Author Archives: SHG

Why Law Review Will Make You Rich!

Scott Dodson at  LawPrawfs writes about whether there are too many law reviews.  Like there’s a question?  But Scott offers a justification for the proliferation of nuclear weapons law reviews that caught my eye.  He asks, “does law review experience actually make better law students and lawyers . . . ?”

His answer?  Yes!  Yes, yes, yes.  Of course, Scott inserts that “I was on two journals at Duke (yes, I was not very bright back then).”   Notice the deft self-deprecation while simultaneously smacking those of you who weren’t invited to be on even one law journal?  Sweet.

His reasoning for elevating his own experience into a rationale for more law reviews, and hence more law review articles, than anyone could possibly read or want goes like this:


I think journal experience is beneficial.  Journal members learn at least two skills: how to Bluebook and how to edit.  Granted, journal Bluebooking is different than brief Bluebooking, and scholarly editing is different than brief editing, but there are also similarities, and I think those similarities end up enhancing lawyerly skills . . . A third skill that many journal members develop is writing, if they have the opportunity to publish a student note or comment.  Not every journal member does that, but those that do usually gain valuable writing experience.

That’s it?  That’s the best he can say about students on law review?  And Biglaw pays big bucks for this?  Anyone want to consider the impact of in-breeding?

The learn to use the Bluebook (kinda).  Doesn’t every student?  And Scott, it’s really not that hard to learn citation form, nor all that critical.  You can always look it up if you’ve got a question.

They learn to edit (kinda).  I’ve always found it curious that students edit lawprofs’ work.  What does this tell you about the lawprofs?  Proofread, I understand, but edit?  If they removed every use of the words “normative pedagogy,” I would be behind you 100%.  Otherwise, so what.

They learn to write a note or comment (maybe).  I completely agree that too many students leave law school unable to write a cogent sentence.  But I fail to see the connection between writing a law review comment and writing a cogent sentence that a lawyer might ever need. 

The best reason that I can think of appears nowhere in Scott Dodson’s post.  The reason for so many law reviews is that it allows that many more students to be on them, thus assuring them jobs with Biglaw and starting salaries equivalent with Supreme Court Justices.  Cut the number of law reviews and how would Biglaw know who to invite to the picnic? 

As for lawprofs, what would you do without a bunch of law journals begging for articles?  You would have all this extra time to spend preparing for class, conceiving of brilliant discussion topics for your students, enlightening young minds to the mystery of the law.  God forbid.

ABA Calls for Prosecutorial Ethics

What’s most shocking about this story from the  ABA Journal is that there is any need for it.  The ABA House of Delegates this morning, by overwhelming voice vote, passed a measure (DOC), 105B, that would seek changes in state ethics rules for


prosecutors to disclose evidence creating a reasonable likelihood that a defendant did not commit the crime for which he or she was convicted, and to take steps to remedy such convictions.

Imagine, prosecutors would be ethically required not to convict people knowing that they concealed evidence that the defendant was innocent, or keeping people they have reason to believe are innocent in prison just because they managed to get a conviction.  The ABA has gone radical.

Stephen Saltzburg, chair of the ABA’s Criminal Justice Section and a professor at the George Washington University Law School in Washington, D.C., told the House, “The rules are very simple: if prosecutors have new, credible evidence of innocence, they have to do something about it. It’s not a big burden.”

Nor has it ever been that big a burden.  It’s just that some prosecutors do it, other don’t.  Some believe in their responsibility to disclose Brady, or worse yet, not convict people they believe may be innocent, others don’t.

That’s the problem with ethical precepts: They work best when people choose to comply.  The fact that the ABA feels compelled to spell this out is truly a shame.  But for those prosecutors who were a little unclear about their ethical responsibilities, I hope this clears things up.

Avvo Giveth and Avvo Taketh Away

Late last week, an after-hours call came into my office.  It was a young woman from New England in need of a lawyer for her friend.  I called her back and learned that she had gotten  my name from Avvo.  Now, I’ve written quite a bit about the efficacy of Avvo, as has the rest of the blawgosphere, but this was the first time that I’m aware of that someone actually used Avvo and came up with my name.

