Author Archives: SHG

Breaking Blog News: Don’t Break News

There has been a theme of late suggesting that far too many judges slept through their Constitutional Law class.  At least the part about the First Amendment’s guarantee of free speech.  The latest involves a website called wikileaks.org. 

Don’t bother to click on the link.  It’s dead air now.  Why?  A federal judge ordered the domain registrar to pull the plug on it. According to this editorial in the San Jose Mercury News,


In a suit filed by a Swiss bank complaining that Wikileaks had published confidential bank records, federal District Judge Jeffrey S. White last week signed an order directing the Web site’s Internet domain registrar to disable the wikileaks.org domain – resulting not only in removal of the offending bank documents, but the entire wikileaks.org site, including documents that were the basis for major news stories on the U.S. military’s rules of engagement in Iraq (in the New York Times), treatment of terrorist suspects held at Guantánamo (Wired.com) and official corruption in Kenya (BBC News), among others.

This ruling is called “breathtaking”, and indeed it is.  For obvious reasons, mainstream media has raised its collective voice and cried foul over this trampling of constitutional rights, from its prior restraint to the death of a website because of uploading one set of documents that is challenged.  Even the  New York Times got into the action.  Not surprisingly, they compare it to ending the publication of a newspaper because there was a problem with one article.

The mainstream media interest in this ruling out of San Francisco is a matter of self-interest.  It’s not that they love and admire the blogosphere to greatly that they are standing shoulder to shoulder with their blogging brothers, but that they see this as precedent that can, and eventually will, be used to stifle them.

But there’s a difference.  Newspapers are big business.  They are well-funded (even if not particularly profitable) and equipped to do battle with the government or some shady bank in the event that someone hauls them into court.  They can galvanize support through their reach amongst others in the media, as well as their readership.  They carry weight with politicians and can influence elections.

We, on the other hand, are just a bunch of blogs.  With a few rare exceptions (such as  David Lat and Ted Frank), nobody owns us and nobody finances us.  These are labors of love, not money.  We do not have the ability to finance a defense against all comers, or courts determined to view us as gnats annoying more important players, like banks or governments.  But we are, clearly, sufficiently annoying gnats that important players may want us to go away.

While mainstream media has come out with editorials decrying Judge White’s order shuttering wikileaks.org, I’ve heard nothing about a defense fund having been raised to aid it through its litigation.  To newspapers, words are cheap.  They have tons of them in the storage closet and pulling a few out for some editorials costs them nothing.  Where is the real concern, as shown through hard cash, legal support and amici?

There is a parallel here between the defense of free speech and the defense of criminal defendants.  It is always the smallest and weakest amongst us that ends up being the test case.  Clarence Earl Gideon was a “nobody”.  So was Ernesto Miranda and Danny Escobedo.  Yet each of these names is enshrined in our criminal law because a lawyer somewhere did his job and changed the face of criminal jurisprudence.

Who will stand behind wikileaks.org?  Where are the battery of attorneys that the New York Times keeps on the shelf for just such a challenge?  Now I’m not suggesting that Simple Justice is critical to the continued existence of western civilization by suggesting that the mainstream media needs to do a little more than pat the loser on the back and say they’re sorry for their loss.  But blogs are the runt of the media litter, and roundly misunderstood by the courts.  If bad law is going to come, it will be through us.

On the other hand, blawgs to have their impact.  Take a look at how the Texas Tornado, Mark Bennett, has been at the center of the Chuck Rosenthal (the now-former Houston “love” District Attorney) and broke most of the news that later appears (without proper attribution) in newspapers nationwide.   If anybody thinks that Mark wasn’t instrumental in this scandal, they’re dead wrong.  A blawg can make a difference. 

If you, fellow-blawger, found yourself the named defendant in a federal suit tomorrow, would you be willing to put your practice on hold, commit your life savings and family’s security to the fight, to fight the good fight for your right to exercise freedom of speech?  I probably would, just out of spite.  I bet Bennett would too.  But many would not.  Would the New York Times come to the rescue?  Would anyone?

