Author Archives: SHG

Common Sense As the Easy Alternative To Thought

One of the offshoots of the push that resulted in the elevation of George W. Bush to the presidency was the empowerment of “regular” people.  This meant that views and opinions, under the category of “common sense,” were raised to a level equal to, or above, that of thoughtful analysis.

We see it in the blogosphere all the time.  Whether on blogs like Common Folk Using Common Sense, which is really a great name for a blog, or the rantings of commenters who parrot simplistic positions that reflect deeply held beliefs that avoid any connection to logic, reason or even a mildly in-depth understanding of the issue.

A while back, I posted about the use of the words “common sense” in the jury charge.

An appeal to common sense is a shorthand way of telling the jurors, make your decisions here like you do out there in your world.  The problem is that people invariably make decisions, even important decisions, about their lives based upon little or no information.  There is only one way to get to the Island of Conclusion, according to the Phantom Toll Booth:  Jump.

Much of the thoughtful, deliberative discussion requires a level of effort and a willingness to consider the possibility that long-held beliefs formed without any particular basis may be wrong.

Ironically, the end result of these “common sense” contenders may very well be correct, to some greater or lesser extent.  It’s not that this approach produces an inherently wrong result, but gets there by way of an inherently invalid process.

While supporters of the President and his many jingoistic initiatives have fled like rats from a sinking ship, they have not abandoned their beliefs.  They still carry the same baggage, and do so for the exact same reasons they did in the first place.  We don’t need no stinkin’ thought.  This is what we think, and that’s good enough.

One of the maxims that characterize America is that everyone is entitled to their own opinion.  I’ve never been able to agree with this, unless it includes the proviso that an opinion is based upon something, be it facts or reason.  Thoughtless or baseless “opinion” isn’t opinion at all.  It’s just facile conclusion.  As my daughter once said in response to my challenging her assessment of American politics, “I hate thinking. It hurts.”  Tough noogies.

Frankly, I admire the fact that the blogosphere has been populated by a bunch of thinkers, particularly academics of various minds, liberal, conservative and libertarian.  I know that some of my neighbors in the blawgosphere don’t care for some of these thinkers with whom they disagree.  But shutting out or ignoring those well-conceived but (as some believe) wrong opinions is no better than settling for knee-jerk “common sense” conclusions that fail in the face of scrutiny.

Rational, well-conceived disagreement makes it hard to maintain control of the discussion.  So too, of course, does irrational, insipid disagreement, but the blogosphere is open to all comers.  But that doesn’t mean they get to spout nonsense wherever they want.  Noting that an opinion lacks rational basis rarely convinced the holder of anything.  But then, the opinion-holder isn’t looking to consider the issue, just state his or her “opinion”.

I’ve changed many of my ideas as a result of what I’ve learned in the blogosphere.  I’ve also seen irrefutable proof of the Dunning-Kruger effect.  One of the things I hope to bring to the conversation is the rejection of those who, through their prolific attacks, their vapid points and their offensive vehemence, push “common sense” at the expense of actual thought.  I understand that thinking hurts, but no pain, no gain.

I remember a poster in a dorm room many years ago.  There was a picture of a pile of feces, and the words above it stated, “10 Million flies can’t be wrong.”  It really doesn’t matter how many people believe the earth is flat.  It isn’t.  So spare me your “common sense,” your knee-jerk simplistic conclusions.  But if you’ve got some thought behind your ideas, or at the very least some humor, welcome.

NRA Says No 2d Amendment RKBA For You!

The upcoming Supreme Court case of District of Columbia v. Heller has brought out a ton of amici, as one would suspect, ranging from  Jews for the Preservation of Firearms Ownership to  Pink Pistols (Gays and Lesbians for Individual Liberty), to the most natural ally of all, the National Rife Association.  Thanks to  SCOTUSblog and  Doc Berman for putting this all together.

For as long as I can remember, the NRA was the loudest voice against any law that limited the right to keep and bear arms (RKBA amongst those engaged in the struggle).  With fiery rhetoric and cold cash, they fought against every perceived violation of the right of each and every individual to arm themselves, as the Second Amendment said they could.  This was fundamental.  But that was then, and this is now.

