A big story yesterday was that a motorcycle cop escorting Hillary Clinton died when he crashed into a concrete barrier. This was a tragedy, “the death of Senior Cpl. Victor Lozada Tirado , a father of four and 20-year veteran of the force.”
It has long troubled me that the tragic death of a police officer or firefighter is viewed and treated so differently than the tragic death of anyone else. Hillary Clinton was affected by the death of this cop, and due to the direct connection between the two, it’s understandable that this would have a more significant impact, perhaps even suggesting that there was some indirect responsibility. I don’t begrudge Clinton her feelings in this instance.
But this gives rise to the general issue. When a police officer is killed in the line of duty, it’s a front page story. When a non-police officer dies tragically, with the same 4 kids and a 20 year career, it’s buried on page 14 if it appears at all. Do we care less about the lives of people who are not cops?
There is much talk on the campaign trail about the sacred cow of “our men and women in uniform,” yet we don’t hear about anyone dying in Iraq for the most part, and we rarely hear about any individual soldier’s death. Do they not count?
This is not to detract from the consequence of the death of a police officer or firefighter. It is to question why the death of others are not given the same prominence or shown the same level of concern.
When a police officer dies in the line of duty, there is often a fund created for her children so that they can attend college. People read about it and contribute to the fund. This is a good thing. When a civilian dies tragically, and she has children as well, are we less concerned about them?
There is a hierarchy in our concern for tragedy. Cops trump civilians. White trumps black, as can be seen when a pretty white girl is kidnapped and murdered versus a black girl, regardless of comeliness, about whom we hear nothing. Female over male as well.
Will this question be taken as a slight toward police officers? It shouldn’t be. I don’t raise the issue to say that we should neglect the significance of the tragic death of Cpl. Torado, or any officer. But I wonder why we don’t have the capacity or will to recognize the death of others with similar concern. All life is precious, and worthy of our attention. Tragedy is tragedy, whether it happens to a cop or anyone else.
Author Archives: SHG
Are Videotaped Confessions The Answer? (Updated)
Yesterday, I posted about lawprof Charles Weisselberg’s new article, Mourning Miranda. Gideon also posted about it, and brought up the subject of videotaping confessions. This has been the growing trend to resolve the issues of improper confessions, and many have viewed this as a panacea. I don’t.
The initial resistance to videotaping confessions comes from law enforcement. The primary problem there is logistical; they will need to pay the cost for the equipment and its maintenance and they will need to adjust their approach to actually use the equipment. There is the institutional resistance to change, and there is the hard problem of putting every perp in a room with a camera to record the statement. They don’t have that many rooms, and when the perp wants to talk, who are they to tell them, “No, no. You have to wait until we can videotape you.”
My problem is different. As with Miranda, not to mention so many other safeguards for the preservation of constitutional rights that have been turned upside down to be used as a weapon against defendants, I can see the use of videotaped confessions as a nightmare, easily manipulated and nearly impossible to overcome.
First, we have to bear in mind that any effort to protect defendants from abusive tactics will be met with a vigorous effort to circumvent the protection, and then develop ways to use it as a tool against the defendant. Videotapes seem particularly susceptible to this, even more so than Miranda warnings.
The interrogation begins the moment the cop faces the defendant. It starts on the street, in the cruiser, during the walk into the precinct. It goes on during booking and fingerprinting. It happens while they get the defendant a glass of water, a cheese sandwich, or let him use the bathroom. Interrogation is far more than the old Q&A under a hot white light. Every aspect of police-civilian interaction is designed to make a defendant talk. And talk they do.
By the time a defendant is seated in a room with a video camera rolling, the cops have long-since completed the psychological pressure necessary to undermine the defendant’s free will. In many cases, they have already obtained the statement, and the video will record it’s repetition, but without the manipulative aspect. But no one will ever see that part of it, and the cop will deny any effort to get the defendant to talk.
When a defendant is sitting in that video room in the precinct, 5 hours after his arrest, he’s not going to look very good. We may dress him up for trial, perhaps just like he was dressed up the moment before the cops pinched him, but nobody ever looks good in a police precinct (except Tom DeLay).
