Author Archives: SHG

The Right To Be Left Alone

A couple of unrelated posts at  Volokh reminded me of my problem with New York’s love of DeBour, 40 NY2d 210 (1976), a Court of Appeals decision that created a quadripartite test for police intrusiveness.  Of particular concern is the bottom of the barrel, known as a level 1 DeBour stop under the “common law right of inquiry.”


Due to the tendency to submit to the badge and our belief that the right to be left alone is “too precious to entrust to the discretion of those whose job is the detection of crime” (McDonald v United States, 335 US 451, 455), a policeman’s right to request information while discharging his law enforcement duties will hinge on the manner and intensity of the interference, the gravity of the crime involved and the circumstances attending the encounter.

All the right words (except for the use of the word “right” as to police, since the State has no “rights”, only authority), but after providing the feel-good rhetoric, the Court goes into its flight of fantasy where police/citizen confrontations are benign because there’s no gun pointed at the citizen’s head.

The same problem arises in the federal context with Miranda issues when the question posed is whether the subject of interrogation is in custody. 

When a police officer turns his or her attention to an ordinary person and says something, does that ordinary person truly believe that he or she has the right to be left alone?  Can he or she simply keep walking, or turn away, or refuse to respond to the officer’s inquiry?  On what planet?

No one, from begger to Senator (which may not be a very broad spectrum), feels this way.  We all feel constrained to submit to the badge.  No one feels sufficiently bold to elect to ignore the officer and continue going about our business.  McDonald says we can make that choice, but no cop I’ve ever known would let that happen.  And no person I’ve ever seen believes it to be true.

The exercise of our right to be left alone, and this is a constitutional right, exists only in judicial decisions.  It’s never existed on the street or in our cars.  When a couple of cops stops a person on the street and demand that a person identify themself, does anyone believe that it is “merely” a request that they have an absolute right to ignore?  Does anyone believe that if they ignored the request and walked away, that would be the end of it?  Anyone?

Why then do courts continue to decide cases that affect the lives of people based upon premises that every senscient being knows is silly?  The law has become so top heavy is legal fantasies and rhetorical explanations substituting for what happens in the real world that it is becoming increasingly difficult to take stop and search decisions seriously.  For most criminal defense lawyers, they are exercises in judicial slight of hand to find some phraseology that pretends to honor the Constitution while invariably upholding the search.

Usually, the decision goes at its foregone conclusion directly, using language that strains reality by calling the police intrusion “minimal” or consensual, as if people with guns (always protruding from their waistband and readily visible, since criminal gun-possessors are too stupid to make any effort to hide them from the cops) or drugs are happy to show police their contraband for the mere asking. 

But when hard evidence precludes a direct decision, a few wiggly words will sufficiently change the clear facts to enable the court to decide in the cops’ favor based upon some utterly baseless factual scenario that no one believes, or ever suggested, happened.  It exists only on paper in court decisions. 

Non-lawyers (and some lawyers as well) view the factual recitation in court opinions with a child-like naiveté that makes them above reproach.  If the court said something happened, then it happened.  It becomes absolute reality.  Now while it does become legal reality, it bears little recognition with the evidence with shocking frequency.  This is where judicial integrity clashes with the less than principled outcome.  Sometimes, courts can’t decide the way they want without fudging the facts a bit.  It’s a practical solution to a thorny problem.  And after they’ve gotten away with it once, the sense of being hemmed in by facts dissipates and it become easy to justify an outcome based on adding in, leaving out, or mischaracterizing, a few details.

Frankly, I cherish my right to be left alone.  I am not prepared to surrender my right to walk down the street without being stopped or questioned by police for some purpose completely unknown to me.  I would be no more rude to a police officer than I would to anyone else (though I’m not sure how much that means), but I want the ability to simply ignore the cop if I chose to do so and continue on my way.  I do not believe that my refusal to respond would play out that way.  I don’t think anyone really does.

So as we discuss stuff here and elsewhere in the blawgosphere, or in court, let us stop pretending that these rights that exist only on paper really happen on the street.  Who are we kidding?

