Author Archives: SHG

Of Northern Illinois University and Death

I avoid posting about things like the killings at NIU or Virginia Tech because I don’t believe I have anything to add other than my sympathies, which I believe is shared with the rest of the nation.

I can’t help but wonder, as I have since Columbine, how we have contributed to the outward displays of violence toward others.  I have urged that we remove the incentive for infamy by  not disclosing the identities of shooters.  I have questioned the mainstream acceptance of pain as humor.  It’s not that I presume to have any answers.  It’s just that we need to find a way to stop this from happening, not be mourning the aftermath or finding stop-gap treatments for the symptoms, but by curing the disease.

No child should die.  No child should suffer.  To the extent we can stop it, this is imperative.  We need to spend more time figuring out why this is happening, truly understanding the problem, so that we can do something to stop it.  We need to put an end to sensationalizing it as if it’s another form of melodramatic entertainment.  Let us make the effort to find out how to help these young people so that this never happens again.

You Can’t Make This Stuff Up

Is it just me, or does more weird stuff come out of Texas than anywhere else?

Out of beautiful Amarillo comes a decision by the “HONORABLE W.F. “CORKY” ROBERTS, JUDGE.”  Now before we go anywhere near the decision, I’ve got to deal with this name.  I’ve never heard of a judge signing an opinion using a nickname.  Whether everybody knows the judge by the nickname or not, a judicial decision is a kinda formal thing.  You use the real name, leave the nicknames home.  Who reviews this decision, the Honorable”Stinky” Jones?  Come on.  You Texas guys are killing me.

And now we turn to the case itself, Little v. Texas.  It’s your typical teenage girl gets a date with boy from religious cult family whose parents convince her that she must leave her home and family because her Teddy Bear is possessed by demons.  Yup, another demonic teddy case.


Abigail [our misguided teenager] began telling Matilde [her mother] that their house was filled with sin. Walter [surrogate daddy, father of boyfriend and regular confidante of supreme deity] had instructed Abigail to be spiritually prepared for all the demons living in their house because Matilde and Carlos were living out of wedlock. Abigail told Matilde she didn’t belong in her home any longer because she had to fight demons every day and she belonged with her daddy, Walter. Abigail cried daily and spent a lot of time in her closet during the daytime. At times, Matilde found Abigail in her closet with her Bible where she twice slept overnight. Abigail also believed certain objects including her teddy bears were possessed by demons. The only place Abigail could find comfort was in her closet with her Bible. She told Matilde that her home was Walter’s home, and she wanted to live there.

Just another typical day in Amarillo.  The Littles were convicted of the offense of enticing a child if, with the intent to interfere with the lawful custody of a child younger than eighteen years.  Apparently, this happens enough in Texas that they need to have a specific law against it. 

The legal discussion of the decision is relatively pedestrian, disposing of your basic, ordinary defenses to convincing some teen that her real parents are instruments of the devil and that she should voluntarily adopt the defendants as her new mommy and daddy.  You know, the usual stuff.

But it is truly disappointing that nowhere does “Corky” make a finding that the teddy bear was or was not possessed by demons.  Does this not leave you with the fear that young Abigail will be thrust back into the bosom of her family and placed at risk of demonic possession? 

H/T Volokh

Preservation of Error, The Magical Escape

As an attorney who does both trials and appeals, I can appreciate the twitchy ambivalence when you need to make a snap decision or offer an impromptu argument at the trial court level that commits to a position that can come back and bite you in the butt on appeal.

Here’s the problem, in a nutshell.  A trial lawyer tries a case to win before a jury, not to make a record in anticipation of losing the trial and preserving an argument for appeal.  Sometimes, the lawyer just hasn’t had a chance to think of every potential argument available, or has one idea in mind but other arguments, sometimes better arguments, just don’t occur to him in the midst of combat.  Other times, he’s forced to make a judgment call and chooses the tact that seems to offer the most benefit before a jury, leaving other arguments on the side of the road.

In the old days, this really wasn’t that much of a problem.  First level appellate courts in New York have plenary powers.  They have full jurisdiction over all issues of law and fact, including an overarching “interest of justice” jurisdiction that would assure every appellant the availability of full appellate review.