How Hard On Restaino?

You may remember the upstate New York judge who  flipped out when a cellphone went off in his courtroom?  Well, Niagara Falls Judge Robert Restaino now awaits the Court of Appeals decision on his fate. 

After jailing 46 people who had the misfortune of being in his courtroom at the time the phone rang, Restaino became the latest poster boy for judicial intemperance.  The Commission on Judicial Conduct recommended removal for his conduct, except for divorce lawyer Raoul Felder, the Paula Abdul of the commission, who was more concerned for Retaino’s self-esteem than the 46 people he locked up.

As reported by  Carolyn Elefant at Legal Blog Watch, the  New York Law Journal has a story about a sudden outpouring of concern for Restaino.


New York state’s Court of Appeals last week accepted 10 amicus curiae briefs filed by legal, judicial and civic groups, all pleading with the court to spare the job of Niagara Falls City Court Judge Robert M. Restaino.

The amicus briefs cite Restaino’s spotless 12-year judicial record, his standing in the community and the isolated nature of the incident in his courtroom on March 11, 2005, as all weighing in favor of the court reducing his punishment to censure.

To tell the truth, for a Niagara Falls judge to have 10 amici back him up is quite impressive.  Based upon my admittedly biased New York City calculations, that’s one amicus brief for every 2 lawyers in practice above the Bronx.

My earlier information, based upon my spies in the Niagara Falls area, was the Restaino was, shall we say, a bit inflexible as a judge.  He was rather firm in his treatment of people.  He was, in fact, a very self-important judge who was taken with his power and authority.  He ruled with an iron fist.

This could be said of a lot of judges.  And it could also be argued that judges who do not run a tight courtroom are not doing their job.  Courts are not supposed to be fun places, and a well-run court may not be the kind of place you want to hang out for kicks, provided the judge performs her function well otherwise.

So what do we do about Restaino (as if it were up to us)?


Dan Slater at WSJ Law Blog asked readers whether Restaino should face removal for “two hours of inexplicable madness” — and the commenters aren’t very sympathetic towards the judge.

As for [Carolyn], while [she] feels badly for Judge Restaino, ultimately, he’s getting the punishment he deserves.  The 46 defendants who showed up for court to appear in domestic violence cases and wound up in jail didn’t get a second chance.  Why should the judge who put them there?

This is a close call for me.  Not because Restaino’s conduct shows any evidence of self-control or mercy.  It doesn’t.  Not even because he had 12 years of (theoretically) “unblemished” service, a dubious claim as far as I hear.  After all, nobody gets their first murder free.  The biggest factor holding me back from playing the Queen of Hearts is that this is the death penalty for a judge, and it’s hard to condemn a person to the ultimate sanction without certainty that this wasn’t truly aberrational conduct.  In other words, I would cut Restaino more slack than he’d cut the people in his courtroom that day.

But then, sitting in judgment of others isn’t a right.  It’s a privilege, earned on a daily basis.  This excess of zeal on Restaino’s part reflects something deeply disturbing, and gives rise to concerns that this is not the first time he’s lashed out in anger, but merely the first time it’s been publicly recognized.  To this end, I would have to defer to the judgment of the other members of the Judicial Conduct Commission, which is not generally inclined to be terribly harsh to judges. 

If they believe, as they do if we remove Raoul from the mix, that Restaino should not be sitting on the big bench, then it tips the scale in favor of removal.  And given what happened, plus the fears that his harsh decisions toward individuals would never blemish his record, the record is hardly so clear that Restaino deserves any further sympathy. 

Encouraging Incompetence: The Supremes Munch on Herring

For many, the exclusionary rule (the rule that says that evidence seized in violation of the 4th Amendment must be suppressed) is one of the bedrocks of criminal law.  For others, including some of our favorite Supreme Court Justices, the rule is a judicially-created stumbling block that rewards the criminal for the constables’ error.  We will soon see who is who in Washington, since cert was  granted yesterday in Herring v. United States.