The woman explained to me that she had gotten a referral locally to a New York lawyer, but she wasn’t thrilled with her choice.  Consequently, she decided to use the internet to find a different lawyer.  Somehow, she stumbled on Avvo and found me.

I emailed Avvo co-founder and Vice President Paul Bloom to let him know.  He urged me to post about it, but I wasn’t entirely sure whether I should and, if I did, what exactly I thought about it.  One call doesn’t validate a process.

As far as the caller went, she wanted to find a lawyer but the case wasn’t all that serious and it was in Westchester County, some distance from my office (meaning that it required substantial travel time).  Given financial priorities, it seemed more appropriate for her to retain an attorney closer to the courthouse.  I referred her to an excellent local attorney.

She expressed appreciation for the name, and then told me that he was one of the dozen lawyers whose names she had located via the internet.  It was her plan of action to call each of them and discuss the case and their fee structure.  Since I had already taken myself out of the running for the case, I decided to give a little paternalistic unsolicited advice.

In the old days, a potential client might get one or two names of attorneys.  On a bad day, three names.  They would call and meet with them, make a decision and be represented.  This was usually doable, though the time that it would take to meet with the two or three lawyers left the defendant unrepresented during a critical period.  But this was the price of being thorough, and within a few days a lawyer would be retained.

Things are different now.  As this young woman made me realize, the list of potential attorneys has grown exponentially.  It was now overwhelming.  There was no possible way she could meet a dozen lawyers in a timely fashion.  Moreover, she frankly had no ability to assess their relative qualifications in any event, making this dozen appointments a monumental waste of everyone’s time.  She would gather so much information that she would be paralyzed, unable to reach a reasoned decision and incapable of making any meaningful comparison.  All the while, the defendant would be effectively without counsel.

There are some placed on earth where there may only be a handful of criminal defense lawyers in the area.  New York City is not one of those places.  Too much information is just as useless as too little.  It also brings out the worst of lawyer in the effort to get the case, both in self-hype and for those inclined to denigrate others.  Let us say that, in broad strokes, there are 200 top criminal defense lawyers in New York City.  Can someone tell me how a person is supposed to chose when you can access all of them from your keyboard?

I received an email from the Westchester County lawyer to whom I referred the case.  He met with the young woman over the weekend, and thought the meeting went very well.  But she told him at the end of the meeting that she couldn’t make a decision yet, as she had appointments to meet more lawyers.  She found them on Avvo.  As far as I’m aware, she has yet to retain counsel.

You Could Be President, If They Let You In

I’ve been  reading  a lot about a musician named Amy Winehouse.  She must be pretty good, since she won 5 out of 6 Grammy Awards last night.  But she wasn’t there to accept them, because the United States Department of Keeping People Out denied her a visa because of a photograph showing her smoking something from a pipe.

According to the government, this showed that she was engaged in the “use and abuse of narcotics.”  They relented at the last minute, but by then it was too late.

Now I have no idea who Amy Winehouse is.  I don’t know if I’ve ever heard her music, but if I have I’m not aware of it.  Chances are my daughter would know all about her, and if she ever pulls this Ipod earplugs out of her head, I’ll ask her about it.  My point is that Amy Winehouse is just another human being to me.

But I have some difficulty understanding how we maintain this archaic approach to people who want to visit the United States who have used drugs.  Our presidential candidates have used drugs.  We know this, regardless of what they have to say on the subject, because there are only 3 people who lived through the 1960s who never ingested any substances at all, and they are all now retired from the Bush administration.

Yet, our Puritan ethic prevents us from getting beyond this detail when it comes to visitors from foreign lands?  Do we really suppose that those British Airways jets are full of people who have avoided all contact with improper substances?   de Tocqueville knew this about us in 1840, and we have learned a darn thing since?

I’m not advocating drug use.  I’m advocating that we grow up.  We went through all this in 1972, when Nixon tried to deport John Lennon, the moptop anarchist. 