Death and Dying in the Blawgosphere

I’m beginning to form a deeper appreciation of the struggle that guys like  Kevin O’Keefe go through trying to keep propping this darn blawgosphere up in the face of impending malaise.  Pretty soon, Simple Justice is going to be one year old.  Someone mentioned recently that unlike most blawgers, whose enthusiasm wanes over time until it finally disappears, my posting has only gotten stronger and more prolific. 

In fact, more than a handful have had some fun at my expense about how I manage to post as much as I do.  While I know it’s not meant as an affront, some of the comments question what I do all day long that I have the time to keep up this blawg at the current pace.  What this really means is that others have trouble keeping up theirs, and can’t figure out how I find the time. 

The easy answer is that I just get things done.  Writing comes easily to me, and it’s a pleasure.  It just doesn’t take me anywhere as much time as it apparently takes others.  My work on behalf of my clients always comes first, but there are always a few minutes available to blawg.  It’s just not a problem for me.  In fact, I could easily post twice as much as I do now on quiet days or days when there are a ton of things that strike me as blawgworthy.  I don’t just to keep the rabble from biting my head off for being alarmingly prolific.

But I watch as blawgs that I read daily are beginning to enter the decline phase.  This is a downward spiral, that happens slowly, slowly, until day it dawns on you that the blawg isn’t just sleeping.  It’s passed…

Infusing interest and enthusiasm, as Kevin,  Susan and  Carolyn do so well, must be a tiring job.  I can’t imagine how many blawgs, and blawgers, between them, they’ve seen come on like a hurricane, and then ultimately lose their steam (note the mixed metaphor for pedagogical purposes). 

What am I talking about?  The blawgs that would post every day, or at least every other day, consistently bringing great ideas, or maybe just funny stuff, but creating a sense of vibrancy and community in the blawgosphere.  Then the posts start to slow down.  Every few days.  Once a week.  Two weeks.  Frankly, it more than disappointing, but almost depressing, to go to a blawg and see nothing new day after day.  It’s like looking at the storefronts on Main Street and seeing them shuttered, one after another.

I go back every day in anticipation of finding some bit of genius, only to find there’s nothing new at all.  And the next day.  And the next. And then I don’t go back to look.  And then it falls off my radar. 

In the Darwinian world of the blawgosphere, not everyone will survive.  Not everyone can find the time, or maintain the level of interest.  For some, this is just such tedious work that whatever pleasure came from expression wasn’t worth the effort.   It’s not for everyone.

My comments to Kevin, which he fought valiently though not necessarily successfully to dispel, that most new blawgs will fade into oblivian within a year, are coming to pass.  But I’m not talking now about the self-promotional blogs.  I never gave them a lot of credit because I doubted that these erstwhile bloggers would find the outcome sufficient to justify the effort.  But the practical blawgosphere people, the ones who post for fun and love about real things.  Some are drifting off as well, and I hate to see this happen.

But if there’s nothing on your blawg for a few days, a week, longer, then what am I to think?  If you don’t mean to blow this off, then get off your duff and get back to blawging.  Besides, I miss you guys.  Who else can I make fun of someone who isn’t close enough to hit me?

Laws and Rulings That Embarrass Real Americans (Updated)

From Bashman’s How Appealing, this  AP report on the reversal of a $400,000 jury award to man baselessly removed from a plane by the 1st Circuit in Boston.  Stories like these, even more than the myriad of criminal case improprieties, make me realize just how sorry and pathetic this country has become.

John Cerqueira, a naturalized U.S. citizen born in Portugal, was taken off an American Airlines flight from Boston to Ft. Lauderdale in December, 2003.  Also removed were two Israelis seated in the same row, though having no connection to Cerqueira.  State police cleared him, but they still refused to let him board. 

Remember, this was 2003, and arab terrorists were going to destroy America every day.  We feared anyone with a swarthy complexion, and as long as it didn’t involve us personally, America was 100% behind getting anyone with darkish skin off our planes as fast as they could.  It was an ugly and foolish way to run a country, and so very typically American.

So, Cerqueira sued and won a judgment for $130,000 in compensatory and $270,000 in punitive damages.  Justice prevailed?  Not today.

According to Judge Lynch writing for a unanimous Circuit,

“No properly instructed jury could return a verdict against the air carrier,” Circuit Judge Sandra Lynch wrote in the decision issued Thursday. 