Then one day, somebody came up with the bright idea of “preservation”.  Preservation is the concept that an issue or argument was raised before the court below, thus giving the judge and adversary an opportunity hear, argue, consider and rule on the issue.  Preservation quickly became the favorite argument of the prosecution (since it’s almost always the defendant appealing) and first level appellate courts to toss an important, viable, significant issue or argument out the window as a means of not dealing with it.

In almost every respondent’s brief I get these days, the first level of defense is lack of preservation if there is any colorable basis for the argument.  Prosecutors parse the most minute nuances of arguments made below to raise the specter of an unpreserved point.  They do this knowing that there is a 99.3% (I just made this number up, but I bet it’s not too far off) chance that the court will seize upon it as an excuse to avoid ruling on the issue.

Not only does the issue preservation undermine fundamental notions of justice, but it’s an abdication of judicial responsibility.  It shifts the responsibility to do justice from the courts to the attorney for the defendant, preventing review if there is any arguable claim that the lawyer was less than comprehensive, made a tactical choice or just plain screwed up.  And if he did, the remedy is to go back, challenge whether the defendant received ineffective assistance of counsel because of the lawyer’s failure to raise an issue or make an argument, and then try again.  Unfortunately, the standard for effective assistance of counsel is far below perfection.  Far, far, far below perfection.

So why do first level appellate courts, who always have the power of plenary review, chose escape out the back door of lack of preservation rather than do their jobs of deciding whether the defendant was properly convicted?  The theoretical basis is one of fairness.  We like fairness, in general, as it sounds so like we’re doing the right thing.  But fairness to whom and why?  This is where the entire preservation escape hatch fails.

Preservation is intended to provide fairness to the judge below, to protect her from the stigma of reversal for an error that was never claimed or presented, and hence she had no opportunity to avoid.  But nowhere in the Constitution do we find anything about the rights of judges to fairness or protection.  And certainly, no notion of fairness to judges can be said to trump the rest of those express rights that are provided defendants.  How did preservation come to trump all else?

There is an ugly, cynical side to preservation that is hidden behind this fairness notion.  This is particularly true when you remember that the first level appellate courts maintain the power to review anything they want to review, making preservation an announcement that they have affirmatively chosen to ignore injustice and error.  It protects their decision as well, since the top level appellate court, the Court of Appeals, is a court of limited jurisdiction rather than plenary power, and a lack of preservation decision almost always precludes further review.

It is important to understand the depths to which lack of preservations goes in order to appreciate how insidious it is.  If an objectionable question is asked, but the defense attorney doesn’t object, it is unpreserved.  Maybe the client chose that moment to whisper in the attorneys ear and he missed the question.  Too bad.  Move on.  If a surprise ruling is made from the bench and the attorney, on his feet trying to deal with being sandbagged, misses an argument against it, it is unpreserved.  Too bad.  Move on. 

But if the ruling was wrong, or the question objectionable, why should the defendant be denied the opportunity to challenge it on appeal.  After all, isn’t that why we have appellate courts?  Why yes, that is the reason.  Or at least it used to be.  Now it’s a game of “gotcha” to see how perfectly the lawyer defended, an odd concept given that the courts have held that no one is entitled to a perfect defense.

And preservation, like most things legal, has become a slippery slope, with ever-increasing notions of what constitutes adequate preservation.  The prosecutorial attacks on preservation have increasingly raised issues because of specific words used or left out.  The level of detail demanded increases decision by decision, always to the detriment of the defense.  First, an objection was required.  Then an objection with its basis.  Then an objection with its basis in highly specific terms.  Often with citation to a particular rule of evidence.  And so on.  And, of course, most judges won’t let lawyers make talking objections anyway, precluding fulfillment of the preservation requirement.

The concept of preservation is the antithesis of justice.  It’s the elevation of judicial self-protection over justice, the Constitution and fundamental fairness.  Note that fairness is due the guy they are trying to put in prison, not the judges who are paid to do their job properly.  At a time when we learn with regularity of innocent people spending decades in prison for crimes they didn’t commit, appellate reliance on lack of preservation to ignore error is inexcusable. 

