One of the dividing issues over the past four years was tax breaks. Under Bush, they were “tax breaks for the rich.” Under Obama and Clinton, they will be “tax breaks for the middle class.” The latter is more appealing politically, because there are way more middle class than rich, and this is an appeal to self-interest in exchange for a vote, better known as “The American Way.”
There is no one who likes taking the money they earned and handing it over to the government so that a bunch of people they don’t know can redistribute the taxpayer’s money. Taxes aren’t a rational discussion, but a purely self-serving one. Everyone hates paying taxes. We like some government services (the ones that do what we want done) and we hate the rest (especially the pork that we pay for so that incumbent politicians can get re-elected on our dime). But we still hate paying taxes.
Any view of taxes is going to be skewed by self-interest. If you’re rich, you argue that you pay the darn taxes so you should get a break. If you’re middle class, you argue that the rich have plenty of money and you’re struggling, so you should get a break. If you’re poor, then you should just get a break.
But Mike Cernovich at Crime & Federalism posts an example that is going to piss off a lot of people. But it makes its point very well. Plus, the example involves drinking beer on a daily basis, which makes it relevant in most people’s lives. Go read it, then come back here.
If you divorce the politics from the example, you have to admit that it makes its point.
Let’s admit something that is unpleasant. We want government to provide services, but we want someone else to pay for them. When it comes to taxes, the bottom line is that it’s unfair to you, no matter who you are. One of the best examples of a horribly conceived tax is the inheritance tax (called the “death tax” by those bad Republicans), except that they happen to be right on this one. Taxes are paid on the money coming in, but are then levied again when handed down to the next generation. Why is this right? Because it doesn’t affect most people, and it pays the freight out of someone else’s pocket. We can live with taxes that other people pay. It’s only the taxes we pay that suck.
It’s no crime to make money. It’s no crime to save and invest, and if all goes well, accumulate some degree of wealth. Sure, we indulge our socialist fantasies when we argue that “they can afford it,” but what we really mean is “better them than me.” So let’s all admit that what we really want is as free a ride as we can get, because we hate paying taxes.
Of course, the alternative is to elect people who don’t spend as much, or allocate funds toward things that really matter and stop dropping million dollar bombs, regardless of their positions on other issues. Of course, nobody would ever agree on what are worthy expenses. We all want the government to give us what we want, whether that includes health care for the poor or the mother of all bombs.
I’ve got to give Mike credit, not only for finding this but for being bold enough to post it.
Author Archives: SHG
Clemens Caught in the Perjury Trap (Update)
I’m not a baseball fan. Yankees, Mets, Red Sox, who cares. So the steroid scandal has no particular impact on me, so long as they stay away from the Super Bowl winning Giants locker room. But the fascination offers an opportunity to discuss perjury and obstruction of justice.
Since I wasn’t in Washington observing Roger the Rocket’s testimony, nor did I watch it on the telly, I have no opinion about how good or bad a job he did testifying. I know Brian McNamee’s lawyer, Earl Ward, and he’s a good guy. But Earl’s also a good lawyer, and he’d protect his client (by arguing in support of his credibility) no matter what.
So from Doug Berman comes this MLB.com article comes this opinion about Clemens’ testimony:
Roger Clemens was unconvincing in his testimony before Congress and may have opened himself up to federal perjury charges, a legal expert told MLB.com on Wednesday. Katherine Darmer, a former assistant U.S. attorney in New York and an expert on criminal procedure, said that Clemens did not come across as credible and that it would not be surprising to see the former big league hurler experience more legal troubles in days to come. “I thought Roger Clemens did not come across well,” said Darmer, a professor of law at Chapman (Calif.) University. “Coming at it from pretty much an open mind, I just thought he was not credible. He’s obviously got a lot to lose with his denials, but if I were his lawyer or his family, I’d be worried about perjury charges.”
First, the fact that Clemens felt it necessary to testify is understandable. He’s a public personality whose career is on the line. If he’s left forever tainted by this scandal, then his career is rendered meaningless. From a legal standpoint, it was foolish. But lawyering up and hiding behind an invocation of rights (or technicalities, if you prefer to view rights in that fashion), isn’t going to salvage his reputation. He had something to prove if his baseball reputation was to be salvaged.