All those years of effort are now unbearably close to bearing fruit.  The issue is before the Court.  The scholars are now behind them.  The stars have aligned.  No longer are they the lunatic fringe that liberals claimed them to be, but righteous Americans demanding nothing more or less than what the Constitution guarantees. 

But just as the vision of the Second Amendment has turned around, so too has the NRA.  How odd to see the shoe on the other foot. 

The National Rifle Association argues in its amicus brief to the Supreme Court that the Second Amendment does not apply to felons.  The “Martha Stewart” exception has been born.


This individual right to keep and bear arms is a fundamental right; the Second Amendment on its face describes it as essential to a “free State”—a democratic state free from government tyranny. As with the fundamental democratic rights guaranteed by the First Amendment, laws burdening Second Amendment rights should be subjected to strict scrutiny and struck down in their entirety when overly broad. Petitioners and their supporting attempt to conjure fears of legal bedlam should courts examine firearms laws under strict scrutiny, yet they present no real argument that long-standing laws regulating the ownership and use of firearms, such as laws barring ownership by convicted felons or the insane, would fail to pass muster under that test.

Well, ain’t that something?  It appears that “the people” just turned into “the people we like” when it comes to fundamental, unequivocal rights. 

So “strict scrutiny” provides a test that will allow the government to legislate away the Second Amendment right of Martha Stewart to carry a weapon to protect herself, eh?  The NRA responds to what they characterize as Professor Chemerinsky’s “in terrorem argument” that under their proposed strict scrutiny test for this fundamental right, felons and the insane would still be subject to regulation.  Why?  They don’t say.  They just say they would.  A little dodge and weave around the threat that the Supreme Court might sink their big win if the bad guys get guns too.

This is not going to be as easy as the NRA would like it to be.  As posted here, I see some difficulty in drawing the fine distinctions that the NRA suddenly supports, in contrast to its fundamental rights position.  Will strict scrutiny keep guns (not to mention swords, knives, etc.) out of the hands of felons?  What about felons whose crimes bear no connection to violence?  Or felons convicted 40 years ago?  Or felons whose crime was possession of a weapon, the fundamental right itself?

Heller is going to be one interesting decision.  But the NRA, ever true to its mission, is busy trying to scurry around that little hole it dug for itself over the years, and just keeps digging.

The Hidden Risks

Going after my post yesterday about the Megatrial problem, the Texas Tornado, Mark Bennett, put the problems of retaining counsel in context with my earlier commentary about the world of assigned counsel.  The problems in the rarified world of big cases and big defendants are below the radar of criminal defense lawyers.  Not that they don’t want to be there, and hope to be there someday, but they aren’t there yet.

Now comes the apocryphal tale of Ben Kuehne.  Ben Kuehne was one of the paragons of the Miami bar, the kind who was named to blue ribbon committees, the kind who represented Al Gore when chads were hanging.  He wore kuehnea bow tie, and nobody made fun of him for it.  It was because of his impeccable reputation that he was asked to vet the payment of legal fees for Roy Black, another big name, from a client, accused Medellin drug lord, Fabio Ochoa Vasquez.


Representing a fellow like Fabio Ochoa is like playing Russian Roulette.  But Roy Black recognized that he was in a dangerous position, so he turned the a lawyer who was known by all to be so squeaky clean that no one could question his bona fides.  Or so Roy thought.

Before turning back to Ben, let’s remember that even Fabio Ochoa is entitled to be represented by counsel in a criminal prosecution in the United States.  He is not entitled, however, to use the proceeds of a crime to do so, but he’s not yet been convicted of a crime.  This is one of those vicious circle problems, where the government uses its vast power to prevent a defendant from using his funds to pay for counsel under the guise that its criminal proceeds, then denies him counsel of choice in a huge case, then gets to convict him, thus proving it was right all along.

Now back to Ben.


