Author Archives: SHG

Why Are Incompetents So Certain?

I stumbled across Rob Millard’s blog, The Adventure of Strategy, and found a name for a phenomenon that has long plagued me, the Dunning Kruger Effect.  This is so brilliant that Dunning and Kruger won the Nobel [major correction per Rob; the  Ig Nobel prize.  Well, that changes things, doesn’t it?] Prize for it in 2000.  I wish I had thought of the name first so I could have won a prize.

The concept is simple and counterintuitive:  People who have little knowledge think that they know more than others who have much more knowledge.  Put otherwise, those who have no clue what they are talking about, do so with greater confidence than those who actually do know what they are talking about.

Dunning and Kruger, both from my alma mater, Cornell University, hypothesized as follows:

  1. Incompetent individuals tend to overestimate their own level of skill.
  2. Incompetent individuals fail to recognize genuine skill in others.
  3. Incompetent individuals fail to recognize the extremity of their inadequacy.
  4. If they can be trained to substantially improve their own skill level, these individuals can recognize and acknowledge their own previous lack of skill.

Now Rob Millard takes this phenom into places where it can be addressed, such as creating hard goals in law firms so that incompetents can’t refute their inadequacies because there is some objective sign of failure that they simply can’t ignore.  Frankly, my experience is that incompetent individuals are never at a loss for finding ways to rationalize their failures and thereby never have to face the fact of their incompetency.  It’s just a matter of having a sufficiently fertile imagination combined with the overdeveloped ability to ignore anything that fails to fit into your personal self-vision.

Obviously, the application of this concept is essentially unlimited.  Whether it be judges, prosecutors, spouses, whoever, there is always some secret joy to be had by applying the D-K Effect.  It makes for a great game at parties, too!

So now that it has a name, at least as far as I was aware though you may have been paying closer attention to the Nobel Prizes in 2000 and caught this one the first time around, go out and apply it at will.  And remember, the next time you tell someone how certain you are about something, “ignorance more frequently begets confidence than does knowledge.”

The Post-Appeal Question: Why Did You Fail?

While appellate practice can be very gratifying from the lawyer’s perspective, it isn’t always as much fun for the client.  In 2007, the Appellate Divisions that cover New York City reversed a grand total of 45 criminal convictions.  So when that 46th lawyer you run into tells you that he too got a reversal, you know that something is wrong.

One of the hard truths of doing appeals is that the odds are stacked against you.  They are really stacked against you.  As much as you inform a client, and his family, that it’s an uphill fight, they believe that their case will be the one that gets reversed, and the “justice” will be done for them because they, more so than anyone else, have been maligned by the system.

For some, there is a lot of truth in their belief, but their conviction just doesn’t have anything so gripping that it catches the appellate court’s interest sufficiently to give it serious thought.  To a large extent, the threshold question is whether they believe the defendant was guilty and got a generally fair, albeit imperfect, shot.  It’s hard to feel all that sorry for the bad guy who suffered some inconsequential flaw in his trial.

For this reason, we strive to find a way to present the issues on appeal that will strike the judges in such a way as to get them to think that this is a case worthy of their attention.  If we can get them to focus on our case, we’ve got half a chance.  At least, that’s what we believe.  It doesn’t mean we win, but we know we can’t win if the judges aren’t paying attention in the first place.

Despite all efforts, however, some appeals will lose.  By the numbers, the vast majority will lose.  And this blow is crushing for defendants and their families, as it represents their last chance at getting out from under the conviction. 

Norm Pattis  posts about the talk that comes after the losing decision.  No matter how good a lawyer you are, you will get this telephone call at one point or another.


What could be done for a client whose murder conviction was just upheld on appeal? The client is angry. Wants to know what comes next. Wants a visit. Wants to know why we raised losing issues, rather than the winners he knows all about. When does he get a new trial? When is he going home? You get the drill.

Few things more squarely frame the job then this talk.  Defendants hire criminal defense lawyers to win their freedom.  When the lawyer fails to accomplish that goal, it’s because the lawyer failed.  That’s just the way it goes.  Lawyers are viewed like plumbers, expected to fix the leak that they were hired to fix.  No one wants to hear why the plumber can’t fix the leak, and no one need a plumber who can’t do his job.