Second, testifying isn’t as easy as everyone thinks. It’s unnatural. It requires practice, patience, and an ability to respond in what appears to be a credible fashion. Anyone who tries cases knows a simple truth: A witness can testify truthfully and look like crap. A witness can lie through his teeth and look credible. Truthfulness and giving the appearance of credibility are two entirely different things.
So now we come to former AUSA, now lawprof, Katherine Darmer’s view. She says that “Clemens did not come across as credible.” Since I have no clue whether this is true or not, and have some doubt whether this varies from observer to observer, I will accept her view as accurate. So my question is, “so what?”
The problem is that we have never figured out a foolproof way of determining which of two conflicting stories is true, or even if both are true as far as the witnesses are concerned. We look for “hallmarks” of truthfulness, such as consistency and the ability to answer questions in a forthright manner. But we also know that the hallmarks can go either way, such as consistency as evidence of a practiced, fabricated story that leaves no loose ends. Truth is often sloppy. If a witness has constructed a lie, then he would make it clean and perfect. Why create an imperfect lie?
Responses to questions may come off smooth ahd helpful, or resistant and misdirected. The former appears more credible, but the latter is often the normal human reaction to questions premised on assumptions with which the witness disagrees. Normal people answer questions in a way that corrects what is perceived to be the underlying assumptive error in the question. They try to help by correcting the question, and answering what they perceive to be the true point of the question. It’s very hard to completely let go of control, and just respond to questions no matter how far off base to the witness’ reality they may be.
But the real problem facing Rocket Roger can be seen quite clearly from Prof. Darmer’s conclusion. She doesn’t know who is telling the truth. But she has decided that, based upon his performance, Clemens is at risk of perjury. Where witnesses conflict, there is an inherent assumption that someone must be lying. Perjury, intentionally giving false testimony under oath on a material point, is in the wind. Obstruction of justice (or perjury light) is the fallback. But if there is a conflict, then someone must pay.
If this were TV, the cameras would now cut to the scene where we see exactly what happened so that we would know the truth, know who was lying and have closure. But this isn’t TV. Instead, we are left to the personal observations of people like Prof. Darmer. Is she right? Well, yes, that Clemens testimony did not appear credible to her is not subject to dispute. She tells us this.
However, giving testimony poorly, inconsistently, resistantly, does not provide an answer to the question. We are still left with deciding truth on a secondary basis, how well the witness performed. The nature of conflict, particularly at trial, is that there has to be a winner and loser. The winner becomes truthful by virtue of being the winner. And that makes the loser the liar. Not because he’s a liar, but because he didn’t win.
This can be seen more clearly when two witnesses give good performances on the stand, but offer testimony that is impossible to reconcile. Independently, each witness’ story sounds great. Together, they just can’t be. So who’s lying? Simple. The loser. Ask any defendant who has taken the stand in his own defense, only to be convicted. Ask about that obstruction of justice enhancement for exercising his constitutional right to testify on his own behalf. Note the smarmy look on the agent’s face outside the courtroom. Agents are taught to testify, and tend to be well-practiced. They usually look awfully good on the stand. And isn’t that what “truth” is all about?
People will decide who they believe in this scandal. Andy Pettitte was smart to stay away and let Clemens be the lightning rod. Clemens took a huge risk by appearing and answering questions. But that’s what you do when you are a major league baseball hero. Did he testify poorly? Apparently. Is he a liar. Possibly. Will he be indicted for perjury? Potentially. Is he guilty of perjury? Who can say he’s guilty of anything other than a poor performance.
This was a perjury trap. Someone was going to walk away under the cloud of perjury, whether it was Clemens or McNamee. McNamee had the upper hand, having been far more practiced for the performance ahead of him by having had much more time and being far more inclined to be molded for the purpose of giving a good performance.
Celebrities tend to make tough clients, unwilling to bend to the advice of counsel in how to testify and often having counsel too starstruck to tell the client that they aren’t coming off as credible as they think. Sometimes, they just won’t listen to advice. These are people who are used to getting their way. They don’t like being told what to do, especially by people they are paying. But that makes them arrogant, not deceptive.