Under the Air Transportation Security Act, the three-judge panel ruled, carriers are permitted to turn away passengers who might be “inimical to safety.” Because the crew must decide such matters quickly, it said, “even mistaken decisions are protected so long as they are not arbitrary or capricious.”

Was this arbitrary and capricious?  Let’s cut to the facts as set forth in the decision:


Flight Attendant Two told the Captain that she perceived the man in the ponytail [one of the Israeli men who had piqued the Captain’s interest] was traveling with the two other men in the row, one of whom was the plaintiff. Regardless, the Captain said it was not important from his perspective whether or not the three men were traveling together: “[I]f people are trying to harm the aircraft or anyone on board, they might be traveling together, they might not be traveling together.

So being assigned a seat in a row with somebody else who appears suspicious, in airlinethink, means it’s okay to toss the whole row off the plane?  Sounds like brilliant reasoning to me.  But there was more.

Flight Attendant Two also expressed her concerns to the Captain about the plaintiff. She described an incident she had with the plaintiff in the terminal. She told the Captain that this passenger, the plaintiff, had been hostile to her.


Hostile?  Well, he asked to have his seat moved to an exit row, and according to the flight attendant, he was very hostile and insistent.  Worse yet, he stared at her and made her feel uncomfortable.  And if that’s how the flight attendant feels, you must be a threat to national security.  Omitted from the decision were comments by Flight Attendants 4 and 5 that he dressed funny and had bad breath, “breath like a terrorist.”

This issue of the extraordinary power given to flight attendants and airline personnel, who would otherwise be working the lobster shift at McDonalds, is one that should really disturb everyone.  Say you’re not entirely cheerful and smiley to the pregnesone-stressed woman snarling “good morning” at the door, or giving you orders to allow the 357 pound person in the next seat share half of yours, and you happen to have a decent tan, she can make your life shockingly unpleasant.  You see, inside that plane she owns you. 

Sure, she has neither the training, judgment nor temperament to appreciate the consequences to you of her choices, but she doesn’t give a rat’s butt about you.  She’s the protector of the American way of life, and she does that by tossing off the plane anyone she doesn’t like.  Because you are “hostile”.  That’s what it means to be disliked, and hostile means anyone who doesn’t do exactly what she says.  Too bad they don’t give stewardesses tasers.  We could really have a party.

But enough about the flight attendants.  Once again, we have a court and a Constitution.  The only thing standing in the way of rightful compensation is a law by Congress that empowers airlines to be wrong at our expense.  Yet, there’s still a breath of hope, because airlines cannot be arbitrary and capricious.  Arbitrary alone, fine. Same with capricious.  But not both together.

So what did Mr. Cerqueira do exactly to justify his removal from the plane?  Two things:  Skin color and the stewardesses comment that he was “hostile”.   Sounds a little like arbitrary and capricious to me.  I guess it sounded like that to District Court Judge William G. Young, who was criticized by the Circuit for not dismissing the case.  Apparently, it sounded that way to the jury as well.

From a different angle, who exactly do I speak with when I want to complain about the exercise of power by the employees of private corporations who are empowered by government and courts to make decisions and take actions that have a significant negative impact on a person’s life?  Police may not be above the law, but American Airlines flight attendants are?  Pilots are unreproachable?  Since when are the judgments of pilots better than anyone else?

Since when are courts so deferential to private individual decisions that any rhetorical explanation that includes an inkling of potential fear sufficient to trump the rights of individuals?  What country does this?  Ours.

Update:  And like clockwork, Overlawyered chimes in to pray at the corporate alter of how unfair the world is to its patrons, as the “verdict of $400,000 says a lot about how justice seems proportionality unfair and unmeasured.”  I’m sure a $50 voucher and a free lunch would have more than adequately compensated the plaintiff, per the American Enterprise Institute’s guidelines for True Justice For Patriotic Corporations of America.

Answers to Pop Quiz

Yesterday, I  posted the questions raised by David Giacalone at  f/k/a about lawyers and pop culture, and asked what anybody else thought.  Not one stinking comment.  Not one.  Plenty of people read the post, and not one person was willing to respond.  What a buch of weenies.