The indictment revives the issue of the legal suitability of money accepted by criminal defense attorneys from clients accused of drug trafficking and money laundering. Medellin kingpin Fabio Ochoa faced charges of plotting to smuggle 30 tons of powder cocaine per month into the United States from 1997 to 1999. Since it’s illegal to accept funds from a criminal enterprise, Black paid Kuehne $197,300 to vet money coming from horse and cattle holdings of the Ochoa family and property offered to cover Black’s fees.

Roy Black needed a lawyer of unquestioned integrity to insulate himself from risk, both of losing his legal fee to forfeiture as well as potential indictment for laundering Ochoa’s drug money.  It was a very responsible way of handling the problems incumbent in representing someone like Ochoa.  And there was no better choice for the job than Ben Kuehne.


Kuehne’s investigation played out in an elaborate procedure prior to Ochoa’s trial in front of U.S. District Judge K. Michael Moore in 2003. The attorney produced six opinion letters concluding funds transferred to Black for Ochoa’s defense were legitimate, the six-count indictment said. But prosecutors charge almost $1 million tracked to Black ran through five federal undercover operations that intercepted drug money in Miami, New York and Houston in 2002.

Notably, nothing here suggests that Ben Kuehne knew, or had reason to know, that any of the funds that passed from Ochoa to Black ever passed through any covert federal operations.  Still, the government claims that he “knew” the funds were tainted.  So Ben Kuehne stands indicted for money laundering $5.2 Million for the Medellin cartel.  Not a bad legal fee, I might add.

At his arraignment, Ben Kuehne stood before the court in a blue suit, with his trademark bow tie and an American flag pin in his lapel. 

Now back to the new case in Brooklyn and Queens, designed to break the Gambino crime family, as claimed by the government.  Part of the design of this megatrial is to preclude any of the defendants from being able to use their alleged criminal proceeds to retain counsel.  Bennett asks:


But what if you’re an alleged crime boss, and you don’t have a million dollars hidden under the birdseed?

Tony Soprano kept some cash hidden in a garbage pail of birdseed in the back yard, but that wouldn’t help him here.  First, these are real people, not TV mobsters.  Second, even if the Soprano scenario were real, it wouldn’t help. 

The constraints on accepting criminal proceeds precludes anyone but a fool from taking bundles of cash to represent anyone in this case.  The legal fees for these defendants will be subject to intense scrutiny.  Lack of compliance, or worse yet, obvious laundering, will land the lawyer in the cell next to the defendant. 

So it isn’t just a matter of having enough cash, but having legitimate funds (at least in the eyes of the government) paid in compliance with IRS regulations sufficient to cover the costs.  Hey, this isn’t a DWI case in Texas.  This is the big time.  It’s a trap for the unwary criminal defense lawyer, who may have never experienced a degree of scrutiny like this before.  It’s a trap for those who have.

When criminal defense lawyers become engaged in major cases, they play by a very strict set of rules, lest they put themselves at risk for doing their job too well.  Sometimes, no matter how hard we try to play by the rules, the government will come after us anyway. 

Just ask Ben Kuehne. 

Where Did Those Years of Work Go?

Sometimes, I wonder why.  It happened in big time in 1987, and again in the dot com crash.  It’s happening again now.  Some people try to live their lives in a way that suits their bourgeois sensibilities.  I am one such person.  I save my earnings, invest, avoid debt and do not buy things that I can’t afford. 

I was careful to get a fixed mortgage, so when the subprime crisis hit, it didn’t affect me.  Now it seems that people who took 110% mortgages with teaser rates are going to be bailed out by the government, as are the investors who purchased the mortgages from companies that took in bad loans.  

When the dot com market imploded, many of my funds, heavily invested in these stocks, lost a substantial amount of their value, some up to 70%.  That represented years of my work, countless legal fees, cases, defendants, trials. Poof. 

It’s happened again.  Not as badly (yet), but still I watched as my past year’s worth of work disappeared.  The talking heads on TV told me not to panic.  I never panic.  Maybe I should?  It wasn’t easy for many of my clients to pay my fees.  It wasn’t easy for me to earn them.  Now, it’s as if it never happened.