There have been casualties in this war on steroids. Barry Bonds, Marion Jones and Dana Stubblefield, all black, as noted by Doug Berman, opening the political door to the need for a white defendant. Clemens walked into this void and may very well find himself the perfect target. Whether he deserves it may never been known, but that doesn’t really matter when you find yourself in the perjury trap.
Clemens might have walked out of the hearing a hero if he had put on a spectacular performance. But alas, he’s only a baseball player, not an actor. Or an agent. It looks like he rolled the dice and lost. But that doesn’t answer the question of whether he lied.
Update: Howard Wasserman at PrawfsBlawg points out in this post the partisan attacks on Clemens, which may well have plenty to do with how credible he appeared. Darmer never mentioned anything about it being an inquisition. So maybe credibility is an issue all around?
Also, with all the attention focused on Roger the Rocket, did everybody forget that the Senate voted yesterday to let the government wiretap at will and immunize corporate America for aiding and abetting? I hope not. I mean, it’s not baseball, but it still matters.
Simple Justice Now Has One Rule
After a year, you come to learn a few things. Up to now, I’ve run this joint with very few rules. One, self-imposed, is that I prefer to avoid the use of profanity. Not because I have anything against it per se, but because it’s usually unnecessary to express one’s point. Another rule has been to delete (or edit out) promotion content from comments. And a third has been to delete attach comments, where one commenter has an ax to grind against another. The bottom line has been about civility.
But I’m going to make one new rule, and break one old rule. Before telling you what the new one is, I want to preface it by saying the obvious. This is my blawg. I invite readers to read, but that doesn’t give them a right to make demands, be obnoxious or be offensive. In fact, you have no right to comment at all. I reserve the right to delete and/or edit comments, and to block you from commenting altogether. Why? Because I can.
While I generally don’t moderate comments, I eventually get tired of people behaving poorly. If you don’t like it, you don’t have to come here. My feelings won’t be hurt. But if you do come here and wish to comment, act like a human being. You definitely do not have a right to come here and be offensive. It’s my blawg. If you want to be offensive, do it on your own blawg. I now understand why so many blogs that have been around for a while either moderate or do plenty of deleting. There are lot of inappropriate people out there.
And so, without further ado, my new rule:
That’s it. I’m here to have fun, not deal with assholes. If you want to be an asshole, go somewhere else.
Scalia Has Outsmarted Us Again
Yet another bit of turmoil stemming from Justice Antonin Scalia’s BBC interview on the constitutionality of torture. Jan Greenberg, in her Legalities column, raises the time-worn but still manly Scalia connection to Jack Bauer.
But in the interview, it’s Scalia who seems to be taking folks to task–venting about people who make quick moral judgments about torture without considering the hard hypotheticals. The choice made, he suggested to the BBC reporter, depends on the circumstances.
The interview has Nino calling the rejection of torture as a lawful means of prevent nuclear holocaust in Los Angeles (does this plot line sound familiar?) “absurd”.
Oh, that Justice Scalia is a sly one. He sucked Jan Greenberg right into his trap. But he’s not gonna get me, nosireebob.
Listen to the timbre of his voice. He can barely keep himself from laughing. He can barely hold it in. People, he’s messing with us. He’s playing with our heads. He’s outsmarted us!
Justice Scalia doesn’t really believe this. Come on. This is one very smart guy. Do you really think he’d be talking up some Brit reporter (Brit, for goodness sake!) about an issue that is likely to come before the Supreme Court, expressing his prejudice in advance of a case and controversy?
This is his recusal trap. He’s set himself up so that when the torture case finally makes its way to the Supremes, he’s forced to offer his profuse apologies and beg off the case, finding himself to have “inadvertently” expressed opinions on the subject that would create the grave appearance of impropriety.
But why would he do this? Come on. He knows torture is wrong, but if he’s forced to take sides, his fan club is going to burn his signed decisions in a huge bonfire. How could he abandon his favorite fictional character, Jack?
But he sounded sorta equivocal. Not really, unless you think the word absurd is open to more interpretations that most. Sure, he had to keep it a little wiggly, or nobody would buy into his scheme. We all know he’s too smart to do something so blatantly foolish as make a clear, blanket statement of position on a highly controversial subject likely to come before the Supreme Court. That would be crazy, right?
But how could he not know that by giving this interview and making these statements, he would be compelled to recuse himself from the Court’s consideration of cases of monumental significance to the nation? Exactly. How could he not know.
