Author Archives: SHG

Life Without Parole: Children Thrown Away

The  New York Times editorial calls it “A Shameful Record.”  The United States now has 2,380 human beings in prison, who will spend their lives in prison and never be released, upon convictions of crimes committed when they were children. 

Some juvenile criminals commit horrible crimes, and the justice system should punish them accordingly. Juveniles, though, are not adults. Even their brain development is different, making them less able than older people to resist impulses. Consideration should also be given to the nature of the crime. In some cases, juveniles have been imprisoned for life for acting as accessories or lookouts for adults. Putting a 16-year-old who played such a role in jail for perhaps 65 years is an extraordinarily harsh, and expensive, societal response.

Legislation to treat children as adults came about largely as a response to the “super predator” myth following, ironically, New York’s notorious  Central Park Jogger case, where the verb “wilding” came into the general lexicon.  Ironic, of course, because the children convicted of the crime were subsequently proven innocent by DNA evidence. Their confessions, found to be false confessions, so angered Americans that they were deemed salvageable. 

And yet, in that most American of psychological twists, people have disconnected the problem from the solution.  While the impetus for our harsh and inflexible treatment of children has proven why the approach is both fundamentally wrong and misconceived, the “ultimate solution” remains in place and its supporters undeterred.

The crimes may indeed be horrible, regardless of whether the children played a central or peripheral role, and serve to outrage people.  We hate horrible crimes.  We demand action, and decisive action.  It’s what Americans crave.  No matter how simplistic the solution, and the simpler the better so we don’t need to spend too much time thinking (remember, “I hate thinking. It hurts?”), we demand that the problem be solved.

So has it been solved?  These children are not ours, so what do we care if they are thrown away forever.  We can better rationalize how these children could never be ours by filing them away under “unsaveable”.  We try not to think of them ever again, because if we did we might have some problems with the notion that we would rather throw children away than help them.  Silently, when no one else is around, we thank God that it isn’t our children.

American criminal law is a study in extremes.  In our fruitless effort to cure humankind, we keep upping the ante with higher penalties, longer punishments, more and more crimes.  It’s one fight to address what this means to us as a society, since our fears have long been politically driven rather than real.  Crime is falling everywhere except in the media and the rhetoric of politicians, though this seems to finally be changing.

But today’s battle is for the children.  The concept of treating children like adults, of locking them away forever, is an abdication of our responsibility as adults to all children, to give them a chance to grow up as productive, law-abiding, happy contributing members of society.  True, it may take some effort and there may be some stumbling blocks along the way, as there are with any child, but there are 2,380 children whom we have failed.  The Times is right.  This is a shameful record.

The Need for Campaign Finance Reform, If You Happen to Hate it

As much as I hate to disagree with Ted Frank and the American Enterprise Institute gang over at Overlawyered, and not to suggest that they have any agenda at all, I’m constrained to pick a nit.  It seems that John McCain’s big Super Tuesday win over Millionaire Mitt Romney is proof positive that the Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act of 2002 (which has some tenuous connection to McCain) was unnecessary.  Or,  as Ted puts it,


John McCain’s decisive victory yesterday is simultaneously a decisive repudiation of the campaign finance law he is most known for.

So there, McCain.  In your face!  But wait.  Why is that you ask?  Ted explains:


McCain-Feingold is based on the premise that money used to purchase speech distorts the political process because candidates can use money to fool voters, and therefore the speech purchased by money must be regulated.

The post is a little shy on attribution for this “premise”, but I don’t recall its basis being that money can “fool” voters.  My recollection, as discussed in  McConnell v. Federal Election Commission (2003), was that limited impact on free speech rights was justified by the legitimate government interest in preventing the corruption, and appearance of corruption, of candidates for and holders of public office who could be influenced by significant financial donations. 

Is that the same thing as what Ted said?  Why no, I don’t believe it is.  From where I sit, candidates can use money to fool voters regardless of where the money comes from.  The “fooling” part is where the money goes out of the system.  The McCain-Feingold part is where the money come into the system.  There seems to be a disagreement of anatomy here.

