Author Archives: SHG

Make Room in the Well For Paul Cassell

Judge Lawprof Utah Lawyer Victims Rights Advocate Conspirator Paul Cassell has made his debut at Volokh, and what a heart-warming reception he’s received.  After a hearty “welcome aboard,” they are ripping his lungs out through his derrière.

What?  You thought that the libertarians were going to change their stripes?

Paul (boy, calling an ex-judge by his first name comes really hard) posts about his defeat in Antrobus, which I posted about here.  Mind you, he didn’t lose the appeal of his clients’ (victims twice removed if you enjoy primogeniture as a means of clarifying relationships) purported right to present their views at the sentencing of the man who sold the gun that was later used to kill their daughter.  It’s that his side was so clearly, utterly wrong. 

But Paul is still pushing the “victims as second class citizens” argument, which falls a little short of Johnny Cochran quality as a promotional mantra.  It’s just not that snappy.

There are many responsive comments to Paul’s position, most taking issue with his facile characterization.  But there’s no comment that amuses more than this one:





SupremacyClaus (mail) (www):


Mr. Cassell:

Your title misleads and insults the intelligence of the public. You represent survivors, untapped, potential lawyer customers. The victim is deceased and took all rights to oblivion, courtesy of the criminal, the pal of the criminal lover lawyer. You propose a thinly disguised pretext to increase lawyer employment. Period.

If you wanted to reduce victimization, you would not advocate an explosion in legal procedure. You would advocate an explosion in the death penalty, to reduce the number of vicious predators by attrition.                                                                                                                    1.16.2008 1:38am


In fairness, Eugene has blocked SupremacyClaus from posting comments there anymore.  Apparently, even Volokh has lines that can’t be crossed.  Seriously, this comment does not reflect either the attitude or level of thoughtfulness of their readers, so don’t assume that this is the norm.

Frankly, I think that most people are still being fairly kind to him, despite their polite challenge to his primary concept that the victims are equal partners in the criminal justice system.  Of course, as someone pointed out, even if they get to speak, it’s not like anybody has to pay attention to them.  But hey, that’s his position and he’s sticking with it.

It may prove quite a shock to Paul Cassell to find what life is like when you aren’t wearing the robe.  No more obsequious lawyers kissing butt, laughing at your jokes, caring what you think.  This is the rough and tumble world of disembodied ideas and loose talk.  So let me add my voice to the chorus:  Welcome to the blawgosphere!

DOJ: Still Disingenuous, But At Least Amusing

Now that our Government has taken the position that felons are no longer people, which could save a small fortune on medicaid since only people get sick, the DOJ has moved on to address its newest and latest problem.  Bandwidth.

It seems that the government is just a tad short, and is forced to cut  Talking Points Memo from its press release distribution list.  Darn, if only they could scrape up an extra kilobyte.  But alas, the last one is all used up and none left for TPM.

They used to get PRs from DOJ, and then one day they didn’t.  So being good citizens, the duly contacted the DOJ to find out why they are no longer on the list.  This is our government’s response:

I appreciated your desire to be in tune with DOJ press releases, however, unfortunately I am not able to add you to our distribution list. As you may realize we have a lot of requests to be put on our media lists and we simply are not able to put everyone on the list. We do however have all our press releases on our website and update them the minute they are released so I would suggest looking there. You can also always call us with press inquiries. Thanks again for your interest.

Sincerely,

Jamie Hais
Press Assistant
Office of Public Affairs
Department of Justice


Maybe if we all chip in, say a dollar, the DOJ can buy some more bandwidth and add some more emails to its distribution list?  Did I mention that TPM has, on occasion, said negative things about the Department of Justice.  It may have slipped my mind.  Sorry.

H/T Orin at Volokh, who has never asked to be on the mailing list but gets stuff anyway.