Simple Justice is 1 Year Old Today
It seems like I’ve been blawging forever, but today is one year. This offers an opportunity to step back and look at what has happened in that brief time.
- 910 Posts
- 569,216 Words
- 1872 Comments
- 268,303 Page Views
- 936,478 Visitors
The most read post over the past year is The Lawyer Look, read 17,431 times. Some posts were not well received.
Like Anne Reed, whose first anniversary at Deliberations was a few days ago, I have many to thank for the success Simple Justice has enjoyed over the past year. Rather than provide a list and risk leaving out someone to whom I owe a debt of gratitude, I thank you all.
During the past year, I’ve seen some terrific new blawgs come online, and some fade away. I’ve heard from brilliant people and not so brilliant people. I’ve been recognized by blogs of consequence, and roundly ignored by blogs of consequence. I’ve been been included in beauty pageants, and found to be mildly unattractive. It’s been a good year.
I hope that Simple Justice has been able to bring some value to the conversation around the blawgosphere. It has been enormously valuable to me, as I have learned more in the past year than in the 25 preceding it. I know I’ve been a strident supporting of a substantive practical blawgosphere, sometimes to the consternation of many, but it offers so much to so many. My hope is that it continues to be a vibrant force, and that its reach continues to grow.
So thank you for visiting, for reading and for participating in my small corner of the blawgosphere.
The Senate Has Voted: Privacy is Dead (Olbermann Video Update)
The United States Senate, under control of people who call themselves Democrats, has voted 68 to 29 to put an end to privacy and to elevate the sanctity of corporate profits above the interests of the American People.
As the New York Times limply puts it:
After more than a year of wrangling, the Senate handed the White House a major victory on Tuesday by voting to broaden the government’s spy powers and to give legal protection to phone companies that cooperated in President Bush’s program of eavesdropping without warrants.
And why would the Senate hand a lame-duck President with the lowest approval rating in history such a massive victory?
Republicans hailed the reworking of the surveillance law as essential to protecting national security, but some Democrats and many liberal advocacy groups saw the outcome as another example of the Democrats’ fears of being branded weak on terrorism.
Glenn Greenwald at Salon, on the other hand, is hardly as reluctant to call it what it is.
The Senate today — led by Jay Rockefeller, enabled by Harry Reid, and with the active support of at least 12 (and probably more) Democrats, in conjunction with an as-always lockstep GOP caucus — will vote to legalize warrantless spying on the telephone calls and emails of Americans, and will also provide full retroactive amnesty to lawbreaking telecoms, thus forever putting an end to any efforts to investigate and obtain a judicial ruling regarding the Bush administration’s years-long illegal spying programs aimed at Americans.
Glenn makes the significance clear:
[T]he Senate is about to [this was published before the vote] enact a bill which has two simple purposes: (1) to render retroactively legal the President’s illegal spying program by legalizing its crux: warrantless eavesdropping on Americans, and (2) to stifle forever the sole remaining avenue for finding out what the Government did and obtaining a judicial ruling as to its legality: namely, the lawsuits brought against the co-conspiring telecoms. In other words, the only steps taken by our political class upon exposure by the NYT of this profound lawbreaking is to endorse it all and then suppress any and all efforts to investigate it and subject it to the rule of law.
That’s it. Game over. The slippery slope that started with the FISA court, then got a huge push from the most bizarre series of assaults on basic freedom, the USA Patriot Act, has now hit bottom. Years of illegal wiretaps legalized, and, for the truly cynical amongst us, a free pass to corporate America to join with the government in the subjugation of its People.
The People are now officially the enemy of the government in the rhetorical name of protecting the People. It’s the perfect circle, if you’re inclined to view politics through Orwellian eyes. Some might view this statement as overwrought, and perhaps it is for the moment. But the trend has been clear and overwhelming for a long time now. And Americans have found excuse after excuse to allow it, if not embrace it. I wonder if Jefferson would agree with de Tocqueville that we are unworthy of democracy and freedom.
Consider Olbermann’s perspective:
One of the problems with being a little long in the tooth is that you get to watch things develop. Wiretaps were once viewed as such a shocking intrusion into the privacy of people that they were heavily scrutinized and frequently frowned upon. Eavesdropping was a bad thing, heavily disfavored and a last resort. It’s now the panacea of security, described as if it’s the savior of freedom. And people nod their heads, acceptingly.
