Author Archives: SHG

The Great Cultural Divide: The Chinese View of Punishment

Mark Bennett, the Texas Tornado, posted about Japanese Justice, an oxymoron to my American sensibilities.  It reminded me of a fascinating meeting that I was a part of with a criminal Judge from China.

The Chinese judge had come to the United States as part of a legal exchange program, where he was to learn about the American way and share with us the Chinese way.  In New York, he was to meet with a delegation from the New York State Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers. 

At the last minute, the president asked me if I would be part of the delegation, since some others begged off and it left past-president Larry Goldman essentially the sole member of the New York delegation.  The idea of Larry on his own with a representative of a foreign government had broad international relations implications, so I felt compelled to join him.

The Chinese judge spoke no English, but had an interpreter with a finely honed sense of humor to help him.  During the course of our discussions, the judge reluctantly expressed his view that the death penalty was more humane than life in prison.  His reluctance was due to his recognition that American’s often feel the opposite, and he did not want to appear confrontational.

But neither Larry nor I would take offense at a different point of view.  The judge explained that Chinese prisons were not the most user-friendly places.  In fact, they were horrible, and perfectly suited to the desire for retribution and little else.  But also, the judge’s attitude was framed by the fact that China is so heavily populated that life is, well, relatively cheap.  China had numerous policies that impacted on life, from limiting “needless” childbirth to shipping their extras off to child-less Americans.  It was hard for the Chinese to get all that worked up about an execution.

Then Larry chimed in, as only Larry could, to express that he did NOT disagree with the judge’s basic premise, and in fact he too would prefer the death penalty over life in prison.  He explained that the idea of spending the rest of his life behind bars was so terrible to him that a swift, painless death seemed preferable.  But he quickly added, ever the statesman, the I would no doubt disagree.

To Goldman’s surprise, I quickly responded, “Absolutely not Larry.  If the choice was whether to put you in prison for the rest of your life of put you to death, I’m behind your execution 100%.”

The Chinese judge, about 30 second after the interpreter was able to stop laughing and catch his breath, started laughing uproariously.  Lawyers.  We are a fun bunch, no?

The Unlearned Lesson of False Confessions (Updated)

It’s only been a few weeks since the Appellate Division, 2d Department, reversed the conviction of Marty Tankleff.  The centerpiece of the Tankleff conviction was his confession.  The reversal, predicated upon subsequently discovered evidence that the murders of Marty’s parents was convicted by others, served to confirm one clear point:  His confession was false.  Yes he admitted the murders.  No, the confession was not inviolate.

Yet, as reported in the New York Law Journal, Judge C. Randall Hinrichs, sitting in the same Suffolk County where Judge Braslow, the Tankleff judge, sits, has learned nothing.


Judge C. Randall Hinrichs of Suffolk County determined in People v. Crews, 2353A-06, that the testimony of Solomon Fulero, an Ohio psychologist, would not be helpful to the jury in the upcoming murder trial of Tracy Crews. Mr. Fulero is also a lawyer and community college professor who frequently testifies as an expert witness for the defense.

“[T]he Court is of the opinion that the evaluation of the truthfulness of a statement is a subject for which jurors may easily draw on their day-to-day experience, their common observation and their everyday knowledge,” Judge Hinrichs concluded.

There are few things that lawyers enjoy better than facile, superficially egalitarian pronouncements by a court that insidiously undermine a defense.  Judge Hinrichs conclusion offers a certain appeal to those who suffer from the Dunning-Kruger Effect, having a simple answer to all question based upon their absolute certainty that whatever snaps in their mind from moment to moment reflects the totality of all human knowledge and experience.  Others may not be as taken with the decision.

The prevalence of false confessions is a controversial issue in criminal justice circles. The Innocence Project at Benjamin N. Cardozo School of Law has reported that in 25 percent of DNA exoneration cases, the defendant “made incriminating statements or pleaded guilty, delivered outright confessions or pled guilty.”

If jurors were so darn good at this, or if jury’s worked nearly as well as their supporters contend, there would be no need for the Innocence Project.  Unfortunately, there is a need for the Innocence Project, and a need to put an expert on the witness stand to explain how and why false confessions happen. 

In the past, I’ve discussed the significance of the prosecution’s appeal to “common sense.”  Does common sense tell you that a person does not confess to a murder that he didn’t commit?  Of course it does.  I would never do that.  You would never do that.  Who would do such a thing? 