The facts are described in this New York Times article :

In this instance, officers in Coffee County, Ala., arrested a man, Bennie Dean Herring, in 2004 after being informed by the Sheriff’s Department in neighboring Dale County that he was the subject of an outstanding warrant. But the warrant, although still in Dale County’s computerized database, had in fact been withdrawn five months earlier. In the 10 or 15 minutes it took for the Dale County officers to realize their error, the Coffee County officers had already stopped Mr. Herring, handcuffed him, and searched him and his truck, finding methamphetamine and an unloaded pistol.

Both the district court and the  11th Circuit rejected Herring’s argument.  The courts extended the “good faith” exception of United States v. Leon, 468 U.S. 897 (1984), which allowed searches based upon reliance of an ill-gotten search warrant because the basis for the exclusionary rule, to deter police from engaging in unconstitutional conduct, would not be served if the error was made by the court rather than the cops.

So now it comes to the Supreme Court, and we may be in for a very unpleasant surprise. 


In the 2006 decision to which the 11th Circuit referred, Hudson v. Michigan, five justices expressed deep reservations about the utility of the exclusionary rule. That 5-to-4 decision refused to apply the exclusionary rule to evidence found by police officers who burst into a Detroit man’s home to execute a search warrant without first knocking and giving the man a chance to respond. Justice Antonin Scalia’s majority opinion appeared written to solicit further challenges to the rule’s application.

The Herring case provides the court with the opportunity to divorce the exclusionary rule from the warrant requirement, where up to now the good faith exception was limited to reliance on a court-issued warrant.  But Herring may extend good faith to reliance upon inaccurate computer data, under the theory that the unconstitutional conduct of the searching and seizing officer would not be deterred by suppression since it’s not his fault that the information was erroneous.  This case may well be the hole in the exclusionary dike.


Often in the past, the Supreme Court’s acceptance of a criminal defendant’s appeal suggested that the court was inclined to overturn the conviction. But this appeal, Herring v. United States, No. 07-513, which was prepared as a student project of Stanford Law School’s Supreme Court litigation clinic, might turn out to be a case for Mr. Herring of “watch out what you wish for.”

Let this be a lesson for those lawprofs who want to teach their students a thing or two about the Supreme Court as well.

This potential extension of the good faith exception, and I emphasize “exception”, is that it rewards the government for maintaining a sloppy and erroneous database.  Indeed, if they diligently input negative information, such as warrants, traffic tickets, whatever, but are less than diligent about removing them, should they achieve far greater latitude in searches and seizures?  Essentially, the worse they do the job of deleting old or erroneous information, the more authority they have to exercise good faith in seizing people.

Chipping away at the exclusionary rule has been one of the favorite sports in Washington for a while now.  Remember Whren?  Without announcing that the rule itself has outlived its usefulness, the Court has crafted exception after exception to what was intended to be a straight forward incentive to live by the Constitution or suffer exclusion. 

The potential damage that Herring can bring to the rule is obvious.  Your constitutional rights (and mine) will become contingent upon the diligence (or lack thereof) of some clerk somewhere in the bowels of some government building somewhere who deletes (or doesn’t) information.  Should the Court separate the good faith of the cop on the street from the good faith of the data clerk, or is the clerk (and the clerk’s superiors?) under no obligation to get anything right, thereby conferring broad authority on the street cop to act in good faith on erroneous data? 

Given the implied connection of the “fellow officer rule,” where a cop enjoys the benefit of information he personally lacks but is entitled to rely upon through another cop, it seems that it should be a two-way street when it comes to being held responsible for maintaining an accurate database.  There should be no good faith benefit for the street cop when the counterpart in front of a computer screen is providing erroneous information.  After all, if the street cop enjoys the benefit of the fellow officer rule, then he should also suffer the detriment of the database error rule.  Only by imposing a cost will law enforcement have an incentive to maintain accurate databases and avoid search and seizures that we thought were prohibited by the Constitution.