Appearances aside, the defendant’s mind is racing. What should he do? If he says the right thing, maybe they will let him go. Maybe because he’s innocent. Maybe because he’s not. But who knows? There will be no video of the psychological pressure put on the defendant as he is walked from the police cruiser or holding cell into the interrogation room. Did the cop tell him, “Hey, just admit to it and we’ll let you go right away. We want the big guy, not you.” In that moment of desperation, will the defendant buy it? They often do.
But the flip side of the videotaped statement is that part that puts the final nail in the coffin. We are a TV culture. We are moved by the sight and sound of what really happened at the end of every hour-long drama. Our doubts are put to rest, and we believe whatever is on the tape. Testimony is crap; the tape tells all.
Do you doubt this? In a recent trial, the police taped the third contact with a defendant, stating that the first was initiated by the defendant (and hence not taped), the second wasn’t taped because they had no machine, and the third was taped when the machine was finally available. By the time the third contact was taped, everything was said and done, and it was now just a matter of creating confirmatory evidence.
It was argued to the jury that the tape not only failed to confirm what had already happened, but was affirmatively misleading. It provided nothing to show how the defendant was manipulated in the first place, or how the defendant’s purpose shifted after he had already been subject to the manipulation, fell into the trap, and now sought to obtain the benefit promised by the cops to get him to succumb in the first place. The third tape was ugly and incredibly damaging.
In post-trial discussion, the jurors acknowledged that there was likely something to the defendant’s point, but they just couldn’t ignore the tape. There was a tape! They couldn’t get past it.
If videotaped statements become the rule, there are a few things we can bank on. First, the cops will be on their best behavior on camera. Second, it’s their house and their rules, and they will set it up to serve their purposes. Third, it will never show everything that matters. Fourth, it will be nearly impossible to overcome.
Sure, there will be the occasional cop who does something mind-boggling stupid on camera, just as they do now. But with more practice, they’ll get better at it. And if videotapes become the norm, we’ll never get rid of them and find ourselves arguing the same points of impropriety, but the harm will be much worse. No, I don’t think videotaping statements is the answer.
Updated: Gideon disagrees with me, and thinks that videotaping, while not perfect, is still better than we have now.
Balance in the Work-Life Continuum
Niki Black’s new blawg, Women Lawyers — Back on Track, is dedicated to the proposition that life and lawyering are not mutually exclusive for women. Niki drafted a statement in the February 2008 NYSBA Journal on behalf of NYSBA Gender Equity Task Force Commission:
Historically, legal employers have been steadfastly and notoriously reluctant to change the way business “has always been done” despite a growing outcry from associate attorneys struggling to balance their professional and personal lives. “It will affect our bottom line” is the oft-repeated refrain, offered to justify employers’ resistance to altering the traditional workplace structure.
As the statement goes on to explain, this isn’t merely a sexism issue, but one affecting all young attorneys. The bottom line is that the level of commitment that older lawyers have stuck in their head is changing, whether they like it or not, and they better start to adjust or else.
The Gen X and Y male lawyers are unwilling to sit in the library until 11 pm every night. They want a life, and the big salary isn’t enough to convince them to forgo it. They start out miserable, and end up leaving. Biglaw pays for the next group to fill the constantly changing shoes.
For women lawyers, the issue isn’t merely a matter of preference. If they have a family, there are demands that can’t be ignored. It’s not a matter of going out during the week to hang with friends, but coming home to feed the kids. Those darn kids want to eat. Every day.
One easy answer, let the daddies feed the kiddies, has given rise to retro-sexism. After all, if the women don’t want to do it, why should the men?
Edit: See also Marc Randazzo’s post at the Legal Satyricon , with this great quote from David Brooks in the Atlantic Monthly:
It is as if millions of American men—many of them well educated—took a look at the lifestyle prescribed by modern feminism and decided, No thanks, we’d rather be pigs.
And women have come to accept the proposition that living a male lifestyle isn’t nearly as good as it looked from the outside. In other words, nobody was having a party at the expense of the other. As Niki realizes, the impact may be much harder on women, but the problem exists for everyone.
Dan Hull at What About Clients? also brings up this dilemma. Not because he disagrees in concept with Niki, but because he fears that there’s no solution.
