Mike Cernovich has returned to revive Crime & Federalism. Apparently, there was some truth to the rumor that Mike’s unexpected hiatus from blogging was just to mess with Norm Pattis’ head, so that Mike could take over as Chief Curmudgeon. Mike’s explains, “I was so lame.” No you weren’t, but we can’t wait to see what you’ve got to say now that the gloves are off.
Lisa Solomon at The Billable Hour has launched a great new way to waste yet more time in your otherwise busy day, by watching the funniest of lawyer moments at The Video Venue. I’ve added it to the sidebar here (though only the criminal law pieces so that you would be able to get some work done instead of spending all day watching lawyer stuff. Go visit Lisa and see what else is available, and if you need gift to give those smiling lawyers in your life who send you work, check out The Billable Hour (which may soon be renamed “The Flat Fee” given the impending demise of the former) for fun and appropriate lawyer gifts.
Young Shawn Matlock, Republican, has not been seen recently around the Blawgosphere, making some wonder whether the rumors that he’s in rehab are true. They are not. He simply used up all of his allotted words, and has since gone to Iowa to assist Mike Huckabee in explaining his thoughts on the subject of Mormons.
Head conspirator, Eugene Volokh, has announced that his blog was the lead vote-getter in the ABA Blawg 100, Ivory Tower category. He writes, “Query what that means, but we’ll take it.” Uh, no. You posted about it. To take it, you didn’t have to do anything.
Meanwhile, at Overlawyered, where they ran a desperate last minute plea for votes in the ABA Blawg 100 Beauty Pageant, lost.
Simple Justice came in 6th out of a field of 10 in the Crime Time category. Woo hoo!
Author Archives: SHG
A Reasonable Doubt at a Reasonable Price
Gideon asked, The right to a jury trial: Can you afford it?. This is one of the most painful questions, because it presents the inherent conflict between our desire to serve our clients and the fact that criminal defense lawyers, like everyone else, earn our living this way.
The simple answer is that many clients scramble to make the retainer, generally a flat fee to pay for representation up to a fixed point in the case. The practice of breaking up the fee is usually a sound one, since most cases don’t go to trial and it would improper to charge for services that are neither rendered nor needed. But at the same time, my practice is to include the costs for trial in my retainer agreement, both to alert the client as to what he has to look forward to as well as give him the information up front so that he can appreciate the costs associated with his choices. This can, and does, scare away some clients. Honesty can often do that, but it’s my way and I’m sticking with it.
But it would be a lie to say that the cost of going to trial, particularly when considered in light of the fact that there is never a guarantee of a favorable outcome after trial, enters into the defendant’s decision-making process. It has to. It is a huge factor. It sucks, but there’s no way to ignore it.
There have been times when a client, or his wife more likely, will look me in the eye with a steely stare and tell me, “you better win for all this money we’re paying you.” This is the look that I hate, because I will not lie about it. You pay for my time, experience and effort. There are no guarantees. I won’t be baited into lying about trials. They are always a roll of the dice, no matter how good, smart or caring you are.
Trials are expensive. Not the trials that happen in an afternoon about whether you were driving 72 in a 55 mile zone, but trials where you could end up convicted of murder and spend the rest of your life in prison. These trial take substantial preparation, and noting, but nothing, else happens when you are on trial except the trial. They become your entire world.
Some are over in a week or two. Others go on for months. That means that there will months when you don’t take on any new cases, don’t work on the cases you already have, and pray that your other clients will understand that you will show them the same undivided devotion when it’s their turn to go to trial. But there is a cost associated with this dedication. I am not a public defender. I do not receive the same paycheck whether I’m on trial with you or doing arraignments. This is how I earn my living.
I would like to be so bold as to say that I feel no guilt about the trial fee. That wouldn’t be quite true either. I realize that for normal people, the cost of a trial seems astronomical. Sure, corporations may not blink at tossing a mill or two into a trial, but real people don’t have that to burn. This money comes out of the pockets, their homes, their children’s inheritance. It may be the difference between a reasonably comfortable life and putting themselves into debt. It has a big impact.