Secret Blawgers, Pro and Con

A discussion has broken out at the new criminal law blawg,  Bad Court Thingy (an explanation of the name for those of you who are not as attuned to pop culture as I am can be found here), who complains about my comment that BCTs anonymity is “inexplicable”.  This generated a minor debate about the subject of anonymous blawging.

I am not a fan of anonymous blawgers.  It’s often impossible to appreciate the significance of the message without having some idea of the perspective of the writer.  As I wrote in a comment, whether the writer has been a lawyer for 2 weeks, 2 years or 2 decades makes a difference.  Similarly, is the writer a public defender, a private criminal defense lawyer, a prosecutor or a non-lawyer provides context for the message.  Expectations and understanding of meaning differs markedly based on the writers background.  It matters.

Aside from the writers background, the choice of not putting one’s name to one’s opinions also presents an issue.  Are you ashamed of what you think?  While the name itself is unimportant, it’s the act of attribution that matters.  Like some small person driving dangerously, anonymity emboldens people to express opinions that they lack the guts to stand behind. 

It appears that I’m not the only who thinks anonymity affects credibility.  At lawprof  Nancy Rappaport’s blog, she concludes that only cowards post anonymously.  Granted, she was talking about comments rather than blawgers, but the logic remains the same.  The comment to Nancy’s post by Dean Jim Chen makes the point that, like evidence, the lack of source impacts on weight and sufficiency.

I concur, and believe that anonymous posting impairs credibility, and in some instances, brands them a coward.  Do they fear reprisal from the courts?  Do they think clients won’t like them if they know what they think?  Do they just want to show machismo that they would never display if anyone knew who they were?  By exposing their identities, it tells me that they believe what they write and are ready to take the heat for it.  I respect that.

Grits for Breakfast, a/k/a Scott Henson, takes issue.  Scott argues that I seek to “judge the messenger in lieu of judging the message.”  I think Scott misses the mark by a wide margin.  In fairness, Scott isn’t a lawyer (and makes no bones about it), despite the fact that Grits is one of the best and most respected blawgs around.  While this proves that the message surpasses the messenger, it does not change the fact that understanding the message often requires us to have some clue about the messenger.  The messenger provides the context of the message, and these intertwined concepts preclude such a simple (though well-phrased) analysis.

Nor do I see it as mere idle curiosity, as  Jamie Spencer does, an interesting but inconsequential detail.  While there may be times when an observation is sufficiently meaningful that it’s author becomes irrelevant, there are far more times when the observation is meaningless in the absence of the author’s background.  An observation about how clients can be difficult by a new lawyer is often quaint, but by an experienced lawyer the same observation can be just plain dumb.  If you haven’t figured out the basics in 20 years, then there’s something seriously wrong here.

On the other hand, there are blawgers like  Gideon who, as a public defender as well as individual with strong opinions, has been compelled to blawg anonymously because of hard circumstances.  His views are his, but if he revealed his identity, there would be a problem with his views being attributed to his employer.  Gideon is forced into the shadows for this reason, but has established himself as one of the premier blawgers because of his longevity and the quality of his efforts.  The same is true of Skelly at Arbitrary & Capricious.  I don’t know whether either could go public under other circumstances, but I can understand why they can’t given their current situation.

Of course, it doesn’t really matter what I think since I lack the power (or inclination) to unmask anyone who elects to blawg anonymously.  I actually know who some of the anonymous folks are, and I’m not telling.  But the strength of your opinions, the merit of your observations and the reliability of your information does bear a relationship to who you are, what your experiences are and whether you are willing to stand up and be counted.  If you have no good reason to keep your identity under wraps, yet choose to blawg anonymously, then that tells me something about you as well, and it isn’t pretty.

I’m not saying I won’t read you, and I’m not saying that I won’t find merit in your message.  But I am saying that you haven’t done as much as you could do to allow me to appreciate your message or convince me that you really mean what you say.  Of course, even an anonymous blawger with a strong message is better than a disclosed blawger who never seems to have much of a message to begin with.

But For Video, Volume 27

Let me say this as clearly as humanly possible:  If there is no video, you lose.  The lesson is that simple.