Biglaw Loves a Star

It’s got to be awfully dreary working in the coal mines of Weil Gotshal & Manges.  Why else would they turn to such a bigtime, important, major television personality to spruce up their event.  According to Above The Law, this white shoe powerhouse of a law firm is bringing in none other than the beautiful, fabulous, brilliant Star Jones to their January 22nd “Diversity Reception” so that their lawyers can bask in her reflected glory.


Star Jones Reynolds Above the Law blog.jpgWEIL GOTSHAL & MANGES — INVITATION TO DIVERSITY RECEPTION FEATURING STAR JONES


Please join us at our diversity reception for first year law students next Tuesday, January 22nd! Please also note that the time for the reception has changed to 6:00pm to 9:00pm.


Our guest speaker, Star Jones, will be arriving at 6:00pm to mingle, so plan to be there early! Further details are below.


For those of you who cannot view the JPEG, here are the details for the event:


Location: STK
Date: Tuesday, January 22, 2008
Time: 6:00pm – 9:00pm
Special Guest Speaker: Star Jones of truTV (formerly Court TV)


RSVP by Friday, January 18 to [xxxx] or (212) 833-[xxxx]


[xxxx]
Legal Recruiting Coordinator
Weil, Gotshal & Manges LLP
767 Fifth Avenue

And you thought you were missing something by not being a tier 1 student and Biglaw prospect (other than a few hundred thou in salary)?  It doesn’t get much goofier than this, kids.

But here’s the real question.  Will there be another memo coming out requesting that all attendees only speak in one syllable words and make no mention of “gastric bypass” or her makeup choices?  After all, it would be rude to make their high-profile guest feel unwelcome.

Book Review: Snitch by Ethan Brown

Snitch. Informants, Cooperators & the Corruption of Justice is a title that has to bring a smile to a criminal defense lawyer’s face.  We certainly talk about rats enough, so  Ethan Brown’s new book,  published by Public Affairs, on one of our favorite subjects was a natural.

Ethan comes at writing from the perspective of rap culture, which made me wonder, before opening the book, what the breadth of his vision of the underbelly of the criminal justice system would be.  The prologue confirmed my fears, and served to frame Ethan’s idea of the subject matter.

The book begins with the tale of Gerry Shargel representing hip-hop impresario Irv “Gotti” Lorenzo.  My heart sunk.  This is going to be a love-fest with big time criminals, big time lawyers and the rats that ate them.

Snitch: Informants, Cooperators, and the Corruption of Justice


The book got better, however, as Ethan went into the history of legislation, and the politics surrounding it as it happened, that gave rise to mandatory minimums, sentencing guidelines, and the crack differential.  If you weren’t around in those day when Washington found a magic bullet solution for every problem, and invariably involved more crimes and more time, then this part of the book will be quite enlightening.

But the book never provides a deeper understanding of the dynamic of snitching.  There are good guys and bad snitches, which wasn’t how it happened.  For those of us who lived in the trenches through that period, and whose experience extended beyond black hip-hop to Hispanic, Chinese and white drug groups, none of whom are mentioned, this is not merely a one-dimensional vision.  It’s simply inaccurate.

It may be that some of the sources Ethan used in trying to understand how snitching came to permeate the system were more concerned in promoting themselves or their personal agenda.  Criminal defense lawyers are notoriously bad at providing honest and accurate information, since spin is in our blood.  But that’s where a journalist’s instincts should kick in, digging below the obvious personal agendas to get to the meat of the subject.  It seems as if Ethan liked his sources too much to question them, or look beneath their self-serving positions.  To use a lousy pun, it just wasn’t that black and white.

Nowhere does Ethan recognize the role that snitch lawyers played in creating the CI culture, or why defense lawyers chose to be part of the problem.  There’s no discussion of how it spiraled out of control in a dizzying, geometric decline, as more and more defendants started racing for the United States Attorney’s door.  The feel of despair caused by one defendant in a multi-defendant conspiracy retaining a rat lawyer, and the others, his erstwhile brothers in arms, first denying that he would ever flip, and then coming to terms with reality, one by one, that there was no way out.

