Author Archives: SHG

Salute to Presidents Day

There are holidays that we celebrate, and days that we call holidays because they close schools.  Today is Presidents Day.  Whoopee.  When I was a kid, we had Washington’s Birthday because he was the father of our country.  We had Lincoln’s Birthday because he freed the slaves and saved the Union. But there were two of them and we celebrated them both.  Sure, it was messy since they were both in February, but you can’t tell people when to be born.  A birthday is a birthday.

We celebrated days for a reason.  Whether they were good reasons is subject to dispute (meaning our grandchildren may well celebrate Reagan’s Birthday [he, ahem brought an end to communism]), but they were holidays because they were worthy of being holidays.

But when they start messing with holidays in order to fit in the new ones and get rid of old ones, then they lose their point.  Have Washington and Lincoln lost their Sainthood such that they have to share a day?  Did their feats lesson in the American psyche?  No, no, no.  We just need to squeeze in enough days of work and school given the allocation of scarce holiday resources.

We should recognize some former Presidents, some great Americans, for what they gave to our country.  But if they’re worthy of recognition, then let’s show them the respect they deserve.  Would another day off kill us?  What, we don’t work hard enough?  Who wants to be the person to announce that as much as Lincoln did for the nation, he isn’t worth a day of productivity?  After all, these are old dead presidents, and there’s an economy to deal with out there.

So if there’s any meaning to “Presidents Day,” it is the fundamental American demand for productivity.  Let us have no person, no ideal, no cause that stands in the way of a day of hard work.  By combining a couple of holidays that have outlived their individual usefulness, but still have a few lingering adherents, we can cover the whole “great presidents” thing while getting the one day “give back” to the true idol of American politics and history:  Business.

So have a happy Productivity Day.  Now get to work.

Why Committees Create Camels

While it’s never clear which posts will capture the attention of a lot of readers, I have a fairly good feel for those that won’t.  This one is neither particularly newsworthy nor sensational.  But since I write for my own amusement, this is one that I will enjoy immensely.

Paul Horwitz at PrawfsBlawg has unearthed the Microcosmographia Academica, by F.M. Cornford, a short satirical pamphlet about the politics and decision-making of Cambridge, which can be found here.  While arrogant academicians think it applies to them, they’re wrong.  It’s for anybody who likes to hide behind committees to assert their brilliance while wondering why no one seems to appreciate them.



You think (do you not?) that you have only to state a reasonable case, and people must listen to reason and act upon at once. It is just this conviction that makes you so unpleasant. There is little hope of dissuading you; but has it occurred to you that nothing is ever done until every one is convinced that it ought to be done, and has been convinced for so long that it is now time to do something else? And are you not aware that conviction has never yet been produced by an appeal to reason, which only makes people uncomfortable?


I like you the better for your illusions; but it cannot be denied that they prevent you from being effective, and if you do not become effective before you cease to want anything to be done — why, what will be the good of you?


Now Cornford wrote this in 1908.  One hundred years later, nothing has changed and nothing has been learned. 
This is either a testament to the human spirit, refusing to give up on the notion that consensus will work if we just keep trying.  Or maybe group decision-making has always suffered from this flaw and our refusal to acknowledge and accept this reflects a monumental failing in human nature.

Since I have long held serious doubts as to the value of consensus, to the point where I believe that consensus almost always gives rise to a generally palatable non-solution to any problem or issue.  If you want to accomplish nothing be achieve popularity, make decisions by committee.

But rarely has anybody made fun of this phenomenon as well as Cornford.  If you agree with me, you will enjoy it.  If you don’t, you may learn from it.  If you’re still reading this post, you are one of the few, the proud, the brave.  I salute you.

I Want A Real Attorney

David Tarloff is  accused of murdering Manhattan therapist Kathryn Faughey and stabbing her partner, psychologist Kent Shinbach, with a meat cleaver.  Even in New York, this is a little unusual.  There just aren’t that many meat cleaver murders anymore, and the use of the word “butcher” has become cliché.

But like all defendants, Tarloff must be arraigned.  And to be arraigned, he must have counsel.  Legal Aid lawyer Reginald Sharpe got the nod.  It was his job to tell Supreme Court Judge Ruth Pickholz that Tarloff wasn’t guilty and request a 730 exam.  Under other circumstances, Sharpe might have made a bail application. 