The problem is that we have never been subjected to the coercion and manipulation at the hands of well-trained police whose sole purpose is to obtain a confession.  So this falls far outside of our life experience, and we cannot imagine how it could happen.  No matter how good our faith in contemplating the arguments of the defense, our lack of bias is no match for placing ourselves into the shoes of the defendant.  We plug the argument into the entirety of our life experience to see whether we can find a match.  No match?  Then we reject the argument.

I thought that the Court of Appeals decision in People v. LeGrand put this issue to rest.  The Court held that it would be error to refuse to permit the defense to call an expert to explain to a jury how a false confession can happen.  After so many years, and so many false confessions, the wall appeared to come down so that the defense could finally present the jury with an understanding other than its own.

Not in Suffolk County, however. 

Judge Hinrichs referred to the recent decision of People v. LeGrand, 8 NY3d 449 (2007), in which the Court of Appeals found that judges may admit expert testimony about the reliability of eyewitness identification and that, in some cases, it would be an abuse of discretion to exclude that testimony.

But he noted the LeGrand Court held that the existence of sufficient corroborating evidence could lead to the disallowance of expert testimony. The judge said the guilty pleas of Mr. Crews’ two co-defendants and their agreement to testify against him provided “ample” corroboration to warrant excluding Mr. Fulero’s testimony. Moreover, the judge said he had been influenced by the fact that Mr. Crews was 34 years old at the time of his confession.

And we all know that if someone pleads guilty, it would never happen as a “plea of convenience” to avoid the potential of spending the rest of your life in prison for a crime you didn’t commit, or an allocution implicating a co-defendant at the insistence of the prosecution or you don’t get the deal.  It’s unclear to me what Crews’ age has to do with anything.  Are 34 year old’s immune from coercion? 

The courts are edging closer and closer to recognizing that it’s a bad thing to convict innocent people, and that confessions by their nature are some of the most problematic evidence around.  But this case reminds us that we still have a way to go before the epiphany at the Court of Appeals in LeGrand or at the Second Department in Tankleff filters its way down to the ground level in Suffolk County.  The fight isn’t over yet.

Update:  Upon the excellent recommendation of Kathleen, a little bit of detail about Judge Hinrichs.  He was a Suffolk County ADA from 1982 until 2001, when he assumed the bench.  And that sums up the grand total of Judge Hinrichs’ professional experience.  If anyone has info on reversal rates (noting that he would be in the Second Department), please let me know.

Public School: Debit Cards Are Cooler

When banks first started promoting the birth of the debit card, I laughed.  Who in their right mind would choose plastic that took money right out of their bank account rather than enjoy the float, and protection, that your basic, run of the mill credit card provided?  “Nope”, I said to myself, “nobody is going to buy into this nonsense.”

Wrong again, Greenfield.  I pride myself on having my finger on the pulse of the consuming nation, despite the fact that patient always seems dead to me.  While it was obvious why banks wanted their customers to use these new-fangled debit cards, flashy commercials with people whizzing around in syncopated rhythms wasn’t going turn a nation of money-savvy consumers stupid overnight, right?

For the consumer, debit cards offered one virtue, and only one virtue.  You couldn’t overspend and put yourself into debt.  When the cupboard was bare, so was your spending power.  But who didn’t know when they were spending more than they had?  Only an idiot would unintentionally charge more than they could afford.  Note the word unintentionally, thus removing those who thought borrowing at 24.99% was a good idea.

For the banks, the debit card was pure genius, provided they could convince the public to go along.  No longer would they have to carry a national mountain range of purchases, only to have some wag pay the bill in full some 30 to 45 days later.  Sure, they made their 3% on the merchant’s back, but can still enjoy their piece while eliminating the backside risk of payment.

Yesterday, my high school senior daughter was required to go to a lecture in her required college prep course about how to handle finances when she left the nest.  I’m less than thrilled by this course in the first place, as I have found myself in regular disagreement with the way some teacher thinks my daughter ought to conduct her life when she becomes somewhat independent.  The teacher and I don’t see things eye to eye, but then I’m not a union member, an employee or enamored with pedestrian consumerism.

The school, apparently, is of the view that parents don’t do a sufficient job preparing their children for life outside the home.  They take in loco parentis to the extreme, as if sex education was better taught be a gym teacher than me.  Okay, bad example.  But this college life skills training included a host of value judgments that are not universal.  Who is some teacher to test my child on how to live her life?