Yes, I fully realize that these are paper losses, not real losses, until the stocks are sold.  But anybody watch the old AOL, now Time-Warner (TWX) over the past 6 years?  Or, that one-time star, CMGI?  Even Disney, compared to where it was before the crash.  The market has never really recovered, and now we’re back in the dumps. 

Congress and the President have passed a package to juice up the economy.  We’ll get a check for a couple thousand in May or June.  Woo hoo.  That will change everything.

The libertarians speak to disincentives to conduct oneself appropriately.  With my daughter running off to college next year, I am busily filling out forms.  Financial aid should prove interesting.  If I had spent everything I made, I would be in a great position to have her attend college for free.  But being the good, responsible citizen, I saved enough to pay for college for my daughter.  I will pay for it.  Spend and enjoy.  Save and suffer.  It’s an interesting concept.

There are people who need and deserve our help.  There are people who make foolish, easy, selfish choices, but bear few consequences of their choices.  People like me pay for them instead.  We tell them, make the hard choice; Don’t go for immediate gratification, showing off, living like you’re the king when you can’t afford it.  They don’t listen.  But when things get tough, they are covered.  I’m left holding the bag.

They have sad stories.  Not the legitimate stories of illness, but the ones where they complain of how they are going to lose their homes because they can’t pay the mortgage, then drive off in their leased Mercedes Benz.  They are the ones with every gizmo every invented but without a dollar to buy a cup of coffee in the morning.  I feel like a Puritan next to them.  I could be as flashy as them, but I chose not to be.  Will there be pie in the sky when I die?

Not to complain, as I live a wonderful life notwithstanding all this, but I get tired of watching my investments dwindle because of some fellow I didn’t vote for paying for a war I don’t want using up my taxes like water.  I have those investments because I made certain choices in my life.  Other people made different choices, ones which I could have made but decided against.  I don’t feel responsible for those people.  Don’t make me pay for them. 

My good life isn’t a product of mere kismet, but choices.  No matter how much you earn, you can still screw it all up with stupidity.  We have an infinite capacity for doing stupid things, and it takes effort and sacrifice to make the decision not to be foolish.

Yet when I look at my portfolio and see the number so much lower than it was the day, week, month before, I wonder why I made the choices I did.  I could live like a king too, if I made different choices.  But I could never have lived with myself. 

I’m a lawyer.  I work for a living.  I pay my bills.  I get no million dollar year end bonuses. I get no pension.  But I’m getting awfully tired of watching my years of work disappear because of other people’s choices.  I am so bourgois.

Mukasey’s Logical Disconnect on Crack

As can be seen in Doc Berman’s two posts,  here and here, on Judge Mukasey’s fight against that ultra-liberal gang, the Sentencing Guidelines Commission, there is a problem with the government’s rhetoric.  Now that the crack to powdered cocaine ratio has been reformed (somewhat) from 100 to 1 to about 50 to 1, on an inexplicable sliding scale, Judge Mukasey is crying that the sky is falling.  It just doesn’t follow.

The first scream of fear is that it will release “violent” criminals into society. 

In testimony he’s expected to give before Congress Thursday, Attorney General Michael Mukasey will claim that the sentencing guideline changes will lead to more than 1,500 violent crack cocaine dealers to be released immediately. “Unless Congress acts by the March 3 deadline, nearly 1,600 convicted crack dealers, many of them violent gang members, will be eligible for immediate release into communities nationwide,” Mukasey said in a prepared statement that was sent to the House Judiciary Committee on Wednesday…. 

These are individuals who were convicted of crack offenses.  If they are “violent”, then they should have been tried and convicted for crimes of violence, making their crack sentences secondary to their sentences for violent crimes.  If they don’t stand convicted of violent crimes, or they have completed the sentences for their crimes of violence such that they are only remaining incarcerated because of the crack portion of the sentence, then there’s no issue.