Unfortunately, lawyers aren’t like plumbers and we can’t fix every leak.  In other times and under other circumstances, clients understand this.  But when it’s their last hope for freedom, they don’t tend to focus on the lawyer’s issues but on their own.  This isn’t too hard to understand.

This is a common source of discord between lawyer and client.  The lawyer may feel that he’s worked his butt off, done everything possible and then some, to help his client.  But at the end of the day, he was unable to obtain the desired result.  To the lawyer, his work his personal.  He put his heart and soul into it, because his self-worth is on the line with every case he fights.  Clients think we fight because we love them, or because we are paid a lot of money.  Perhaps that’s true for some, but most lawyers fight to win because they are internally driven to do so.  It makes for some pretty strong motivation, far more so than love of the client.

And so, the lawyer gets annoyed, or worse, with the client who not only doesn’t appreciate the lawyer’s efforts, but blames the lawyer for losing the appeal.  The client remains absolutely certain that, based upon his vast legal experience in the prison law library, his case was not only a huge winner, but the court should have given him an apology to boot for all the heinous violations of his constitutional rights.  And if the client could have won the case, why didn’t you?

For the most part, my appellate practice has been remarkably successful, allowing me to avoid these talks.  This is largely a product of experience, in that I know the appellate judges from the old days when they sat on the trial bench, and they know me.  They take my appeals seriously, and I have a firm grasp of the types of arguments, and the strategies in presenting these arguments, that will at least capture their attention.  When I argue, they listen, and when they listen, there is a far better chance of prevailing.

But that doesn’t mean that I win them all.  Only Gerry Spence wins every time, according to him.  And when I lose, I face the music just like Norm, because I know two things: My client depended on me and I couldn’t fix the leak.  I know, criminal defense lawyers aren’t supermen and can’t fix everything.  But that doesn’t make the loss any easier.  For my client or me.

Collateral Consequences: The Good, The Bad and The Ugly

Andrew Lavoott Bluestone at  New York Attorney Malpractice Blog sent me this New Jersey decision, McKnight v. Public Defender, that has a little something for everyone.  The gist of the decision has to do with a relatively unusual situation, criminal legal malpractice, and when it accrues for statute of limitations purposes.  That’s the boring part (for me), but how this case reaches that point is fascinating.

It seems that Garvin McKnight was indicted for “a dispute” (whatever that means) with his girlfriend and was represented by Kevin Walshe of the Public Defenders office.  Upon Walshe’s advice, McKnight pleaded guilty to third-degree aggravated assault in at the end of July, 2000.  Walshe, apparently, was unaware of one little detail with McKnight, that he was a citizen of the beautiful Isles of Trinidad and Tobago, though he had been in the United States since he was 5 years old.

In September, McKnight received a letter from INS informing him that he had won an all-expense paid one-way trip back to Trinidad.  He wasn’t thrilled.  Six days later, he moved to withdraw his guilty plea, which the judge denied.  This was a very hot and disputed issue at the time, following the huge expansion of deportability in the Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act of 1996. 

The problem then was that anyone not a citizen was subject to deportation, on top of any other punishment that might be meted out, for a conviction of a felony.  While it was unclear whether they would, in fact, be deported, and whether the states would cooperate with INS in alerting them to the conviction of immigrants (note that they could be perfectly legal immigrants who have been in the United States since a minute after birth), this presented a significant problem in criminal prosecutions.

Problem number one was that a plea to a relatively innocuous sentence could produce disastrous collateral consequences.  In other words, a defendant could get probation for a minor drug possession felony, and end up being shipped back to the motherland, where his family left when he was two week old, and separated from his wife and 17 kids. 

On the other hand, the fact that a plea produced these ridiculously severe consequences had nothing to do with the fact that the defendant was still charged with a felony and had the option of pleading or going to trial.  If he refused to accept the potential collateral consequences of deportation, and the case against him was indefensible, then he had a lengthy prison stay to look forward to and then deportation.  It’s not like there was a better option somewhere else.