But I digress.  So the financial training lecture, I later found out, was given by a fellow in the employ of Bank of America.  It was my understanding that he was to tell the students about how to spot and avoid fraud, How to handle their budding finances.  How to establish credit for the future.  How not to squander the funds that I placed into her grubby, Louis Vuitton-loving, hands.

It didn’t turn out quite as expected.  The Bank of America guy did his job well.  He sold the array of products that young people really need, from plastic cards emblazoned with photographs of their pets, friends or idol (“Oh! That’s so coool!”) to why the debit card is the one you want, and why credit cards are bad and evil.

If you grab their hearts and minds while young, you have them for the rest of their lives.  For those of us who instill to some greater or lesser extent that teachers are to be respected, we now have a problem.  The first thing I did was deprogram my daughter from the Bank of America sermon on good and bad financial instruments.  The second thing I did was explain, calmly, reassuringly, that this teacher was the exception to the rule.

I don’t blame the Bank of America guy for his sales job.  That’s what he’s supposed to do.  I do, however, blame the school for bringing in people, and given them the attributed credibility that has long been instilled in my child reserved for teachers.  Where does the school come off teaching my child which plastic to prefer, which bank to use.

Understand that this isn’t the entirety of this independence preparation.  Her assignment today is to go online and shop for all the things she will need to properly outfit her college dorm room.  I do not defer my values as to what is necessary and proper to the teacher.  Not this one.  Not any teacher.  This is mine to do, and the school has no business giving my child an assignment to learn how to shop their way.

For years, there was outcry about schools teaching tolerance, alternative life-styles, and acceptance of the reality that not everyone lives the way we do.  They teach that it’s okay to be different than Ozzie and Harriet, or Ward and June, or Mom and Dad.  Where’s the outcry that schools are turning our children into consumer-machines, ready, willing and able to shop at the drop of a hat.  With a Bank of America debit card with a picture of Fluffy on the front, grasped tightly in their adolescent hands.  This is not why I send my kids to school.

More On Heller; Gun Crimes Turned Upside Down

Just as we tend to think that everything has already been invented, only to be proven wrong several times a day, we tend to view Constitutional law as immutable.  Written in stone, black letter, beyond cavil, there are a host of phrases that lawyers and judges love to pull out to shut down any novel argument or distinctive approach to the law that hasn’t already been approved by someone else.

Mike O’Shea, guest-blogging at Concurring Opinions, deconstructs the  D.C. v. Heller case, where Heller’s merits brief is due this coming week.  This case may turn our view of the Second Amendment right to bear arms upside down.  But remember this oldie but goodie?


Since the Second Amendment right ‘to keep and bear Arms’ applies only to the right of the State to maintain a militia and not to the individual’s right to bear arms, there can be no serious claim to any express constitutional right of an individual to possess a firearm.

United States v. Warin, 530 F.3d 103 (6th Cir. 1976).  Every schoolchild is taught how we started with  Plessy v. Ferguson and ended with Brown v. Board of Ed.  Was Thurgood Marshall just another nutty lawyer when he argued against an interpretation that was beyond question was totally wrong?

The notion that the Second Amendment applied only the collective right to possess guns was beyond question in Warin, and in the minds of lawyers of my generation and beyond.  Yet today, the argument is persuasively made that we were wrong, and obviously so, for all that time.

Mike O’Shea provides a comparison of the language of the Second Amendment with the rest of the Bill of Rights, and how they’ve been viewed by the Supreme Court:


• The First Amendment’s Establishment Clause appears merely to bar Congress from interfering with state religious establishments. However, it has been interpreted to confer a (fully incorporated) individual constitutional right to be free from religious establishment, complete with a custom-tailored exception to the taxpayer standing doctrine to encourage Establishment Clause challenges to legislative action.


• The First Amendment’s Free Speech Clause protects the “freedom of speech, [and] of the press.” It has been interpreted to protect the private possession of works of obscene pornography and at least some forms of virtual child pornography.


• The Fourth Amendment simply states that search warrants shall be subject to requirements of probable cause and particularity. It has been interpreted to presumptively require a warrant for any search or seizure, unless a specific exception applies.


• The Fifth Amendment: Miranda. Enough said.