Much of the problem is that the stories Ethan tells, while some quite interesting, tend to be geared for either the hip-hop lover or at least those who want to read about the more sensationalist cases.  Where are the chapters on conspiracies, the major weapon in the prosecutors’ arsenal?  This is where snitches wreaked the most havoc. 

Another glaring omission is the prisoners’ dilemma.  What about the people sentenced to monumental prison terms who then had to figure out a way to see daylight again by a Rule 35 motion?  They ratted inside, they talked about anyone and anything that ever happened (or didn’t happen), they had their friends do constructive cooperation outside, all to have a glimmer of hope of ever seeing the street again.  People who swore they would never snitch collapsed when facing the rest of their lives in prison.  What about these people?  Nothing.

In terms of making a point, Ethan eschewed the ordinary, everyday stuff to focus on the bling, the big names.  If his point was to capture the Us Weekly reader, then maybe this makes sense.  If his purpose is to produce a book that captures the phenomenon of snitching, it’s birth, growth and impact, then these were the wrong examples to use. 

For the lawyer, this book is worth reading only for its discussion of the law, although it is framed in a way that the non-lawyer would understand, leaving it somewhat superficial from a legal perspective.  Still, it covered all the bases, included quite a bit of the political “back-story” and provided a good primer on how we ended up in this mess.  Ironically, the end of the book discusses Booker, and it’s failure to move federal courts away from the sentencing guidelines. This, of course, has since changed. 

As for the anecdotes, Snitch offers little of interest to a lawyer.  The stories, while involving well-known cases, are not terribly deep or engaging and, frankly, somewhat pedestrian to any criminal defense lawyer with some experience. And if you’ve ever done the “big case,” or any case for that matter, you know that there’s more to the story than meets the eye. It’s not that Ethan doesn’t come out on the right side, but that he planned to get there from the beginning and took the easiest, quickest route. 

Unfortunately, the best part of Snitch, Informants, Cooperators & the Corruption of Justice is the name.

Political Cynicism Close Up

We indulge in political cynicism on a national level because it’s just a fun pastime without really having any personal knowledge of whether candidates mean what they say or are just pandering for a vote.  By the way, I don’t subscribe to Oscar Wilde’s definition of a cynic, “a man who knows the price of everything but the value of nothing,” but rather the fear that some people are motivated to deceive by selfishness. No matter how much we read or hear about national candidates, we don’t really know any of them.

One of my weekly local papers printed a story on its front page about a fellow I know (his name is unimportant) who has announced that he wants to form a coalition to do something about high taxes.  Why this, under any set of circumstances, would merit a front page story is curious, but it is particularly fascinating under the particular circumstances.

A while back, there was a rumor that one of Nassau County’s political parties was looking for a new candidate who they could mold into a contender for the county legislature.  The word was that they needed someone inoffensive, but sufficiently malleable that the person could be easily controlled and manipulated to do the party’s bidding.  Obviously, he could neither be too smart nor too principled, but he would have to be easily flattered so that he want an important position befitting someone of his “stature”.  Oh yeah, and he needed to have enough money to pay the freight.

Wow, did they ever pick the right guy.  A nice enough fellow, well intended, but thick as brick and utterly incapable of understanding a principled position.  He was the sort who extrapolated his financial success in a very peculiar niche business to generalized brilliance, living proof of the Dunning Kruger effect.

With the complicity of the local editor, a story about this fellow appears one day to create the appearance of a deep, abiding concern for the welfare of others because of high taxes.  Now, high taxes have been a monumental problem for 25 years around here, but this fellow has inexplicably discovered it now.  He announced his intention to form a “non-profit” coalition (as opposed to the “for-profit” kind?) of various professionals to come up with a solution.  Of course, the education and skills he seeks for his coalition serve to highlight the fact that he possesses neither. 