The law of which Ted speaks is directed toward those individuals and corporations who would contribute such large amounts that they could buy special influence with money-hungry candidates.  That  FEC v. Wisconsin Right to Life (2007) permits candidates to use as much of their own money as they want doesn’t seem to implicate the same interests, since the candidate’s use of his own funds won’t give him any greater influence with himself, certain types of schizophrenia notwithstanding.

So what then does McCain’s win over Mitt mean?  That Republican primary voters prefer McCain?  Maybe even because he tried to put the breaks on special interests buying candidates?  And maybe no amount of Mitt’s money was going to “fool” the voters enough to change this?  It could happen.

Waiving the (Red) Flag

Jon Katz at  Underdog has a post that would be pretty funny if it wasn’t so true.  One of the words used most frequently in the course of criminal proceedings is “waive”.  Defendant’s are asked if they “waive” counsel, “waive” a jury, “waive” their rights. 

Lawyers hear the word so often, and it has become such a basic word in our legal lexicon, that we fail to give it a second thought.  But for defendants, what does this word mean? 

While the use of legalisms is a systemic problem, often exacerbated by judges and prosecutors who lack a sense of what non-lawyers may comprehend because they have never had the breadth of experience that involves dealing with ordinary people in the way that criminal defense lawyers do, this one word, “waive” probably best captures the problem.  They get frustrated by defendants who can’t seem to grasp what’s painfully obvious to the judge.  The court asks a simple question, and these morons just don’t seem to get it.

People regularly wave hello to friends, wave good-bye to family, do the wave at football games.  What normal people do not regularly do is waive their rights.  This is one of those five-dollar words that works fine amongst lawyers, but is often meaningless for defendants.  They tend to agree with whatever the Court asks, because they want to seem agreeable.  They want to curry favor with, as opposed to upset, the judge.  And so they shake their heads “yes” and mutter something unintelligible, that ends up being the word “yes” in the transcript.

The problem becomes more comical, and more serious, with defendants who do not speak or comprehend English well.  Some have a limited ability with English, and prefer to appear without an interpreter.  Some have no ability to understand English, but don’t want to appear to be an “illegal alien” for fear that it will bias the court against them.  But the inability to fully speak and comprehend English makes the use of words like “waive” just ridiculous. 

They can’t waive anything, because they can’t understand what they are doing.  Waiver must be “knowing, voluntary and intelligent,” which has often been interpreted as meaning nothing more than assent came out of the defendant’s mouth and there was no gun to his head.  Not a metaphorical gun, as is usually the case, but a real gun.  Cold, hard, steel.  No gun, then it must be voluntary. 

And later, when somebody finally takes the time to explain to the defendant that what he did that day in court was give up his rights, the defendant puts on that sheepish face and declares, “but I didn’t know . . .”  And of course, he didn’t.  Sure, he could have.  All he needed to do was say, “But Judge, I do not understand the word you using.  Please explain it to me in simpler language.”  We all know how often that happens, and why defendants so rarely offer anything affirmative during their few minutes in front of the judge.

Much of what’s said in a courtroom goes over, or under, the heads of the people who are expected to understand it.  Waiver is certainly one of the biggies.  But next time the judge asks a defendant if he waives something, ask the judge if she wouldn’t mind substituting the words “give up” for “waive” and see how it flies.  If you think judges look at you funny now, just wait until you see the look you get when make this suggestion.  I bet it will be precious.

The Unusual Politics of Connecticut



Scene:  Round Hill, Greenwich.  Sipping gin and tonics in the solarium.

“Muffy?”

“Yes, Chad?”

“That Joe Lieberman, he’s Jewish, isn’t he?”

“Why do you ask, Chad?”

“Well, he doesn’t wear one of those funny black hats.”

“He’s the new breed, Chad.  Trying to be more like a real person.”

“But he’s a Democrat, Muffy.”

“True, Chad, but he’s not one of those crazy radical Democrats.”