• The Sixth Amendment states that a criminal defendant has the right “to have the Assistance of Counsel for his defense.” It has been interpreted to confer a right, not merely to receive assistance from retained counsel, but to have counsel appointed by the government, free of charge, if a defendant cannot otherwise afford it.


• The Eighth Amendment prohibits cruel and unusual punishment. Although statutes imposing the death penalty for serious felonies were common at the time of the Framing, the Eighth Amendment has been interpreted to prohibit capital punishment for the rape of an adult woman (and probably for child rape).

One thing that smacks me in the face when I read Mike’s comparison is how our political and social agenda has shaped constitutional interpretation.  This is a bitter pull for those of us who argue against it today, when the pendulum seem stuck on the law and order side of the aisle (actually, law and order is both sides of the aisle today).   Hating to be overtly hypocritical, I find this troubling.

But the “emanations and penumbras,” as Wild Bill Douglas called them in Griswold, of the Heller case may open some very curious doors in the world of criminal law.  How many of our clients are in prison, or branded a elon and denied the full panoply of rights given the rest of the People, because of their possession of an unlicensed handgun?  If Heller goes as anticipated, will this mean that all of these defendants, past and present, be exonerated or have their record expunged for engaging in conduct that the Constitution says they have a right to do?  It’s not just that the crimes for which they stand convicted are unconstitutional, but that they have, and always had, an affirmative right to possess a gun.  How can they suffer punishment, or perpetual taint, for the exercise of a right?

But it goes even farther.  If the government imprisoned them for exercising a constitutional right, are they not then entitled to compensation for this wrongful imprisonment?  And the felon in possession issue, not to mention the extra 5 years for the overbroad “use and carry” in a drug case, are huge.  Will this open the door to 1983 actions across the land?  When the vision of a basic constitutional rights turns completely around, it opens the door to a breathtaking bundle of issues, each of which will implicate in some way the work of criminal defense and civil rights lawyers.

The Heller case has the potential for a seismic shift in criminal law.  Hold on to your hats.  This could be a wild ride.

Lynne Stewart Argued Before The 2d Circuit: No “Freewheelers” Wanted

Oral argument before a Second Circuit panel was held yesterday on the Lynne Stewart appeal.  The government argued that the sentence imposed by Judge John Koeltl, 28 months rather than the 30 years that the government sought, constituted an “abuse of discretion,” according to this Daily News story.

“Ooh, shocking,” you say?  Fair enough.  What else would you expect the government to argue?

But what about the panel?  Now this is where it gets interesting. As quoted in the Newsday story;


Judge John Walker seemed to agree, questioning the message Koeltl sent with the sentence.

“There’s a serious aspect to this case _ the role of lawyers sworn to uphold codes of conduct and ethics and to behave in a particular way,” he said.

He said Koeltl failed to adequately consider the factors he was supposed to address as he explained the sentence.

“We don’t want totally freewheeling judges just to make decisions that they choose,” he said.

Wait a sec.  Is Judge Walker (President Bush’s cousin) calling Judge Koeltl a “totally freewheeling judge?” Those are fighting words in the rarified world of the judiciary.  What a smack he just gave his district court colleague.

But then, Judge Guido Calabresi wasn’t having any of that freewheeling talk.


Koeltl appeared to have given the case considerable thought and reached a sentence he thought was fair.

“I find the work Judge Koeltl did admirable to a degree that is amazing,” Calabresi said. “There’s no case quite like this one. This case is a very different case.”

So the battle lines are drawn, at least as far as Judge Koeltl is concerned.  And what of the third member of the panel, Judge Robert Sack?  He said nary a word, leaving us with a Second Circuit cliffhanger.


 


There’s No Party When It’s Ex Parte

Mark Bennett, the Texas Tornado, came home from New York to a surprise:  An order signed by a judge based on a motion that says it was served on him, as required, beforehand.  Except it wasn’t.  This, for you non-lawyers out there, is what we call an ex parte communication, where one side communicates with the court and the other side knows nothing about it.  It’s generally considered a very bad thing.

Bennett asks some important questions, though I’m sure he knows the answers.  They do it because they can.  And they can because Court’s let them get away with it.  Not just the ex parte communication, but the affidavits of service that never happened, class A misdemeanors. 

While the problem of prosecutors neglecting to serve papers isn’t one that I’ve experienced in New York (although they routinely screw up the sequence by serving the court by hand with papers including an affidavit of service, and then mailing the papers out to defense counsel a day or two later), Mark’s secondary question to the judge is the one that intrigues me the most.

