Author Archives: SHG

A Horrible Situation All Around

Mark Bennett at  Defending People posts about one of those horrible, untenable situations that make up a parents’, and criminal defense lawyers’, worst nightmare.  The Star-Telegram story is here.


[A] 32-year-old Arlington, Texas man who believed that his 18-year-old stepson had anally raped the man’s 8-year-old daughter. After the man’s wife (the stepson’s mother) made bail on her son’s aggravated sexual assault charge despite the man’s warning that he would hurt the lad, the man picked his stepson up from jail and then allegedly drove to an abandoned house in Fort Worth, beat his stepson with a baseball bat, and sodomized him with a metal tool.

Acknowledging the horror of the situation, Mark is able to detach himself from the reaction that comes naturally and state that the father’s retaliation was wrong.  Indeed, Mark is correct.  But I have some myself feeling particularly sympathetic to the man’s need to deal with the anal rape of his daughter.

Mark notes that he hopes the man got the right guy, though according to the new story, he caught his stepson in the act, which pretty much does away with that concern.  As much as I can appreciate, from an intellectual standpoint, who retaliation is wrong and why we leave it to our legal system to address crime, I can’t imagine any father of an 8 year old who wouldn’t do the same.  Or worse.

Of course people shouldn’t take the law into their own hands.  But if ever there was a case where it was understandable, this is it.  And this is why I don’t represent sex offenders.

Meet Your Moral Compass, Utah Version

Not that I don’t adore the Utah State Bar Journal, but I would have never seen this had it not been for Skelly.  It seems that there’s a criminal defense lawyer, in the very loosest sense of the phrase, who has decided that we should put aside all that lawyerly gobbledygook about zealous representation and become Jimminy Cricket.  His name is Ted Weckel, and his website is called “taxattorneyutah”, which should serve to enlighten everyone as to his dedication to criminal defense.  More about Ted later.

Ted wrote this article that the Utah Bar Journal published, called Helping Our Clients Tell the Truth: Rule of Professional Conduct 2.1 in Criminal Cases.  After extolling his expertise, based upon his one jury trial, Ted gets to the point:


If our clients tell us that they want to go to trial despite our conclusion that they are lying to us about their innocence, an interesting question presents itself. That question is whether Utah Rule of Professional Conduct 2.1 and American Bar Association Model Rule of Professional Conduct 2.1 (collectively, Rule 2.1) allow us to advise our clients of their moral obligations to be honest to the courts, themselves and any victims, and to consider whether they should plead guilty, if they are in fact guilty, and accept responsibility for what they have done. We would provide such advice not only because the evidence may be stacked against our clients and a plea offer would benefit them – but because doing so would develop our clients’ character and weaken their ability to commit fraud upon the courts through their lawyers. [Emphasis happily added].

Do I laugh or cry?  It’s not that Ted has decided to reinvent the purpose of criminal defense to suit his personal vision of morality, but that the Utah State Bar Journal actually printed it rather than referred this nutjob for disbarment.

But Ted’s not done preaching yet.  Here’s more:


If our clients have never learned the value of making beneficial moral choices for themselves and those whose lives they negatively influence, then I say it is about time that they did. We as members of the criminal law bar are in the prospectively enviable position of being able to advise persons charged with crimes of their moral options and responsibilities on a regular basis.

Ted is no member of any “criminal law bar” that I’m aware of.  The criminal law bar that I’m aware of advocates the representation of their clients, not the imposition of personal visions of morality.  Even as I write this, I’m shaking my head in amazement that anyone could conceivably put such utter crap to paper. 

So who is Ted Weckel, criminal defense lawyer extraordinaire? 


Ted Weckel

 According to his website, this is what Ted, the lawyer who uses the url “taxattorneyutah” (because most criminal defense lawyers really want to promote themselves first and foremost as tax attorneys) has to say about himself:

I have a great deal of experience in this area of law. I represented indigent clients in serious felony cases in Washington, D.C. for approximately six years. I then represented indigent Utah clients in federal felony cases before the United States District Court of Utah, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit for approximately five years. I have also served as a Public Defender for the Virginia Indigent Defense Commission.