But then comes commerce and work. And then what? Even the most touchy-feely clients don’t care for longer than a second if you are pregnant, whether you have 1 kid or 10, what you favorite color is or whether your best 2 associates have the flu or worse. They care, in the final analysis, about their families, their businesses, their projects and their issues. It’s the way things are–and most of us are not in the business to make people evolve. Law and business are hard. Do it, adjust, or leave and teach–or sell women’s shoes…
Nor should they. They don’t pay lawyers for the opportunity to bond emotionally, to share in our feelings and issues. They pay for our professional services. They hired a lawyer. Not a man or a woman. Not a human being. A lawyer. Our problems are just that: ours. They just want us to handle their legal needs, without the baggage of our personal lives.
As lawyers, Dan is obviously right. We are paid to service our clients, and that’s what we are rightfully expected to do. But as a profession, Niki is right as well. We can accomplish much greater balance in life without sacrificing or shifting our lives onto the backs of our clients if only the business of lawyers comes to grips with a changing attitude toward how we service our clients.
Will we achieve the perfect balance? Unlikely, but we can do a whole lot better than we do now. But the resistance to change, as well as the negative attitude that goes along with any begrudging change, remains intact. My take is that older lawyers feel that they paid their dues, so younger lawyers have to suffer like they did. They view the miserable lifestyle as a rite of passage, proving the young’un’s unworthiness to join the club. They view those who promote change as whiners, incapable of toughing it out and unworthy of the rewards at the other end.
I’m not suggesting that Gen X and Y lawyers are completely in the right, by the way. If it was up to them, they would collect their paycheck and play video games all day. There is a lot of the slacker and the slovenly there. They are not interested in sacrificing their desires for the greater good. So the generation gap extends to the polar extremes, making everybody unhappy with each other.
When a litigator is on trial, there is nothing else happening in her life. This is a concession that every litigator makes to the job. But when not on trial, there are many ways to accommodate lifestyle while getting the job done. Today, with the internet, online law libraries, email and ECF submissions, we have opportunity to get work done from anywhere in the world at any time of the day or night. Using these tools is not a sign of weakness, but adaptability. Refusing to understand change, as so many law firms do, is a plain stupidity. It’s available for the using, and it’s no longer cute to reject anything that wasn’t done “that way” in your youth.
The last piece to this balance puzzle is the courts. Judges have little motivation to accept change or be concerned with an attorneys’ work-life balance. Courtrooms run today largely the same way they ran 30 years ago. A few new gadgets, but the demand that you be there on Tuesday at 9:30 am remains, and then sit there for 2 hours awaiting your 30 seconds before the judge. Judges have the authority to make demands, and few really care about much of anything beyond the efficient operation of their courtroom, no matter how much of pointless burden they place on lawyers in the process.
Until we get it into our heads that we are all in this together, and there is no reason why misery has to be a rite of passage for lawyers, we won’t make real headway on changing the way lawyers do their job. But as Niki’s new blawg proves, the push for change has been around for a while now, and every little has been accomplished. Maybe in another generation or two, we will start gaining an awareness that change can make life better for all of us. But I wouldn’t hold my breath.
Practical Blawgosphere: Pushing For the Objection
Shawn Matlock delves into the zen of objecting. Noting that his experience is that prosecutors object to technical errors because they are technical, without any consideration of the impact the objection will have on the jury, even though they leave the jury with the impression that they are trying to “hide” something.
Defense lawyers, on the other hand, object based on the circumstances of the trial, less concerned with technical errors if they are inconsequential to avoid the appearance of keeping the jury from hearing testimony that does no harm. Shawn then gets into the specifics of objecting during opening statements.
When I was in law school, my trial coach used to say that you should never object during the other side’s opening or closing. I don’t agree with that. Although I don’t hold fast to that rule, I will rarely object to a prosecutor’s opening. Mostly, because I know they will object to mine, and it’s more fun.
I feel like I’m not doing a good job if I don’t get objected to during opening. Why? Well, the first reason is I get to say what I want before they object. Secondly, prosecutors don’t think three steps ahead like we do. They hear something objectionable and the object. They don’t think about how it plays in front of the jury.Shawn’s right. In my earliest trials, I tried to avoid saying anything objectionable during the opening. Why? Because I shouldn’t do so. If it was objectionable, it was against the rules, and it was wrong to do something against the rules. Young lawyers are taught the rules, and we’re told that this is the way we should play the game.