But back to McKnight.  Walshe did something a little different here.  In New Jersey, defendants fill out “plea forms” at the time they plead guilty.  The form states that there are collateral consequences to pleading guilty, and McKnight’s form circled “N/A”.  On his motion to withdraw his plea, the judge concluded that the collateral consequences did not support withdrawal of the plea. 

This was the common reaction at the time, and there was plenty of disagreement about whether, and who, should inform pleading defendants about collateral immigration consequences.  Criminal defense lawyers did not want the burden to be on their shoulders.  Court’s didn’t want it.  Nobody wanted to be the one to give the bad news, and essentially become responsible for something that was outside their control, would gum up the works and for which no definitive answers were available. 

McKnight then sought post-conviction relief based on ineffective assistance of counsel.  An interesting aside is that he remained in prison in New Jersey (itself, a heightened punishment that no one should have to endure) because the beautiful Isle of Trinidad didn’t want him and wouldn’t take him.  An evidentiary hearing followed, where Kevin Walshe testified on McKnight’s behalf.

Walshe stated that he neglected to ask McKnight if he was a citizen, and circled the “N/A” on the form himself without discussing it with McKnight.  He said it was “plea day” and he was backed up with pleading defendants.  In the busy, noisy holding cell, he tried to get through the form as quickly as possible and just assumed McKnight to be a citizen.  In the best tradition of the criminal defense lawyer, Walshe fell on the sword and conceded that his affirmative acts deprived McKnight of the opportunity to know about and consider the impact of deportation.

Based upon Walshe’s admission that he not only failed to inform McKnight, but effectively precluded McKnight from knowing of the collateral consequences by his assumptive help, the court vacated the conviction.  McKnight then pleaded guilty to some inconsequential offense with a fine of $155 (noting that he had already spent more time in prison than he would have but for the Immigration hold.

And then, McKnight sues the public defender for legal malpractice.  This portion, the point of the decision, is tedious, so I’ll let Andrew deal with the accrual issues.  But the lessons here are many for the criminal defense practitioner:  Don’t assume.  Don’t rush through someone else’s life, no matter how busy you are and how many other people are waiting for you.  Do take the weight for you mistakes, and when you screw up and do something that hurts your client, be man enough to admit it.  And finally, no good deed goes unpunished.  That’s why they pay us the big bucks.

How Can a Pink Kitty Be Bad?

When it’s a fully functional AR-15 Assault Rifle?  In pink. 

Now this could make up for the dissapointment when the Barbie Minivan didn’t really meet my daughter’s expectations.  If only my favorite Federalist, Gene Volokh, had told me about this before Christmas.

Hello Kitty AR-15

And if you feel that li’l Suzy will feel neglected if there’s only one gift under the tree, you can always add the Rainbow Brite Ammo Loader Kid.



Or the Care Bear body armour. 




And what about that budding homemaker?  All available at GlamGuns, together with the full line of Dora The Explorer weaponry.


Size Does Matter

Digressing, as I sometimes do, into the world of the blawgospheric marketing gurus, I belatedly picked up on Kevin’s provocative post that size doesn’t matter.  Ah, how many fellows have said that to themselves and believed it in their desperation.  How many Hummers have been sold?

Kevin’s size issues are somewhat different.  They have to do with size of audience relative to the success of a blog.


Scoble’s spot on this morning that building a big blog audience is not what matters in blogging. Robert was referencing what advertisers care about, but the same applies equally to you lawyers trying to achieve blog success.

Well, not exactly.  The point was that size alone is insufficient to achieve success.  Scoble’s point was that a big audience, but the wrong audience, will fail to achieve success in generating advertising revenues.  But does that translate to targeting the “right”, but small audience?

This position is part of the LexBlog thrust that blogging is the marketing future for lawyers, and that any blogger can have a successful blog by posting once a week in a half hour.  And it dices and slices.  I admire Kevin’s zeal, but this can produce a very messy blawgosphere, filled with pretend blogs and will scare people away and denigrate the value of the blawgosphere as a whole for the rest of us.  If you are a newbie to the blawgosphere and find that blawg after blawg is some tired, moribund self-promotional site, what are the chances you are going to exert even greater effort to find your way through the maze of self-hyping blawgs until you reach the substance? 