But Tarloff wasn’t happy about the situation.

Accused therapist-killer David Tarloff lit into his court-appointed attorney during his arraignment Sunday, saying he wouldn’t speak until he received “a real attorney.”

Biting his lip throughout the five-minute court appearance, Tarloff interrupted his Legal Aid attorney, Reginald Sharpe, to tell State Supreme Court Judge Ruth Pickholz he wanted a new lawyer.

“He’s not an attorney,” said Tarloff, who wore a white T-shirt and black sweatpants. “I want to see a real attorney. I’m not stupid. That’s it. I won’t talk until I have a real attorney.”

That Tarloff wanted a “real lawyer” comes as no surprise to any public defender.  They’ve lived with this sort of stupidity since the day after Gideon.  But when Tarloff explained, “I’m not stupid,” that must have brought some comic relief to an otherwise tense appearance.

There’s nothing funny about a murder case.  There’s nothing funny about a person being killed, particularly in such a brutal and painful way.  There’s nothing funny about Tarloff, either a killer haunted by such horrible demons that he did the unthinkable or an innocent man vilified for a horrific murder.  Smart money is on the former at the moment.  Confession plus prints will do that.

Insane people usually aren’t stupid.  But they are insane.  Perhaps Tarloff suffers from delusions of grandeur, and thinks his case is worthy of Johnny Cochran.  Maybe he thinks he can get Johnny to give him advice.  He may be one of the few who can still speak to Johnny.  But the likelihood of Johnny representing Tarloff is less than slim.

Defendants like Tarloff reflect one of the better aspects of our system.  He butchered an innocent woman.  The evidence against him is strong, perhaps overwhelming.  And without any money, someone as notorious as Tarloff gets a fellow like Reginald Sharpe to stand up beside him in court.  And Tarloff insults him, acts abusively and still Reginald Sharpe stands beside him.  Sounds like a real lawyer to me.

An Honest Politician

“An honest politician is one who when he’s bought stays bought.” 
— Attributed to Simon Cameron, Pennsylvania (1799-1899).

And so, we consider the  relative positions of our President and the House of Representatives.  The set up is easy enough.  According to the President, if the House allows his surveillance bill, already passed by our pristine Senate, to expire (as it did last Friday), then they are exposing the United States to terrorism.  But within the bill is that minor detail immunizing Telecoms for past transgressions.

So, our President says our lives are threatened should the House refuse to pass the bill, but he insists that the bill retain the immunity provision.  It is more important to the President of the United States of America that telecoms who engage in illegal conduct at the behest of the administration  receive retroactive immunity than that the people of the United States of America are protected from terrorism.

I just want to make sure we were all clear about this.

The House let the surveillance bill lapse.  Not that I buy into the argument that empowering the government to engage in what used to be illegal surveillance is the sine qua non of security from terrorism, since it’s just more of the same old claptrap fear-mongering that the government uses to convince the “common sense” crowd to happily hand over my personal freedom so that they can pretend to be good Americans and sleep well at night in the knowledge that the “price of freedom isn’t free.”  I just like to point out the flaws on the argument. 

Nice to know that the House of Representatives earned its salary on Friday.

Departure From What?

Some say the 2d Circuit Court of Appeals can be a very tough crowd.  Maybe not as silly as the 9th Circuit, given that it took an en banc rehearing for them to figure out that “I plead the fifth” means “I plead the fifth,” as opposed to “ask me more questions because I may really want to incriminate myself,” but tough.

As so the court was in reversing a sentence imposed pursuant to a 5k1.1 deal in  United States v. Richardson where the sentencing judge departed downward by “93%”.  Holy Moly, Batman.  Ninety-three percent?  That’s huge!

Well, maybe not as huge as it first appears.  You see, the Circuit used lawyer math (no, not the kind some use when calculating fees).  Rather than use some relatively meaningful number, say the sentencing guidelines calculation of 63-78 months from the PSR, the court chose to go for broke by comparing the sentence imposed, 464 days, from the statutory minimum for the underlying offense, 20 years.