In America, we don’t keep people in prison because of unproven, untried and unconvicted allegations of incipient violence.  This is true even when we label prisoners as “gang members,” an epithet one step below mass murderer in the publics’ mind.  While I can appreciate as well as the next guy how much fun it is to smear individuals with collective blame, there’s still this bone in my head that says, “but you need to convict somebody first.” 

The entire scheme of tarring these defendants, who have not done easy or brief time under anyone’s rational view, with vague and unsubstantiated claims of violent tendencies is far beneath Judge Mukasey’s dignity.  He knows better, meaning that he’s busily parroting the administration’s talking points.  What a good soldier he is.  Too bad he makes no sense.

Next, we have this quote, which raises some really interesting questions:


The Justice Department is expected to ask Congress to pass legislation to keep certain crack offenders behind bars until they take part in educational, rehabilitation and prisoner re-entry programs, even though a recent change in sentencing regulations makes them eligible for early release….

So these prisoners have been in the system for a decade and now the government’s argument is to hold them longer so that they can “take part in educational, rehabilitation and prisoner re-entry programs?”  What has our brilliant Bureau of Prisons been doing with them all this time? 

This is serious.  Is this an admission by our Attorney General that we warehouse prisoners and nothing more?  Is this a concession that we place defendants into the United States Bureau of Prisons, individuals who are in need of education and rehabilitation, and they simply fail to do so?  Then is our prison system a corrupt failure, incapable of releasing prisoners back into society with the tools necessary to live productive, law-abiding lives?

One would suspect that Judge Mukasey was fighting against the decriminalization of crack based upon the rhetoric beings tossed about, rather than the mere partial rationalization of crack to powdered cocaine.  I can’t help but wonder if this is just an effort to use subterfuge to remind Congress that crack crimes are committed primarily by blacks and Hispanics, while powdered cocaine was preferred to whites.  This is the good drug/bad drug distinction that gets the nod and wink from government based upon implicit tacit prejudice.

Bear in mind that the reforms, which still maintain a substantial enhancement for crack over powdered cocaine despite the fallacious claims that crack was so much more potent, so much more evil, so much more black, came via the United States Sentencing Guidelines Commission, the same group that Congress trusted so much that it took sentencing out of the hands of judges for 20 years.

Sorry, but this one doesn’t even come close to flying.  Judge Mukasey may be a good soldier to a disgraced administration, but this is just irrational.




 

The Most Disturbing Post in the Blogosphere? (Updated)

Dan Markel at  PrawfsBlawg has posted in the finest tradition of a scholar and academic.  But it’s perhaps the most disturbing post I can remember.  While I truly believe that limiting discussion to “politically correct” topics or assumptions has precluded the resolution, correction, adjustment or understanding of many critical issues, and for this reason applaud Dan’s boldness in raising unpleasant questions, this one just disgusts me.


In the news today is the arrest of a 38 year old man, a Rhodes Scholar and HLS grad who is a high-ranking Mass. gov’t official, for allegedly masturbating and performing oral sex on a 15 year old male in a steam room at a resort in Florida. (HT: ATL) I’m less interested in the facts here and more interested in the normative legal questions posed by this conduct and conduct similar to but different to it as posed in the following scenarios.  What reactions do you have regarding what you think the law should be in a liberal democracy under the following conditions, and why?

Dan runs through a series of questions, based upon adjustments to the facts to alter the details sufficiently to raise or eliminate factors that would/should change the analysis.  He then gives his responses as to how the law “in a liberal democracy” should treat the scenario.

In one sense, Dan’s point is to distinguish the law’s treatment of homosexual contact between an adult and a child from heterosexual contact.  If we believe, as most say they do, that homosexuality is not a “disease” or “evil”, then why does the public, and the law, respond so differently to the two?   This exercise reveals the fallacy of our professed acceptance of homosexuality as a legitimate alternative preference, since it’s impossible to give an intellectually honest distinction.  That, I presume, was Dan’s point.

But Dan takes the lesson even further, dealing with other taboo subjects such as consanguinity, bringing the connection increasingly closer to face the taboo of incest.  I guess when you’re going out on a limb, you might as well go all the way out.