The point is that the marketing blawgosphere, artfully designed to pop up first on google and, if all goes well for Kevin, far outnumbering the substantive blawgosphere, will result in the blawgosphere collapsing under its own dead weight.  The marketing blawgs will strangle the real blawgs, and whatever future the blawgosphere may have otherwise held will never come to fruition. 

Now I have no issue with LexBlog promoting hardcore blawging by its new members.  Bless them for finding the joys of entering the conversation with interesting comments and fascinating news.  But the part of the deal that says, “you too can be a blawger in only a half hour a week!” doesn’t thrill me.  It’s not true.  It won’t happen.  And most importantly, it will not pay off.

I’ve spent a little time cruising around the blawgosphere.  I’ve seen some people start up a blawg, go like gangbusters for a few weeks and then peter out.  Sure, it was fun while it lasted, but it took time to produce content that anyone wanted to read.  When you produce garbage content, readers go away.  If you intend to impress potential clients, garbage content does just the opposite.  You may be a great lawyer, but if your efforts are reflected in some crap that you threw onto your blawg because you felt you had to do something, then potential clients will see it, recognize it for crap, and go elsewhere.

So how do you know if you’re producing crap?  Size, baby.  If you provide something of substance, people will come.  You will gain an audience.  Your audience will grow, and people will take note of you.  And if you start a blog, post some stuff and nobody comes, then there’s a lesson there too. 

So if you believe that being able to draw the picture on the back of a matchbook will make you a famous artist, then buy into the story that size doesn’t matter.  But by clogging up the blawgosphere with junk that will drive away new readers who believe that they can find something worth the time to read, you’re ruining it for the rest of us.  Don’t do it.

Update:  Some worthwhile thoughts on what “size” means from gapingvoid.

The Things We Do For Love

If you don’t have young children, you probably can’t appreciate the yearning to get your hands on Hannah Montana concert tickets.  Your child’s eyes burn for the chance to see her idol.  As a parent, there is little that drives you more than the burning desire of your child. 

Priscilla Ceballos did what she had to door her 6 year old daughter.  She was a good mother.  No, a great mother.  She wrote and essay, attributed it to her daughter, and won 4 tickets (and airfare) to a sold-out concert in Albany, New York.  Just the thought of going to Albany this time of year makes me shudder, but these are the things that a good mother endures for her child.

For her efforts, Priscilla Ceballos should have given the Mother of the Year Award.  Instead, she has been publicly castigated as evil by national television.  A columnist  called this a “new low,” proving that the columnist doesn’t get out much.   Even the BBC thought this was important enough to notice, because there aren’t any other world events of consequence.

Talk about a fall from grace.  She even lost the tickets.

Her downfall happened because her essay was too good.  She wrote about her daughter’s fallen daddy in Iraq.  It was a very moving essay.  It wasn’t true, but it was moving. 

There was no rule that the essay be true.  It wasn’t under oath.  Does the phrase, “creative writing” mean anything? 

Things got out of hand when the sponsor of the contest decided to take the essay one step further than expected because it was so moving.  They wanted to milk their investment for all it was worth by taking this tear-jerker essay and getting the media to elevate their contest to martyr status.  The sponsor tried to sell the essay as true, and the media didn’t play ball when it “investigated” the details. 

So instead of scoring some Hannah Montana tix for her daughter, Priscilla was hounded as a scammer for trying to pass off this fake story.  Sure, she tried to game the system.  Are people who have no “true” stories that evoke tears precluded from winning Hannah Montana tickets?  Are their children less worthy of their parents’ love and devotion? 

If they wanted a true story for their essay contest, then that should have been a requirement.  As long as any essay will do, then Priscilla Ceballos is owed an apology.  She did what she had to do to win some of the hottest kiddie tickets in the country for her little girl.  She won them fair and square.  Screw the Puritans who want to hold you to some ex post facto rule because of their self-promotional choice, Priscilla.  Your first priority is your daughter, not appeasing the media lust for a villain.  Not only did you do nothing wrong, but you did it for the love of your child.  That’s what a parent is supposed to do.

It Was The Rush, Not The Race, That Convicted John White

The conviction of John White for manslaughter for the death of Daniel Cicciaro is an odd subject for an editorial on the first day of the New Year at Newsday.  The gist of the editorial is that the new defense strategy is to taint the conviction as one motivated by race is misguided. 