“Like that Osama?”

“It’s Obama, Chad.  You know that, you wag!”

“Ha, ha.  I’ll always enjoy that one, Muff.”

“So why did we elect that Lieberman fellow?”

“Because we’re enlightened, Chad.  We’re compassionate toward others.”

“Oh yes. Noblesse oblige and all that.”

“Can you freshen this a bit, Muffy?”

“And he certainly won’t tolerate that Hillary woman. Chad.”

“Well, she has no self-respect at all.  Another lime wedge, please, dear.”

“Considering that she’s married to that animal, what would you expect?”

“Can you imagine if they move here instead of Chappaqua? Heh, heh, heh.”

“Can you imagine trying to get a tee time at Winged Foot!”

“I gather that Lieberman fellow doesn’t care much for those radical Democrats.”

“Well, I should hope not, Chad.  He’s our Senator, not some rabble rouser from New York!”

“Still, one has to wonder since he calls himself a Democrat.”

“Oh, Chad! Don’t be silly. He may call himself a Democrat, but he’s from Connecticut.  You goose, you.”

“So who are we voting for, Muffy?”

“This Hucklebee fellow seems quite appropriate, Chad.”

“No, no. The name simply won’t do.  Can you imagine how the fun they’ll have London over that?”

“Well then, I would guess that we should vote for this Arizona fellow, McCain.”

“But Muffy, he’s the person Lieberman supports.  And hat or no hat, he is a Jew.”

“Oh Chad, finish up that cocktail.  We’re having dinner at the club with the Joneses.”

“You know, Muffy, America has come a long way politically.  And I, for one, feel damn good about it.”

“Oh, me too, Chad.  Me too.”

Martindale-Hubbell Blog Makes Avvo Look Classy

No such thing as a bad blog, you say?  Pushaw.  An email from Rob (Kevin’s other right arm) at  Real Lawyers Have Blogs arrived yesterday as a follow up to  my post about clogging the blawgosphere with garbage, which Kevin turned into a very interesting debate format.

Martindale is one of the venerable old names in legal services, back when there was no blawgosphere (and no Avvo).  They were the only game in town, if you wanted a lawyer rating.  Law libraries had their heavy tomes lining the shelves, listing every lawyer in the front with expensive, detailed information comprising the majority of their considerable bulk. 

Then everything changed. They are now owned by Lexis-Nexis, the once cutting edge online legal research giant.  The need to pay for those M-H books disappeared.  They started up an overpriced, half-baked lawyer website business, and then started charging lawyers to have their rating appear.  Oh, the mighty have to adapt just like the upstart.

And now Martindale-Hubbell is in the blog business.  And man, does it suck.  Here’s a taste of what they offer:
















Wishes for Green


Posted by


:   Barry Solomon; VP Client Development


Date


:  Feb 4, 2008


Topic


:   martindale.com


Last year, to commemorate 10 years of martindale.com, we ran a “make a birthday wish” contest for legal professionals to e-mail us their own birthday wish for the legal industry. That’s just one of the many ways we’re making sure we get a conversation going with you, our customers.


Based on random selections and judge review, the winner has just been named….

…and it’s Continue reading >>


Now if that doesn’t make you want to add them to your RSS feed, then nothing will.

Nor can this be excused as just some corporate-type necessity.  Avvo has a blog, and while it doesn’t fall into the daily read category, it’s actually got some fun stuff as well as its self-promotional crap.  At least they have a sense of humor at Avvo, whereas the M-H blog has the stink of desperation.

In the grand scheme of the blawgosphere, there are always going to be some who just don’t get it.  Martindale-Hubbell appears be in the lead in this regard, and it’s the only lead they hold.   Steve Matthews calls it a “Cheezy Non-Blog.” which may well result in protests from various drippy forms of camembert everywhere.  This pseudo-blog is just pathetic.