The problem is that it’s not a game. It’s a person’s life, and there’s no satisfaction in playing by the rules but losing the game. We play to win. We play to keep a person from getting convicted, and that involves a strategic view of everything that happens, including how we open and whether we can get the other side to do something that will make them look obstructionist to the jury. Do we try to give the jury a false impression that the prosecutor is trying to conceal the truth from them? You bet.
The opening statement is where we get to speak, face to face, with the jury. We prime them for what we intend to do during the trial. We prepare them to think critically of the prosecution’s witnesses. We challenge the jury to challenge the government. Any lawyer who is more concerned about the rules than about using this opportunity to argue his case to the jury doesn’t understand what he’s doing up there.
During openings, I will make argument. I will testify. I will raise points that I seriously doubt that I will ultimately prove for lack of a witness to say so, but will plant the seed of problems with the prosecution’s proof and create the foundation for doubt. And after I get the words out, going beyond the scope of a proper opening statement, I listen for the objection. I anticipate it. I expect it. I’m ready for it.
If the objection doesn’t come, then I push the envelope farther. I will continue to push until I get every argument out on opening that I possibly can. If no one objects, I just keep going. The funny thing about the rules at trial is that if no one invokes them, there are no rules.
When the objects finally comes, I’m ready for it. I then highlight the objection in order to make sure that the jury knows that I was in the process of telling them something very important about the case, but the prosecutor doesn’t want me to do so. I make the prosecutor pay dearly for the objection.
Rarely do I object to the prosecutor’s opening. Rarely do they do anything objectionable. They are trained to play by the rules, and they usually do. They are a very rule-based group. I also want to be in a position to juxtapose how I let them open without interruption, but they refused to give me the same courtesy. People don’t like the sense that one side is behaving unfairly toward the other. And we all know that it is rude to interrupt.
When I teach at the ITAP program at Cardozo Law School, one of the other faculty members will often critique a student for asking a question in an improper but effective manner. This never comes out of the mouth of a criminal defense lawyer. Usually, it’s from a lawyer who has limited trial experience, who knows the rules and plays by them.
I tend to explain that I disagree; if the other side didn’t object, and the question was effective, then the student did well. Sure, they have to know how to properly frame a question, since the objection will force them to rephrase it properly or walk away from it. That happens a lot when the can’t figure out how to get the question out properly and finally give up. They tend to get stuck on one approach, and have problems shifting gears on the fly. This comes with experience.
But the one thing you never want to have happen is the judge telling you after the guilty verdict comes in that you did a wonderful job playing by the rules. The only rule that matters is to constantly think strategically so that you have given your client the best possible chance at the verdict he seeks. All of the other rules are just obstacles to overcome. If there’s no objection, you haven’t pushed far enough.
Getting More Than You Paid For
As the great philosopher Joni Mitchell wrote, “he was playing real good for free.” I’ve posted a few things recently about the problems and risks one takes when blawging. For some unknown reason, the existence of a blawg in cyberspace gives some people the impression that there’s a big brick building somewhere with lots of elves in the backroom collecting all the money that blawgs are making.
Now me I play for fortune
And those velvet curtain calls
Ive got a black limousine
And two gentlemen
Escorting me to the halls
And I play if you have the money
Or if you’re a friend to me
But the one man band
By the quick lunch stand
He was playing real good, for free.
But this is a one man band, sitting on a chair before a computer, tapping on keys to make words appear on the screen to reflect whatever thoughts are going on inside my head. There’s no cash draw, no credit card machine, no sound of cha-ching ringing in the background.
Nobody stopped to hear him
Though he played so sweet and high
They knew he had never
Been on their t.v.
So they passed his music by
I meant to go over and ask for a song
Maybe put on a harmony…
I heard his refrain
As the signal changed
He was playing real good, for free.
So if you find purpose in reading blawgs, enjoy their content whether because you agree or disagree, or just learn a little something, show a little appreciation. Nobody pays blawgers to sit in front of the keyboard, and nobody charges you to read whatever they write. You’re getting a good deal.
And if you disagree, even vehemently disagree, with what a blawger has to say or how she handles a topic that is dear to your heart, show some grace. You don’t have to hold your tongue, as most of us appreciate all legitimate comments, whether pro or con, but don’t act like we owe you something. We don’t. We’re playing real good for free.