While Dan’s post raised a wealth of substantive issues that some of us (like me) prefer not to face, and from a scholarly perspective should be addressed if we are to have meaningful discussions of what our norms and mores and purported liberal leanings really mean, I find this post to be exceptionally disturbing.  Perhaps it’s because it crosses lines that I can’t bear to cross, or just because the taboos are far too ingrained in an old man like me to separate my intellectual consideration from my visceral reactions.

But I cannot agree with many of Dan’s responses.  I do not subscribe to the notion that it is acceptable for adults to engage children in sexual conduct, regardless of whether it is homosexual or heterosexual.  Indeed, just as I believe that children should not be treated like adults with regard to criminal conduct, I do not accept that children are sufficiently mature and responsible to make decisions of lasting consequence. 

Similarly, I am unconvinced that most children are capable of exercising independent choice when confronted by adults.  They are taught to do as they are told by their elders, and this lesson, even when not obvious, impacts their ability to refuse.  Rather than risk a child by considering choices on a post hoc basis, I favor a bright line test.  It is simply unacceptable to me to put children at risk, and getting anywhere near that slippery slope is wrong.

As for incestuous potential, just gag me.  There are enough people in the world that we can stay away from anyone related to us with a 10 degrees.  On this point, there’s just no reason to go there, unless you’re Rudy Giuliani, and thankfully, I’m not.

Update:  Dan’s at it again.  He’s pushing the envelope further :


Today I’m interested in reactions to marriages with minors and between minors in both polygamous and monogamous situations.

It’s not enough to ask about marriages with minors, but throw in polygamous to boot?  Where are we, Utah?  No clue where Dan will be heading next on this topic, but it appears a safe bet that it will challenge one’s sensibilities.

Rebirth of the Megatrial

Not since the Pizza Connection case, which ran from October, 1985 to March, 1987, has New York seen a real megatrial.  Yesterday, state and federal agents took down 87 alleged members and “friends” of the Gambinos, the group once headed by the “Dapper Don,” John Gotti after Paul Castellano found that steak disagreed with him.

Ask any OC lawyer in New York about business, and they’ll shrug and say that other than the serial trials against John Gotti, Jr., and the occasional side-show, it’s history.  Not any more.  According to the New York Times, the feds believe they have broken one of the 5 families of La Cosa Nostra. 

The initial shock was that they could come up with 87 people with a purported connection to the Gambinos.  Who knew there were that many still around?  Not surprisingly, the case is based on a snitch:

The case was made with assistance of an informant, a trucking company executive who had been the victim of extortions and who had paid more than $200,000 to Gambino family figures, according to several officials with knowledge of the case. The executive, Joseph Vollaro, served prison time on a drug conviction several years ago and had shared a cell with Nicholas Corozzo, the officials said, and Mr. Vollaro’s successful trucking companies, Andrews Trucking and Dumpmasters of NY, were extorted by Mr. Corozzo and his brother.

While the take-down yesterday was massive, there are two separate indictments involved, a 62 defendant indictment in the Eastern District of New York (that’s Brooklyn, for you out-of-towners) and a 26 defendant indictment in Queens County Supreme Court.


The charges, unsealed in United States District Court in Brooklyn and in State Supreme Court in Queens, include seven murders, three dating back more than a quarter century, and racketeering, construction extortion and state gambling charges

From the word on the street, they’ve thrown every crime that ever happened in New York into these cases.  The cops are closing out every old murder on the books.  Why waste the opportunity when they can cover everything but the kitchen sink in these cases and make it look like there has never been an unsolved crime in New York?

But massive indictments inexorably lead to massive trials.  The Pizza Connection case ultimately saw 22 defendants on trial.  The case took over a year to present, cost the government more than $50 Million and raised legal issues that were roundly ignored because they were so far beyond the pale of the courts to address.  Did anyone think it possible that there would be a reversal and new trial in a case like this? 

The biggest benefit went to lead prosecutor, Louis Freeh, who went on to become a federal District Court judge, and later Director of the FBI, as a reward for a job well done under United States Attorney Rudy Giuliani, who didn’t make out too badly himself.  But the Pizza Connection case was supposed to be the end of drug traffic in the United States, making it worth the cost, effort and expense to due process.  In that regard, it was a miserable failure.

