser.

According to Reuters,

The Arizona case will require the Supreme Court to reexamine its 1981 ruling that risks to officer safety and the preservation of evidence justify a warrantless car search as part of the arrest.

Arizona officials said the state Supreme Court effectively overruled the 1981 ruling in requiring that the police show that inherent dangers actually existed at the time of the search.

This is yet another example of remembering the rubric and forgetting the rationale.  The rationale for creating this exception to the warrant requirement was to protect the safety of police officers from imminent harm.  Fair enough, but once the defendant is away from the car, the contents of the car no longer present any threat.  End of story?  Not even close.

Automobile stop jurisprudence is a wreck.  More often than not, judges just throw up their hands whenever a car is involved, say that magic words, “automobile exception,” and let cops search at will.  Basically, they figure that the cops are going to end up searching one way or another, given that there are more exceptions than rule.  But the Arizona Supreme Court held this search unconstitutional.

So what will SCOTUS do?  Will Scalia, in a fit of reason, demand that the rationale for ignoring the 4th Amendment be honored and affirm the Arizona decision, or will the Court reverse and proclaim that when it comes to cars, there’s no 4th Amendment anymore?

Arizona v. Gant is a great case to test the integrity of the Supreme Court.  There is no rational justification for permitting this search under any existing exception.  No threat.  No search incident to arrest.  No inventory search.  No risk to preservation of evidence.  Nothing.  If they uphold the search, then they will prove that they have abandoned the 4th Amendment as to cars entirely, removing all reason from the equation.  It will take some mighty efforts to explain away that one, but they are smart cookies.

If ever there was a case that screamed “search warrant,” this is it.  We shall see whether there’s any vitality left in the 4th Amendment when it comes to searching automobiles.

And The Award Goes To…

Talking Points Memo.  What, you thought this was some Academy Awards post?  Like I care about that (or even know about that).  Nope, this is about how a blog beat the big boys.  That’s right.  Boys.  Big Media.  Big Government. 

The  New York Times reports that Joshua Marshall of talkingpointsmemo.com won the George Polk Award for Legal Reporting.  Winning the Polk is big.  Huge.  It’s the sort of thing that reporters tell their agents to start renegotiating the contract over when they win it.  They stand taller, their voice gets deeper and they cock their head to a more dashing angle when they look deeply into the camera.  They won a Polk.  They’re entitled.

Except this time they didn’t.  Marshall did.  A blogger, for God’s sake.  A BLOGGER! 

If you ever needed encouragement to blawg, look no further.  TPM proves it’s for real.

But it’s not over yet.  Oh no.  Not by a long shot.

You may recall that talkingpointsmemo  was dropped by our very own Department of Justice from its email list.


It seems that the government is just a tad short [on bandwidth], and is forced to cut  Talking Points Memo from its press release distribution list.  Darn, if only they could scrape up an extra kilobyte.  But alas, the last one is all used up and none left for TPM.

Well, it would appear that the government has decided to reallocate scarce resources to squeak out a few bytes for TPM.



Representative John Conyers Jr., Democrat of Michigan and chairman of the House Judiciary Committee, sent a letter to Attorney General Michael B. Mukasey asking about the Justice Department’s treatment of the Web site.


Talking Points Memo “revealed that it has recently been removed from D.O.J.’s press release e-mail distribution list,” the letter said.


“Who made this decision and why, and was there a change in policy in press release distribution after you became attorney general?” The next section of the letter addressed “Waterboarding and Torture.”


In a hearing on Feb. 7, Mr. Mukasey said he “was not aware of” the removal of the site from the mailing list, and last week it was restored. In an e-mail message on Friday, the Justice Department said the issue was simply about whether Talking Points Memo was “credentialed.”


Glad our government cleared that up.

Congratulations to Joshua Marshall, on both counts.

Will The Nader Effect Strike Again?

Eugene V. Debs ran 5 times as a Socialist for President, the last time from prison.  He didn’t win, but Debs got 1,000,000 votes from his prison cell in Atlanta. His last run was against Warren G. Harding (who commuted Debs’ sentence in 1921).  I wonder how many people wish they could take back their Harding vote. 

We have Ralph Nader.  For those of you who can’t figure out who Ralph Nader is and why anyone cares, in 1965, he published a book, Unsafe at Any Speed: The Designed-In Dangers of the American Automobile.  This book killed the Chevy Corvair, a very cool car but for the fact that it was patently unsafe.