If I read this correctly, he’s never actually been retained by a paying client for representation.  Well, that could explain things a bit.  Maybe he falls into that trap where indigents are less worthy of being treated like “real clients,” and that good old Utah paternalism kicks in, since Ted the lawyer gets to give sermon to the poor, ignorant, unworthy, morality-challenged indigent defendants.

But if you head over to the main page of his website, you can see that Ted’s not exactly as concerned with ethics and morality as he would have you think.  Here are some pieces of the Ted Weckel puzzle:


I am a highly educated lawyer with a great deal of courtroom experience.

I practice in the following four areas:  family law, tax litigation, criminal defense, and bankruptcy. 

Some people wonder if it is better to hire a lawyer who “specializes” in one area of law, rather than choosing a practitioner who is well versed in a variety of subject areas. Actually, it is unethical for lawyers to advertise or represent that they specialize in an area of law. [My emphasis again]

Now, were I not such a gentleman, disinclined to disparage people for being hypocritical, arrogant pissants, I might write something unsavory about Ted’s character.  After all, has he not just puffed the virtue of his being a criminal pretender while stating (not suggesting, but stating) that people who actually do criminal defense are unethical for saying so? 

But that’s not the way I wish to approach this fellow who the Utah State Bar promotes as a paragon of legal ethics by virtue of his displacing defense with a passion play.  Instead, I would merely suggest that he’s probably not the sort of lawyer that I would want representing any person accused of a crime.  And you thought Utah was a weird state before.

Is Home Safer Than The Street?

Following up on the  right to left alone on the street comes this far more egregious case, involving an intrusion into the sanctity of the home.  Thanks to reader Kathleen for bringing this Fourth Department decision in People v. Alfonzo Perez, 

Now the Fourth Department isn’t known for fawning over defendants or being all that worried about silly liberal stuff like constitutional rights, at least not when it comes to cops taking down bad guys (or doing pretty much anything else, for that matter).  But it looks like they have finally drawn a line that even cops can’t cross.


The conviction arises out of an altercation with police officers who were investigating the origin of loud music emanating from defendant’s apartment building. When the first two officers arrived at defendant’s apartment, defendant opened the door a crack and stated that he had just gotten out of the shower and was not wearing any clothes.

Let’s stop here for a moment and consider a couple of things.  First, the court characterizes this situation as an “altercation”.  That’s an interesting choice of words, since the defendant is inside his own apartment and the cops go to his door.  While there may have been a struggle at the end of the arrest, that doesn’t serve to change the initial basis for the police action.  Notably missing is any finding that when the cops arrive at his apartment door, they hear loud music.  No music?  Then what are they doing there?  And you probably thought I was going to talk about his being naked at the door, didn’t you?


Defendant initially refused to give his name in response to repeated inquiries from one of the officers, and he then gave a name and date of birth for which a record search revealed no matches. When the officers advised defendant that his neighbor had given them defendant’s name, defendant initially replied that he did not need to give his name but soon thereafter provided his correct name and date of birth. When one of the officers informed defendant that he was under arrest for criminal impersonation, disorderly conduct and obstructing governmental administration, defendant attempted to shut his door. A second officer grabbed defendant and pulled him from his apartment.

This part of the findings has more things wrong than any paragraph in a decision I’ve read in a long time.  But the one that strikes me as most amazing is that they barred the defendant from shutting his door and pulled the defendant out of his apartment. 

To the exten that the defendant affirmatively “did” something wrong so as to annoy the cops sufficiently for them to decide to make your evening unpleasant, it was the heinous act of giving them the wrong name.  Put aside the fact that Perez had no obligation to give them any name, and consider whether this was reason enough to engender such ire in the police.  Not that pissing off cops, in itself, is a crime, but for those inclined to believe that anyone who does something evil deserves whatever consequences follow, does giving the cops a false name justify this arrest?

Homes have a special place in criminal law.  There are certain lines that can’t be crossed, and one is the threshold to the home.  If Perez is within his home, and the cops have no warrant, that’s where Perez stays.  Absent certain exigent circumstances, pulling a person out of his home so that he can be arrested just isn’t permitted.