The people of the United States have come to grips with the fact that many most young people have at least experimented with illegal drugs.  Other than the ones misfortunate enough to have gotten arrested for it, and who spend the rest of their lives tainted as violent felons (as per Mukasey), the rest are forgiven and allowed to grow up to be President. 

Is the irony of this misbegotten mindset bothering anyone other than me?

When Private Practice Isn’t For You

Blonde Justice was long a blog about a woman public defender’s world with a great following.  I don’t usually read it or post about it, because its emphasis was more on how its anonymous Blond protagonist feels, and feelings are a subject with which I am largely unfamiliar.

A while back, the anonymous Blond protagonist made the Big Change.  She went from public defender to private criminal defense lawyer.  I guess it seemed like the right thing to do at the time, a natural progression.  Now, it appears that she regrets her decision.

After a discussion about therapy and anti-depressants, she makes her point:


But, in this situation, I don’t really want to just be happier about where I am. I want to make a change. And I worry that taking an anti-depressant would placate me into staying in this job longer than necessary. And if I could carve out an hour a week to see a therapist, that hour might be better spent looking for a new job. Right now, I think finding a new job would do more for me than any amount of therapy or drugs.

Being unhappy (depressed?) about one’s circumstance may be a product of some organic problem.  Or, it may be a product of being unhappy about one’s circumstance.  Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar.

Private criminal defense is not for everyone.  Heck, being a lawyer is not for everyone.  Some of the knee-jerk reactions are to dwell in the misery, blame depression as if it’s an end in itself, and discuss feelings ad naseum.  I can imagine the ensuing comments discussing the relative merits of drugs versus therapy to deal with depression.  My, how some people love to love depression.

But the anonymous Blond protagonist has chosen not to bask in self-pity, but rather to recognize that she’s found herself in a place that isn’t right for her, and that the solution to the problem is to move to another place.  No matter how many people, how many blogs, tell you about the glory and wonders of private practice; No matter how many friends and admirers discuss the millions of books about dealing with depression; it’s good to recognize that you don’t care for your situation and you would be happier with a change of scenery.

Since I don’t know the anonymous Blond protagonist at all, I couldn’t possibly say whether she’s nailed her own dilemma or not.  But I’m inclined to believe that she knows herself better than those who project their vision of depression onto her.  It’s always interesting to see how people want to “help” by trying to impose their lifestyle onto someone else.

I just wanted to let her know that there’s nothing wrong or unusual about finding that this isn’t the life you want for yourself. Forget the drugs and therapy to mask reality, and just change it.   It takes guts to recognize that a mistake has been made, but if you believe that your unhappiness stems from a decision to enter private practice, then change it and get back to the place where you want to be. 

Will Lawprofs Really Loosen Up?

A new blog has magically appeared, with built in mahogany paneling and a raging fire in the limestone fireplace.  Big cushy leather Chesterfield chairs and Queen Anne side tables, with sifters of brandy scattered around the room.  It’s the Faculty Lounge.

I can hear  Gideon asking already, “Why do I care?” But I know his devilish attitude will force him to stop by, even though he’ll hide behind the curtains.  The lawprofs have been the antithesis of the practical blawgosphere, blogging about scholarly subjects from their Ivory Tower offices, opining about our clients when they’ve never shaken hands with an accused murderer or listened to why someone has chosen heroin over gainful employment.

But lawprofs have something that us working lawyers don’t: time.  And, while I say this begrudgingly, some are awfully darned smart and bring some incredible ideas about the law to the blogosphere. 

Up to now, many of the lawprof networks try to structure their blogs as if they were mini-law reviews, their discussions mired in jargonistic lawprof-speech and weighed down by needlessly lofty sounding ideals and philosophies.  The subjects are often interesting, but their discussions can be boring.  They are often strained and pretentious.  Then commenters come on board, trying to out-pretentious each other to prove their superior intellect is the match of any academic. 