Has Miranda Outlived Its Usefulness?
Lawprof Charles Weisselberg’s new article, Mourning Miranda, raises some very interesting questions about how a good thing can go south over time. Via Orin Kerr,
Weisselberg looks closely at how police officers in California are trained to conduct interrogations, and he concludes that the police interpret Miranda to let them do many of the things that the U.S. Supreme Court found objectionable in 1966 that led the Court to create the Miranda framework. Although Weisselberg has long been a noted defender of Miranda, he finds himself concluding that the Miranda experiment has been a failure:
. . . Miranda is now detrimental to our criminal justice system. It is bad enough that Miranda’s vaunted safeguards appear not to afford meaningful protection to suspects. But following Miranda’s hollow ritual often forecloses a searching inquiry into the voluntariness of a statement. I am skeptical that the courts may retool Miranda’s procedures. I suggest other possibilities, including legislation.
Anybody who watches a cop show on TV is familiar with the Miranda mantra, so much so that it usually has no impact at all when the familiar words are spoken. Criminal defense lawyers harp on the first line of Miranda all the time, “you have the right to remain silent.” Better than anyone, we know how people just can’t seem to do this, and just how much damage they do when the sounds start spewing from defendants’ mouths. We cringe all the time, as our clients explain why they thought talking to the cops was a good idea.
But Weisselberg’s statement, that Miranda has become “a hollow ritual [that] often forecloses a searching inquiry” rings true. Under the best of circumstances, the cop testifies that he read the defendant his Miranda rights “from this little card right here” and the defendant responded “yes” to all the questions. Whatever happens after that is invariably admissible, unless the defendant speaks the magic words that stop interrogation and the cop admits he did so. Of course, if the cop is that honest, he will respect the invocation of rights in the first place and there won’t be any post-invocation interrogation.
But as Weisselberg correctly recognizes that the police haven’t been sitting around eating donuts since Miranda was decided. Well, okay, they have, but they have people who do stuff while they are sitting around eating donuts. These people have figured out how to use sophisticated psychological pressure to undermine the exercise of free will that Miranda was supposed to protect.
Since Miranda was decided, the Supreme Court has encouraged police practices that have effectively gutted Miranda’s safeguards. This paper presents police training materials that are not generally available to the public. Training is a primary link between the Court’s pronouncements and the way in which interrogations are actually conducted. Combined with the social science literature, these training resources demonstrate how the warning and waiver regime coheres with a sophisticated psychological approach to police interrogation, rather than operate apart from it, as the Court intended.
Somehow, judges who hear suppression motions don’t seem to recognize that this sort of thing happens. Bad judge. Bad judge. The truth, of course, is that we all know too well that the cops know how to squeeze a statement out of a defendant with some subtle psychological ploys, and that defendants fall for this over and over again.
So why don’t well-intended, intelligent, fair-minded judges put a stop to these mind-games that cops use to overcome the exercise of free will by defendants? Miranda! Once the cops say the mantra, all bets are off. The defendants have been duly warned, and the cops are now free to exert whatever pressures they can to get the bad guys to talk. Miranda has tipped the balance away from an actual inquiry into the voluntariness of a confession, toward the rote application of the rule. Courts love rote applications of rules. It makes their job infinitely easier.
Few on the defense side favor the end of Ernesto Miranda’s legacy, mostly because we’ve lived with it for a long time and gotten used to it being there. But Weisselberg’s point is persuasive, and Miranda may have outlived its usefulness. Perhaps it will serve better in a post-Miranda environment, where the mantra no longer ends the inquiry, but remains a fixture in everyone’s mind.
But bear in mind, an ugly truth for most criminal defense lawyers is that defendant need very little pressure to start talking when they snap the cuffs on. More often than not, they can’t help themselves and the words that will hang them just start coming. And they don’t stop until the cops have enough to lock up the conviction and get bored. Then they just walk away and return to their donut, praying that it hasn’t gotten stale.
Rental Cars Find New Revenue Stream
This morning on the Today Show (Lester Holt edition), an interesting story about how rental car companies deal with the problem of renters getting tickets, fines, whatever, in their cars. Let’s say you don’t have two dimes when you have to go through a toll booth in your Ford Fiesta from Enterprise Rent-a-Car. Eh, big deal, right? Well, when you see a charge for $25 on your credit card 6 months later from Enterprise, you are not going to be pleased.