While the appellate court reversed the defendant’s conviction for resisting, criminal impersonation, obstructing government administration and assault (which comes from a struggle after Perez was pulled out of his home), this case is hardly a shining example of the law working well.

Bear in mind that this case doesn’t reach the appellate courts until after the defendant has been convicted.  That means that a case that should have been tossed out at arraignment made it all the through the system, and to appeal, before anybody seemed to realize just how many things went wrong.  

Adding insult to injury, it appears that the defense lawyer blew it, as appears from the failure to preserve the issues for appeal, reached only by the court’s willingness to consider issues under its extended “interest of justice” jurisdiction, rarely exercised anymore.  That means that the court believed this case to so ridiculously outrageous that it wasn’t going to allow it to stand.

While the 4th Department decision doesn’t discuss it, it would appear that the wealth of issues presented here were simply neglected or ignored by defense counsel.  While that doesn’t excuse the lower court judge from dealing with glaringly unlawful conduct by cops, or convicting someone for acts that aren’t unlawful, it does make it somewhat more comprehensible when defense counsel fails to do his job.

While Perez should be happy that the half-dozen charges against him were dismissed, the fact that it took an appellate court to end the nightmare that started with a knock on his apartment door, with him inside his home, demonstrates the huge gap between the rhetoric of the right to be left alone and the reality of what happens when a police officer decides that your going to do what he says.

Next time, he should just check his peep hole first and leave the door closed and locked.

Vermont Juror Roundup, Or Else

Thanks to Susan Cartier Leibel, host of today’s fantastic Blawg Review, this story from the northern hinterlands of Yankee spontaneity, Vermont, proving it’s dangerous to walk the streets.  No, not crime afoot, but a wacky judge bent on filling out a jury pool.

According to this story, Judge Harold Eaton Jr. wasn’t satisfied with putting together a jury pool the old fashioned way, so lacking enough jurors for his upcoming sex trial, he sent deputies into the streets of St. Johnsbury to round up some more.


Caledonia County Sheriff Michael Bergeron and three uniformed deputies stopped people on a sidewalk in front of the post office, asking if they lived in the county. Those who did and were 18 or older were given a summons to report to the courthouse.

That will teach them for using snail mail. 

Now most people will jump through hoops to avoid jury duty, despite the fact that all lawyers know how thrilling it is to sit in a seat, day after day, and listen to lawyers talk for hours.  But what do you do when you’re walking along, minding your own business and some uniformed fellows with guns ask you a question?  I bet these good folk of St. Johnsbury wished they had read my post about being left alone.

Apparently, they succumbed to the badge, admitted their residency and were immediately summonsed for jury duty before Judge Eaton.  It’s funny, except the summons were real.  You have to wonder if they thought Allen Funt would pop out at any moment and tell them to “smile”.

Over defense counsel’s objections, the judge filled out his jury pool. 


According to [Sheriff] Bergeron, “99.9 percent were just excellent” about being summoned.

I’m sure they were all just thrilled to have their lives disrupted, without any opportunity for preparation to clear their schedule of whatever activities and responsibilities that ordinary people have, to be commandeered into jury service.  Most people would just love the opportunity, right?  I wonder who these find Vermonters will blame when they think of the problems this kidnapping has caused them.  Oh, maybe the miscreant defendant who’s demand for a trial forced them onto a jury a theoretical gunpoint?



REAL ID: We Know Who You Are

It was inevitable.  I’m only surprised that it took as long as it did.  But courtesy of Congress and Homeland Security Czar (and New Jersey’s snappiest dresser) Michael Chertoff, the REAL ID is now . . .real.

The point of the REAL ID is to link the various databases available state by state, across the nation, and provide all information to the feds.  This has long been a goal, to know everything there is to know about anyone at the push of a button.  And here it is.

It’s impossible to think about the REAL ID without hearing the words, “show me your papers” from some old WWII movie, in your head.   Jonathon Turley goes into this pretty deeply, so there’s no reason for me to do it again.  Suffice it to say that those of us old enough to have sat at our father’s knee to hear about the Nazis would never have believed that those words would be spoken in our very own country.

