It Must Be Something in the Water
It seems like there’s another new blawg by a Texas lawyer for every new one by a lawyer anywhere else in the country. Why is that? Today, I stumbled upon two blogs I’d never seen before, Bad Court Thingy and Not Guilty. The former is by a new lawyer who has inexplicably chosen to post anonymously, while the latter comes from a more experienced lawyer who is skirting the edges of the blawgosphere and self-promotion. Then, there’s the eponymous Life at the Harris County Criminal Justice Center, a tad parochial on the parochial side.
The odd thing about the Texas blawgs is that they tend to focus largely on the sovereign Nation of Texas. Some might think they are narrow for that reason. I just think they don’t give a hoot about what happens in foreign lands, like the United States of America.
Young Lawyers Discover the Wheel
It’s hardly surprising that a substantial number of blawgers are young. After all, this is new-fangled media, Web 2.0, and older lawyers tend not to acknowledge its existence, no less participate. But a product of this youth-oriented blawgosphere is their view of criminal law through their youthful eyes.
In one sense, it’s quite funny to read of their discovery of the joys of dealing with unpleasant clients, difficult judges and offensive adversaries. It’s similarly interesting to read of their epiphany when they realize that law may not be as perfect as they were taught in law school, or that their brethren in the criminal defense bar are not always as competent or ethical as they are. Every generation has to discover the obvious on their own, and each time it’s as new as the last.
For some of us slightly older lawyers, we need to remember that these young guys may not have the same breadth of experience yet, and while they are talking about trials all day long, they mean DWI trials and not murders or conspiracies. Whenever I read about somebody doing 3 trials in a day, I have to remind myself that we live in different professional worlds.
It’s a Strain for a Reason
An increasing phenomenon is the cross-bred blog, trying to straddle the practical blawgosphere and marketing. These involve posts about clients and cases that would hold some general interest, but for the fact that they are invariably built around the lawyer’s personal triumph or experience such that it becomes obvious that the substantive post exists solely to promote the lawyer.
These posts tend to be horribly strained, where it seems that the lawyer is desperately trying not to make the post sound purely self-promotional, while trying to make sure that one can’t read the post without concluding that this must be the greatest lawyer ever. I understand why they do this, and I can’t blame any lawyer for trying to use whatever tools are at his disposal to help his business. Hey, this is a business. But the strained language, the flagrant attempt to promote the writer while making it appear that this is not unmitigated self-promotion, makes the post painful to read.
If you want to self-promote, do it. If you want to be part of the larger conversation, do it. I don’t think you can do both successfully. Or at least I’ve yet to see anyone accomplish it.
I’ll See Your Link and Raise You
As more blawgs come online, there is an increase in emails seeking a place in the blogroll or a link in a post somewhere. I don’t bother with the requests that are obviously not blogs, but I will take a look at blawgs that link to me (unrequested) or include me in their post. That doesn’t mean that I’ll end up putting you into my blogroll, unless your blawg has something that I would want to read. This is going to get increasingly more difficult as more blawgs come along. There’s only so many that can riff off of Bennett and Gideon, repeating posts that they’ve already done so well.
But don’t feel offended. There are plenty of blawgs that I post about, and have in my blogroll, that don’t return the favor. Take Doc Berman’s Sentencing Law and Policy, for example. I link to his stuff all the time, and he doesn’t even know I exist. I do it because he’s got great information, not to try to catch his eye. It’s all about the substance, and there’s no doubt that there will be some other folks who don’t think Simple Justice is worth a mention. The only thing I can do about it is keep writing. If I write something that matters to them, maybe I’ll make it onto their radar. If I don’t, then I don’t deserve to be on their radar.
This problem also exists in the parochial nest of the Texas criminal law blawgs, where they seem to ignore the outside world and cross-breed internally. But that’s how isolationism happens, right President Bush? The only problem is that there are so many of them, and some are quite good, that it’s a shame that they don’t branch out more. It’s like a clique that will only chat amongst themselves. Except Bennett and Young Shawn, both of whom will talk with anyone.
Speeding Up and Slowing Down
Some of my favorite blawgs have started slowing their pace since the new year. Anne Reed at Deliberations, for example. Anne’s blawg is one of the best around, but she’s sticking to her New Year’s resolution to slow down on the blogging (and I guess bulk up on those billable hours). I miss her brilliant posts.
Then there’s my all-time favorite young Republican, Shawn Matlock of the blog with the fascinating name, The Matlock Blog, attesting to his imagination and branding capabilities. With Young Shawn, it’s either feast or famine. Nothing for a week, then 10 posts in a day. Pent up hostility? You be the judge.
And another MIA blawger is Jamie Spencer, whose posts are always exceptional but increasingly sporadic. Come on Jamie, hunker down and get to work.
And finally, there’s the quiet demise of Malum in Se, whose blawg burned bright until it burned out. I’m sorry to see him go. Maybe like the blawgosphere’s Phoenix, Norm Pattis, he’ll be back. If not, then we’ll keep our eye on Bad Court Thingy to see if he can fill the void, and perhaps take a lesson from Reasonable Doubts, where Todd Taylor decided to select a more fitting blawg name. An excellent choice, I might add.