When I first learned of the take-down yesterday, I was talking with a TV reporter friend, who jokingly told me that the 87 were arrested under the “Full Employment for Lawyers Act.”  But for those of us around during the Pizza Connection case remember, the megatrial was a financial disaster for those involved.  Few had the assets necessary to pay for a case that long and involved, and law practices died during the year long trial when lawyers were unavailable to the rest of their clients.  It was a nightmare, and back then the financial reporting requirements (IRS Form 8300) were substantially different than they are today.

Lessons Learned

The Pizza Connection trial taught everyone involved of the insurmountable problems/benefit with the Megatrial.  The first and foremost casualty was due process, primarily described as “spillover prejudice.”  Testimony was presented, day after day, week after week, of criminal conduct that applied in generic fashion to the group, rather than to specific individuals, or to one member of the group but in a way that was designed to taint the group as a whole.  Given the mass of testimony, the length of the trial, the volume of alleged crimes, it became soon impossible for the jury to distinguish what evidence applied to what defendant.  Essentially, it all became a morass of allegations that engulfed the defendants as a whole, with plenty of vagaries and promises to tie it all together later.

The trial itself was a logistical nightmare.  There was no courtroom on the planet large enough to hold this trial, so a gymnasium was converted for its use.  The availability of jurors with a year or more free to sit around certainly strained the concept of a jury of one’s peers.

While this case may bring out an interesting assortment of legal talent, there is a strong likelihood that many (if not all) of the defendants will be unable to retain counsel to represent them in this matter.  Between the limitations on funds available for use to retain counsel, the sheer anticipated length of this case, the potential conflicts of interest that will preclude the usual assortment of lawyers who represent alleged organized crime figures, it is hard to imagine that many defendants will be capable of retaining counsel for the trial, though it’s hard for OC lawyers to imagine themselves standing on the sidelines for a case like this.

From the government’s perspective, a case like this presents a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to grand stand in their war against the Mafia.  Just the word, Mafia, conjures up such exciting images that it captures the publics’ imagination.  Given the popularity and allure of HBOs Sopranos, these cases present the rare opportunity for a spectacle, with allegations of vast conspiracies, murders, all the good stuff that makes for exciting courtroom drama.  Careers are made in cases like these, with the lead prosecutor likely to climb the ladder of legal success to dizzying heights. 

Unfortunately, these cases cannot be prosecuted without the sacrifice of substantive and procedural due process.  That’s the price we pay for a grand spectacle.

Lawyer Advertising: Separating Content From Delivery

There have been a number of posts around the blawgosphere on the decision in Stern v. Bluestone,  here and elsewhere. (New York Personal Injury Blog, Legal Blog Watch, New York Legal Update,  Volokh Conspiracy I and Volokh Conspiracy II).

There are two fascinating and contradictory themes in these posts.  Each commentary recognizes that while the delivery mechanism, the good ‘le fax machine, can be a huge annoyance when something comes across on your dime that you didn’t ask for, don’t want but now have to pay for, there is a far more important issue at stake here.

On the flipe side, much of the commentary simply can’t get past the fax problem.  To a large extent, they get stuck on wanting to recreate the law (including the first amendment, another one of those darn technicalities that seems to get in the way of stopping stuff that annoys us), mischaracterize the facts to fit their conclusions, or just ignore the issue in its entirety because, well, they just hate getting unsolicited faxes so much that they just don’t care about anything else.

But the  Wall Street Journal Blog has a post today that provides an interesting juxtaposition for the purpose of appreciating why the decision in Stern is so dangerous to lawyers. 


When it comes to advertising, lawyers have it harder than some other industries. That’s largely because a sizable sector of the bar generally regards ads as cheap and tawdry. As a result, state regulators have cobbled together a fairly restrictive — some might say amusing — set of rules on what lawyer ads can and can’t say.