Last week, former NFL quarterback and current sportscaster Josh Booty was tasered following a DWI arrest.  He deserved it.  How do I know?  Because there was no video.  No outrage.  No cries for justice.  No cop arrested, or at least fired, after Booty ended up tased and sporting a black eye and other injuries following his arrest.  If a former NFL quarterback and current sportscaster can’t be arrested without ending up hurt, do you really think you’re safe?

Compare this woman in Shreveport arrested for DWI. 



She’s not famous.  In all likelihood, she can’t throw a decent spiral.  And yet her ending up lying in a pool of her own blood, with her face showing evidence of a real good “tuning”, unlike Josh Booty, has generated outrage.  Why?  Video. 

This woman was hardly what one would call eminently cooperative.  Drunk people are like that sometimes.  But the point remains that the failure to do as you’re told is not a reason for a cop to beat a woman.  Some of you will watch this video and say she deserved it, she should have just done whatever the cop told her to do and then she wouldn’t have been beaten.  Hopefully, not too many of you will say that, and none will be foolish enough to post a comment to that effect. 

And to those police officers who come here to gawk at how the other half thinks (and you know who you are), please explain how an officer can beat a hand-cuffed woman like this?  Can you seriously tell me that the officer felt threatened?  Or was his manhood so deeply in doubt that he needed to prove his power and might by leaving her in a pool of blood on the floor.  Does that make him feel good about himself?

Punditry In A Perfect World

One of the things that blawgers (myself excepted, of course) like to do is give broad advice to others about how to be the best lawyer you can be.  Yes, it can be a bit pedantic, but if you can’t be pedantic on a blawg, where can you be?

Since I want to be the best lawyer possible too, I paid close attention to the newest addition to the  MoneyLaw crew, who likes to call himself “MoneyLawyer“.  I know, catchy name, right? 

Full disclosure:  After begging and pleading with Jim Chen, he’s agreed to let me sneak in every once in a while to  post something over at MoneyLaw just to add some comic relief, plus bring in the low-brow crowd that would otherwise be out drinking beer and munching on hard-boiled eggs.

Now I wish I had some more info to share about MoneyLawyer, because I really want to know where he practices.  Clearly, it’s nowhere I’ve ever been, because  he posts about how to win with judges who are smart, unbiased and interested. 


Many lawyers mistakenly structure their arguments so that they demand an emotional investment from judges. Their arguments ask the judge to cheer for them, to grant the relief because the judge wants to grant it. Their prose is emotionally charged, laced with opinions about the facts and attacks on the other side’s reasoning. It conjures images of Conan smiting his enemies with a broad sword. This is a bad way to convince a judge who is charged to remain impartial. Many judges interpret this type of writing as overcompensation for a weak legal position. I have read a lot of Conan briefs, but I have yet to see one obtain the relief it requested.

How he got an old picture of me is anyone’s guess.

MoneyLawyer explains that while judges view the “Conan Brief” as a loser, an epistle of weakness and clarion call of vapidity, clients love them.  I can’t disagree with that point.  My clients derive great pleasure from yelling bad words at the other side, especially the lying, scheming rats who lie and scheme.  But if we can’t go for the emotional investment, whats left?


The client is best served with an understated approach, which takes more skill and intelligence than writing a Conan brief. Understated does not mean boring; it means giving the judge what she needs to make her decision without making an emotional investment. If written properly, this style of writing is much more interesting for the judge because she does not have to waste time filtering out the Conan elements.

Is it much more interesting?  That’s hard to say, since you’d have to wait for the judge to stop laughing before you would get a straight answer. 

It’s not that I disagree with much of what MoneyLawyer suggests.  Good legal writing is good legal writing, and persuasive is persuasive.  But where I live, the idea that judges are above mere mortals is sheer fantasy.  It’s not that there aren’t smart judges (there are) or fair judges (there are) or judges who wear  a black cocktail dress and fish net stockings under their robes (I’m speculating on this one), but that all the judges I know are real people with typical foibles. 