Is that the lawyer’s fault? Perhaps, since if the lawyer would only cut them a break, they wouldn’t have to pay it. But then, the lawyer too is entitled to earn a living. It’s not his fault that there’s a prosecution requiring an attorney. He’s just a person delivering the services needed by the client. He works for a living. There’s no sin in getting paid for your services.
But these arguments dance around Gid’s primary question, which is whether people can afford a trial, as guaranteed them by the Constitution, when it comes with a price tag that they can’t, or won’t, pay. Implicit is the fact that these may be wholly innocent people, who are unable to afford the tab. The alternative is the guilty plea by the innocent, a commonplace reality that judges refuse to accept since it reduces the system to a farce. We wouldn’t want that, now would we.
It is not entirely uncommon to find that a defendant shows up for trial with no money in his pockets. He’s paid his way up to that point, but when time comes for trial, the cupboard is bare. He gives you that sheepish face, his feet shuffling, and then he says the magic words, “but I ain’t got no money.” This is the criminal defense lawyers’ nightmare. When we take our fee up front, it is not (as some cynics would have it) because we want to get paid before we screw the client, but because we never want to find ourselves in this position. Most people don’t mean to screw the lawyer, it just happens that way. Stuff happens, despite the best of intentions. But the lawyer gets screwed nonetheless.
There are so many problems that arise from the client’s inability to pay the trial fee. The cost of experts cannot be paid. Investigators are gone. Exhibits cannot be produced. Research fees can’t be paid. These are all for the clients benefit, and they all cost money. The unfortunate truth is that the lawyer can’t finance the client, and if the client has put himself into a bind by committing to something that he is unable to do, then everything collapses around him. This is a disaster for all involved. After having lived this experience a few times, I have sworn to never be in the position again where this can happen. Again, some potential clients view this as harsh, but that’s because they refuse to see the potential for disaster down the line. As a lawyer, I cannot indulge in such fantasies. I have an obligation, and I also have bills to pay.
You really nailed the conundrum on this one Gid. I wish I had a better answer.
When The Investigation Is The Cover-Up
So the CIA destroyed video-tapes of “harsh interrogation techniques” (lest anyone use the word torture to describe torture). We know it now. But pretty much everybody in the world who had any say about such things in Washington knew about it in 2003. The White House knew. Congress knew. The CIA lawyers knew. As did the good men and women who run the Central Intelligence Agency. How they managed to keep Bob Novack from spilling the beans, I don’t know.
So naturally, Congress has to start an investigation, since there’s nothing they like better than a foregone conclusion. But my old friend, Michael Mukasey, has joined in the fray by appointing a special prosecutor, John H. Durham, a senior prosecutor in the District of Connecticut.
Now I don’t know anything about Durham, except what Norm Pattis tells me. Norm says “Durham is a tough as nails prosecutor who has earned a reputation for ferocious and determined advocacy.” I believe him. And that means that if one supports the concept of an independent prosecutor in this instance, John Durham would be the guy you would want.
But I do not believe that the solution to all problems Washingtonian is an independent prosecutor. In fact, I believe that this situation is one where a criminal investigation by an outsider is just what the CIA doctor ordered. It’s not that Durham would be inclined to sweep anything under the rug. It’s that these investigations tend to miss seeing the forest through the trees. They focus on individual wrongdoing. That’s what criminal investigations do.
And so I predict that the investigation will identify a handful of individuals who will be hung out to dry as the villains who destroyed the videos of “harsh interrogations,” who will be dutifully punished. And then, we can all go grab a beer and bask in the glow of kinder, gentler CIA. This is not my idea of a good outcome.