For many, this is indeed an amusing situation because we don’t see how these restrictions and prohibitions apply to us.  After all, we don’t have billboards urging husbands to divorce their wives before it’s too late, or lions and tigers and bears to show how tough we are.  We’re much more dignified.

Unfortunately, this is unlawyerlike thinking, because we resort to an intuitive definition of advertising when we know, or ought to know, that when the book is hurtling closer to our own head, the courts will look for a legal definition.  Say, anybody wonder where they will find that legal definition of what constitutes advertising?

The problem here is that Stern v. Bluestone provides a definition, in one context, that will be applied thereafter to a multitude of contexts, particularly lawyer advertising regulations.  It won’t so funny then, now will it? 

Those who try to distinguish the decision, based upon the use of the fax, are hiding their heads in some very facile sand.  This is not a matter of statutory definitions, but purely caselaw driven in order to define and delimit lawyer advertising.  Once done, it will be the definition of lawyer advertising when the issue arises going forward with the variety of restrictions, prohibitions, whatever, that are invariably applied to attorneys.

Those who contend that the judges will never let this stand when it impacts their beloved law review articles, learned treatises, etc., may well be correct, but then we are left with an argument that bring further intellectual problems.  Is advertising defined differently for media we like as opposed to media we dislike?  Some would be very happy with this answer, despite its cynical approach to the law.

But the best answer is to define lawyer advertising in accordance with the first amendment from the outset, apply it consistently thereafter, and provide lawyers with at least something similar to that offered to the rest of society.  We will have enough problems dealing with lawyer advertising regulations and restrictions in the future without being saddled with this misguided definitional problem.  Forget the fax.  It’s the least of your problems.

Surviving Prison, Part II

When  posting about US District Judge Robert Dawson statement when sentencing Wal-Mart executive Tom Coughlin, “prison would threaten the life of a nonviolent offender,” the commentary was directed toward a nice, white-collar federal defendants being incarcerated in a nice, white-collar federal prison camp.  These camps have been called “Club Fed,” which may be an overstatement, but only slightly.  I was less than convinced that this was a life-threatening situation.

Commenters related stories of nonviolent prisoners who would not be so lucky as to get a free, all-expense paid vacation at Club Fed.  If Judge Dawson feared for Coughlin’s life in federal custody, what of those people who would spend their time in state prisons?

This is a whole ‘nother animal.  The nature of crimes for which people go to state prison tends to be very different.  State crimes are what are thoughtfully called garden variety, meaning regular violent crime, common drug dealing, run of the mill fraud, theft and burglary.  Not the stuff that headlines are made of.  Not the stuff that Congress takes under its wing.

But when it comes to the mix of violent and non-violent, state prisons are the champs.  They tend to be uglier, dirtier and far less capable of matching the nature of the crime and criminal to a security level that bears any appropriate relation.  Too many criminals all thrown together in the big house, left to their own devices to survive.

Now we’re in the realm that justifies Judge Dawson’s fear.  It’s not just a matter of being life-threatening, but surviving the daily threat of violent assault and sexual assault.  Some will say that anyone who winds up in there gets what they deserve, but of course no one is sentenced to be sexually assaulted daily by other, stronger, meaner, more violent prisoners. 

No one has figured out a way to deal with the problem when “criminals”, whether violent or peaceful, of all types are put in a big room and left to deal with each other according to the rules of the jungle.  Groups develop for self-protection, but even they have a price of admission.  There’s no school to teach prison culture and survival before being told to survive, or not. 

It’s not that prison should be fun and pleasant.  It’s that prison should not be tantamount to a death sentence, or even the mere daily physical or sexual assault.  The feds have seen fit to create such places as Club Fed to separate the nonviolent, the nonthreatening, the white-collar, convict from others.  States have largely failed to make this distinction, and we’ve all known this forever.

An advertisement for an HBO show “Oz” asked, in substance: “It’s your first day in prison.  Who will get you first, the gangs, the crack addicts or the guards?”  It may only be a TV show, but the point remains.  Judge Dawson’s point was correct, but only slightly misdirected.