No matter how much easier it may be for courts to punt, clear their overburdened dockets and cover the backs of their brethren, preservation is one of the most insidious enemies to the legitimacy of our court system.  If we cannot look to appellate courts to fulfill their responsibility of plenary review, then there is no place left to turn.

The Busiest Lawyer on Long Island

Some lawyers work hard.  But apparently none as hard as  Lawrence Reich, according to this Newsday story.  Not only does he work for the law firm of Ingerman Smith of Northport, but he also holds down 5 full-time jobs at 5 different school districts.


The attorney, Lawrence W. Reich, was listed as full time by five different school districts at once – Baldwin, Copiague, East Meadow, Bellmore-Merrick High School and Harborfields, according to records supplied by the New York State comptroller’s office. In 2000, for example, he was credited with working 1,271 days in one year. The year before, he was credited with working 1,286 days.

Wow.  My years don’t even have that many days.  I’m stuck with the usual 365 (leap years excepted).  I bet this guy could give seminars to Biglaw about how to bill.

So what does Reich have to say about his extraordinary, no heroic, efforts on the public dole?


Reich defended his arrangement with the districts as “common practice” among attorneys on Long Island.

This must be the “common practice” of lying, cheating, stealing?  I must have missed that day in law school. 

But he must have some ethical issues, right?  Not according to  his AV rating by Martindale-Hubbell.  So I guess this must be the norm for “V” rated lawyers, as he claims.

I keep wondering what I do wrong when I can’t manage to fit more hours into the day.  This is a lawyer we can all learn something from, provided we don’t get all hung up on little details like scamming the public.

Happy-Slapping, Another Sick Fad, Kills One And Puts Another in Prison

While not exactly new, happy-slapping is one of those truly sick and bizarre things that kids have dreamed up to ensure that stupidity is not lost from the gene pool. It’s just too funny, as far as these kids are concerned.

Happy-slapping is a random attack on an unsuspecting person that is filmed so that the perpetrators can enjoy the memories over and over again, and share it with all their friends to prove how brilliant they are.  It comes from our brothers across the pond, where spiked hair is considered way too ordinary to prove one’s machismo.

But for this young lady, it isn’t going to be very happy.

The 15-year-old, who cannot be named for legal reasons, pleaded guilty to aiding and abetting the manslaughter of Gavin Waterhouse last September when she filmed the attack on a mobile phone.

The girl admitted filming an attack on Mr Waterhouse, 29, of Keighley, West Yorkshire, in which he was punched and kicked. He died of a ruptured spleen.

The problem with this fad, other than the obvious harm it does to its victims, is that it reflects a broader disease that inflicts youth (and others).  In its more benign form, it can be seen in television shows and movies like “Jackass”, and even such “family entertainment” as “America’s Funniest Home Videos,” where videos of people being injured are the fodder of great humor.

Is it funny to watch someone do something stupid and suffer serious physical injury as a result?  Do we really enjoy seeing others hurt and in pain?  If so, what does this say about our society, and what message do these shows give our youth?

Reading up on the happy-slapping phenomenon, it appears that the perpetrators view it as harmless fun, a beating of an innocent, wholly unrelated victim, of no real consequence.  In the case noted above, the victim died, but the outcome usually isn’t death and so, to those who relish the happy-slap, it’s an anomaly and not representative of the usual circumstance.  What’s a mere beating, they figure.

The promotion of physical violence and harm as a form of entertainment is a disease, and it comes as no surprise that children have seized upon it as humorous.  When they end up prosecuted, such as this young woman for recording others inadvertently killing a man, it likely comes as a shock.  But they didn’t mean to hurt anybody, they proclaim.  It was an “accident”.  And she didn’t actually “do” anything to hurt the man; she just recorded it.

I don’t doubt for a moment that they mean what they say.  But they are wrong, and the problem is that they don’t realize they are wrong before they cause harm.  There is a fundamental disconnect in their minds between intent and conduct, and I believe this disconnect is the product of the message that pain and harm is funny.