Mark asks why judges allow, tolerate, facilitate illegal conduct by prosecutors.   Mark pushes further:

Every day you take it upon yourself to help the baby prosecutors in your court be better lawyers: you give them little hints and pointers about how better to prosecute people. Now, that’s not really appropriate, but it’s going to happen however much I fuss — even if you don’t care whether the state wins, you naturally want the state’s inexperienced and poorly-trained lawyers who are in your court every day to become better lawyers. Right?

It’s a fascinating irony that the less experienced, less competent a prosecutor, the more a judge will involve herself in assisting the prosecutorial function.  Sure, we talk about an adversarial system, but when the judge gets down from the bench and starts showing the prosecutor what to do, you start to get the sense that they’re ganging up on you.

The answer to the question is precisely what Mark suggests.  The prosecutorial function is for the benefit of the State, the Commonwealth, the People, whatever they are called in your jurisdiction.  The defense represents the defendant.  One person versus society at large. 

The prosecutor is often a youngster, inexperienced and undertrained.  The fact that they are pompous and flush with power and authority has nothing to do with their skill level.  So the judge takes it upon herself to be a part of the training process of baby prosecutors by helping them along.  Is it so wrong that judges want to make sure that violent criminals don’t walk free because of some kid’s inexperience?  Doesn’t society have an interest in putting bad guys behind bars?

Of course society cares.  Even criminal defense lawyers, when not in the well, admit that we want bad guys convicted.  We just want it done fairly and properly.  It is not the judge’s role to play super-prosecutor.  This leads to rank partiality, even when the judges believe that they aren’t favoring the prosecution.

This also leads to judges cutting prosecutors a break on the “technicalities” of criminal prosecutions, like serving motions and filing false affidavits.  They don’t mean it.  They just don’t know any better.  What do you expect from them?

A very slippery slope, when perjurious affidavits become routine and incompetence is rewarded by judicial facilitation.

Some wags might suggest that the training of baby prosecutors be left to grown up prosecutors.  Worse still, some might suggest that judges are doing no favors by easing prosecutors into the job, encouraging sloppy work and bad institutional habits. 

But what do the judges think?  That they’re just leveling the playing field between experienced and vicious criminal defense lawyers, ready at the drop of a hat to rip some young prosecutor’s heart out through his nose if he makes the slightest mistake, and young, well-intended, over-burdened prosecutors trying to do their best to serve the public good.  And they don’t see this as presenting a bit of a problem with impartiality.

Rudy Crushed, Vows Indictment

Sources deep within the Giuliani camp have disclosed that Rudy isn’t taking his crushing defeat at the hands of Florida Republicans lying down.

According to my source, Rudy knows that this is vast libertarian conspiracy by Ron Paul supporters to undermine his candidacy.

“It’s one thing if he was beat legit, but he can smell a conspiracy a mile away,” the source said.  The plan of action is to spread misinformation to the media today to through the perps off the trail and lull them into a false sense of security.  While claiming to concede his loss and drop out of the race, Rudy’s people will be digitally scanning the face of every person present under the theory that the criminals always return to the scene of the crime.

“He knows how these people think, and there’s no way that Rudy is going down without bringing Ron Paul cartel with him.”

My source also informs me that during the hiatus between today’s press conference and Giuliani’s announcement of the indictment, he plans to seek a high level position with the Hair Club for Men.

In other news, Rudy Giuliani has admitted his decade long affair with Bernie Kerik, but proclaimed, “It’s over. Move on”

The TV Time Out

Norm Pattis planned to do his job representing his client at a bail hearing.  He sent his associate to a bail hearing for a client bright and early.  I’m sure the family was there waiting, hoping, that bail would be set in an amount they could make, bringing the defendant home to the loving bosom of his family.

But this wasn’t your run of the mill case.  It was a high profile case.  And since Connecticut has enacted the Mickey Sherman Law and allows cameras in the courtroom, the proceedings had to wait.  Why?  The media wasn’t ready.  Put over to 2:00 PM, when the cameras would be ready to roll.

For anyone who goes to the stadium for a professional football game, you know that there’s a little secret that the fans at home may not be aware of.  Sure, the teams play the clock game, saving or using their time-outs strategically.  But there’s a time out that’s never talked about by the commentators:  The TV Time Out. 