The Faculty Lounge is self-described as



When I was a student, I always romanticized the faculty lounge as a place where big ideas, witty repartee and afternoon tea came to meet and mingle–a combination of Claridge’s, the Algonquin Table, college literary societies and the Keats-Shelley House in Rome, with a little Bloomsbury thrown in for good measure.  But the average faculty lounge nowadays is often empty or barely populated, as we all fall prey to the  incessant demands and overload of modern life.


Hence *this* Faculty Lounge:  online, 24-7, easily accessible, open to anyone who wants to talk ideas or ponder questions large and small.   Although you’ll have to provide your own sherry and biscuits, there’s no need to don your tweed blazer with leather patches or velvet smoking jacket (but do feel free!).  I’ll be in that far corner in the big leather chair, sipping my Makaibari Estate Darjeeling (milk, two sugars) and holding forth on topics from juries and sentencing to late-Victorian literature and verse.   See you there!


Can the lawprofs break away from their tightened collars and sphincters?  I hope so.  In my mind’s eye, I see them letting their hair down, talking like normal people and having conversations that the rest of us will want to hear, and maybe even engage!  Yes, the witty repartee part strains credulity, but my thought is to let them indulge in their own fantasy as long as it helps them to relax.  Instead of sherry, have you considered just tapping a keg?

Welcome to the blogosphere.  And maybe even the practical blawgosphere.  Let’s see whether you guys can blow off a little steam, or whether this is just another “lets pretend we only think important thoughts” blog.  Your choice.

Random Thoughts on the State of the Blawgosphere

It Must Be Something in the Water

It seems like there’s another new blawg by a Texas lawyer for every new one by a lawyer anywhere else in the country.  Why is that?  Today, I stumbled upon two blogs I’d never seen before,  Bad Court Thingy and Not Guilty.  The former is by a new lawyer who has inexplicably chosen to post anonymously, while the latter comes from a more experienced lawyer who is skirting the edges of the blawgosphere and self-promotion.  Then, there’s the eponymous Life at the Harris County Criminal Justice Center, a tad parochial on the parochial side.

The odd thing about the Texas blawgs is that they tend to focus largely on the sovereign Nation of Texas.  Some might think they are narrow for that reason.  I just think they don’t give a hoot about what happens in foreign lands, like the United States of America.

Young Lawyers Discover the Wheel

It’s hardly surprising that a substantial number of blawgers are young.  After all, this is new-fangled media, Web 2.0, and older lawyers tend not to acknowledge its existence, no less participate.  But a product of this youth-oriented blawgosphere is their view of criminal law through their youthful eyes.

In one sense, it’s quite funny to read of their discovery of the joys of dealing with unpleasant clients, difficult judges and offensive adversaries.  It’s similarly interesting to read of their epiphany when they realize that law may not be as perfect as they were taught in law school, or that their brethren in the criminal defense bar are not always as competent or ethical as they are.  Every generation has to discover the obvious on their own, and each time it’s as new as the last.

For some of us slightly older lawyers, we need to remember that these young guys may not have the same breadth of experience yet, and while they are talking about trials all day long, they mean DWI trials and not murders or conspiracies.  Whenever I read about somebody doing 3 trials in a day, I have to remind myself that we live in different professional worlds. 

It’s a Strain for a Reason

An increasing phenomenon is the cross-bred blog, trying to straddle the practical blawgosphere and marketing.  These involve posts about clients and cases that would hold some general interest, but for the fact that they are invariably built around the lawyer’s personal triumph or experience such that it becomes obvious that the substantive post exists solely to promote the lawyer.

These posts tend to be horribly strained, where it seems that the lawyer is desperately trying not to make the post sound purely self-promotional, while trying to make sure that one can’t read the post without concluding that this must be the greatest lawyer ever.  I understand why they do this, and I can’t blame any lawyer for trying to use whatever tools are at his disposal to help his business.  Hey, this is a business.  But the strained language, the flagrant attempt to promote the writer while making it appear that this is not unmitigated self-promotion, makes the post painful to read.

If you want to self-promote, do it.  If you want to be part of the larger conversation, do it.  I don’t think you can do both successfully.  Or at least I’ve yet to see anyone accomplish it.