Perhaps this question, important enough for David to ask and worthy enough for me to repeat, didn’t interest anyone else.  Fine.  Be that way.  It’s your loss, because David’s question is not only an important one, but one that should stir a bit of thought amongst the lawyeratti, especially the young guys like Malum and the scotch-swilling, bow-tie adorned, gun-toting Young Shawn.  What was wrong, boys?  Did all that thinking make your heads hurt?

Despite the apparent lack of interest, this is an issue that real lawyers who try real cases should be highly concerned about.  The relationship between our job, making facts and their implications clear to people with diverse cultural understandings and influences, is huge.  Ignore it at your peril.

I recall a case where my defense theme fit perfectly with the movie, Looking for Mr. Goodbar.  I mean perfectly.  And so I plotted out my themes and researched and put it all together in my head, and then . . . it dawned on my that this was a movie from 1977.  1977?  Would any of my jurors have been born yet?  The likelihood was that I would have a few who would understand and appreciate the theme, if they could still remember stuff despite their advanced years.  But I would have a few who would be utterly clueless as to the meaning of my theme.  It was be a miserable failure.

What we think of ourselves, and of lawyers, and of defendants, and of cops, means nothing.  We don’t get to vote in the jury room.  What they think, on the other hand, is critical.  Meeting their expectations, or missing them as the case can be, is the silent death of our case in the back of their minds. 

So I know what I grew up with for lawyers and cops and witnesses.  I know what my expectations of evidence and investigations would be.  But I don’t think I reflect the norm these days.  I have a teenage daughter and I’ve seen MTV.  That world is totally foreign to me.  And frankly. pretty disgusting.

I similarly avoid the legal and cop dramas on TV.  I don’t watch CSI or Law & Order.  I know many do, so they won’t miss me.  But it’s not what I want to do with my free time.  But many jurors do.  And if it’s on TV, it must be true. 

That said, here’s David’s questions.

• Are jurors “influenced” by popular culture representations
of law and lawyers?

Absolutely.  What other basis would jurors (or anybody) have to know anything about the law? 

• Do lawyers and judges think that jurors are being influenced
by popular culture representations?

As I am the authorized spokesperson for all lawyers and judges everywhere, I answer by noting that the ever shifting paradigm of popular cultural representations of law, in all its emanations and penumbras, inherently influences the intrinsic outcomes from a normative perspective, given its pedagogical underpinnings.  In other words, how should I know?  I assume most would think about it if someone pointed it out to them, but in the grand scheme of things, popular culture probably doesn’t come high on the list of influences lawyers and judges lose sleep about.  Except immediately after OJ and when the case involved high tech evidence.

• How does the influence of popular culture representations
change the legal system?

If it dawns on us, as it did to me in my Looking for Mr. Goodbar example, that I can make use of popular culture to further my case, then it can have a significant influence on what I do.  In a more macrocosmic way, it brings little change.  But the problem isn’t with pop culture, but systemic resistance to change and its institutional love of stability.  One huge example of change is the Supreme Court’s use of a video, and subsequent placement on youtube, in Scott v. Harris.  What were the chances that Scalia hangs out on youtube?

Of course, what judges wear under their robes today, as opposed to 50 years ago, may disclose a lot.  The only think I know is that  some judge in Milwaukee who still sports a pompadour isn’t ready to wear an ascot.

But if a lawyer goes into battle without an understanding of the pop culture that influences his jurors, as one of the many factors that form our jurisprudence, then he’s not doing his job.

New Ideas Must Be Wrong

Nassau County District Attorney Kathleen Rice just can’t catch a break.  Granted, she road the coattails of Tom Suozzi into office, having brought little to the table on her own and evoked the wrath of everybody in her office in first 7 minutes in office.  But that doesn’t make her a bad person, does it?

Well, putting the hate aside, Newsday has run  a series of articles about her new initiative to try to put a stop to rampant low-level drug dealing in Hempstead.  After capturing numerous people selling drugs in an open air market, cops rounded the bunch up and brought them to a meeting at the African-American Museum.  There, she told them that they have two choices, either clean up or go to jail.  These weren’t those nice, clean, sympathetic first time dealers, but people with prior convictions, violent background and sociopathic issues.