This is the latest game for rental car companies. On the one hand, if you get the parking ticket (or blow through the toll booth), what makes you think this ought to be their problem? This was a nightmare for rental companies, who were forced to either track you down or eat the cost of your breaking the law. Not nice. Not responsible. And not something that they should have to deal with.
But along came companies like Violations Management Services. This was a very smart concept. It proposes to turn a huge problem for rental companies into a profit center. Get a $10 parking ticket (and keep it to yourself), and have your credit card charged $100. Or maybe $1,000. If you thought that you beat the system when you walked out of the rent-a-car place without them knowing about your “little indiscretion,” you got another thing coming.
These businesses certainly need to deal with the fact that they aren’t there to pay your fines. And there are costs associated with this problem, managing this otherwise totally non-productive cost, tracking you down, obtaining payment. There is no rational reason under the sun that the rental companies should eat these costs.
But turning civic violations into private profit centers is another matter. Does 10 times the fine, or 100 times the fine, relate rationally to the wrong? There is no connection between the handling of this problem and the amounts being charged. Essentially, the rental companies are levying a fine of their own on top of the government’s fine. And yes, they are turning what was once a problem into a new-found revenue stream and making some good money on the deal.
What should you do about it? The best answer is don’t break the law and get the fine. The second best answer is deal with it when it happens, rather than try to skip out on it. If it never happened and you dispute that you deserve the fine, you are going to have a problem. First, it can only be addressed where the violation allegedly occurred, and second you are likely going to have some difficult problems, both with getting the information from the rental company and dealing with the local authorities due to time bars (you’re too late to challenge the violation) and distance.One invisible victim of all this: due process. It’s very difficult for consumers to get a copy of underlying citations in rental car violations, giving them little or no chance to invoke their rights to adjudication. It is alarming to think private companies can act as enforcement agents for municipal authorities without having to abide by normal due process procedures.
It’s also alarming to think about the perverse incentives created by the “summons incentives” paid by firms like Violation Management Services. Parking tickets are already often abused by local governments as hidden taxes; privatizing that process and adding even more to the cost seems positively un-American.
You can certainly argue the point with a customer service representative, who will no doubt apologize for the “inconvenience” and then explain the company policy that she is powerless to change. So I have no fail-safe solution to offer, but just provide this tidbit as a public service. Consider yourself warned.
Housekeeping: Anon Comment
A little housekeeping issue that needs to be discussed. Comments here require a real email address. They aren’t going to appear without one, unless I go into the control room and manually approve them. I do this from time to time, but I can’t guarantee that it will happen or when.
Just today, one commenter (with a great comment) listed the email address as [email protected]. Cute but unhelpful. And [email protected] is not as cute but equally unhelpful. Your email doesn’t show up in the comment, but it is required for your comment to post. That’s just how it works.
Why, Greenfield? Why, why? A few reasons. First, to eliminate spam comments, always a problem. As Simple Justice became more popular, we became a target for spammers with literally hundreds of trackbacks and spam comments daily. But the robots can’t input the code, and the human spammers don’t want me to know who they are.
Second, there are some nuts out there. They leave some very unpleasant comments. In one instance, there was a commenter who was stalking another commenter, and left some very nasty stuff about them in a comment. Not in my home, you don’t.
But what about my 1st Amendment rights, Greenfield? I want my rights! Well, the government is prohibits (sometimes) from interfering with your right to free speech, but I’m most definitely not the government. You have no 1st Amendment rights here. It just doesn’t apply.
A while back, one of my favorite blawgers, Susan Cartier Leibel, told me that if I insisted on only playing by my rules here, I would end up playing alone. But my purpose is different from Susan’s, who uses her blog to market her business. If no one wants to play by my rules, then I’ll play by myself (It’s not like it’s never happened before).
Now all of this is about including a real email in the little box that says “email required.” You don’t have to use your real name. Everyone is entitled to be a coward, if they want (only partially kidding). But when it says that a real email is required, that’s what it means. There’s a little guy inside my computer who personally checks every email address, and if it’s not real (or not yours), he knows.