You see, the networks make money from commercials, and football commercials sell for some of the biggest bucks around.  So if there are no breaks in the game, there’s no time for commercials.  And really, aren’t commercials what football is all about?  So when ten minutes goes by without a natural break in the game, the refs wave their arms, the teams gather on the sidelines, the fans sit there and the network cuts to a commercial.  The game just stops.

Welcome to the TV-driven courtroom.  It’s no longer about the judge, or the prosecutor, or even the defendant.  Forget about rights (remember, that defendant has to sit in a cell for few hours more while the media finishes its morning coffee and starts to filter in).  Forget about procedure.  It’s showtime.

Let’s take this down the road apiece.  Killer question on cross, witness breaks down in tears and screams, “yes, I lied.”  Director says, “Cut, we didn’t get that shot. Let’s do it again.”  Too far-fetched?  What about cross building to a crescendo, hammering away at the witness on the stand, when suddenly the Judge says, “Okay, let’s take a 2 minutes recess for a commercial break.”

I’m no fan of cameras in the courtroom.  But this goes well beyond cameras.  In a high-profile murder case I did a few years back, my arraignment (like Norm’s bail hearing) was changed from 9:30 a.m., when court typically starts, to 2:00 p.m. to accommodate the media.  This is just wrong.  It’s one thing for the media to cover the case, but to have any say in the proceedings is crazy. 

In my case, the producer of Law & Order sat on the bench with the judge during the trial.  I kid you not.  If you think this can’t get out of control in our media-crazed society, never underestimate the allure of those 15 minutes of fame.  The only saving grace is that trials are, for the most part, tedious and boring to watch.  But then, that’s what editing is for.

Our Friend, The Bail Bondsman

As I read this piece by Adam Liptak in the New York Times, I wondered to myself, “had Liptak ever met a bail bondsman in the Bronx?”  The story carries a dateline from Fort Lauderdale, Florida (where all good New York journalism comes from in the winter), and Liptak describes the bondsman’s office has looking like a dentists’ office.
I’ve been to the office of dentists and bondsmen.  They didn’t look anything alike.

There is no scuzzier business on the face of the earth than bail bondsman.  I represent one.  I have one bondsman that I trust and to whom I send clients when they need one.  But there is nothing recognizable in Liptak’s description to my experience with bondsmen.

It’s a business of misery.  People go there in desperation, a loved one arrested and held in jail.  Usually, they are poor and can’t post bail for the release.  They are treated like scum.  They take it because they have no choice; they need the bondsman at that moment far more than the bondsman needs them. 

The story makes it sound as if this is a business with rules.  While bondsman are nothing more than insurance brokers issuing insurance policies on the return of a defendant to court, there is no feeling that you’re in “good hands.”  Forget this nonsense about a 10% fee.  They demand whatever collateral they can get, even if you’re the best flight risk in town.  They never want to be left holding the bag, and they are not doing this for love.  This is a cold, hard business, and the bondsman intends to win every deal.

The fee they charge, regardless of guilt or innocence, regardless of flight or return, is a shady matter.  When I send a client to my trusted bondsman, I make sure that there is no over-reaching on the fee nor collateral.  It’s part of my job as their lawyer.  But when people come who have already been to the bondsman, I’m shocked to learn of gross overcharging, with outrageous fees paid up front.  But then, they wanted to get their loved one out and that was all the money they had in the world.

As Jeralyn from  TalkLeft comments, it’s a system that discriminates against the poor, and indeed it does.  People with money post bail directly.  In New York, they lose 3% to the State if the defendant is convicted.  Call it a “convenience fee,” since it’s convenient for the state to take money from people who everybody hates. 

People who don’t have the funds to post bail directly has no choice but to go to the bail bondsman, and pay whatever they extort.  Fees of 25%, 50%, are common but unspoken.  It’s flagrantly illegal, but who’s going to complain?  It’s cash that goes directly into the pocket, and there’s no proof it ever happened.

Even in the sanitized world of bail bondsmen that Liptak writes about, the business is despised and rejected.  It’s an American invention, but four states have outlawed it. 


“It’s really the only place in the criminal justice system where a liberty decision is governed by a profit-making businessman who will or will not take your business.”

There’s nothing more American than free enterprise, even when it comes to freedom.  But the problem is that the consumers of bond services have no other option.  Either the defendant stays in jail or they pay the bondsman. 