As the discussion about useless blogging continues, a little something to bear in mind for all you erst-while blawgers out there.  A good blog may well bring you fame and fortune (although it’s done neither for me, though that may be the message), but a bad blog will make you the butt of ridicule throughout the blawgosphere.

As for the future of the Martindale-Hubbell blog, there may be no better evidence of M-H’s lost relevance in the future of the legal profession than this.  And I’m not paying you a dime so that people can see my AV rating.

A New Rule That Smells Really Bad

When I was a youth, the thought of emitting flatulence in school was terribly embarrassing.


One little fart in the middle of math class and they call you stinky forever.

Not so anymore, apparently.  The young ladies and gentlemen of Camden-Rockport Middle School (more particularly, the mature ones in 8th grade) find humor in odor.    Eugene Volokh, ever vigilant for tales of flatus (and we owe him a deep debt, since few others are willing to do the job), brings us this story from the  Village Soup / the Knox County Times (by way of Glenn Reynolds at  InstaPundit, the world-wide clearing house of flatus-related news).

The school has determined that the game of “intentional farting” must come to an end, and that anyone caught doing so will be punished by detention.  Eugene, ever the lawprof, comments:


True, I’d hate to try to prove beyond a reasonable doubt in a criminal case that a fart was intentional. But school discipline isn’t a criminal case, there’s no need to prove the intent beyond a reasonable doubt, and often the students’ statements, giggles, and other behavior will give a perfectly adequate clue to the clueful teacher. Perhaps experience will show the school that for some reason this policy won’t work, but it certainly seems to me to be worth trying.

I should say so!  If this disgusting lack of self-control and decorum isn’t nipped in the bud, it could become a phenomenon, a plague. A new MTV television series. Can you imagine the faces of Biglaw partners walking down the hallway, their faces contorted as they pass through an odorous yet invisible cloud, hearing the giggles of first year associates in the background?

Seriously, there’s a reason why we don’t let 8th graders do stand-up comedy.  I would think a nice note to their parents, and the appropriate reaction, would do the trick.  As for the poor teachers left to do the investigating, I see a new provision in the union contract coming soon.  This could really suck the glamour out of being a teacher.

Ohio’s Finest Make Me Sick, Thanks To Gideon

Gideon at  A Public Defender has posted  two videos of a TV news story about a Stark County, Ohio woman that must be seen.  The woman, Hope Steffi, was the victim of an assault when police came to her home, but ended up the perp when police became annoyed and intolerant of her.  She was then brought to jail, where she was forcibly stripped naked by both male and female guards, then left naked and injured for 6 hours in a cell.  Naturally, the Stark County Sheriff says that his people did nothing wrong.

I would post the videos here, but Gid found them and it would be wrong to steal his blawgospheric scoop.  So go watch the videos and then come back.  I’ll wait.

Okay, you’re back.  That this was how Hope Steffi, whether as victim or simply as human being, was treated in the hands of our public servants is an outrage.  That the Sheriff’s knee-jerk reaction is to blindly defend the conduct is despicable.  But that the station was castigated by some for “convicting those deputies on the air.”  Convicting?  By showing a videotape made by the deputies themselves, the station has been unfair to them.

On the most visceral level, it’s shocking whenever we see the inside of “law enforcement” at work, doing the things to people that we would never believe possible.  As Hope Steffi’s husband pointed out, what if this were your wife, hysterical, injured and in pain, was being stripped naked by men in a jail.  At the very worst, she was a vicious arrest-resister, a threat to all that truly matters to cops.  She didn’t do exactly what she was told to do quickly enough.  Now there’s a good reason for cops to behave this way.

Beyond what the deputies/guards/cops, whatever they’re called in Stark County, there are the people who will contort this scenario to think that there is any possible reason to justify the handling of Hope Steffi.  We will never be able to end this sick, abusive power trip if people don’t stop trying to rationalize police misconduct.  As long as there are supporters for violent abuse by law enforcement officers, the culture of abuse will continue.