Ralph Nader was the model of the American watchdog, a man unafraid of taking on anyone anywhere when he thought something was wrong.  It didn’t matter that he was always the underdog, always David to corporate Goliaths.  He  formed an organization to challenge government and corporations.  And he is running for President.  Again.

When Ralph Nader ran for President in 2000, it’s said that he siphoned off enough votes from Al Gore to throw the election to George Bush. 


Nader is still loathed by many Democrats who call him a spoiler and claim his candidacy in 2000 cost Democrats the election by siphoning votes away from Al Gore in a razor-thin contest in Florida. Nader has vociferously disputed the spoiler claim, saying only Democrats are to blame for losing the race to George W. Bush.

There are arguments to be made on both sides on this point.  Splitting the liberal vote is a reflection of mainstream Democrats efforts to position themselves for mass appeal to the middle, or to put it differently, abandoning liberal values to win an election.  As the Republicans positioned themselves further to the right to appeal to conservatives, Democrats positioned themselves further to the right to avoid being branded liberals.  That meant the left was available to Nader, since no one else wanted ownership of it.

It’s hard to imagine that Nader believes he has a chance to win, though I’m sure there are some nights when he has pleasant dreams of a presidency.  Instead, I suspect that he believes that he needs to keep traditional liberal values on the table since the Democrats have abandoned them in favor of becoming Republicans Lite.  If not him, who speaks for the individual who, like a lamb to the slaughter, has been manipulated into believing that things are going swell.

Still, the ironic by-product of Nader’s 2000 run cannot be ignored.  George Bush became our President.  Whether this is Nader’s “fault” may be subject to debate, but it is undeniable that this was the outcome under the circumstances. 

It may be that Nader is not unhappy with this outcome.  Only by pushing the nation to negative extremes can one fully appreciate how bad a choice it was.  George W. Bush is now a dirty word, much like liberal was before it.  No one wants the President’s endorsement, as it is viewed as the kiss of death.  Failed policies, lies and deception have made the sacrifices of the past 8 years seem like a sick joke. 

Have we learned anything?  Has Nader learned anything?  Will there be another “Nader Effect” this time around?  And if so, do we deserve it?  Stay tuned.

If You Don’t Believe Me, Then Read This

All the criminal defense lawyers who blawg say the same thing.  We tend to say it over and over again.  In my case, it’s usually because I can’t remember if I said it already.  With others, it’s repeated for emphasis.  You have the right to remain silent.  Use it.

But people talk.  They want to talk.  They need to talk.  Sounds just keep coming out of their mouths no matter what.  Since we have just had some interesting discussion of the continued viability of Miranda, and the  potential for videotaping to “cure” the Miranda disease, it seems opportune to raise the point (yet again) of why this matter so much that a bunch of lawyers would sit at their computers and continue to agonize over how best to make this work.

Of course, this discussion happened elsewhere as well, including at our favorite conspiracy.  One of the commenters there, Dave, is a cop.  I don’t know where he works, but he’s a stand-up guy.  With his permission, I’m reposting a lengthy comment from Volokh.  My purpose is to provide you with the cop’s perspective on Miranda, statements and people.  Sure, I’m just a lawyer dealing with defendants after they’ve been arrested.  Dave deals with them on the street, as the sounds emit from their mouths.  If you think lawyers are just blowing wind, read what a cop has to say:

[Edit Note: I’ve cleaned the comment up a bit to make it a little easier to read, but have not changed its substance in any way.]

….I’ve read the Miranda warning to suspects for 32 years It was my experience that those who had thought about it, or were con wise, or lawyers, knew that they were not going to waive and answer questions and told you very quickly that they wanted a lawyer. AND THEY SHUT UP.

…But most folks wanted to tell me their story. They thought they were arrested by mistake, or they could catch a break, or correct my bad impression about them and so they waived their right to silence and blithered on. Some of these folks were arrogant and were sure they could outsmart me by winging it. Or they had a story down pat and wanted to get it out as a demonstration of their innocence.

…The Miranda warning is so ubiquitous that most folks didn’t listen to the words. They’ve heard it so many times they turn off their ‘listeners’ and think of what they want to say next. And the spoken word has less authority than the written word. Crazy as it seems, many, many folks responded to my advisal as if it were an incantation…magic words, as though they were listening to the Latin Mass and had to be there but didn’t need to understand and weren’t responsible for what was said.