There are stipulations. It’s a one-time offer for the suspects, who have previous arrests and face prison terms ranging from a year in jail to life in prison. And they had to show up last night to accept the terms of the deal at a town hall meeting at the African-American Museum in Hempstead, Rice said

Rice offered fast-track access to a broad array of services, from education to drug treatment to psychological therapy.  One would think that the community, upon hearing of this liberal’s dream, would go after her with torches and pitchforks.  But that’s not at all what happened.  Instead, she was attacked by criminal defense and civil rights lawyers.  Notably, Fred Brewington complained that this was racist, because it started in a black neighborhood.

Marty Tankleff lawyer, Bruce Barkett, was even more strident:


[F]requent Rice critic Bruce Barket, another Garden City defense attorney, said there “ought to be an investigation on how these individuals were selected and why other individuals were not included.”

“It’s an outrageous abuse of power,” he added. “It was not a rational approach to a systemic problem.”

How dare this prosecutor help people rather than prosecute.  Bruce’s idea of an outrage is, well, broad.

But Rice didn’t dream this plan up on her own.


David Kennedy, professor at New York’s John Jay College of Criminal Justice, developed the anti-crime strategy while at Harvard University. He said the program targets violent drug markets, which happen to be in neighborhoods with minorities.

“It is a reality that those drug markets that are public, out of control, violent and most destructive to the community, are in troubled minority neighborhoods,” Kennedy said. “That’s not racism; that’s a fact.”

Whether this program will work is hard so say.  It’s one of those things that may well sound better in theory than it pans out in practice.  But does it not include so many of the things that we have long sought to attain for defendants?  Treatment.  Education.  Therapy.  And no prison.  How did this suddenly because an “outrage” because it came with the blessing of the District Attorney?

And unforuntately, the hard fact is that the program started in Hempstead because there just wasn’t an available open-air drug market on the north shore to use as an example.  And finally, if we keep harping on the fact that old strategies have failed, then we have to consider, if not embrace, new ideas.  This knee-jerk rejection of a potentially beneficial new idea is not merely silly, but it reduced its detractors to hypocrites.  Grow up and give it a chance.  It may actually work, but even if it doesn’t, it’s a step in the right direction.

Ped’ Proof: Voir Dire is Voodoo

At the end of each day at ITAP, lawyers put on a demonstration of what they students will be doing the following day to show them how it’s supposed to be done and provide some inspiration.  Today is voir dire day at Cardozo Law School, which means that yesterday was the demonstration of how to pick a jury.

The mechanism used was interesting.  It was a mock state court jury selection (since there’s no point in ever doing a mock federal court jury selection), with twelve students in the box.  They filled out questionnaires in advance, which already takes it outside the realm of normalcy, though the questionnaire asked the typical questions that the judge would ask during the preliminary examination, so it didn’t change reality too much. 

Two attorneys, both experienced lawyers who were recognized for their expertise in voir dire did the heavy lifting.  Each was given 15 minutes by the judge (a real Supreme, by the way, but one disinclined to abuse lawyers in general, and certainly not in front of students).

Afterward, they engaged in what Barry Scheck announced would be a “pedagogical exercise,” mostly because it would be undignified and too understandable to call it a teaching exercise and because he clearly liked using the word “pedagogical”.  Who doesn’t?

Each of the lawyers then listed on a piece of paper his three peremptory challenges and the three jurors he would most prefer to have on his jury, and why.  The students then wrote down which side they leaned toward after voir dire and why.  First the lawyers, then the students, told the room their thoughts.

Because  Anne Reed is never far from my thoughts, I stuck around for the demonstration to see others do voir dire and learn.  And learn I did.

The voir dire was artful.  Beautifully crafted and masterfully executed.  The student/jurors were relatively cooperative.  They were responsive and articulate.  While I’ve had judges who put more than the basic 12 in the box, including one who required us to voir dire 45 at a time, the scenario was sufficiently close to reality to simulate a real voir dire.  The only material difference was that the “jurors” were all law students, a homogeneity that would never happen.  On the other hand, my last few Manhattan juries were made up mostly of lawyers and investment bankers, so the breadth of opinion wasn’t that far off the mark.