But it’s been coming for a while.  Even before 9/11, which simply provided the excuse to do all the things that DOJ had been pining for in the decades that preceded.  It was just too tempting, know that all this great information was being collected and there was no way they could get their hands on all of it.  Oh, the power in all the information.  Power that could be harnessed for good, since whatever they did was, by definition, for good. 

Of course, there was once a time when you could travel anywhere in the United States without ever having to show identification to anyone.  When I started as a lawyer, there was no such thing in New York as a bar card, like other jurisdictions adopted, or the secure pass, as we now have.  Eventually, there was an attorney ID, but it was so cheesy that Times Square hucksters used to laugh at it.

The feds have an ingenuous scheme to force this down the throats of the States who might otherwise be inclined to listen to Publius and flex their anti-federalist muscle.  You see, the feds can’t force states to turn over their databases, but the feds can make life for residents of states that refuse so unbearably miserable that the pressure will be overwhelming.  As Chertoff explained, “in instances where a particular state doesn’t seek a waiver, its residents will have to use a passport or a newly created federal passport card if they want to avoid a vigorous secondary screening at airport security.”  Vigorous, as in cavity searches perhaps?  But Chertoff is truly a populist. 


The last thing I want to do is punish citizens of a state who would love to have a REAL ID license but can’t get one,” Chertoff said.

Chertoff doesn’t want to disappoint the cheering throngs, desperate to get a REAL ID of their very own.  Is this a man of the people or what?

The notion of someone asking me to identify myself to get on a plane to go to California was ridiculous.  I’m an American.  I can go any darn place I want without having to answer to anyone.  That’s my birthright.  That’s what it means to be American.

We used to be taught that in school.  I gather it hasn’t been taught in quite some time, as it’s no longer in vogue.  And no longer true.  Today, real American’s proudly show identification.  Real American’s empty their pockets and walk barefooted through the magnetometer.  Real Americans have nothing to hide.

The question posed, of course, is how this is happening when our President, and his high public officials, no longer have total control over the government.  There’s that crazy Dem woman, Nancy Pelosi, in charge of the House.  Why didn’t she put a stop to this madness?

Welcome to the nightmare of politics.  This is what I’ve been saying all along, that while our fears and concerns about what Karl Rove and Dick Cheney think is best for the country may be overwhelming, we’ve failed to notice that the Democrats are merely Republican Light.  They’ve been trying to out-tough the Reps on crime for almost two decades, even since Michael Dukakis got Willie Horton’s face shoved down his throat.

Our friendly Democrats smell a fragrant victory in the air, and when they have their people in place, they want as much power, if not more, than our overly-paternalistic Republicans.  Remember the line item veto, dangerous in their hands but wonderful in ours?  Our House Dems consider this a parting gift from the Republicans, who will take the heat while they get the juice. 

And so, we note the passing of another of our American birthrights, the right to go anywhere in these great United States without anyone having the right to demand that you show them your papers.   We would also mourn the death of personal privacy, but we’ve been on death watch for so long that we can no longer muster the tears.

What If The Second Amendment Does Apply to Everyone?

Liptak is back with  a piece about the pending Supreme Court case of District of Columbia v. Heller, where the court is poised to decide, maybe once and for all, what the second amendment means.

As passed by the House and Senate:


A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed.

As circulated and ratified by the States:


A well regulated militia being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the People to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed.

Note that there are difference in punctuation and capitalization.  Whether this was intentional, or just a quirk of the time, remains something of a mystery.  Regardless, at some point we need to move beyond a few hundred years of squabbling and decide what right our founding fathers gave us. 

To illuminate the issue, Liptak turned to none other than our dear friend, libertarian icon and learned colleague, Eugene Volokh, for succor:


Many state constitutions have clauses that say why various rights are guaranteed. In an article surveying them in the New York University Law Review in 1998, Eugene Volokh concluded that the fit between purpose and command is often loose, “casting doubt on the argument that the right exists only when (in the courts’ judgment) it furthers the goals identified in the justification clause.”

While he soft-pedaled the sell, his point is clear.  The precatory phrase doesn’t limit the right.  Ah, if only he was as sanguine about the Fourth.  Of course, this has become the prevailing view of the second amendment by scholars, liberal and conservative alike.