This curious choice of theoretical sentences certainly makes the sentence actually imposed seem rather dramatic, perhaps bordering on hyperbolic.  Not that a court one step below the Supremes would ever be hyperbolic, because that would just be wrong.  But it certainly does add a certain flair to the ruling, making it appear that District Judge Hurd, up there in the New York hinterlands, went a little nuts.

Of course, once the defendant, Carol Dominguez, received the 5K1.1 letter from the government, the mandatory minimum was off the table, rendering it a meaningless number for all purpose other than ridiculing the sentence actually imposed. 

The Circuit’s rejection of the sentence on the government’s appeal (and for all you 5K1.1 lovers out there, remember to let your clients know that if you do your job too well, their good buddies at the United States Attorneys office are going to get miffed and go after you again), was because the judge used “specified and unspecified factors” to reach a fair sentence.  I guess this is their way of saying, “if that’s all you got, then fuhgeddaboutit.”

And with that, the 2d Circuit reversed and remanded for the court to better “articulate” his reasoning.  I can’t help but wonder if that means that Judge Hurd will speak more slowly and with better enunciation the next time around.  I bet that Dominguez’s lawyer, Craig Schlanger of Syracuse, isn’t wondering the same thing.

Can We At Least Finish The Trial First?

Judges are only human.  They can make mistakes too, you know.  And nobody knows this better than Plymouth, Massachusetts Superior Court Judge Charles M. Grabau.

This small, seemingly inconsequential local story of the trial of 21 year old Joseph Nee reminds us that there is nothing funny about the sequentially-challenged.  It seems that Judge Grabau meant to give Nee a great trial.  He really did.  He just lost track of what comes before what.



Much to the surprise of Nee’s lawyers, Grabau started to issue his ruling close to 10 a.m., before closing arguments had been made. “The Commonwealth has proved this case beyond a reasonable doubt . . ., ” he began.

Dang!  Don’t you just hate it when that happens?

But when Nee’s lawyer, Thomas Drechsler, stood up and pointed out that he had not made his closing argument yet, the judge stopped short of announcing his decision and directed the lawyer to begin his closing argument.

  Picture Emily Litella saying, “Oh.  Never mind.” 

  Of course, there’s nothing that instills faith in the system more than a judge who can readily admit that he was in the process of convicting the defendant just a wee bit early.  Premature conviction is one of the first things that shouldn’t happen, according to the judges’ handbook.  “Always wait until the trial is over before convicting,” it clearly states.

Of course, the worst part about this story, and was inadvertently left out of the article, was that Judge Grabau didn’t have to craft his decision convicting Joseph Nee.  He just reused the same ruling that he uses in every other case.  Why reinvent the wheel?

H/T Kevin Underhill at Lowering the Bar.

Explaining Our Government To Our Children

If your kids are like mine, they ask the darndest questions about the state of our nation around the dinner table.  As Jon Katz posts here, they’ve grown up in a country bound by fear and the mechanisms of security.  They have no memory of a time when freedom meant, well, freedom.

So how do we explain?  So many why questions and so few good answers.  Well, thanks to Mark Fiore, we now have a soft, cuddly way to give our children the answers they seek.

spies1.jpg

I don’t know about your kids, but mine just love anything with a teddy bear (provided it is not possessed by demons).  So get grab the kids, sit back and let this video do all the work.

Let’s Not Forget Who’s Minding The Store

Yesterday, the front page of Newsday had a relatively unattractive photo of Lawrence Reich, the lawyer with full-time jobs in 5 different school districts, plus his law firm gig.  As inevitably as form follows function, today’s headline is that the FBI has subpoenaed records from the school districts for a federal grand jury.  You gotta give those Fibbers credit, at least they read the headlines.

And while the alleged miscreant is left to bear the burden of taxpayer outrage, a lone voice rings out in the wilderness, “Who was supposed to be watching the public fisc?”  That would be my voice, alone at least for the moment.  No, I’m not saying anyone should ignore Mr. Reich.  But I must inquire how Long Island school districts, yet again, find themselves in another scandal.

This is actually a straw man question, since I fully intend to answer my own question.  School districts, like water districts, like sewer districts, like villages, all suffer from the same inherent fault.  They are run by people who lack the skillset to manage and the comprehension to appreciate their lack of the necessary skills.  Most are well intended.  Some are malevolent.  Some are just plain nuts and stupid. 