No doubt I’ll get the standard handful of emails after this post telling me (again) that I’m despoiling the image of lawyers as dignified professionals but letting our little secrets out of the otherwise ignorant public, but who cares.  If you’re going to hold yourself out as having the answer, then the least you can do is have the right question.  If you live in a world of perfect judges, then MoneyLaw’s disdain for the Conan Brief is the perfect solution.  In my world, you figure out what will be persuasive to your particular judge and then make it happen. 

More Than One Way To Prove Your Credibility

Shawn Matlock (formerly Young Shawn) wasn’t on slut patrol when he plopped his butt down to watch TV.  Sometimes, it just happens that way.

Being a staunch Republican, Shawn naturally gravitated toward Fox News so he could get the day’s news in a fair and balanced presentation. 


As Neil Cavuto introduced his guest, I dropped my pen. The expert was none other than Fort Worth’s own Mimi Coffey. Some might think that’s great. I mean a local attorney called upon by one of the major news networks to comment as a legal expert on the ongoing celebrity divorce.

The lawyers of Tarrant County, Texas, don’t get a lot of call for television appearances.  It’s not like Harris County, where  scandal and intrigue make the  national news on a regular basis.  So when the call comes, it’s hard to say no.

But Cavuto, a man with his finger on the pulse of society, stemming from his early experiences as a  White House intern in the Carter administration where he was charged with making sure Jimmy was still alive at all times, was doing a story on the Paul McCartney/Heather Mills divorce, part of the great liberal plot to undermine a family values, and needed a lawyer to call them as she saw them.  And there was Mimi.

Why Mimi?


Mimi Coffey is a self-appointed expert DWI defense attorney in Fort Worth. Yeah, she’s a criminal defense attorney. As far as I know, she doesn’t handle family law cases. I’m even more certain that she doesn’t practice family law in England.

Apparently, she’s no Raoul Lionel Felder.  But then, who is?  Now I think Shawn may be getting a bit nit-picking with the England bit, since few of us have QC after our names.  This may have something to do with Shawn’s open disdain for the Beatles, itself a very telling detail that could help explain why he turned to the Republican party for comfort and companionship.  “You ain’t gonna make it with anyone anyhow.”

But as those of us who are occasionally asked to be the lunch meat in the media sandwich know, attorneys are pre-interviewed before hitting the airwaves to make sure that we have something to say that they TV producers want the public to hear.  Mimi obviously gave them some of the good stuff or she would have never hit the big time.


Ms. Coffey never really answered a question posed to her. How she got on the Neil Cavuto show on Fox News to discuss the divorce of a former Beatle and, in Ms. Coffey’s words, “a gold digger” is a complete mystery to me.

There’s the money line.  Heather Mills, a woman who has known adversity as well as the life of plenty, is a “gold digger.”  That’s a pretty harsh characterization, implying evil intent in her seducing the cute Beatle into her web of fiscal foolery.  Did Mimi’s attack come from her heartfelt political convictions?  Not at all, Shawn tells us.


Now before someone out there criticizes Fox News because they are “too conservative” like me, hold on a second. Keep this in mind. Mimi Coffey is a bleeding heart liberal Democrat. She’s not afraid to say it either.

Far be it for me to criticize Fox News for being “too conservative.”  After all, it’s one of my favorite gigs, before they  cut me off for making fun of the anchors too well.  But that doesn’t mean that Fox News gets a free ride at Simple Justice.

I can’t blame Mimi for taking the divorce commentary gig, though one may wonder whether she told the assistant who called that she doesn’t actually do divorces, and neither Paul nor Heather has much of a connection to Fort Worth, Texas.  After all, it’s not like she’s going to get a lot of opportunity to get her smiling face on the tube, nor is anything she’s going to say have any influence over public thought on a topic of importance. 

Neil Cavuto, on the other hand, doesn’t get away that easy.  It’s not that Fox News in “conservative” (what happened to fair and balanced, Shawn?), but his lack of credibility comes across loud and clear.  Mimi didn’t call Fox News and demand her time on-air to opine about this divorce; They called her. 