Society has enough trouble dealing with crimes caused by malevolence.  It’s inexcusable to add crimes caused by the promotion of stupidity to the mix.  This has really got to stop.

H/T  Susan Cartier Leibel for this story.

Like Your Clients

Dan Hull at  What About Client? is absolutely right.  Lawyers should only represent clients they actually like.

Now this isn’t always an option, as public defenders and assigned counsel aren’t given an option as to whom they represent.  But one of the hallmarks of a private practice is the ability to pick your clients.  As my legal ethics prof in law school loved to say, “lawyers aren’t buses; they don’t have to pick up anybody waiting at the stop.” 

Too often, criminal defense lawyers take any case that walks in the door.  It has more to do with whether they have any loose change in their pocket than anything else, which relates to another pervasive issue.  But they don’t care whether they like the client.  They like the client’s money, and that’s good enough for them.

Not for me.  When I meet a new client, it is always my decision whether I want to take his case.  The client may well be interviewing me, but I’m interviewing the client as well.  It has nothing to do with whether they are guilty or innocent, or whether they are telling me the truth.  It rarely has anything to do with the nature of the offense, though I do not accept cases involving offenses against children (particularly sex offenses) unless I am persuaded that the defendant is innocent.  This is my one open issue as a criminal defense lawyer, and while others totally disagree with me, this is where I draw the line.

My interview is for the purpose of determining whether the representation will be a good fit.  A long time ago, I came to realize that working with defendants that I like makes a world of difference in my enjoyment of my work.  No, it doesn’t make it necessarily fun to be a criminal defense lawyer, as you’re still stuck with prosecutors and judges who may be markedly unpleasant, but it prevents a certain degree of misery.  Life is too short to make yourself miserable day after day.   

Liking your client has nothing to do with wanting to hang out with them, be like them, have them over for dinner.  It’s about having the ability to talk to them, show mutual respect and work with them productively.  If there was one word to describe what I look for, it’s respect.  No, not their respect toward me, but mine toward them.  If I find that I can’t muster respect for them, then my experience tells me that this will not work.

I’ve had many crazy client (a group that seems to have increased significantly in the past few years, by the way) who have been very satisfying to work with.  I’ve had remarkable success representing people with varying types of psychological problems and intellectual deficits, both in beating the case and getting them properly diagnosed and treated.  My approach toward clients is holistic, and if I can provide them with broader help than just as a lawyer, I do so.  This is particularly true when their families, schools, the system, have failed them.  Somebody has to take enough of an interest in their welfare to help them.

Naturally, professionals are the best clients to represent.  No, not doctors and lawyers, but professional criminals.  They understand that laws exists and that their conduct violates them.  The criminal justice system is a cost of doing business to them.  While they never meet the publics’ perception of sophistication about the system, they understood the risks they took and show the greatest appreciation of effort, regardless of result.  They are sophisticated enough to realize that lawyers aren’t plumbers; We can’t guarantee that we can stop the leak.

And what of doctors, lawyers, top-level executives?  White collar defendants are often the most difficult to work with in the beginning.  They are often incapable of comprehending their role in a prosecution at first, since they don’t perceive themselves as criminal defendants.  They are often too smart for their own good, trying to outsmart the lawyer or wanting to be involved in every aspect of decision-making.  They are “social equivalents” of the lawyer, and hence fight against the lawyer’s fulfillment of his role in order to maintain their status.

Ironically, white collar defendants are often the people who, under slightly different circumstances, would be the ones you would have to your home for dinner.  But not when you’re representing them.  If they cannot get it into their head that they are the client and you are the lawyer, then the representation will be unfulfilling and ineffective.  With gentle understanding, I find that they will slowly come to the realization that, for the purpose of the case, you are the lawyer and they are the client. 

But white collar defendants can be terribly overbearing as well.  Some will refuse to accept the respective roles of lawyer and client, and insist on being in control of their representation.  They will project their anger and frustration of the attorney, as if it’s the attorney’s fault that they were arrested and prosecuted.  They will make irresponsible demands, both of time and outcome.  Sometimes, this happens because they have no place else to vent and desperately need a catharsis.  Other times, it’s purely money-driven.  They pay you so you must do what they say. 