Even more cynically, our Senate Democrats have made it clear that corporate America is no longer subject to law as long as it’s acting with the blessing of the government. Not only does the Senate elevate profits over its citizens, but it has ensured that dirty secrets will never be revealed.
History is written by the victor. The victor here is the government in the war against the American people. And victory was handed to the government by the Democrats in the Senate. You can argue about whether to vote for Clinton or Obama, but I fail to see the differences between politicians anymore. Jefferson and Madison are long dead, and the people of America have grown too tired, complacent and ignorant to fill their shoes.
When the Lawyer Fails
Can anyone think of any federal criminal defense lawyer who doesn’t know about the safety valve? I can. Glenn G. Cortello. Hard to imagine, you say? Not only is it true, but it gets worse.
Liptak’s Sidebar column tells about the sentencing of Army Sgt. Patrick Lett to 5 years. He was represented by this Cortello, and despite Judge William H. Steele’s expressed desire to go below the mandatory minimum due to aberrant behavior, he was stuck.
Except he wasn’t stuck. An army buddy, Matthew Sinor, who was in his second year at Ohio State, went to the sentencing to support his friend. When he heard the sentence, he wrote to the judge, and the lawyers, to advise them that Lett was safety valve eligible.
Realizing that he had an out, the judge, a former marine, corrected his mistake and sentenced Sgt. Lett to time served, 11 days. Great, right? Except, you technically can’t do that.
The government, in all its appreciation and generosity for Sgt. Lett’s putting himself in harm’s way, appealed. The 11th Circuit reversed, holding that while Judge Steele could have sentenced the defendant to 11 days, once he sentenced him to 5 years, he could not change his mind.
So what did Glenn G. Cortello have to say about all this? Did he thank Matthew Sinor? Send him a bottle of champagne? Offer him a job upon graduation? Show some sign of humanity and humility?
Sergeant Lett’s defense lawyer, who had been paid $10,000, did not appreciate Mr. Sinor’s intercession, which he called “insulting.”
“If you think five years was a bad job on my part, then you wanted a magician and not a lawyer,” the lawyer, Glenn G. Cortello, wrote to Mr. Sinor in an e-mail message. “When you get out of law school and have practiced criminal law for over 20 years, I’ll discuss it with you.”
Apparently, Cortello was a very, very small man. Not only had he blown the safety valve, making neither an attempt to have his client “valved” despite the mandatory minimum, nor objecting to the PSI or offering any argument to even make the effort to help his client, but he then ridicules and abuses this kid law student who did the job that Cortello was paid to do.
Now, I grant you that this must have been an unbelievably humiliating experience for Cortello, Mr. Big-Shot 20 year lawyer, being showed up by some kid law student. But then, he earned it through his ineffective assistance and disgraceful post-hoc attack.
But the guy couldn’t be that big a jackass, you say? Once he calms down, he’ll recognize the error of his ways, his massive incompetence, his misguided antagonism? Nope.
On the phone Monday, Mr. Cortello said Sergeant Lett “got lucky” with his five-year sentence. “They would have been justified in giving him 20 years,” Mr. Cortello said.
If only Liptak had included the phone number so we could keep Cortello in our Rolodex for future referrals.
Some might point out that the judge neglected to consider the safety valve as well, though from the Circuit opinion, the judge believe himself constrained by the mandatory minimum based on a pre-Booker analysis of his authority, which he was persuaded by Sinor no longer applied in a post-Booker world. Also, the plea itself was considered pretty good, since the local prosecutors rarely allowed a defendant to plea to distribution when charged with a conspiracy. So the Cortello had accomplished a significant coup in getting the plea. But in light of the safety valve, one accomplishment just wasn’t good enough.
And now for the incredible blogosphere hook. So who taught Matthew Sinor sentencing law? None other than Doc Berman of Sentencing Law and Policy! Doug Berman is now doing a pro bono cert. petition, though I can’t see any real issue with the 11th Circuit’s decision. It sucks, but that’s the law. On the other hand, the defendant has not been resentenced, so he remains out on supervised release under the original sentence. Thus, it’s not like he’s sitting in jail while awaiting the court to reject the petition.