But what gives rise to the most virulent cynicism is that this fellow, in a very minor elected position, when he bothers to appear for a meeting (an infrequent occurrence), when he has read anything in preparation for the meeting (an even more infrequent occurrence), and when he has shown any capacity to understand the rather obvious issues at stake (more on the level of a stopped clock), has shown an utter lack of concern for wasting taxpayer money.  “Cost?  Oh, who cares.  Whatever. They can afford it.”  After all, it’s not like it’s his money that he’s spending, right?  No, but he doesn’t even get the connection with wasting money and that he pays taxes too.  I told you he was thick.

And so, the party has started to create a persona of intelligence and caring that is so fundamentally at odds with reality as to make those of us who know this fellow laugh, long and hard.  It’s absurd.  It’s ridiculous.  It’s a total lie.

But it may well work.  You see, only the people who know the truth know the lie.  To everyone else, this fellow will be whatever the story makes him out to be, no matter how crazy it is.  Reality is perception, and creating perception is what sells candidates to a public hoping for someone to come along and deliver on promises of hope and goodwill.

Because I know the person, I know the fabricated persona to be an outright fraud.  But I don’t personally know anyone running for President.  This frightens me greatly.  How many articles like the one in my local paper went into fabricating the persona that now bolsters our candidates? 

Cautious Praise For Solo Practice

A pervasive theme in the blawgosphere is that solo practice is the answer to so many of the ailments of the legal profession.  Indeed, there are a number of blawgs dedicated exclusively to this theme, promoting the virtues of solo practice as the cure for the malaise of employment.

In criminal defense, most practitioners are solo, or at worst small firm (meaning less than 5, as opposed to the New York “boutique” definition of under 100 lawyers).  For us, the solo versus firm differential has little meaning, as there are few law firms of any size that are dedicated to the practice of criminal defense.  There is Morvillo Abramowitz, the closest thing I know to a white shoe firm doing criminal defense, but they are an anomaly.  And look what happened to Martha Stewart.  I could have lost her case for a fraction of the cost (but I wouldn’t have).

The reason why solos prevail in criminal defense is that our clients seek the representation of a particular lawyer, not a firm.  While some white collar defendants, whose thought processes are impaired by their overwhelming fear and limited comprehension, think that representation by amorphous big firm lawyers somehow provides them the “resources” that are worth the price, they invariably come to realize (usually right after the sentence) the error of their ways.  Oops. Too late.

So the praise of solos is generally directed to civil practice, since there’s no need to argue the point to criminal defense lawyers.  While the issues confronting the solo civil practitioner may well be different from us, I have often wondered whether we share a few of the same concerns.  Upon reading some recent commentary, I believe we do, and in the spirit of helping those of our civil brethren from being swept into civil practice without their eyes fully open, it seems appropriate to share a few of my experiences in a solo and small firm practice.

The ringing telephone is the most important thing in your world.  Unlike the big firm, where the issue of your next case is spread across a few hundred “rainmakers” and assured by a client roster of major corporations who are always engaged in one controversy or another, there is no endless stream of clients demanding the right to give your firm money.  Do not be fooled by lawyers proclaiming how their marketing produces an endless stream of revenue.  If they are that busy, then they have neither the time nor need to sell themselves to you.

Then there are costs.  Lots of costs.  From rent to library to FICA, there are costs that you, new solo guy, must pay.  When fixing fees, don’t make the mistake of thinking that the money goes straight to the Ferrari dealer.  Do you have a clue what group health costs? 

And it’s not someone else’s problem to tell you of all the obligations that come with being a solo.  Fail to pay your quarterly withholding and you’ll find out.  Somebody has to look at all the bills, make sure they are right, call every customer service representative in the world and become an expert at dealing with voice cues.  Do you think your receptionist is going to run your business for you?  Oh yeah, she has to get paid too.  And she didn’t come in today because her kid is sick.  And the phones are ringing and nobody is picking up.  And when she is in the office, and does pick up, and you overhear her tell someone, “No, I don’t think he does that type of case,” all the blood rushes to your head.