I’ll See Your Link and Raise You

As more blawgs come online, there is an increase in emails seeking a place in the blogroll or a link in a post somewhere.  I don’t bother with the requests that are obviously not blogs, but I will take a look at blawgs that link to me (unrequested) or include me in their post.  That doesn’t mean that I’ll end up putting you into my blogroll, unless your blawg has something that I would want to read.  This is going to get increasingly more difficult as more blawgs come along.  There’s only so many that can riff off of Bennett and Gideon, repeating posts that they’ve already done so well.

But don’t feel offended.  There are plenty of blawgs that I post about, and have in my blogroll, that don’t return the favor.  Take Doc Berman’s Sentencing Law and Policy, for example.  I link to his stuff all the time, and he doesn’t even know I exist.  I do it because he’s got great information, not to try to catch his eye.  It’s all about the substance, and there’s no doubt that there will be some other folks who don’t think Simple Justice is worth a mention.  The only thing I can do about it is keep writing.  If I write something that matters to them, maybe I’ll make it onto their radar.  If I don’t, then I don’t deserve to be on their radar.

This problem also exists in the parochial nest of the Texas criminal law blawgs, where they seem to ignore the outside world and cross-breed internally.  But that’s how isolationism happens, right President Bush?  The only problem is that there are so many of them, and some are quite good, that it’s a shame that they don’t branch out more.  It’s like a clique that will only chat amongst themselves.  Except Bennett and Young Shawn, both of whom will talk with anyone.

Speeding Up and Slowing Down

Some of my favorite blawgs have started slowing their pace since the new year.  Anne Reed at Deliberations, for example.  Anne’s blawg is one of the best around, but she’s sticking to her New Year’s resolution to slow down on the blogging (and I guess bulk up on those billable hours).  I miss her brilliant posts.

Then there’s my all-time favorite young Republican, Shawn Matlock of the blog with the fascinating name, The Matlock Blog, attesting to his imagination and branding capabilities.  With Young Shawn, it’s either feast or famine.  Nothing for a week, then 10 posts in a day.  Pent up hostility?  You be the judge.

And another MIA blawger is Jamie Spencer, whose posts are always exceptional but increasingly sporadic.  Come on Jamie, hunker down and get to work.

And finally, there’s the quiet demise of Malum in Se, whose blawg burned bright until it burned out.  I’m sorry to see him go.  Maybe like the blawgosphere’s Phoenix, Norm Pattis, he’ll be back.  If not, then we’ll keep our eye on  Bad Court Thingy to see if he can fill the void, and perhaps take a lesson from Reasonable Doubts, where Todd Taylor decided to select a more fitting blawg name.  An excellent choice, I might add.

President Bush, Embodiment of America

Dan Hull of What About Clients? is quite the fan of Alexis de Tocqueville, and with good reason.  While Hobbs, Locke and Rousseau tend to appeal more to the flashy MTV crowd, de Tocqueville (On Democracy in America [1840]) was no slouch.

Still, applying the views of great philosophers to our current affairs is no mean feat.  Indeed, you have to show great respect when you can not only do so, but have some fun in the process.  Dan has managed both in this column in the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review.

What’s especially striking about this is that President Bush is very, well, American. Bush is American in the way citizens of the U.S. have been perceived by outsiders for nearly two centuries. He mirrors national traits — some admirable and some not — which Alexis de Tocqueville observed 170 years ago in his book “Democracy in America.”

Talk about a segue!  Okay, I’m dying.  Why, Dan, Why?

Tocqueville identified certain attributes of this new American:

• By nature or necessity disinterested in other nations and cultures

• Practical rather than theoretical

• Plain spoken but occasionally bombastic

• Openly religious (an “exalted spiritualism,” he called it)

• Stubborn, prideful, hurried in all things, impulsive and prone to do “ill considered things”

• He found that Americans were not overly enamored with ideas for their own sake

• Tocqueville even mentioned, delicately, that these new creatures had run roughshod over the English language and abused its inherent flexibility.

Now bring it home, baby:

A Texan’s Texan, Bush is a hardworking, action-oriented, driven and headstrong man who, despite his Ivy League education, has shown little interest in ideas generally.