It strikes me that this is ripe for a 2255 motion (28 USC 2255) on the basis of ineffective assistance of counsel. There’s discussion over at Doc Berman’s blog about how they can get to the 2255 after the Supreme Court if they don’t win. While that’s true, and the defendant remains out, it was made clear by the sentencing judge that he wanted to sentence this defendant to time served. I wouldn’t be so cavalier about this detail. Not all judges would have seen things quite the same.
What if Judge Steele is hit by a truck? Then, the slam-dunk 2255 could turn into an iffy proposition. Times change. Things happen. You have a judge prepared to give you the outcome the defendant desires and should get. Having fun playing lawyer in front of the Supremes, unlikely to ever reach the Supremes in this case, could result in losing the judge you want and need. That would be a disaster, and a shame.
Calling a Witness to Plead the Fifth (Updated)
Update: While the trial of Cesar Rodriguez has had its low points, this was not one of them. I failed to note in the article that the testimony of the mother, Nixzalis Santiago, was taken outside the presence of the jury, which changes everything. She was not called to plead the fifth in front of the jury, and Justice Priscilla Hall’s actions were precisely what she should have done. So mea culpa, and my thanks to Brooklyn ADA John O’Marra for bringing this error to my attention.
The bizarre trial of Cesar Rodriguez, on trial for the murder of his daughter Nixzmary, just gets weirder and weirder. According to this Newsday account, the defense was allowed by Justice Priscilla Hall to call the mother, 29 year old Nixzaliz Santiago to the witness stand even though her attorney told the court that she would assert her right not to incriminate herself.
Rodriguez’s defense attorney, Jeffrey Schwartz, wanted Santiago to testify in an effort to substantiate the defense argument that it was Santiago who struck the fatal blows that killed Nixzmary. Though Santiago’s defense attorneys said she would assert her right not to testify, Justice Priscilla Hall said Santiago had to take the stand to make sure there weren’t any questions she could safely answer.
Black letter law provides that a witness cannot be called to testify if the only purpose of the testimony is to have the witness invoke privilege in front of the jury.
From the defendant’s side, however, the constitutional right to present a defense, that the mother rather than the father delivered the death blow, is a critical fact to be proven. Of course, the defendant might be able to testify to that fact, but he has a right not to testify too.
So what was Justice Hall thinking when she allowed the mother to be called to take the 5th? Did the judge really think that the mother might slip up, take the 5th as to most questions, but somehow answer the question of whether she delivered the death blow? It’s doesn’t seem likely.
“She was only being used by Cesar Rodriguez’s lawyers in order to try and find some way to incriminate her in this trial of Cesar Rodriguez, to make it seem she was the person who killed her daughter,” said one of her lawyers, Robert Abrams, after the hearing. “She had nothing to do with the killing of her daughter. She took the Fifth Amendment because that is her right.”
Aside from the non-sequitur, that’s obviously the defense’s purpose. By asking the damning question and getting an invocation of the 5th in response, it clearly leaves the jury to conclude that the testimony that would be incriminating is that she did exactly what the defense is arguing she did. It’s not supposed to work that way, meaning the jury should take nothing from the invocation of privilege, but of course it will. It’s only human nature.
So, after the “coffee mug defense” fiasco, the defendant seems to have scored big by having the mother take the stand. Like I said, this is turning out to be one weird trial.
More Heller: What Do The States Think?
I know, everyone is tired of hearing about DC v. Heller (you remember, the 2d Amendment RKBA case?). But I still find it interesting, and since this is my blawg, I get to write about it. Nobody makes you read this stuff, you know.
From David Kopel at Volokh, who has done yeoman’s work parsing the 732 amici briefs submitted for both sides and has earned my personal gratitude, comes this examination of the positions taken by various states and cities as to the efficacy of the reinterpretation of the second amendment to guarantee an individual, fundamental right.
Here’s the breakdown:
- 31 States have backed Heller
- 5 States have backed the District of Columbia
- 18 District Attorneys have backed DC
- 14 States are still looking for someone who can read the Circuit decision
What’s fascinating about this breakdown is how the various states deal with the impact of this decision on gun control and regulation, and the significance of the lack thereof on the safety of Americans. Those states backing Heller argue that making the RKBA a fundamental right, subject to strict scrutiny, will have no impact on the ability to regulate gun possession, and simultaneously argue that more guns carried by law-abiding citizens means better protection against crime.