We all want to respect police.  We want to believe that they are there to protect and serve.  We need to believe it, for the alternative is unthinkable.  But when it stares us in the face on video, the deniers are just as sick as the cops who engage in the abuse and their superiors who approve of it.  This will never stop until everyone who enables it opens their eyes and demands that it end.

Wall Street Journal: Peter Lattman Goes Legit

Answering the age old question of whether a blog is a destination or a stepping stone, Peter Lattman, the venerable blog-guru for the Wall Street Journal’s Law Blog, announced that he’s got a real job.


After two years, over 4000 posts and countless reader comments, I’m moving on, to a new beat at the Journal. . . . So I’m leaving to cover the private-equity industry for the paper. While I am really excited for a new challenge, I know that I will miss the Law Blog. This has been the most rewarding professional experience of my life. Thank you, and goodbye

It’s hard to believe that Lattman started the WSJ blog only two years ago, and harder still to believe that he’s put up 4000 posts in that short period.  And some say I’m prolific. Hah!

What was amazing was that Lattman’s posts were themselves snarky and sarcastic, and often dealt with subjects far below the level of crucial earthly importance that characterized the Journal itself.  He was funny.  The Wall Street Journal, not so funny.  This was one weird match.

Under Lattman, the WSJ Blog became the model for a successful, relevant and enjoyable “corporate” blog.  Despite being sanctioned by perhaps the single stodgiest rag in the business, which focused on some of the most boring and arcane issues in finance, Lattman made the blog fun and interesting.  No, not always, but almost.

The only part that I’m struggling to understand is how he’s going from the blog to the “private-equity industry.”  Sure, those private-equity boys are a laugh-riot (“right, Muffy? “Oh yes, Chad, yes, Yes!”), but I doubt they’re ready for Lattman, or he’s ready for them. 

And what’s to become of the WSJ blog? 


It gives me great pleasure to introduce Dan Slater, the next Law Blog. As a litigator at Kaye Scholer in New York a couple of years back, Dan was one of our first loyal Law Blog readers (and you know how we love our loyal readers). He quickly jettisoned the practice of law for a journalism career.

Let this be a lesson, comment early and often and you too can be an ex-litigator at Kaye Scholer.  Dan Slater is scheduled to make his debut today with an introductory post.  The torch will be passed, and we’ll see whether Slater can carry it.  Best of luck to Peter Lattman, and we’re sorry to see you go.

H/T ATL

Jail on $40 a Day?

Nassau County, New York, must think its jail is awfully darn special.  So special that it can charge for the privilege of spending some quality time there.  Fortunately, Supreme Court Justice Dana Winslow has decided that no matter how special the jail is, Nassau County can’t charge its inmates for the privilege.

According to the New York Law Journal, Justice Winslow has ordered the County to comply with the State Commission of Corrections and stop charging its inmates in New York State Commission of Correction v. Reilly.


The county conceded that it could not charge for food or medical and dental care under two other sections of the law. But it claimed that its fee covered 22.9 percent of the actual costs of housing each of the jail’s 1,600 inmates, excluding food and medical costs.

Does that mean the minibar is free? 


The contested section of the [Corrections] law, §500-n, provides that “Except as otherwise provided by law, a sheriff or other person in charge of a correctional facility . . . shall not charge a prisoner or other person in custody with any sum of money, or demand or receive from him money . . . or any valuable thing for any drink, food or other thing furnished or provided for such prisoner or person at any correctional facility.”

The County argued that their fees fell under the “except as otherwise provided by law” provision, and that the state statute was intended to prevent extortion by jail guards.  Of course, since jail guards inclined toward extortion generally are not otherwise persuaded to go legit by a non-criminal statute, this argument was unconvincing. 

The judge held that the County could not decide to impose it’s own fees and ignore State law at its leisure.  Only the state could pass a law that would fall within the exception, and the County, as directed by the Commission of Correction, had to stop charging its customers inmates.

What’s fascinating about this decision is how it juxtaposes the dual problems facing local jurisdictions, the trade off between the tough-on-crime stance taken by everyone running for public office, but the need to reduce taxes that pay for the tough-on-crime stance.  Nassau’s answer was to charge ’em for the pleasure, though my understanding is that the maid service is mediocre and none of the cells have a decent view.