As a young lawyer with a small firm (I had a 2-3 lawyer firm in those early days), there was little issue in mustering the effort to go out and drum up business.  We went out at night to socialize, occasionally in unsavory places (the Willie Sutton rule), and establish personal relationships with the people who would likely need our services.  But that was before children (BC). 

As the confluence of kids, exhaustion and a reduced tolerance for alcohol kicked in, the desire to go out and meet people waned.  After all, one of the primary purposes of being a solo is take back control over your life, and for me that meant having dinner with my family.

As a slightly older lawyer now, I live off the fruits of my earlier efforts.  In other words, the hard work that I put in representing defendants established my reputation as a lawyer, and clients seek me out to represent them.  But at the same time, there are always younger lawyers trying to poach those clients, and in a declining environment of clients who have the ability to retain counsel, these younger lawyers who are undercutting my price can have an impact.  Sure, they are incapable of delivering the quality of representation that I can, but many clients don’t realize this until it’s too late. 

Ironically, I hear constantly from these younger lawyers about their struggle to get clients, and get paid, and get paid a decent price.  They want me to refer work to them, while they are busy convincing clients that they can win their case for a legal fee of $12.73.  Sure, many are pretenders, neither capable nor desirous of providing quality legal representation.  That’s $12.73 flushed down the toilet.  But some are merely desperate for business.  No one told them that there’s no guarantee when you hang out your shingle that the phone will ring.  That’s why I’m saying it here.

The solo solution promoters tell us that clients are out there, just waiting for you to establish a website and blog so they know you’re there.  In support, they offer vague proof of some lawyer practicing some place that you’re not whose phone is ringing off the hook with great cases coming every day.  This may be 100% accurate.  But does that mean it happens for everyone?  Does that mean it will happen for you, if you only take the 3 steps necessary to successful solo practice? I doubt it.

I know a few blawgers who are civil solo practitioners.  They get some work because of their blawgs, but not enough to survive without supplementing it significantly with nights out and a variety of self-promotional efforts.  No one I know (granted, that’s limited to my small circle) is making a killing this way.  And some are struggling.  Some exceptionally good lawyers are struggling.  In my experience, there is no correlation (not little, but none) between lawyer competency and business success. 

Clients are usually clueless as to who are the good lawyers and who aren’t.  They are not equipped to distinguish one from the other, despite what anyone says.  Clients only know outcomes.  Win and you’re good.  Lose and you’re a nice guy, but a loser.  No one wants a loser.

So every solo, whether they are honest enough to admit it or prefer to hide behind a facade of self-promotional bravado, listens for that phone to ring.  Instead of being a slave to the senior partner, you’re a slave to the telephone company.  And every time that phone rings, you pray that it’s a new client with a terrific case who can afford a lawyer.  That’s what solos do.  Don’t say I didn’t warn you.

Another Reason Why Justice Scalia Isn’t the Devil

Some people who sit at the defense table hate Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia.  I don’t, which brings no small degree of disdain of my peers.  Don’t feel bad for me.  I can take it.  But even my arch nemesis in Scaliadom, Gideon, posts something good about him. 

Gideon’s epiphany (okay, maybe epiphany is too strong a word) comes in light of the  oral argument in Virginia v. Moore.  In case you weren’t following, this case is (at least to me) highly reminiscent of the purpose of Whren, an effort use a Fourth Amendment exception to overcome the rational connection between crime, arrest and search.

In Moore, the state (with federal amicus) argued that a search incident to arrest, as one of the seven zillion permissible exceptions to the warrant requirement, is permissible if the arrest was based upon probable cause, even if the arrest was unlawful under state law.  Yes, the same state law that created the crime for which probable cause existed.  Moore (represented by Tom Goldstein of SCOTUSblog) argued that if the arrest was unlawful, then the search incident to it was unconstitutional.