Why can’t people put up 10% of the bond, the amount they would theoretically pay the bondsman for his fee, to the court and get the defendant out?  Many people who lack experience with the New York system think this is how it works.  It could be, though this would produce an anomaly, since a judge has already decided that a particular number is warranted to assure the defendant’s return to court.  If the family only had to post 10% of that amount, then the judge would simply increase the bail amount to compensate, putting equally out of reach.

And nowhere in Liptak’s story is there any mention of the dark side of the bail bondsman’s trade, the bounty hunter.  He’s the fellow who comes after the defendant who doesn’t return to court, the guy who costs the bondsman money.  Talk about lawlessness, there’s nothing meaner than a bondsman who gets beat and has to pay his “hard earned” money to the court. 

Like I said, bail bonding is one scuzzy business.

Predator By Association (Updated)

Following on the heels of my polemic on how judges and other old-timers don’t get  cutting edge technology comes this ridiculous tale from Gideon at A Public Defender.


If you don’t have a MySpace or Facebook account, you’re nobody. Especially teens. Everyone has them and then some. So when middle school resource officer John Nohejl in Florida decided to set up a MySpace account so he could communicate with students in ways they do (with the blessing of the school), it seemed like a brilliant idea.

But someone on his 170 person “friends” list had a link on their profile to a porn site.  And so, “the Florida attorney general’s elite cyber crimes unit are investigating him for making adult content  available to underage children.”  Allegations have also surfaced that Officer Nohejl’s mailman took his AMC Pacer to a garage where someone else had their K-car services who had a cousin who was once seen purchasing a Starbucks Vente Frocacino Latte made by a barista who knew someone with a Facebook account that included a “friend” who had another “friend” with a link to a porn site on their profile. 

Almost everyone who reads Gid’s story will fully appreciate the significance, not to mention stupidity, of tainting the officer with a link on a profile of a “friend”.  How much more obvious and ridiculous can it be?
Nohejl
Well, apparently it was not only deemed worthy of investigation by this “elite” investigative unit of the Florida AGs office, but required them to go public about predatory threat to children.  Against a middle school resource officer, who appears (from his picture) to look an awful lot like a police officer.  He looks like he knows his way around a donut.

Today, almost everybody has some connection to an account like Facebook, even someone as out of touch as me.  I admit that I don’t really have a clue what Facebook is all about, or how to use my profile, or what to do when I get these “invitations” from people I don’t actually know who invite me to be their Facebook “friend”.  

These invites come because I’m listed as a “friend” to someone else, who the inviter is also “friends” with, and I guess that they invite their friend’s friends.  In any event, it somehow winds its way down to me.  I don’t actually have a clue who these people are or why they are sending me an invitation.  What am I to do about it?

Do people who understand and use Facebook know who their “friends” are?  Do they check them out before letting them in the cyberdoor to make sure they are kosher?  Assuming that eventually, every person with a computer will be a degree or two of separation from everyone else on Facebook (or whatever replaces it as the hot new place to be on the internet next week), are we all tainted by the one person who has an inappropriate link on his profile?

But here’s the thing that worries me.  This “elite cyber crimes unit,” a group that someone like me would assume to have sufficient knowledge of how this stuff works to understand just how ridiculous this was, took it very seriously.  If they took action against the officer, would the judge not presume that they know what they’re talking about?  Would the judge have laughed the AG’s “elite cyber crimes unit” out of court?  Let us assume that eventually, even a judge would figure out this was just stupid, but would the officer’s career and life be in shambles by the time that happened?

Hopefully, ridicule in the blawgosphere for this idiocy will put an end to this AG investigation and save the next person from being the target of a witch hunt.  But there will be another techno threat down the road of similar foolishness.  This is going to be a problem for a long time to come.

Update:  And another good yuk out of the New York Times City Room:


“We have to admit that life is different than when we were growing up,” said Assemblyman Joseph R. Lentol. “We have to have educational programs so that parents know about MySpace and Spacebook and…”

Uh, did he just say “Spacebook?”

O.K., well, Mr. Lentol, a Brooklyn Democrat, did admit he was out of his depth. “When we were young, things were different. And we need to pass legislation that reflects today’s world, not yesterday’s world,” he continued. “Old geezers like me have no clue about the Internet and all of its intricacies.”

I am really not kidding about this.  People are making all sorts of important decisions without the slightest clue what they’re talking about.  Really!

H/T  Heather in a comment at A Public Defender