Consider what the implications are for a second amendment that provides a right to “keep and bear arms.”  There would be no crime of simple weapons possession.  Bulges under the arm of men in suits would be commonplace, and the new status-symbol might be a pearl handled revolver.  Louis Vuitton would make holsters.  Rappers would carry diamond and platinum weapons, while street hustlers would have to chose between gun metal and chrome, deciding whether it’s better to show it or hide it.

There are a lot of angry people around these days, and they might be inclined to use a gun when someone annoys them, even if it’s just because they won’t give them a bag to protect their newspaper. (read this link to the NY Times Magazine; it’s hysterical.)  Road rage offers so many weapons opportunities that I wouldn’t know where to begin.

And consider that the Second Amendment, though always discussed in terms of guns, doesn’t limit itself to guns at all.  It speaks to “arms”.  Will swords become part of the well-dressed executives uniform?  You have to admit, there is something about a beautifully-made sword that is quite alluring.  Or perhaps kids will take up sling-shots, hanging from their back-pockets like Huck Finn.  Certainly school rules prohibiting weapons, part of that zero-tolerance policy that keeps embarrassing school officials and creates confusion amongst students who learn about citizenship but are so often denied the ability to exercise it, will need to be revisited.

There aren’t a lot of gun shops around my neighborhood.  The few that exist are frankly pretty drab and unattractive.  I guess they really didn’t need to gussy themselves up to attract the walk-in crowd for that spur-of-the-moment Glock purchase.  But the court’s decision in Heller could change everything.  Do you hear that sound?  It’s opportunity knocking.  Or maybe just a snubby firing a few rounds at the guy who made an annoying right on red.

OT — A Post-Consumer Utopia

Part of a segment on 20/20 the other night was about Denmark, because it was the place where people were happiest in the world.  One of the factors cited was that it was a post-consumer society, where possession of “things” was inconsequential in terms of personal prestige and hence self-worth. 

As I was driving around yesterday, noting yet again that everyone on Long Island is required to drive a car worth nearly as much as a house in most other parts of the country, where Mercedes Benz, BMW and Range Rover were de rigor for anyone aspiring to someday be middle management, I was struck again by the absurdity of the status conscious. 

What a source of unhappiness these things bring people.  As a lawyer, I get to hear some of the sordid details that hide behind the facade of relative success.  People struggling to keep up the payments on their baby Benz or maxing out their credit cards to put a Rolex on their arm.  All to show their neighbors or colleagues that they aren’t losers.  Mind you, it isn’t to prove success, because having the same thing as everyone else just places you in the pack, not above it.  But to not have the accoutrement’s that are deemed a necessity is to tell the world that you are the loser of the group.  No one wants to be a loser.

As I drove my Toyota Prius (because we’re “green”), I passed a Ford Taurus.  It was an old one, looking pretty shabby.  Mind you, it was an ugly car in the showroom, and it clearly didn’t get better with age.  It stood out like a sore thumb amidst the shiny European SUVs and sports cars surrounding it.  But it drove well enough to keep up with traffic.  I assume that its driver found his way home safely.

One of my neighbors, a gentleman (in the old-world sense of the word) from an old and well-known family, who had inherited substantial wealth and did quite well with it on his own, once invited me to join him at his country club.  It was a club where I would not be allowed to join, and I accepted.  He picked me up in an old, amorphous looking Buick.  After putting my clubs in the trunk, I kidded him about his car.  Couldn’t he afford to get himself a nice little Bentley to cruise around in?

He smiled at me broadly.  He told that this car wasn’t his, but his wife’s (who happened to be a scion of the Rockefeller clan), though his car was no newer or more prestigious.  So I asked again why he didn’t drive a “better” car.  He laughed and responded, “because I don’t have to.”

This quest for prestige is killing us.  No one ever wins the battle.  At least not for long.  There’s always someone bigger, better, richer and possessed of a toy you don’t have.  But the struggle to keep afloat is killing so many people, dragging them down, engulfing them, to no avail.  This is the arms race with bling.  Forget the TV commercials, does your wife really love you more because you drive a BMW?  Would owning a Porsche really make you look taller, slimmer and younger?