My issue with this new scheme is that the handful of individuals who were directly involved in the destruction of the tapes are not what went wrong here. These individuals were the fingers, connected to an arm, connected to a body, directed by a mind to do the dirty work. Cutting off the fingers will not alter the evil that remains in the mind.
The destruction of these videotapes, following upon advice and admonitions by nearly everyone else in Washington to not destroy them, was an institutional decision. The CIA is a spy institution, and inherent in its culture is secrecy. That means when they do something that us ordinary folk aren’t supposed to know or believe happened, they make it disappear. That’s what the CIA does.
What this incident has taught us is that there is no one in Washington who exerts control or influence over the CIA. It exists independent of everything else American. It makes its own decisions and executed them. While the CIA may believe that it does so for the benefit of the country, and in furtherance of the American way, by disconnecting itself from the control of the three branches of government that we were under the impression ran the United States, they have become a rogue agency.
And that’s my issue. The investigation will necessarily direct its focus at a few of the trees that were involved in some direct, provable way, to the destruction of the videos. These people are likely to be good soldiers, doing what the institution of the CIA directs and expects them to do. Given the nature of their work, this is hardly a bad thing. The CIA does lots of shifty stuff, and every country needs an agency to do their dirty work.
But the problem here is that the CIA, even while doing its country’s dirty work, needs to answer to someone. The tape destruction showed that it didn’t, and doesn’t. That’s an entirely different problem, and no criminal investigation, even by a prosecutor as tough and honest as Durham, is going to be able to touch the real culprit. So the CIA will go free and some poor spooks will fall on the sword. And the United States of America will still have a rogue agency in Washington, except that next time it will be smarter than to let everybody know what it’s up to.
There’s No Arguing With “Sua Sponte”
The American system of law is putatively adversarial. Not that it encourages the use of well-aimed weapons, unless one possesses deadly weapons in a battle of wits, but that one side makes an argument and the other gets an opportunity to challenge it.
The reasoning is simple. Since we can’t see into the minds of others, we don’t know what they are thinking unless they give it voice. At that point, we have an opportunity to correct, question, challenge or punt, as the case may be. There is supposed to be a parry and riposte, so that each side has a fair chance. Fat chance.
In this pathetic decision, via Appellate Law & Practice, an en banc opinion in Moore v. Com shows how the court can outsmart an attorney (like that takes a lot of brains) through the simple mechanics of raising an issue sua sponte (latin for “on one’s own accord”). It was not enough that there was a prosecutor against the defense, the court had to get in the game as well.
In this decision, the court seized on an error in the appellant’s brief, where he used the wrong legal standard of probable cause in framing the issue of whether a traffic stop was lawful, rather than the standard of reasonable suspicion. Rather than addressing the merits, in its search for fairness and intellectual integrity, the court found the perfect means of side-stepping the appeal altogether:
Moore sets forth the wrong legal standard that governs this case and also misstates the law. Whether an officer is justified in making an investigatory traffic stop is not governed by probable cause; rather, the officer’s action is judged by the lesser standard of reasonable and articulable suspicion of criminal activity. … As no appeal was sought or granted on the issue of whether “the officer’s action [was] supported by reasonable suspicion” of “legal wrongdoing” when making the traffic stop, Arvizu, 534 U.S. at 273, “we may not consider this issue on appeal” under Rule 5A:12(c).
According to the court, the use of the erroneous standard divested the court of jurisdiction. Mind you, this wasn’t raised by the prosecution so that the defense would be alerted to its error and given an opportunity to change its rhetoric to the correct legal standard. No, they missed it too, apparently. But not that tricky court. They caught it, and slam-dunked the appeal on jurisdictional grounds. Sorry, Mr. Defendant, no day in court for you.
Mind you, the error in the legal standard used for a traffic stop is (ahem) an incredibly stupid mistake. Criminal defense lawyers work with these standards every day. While their actual meaning tends to float in the breeze, given the limitations of language and the viscitudes of judges, the phrasing of the standard itself is awfully easy. There really isn’t any excuse for appellate counsel to use the wrong standard, unless he was rushing to get the brief done between real estate closings.