The others, and particularly the big city district attorneys, argue that this will have a devastating affect on safety, with gun-toting mamas shooting up the place since they would no longer be able to prevent people from exercising their fundamental RKBA.
But all of this begs one question. If the 2d Amendment is a fundamental individual right, then what difference does the potentially perilous outcome make? Like it or not, a right is a right. If you don’t like the right, then amend the Constitution. It’s akin to arguing that you don’t like the 4th because it lets criminals go free. Another tough noogies argument.
Clearly, the purpose of arguing the impact of the change is to give the Justices pause to step back from the textual and historical analysis and consider the practical perspective. We do this all the time, arguing that the evidence was legally insufficient because we want the court to keep the idea in the back of its head that an innocent person may have been convicted while its considering our other arguments. In short, it’s a blatant attempt to prejudice the Supreme Court while it’s considering the primary issue before it.
It’s exciting to see such divergent and strong positions taken by so many big-time players. This is federalism in action, and I can imagine Jefferson watching this play out and smiling, content in the knowledge that states still have enough life in them to disagree with each other.
How The Other Half Thinks About Wiretaps
While some prefer to deny they exist, I find it helpful to understand how the other half (third, three-quarters?) thinks. To do that, I turn to one of two conclusive sources, the New York Post or the Wall Street Journal, which are largely the same, except that Rupert Murdoch prefers the Post because it has better headlines.
Yesterday, the WSJ had an editorial about wiretaps. It was fascinating, not because it was persuasive or accurate, but because there are a lot of people who will read this and accept it as reality.
The Senate takes up wiretapping of foreign terrorists this week, and the stakes couldn’t be higher. Not only for the ability of our spooks to eavesdrop on al Qaeda, but also regarding Congressional and judicial intrusion into Presidential war powers. Some damage seems certain, but the issue is how much damage President Bush will accept.
The first step is to frame the issue. We are informed that while the superficial issue is the ability of “our spooks” (when’s the last time you heard that term used?) to eavesdrop on al Qaeda, the secret issue is the damage to the presidency. And where does the Journal stand on this attack on executive sovereignty?
We believe — and appellate courts have stated — that the President already has such authority under the Constitution. But the political left claims this is “illegal” under FISA, and Mr. Bush has agreed to work with Congress on a compromise.
Who knew that the political left held such sway over President Bush? What a sell-out.
By far the worst threat is an amendment from Senator Chris Dodd (D., Conn.) to deny legal immunity to telephone companies that cooperated with the government on these wiretaps after 9/11. The companies face multiple lawsuits, so a denial of even retrospective immunity would certainly lead to less such cooperation in the future.
It’s always about lawsuits with those guys. But wait, there’s more evil afoot.
Which brings us to the larger problem with this entire exercise. Congress’s overriding goal here is to further hamstring our intelligence war-fighters with legal rigidity and complexity, but to do so in a way that dodges its own oversight duties by passing the buck to FISA judges. White House lawyers know this is unconstitutional, but intelligence officials say it’s more important to have Congress’s blessing for these wiretaps. And because the telecom companies won’t cooperate without immunity, Mr. Bush is being bullied into trading away some of his own power to get that immunity.
And if White House lawyers “know this is unconstitutional,” then it’s unconstitutional. Just ask John Yoo.
This editorial love-note to President Bush is designed to bolster his fortitude to stand up to those lefties who would emasculate the presidency by suing telecoms for enabling warrantless wiretaps. Not even a lame-duck Texan likes to be called a pansy by a New Yorker.
Now is our President going to let Congress dodge it’s duty by leaving it up to judges to make judicial decisions? And will those decision-dodgers in Congress emasculate the presidency by usurping the constitutional executive spook powers? The editors offer their answer:
[A]ny further concessions would amount to an abdication as Commander in Chief. He has the political high ground on this issue. If Congress does more harm, he should declare that to protect the country he’ll use his Constitutional war powers to wiretap al Qaeda anyway and toss the issue squarely in the middle of the Presidential campaign.
Take that, Obama girl! I thought you ought to know.