Our consumer-driven society is not making us happier, but it is sucking the life out of so many people who struggle beyond their means to find self-worth in material possessions.  Having just posted about how a law degree is not the guaranteed engine to wealth, I wonder how many lawyers don’t want their clients or in-laws to think they are unsuccessful and put on airs that their practice can’t justify. 

For the sake of sanity and happiness, I hope this society can grow beyond this in my lifetime.  Until then, I repeat to my children the words my courtly neighbor told me whenever they ask me why I won’t buy them some ridiculously expensive, and utterly inconsequential, trinket.  Because I don’t have to.  I hope they understand.

Auctioning Professional Misery on eBay

This post by Susan Cartier Leibel (who will be hosting Blawg Review tomorrow!) at  Build a Solo Practice has been staring at me for a few days, challenging me to write something.  It’s about a fellow named David Wold who went to DePaul University law school and ended up miserable and deeply in debt.  He decided that he would  sell his law school diploma on eBay as a means of openly announcing his disenchantment.


Why am I selling this great item? Because it has been nothing but a curse and aggravation in my life. Going to school for this degree has been a joke, and has only brought me stress and misery. This degree has been a great invitation to work at least 60 hours a week at a place where I don’t want to be for people that I don’t care about. It has helped me develop great relationships with bill collectors as I can’t afford the cost this great privilege has afforded me. It has limited my ability to pursue other work options as people just can’t understand why someone with a law degree wouldn’t want to be a lawyer. Believe it or not, the extensive job dissatisfaction amongst lawyers, high suicide rates, and failed personal relationships that lawyers have isn’t enough to convince others that it’s not a healthy, worthy pursuit. And of course even if I would be happier as a bartender, I couldn’t afford to pay back the loans needed to earn this degree. Though that’s true of many that I graduated with. Individuals that wanted to practice law for the benefit of the poor or impoverished or those who can’t afford legal counsel are having a hard time too because they aren’t paid enough. But that’s justice.

The reactions to this were varied; some called him a self-defeating whiner, while others called him greedy because the auction price was $100,000 (as if someone was really going to pay that).  While the latter characterization is silly, the former is more disturbing.  He’s hardly wrong about his personal life choice because you disagree, and the protest itself shines some light on the compulsive defensiveness of the profession. 

Susan was sympathetic to this fellow, as am I though for different reasons.  Susan felt that his anguish might be different if he was taught in law school how to strike out on his own in solo practice.  Perhaps, but I doubt that’s his real problem.

There is quite a bit of truth to what David Wold experienced, and the fact that he chose eBay as the venue to protest is fascinating.  It’s one of the most visited sites around, and touches a broad spectrum of people.  More importantly, I thought it was an effective way to make his point, auctioning off his diploma. 

But the most important thing about this protest was the lesson it carries for inchoate lawyers who may have little clue what they are getting into.  Too many extol the virtues of being a lawyer, while too many are deeply disappointed with this career choice and find themselves stuck with a profession that they despise and that fails to keep the promise of a decent social and economic life.  

Many find being a lawyer decidedly unfulfilling, so what’s wrong with telling people that up front?  Is it that we’re lawyers, so we have some duty of loyalty to project the image of happiness and virtue?  Frankly, there are very few lawyers I’ve met in 25 years who don’t question their decision to become a lawyer.  Even the Biglaw ones, who have all the trappings of success and none of the pleasure of a good life.  And the solos, who wonder every day whether the phone will ring again.  And the ones who believe in helping others, who watch innocent people go to jail and guilty people rat out their mothers, and wonder why they are a part of this system of pain and unfairness.

Who doesn’t think about what his or her life would be like if he or she had made a different choice?

There are lawyers who love what they do, make excellent incomes and feel that there was no better choice for them than the law.  I don’t mean to suggest that all lawyers are miserable, and I’m sure that some who read this will say to themselves, “that’s ridiculous. I LOVE being a lawyer.”  That’s wonderful, but your personal happiness doesn’t mean that everyone else must share your feelings.  To deny that many are unhappy is just silly.  The profession has its issues with job and lifestyle dissatisfaction, and these issues are huge.