Before getting to the fun part, allow me to cut to the end.  Barry telling the students how the demonstration showed the way one conducts voir dire, open ended questions, eliciting the potential jurors hidden biases, getting the sense of who favors or disfavors your side, and how one strives for an impartial, rather than a favorable, jury since the other guy is going to bump the ones you like, while you bump the ones he likes, and you end up with a jury in the middle.  Not quite an Anne Reed level of sophistication, but certainly the common wisdom.

The exercise in pedagogy was enlightening.  Everyone involved was half right and half wrong.  Everyone.  Decisions were made for speculative reasons or no reasons.  Assumptions were made that were dead wrong.  It was no better than flipping a coin.  Despite the picture perfect exercise, these experienced and competent lawyers picked jurors on a wing and a prayer.

The one theme that came out of it was that they might have had half a chance to get a clue what was happening in the students minds if they only had more time to question them individually, and follow up answers from one juror with questions to the others.  But in 15 minutes for 12 jurors, they learned nothing that made the process accurate.  Would a half hour have helped?  Doubtful.  Perhaps a 3 hours would have been enough time, but after 16 minutes the jurors were getting annoyed. 

When I think about the many and varied ideas that jury research has to offer, I keep trying to plug it into what happens in a courtroom in a normal criminal trial.  I have often said, and have always maintained, that all this effort to refine what we do in voir dire to gain insight where we have none is an exercise in futility.  It all sounds great, but it just never seems to work out the way we think it should. 

Thanks to this teaching pedagogical exercise, my confidence in voir dire is restored.  It’s still just voodoo. 

How To Explain A Low Grape Point Average

I was interviewed the other day for a publication, Inside Higher Ed, about the Lisa Dan Rittenhouse case that I had blawged about here.  The piece comes out today to discuss the conflict between inclusion for learning disabled students and the role of law schools as gatekeepers of the profession.

My concern is less with the specific individual involved as it is with the inherent conflict and how schools understand what their role is and what it should be.

My experience is that both sides in this situation tend to have a “take no prisoners” perspective.  The LD side demands free access and accommodations regardless of its implications for the future.  The schools, on the other hand, can’t be bothered looking outside the box to understand that nature of learning disabilities and what they can do to educate students who may make great lawyers but have some problems with the nature of law school.

One of the questions that I was asked, but never made it into the article, was whether an inability to perform well in law school indicated that the student would be unable to make a good lawyer.  My response was, what makes you think the skills needed to survive law school have anything to do with being a lawyer.  It may be what we do, but it’s a huge and unwarranted leap to assume that there’s any real correlation between the two.

Lawyers Place in Pop Culture

David Giacalone at  f/k/a raises the interesting question of how pop culture influences the perception of the law and lawyers, and what we should do to deal with it.

The issue arises via lawprof James Elkins, who


challenges the “reality critique”— the supposition by some legal scholars that law as portrayed on screen inaccurately represents law, lawyers, or the “legal system.” He also claims that “we know far less about the effects of popular culture on law and lawyering than we would like to think we do.”

So David posits a few questions to some blawgers:


Although I’m admitting sloth and avoiding commentary these days, I’d like to hear what blawggers — such as Anne Reed at Deliberations, Dan Solove at Law & Humanities Blog and Concurring Opinions, Anne Skove at Court-o-Rama, and Scott G-r-e-e-n-f-i-e-l-d of Simple Justice — have to say about some of the issues raised by Jim Elkins:


• Are jurors “influenced” by popular culture representations
of law and lawyers?
• Do lawyers and judges think that jurors are being influenced
by popular culture representations?
• How does the influence of popular culture representations
change the legal system?


Notably, Mr. Sloth Giacalone punts to others without offering his own finely honed views.  I know what I think, and plan to get back to this tomorrow, right after I hear from what others here think.

So, is pop culture a real influence on what we do and how we’re perceived?  Consider, for example, the “CSI Effect.”  Do we all want to secretly portray ourselves as Atticus Finch (without sharpshooting skills, unless you’re in Texas)?

By the way, if you want to know why David spelled out my name, it’s to make sure I appreciate that he got it right this time, because he has this awkward tendency to call me Greenberg (like my mother used to do).

ITAP: Great Kids, Students and Lawyers

Today was 8 hours of doing the summations in two cases over and over.  And over.  They don’t pay jurors enough.