Of all the lawyers in all the world, they selected Mimi to be the one to go onto Cavuto’s national cable show as a celebrity divorce expert.  So while I might be inclined to ridicule Neil Cavuto for being an unmitigated slut to the conservative leanings of Rupert Murdoch following the demise of his career as a respected business journalist, today I don’t have to.  Instead, I need only note that his use of Mimi demonstrates that he has no credibility at all.  And that’s good enough for me.

The Fastest Growing Specialty in Law? You Dog!

Do you ever get the feeling that someone, somewhere, is playing a joke on lawyers and we’re just not getting it?  Doug Berman, in a fit of pique after Dan Filler knocked over his snifter full of cognac at the  Faculty Lounge and refused to apologize, decided to make him pay by rubbing his nose in dog poop.

It seems that the other lawprofs sitting around in their tweed jackets think that too much emphasis is placed on the death penalty in law school because it’s hot and sexy, which represents a small portion of sentencing issues, rather than the more mundane but far more extensive issues surrounding general sentencing. 

Aside:  If they did a better job teaching constitutional issues in criminal law, maybe they wouldn’t have as many sentencing issues to begin with because criminal defense lawyers would win more cases.

In retaliation for their Philistine thoughts, Doug decided to  dredge up the newest, latest and coolest of law school course offerings:  Animal Law!  Take that, you social utility snobs.


I am drawn back to these comments today upon tripping across this law school website that indicates that nearly 100 law schools have a course on animal law.  The website explains: “Nearly half of US law schools teach an overview course and a growing number of schools now offer clinical opportunities. Lewis & Clark Law School has the most developed animal law program offering six courses, including summer courses, moot court, and the Animal Law Clinic.” 

So how do you do the intake at the Animal Law Clinic?  Seriously, what if you’re a cat person and a dog walks in?  Do you just pooh-pooh his complaint?

Now this isn’t the first I’ve heard of the burgeoning practice of animal law.  Indeed, even commercials have come out in this highly competitive specialty.




For Doug, this is no laughing matter. 


I suppose it is a sad and telling commentary that many law schools have devoted more resources toward having students question the legal treatment of animals than the legal treatment of criminal offenders.  Perhaps advocates for sentencing and corrections reform need to find some incarcerated people with sad puppy-dog eyes so that humans locked in cages will evoke as much sympathy in elite law schools as animals locked in cages.

For those of us who may not have had the experience of participating in the Animal Law National Moot Court Competition, we are likely to lack a full appreciation of the seriousness of the plight of animals.  On the other hand, since we do such a lousy job with humans, maybe we should focus a little harder on dealing with our own species in law school and leave Fido to walk it off.

I apologize in advance to any animal lovers out there who find this post outrageous, ignorant and offensive.  But frankly, I’m with Doc Berman.  We have enough problems trying to make our legal system work well for people, and finding new yet silly ways to waste scarce resources just strikes me as ludicrous. 

Now It’s The Trains Too

The notion of free travel, where one could go anywhere in the United States without having to prove who you are or subject yourself to search, was given away without much of a fuss when it came to airplanes.  After all, that was the weapon of choice for 9/11 terrorists, and who would argue the point.

Today, Amtrak will announce the same for trains.  According to the AP story, courtesy of Concurring Opinions,


Amtrak plans to roll out the new “mobile security teams” first on the Northeast Corridor between Washington and Boston, the railroad’s most heavily used route, before expanding them to the rest of the country.

The teams will show up unannounced at stations and set up baggage screening areas in front of boarding gates. Officers will randomly pull people out of line and wipe their bags with a special swab that is then put through a machine that detects explosives. If the machine detects anything, officers will open the bag for visual inspection.

Anybody who is selected for screening and refuses will not be allowed to board and their ticket will be refunded.

In addition, they will have bomb-sniffing dogs and will require people buying tickets to show ID.  How showing ID when buying a train tickets helps is not explained.


Amtrak hopes the new force can serve as a powerful deterrent to would-be terrorists.  “What we are trying to do is make sure the bad guys know we’re out there but don’t know where we’ll be, or when,” Rooney said.