But counsel’s dumb mistake could have been corrected by the court, sua sponte, in its decision on the merits. Or, the court could have directed to him to rebrief it using the correct standard. Or, the court could have accepted the standard proffered by the appellant since the respondent neglected to challenge it. But not in ol’ Virginny.
Here’s the deal. When appellate counsel makes a mistake, he loses the appeal. The court considers the argument and, if he’s wrong, he loses. That’s how it goes. Sometimes, the court will pick up on a stupid mistake like this one, and apply the correct standard to the facts, and render a decision based upon the correct application of law. And then the appellant loses anyway. Okay, sometimes not, but we’re working with the odds here.
What appellate courts do not do is divest themselves of jurisdiction because of a mistaken use of the wrong words. S.Cotus nailed it with his succinct commentary:
I think this pretty much shows how we are all fooling ourselves when we claim that “the law” is all about intellectual legal argument and devoid of politics. In fact, this decision is pretty much a case-study of how judicial politics work.
Is he suggesting that the appellate courts of Virginia might be politically antagonistic to defendants, searching for new and imaginative ways to not only beat them back, but slam the door shut hard enough to whack ’em on the butt? Why, I believe he is.
Right, Wrong and Consensus
This post started its life as a “readers’ mailbag,” but promptly shifted gears when I saw where it was heading. The impetus was an email that was sent to me by another blawger, to effect that my posting, besides being prolific, tended to be particularly provocative.
Provocative? I supposed they are, but that’s not my purpose. Rather, my purpose is to say something. I like to read other people’s blogs. They give me ideas and make me think. As opposed to the quote from my daughter that had graced my sidebar for a while (“I hate thinking. It hurts.”), I enjoy thinking. Cogito ergo sum. If I didn’t think, then I wouldn’t be. And we can’t have that.
My style is to be straightforward, so that you know exactly where I stand after reading one of my posts. I avoid wiggling my way through a point, or doing things to skirt responsibility for my thoughts. Many of the posts I read ultimately offer no conclusion as to what the writer believes. This may be the best means of serving as the citizen journalist, reporting the news without taking a position on it, but that’s not why I post.
If it’s just reporting, then Bashman already posted about it and there’s no reason to read anything I wrote. If you think I’m prolific, see what Bashman produces every day. I post about things that I find interesting, and evoke some degree of thought and feeling. Some find the number of posts I produce disturbing. I could probably do another half dozen every day if I had the time because of the variety of things throughout the day that peak my interest. If they think 5 or 6 posts a day is too many, what would they think of me then?
When people read my posts, they tend to either agree or disagree with me, but with a fair degree of vehemence in either direction. Thank God for that. There is nothing that I would find more distressing than to have written my thoughts on a subject and evoke no reaction. Love me or hate me, but feel something.
What I cannot do is try to form a consensus. No, it’s not that I am anti-collegial or just can’t play well with others. It’s that I never want to create a camel when I’m trying to design a horse. Consensus involves compromising what you believe to be right and wrong, correct and incorrect, in order to find common ground. Sometimes, this works exceptionally well, and the outcome of consensus is better than any individual idea. More often, however, consensus produces an outcome that satisfies no one and produces nothing of value.
Compromise has become a vaunted goal in itself lately. It can be overrated. If the result is not right, then it’s wrong. To prefer a wrong result over a right one merely avoid conflict or be collegial is the realm of the coward. There has to be something you believe in, or there’s just no reason to exist.
This should be distinguished from people who take the position that they don’t care enough to make a fight out of something. That’s different. Then it merely becomes an “acceptance” decision, where there is no right or wrong involved as far as you are concerned, and hence no reason to care what the outcome is. For example, if the choice is to go out for Chinese food or Italian, both of which you enjoy, then either one will do and you’re equally happy with either choice. I don’t tend to post about acceptance decisions. They don’t require thought.