When I stand beside a defendant in court, I act as the shield between that one human being and everything else in the world.  If the proverbial bullet comes, I take the hit.  The bottom line is that once I accept a case, I accept the possibility that I will be called on to stand in front of that bullet and I am committed to doing so.  I’m not going to do it for a client I don’t like.

All said, over my 25 years, I’m happy to say that I’ve held firm to this position.  Money has never swayed me.  Hot cases have never turned my head.  And the results, both for my clients and myself, have proven over and over that it was the right choice.

What’s That Smell? Yesterday Telecoms, Today Banks

Perhaps the stench emanating from the Senate chamber wasn’t strong enough for you yesterday?  Well, it just got worse.  Senator Jeff Sessions (R-Ala) has sponsored a bill that immunizes commercial banks from having to pay billions of dollars in damages to a small, Plano, Texas company named DataTreasury, according to the Washington Post.

DataTreasury is the company that developed the system for digitally scanning, sending and storing checks.  This would be the system that banks have been using for years.  Except they have been infringing on DataTreasury’s patent to do so, and the boom is about to fall.

So what do banks do when they caught with their finger in the cookie jar?  They buy Congress.

Lobbyists for the Roundtable and the banks, including prominent free-lance lobbying firms Smith-Free Group, Bryan Cave Strategies and Quadripoint Strategies, conducted rush visits with Judiciary Committee members and their aides to advocate the measure. Sessions’s staff produced a three-page description of the amendment and its background with the help of the Roundtable and distributed it to the committee.

Commercial banks are considered a potent force on Capitol Hill, in part because of their heavy contributions to lawmakers. They are the 10th-largest donor to federal candidates among the industry groups followed by the Center for Responsive Politics. They also spend millions of dollars a year on lobbying.

Suddenly, an amendment gets tucked inside a bill that nobody knows about and slides through like a senator with a full tube of KY Jelly at a Jamaican international trade conference.

And is there any doubt as to the social utility of this amendment?


The provision introduced by Sessions did not name DataTreasury but was carefully tailored to apply to that company and its “check collection” system.  The amendment was approved by the committee in minutes and without opposition. The measure received little news media attention outside the banking trade press.

 That’s how they make sausage in Washington to feed those hungry lobbyists.  After all, it’s a lot cheaper to through a few mil into the campaign coffers than pay a few bil to the guy you stole the technology from.  And this way, many politicians will get to feed from the trough instead of one poor schmuck in Plano.  Or one small company.

The banks, naturally, are thrilled with the helpfulness of our fine government.


The banks are emphatic about the need for the protection. “This is a glaring example of the abuse of the system,” said former congressman Steve Bartlett (R-Tex.), president of the Financial Services Roundtable. “It’s an example of what’s wrong with patent law.” He called the Sessions amendment a priority for the banking industry.

So what’s wrong with patent law is that the guy who invents the system expects the big banks to pay for it?  Bad patent system.  Evil patent system.   This is an outrage.

But the United States Department of Commerce recognizes this end run as a dangerous precedent.


The Commerce Department has objected to the amendment, including in a letter last week to Sen. Patrick J. Leahy (D-Vt.), the Judiciary Committee chairman. “Limiting patent holders’ rights and remedies in this instance could reduce innovation in this technology area,” wrote Assistant Secretary Nathaniel F. Wienecke. “The Administration does not support exceptions to patent protection based on a particular technology.”

Who would invest in developing a new technology if the big corps can steal it and they buy off Congress to pass a law giving them immunity from liability? 

Rarely does one see Congress function in such a flagrantly cynical and despicable way.  Sure, they tried to slide it past everybody quietly, but they must have known that eventually somebody would learn about it.  The notion that banks can buy off liability through Congress makes the whole Telecom stink almost bearable.  At least the Telecoms did it because Justice told them it was to protect us from terrorists.  This one is pure simple greed, without any connection to a legitimate purpose, no matter how ridiculous.  Pure and simple, the banks need Congress to help them steal patented technology from this company, and our Congress is happy to help if the price is right.