My sense is that many young people who go to law school have little idea what they are in for.  They don’t really appreciate what lawyers “do”, limited to some vague sense from television or movies, or perhaps envisioning the prestige of the lawyer on some news magazine.  They want to be a “professional”, whatever that means to them, with the implicit promise of wealth, security and respect.  They hear the many and varied platitudes of the glory of the law, and want to be a part of a system that exists to protect these virtues of fairness and integrity, to help the downtrodden achieve justice. 

My introduction to the “problems” of the law came as a law clerk while going to law school.  I worked for an old-time criminal lawyer, who treated me like a son in many ways.  He had achieved a fair degree of financial success and had a pretty decent practice, good enough to need me as a law clerk.  But he was nearing 70 years old when I started, and he was tired.  Even at 70, he was never sure if tomorrow would bring a new case and thus revenue.  He wondered aloud he really helped or hurt society, or meant anything at all.  He loved his children dearly, and regretted horribly having missed so much of their lives while fighting everyday to earn enough money to satisfy his wife’s need for prestige.  This was not the profession that my mother told me about.

Like many, it was too late for me to turn back.  I was committed to becoming a lawyer, and I was no quitter. Besides, it would be different for me.  I learned a few things from my mentor, the most important of which is that when not on trial, I leave my office at 5 and go home to dinner with my family every day.  But much of what I learned as a law clerk couldn’t be changed.  It was the life of a criminal defense lawyer.  It was the life I unwittingly chose.  It is hardly a perfect life.

Three years and one hundred thousand dollars later, David Wold learned that the law provided him none of these.  He’s not alone.  Every young man and woman who thinks they want to go to law school should read what David Wold had to say.  Some will eschew it.  Some will embrace it.  Some will think twice about going to law school.  And they should.

Paul Cassell: Victims are Second Class Citizens

Former federal judge Paul Cassell, who left the bench to become a Utah lawprof and crime victims rights advocate, lost a big case, according to Sentencing Law & PoLicy.  Thank God.

Professor Cassell also criticized the broader implications of the ruling today: “Unfortunately, the Tenth Circuit today has continued the sad legacy in this country of making crime victims’ second-class citizens in the criminal justice process.  The Circuit refused to give crime victims the ordinary appellate review that other litigants receive.”

That, dear lawprof, is because they are NOT litigants.  Forgive me, as I was probably unclear in the last sentence.  Crime victims are not parties.  Crime victims have no role to play in sentencing.  Was that more clear?  I do hope so.

In this particular case, Cassell’s clients, the Antrobuses, sought to speak as victims at the sentence of a guy who sold a gun to another guy who killed their child 8 months later.  The court refused to allow them victim status under the Crime Victims Rights Act, 18 U.S.C. § 3771(d)(3), which brazenly panders to the sympathetic victim and family in order to dissolve the fundamental purpose of separating the criminal from civil legal systems.  Yes, I said it, and I mean it.

It’s that whole rational sentencing scheme that puts the brakes on taking the defendant and cutting him into little pieces and feeding it to pigeons, one of the many potential sentences favored by victims.  We all know too well what thoughts can pass through a victims head, even for petty offenses.  We understand why, and can appreciate that we would all likely have the same thoughts if we are the victims.  This is why they don’t let victims decide the sentence.  We already know they are victims, and that the criminal conduct results in victimization.  That’s why it’s a crime.  That’s why people go to prison for it. 

Without harping on this point, Judge Cassell did some great work on the bench, but this crusade for victims is nuts.  It’s wrong and it’s fundamentally destructive to the criminal justice system.  I’ve posted about this  again and again.  I am not unsympathetic to crime victims.  Not at all.  But this is not the remedy, unless what you really want to do is make pure personal, visceral revenge the sole function of the criminal justice system.  It that’s not your goal, then victims have no place whatsoever in the sentencing scheme.  No matter how politically unacceptable it seems, victims are NOT a party to the criminal justice process.