But here’s the really big distinction. For the many (most?) blawgers who post not for the pleasure (mental masturbation?) but for client consumption and marketing, how then to present something of substance that serves to bring clients in rather than drive them away? After all, if you take a position, those who disagree with you (or just don’t understand you) may well say to themselves, “well, there’s a lawyer I wouldn’t hire.” It’s risky business, and there is no lawyer who is in business to drive potential clients away.
So I could write upbeat, positive, inspirational posts or the sort that would warm the cockles of potential clients’ hearts, surrounding myself with an aura of warmth and safety that would have clients searching online for the criminal defense lawyer of their dreams swarming around me like flies to light, but it would kill me. Playing to the crowd is the antithesis of why I write. I write to think. I write to evoke thought.
So when I post, it’s what I believe to be right. It doesn’t mean that I am right, and I have occasionally sometimes often frequently been told that I’m wrong. And I learned a great deal from those who challenge me. I’ve realized that I failed to fully consider an issue, or misunderstood something or just plain blew it. If I make some readers think, they make me think too.
It doesn’t get any better than that. So if you think I’m provocative, well, thanks.
The Conflicted World of Assigned Counsel
Unlike many states that provide indigent defense via a statewide public defender system, New York is a hodgepodge of county run programs filling the unfunded mandate of Gideon. And filling it poorly.
While the situation varies by location, there is essentially a two-tier system in New York for indigent defense, the first line being the local indigent defenders, whether Legal Aid, Bronx Defenders, etc. The second line is assigned counsel, attorney who join the appellate division 18b panels who are used to “fill in” for the indigent defenders. These are the “assigned counsel,” also known as “18b lawyers” or Pelicans. It’s not a term of endearment.
Issues relating to assigned counsel tend to result in heated discussions, which is a nice way to say that they devolve into fury. The reason for this is clear: Gideon may be the mantra, but welfare for lawyers is the problem. Before I explain, I add the important caveat that this is a generalization, not a specific attack on any lawyer who does 18b work. Some are great lawyers. Some are motivated purely by altruism. Some work their butt off for the benefit of their clients. Some don’t. This is a very emotional and controversial subject.
The problem arises from a problematic scheme in its inception. When a lawyer gets on the panel, he gets cases. It doesn’t pay very well ($60 out of court, $75 in court), but poor pay is better than no pay. And therein lies the problem.
Lawyers on the 18b panels characterize themselves as “private lawyers.” Many are, maintaining vibrant private practices and filling in their spare time with a few assigned cases. But a substantial number have no private practice to speak of, living almost entirely off of 18b cases. This was never supposed to be the way it happened. No one was supposed to feed only at the 18b trough.
The problem is two-fold: First, the 18b bar lacks the oversight that exists for the institutional indigent defenders. There are no supervisors making sure that indigent defendants receive competent legal representation. There is no training for the panel members per se. And there is no stop-gap for the defendants who are treated poorly, ignored or just plain dissatisfied with their representation.
Now must assigned counsel will insist that they do a brilliant job representing 18b defendants. Would you expect otherwise? And some do, and some don’t. Consider the Dunning Kruger Effect when one looks to lawyer self-assessment. Could there be a reason why these lawyers are living off 18b and have no private clients?
The second problem is that assigned counsel, by dint of their reliance on these cases to maintain their “private” practice, have a strong motivation to maintain that steady stream of cases coming from the panels. While the pay may not be much, they are still substantially more expensive than institutional indigent defenders and still work without any controls. But most importantly, they see assigned counsel work as an entitlement, that they are due a steady flow of assigned cases so that they can maintain their practice. This is where it all falls to pieces.
