The New York Times editorial calls it “A Shameful Record.” The United States now has 2,380 human beings in prison, who will spend their lives in prison and never be released, upon convictions of crimes committed when they were children.
Some juvenile criminals commit horrible crimes, and the justice system should punish them accordingly. Juveniles, though, are not adults. Even their brain development is different, making them less able than older people to resist impulses. Consideration should also be given to the nature of the crime. In some cases, juveniles have been imprisoned for life for acting as accessories or lookouts for adults. Putting a 16-year-old who played such a role in jail for perhaps 65 years is an extraordinarily harsh, and expensive, societal response.
Legislation to treat children as adults came about largely as a response to the “super predator” myth following, ironically, New York’s notorious Central Park Jogger case, where the verb “wilding” came into the general lexicon. Ironic, of course, because the children convicted of the crime were subsequently proven innocent by DNA evidence. Their confessions, found to be false confessions, so angered Americans that they were deemed salvageable.
And yet, in that most American of psychological twists, people have disconnected the problem from the solution. While the impetus for our harsh and inflexible treatment of children has proven why the approach is both fundamentally wrong and misconceived, the “ultimate solution” remains in place and its supporters undeterred.
The crimes may indeed be horrible, regardless of whether the children played a central or peripheral role, and serve to outrage people. We hate horrible crimes. We demand action, and decisive action. It’s what Americans crave. No matter how simplistic the solution, and the simpler the better so we don’t need to spend too much time thinking (remember, “I hate thinking. It hurts?”), we demand that the problem be solved.
So has it been solved? These children are not ours, so what do we care if they are thrown away forever. We can better rationalize how these children could never be ours by filing them away under “unsaveable”. We try not to think of them ever again, because if we did we might have some problems with the notion that we would rather throw children away than help them. Silently, when no one else is around, we thank God that it isn’t our children.
American criminal law is a study in extremes. In our fruitless effort to cure humankind, we keep upping the ante with higher penalties, longer punishments, more and more crimes. It’s one fight to address what this means to us as a society, since our fears have long been politically driven rather than real. Crime is falling everywhere except in the media and the rhetoric of politicians, though this seems to finally be changing.
But today’s battle is for the children. The concept of treating children like adults, of locking them away forever, is an abdication of our responsibility as adults to all children, to give them a chance to grow up as productive, law-abiding, happy contributing members of society. True, it may take some effort and there may be some stumbling blocks along the way, as there are with any child, but there are 2,380 children whom we have failed. The Times is right. This is a shameful record.