Yet, despite the rhetoric of civil rights activists arguing that the case “smacks of 1950s Mississippi” and vague claims by some members of the jury that they were pressured, there is scant evidence, so far, that racism determined the outcome of the Miller Place case.

This statement mixes separate issues, and unfortunately muddies things of real impact with a rhetorical strategy that will ultimately fail.  The “vague claims by some members of the jury” don’t relate to some racial overtone, but to an ordinary, basic problem that has long existed in our legal system.  We pretend that it doesn’t, because America is vested in the jury system, and admitting that it is a fundamentally flawed system would call every conviction (and every acquittal) into question.  The “majesty” of the law would be revealed as something of a farce, and that would make for a very messy situation.

Let me make this clear:  The legal is not a farce.  It just isn’t nearly as good as we pretend it is.  It has some very serious institutional problems that no one has been able to fix.  We mask it in grandiose platitudes that usually suffice to quiet the masses, because admitting that we have a system that fails to ensure a fair and proper outcome would wreak havoc.

John White’s jury reached its verdict for a fairly common reason.  Time ran out.  The judge gave an Allen charge, with is a nice way of saying that she pressured the jury to reach a decision, any decision, rather than hang.  Words are thrown in to the back end of the Allen charge to tell jurors that they need not give up their strongly held beliefs, but the mass of the instruction is for the minority to listen to the majority and give in.  The threat is that they judge will not respect their “strongly held beliefs” by keeping them locked in their jury room until they reach a verdict. 

The jurors are regular people, with things to do and a life to lead.  They are forced to chose between their lives, and their families, and holding firm in the face of an angry mob for a person they don’t know who may have done something wrong.  The quiet subtext is that while some jurors may doubt guilt, they aren’t sufficiently sure that they are prepared to go to the mat.  Deciding between conflicting stories is almost impossible, even though we pretend that anyone can do it.  Every juror fears, in her heart, that she will make the wrong decision.  The most persuasive thing in a trial is the support of others that the choice is correct.  There is always strength in numbers.

Spinning John White’s conviction into a race issue is not only a dubious strategy, but one that detracts from a real and serious issue.  In fact, it is rather remarkable that the conviction shows no sign of taint because of the race of the shooter and shootee.  If anything, the racial implications ran in John White’s favor, with a drunken Italian kid coming after a Black kid because of an erroneous assumption that he threatened to rape a white girl.  It tends to vilify the victim far more than John White, who did nothing more than try to protect his home and family.  Except for the detail that John White’s gun killed Daniel Cicciaro, he is the more sympathetic person.

If the White conviction causes a real discussion of the failings of the jury system to reach a sound verdict, it will serve a higher function.  This case points to only one of the many flaws of the system.  Others, such as the  Joseph Cammarano conviction, point to the silliness of jury instructions and the ridiculous notion that reading a lengthy set of instructions in pseudo-legalese somehow enlightens 12 normal people as to the nuance of their duty.   Deliberations is dedicated to the pervasive issue of inherent bias on juries, which for all our tricks and tribulations, continues to elude detection.

Perhaps the scholars can put aside their deep thoughts on  due process at the Ministry of Magic and focus a bit on how to address more mundane issues, like juries.  But then, the subject has been done a million times (to no avail) and would require them to dirty themselves in the practical world of litigation, an unfamiliar place. 

There is one very important, and uplifting thing, about the John White conviction.  For all its flaws, it did not reflect a jury inclined to side with a white man and convict a Black man.  So we are moving forward in that respect.  Slowly, but forward. 

Welcome to 2008, When Everything Will Change

The New Year is here, and it makes for a perfect opportunity to start fresh.  No, it holds no magical powers.  It’s simply a natural break in time, which many need to motivate them to gather the strength to do something they have been meaning to do but just couldn’t get off the ground.

Norm has chosen to make New Years Resolutions, which mostly revolve around being nicer to kittens and puppies.  I have made no such resolutions, and plan to continue to do what I’ve done up to now.  I have nothing against kittens and puppies, but also find no reason to change the way I treat them.  If there was something that I needed to change about myself, I would have already done so.  I’m not inclined to put things off.