Within the criminal defense bar, there are a variety of reforms being pursued to provide a less expensive, more effective means of providing excellent criminal defense to indigent defendants. This, after all, is what Gideon is really all about, right? well, who stands in the way of this effort? That’s right, the assigned counsel. “What about us?” “How are we going to earn a living?” The implication is clear. They see any effort to reform indigent defense as an attack on their right to be assigned cases.
The problem really began with a false promise, that attorneys who (for whatever reason) were unable to attract private clients could take comfort in a never ending stream of indigent clients. This guarantee of a low-paying but omnipresent clientèle proved to be a slippery slope, where lawyers lost the incentive to improve their skills, work harder to attract retained clients and provide the level of service that private clients demand.
Instead, they could carry 10 assigned cases a day, have no hassles (because it wasn’t like the indigent defendants had a choice in the matter) and be assured that eventually they would receive a check from the county. For a while, abuse in the system was rampant, with lawyers billing 18b for 27 hours a day of services. We don’t hear this happening anymore, and assume that it’s calmed down as far as outright fraud is concerned.
Still, there should never have been an 18b bar to begin with. It was my thought that no lawyer should be permitted to do more than 10 assigned cases a year. That way, no one would ever be able to build an entire practice on assigned counsel work alone. They would be required to find retained clients or else a new line of work. No one should live solely off of assigned work, and if they wanted to represent indigents that badly, they should get a job with Legal Aid.
The upshot today is that as New York considers the future of indigent representation, and as the criminal defense bar associations weigh in on what would be the best direction to take for the future, there is anger, no fury, at the consequences. Us “high and mighty” theorists, who have no financial horse in the race, are stealing the bread off the plates of the children of the 18b bar.
As the conflict-averse amongst us try to appease these very angry lawyers by suggesting that there may still be some left-over conflict cases around for assignment, the obvious reality is that the future has no room for the assigned counsel bar if we are to improve the delivery of indigent defense and reduce the cost to the public. While there will be plenty of pain amongst the group, it is the only way to return sanity and quality to indigent defense. And frankly, this is a problem that should never have existed in the first place. No one ever guaranteed “private” lawyers a living off the assigned counsel panels. If you cant survive without it, then perhaps you need to think long and hard about why and where you should focus your energies in the future.
SCOTUS, Never Trust Anyone Over 30
Well, this week anyway. I’ve explained the significance of Baze v. Rees, the lethal injection case to be argued before the Supreme Court on January 7th. But I was unaware, until reading all about it in Arbitrary and Capricious and In the Moment, that the lead attorney for Baze and another death row convict was a Kentucky Public Defender, David Barron, age 29.
While many attorneys try, few ever get to stand before the Supreme Court and do their job. I’ve never been there, though I’m available if anybody needs me to carry their briefcase up the stairs. So the fact that David Barron fought for 3 years to get this case before the Court is quite a coup. Needless to say, David went to Brooklyn (that’s in New York for all you Texas folk) Law School.
Not only his youth, but the fact that he is a Kentucky PD, makes this achievement all the more remarkable.
Public defenders work one of the lowest rungs of the legal profession, one that is often not very highly regarded by other lawyers. Many young lawyers right out of law school often get their start as public defenders, and often race from case to case with barely enough time to read the file, much less do the in-depth investigation attorneys in private practice can do.
Public defenders have traditionally received little funding, particularly in the South. Kentucky has one of the lowest-funded offices in the country. The starting pay for most Kentucky’s public defenders is about $38,000 a year.
Kentucky spends about $33.5 million in 2005 (the last year for which numbers were available) on a population of 4.1 million. That’s about $8.14 per person for public defense — 23rd among the 30 state-run public defender offices nationally.
Not too shabby to get into the big game on $8.14 per defendant.
There has been some earlier comment about the ability of lone wolf criminal defense lawyers to find their way into the SCOTUS well without tripping all over themselves. The academics, beloved of the mandarins of the Supreme Court bar, think that the reason criminal defense lawyers do so poorly in Washington is that we’re just not up to scholarly snuff.