Seriously, this is one of those initiatives that give real meaning to the phrase “adding insult to injury.”  There is no one in Nassau County jail of their own volition.  They aren’t there for a vacation.  You want to put them there, you pay for it. 

The thought that keeps popping into my head is, if the inmates refuse to pay, do they throw them out?  

If the county wants to cut its jail costs, how about asking the District Attorney to have her ADAs stop demanding $100,000 bail on first offender DWIs?  How about ending the “zero tolerance” policies toward everything short contributing to the County Executive’s political campaign?  I bet that Nassau County is feeling pretty darn foolish about putting that  Red Roof on the jail right about now.

Survivor: Blawgosphere Version

Gideon posted, during the cocktail hour, of the demise of two top criminal law blawgs, “Corrections Sentencing closed up shop and Audacity called it quits.”  I am unable to let the irony pass unmentioned.

While others promote the expansion of the blogosphere, whether for their own purpose or the general welfare (according to what version you find more persuasive), we have existing, respected substantive blawgs turning off the lights.  Not too long about,  Crime & Federalism did the same, though neither  Mike nor  Norm could handle life without their fix.

While I can’t say for sure that there is a pervasive reason for blawgs going dark, there seems to be some common themes.  What makes it important to mention these themes is that they are in direct conflict with the claims and promotions of the ever-expanding blogosphere approach. 

Theme Number 1:  It’s hard work.  It takes time and effort to maintain a good blawg.  You need to keep on top of the legal world.  You need to keep on top of the blawgosphere.  You need to put some time and thought into what you post, why you’re posting it and whether you have anything meaningful to say about it. 

Every once in a while, a blogger burns out.  The posts start sounding a little too familiar, as the news goes around in one big circle after another, with nothing new and nothing changed.  Then why bother?  There’s a harsh reality for those people who are just discovering the issues that seem to appear in criminal law blawgs:  These are the same issues, in one permutation or another, that we have been dealing with forever.  Change is rare.  News is rare.  Everything becomes a grind after a while.

Theme Number 2:  There’s no glory in blawging. Again, promoters write about the “success” stories of becoming a big-time blogger, but such success is awfully hard to prove or quantify.  We don’t get paid for doing this (except Lat at ATL and those American Enterprise Institute shills).  Some may make a few shekels off advertising, but its lunch money.  Others say that blawgs bring in plenty of business.  Norm once wrote that he probably loses business because of blogging.  I suspect that most criminal blawgers (and certainly all public defender bloggers) never made a dime for their efforts.  It’s different in criminal law than in other areas of practice, though I have my doubts about the other areas as well.

The people who read blawgs are unlikely to think about why a bunch of people write stuff every day for their amusement and occasional enlightenment.  When the authors tire out, readers post nice comments about them, their blawgospheric eulogy. 

You pay to buy the morning paper, but the blawgosphere comes free of charge.  It’s a pretty darned good deal.  The news is newer.  The commentary is often far better.  The edge is cut sharper than anywhere else.  But it’s still a product of individual effort and personal sacrifice.  I’m not asking for sympathy at all; it’s entirely up to each individual blawger to post or not, and if it’s too much trouble, then the blawger can stop whenever he or she wants to.  There’s no social contract involved in this game.

There may well come a time when the blawgosphere begins to wear out on its own, provided that it remains a purely voluntary endeavor.  Should there be a way to monetize substantive effort, that may change the equation.  For now, there is no way to do so. 

I’m sorry to see anybody with a good blawg give up, but I understand it.  This is a tough game to keep up, and just so the readers hear it again and clearly, this is all a gift from the blawger to whoever decides to read it.  It is not, as some readers believe, something we owe you, so enjoy it if you will but try not to make this unnecessarily aggravating.  Or one morning, there will be no more blawgosphere, just a bunch of lawyer ads called “blogs”.