Most of the country will be fast asleep as I write this post.  Some will just be putting their head on their pillow (or someone’s pillow) at this moment.  My New Years tradition is to go to sleep at the same time I do every night.  I don’t go out to Times Square and wear funny glasses or hats.  I spend it with my family.  I can’t think of any group of people with whom I would prefer to ring in the new year. 

But this isn’t a blog about my life, and so I won’t bore you with any more about my traditions.  The renewal of the New Year brings inspiration to many, particularly those who believe that we have a duty to improve the world around us by being better people and helping the lot of others.  Most people believe this.  They just differ on what constitutes being better. 

In a comment to my Happy New Year post, Carolyn Elefant wrote:


And thank you Scott, for all of your opinions, and more importantly, for showing, by example, how lawyers can strongly express an opinion while still acting respectfully towards those espousing opposing views. And doing it all with an “alarming” amount of speed and grace! Happy New Year

It was a very kind comment.  Carolyn is a kind person.  I’ve always been inclined to express straightforward opinions.  Many people fear offending others by having a point of view, and their desire to be liked stifles their willingness to express their views.  This is less true on the internet, where people can vent their spleen anonymously, and thus avoid the consequences that they fear if they did so under their own name. 

It’s not that people we know don’t feel strongly about things; they just won’t tell you what they think.  There are no people without opinions.  There are only people whose opinions you don’t know because they won’t say.  I’ve chose to express my views on a variety of subjects.  On the whole, they generally fall into the category of being fair to all.  I seem to challenge certain groups with frequency, cops and prosecutors mostly.  This isn’t because I have something against cops and prosecutors per se, but that I take note when they do something that I perceive as unfair.  I also go after criminal defense lawyers from time to time when they fail to live up to their responsibilities.  None of us are perfect, but that doesn’t mean we can strive to be better than we are now.

I’m not so sure that I’ve generally acted respectfully toward people who disagree with me.  Sometimes I’ve learned of opposing views that I hadn’t considered, or adequately considered, and I adjust my views accordingly.  Sometimes, comments will deal with a minor tangential point that was mentioned but not fully (or particularly well) developed in a blog post.  The medium doesn’t always lend itself to thoroughness.  While I may have explained things better in a 70 page brief, nobody wants to read that much here.  I know I wouldn’t read it.  So, I sometimes touch on a point and move on.

But my tangential point may raise a red flag to someone with a different focus than mine, and they will go after it with a vengeance.  This tests my tolerance, and I think that I often fail to live up to Carolyn’s observation.  I plan to come up with a better way to deal with this in 2008. 

Stephen Gustitis wrote  a very nice post reflecting on 2007.  He thanks many members, including me, of the practical blawgosphere for their “link love.”  Great phrase.  Link love is how we navigate the internet.  Norm  doesn’t care for link love, but he gets it from me anyway.  I guess that makes it unrequited link love? 

There are a few predictions that I feel comfortable making for 2008.  We will elect a Democrat of either a different color or sex than our current President, and waste a lot of words on how we have broken through barriers.  But our government will continue to function along the lines that it has over the past two decades.  The federal government will continue to usurp power and authority to intrude on our freedoms in the name of order, and we will let it happen.  Our new Democratic president will gather and retain power like our old one. 

The Blawgosphere will grow and the distinctions between the academics and the practical will blur.  The academics will fight it, but they will have no choice but to acknowledge our existence.  What this means for those of us who spend our time writing this stuff remains unclear, since I doubt that the internet will become the great shopping mall for legal talent that the blogging businesses keep saying it will.  But that doesn’t really matter for many of us, since we aren’t here to open an online storefront. 

I think many new bloggers will become quickly disenchanted with the internet when they find out that it doesn’t pan out they way they thought it would.  Kevin keeps  whipping his horse in the hope of winning the race, but the more entrants, the more losers.  But he will have some winners, and they will deserve to win and be a welcome addition. 

2008 will bring a paradigm shift in police culture.  They will stop seeing themselves as a separate entity, apart from all other people, and as a part of our society as a whole.  This will fundamentally alter their compulsive need to subjugate others, to cause others physical pain and harm, simply because we have given them permission to use force without consequence against people.  They will realize that the person they are about to taser is no different than their mother, or brother, or partner.  Just people, some doing foolish things and some just unclear how or why they are the target of an armed person’s angst. 