Telecoms, Banks, just one question.  How much does Senator Sessions cost, and does he do children’s birthday parties?

Update:  Take a look at the comments to this post at Patently-O.  If the banks can just buy their way out of one big patent mess, what does that mean for others, and for the lawyers who represent them?  Might as well patent your innovation in China for all the good the United States will do you.

Full Disclosure:  I am an equity holder in DataTreasury, having received a small interest from a client some years ago, which is how I became aware of this story. 

What If Someone is Tasered And There’s No Video?

Then you deserved it.

Josh Booty, former NFL quarterback and sportscaster, found that out.  He was tased because he was “belligerent”.


“After being Tased, he was fully compliant,” Santa Ana, Orange County Sheriff’s Lt. Hal Brotheim said.

I would be too.  I don’t think you would need to tase me twice before I got the point.  And check out the nice shiner as well.  Obviously, if you’re going to get tased, it’s smart to wear your face guard.



We’ve had a number of important videos revealing  an officer pushing kids around or  knocking quadriplegics out of their wheelchairs to see if they bounce.  A cellphone with really good video capabilities seems like a worthy investment nowadays, doesn’t it?

Daily Dose of Heller

I know, most of you just can’t get enough of D.C. v. Heller.  And who am I to deny you?

When last we discussed Heller (which was somewhere like 5 minutes ago, I think), we noted that the concerns by big city District Attorneys that the Heller side (we want our guns and we want them NOW!) would wreak havoc for law enforcement.  This, it should be noted, is in contrast to the 31 Attorneys General who argue that we’re all safer when everybody packs heat.  Whatever.

But being an avid follower of Doug Berman, I learn more and more.  While we have already gotten the neo-con line(RKBA is a fundamental right, except for people we don’t like), which was as convincing as an unloaded AK-47.  But Doc Berman, who has clearly given this a lot of thought, has come up with a way to express this concern that spells out the situation with extreme clarity:

In other words, whether seen as living or dead, provisions in the Bill of Rights have often been dynamically interpreted to safeguard rights against the government that courts consider important (and I am not even talking about any penumbral emanations).  And, lets play out the Sixth Amendment analogy in light of current federal law barring all felons from gun ownership:  Would anyone find constitutional a federal law that made it a felony offense — and one subject to a 10-year federal prison sentence — for any and all previously convicted felon to hire a lawyer?

Now this argument may at first blush seem flip and facile.  And indeed, many of the comments Berman received argue that the analogy is way off base, whether texturally, historically, pragmatically or just because it seems too weird to be right.

I think he’s made a good point here.  Trying to pigeonhole the historic approach of excluding felons and the insane from weapons possession is no longer valid when the basic argument is that it’s a fundamental right.  That changes everything, and everything means that you can’t keep the parts you like and get rid of the parts you don’t. 

One of the better comparisons was the 1st Amendment free speech restrictions; a fundamental right but still subject to limits.  Of course, the limitations are subject to strict scrutiny, which is what is argued by the Heller supporters (the same one’s who dismiss the notion of felons having a right to arms).  What has yet to be heard is a good argument of how this would limitation would survive strict scrutiny for felons.  The insane may be another matter, at least during the pendancy of their incompetence.  Those convicted of violent felonies may similarly pass muster.  But what legitimate government purpose is served by denying Martha Stewart her snub-nose .22?

There are plenty of folks with felonies without a nexus to violence, most notably in the realm of drug sale and possessions.  Then there are those whose felonies are possession of a weapon itself, then a crime and soon to be a fundamental constitutional right.  What about felons who have not committed a crime in 5 years?  10 years?  25 years?  Don’t they have a right to protect themselves?

And of course, if the purpose of the 2nd Amendment is to have an armed population just in case the feds get a little too crazy and start behaving like King George (the third, not the 43rd), aren’t felons just as entitled to defend their rights, their homes, their families as anyone else?  Maybe, given the fact that the government has already imprisoned some of them for exercising their constitutional right to keep and bear arms, they are the ones most in need of guns.