He plainly believes, however, in the primacy and superiority of American ideas and institutions. Although his presidency has been consumed by foreign affairs, Bush is no internationalist.

Bush also is perceived to not think things through (i.e., the details of the Iraq occupation), yet apparently considers himself pragmatic. He is not shy about bringing “God” into the national discourse. He is happy in cowboy garb and with a folksy manner of speech.

Note how Dan worked in the little Texas dig without any effort at all!  Every paragraph in Dan’s column gives us another gem, and reluctant as I am to reprint it word by word so as to avoid missing a critical piece of the puzzle, I can’t pass up this one:

And Tocqueville would have been fascinated with George Bernard Shaw’s famous quip that democracy is “a device that ensures we shall be governed no better than we deserve.”

It sounds so much better when Shaw says it than when I do, which explains why most of my best quips are attributed to him.  Read the whole column and enjoy.  Anybody who can make de Tocqueville relevant to Bush 43 has earned my admiration.

Trading Cash For Junkets At The Federal Courthouse

This Washington Post editorial addresses the heavily supported issue of raising the pay of federal judges.  For those who haven’t followed this too closely, perhaps because it had little consequence on their pocketbook, this is the basic idea:

Under the Senate bill, which calls for 29 percent raises, trial judges’ salaries would increase to $218,000; appeals judges would earn $231,100; Supreme Court associate justices, $267,900; and the chief justice, $279,900. Judges would continue to enjoy extraordinarily generous pensions, and they would be entitled to automatic annual cost-of-living raises. Similar legislation has been approved by the House Judiciary Committee.

While a 29% raise seems pretty generous, it has to be viewed in context.   This fact sheet purports to show how real income for the federal judiciary has fared over the years.  Granted, it contains some dubious claims, but the general point is well taken:  Judges are no less worthy of being able to support themselves than anyone else, and it is unbecoming to compensate federal judges at a level roughly equivalent to a first year Biglaw associates (before bonus).

But Congress, being Congress, can’t stop itself from demanding a giveback.  There’s no free lunch in the Senate.


The biggest hit comes in the form of limits to the amount of outside income judges may earn and restrictions on reimbursements for educational seminars. Under the Senate bill, judges can be reimbursed for expenses related to a seminar “a significant purpose of which is the education” of judges if the event is sponsored by bar associations, judicial associations or the judicial division of the American Bar Association. The purpose of this amendment is to stop judges from accepting thousands of dollars worth of transportation, lodging and food from interest groups that hold “seminars” to push their legal and ideological agendas to a captive audience.

While proponents of junkets speak to judges’ reimbursement for those “pure” trips, to the ABA conferences and law school moot court competitions, most people give little thought to the “dirty” junkets where the judges’ “expenses” are paid by interest groups or corporations.

Clearly, there is a vast difference between a judge (or a justice) accepting reimbursement for a lecture at HLS and a “conference” in Anguilla on the merits of private-purpose eminent domain. 


The move to prohibit these junkets is long overdue, but it may have unintended consequences. Judges may accept no more than a $2,000 reimbursement per event or $20,000 annually for attending approved educational seminars, speaking engagements, or teaching opportunities. As the Judicial Conference of the United States noted in a letter to the Senate Judiciary Committee, such caps could “severely and unnecessarily restrict judges from traveling to law schools for lectures, conferences and moot courts.”

It strikes me that there is no reason to limit reimbursement at all, provided the purpose are “pure”.  On the other hand, I fail to understand why any member of the federal judiciary should be permitted to accept “reimbursement” in any amount from any interest group or corporation.  If the purpose of the junket conflicts with their duty to remain neutral, then there is no amount of money that appropriately limits this inherent violation of their oath. 

The Washington Post concludes that Congress should increase the caps for appropriate junkets, as opposed to inappropriate ones.  This strikes me as simply wrong.  Congress should impose no cap for appropriate junkets, and tolerate no inappropriate ones.  It is not acceptable that federal judges be just a little bit dirty.