But they all have one thing in common.  They have shown sufficient desire to be important people to run for office, while the rest of the taxpayers are satisfied with generic complaining but lack sufficient will to learn the issues, understand what’s right or wrong, and do something about it.  In short, the elected folks generally aren’t qualified, and we the People are happy enough to let them have their way provided it doesn’t get too bad or affect us personally.

It is a truism that we get the government we deserve.  Fail to be knowledgeable and you forfeit the ability to know when things are bad.  Love your importance too much and become blinded to problems that are obvious to everyone else.  There is no real training for these positions, and otherwise ordinary people step into positions that are so far outside the realm of their normal experience that it akin to asking a bunch of kindergartners to invent nuclear fusion.  But since they don’t know that they don’t know, they think they’re doing a bang up job.

There are always a few who can see that the Emperor is wearing no clothes, but they’re denigrated as malcontents and ignored.  The good people would rather keep their distance and enjoy the fact that they don’t have to exert any effort because there are others doing it for them.  Unless something bad happens to them personally, which be definition is unique and a travesty, then they are quite content letting things slide and sitting it out.

Eventually, these 5 school boards will be put under the microscope to find out whether they knew that their trusted lawyer was doing them dirty.  And there will be explanations galore, all directed toward putting measures in place to prevent this from ever happening again.  Until next time.  Someone will invariably announce that we need to stop looking for blame, put the past behind us and move forward.  That usually comes from the mouth of a very close friend of the guilty party.

All of these mini-fiefdoms suffer from the same malady.  They may not be completely incompetent, just not very good at paying close attention.  They aren’t exactly corrupt, but skirt the law with nepotism, favoritism, and the occasional “fix” for a friend or ally.  Along the lines of good old Plunkett of Tammany Hall, under the heading of “honest graft.” 

When our expectations of competence and comprehension are so low to begin with, why are we surprised that corruption exists, funds are wasted or stolen, laws become weapons to hurt the very people they were elected to serve?  If we only wake up to reality when something truly venal happens, then we have enabled the incompetent and malevolent. 

We’re all in this together, though rarely from the same perspective.  If you can’t be bothered to pay attention, and then do something when you find that things are going very wrong, then ultimately 5 school boards will believe that they acted quite properly by keeping one lawyer on the books as a full time employee for 5 separate districts.  A few years ago, I bought my wife a T-shirt on the street in Manhattan that read “Stop Your Bitching, Start a Revolution.”  Complaining afterward is just a waste of time. 

This wasn’t an accident or an oversight in the case of Lawrence Reich.  And it isn’t in your local governments either.  You just don’t know about it yet.  If things like this displease you, then get off that chair and do something about it.

A Game The Whole Family Can Play

Kansas Governor Kathleen Sebelius was given the prime time opportunity to provide the Democratic response to the President’s State of the Union speech this year, which is often reserved for a party up-and-comer to show off her wares.  Apparently, the Sebelius family had  more to sell than the Dems knew.


John Sebelius, 23, has the backing of his mother and father, U.S. Magistrate Judge Gary Sebelius. The governor’s spokeswoman, Nicole Corcoran, said both parents “are very proud of their son John’s creativity and talent.”

And why are Mom and Dad so proud? 


The son of Gov. Kathleen Sebelius is peddling a board game titled “Don’t Drop the Soap,” a prison-themed game he created as part of a class project at the Rhode Island School of Design.

Excuse me?  And what exactly does that title refer to?


“Fight your way through 6 different exciting locations in hopes of being granted parole,” the site says. “Escape prison riots in The Yard, slip glass into a mob boss’ lasagna in the Cafeteria, steal painkillers from the nurse’s desk in the Infirmary.”

The game includes five tokens representing a bag of cocaine, a handgun and three characters: wheelchair-using ‘Wheelz,” muscle-flexing “Anferny” and business suit-clad “Sal ‘the Butcher.”

So let me get this clear, this is an exciting new board game about criminals surviving prison by committing internal crimes while avoiding being buggered in the shower room?  I don’t know whether to laugh or cry.  Did Governor Mommy and Judge Daddy raise their son to create a game that satirizes the horrific state of the American prison system, or does this reflect a belief that the harm that comes to those incarcerated makes for high comedy?  The image created by the name of the game is certainly going to make it a big draw no matter what.