Justice Scalia, for all his despised originalism, engaged in the following repartee:


JUSTICE SCALIA: So any Federal employee can go crashing around conducting searches and seizures?
MR. McCULLOUGH: So long –
JUSTICE SCALIA: So long as he has probable cause?
MR. McCULLOUGH: That’s correct.
JUSTICE SCALIA: That’s fantastic.
(Laughter.)
JUSTICE SCALIA: Do you really think that?
MR. McCULLOUGH: I think if there is State action, it doesn’t matter that you’re wearing a badge or that you’ve gone through the police academy.
JUSTICE SCALIA: Or that you are an administrative law judge at the, you know, Bureau of Customs? It doesn’t matter?
MR. McCULLOUGH: I think that’s right. That if you have — if the State –
JUSTICE SCALIA: What about a janitor? You’re a janitor, a federally employed janitor.
MR. McCULLOUGH: Your Honor –
JUSTICE SCALIA: His neighbor is growing marijuana, and he’s just as offended as a Supreme Court Justice would be. Can he conduct a search?
MR. McCULLOUGH: I think if he’s doing it on behalf of the State, the answer is yes.
JUSTICE SCALIA: Wow.

And that is why I do not think Justice Scalia is the devil.  He gets it.  While he may be no friend of the accused, his intellectual integrity compels him to recognize the absurdity of the position that disconnects the authority to act from the result.  This counts for something.

This is remarkably different from the defendant-hating judge who subscribes to the “ends justify the means” line of reasoning, willing to either ignore the lack of logic behind an argument or bend the facts to reach his goal.  

Now an argument can be made here that even a clock that’s stopped is right twice a day, but that’s just not the case.  Consider Justice Scalia’s  County of Riverside opinion, dissenting from the holding that state’s must bring a defendant before a neutral magistrate within 48 hours of arrest for a probable cause determination.  Justice Scalia opined that prompt meant prompt, not an arbitrary period of time long enough for the police to do whatever voodoo they felt like doing in advance of arraignment.  Justice Scalia would have given no more than 24 hours, and arguably less. 

While we, of the criminal defense bar, frequently find ourselves at odds with Justice Scalia’s opinions, it has long been my suspicion that as the Supreme Court moves into the future, he may well be our best chance at a rational, logic-oriented jurisprudence.  I respect intellectual integrity more than a decent outcome per se, because the former I can count on and the latter is a shot in the dark.  Give me a smart, honest judge, even if generally hostile to my side, rather than a judge whose views blow in the wind.  One I know how to address.  The other provides me with little direction, and can flip on me as easily as side with me.  In reason I trust.

Former Federal Judge Joins Conspiracy

This presents a quandary. Maybe even a quandary and half.   Eugene Volokh has announced the blawgospherical coup of getting former federal judge, now Utah lawprof, Paul Cassell, to join in one of the academic, libertarian longest-running conspiracies on the internet.  Uh oh.  (If I knew he was in play, I would have invited him to blog here.  Nuts).

I’m still trying to process all the problems this is going to cause me.  First, what do I call him?  Is he judge, or lawprof, or just plain old Paul?  It’s my practice to call former judges “judge” as a matter of respect.  But that gives him too much of leg up when I’m constrained to post about why he’s  unbearably wrong about something.  While I can always use some sort of emphasis in oral argument to make the word “judge” sound like an epithet, it just doesn’t work in writing.  What to do?

But this guy wears too many hats.  And to add insult to injury, he’s wearing them in Utah, of all places, where thoughtfulness goes to die. 

Even if I put aside Paul Cassell’s bizarre perspective on the role of victims in the criminal justice process (did I mention that he’s unbearably wrong about that?), this is the same fellow who, as a federal judge in 2004, gave us  Croxford, the precursor to Booker, ruling that the sentencing guidelines were merely advisory.  Doesn’t he get some credit for that? 

And yet, he’s going to blog at the Volokh Conspiracy, the mother-ship of libertarian conservatism (not to mention a blawg with one of the biggest, and yet most pretentious, readerships around).  Speak ill of the Volokh Conspiracy and watch as thousands of words are pointlessly slaughtered. 