…YOU HAVE THE RIGHT TO REMAIN SILENT. ( yeah, yeah, I KNOW that )

…ANYTHING YOU SAY CAN AND WILL BE USED AGAINST YOU IN A COURT OF LAW.

…Few legal statements are as absolute as this one is. What part of ” Anything ” and ” Can and will ” don’t they get? But the majority would look at me and have no visible indication that they heard, understood or considered these words to be taken literally.

…YOU HAVE THE RIGHT TO SPEAK TO AN ATTORNEY AND TO HAVE ONE PRESENT WITH YOU WHILE YOU’RE BEING QUESTIONED. ONE WILL BE APPOINTED TO REPRESENT YOU, BEFORE QUESTIONING, IF YOU WISH ONE.

…Here’s where the smart guys said they wanted an Attorney. But most folks just looked at me with bored eyes glazed over, or looked away engrossed in watching something else.

…DO YOU UNDERSTAND THESE RIGHTS THAT I HAVE EXPLAINED TO YOU? HAVING THESE RIGHTS IN MIND, DO YOU WANT TO TALK TO ME NOW?

…I, like Whit [another P.O. commenter], found that most folks think they know the words. But it was my experience that few folks I Mirandized truly understood the meaning that is so succinctly stated therein. There is something wrong with a warning that so often is ignored. Perhaps it’s too much legaleeze, too glib, too ritualistic, or some other combination of too’s. But I’ve got to agree with that Berkeley Lawyer, it’s lost it’s warning effect and is not effective now, if it ever really was.

…Last point. Whether the suspect waives or not, they are still responsible for what they say. Go ahead and invoke, but don’t then get bored, or angry, or stupid and blither on about anything. One of my jobs is to tie you to a story. Your story of events. Maybe it’s true, maybe not. That isn’t all so apparent at the beginning of an investigation. But once you’ve said it (muttered, shouted, cursed or mumbled it) YOU OWN IT. If you’re going to invoke, choke yourself into silence. Don’t even ask questions (Will the Deputies let me go after I sober up?). Most folks don’t do that. ANYTHING YOU SAY…….

That last paragraph is one every defendant should read.  Dave is a straight-shooter, and isn’t posting this to mess around with people’s heads.  Once you’ve said something, “YOU OWN IT.”  And there’s nothing a lawyer can do to change that fact.

The Blogosphere, Mainstream Media, and Pain

This is something that needs to be passed along so that everybody who pays any attention at all to the blogosphere knows about it.  Thanks to  Jamie Spencer for letting me know. 

From Deus Ex Malcontent, the words of any angry, yet aware, former CNN producer/blogger:


As far as CNN (and to be fair, the mainstream TV press in general) believes, it still sits comfortably at the top of the food chain, unthreatened by any possibility of a major paradigm shift being brought to bear by a horde of little people with laptops and opinions. Although the big networks recognize the need to appeal to bloggers, they don’t fear them — and that means they don’t respect them. Corporate-think dictates that the mainstream television press as a monstrous multi-headed hydra is the ultimate news authority and therefore is in possession of the one and only hotline to the ghosts of Murrow and Sevareid. Sure those bloggers are entertaining, but in the end they’re really just insects who either feed off the carcasses of news items vetted through various networks or, when they do break stories, want nothing more than to see themselves granted an audience by the kingmakers on television.

This, of course, is horseshit.

Read the entire piece.  It’s well worth your time.

But For Video, Volume 28

Courtesy of  Jonathon Turley comes today’s edition of But For Video!

My personal favorite part is when Cookeville, Tennessee Police Officer Carlos Ferell, as he’s reaching in his pocket for a little weed to plant on the perp, turns toward the dash camera and mugs for the camera.  He just looks so darn cute when he does that, dontcha think?

Also of note before watching this video is the hand gesture used by the other officer to cue Ferell to plant the grass on the guy.  A group of cops who work together tend to develop little secret codes and gestures for doing things that “need to get done.”  For example, they will have a secret word to alert the other officers of a person who has a concealed weapon, so as not to alert the perp that they know he’s armed and prod him into using the weapon.

Here, however, they have a hand signal to plant drugs on the perp.  If they’ve got that set up in advance, then you have to assume this isn’t the very first and only time it’s ever happened.  “But Judge, Police Officer Ferell has a distinguished career of serving the community faithfully, and has never been caught planting drugs on a defendant before.”  It makes me wonder what the hand signal for “beat the living daylights out of this mutt” might be.

So get the popcorn out, call the kids and enjoy the show.