Most of the anonymous comments are awfully good, and I would very much like to make sure that they see daylight. So include your real email address in your comments so that they make it onto the screen. As Dan Quayle tried to say, a mind is a terrible thing to waste. So don’t be a potato(e)-head and spend all that time writing a brilliant comment only to have it fall into the spam box.
Thank you.
Die or Comply: The “Right” of Self-Defense
Conspirator David Kopel argues that there is a “human right” of self-defense. His point was to distinguish it from a legal excuse, such as duress or insanity, and to argue that the right to self-defense should be recognized as a human right and forms the basis of international law.
This is one of those issues that is best decided in the school yard than the courtroom. If a kid punches you in the nose, you have the right to punch back. But schools have new rules these days, where they have “zero” tolerance for violence. So a basic school yard fight breaks out, both the initial aggressor and the defender are punished. Besides fighting human nature (the “fight or flight” response), this sends a conflicted message: The victim must make a choice between survival and compliance with the rules.
Granted, the school yard punch isn’t generally a death blow, but it often becomes one as school children grow up and the weapon isn’t a 12-year-old fist but a tire iron swung at one’s cranium. Sometimes, the simple answer is the only viable one: If you do not defend yourself, your dead. They can speak of what a law-abiding fellow you are, but it will be in your eulogy.
There must be a definitive right to self-defense. The option cannot be comply and die. Neither the law nor reason can require that a person be forced to choose between survival and suffering a criminal sentence. When we (or are children) are threatened with harm, we must do whatever is necessary to defend/protect ourselves. I reject the notion that anything else is right.
The problem is that the law still doesn’t see it this way. As with all things legal, we have created a construct of nuanced rules that compel the victim of potential harm to take certain actions, to certain degrees, under certain circumstances. We require retreat where, in the eyes of those who were not functioning with the proverbial gun to their head, think it feasible. We allow “reasonable” force to defend, but no more. Deadly force may be acceptable, but only when threatened by deadly force viewed through the prism of calm deliberation.
The problem is that choices are not made in a calm, thoughtful environment. No matter how smart the actor, how knowledgeable, humans react to threats instinctively. The adrenalin pumps and we do what we have to do, or what we perceive we have to do, to survive. If you’re punched once, are you allowed only one punch in return? After that, do you become the criminal, subject to punishment for the second or third punches?
This dilemma went through my mind yesterday as my wife and I drove our son to a fencing tournament in New Jersey. It had snowed fairly heavily (for Long Island) and the roads were still in rough shape. But the tournament was on, and it was our duty as parents to get him there.
Due to lack of practice, neither the plows nor the drivers around here do a very good job in the snow. As trucks drove through large piles of slush on the road, it kicked up on the sides and splatters onto vehicles in the next lane with shocking force. At best, it blinded the drivers. At worst, it seemed as if it would break the windshield. There was no way to stop it. But there was an alternative.
To the far left was a High Occupancy Vehicle (HOV) Lane. Between the regular travel lanes and the HOV lane was an area of dead space, marked off with lines, which no one is ever allowed to cross. This is an ironclad rule. As my wife was driving, I told her to cross the lines and go into the HOV lane, where we would have much greater distance from the trucks and potentially avoid being blinded if not worse from the icy slush. She refused, at first, She found it impossible to break the rule.
“Would you rather die?” I asked. It was that dangerous. She did it. As this happened, I pondered my right to survive. Any port in a storm. When my life, or the life of my family, is at risk, I will do whatever I have to do to defend it. There is no rule, no law, that trumps my right to survive or protect my family.
As my wife crossed through no-man’s-land, I thought to myself that if some cop stops us for breaking the law, I am fully ready to defend. There was absolutely no doubt in my mind that I have a basic human right to take whatever actions are necessary, under the circumstances, to defend. And that no cop, prosecutor, judge or jury has the authority to tell me that my choice was wrong and that if I was a “good” person, I should have opted to comply with the law. And died.
Only One Post Today?
I tried. I really did. But this was too perfect.
From xkcd via Volokh.
Then there’s this comment, which is really, really sick.
At least he’s in the act of typing out a comment.
I’ll stay up an extra few minutes just to see if anyone else will (wrongly, of course) challenge one of my recent comments.
Sound like anyone you know?