DNA Exoneration Takes Another Weird Turn

The story of Lynn DeJac, her conviction and subsequent exoneration by DNA evidence showing that her boyfriend, the prosecution’s new best friend at trial, was the putative (and immunized) culprit, is not yet over.

Now, it appears that the death of 13 year old Crystallynn was caused by a cocaine overdose, as concluded by Dr. Michael Baden in this Buffalo News story.  Thanks to Kathleen Casey for the heads-up.  It seems that Dr. Sung-ook Baik, the associate chief Erie County medical examiner at the time of Crystallynn’s death in 1993, made a boo-boo.  He neglected to mention toxic levels of cocaine in Crystallyn at the time he gave the cause of death, in his opinion strangulation.  Except for the lethal amount of cocaine.  Oops. 

No, the story still isn’t over.  Lynn DeJac was happy about the blame being placed on her former boyfriend, Dennis P. Donahue (a/k/a the lying rat bastard).  But she was not at all happy about the news that her daughter died from a lethal cocaine overdose.  Not that she was likely to win mother of the year in any event, but this certainly wasn’t going to help.

This new-found forensic detail raises changes the calculus.  DeJac’s lawyer, inexplicably choosing to speak out on the issue (perhaps to make the most of his 15 minutes since there aren’t that many chances up in Buffalo), has this to say:

LoTiempo said he had mixed feelings about the cocaine overdose and the imminent dropping of the charges against his client.  “Professionally, I did my job,” he said of the charges being dropped against DeJac.

On the personal side, though, he feels for DeJac and the effect that the latest findings will have on the reputation of a girl who never saw her 14th birthday. “Personally, Lynn DeJac aside, I almost feel like I knew Crystallynn,” LoTiempo said. “If this isn’t a cocaine overdose, I feel bad for Crystallynn.”

LoTiempo refused to say how he believes Crystallynn died, although he did provide a hint in his final comment. “To me, there’s just as much proof that she was strangled to death,” he said. “But I’ll take it.”

Now it’s understandable that Lynn DeJac would prefer that her daughter’s death be blamed on her boyfriend than her abject failure as a mother.  But LoTiempo isn’t her publicist, and more important, appears to be covering up the issue this raises for him.  While he says he did his job since the charges against DeJac were dropped, there are 13 years of imprisonment that run smack through the middle of that claim.

If the cause of death was a lethal overdose of cocaine, then why didn’t LoTiempo beat the murder trial in the first place? 


Is that list of medical signs — including the frothing and the broken blood vessels — consistent with a manual strangulation?

“Bingo,” LoTiempo replied quickly, without elaborating.

 I bet he replied quickly.  But this is no game of bingo (quite the popular sport in Buffalo, I hear).


LoTiempo explained why he was so shocked at the claim that Crystallynn died from a cocaine overdose, as he recalled his 1994 conversation with Baik just before the medical examiner testified at the DeJac trial.

“The amount [of cocaine] that was being indicated in the bloodstream was such a small amount . . . that it was a non-issue at the time,” LoTiempo said.

Now that’s a curious conclusion, considering that Michael Baden, perhaps the best known pathologist around, found the amount to be lethal.  So how did Andrew LoTiempo arrive at his medical conclusion as to the cocaine being a “non-issue.”  According to LoTiempo, he took Baik’s word for it.  And now it appears that Baik was wrong.  That would be the second “oops”.  Why would DeJac’s attorney not investigate the cause of death if his client denies having murdered her daughter?  Great question.  Glad you asked.  But I have no answer.

And where did 13 year old Crystallyn DeJac get her hands on cocaine, and more particularly, enough cocaine to kill herself? 


Authorities probably will never know how, from whom and where Crystallynn got any cocaine. They believe Crystallynn was not a long-term cocaine abuser, as pathologists found no sign of any buildup of cocaine in her organs, and her friends were adamant that she was not a cocaine abuser.

This has been quite a case study for all involved, and nobody is walking away from this poor dead child with clean hands.  Nobody.