My stint on the Intensive Trial Advocacy Program (ITAP) faculty started today, teaching law students at Cardozo.   There are a bunch of heavy hitting lawyers and judges from around the country who show up for a two week intensive trial advocacy program.  Plus me.  And apparently the guy who was teaching with me today, who (despite his bravado) has never actually tried a case based upon his “advice” that would have been great if there was no such thing as rules of evidence.  As someone today explained to me, there’s a different between moron and liar, but it doesn’t preclude someone from being both.

This year’s experience has been terrific so far.  The students are brilliant.  The worst kid in the room gave a good summation, and improved markedly by the end of the day.  The best was spectacular in the morning, and nothing short of brilliant by the end of the day.  It was exhilarating to watch.

Last year’s experience was not quite as pleasant.  The students weren’t serious.  They goofed off, didn’t know their stuff and would not take it seriously.  When pushed, they whined.  Why I wasted my day was beyond me.

There is a secondary aspect to this program because of all the lawyers who gather as faculty.  You get to see friends that you haven’t seen in a long time, and meet new lawyers who you have heard of but never had the chance to meet.  Some are civil litigators of some renown.  We even had a Texas federal judge wearing cowboy boots. 

When you put all those lawyers into the same room for coffee or lunch, a funny thing happens.  One person called it the “big dick” syndrome, with each male lawyer swinging his to show whose is the biggest.  Oddly, the women lawyers just sit back and laugh, feeling no compulsion to show how important they are.  The men, well, let’s just say that there’s no one in the room who could legitimately take an oath.  If you believe the stories, every lawyer in the place has better cases, bigger clients, higher fees and knows everybody who’s anybody everywhere. 

Me?  I guess they just keep me around for comic relief and to have somebody who will spent time teaching the kids.

One of the funniest aspect is that the faculty are instructed not to tell war stories.  Imagine all the testosterone lawyers with an audience full of young eager students who can’t tell them to shut up or walk out.  The war stories would never end.  And the students would never get to do anything.

One of the lawyers I was working with today kept saying, “I know we’re not supposed to tell war stories, but . . . ”  It was a nightmare.  First, his stories sucks.  Second, he spoke very slowly.  He was, as Seinfeld would say, a slow talker.  And being collegial, as faculty are supposed to be, I tried not to be rude and remind him that the time lost to his stories was gone to me forever.

For any  lawprofs who read this (and I know you do), this is a terrific program.  It’s run by Barry Scheck and Ellen Yaroshefsky at Carodozo, both terrific people.  I’m sure most of you know Barry from the Innocence Project.  The students come out of the program, if they take it seriously, with at least a working knowledge of what happens in a trial and the basic skills to perform each function.  It’s a huge leg up on being a trial lawyer.

We’re back tomorrow for advanced cross, one of my personal favorites.  I hope I get some killers kids again tomorrow, because I couldn’t be prouder of the kids I worked with today.  They will all make great trial lawyers someday, and the one student who was the best of my bunch today, will be scary.  He was that good.  I just hope he doesn’t go to work for the government.  What a waste that would be.

Are They All Bad?

It struck me that we tend to post about all the negatives, whether it be judges, prosecutors or cops.  And the primary posts elicit comments that drag the story even further down, suggesting increasingly worse, more nefarious conduct and motives by all involved.

Are they all that bad?  We need them.  We need them all.  And not merely for the cynical reason that without cops, prosecutors and judges, we wouldn’t have any job to do and couldn’t earn a living.  The same cop who might wrongfully arrest someone today may have saved the life of some child yesterday.  There are, as post after post here shows, problems.  But that’s not the full story.

We, champions of proportionality and fairness, need to maintain a more even keel.  Since I will be teaching at the ITAP program at Cardozo Law School today and tomorrow and won’t be around, I want to make this an open thread for posting about the positive social utility of our system. 

There are good cops, prosecutors and judges.  There are good things done by cops, prosecutors and judges.  No?  Let’s try to go positive for once, and let’s bear in mind that there’s something out there that keeps some of our beloved clients from breaking into our homes at night.  This is your chance to show that they aren’t one dimensional.  And neither are we.