Well, there is a deafening silence in the blawgosphere of lawprofs criticizing David Barron’s work on the Baze briefs. Mind you, these aren’t the papers of some highly paid, big name, fancy pants criminal defense lawyer, but of a lowly Kentucky PD, who was likely paid $38,000 a year when he started work on Baze. Again, not too shabby.
In a sideways dig (not to criminal defense lawyers, but to “certain justices”), Volokh indulges in a flight of fantasy by surveying the means of executions in foreign countries.
Several Supreme Court Justices believe that foreign law and practice can help elucidate the meaning of the United States Constitution. They contend that the experience and practices of other countries are relevant to the meaning of our founding charter; what works for other countries may work for us, and we need to be open-minded to the practices and experiences of other nations rather than be arrogant and think other countries have nothing to teach us.
Notice the non sequitor about learning from the experience of others versus relevance “to the meaning of our founding charter?” That’s the way to promote one’s politics while infusing a little plausible deniability into your sentence. Because I’m sure executions in foreign lands offer no lessons to 110% red-blooded Americans. We die different. It’s not easy to make the phrase “open-minded” sound pejorative. But nary a negative word of our 29 year old “shaggy-haired” protagonist.
Not to prejudge the outcome, but it appears we may have a leading candidate for the 2008 Criminal Defense Lawyer of the Year. Regardless of the outcome of Baze, and it may well be a fascinating outcome indeed if it does nothing more than tie up executions for a while to give everybody a chance to reassess the question of whether killing people is as good an idea as they think in Texas, David Barron has done himself, his office, criminal defense lawyers and certainly all the maligned Public Defenders of this nation proud.
Return of the Texas Tornado
For those of you who, like me, suffered severe withdrawal while Mark Bennett, the Texas Tornado, jetted across the pond to rile up the locals by doing every Paris patisserie from Montmartre to Rive droite, and every arrondissement in between, I am happy to announce that he’s back and posting.
I don’t know about you, but I went through righteous withdrawal when Mark went through customs. And then his jet lagged return. And then working on his car. All selfish endeavors, but even Harris County, Texas has to wait sometimes. What to do when the your moral compass goes on vacation? Who was going to keep me honest, let me know when I was repeating, or worse yet contradicting, myself (that happens when you get to be my age and suffer from CRS).
But 2008 is here, and Bennett is back. Today, you will find 5 new posts, spanning the full panoply of issues of importance, from the personal to Texas to that part of the country outside of Texas that merits mention. In fact, Mark even posted about the Columbus topless case that I posted about here, though he apparently wasn’t keeping up with my “alarming” volume of posts since he found out about it from David Feige’s great top ten list yesterday (which made the Huffington Post!).
So all you non-Texas readers (including people from Dallas, which is not really a part of Texas), I urge you to go check out Bennett’s triumphant return to the practical blawgosphere. And for all you Texas people, no need to tell you about this, since there’s no world outside of Texas for you folks anyway.
Tankleff Tossed! (Update)
Suffolk County District Attorney Thomas Spota announced today that he will not seek to retry Marty Tankleff for the 1988 murder of his parents.
“It was no longer possible to reasonably infer that the case against Marty Tankleff would be successful,” Spota said.
This statement, in light of the position taken by the DAs office following the extensive post-conviction evidentiary hearings, is nothing short of shocking. ADA Leonard Lato ripped the defense claims as lies at the time. If the defense was so strong, why did the DA fight so vehemently to keep Marty in prison?
“Tankleff’s supporters see ‘Marty’ as a young man who ‘had it all,’ and they cannot accept that he is guilty of matricide and patricide,” Lato wrote. “The truth is that, on Sept. 7, 1988, Martin H. Tankleff murdered his parents.”