I bet you’re asking yourself, so how do I get my hands on this challenger to Scrabble for board game hegemony?

The game costs “$34.99, plus packaging, shipping and handling. The contact information on the Web site lists the address of the governor’s mansion.”  Small bills are preferred.  After you’ve given it a whirl, let me know whether this was as much fun as it sounds.

In fairness, the game is intended for mature audiences, not children, and is “simply intended for entertainment,” according to Corcoran.   That’s a relief.

Clemens Isn’t Guilty Because of Race

While the fate of Roger Clemens isn’t the foremost issue of critical consequence facing society today, it raises issues of sufficient consequence to be worthy of discussion.  And so Doug Berman at Sentencing Law and Policy, pursuing the agenda of racial equality, noted the New York Times’ view that Justice Will Be Served Only if Clemens Isn’t Given a Pass.

I usually find myself in agreement with Doc Berman, whose understanding of sentencing policy dwarfs my own.  But not this time.  In fact, I find it shocking that Doug has bought into the “common wisdom” type approach of commentators who, having watched the hearings, have concluded that the Rocket is a liar.


What we all know now is that someone was lying. And at this juncture, that someone would seem to be Clemens. We’re not talking about razor-thin, “I thought it was flaxseed oil” types of lies before a federal grand jury, which is what Barry Bonds stands accused of. We’re talking about potentially whopping lies before Congress, before the world….

This was  also the view of former AUSA, now lawprof, Katherine Darmer.  Karl Keys of Capital Defense Weekly, on the other hand, thought that Clemens was quite credible and took issue with McNamee.  So is it a tie, or does the side with the most votes win?  Is the fact that most commentators have decided that Clemens looked worse than McNamee conclusive?

Whether Clemens lied or told the truth or told the truth as he believed it to be, and whether Clemens appeared credible, appeared incredible, or was an ill-prepared, or just generally lousy witness, is not the subject of popular vote.

While Doug’s point, that there can be no racial disparity in the prosecution of athletes for use of steroids, is certainly valid, it is premature to make Clemens the poster boy.  I don’t care if every person who watched the hearings has decided that he gave the worst performance.  Performances do not prove the truth or falsity of his testimony.  Doug should know this, and should be circumspect in finding Clemens to the liar.

There may well be nothing more to this than “he said, he said” in the absence of evidence.  But don’t rush to judgment because of who you think put on a better show.  Yes, courts do this every day.  Judge Judy, after about 3 seconds, screams at litigants that they are liars.  But she’s a TV judge putting on a show to appeal to people who have the opportunity watch daytime television.  This is not a viable substitute for reality.  Not even Judge Judy has magic powers to know who is telling the truth.

When someone with as much credibility as Doug Berman argues that Clemens must pay, like others who are black, he jumps to conclusions that are as yet unwarranted and inappropriate.  It may be said that he isn’t convicting Clemens, but merely suggesting that Clemens be investigated to determine “if” he perjured himself.


But none of this means a thing unless the Department of Justice investigates Clemens.  On the surface, there seems to be little choice but to do so. What Jones and now Bonds and Clemens have in common is not accusations of illegal use of steroids but of lying to representatives of the federal government: Jones to federal agents, Bonds to a grand jury and Clemens to members of Congress.

This smacks of beginning the path to a foregone conclusion.  To urge an “investigation” is to believe that there is wrongdoing.  If it was not directed to Clemens’ guilt, it would be to urge a broader investigation, without regard to race.  It is directed at Clemens because of the fear that he, being white, will escape scrutiny.

I agree wholeheartedly that no one should be subject to investigation, prosecution and conviction because of their race,  That includes Barry Bond.  It includes Marion Jones.  It also includes Roger Clemens.  Let’s not let the “common wisdom” that we can somehow tell, in the absence of extrinsic evidence, who is lying based upon who gave the best performance stop our thoughtfulness in its tracks and lead us down the path of righteous condemnation in the name of equality.  Better we be fair to all than unfair to all.

Edit:  Note  the comment to Doug’s post by Scott Henson of Grits for Breakfast fame.  Same idea, only Scott managed to say it in 749 fewer words.