“There is no new or different specific threat,” Kummant said. “This is just the correct step to take.”

In the past, at least they showed us the courtesy of offering a half-baked rationale for their ever-increasing restriction on free-mobility.  We are now so used to being sniffed, searched and ID’d that they need only say that it’s “just the correct step to take.”  It “feels” like it’s a good idea.  And that’s good enough.

This is how the slippery slope works.  It just gets easier and easier each time, until no one even bothers to question why another freedom is taken away.

The Measure of Prosperity, And Why People Steal

In this New York Times Op-Ed, W. Michael Cox and Richard Alm argue that measuring prosperity by earnings is a mistake, and that we would be better off measuring prosperity by spending.


Income statistics, however, don’t tell the whole story of Americans’ living standards. Looking at a far more direct measure of American families’ economic status — household consumption — indicates that the gap between rich and poor is far less than most assume, and that the abstract, income-based way in which we measure the so-called poverty rate no longer applies to our society.

While the authors offer no explanation why income is so abstract or misleading, the cue is their reference to Americans’ standard of living.  What difference does it make what they earn, when what they are really interested in knowing is how good a time we’re having.


To understand why consumption is a better guideline of economic prosperity than income, it helps to consider how our lives have changed. Nearly all American families now have refrigerators, stoves, color TVs, telephones and radios. Air-conditioners, cars, VCRs or DVD players, microwave ovens, washing machines, clothes dryers and cellphones have reached more than 80 percent of households.

There is no question from any quarter that we are, if nothing else, a consumer society.  No matter who you are, you’re nobody if you don’t possess the basic accouterments due every American.  But needless to say, there’s a glaring omission in their argument.  How, one wonders, does one achieve this American dream without the income to pay for it?

Before turning to that question, it is worth noting that the authors are not some egg-head academicians, pontificating for no particular reason some strange theory that will get them into the Times and a small dose of name recognition.  The authors are major players at the Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas. 

So how do these Fed movers and shakers view the plight of the income-poor in our society?


The bottom fifth earned just $9,974, but spent nearly twice that — an average of $18,153 a year. How is that possible? A look at the far right-hand column of the consumption chart, labeled “financial flows,” shows why: those lower-income families have access to various sources of spending money that doesn’t fall under taxable income. These sources include portions of sales of property like homes and cars and securities that are not subject to capital gains taxes, insurance policies redeemed, or the drawing down of bank accounts. While some of these families are mired in poverty, many (the exact proportion is unclear) are headed by retirees and those temporarily between jobs, and thus their low income total doesn’t accurately reflect their long-term financial status.

Note those numbers:  Earn $9,974 and spend $18,153, because every American has a right to a flat panel TV.  While they acknowledge that “some of these families are mired in poverty,” they dismiss the rule in favor of the exception (another fine American tradition).

Not only does this position glorify consumerism, the end goal of all real Americans and the standard by which they should be judged.  This view of the American legacy explains a lot about why those neglected folk “mired in poverty” turn to alternative means to accumulate the consumer goods that are their American birthright.  When you can’t buy the TV because you can earn enough money to afford it, and when you’re barely a human being when you don’t have the TV, then you have to something a little more drastic to get the TV.

In the play, “Fiddler on the Roof,” Tevya says “It’s no crime to be poor.”  But that was the schtetl, and this is America, where it is indeed a crime not to have an iPhone or ipod or whatever the latest thing beginning with “i” may be.  There is always the route of massive accumulation of debt, a tried and true method of making sure that people spend mindlessly while being forever kept in an economic hole from which they can never, lawfully, climb out, but eventually that gets tedious.  There’s nothing like a little crime for upward mobility.

For economists from the Fed to suggest that the accumulation of consumer goods that people cannot afford and don’t need lifts American’s to happy heights of prosperity is just plain sick.  By their measure, who can blame people for turning to crime to achieve the American dream.  After all, it’s not how they get the goods that matters, as long as they do.