So will I feel constrained to defend Paul Cassell or put him in the middle of the cross-fire?  Is he friend or foe?  And I still don’t know what to call him.

Nonetheless, I welcome the Honorable Law Professor Paul Cassell to the blawgosphere, who will certainly bring insight and thoughtfulness, and no small dose of controversial views, to Volokh.  I guess I’m just going to have to deal with it in my typical, courteous and gracious manner.  After all, as everyone knows, I try so very hard to avoid anything controversial or potentially offensive here at Simple Justice. 

It’s the Economy, Stupid?

Not that I’m qualified to render political opinions, but didn’t anyone wonder where all the money was coming from to pay for the war in Iraq all these years?  Didn’t anyone wonder what, with all that money diverted to the war du jour and the United States printing new dollar bills on toilet paper, running up deficits and borrowing like crazy, the impact would be on our economy?
 
We are not producing any products that anyone else buys.  We spend money like crazy.  Saudi arabia owns all the best US real estate, as we ship our money and work to China and India.  It is all part of the same jigsaw puzzle, and just because the American public can compartmentalize each component doesn’t mean that it’s not connected.  Guys, it’s all coming out of the same pockets, and always has been. 

We’ve been killing ourselves economically for years.  So why now are the anti-terrorist, president-admiring, war-loving folks suddenly shocked to find that all the money spent is gone, and somebody has to pay for it?  Worse yet, for those of us who weren’t happy to sacrifice our economic future to “stay the course” with “honor”, we have to pay for your choices as well. 

Freedom is definitely not free.  Unfortunately, now we have neither freedom nor the money to pay the bill.  Nice going.  How about you all now admit you were stupid, slink back into your hole and let somebody else clean up your mess before you do even more damage.

DOJ: Disingenuous on Justice

Courtesy of Doug Berman at Sentencing Law and Policy, and via Grits, comes this little bit of nonsense from our very own government in its amicus brief, trying to have it both ways in Heller.


“the Second Amendment, properly construed, … does not provide any protections to certain individuals, such as convicted felons, who have never been understood to be within the Amendment’s coverage.”

Really?  Not according to Doc Berman:


Notably, the Bill of Rights uses the phrase “the people” in four other Amendments (the First, Fourth, Ninth and Tenth). I have never before heard a claim that all convicted felons are categorically denied the individual rights protected by all these Amendments.  The Fourth Amendment, notably, speaks of the “right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures.”  The Supreme Court has never suggested that individuals, once convicted of a felony, thereafter cannot assert Fourth Amendment rights.

While many non-lawyers (Joel?) may assume that the second amendment right to bear arms applies to everyone, they somehow maintain that once the right is firmly established for themselves and people they like and want to be entitled to carry a gun, they can similarly stop the right at will and draw lines so that the people they don’t like can’t have a weapon.

It doesn’t happen that way.  If it’s a right, it’s a right.  It’s a right for everybody.  It’s a right for you.  It’s a right for those people you think are “bad”.  Why?  Because it’s a right, and that’s how rights work.  When it’s a right, everybody gets to enjoy it and there isn’t a thing the government can do about it.

The old adage is be careful what you wish for, because you just may get it.  The point applies here in spades.  The gun advocates may well have the upper hand on the interpretation of the second amendment, but there is no intellectually sound way to distinguish the application of this right, if indeed it is clearly a right belonging to all individuals, to all those people you would prefer weren’t armed.

In the meantime, the only understanding that I can recall from the Constitution regarding who is, and is not, a person, can be found in the three-fifths compromise.  Does the government plan to go there as well?  Or do they just posit, for the sake of political convenience, the self-serving position that despite a ruling that the second amendment applies to all, they still get to regulate guns whenever it suits them.  Some pigs are more equal than others, I believe Orwell put it.

This will indeed be an interesting decision.  Let’s see our government wriggle out of this one.