Speaking Ill of the Dead (Update)

Bashman brings an  AP report that the Supreme Court has granted cert in Giles v. California, a post-Crawford case challenging whether the statements of a murder victim can be admitted into evidence, since the defense cannot cross the deceased.

There has long been an exception that where a person has been murdered to prevent his or her testimony, the defendant cannot gain the benefit of the intentional act of murder to preclude the testimony.  But this case involves no such claim of murder to preclude testimony.  Rather, it’s a straight out murder case.  The court in Giles held that regardless of this distinction, the words of the deceased can be used against the defendant.

Societal norms tell us that we can’t speak ill of the dead.  It’s offensive and paints the speaker as inhumane and despicable.  That’s fine when it comes to cocktail party chatter, or talk around the water cooler, but it presents a problem in court.  When the dead speak to the jury, it carries unbearable weight.  It is devastating.  And there’s nothing you can do to change this.  Even when the dead person wasn’t exactly a saint, she somehow becomes less assailable in death than she ever was in life.  Rest in peace.

What’s wrong with this?  A lot.  The testimony comes in through a third person, the party to whom the dead person’s words were allegedly spoken.  Assuming, arguendo, that the witness isn’t fabricating the words of the dead person, or enhancing them for affect, they are only there to say that the words themselves were uttered.  They cannot bring the context, what preceded the speaking of the words outside the third person’s presence or what happened after, to the witness stand. 

Nor can a third person expound on the dead person’s motive for speaking the words.  Was she angry, and exaggerating when she spoke for dramatic effect?  Was she trying to elicit the support and comfort of the third person, thus leaving out her own role in the underlying context that would have put her in a bad light?  Many of us tell our stories to our friends in such a way that we look better than we deserve.  After all, we aren’t under oath and we are speaking to a buddy.  Who says we can’t spin things for our own benefit in ordinary conversation?
 
But all of this is outside the reach of the defendant when the witness who uttered the words doesn’t testify.  The entire purpose of cross-examination, to test the truthfulness, the accuracy, the implications of affirmative testimony, is lost when the only breathing person is a third person. 

Given Crawford, the question turns on whether the “right” (and I add that the government has no “rights”, just authority) to present this damning evidence trumps the defendant’s constitutional right to cross-examine witnesses.  But how can the Supreme Court rule against the use of this evidence, acknowledged by all to have some hugely sympathetic component that just makes it feel so every wrong to keep it out?   There will be outrage across the nation at such a heartless ruling, characterized as coddling criminals, encouraging murders and preventing justice. 

But we know why the right decision is to preclude the admission of evidence that is not subject to cross-examination.  Every lawyer who has ever tried a case where the defendant was tainted by hearsay, admitted through the zillion backdoors that exist for the purpose of convicting despite the law, knows the impossible situation this evidence creates.  Every honest judge knows that by letting this testimony in, she’s enabling a conviction that couldn’t be won on proper evidence.  And every time this happens, we all know that the real purpose, rhetoric aside, is to guarantee that the ‘bad guy” gets convicted, no matter what.

As much as I may be subject to Gideon’s slings and arrows for writing this (as he accuses me of being obsessed with Justice Antonin Scalia, although I’m NOT), my best hope is that the champion of Crawford will step up again to make the unpopular, but legally correct, decision that the Constitutional right to confront witnesses prevails over the resort to sympathy and appeal to prejudice. 

Update:  Linda Greenhouse in the  New York Times speculates that the court will rule in favor of permitting the statements of the victim to come in:


It is therefore likely that the justices accepted the new case, Giles v. California, No. 07-6053, to make it clear that as long as the victim’s unavailability as a witness was a foreseeable consequence of the murder, the Sixth Amendment does not require the state to prove the actual motive for the murder was to make the victim unavailable.

Her reasoning stems from a portion of Crawford’s author’s subsequent 2006 opinion relating to admissibility of statements where the intention for murder was to prevent the individual to testify,


Defendants who “seek to undermine the judicial process by procuring or coercing silence from witnesses and victims” would forfeit the protection of the confrontation clause.

Frankly, I don’t think she gets the distinction.  The author, who shall remain a nameless Nino, will most assuredly be able to appreciate the distinction.  I trust he will.