There will be a sweeping change toward diffusing hostility rather than inflaming it, and engaging in communication instead of making demands and giving commands.  Thousands of people will live, will walk away unharmed, will avoid needless arrest and imprisonment, will come to understand that the forces of power exist to make our world safer, saner, more pleasant and more fair for everyone.  They will finally hold a vested stake in the preservation of civility, rather than feel stigmatized and alienated from the rest of society. 

These same people, on the cusp of being a contributing member of society or disrupting the flow of ordinary life for someone they don’t know, will decide to take the chance of working within our norms because a police officer treated them with respect and kindness. 

Even if they do something wrong, make an impulsive and foolish decision to place their self-interest above the interests of others, they will come before a judge who will show them that the rules that we must all live within are fair and just.  They will not feel like the perpetual losers and outcasts of society, with nothing to gain by trying to be a part of a group that wants nothing to do with them.  Even the most jaded judges will cease their intemperate diatribes and use their power to demonstrate that there is room in our society for all of its citizens rather than drive the wedge deeper between us, guaranteeing that there is a permanent subculture for which our society offers nothing.

Welcome to 2008. 

We Guarantee a Painless, Happy Death

On January 7, 2008, the Supreme Court will hear argument in Baze v. Rees.  The issue, as framed by Orin Kerr at Volokh, is


the constitutionality of the current method of lethal injection that 35 states use to carry out the death penalty. The question: Does use of the three-drug cocktail of chemicals that states use to carry out executions amount to cruel and unusual punishment because of the risk that state officials could make an error and inadvertently cause the individual to suffer pain before he dies? The briefs of the parties and the various amici are available here.

While much of the discussion centers on the absence of an evidentiary basis to show what the level of risk of improper use of the cocktail that results in a painful death masked by physical paralysis from one of the drugs.  Or as Orin puts it,  how much of a risk of error is too much for the Constitution.  While the inadequate record presents an issue, the consensus is that cert was granted because of too many district judges left to their own devices in the face of inadequate evidence.

But we’re not lawprofs here, so let’s get down to business, shall we?  This strikes me as mind-boggling foolish.  The issue of death penalty or not is one thing, but this case assumes a death penalty and that’s not on the table.  Some of those more knowledgeable in medicine (or perhaps more knowledgeable in opiates, as the case may be), have already suggested that your basic opiate overdose will do the trick; no pain and definitely no gain.  So why are we talking about some complicated and problematic 3 drug cocktail?  They die and they feel darn good for a few minutes.

But the better solution has nothing to do with how many or what drugs.  It’s the death penalty.  If we are to presume they deserve it (I know, but we’re playing hypotheticals here), then why are we so concerned about a little pain?  We are killing them, but a little pain is a problem? 

Moreover, if putting people to death is so popular, then there is no good reason to sanitize it by making it seem like a medical procedure.  One bullet in the back of the head would do the trick, and eliminate any drug company from airing commercials about how they mix the best 3 drug cocktails around (side effects: certain death and 4 hour erection).  Obviously, it would be a total waste not to make this a new reality TV show, filmed on site in Texas.  Imagine what this show could do for the national debt?

The absurdity of arguing about the most humane means of killing people is overwhelming.  Death penalty opponents should, and must, challenge its existence, application and modalities whenever they can.  If they win, they may stop or at least forestall the state sanctioned killing of people.  This is a worthy goal, notwithstanding the stupid cases needed to get there.

What is missing in the discussion over at Volokh, where they foresee a Kennedy concurrence carrying the day, is that this is merely a proxy argument on the penalty itself.  If anything, let’s see Justice Scalia call it what it is and suggest that a good public hanging, a time-honored tradition, is what the founding fathers would have wanted for anyone deserving death.  At least, this would be an honest way to address this silly question.

Better still, let’s just put this stupidity to rest until someone comes up with a way to assure that only the guilty get convicted and we stop sticking our heads in the sand of legal fictions that say that a jury verdict of guilty is so absolutely certain that we are willing to stake someone else’s life on it.