So how did these “lies” suddenly change? Not merely change, but reduce the prosecution’s evidence to the point that it could no longer be inferred that it would be successful? If the DA believed, given all the evidence, that Marty was the murderer as it espoused over and over, then why drop the case and let a murderer walk rather than take the chance and potentially win?
While the outcome is proper here, Spota’s statement is disingenuous, as has been the prosecution’s attack on Marty throughout. It is obvious to me that the subtext to Spota’s statement is that he can’t muster the witnesses and the ones he have now suffer from their lies and deceptions in the past. And that includes Spota, who while in private practice represented the primary detective who deceived Marty into giving the confession.
So rather than wiggle and squirm his way out of a trial, Spota could have said that he no longer believes that the evidence against Marty Tankleff was sufficient to prove guilt. I’m sure Marty is happy with an end to his 17 year nightmare no matter what Spota has to say about it. But it would have been nice if just once the District Attorney ate some crow after all that he’s done to keep Marty Tankleff in prison.
And Marty, welcome home. And Happy New Year.
Update: As was pointed out to me by a friend/prosecutor, Marty was convicted of intentional murder of his father, but acquitted of that charge with regard to his mother. Instead, he was convicted under a depraved indifference murder theory of his mother. While this is not necessarily incompatible with changes in New York law, which no longer routinely permits the mirror charges of intention and depraved, it would not have precluded a theory where Marty had intended to kill the father and the mother just got in the way. But we all agree that Spota’s dismissal of this mess was bizarrely inconsistent with his office’s handling up to now and, quite simply, utterly graceless. And the final question is, is there any money left from the parents’ inheritance? No matter, as I’m sure there will be a civil suit shortly to make up for lost years.
RIP Court TV
Court TV is no more. While this was announced a while back, that Court TV would become TruTV (because “court” lacked the “true” connotation), it still represents the end of an era.
There was once a time when regular lawyers, the guys like me who toiled in the trenches, had little chance of seeing our made-for-radio mugs on television. Lawyers were Perry Mason and Judd. Then came OJ and the world shifted. There weren’t enough lawyers to provide 24/7 trial coverage and commentary. Lawyers were doing Monday Night Football, except for a trial. There were the play by play guys, and the commentary gals, and somebody trying to be inane like Dennis Miller. If you were a lawyer and willing to go on TV without any hope of compensation, there was a place for you.
It made stars of a few, most memorably the Starr herself. With Hynes shoving her fat butt out the door as hard as he could (just to make sure it fit through), Starr Jones violated the Peter Principle by landing herself a gig on TV, where she was admired more than she had been as a assistant district attorney (What? you mean they got all them laws in that little black book? NO WAY!).
For most of us, it was an interesting experience. We had an opportunity to try to overcome the vapid commentary by our hosts and inject some small dose of information and accuracy into the fog of really important questions, like
“how do you think the parents felt abut the ruling?”
“Well Nancy, if your child was just discovered murdered, hacked into a thousand pieces and put through a meat grinder, only to find out that the defendant would be freed because the police officer dropped his jelly donut into the DNA sample, you would probably feel pretty disappointed.”
“Thank you for that insight, and now, the weather . . . “
Those were heady days. But the fact remained that few of us actually watched Court TV. No one I know did, unless they were involved in a particular case or were doing some show themselves. Other than that, it varied from terribly boring to mind-numbingly stupid. Seriously, watching Rikki banter with Eddy is at least a step or two below root canal. They’re all nice enough on their own at a party, but actually spend time listening to them fill dead air? That’s just crazy.
For new lawyers coming out, the heyday of lawyer commentary has passed you by. There will be no new Court TV for you to cut your teeth on, to tell that cute looking guy in the bar what you were doing today (Yeah, it’s just left-over make-up from my TV commentary this afternoon). There will still be the occasional high profile trials that require a 10 video quote to prove the reporter’s not totally ignorant, but then there’s no free limo pickup or donuts in the green room. Yeah, those were heady days.
So long, Court TV.
