Author Archives: SHG

The Private Police of the Recording Industry (Update)

Liptak posts that the University of Oregon has refused to be a party to the persecution of its own students.  While offering little hope for the effort, Adam lauds the fact that someone has finally stood up to the Recording Industry Association of America.

When the University received a subpoena for the identities of certain students, they opposed it.  Fortunately for them, they are represented by the State’s Attorney General, who filed a “blistering” motion to quash.  This is a huge turn of events, since there aren’t many individuals, particularly college students, equipped to take on the Recording Industry.



In the past four years, record companies have sued tens of thousands of people for violating the copyright laws by sharing music on the Internet. The people it sues tend to settle, paying the industry a few thousand dollars rather than risking a potentially ruinous judgment by fighting in court.

“People get pushed into settlements,” said Fred von Lohmann, a lawyer with the Electronic Frontier Foundation, a civil liberties group. “The Oregon attorney general is showing what a real fight among equals would look like.”

You may recall  this story about Jammie Thomas, who tried to challenge the RIAA over a claim of uploading 24 songs.  It cost her $9,250 per song, for a grand total of $220,000.  This is the civil equivalent of the death penalty.

As Liptak correctly notes, there is no reason to cry for people who steal music and deprive the artists, and even the recording companies, of their right to profit from their efforts.  But what the RIAA does, and what they are permitted encouraged to do under federal law, is outrageous.

Under 18 USC 2319, the recording industry is given the power to act as a private police force.  The power is theoretically civil, but the law provides for liability to the copyright owner for actual damages or lost profits, or for statutory damages up to $100,000 per infringed copyright.  At the statutory amount, the incentive for the RIAA, the enforcement arm of the recording industry, to go after little Johnny and little Jammie is awfully strong. 

This law was passed in 1972, long before Napster was a glimmer in anyone’s eye.  This was back when bootlegging was bootlegging, not college kids downloading individual songs.  Not to excuse this conduct (at all), but $100,000 per song is serious overkill. 

The product has been the course of least resistance, lest ordinary people face ruinous bankruptcy.  Why has Congress permitted the recording industry to maintain this level of extortionate power over people?   The mere threat of the RIAA taking a peak under your child’s Ipod is enough to threaten the future of a family.  While this may be wrong, is it wrong enough to financially destroy families?

In another post, I question why citizens who are wrongfully arrested, beaten and denied treatment have no viable recourse against the government.  Yet the RIAA can wrong the horrific crime of file sharing by destroying the lives of kids and their families at a potential $100,000 a pop.  It strikes me that we may have a serious priority issue here.  Since we can’t all be fortunate enough to have the State of Oregon represent us when the RIAA attacks, when will our Congress revisit the enormous power granted this industry and provide a little proportionality to its citizens?  Maybe when Barbra Streisand retires?

Update:  As if there was ever any doubt that I was nowhere near cutting edge, there’s always Gideon to remind me.  Here’s the engadget post about how the RIAA takes the position that ripping legally purchased CDs and loading them on your computer is their new target.   Windypundit is less than thrilled at the prospect.  Be warned, if they hear you humming, you’re next.

“Injustice Anywhere Is A Threat To Justice Everywhere”

Martin Luther King understood.  But rather than employ the dreaded platitude as a substitute for thought, the question that still bangs around in my head is why Packratt, discussed here, cannot find a viable way to address what happened to him at the hands of the Seattle police. 

While we (somewhat) jokingly  attacked the concept of immunity for our beloved employees of the state for their rare occasional systemic abuse of authority, the potential of recovery and attorneys fees after the fact does little to help the victim of abuse to initiate an action.

On the one hand, after prevailing in the criminal prosecution, the defense lawyer’s work is done.  But for the innocent defendant who was beaten and injured in the process, the game isn’t over yet.  Not by a long shot.  In my experience, I’ve had some innocent defendants who, following the win of their prosecution, had become so consumed with anger that they could not move on with their lives.  These defendants suffered no physical injury, but the psychological impact was devastating to them.  They couldn’t let go, and some never recovered from the experience.  But the civil rights guys who I conferred with told me that the likelihood of significant recovery was so small as to make a 1983 suit a waste of time and money.  They wouldn’t take the case.

Other time, I’ve been told that in some federal jurisdictions, judges are so hostile to 1983 cases by white plaintiffs against the police that they will go out of their way to string the case along, cost the plaintiff a fortune in legal fees, and then toss the case on the eve of trial just to spite them.

These 1983 actions are not only available to provide compensation to victims of government violation of rights, but to provide a meaningful smack to the government, which views itself as above reproach no matter what it does wrong.  Is the remedy so totally inadequate that it no longer serves its purpose for the victims of wrongful arrest and physical injury at the hands of police?

Perhaps that is something about Packratt’s case that makes it undesirable to a civil rights lawyer on a contingency fee?  Or is there no good attorney in Seattle who takes these cases without money in his pocket?  I don’t know that market out there.  I know if I had been the criminal defense lawyer, I would have found a referral to a lawyer to handle the back end of the case.

And while Kent wants to add paying the defendant’s attorneys fees to the mix, to further threaten any plaintiff with the audacity to challenge the government, why has Packratt found it impossible to obtain counsel because of his inability, after paying for a criminal defense lawyer, to pay for a civil rights lawyer next?  It seems there should be a better way, and it seems that this case would be worthy of serious consideration, given the extent of injury (not to mention the potential to collect damages from a number of non-governmental sources as well, like the nightclub) to some enterprising lawyer in Seattle.  So why has Packratt been left to his own devises?

Is there no lawyer in Seattle who wants this case?

Everything Changes When It Happens to You

Thanks to Skelly, I found  this post at TechNomadic Packratt.  David, the Packratt, was the victim of the joys of how our system treats its own.  It rocked him to his core, as did the follow-up.  He has good reason to be angry about it, and angry he is. 

Assuming every word he writes it true, and I have no reason to doubt that it’s so, he brings a reminder to the table that he was one of them until he suffered personally.  This is how it usually happens, but then it happens to you, everything changes.

The writing was always on the wall.  It was there for you to see with a hundred, a thousand, ten thousand others, but it didn’t matter until it was you.  Packratt is angry now because he cannot find an attorney willing to sue the Seattle police, prosecutors and public defenders who did this to him.  He is  angry with Skelly because the only thing Skelly gained from Packratt’s experience was the phrase, “legal hobbyists.”   Skelly’s link had to do with Packratt’s intended suit against his public defenders, another rant against PDs because they can’t do the job that a private attorney can do when they carry 200 cases at a time.

Packratt, on a second blog,  Guilty Until Proven Innocent, narrates his effort and failure to find an attorney willing to take his case pro bono.  While non-lawyer commenters presume to point him toward the ACLU (which won’t take let him past the secretary) to bar associations to the assumptive position that “somebody should,” Packratt explains that no one would. 

No attorney will represent him against the myriad of wrongdoers without being paid.  Either no one explains, or he was unable to appreciate, that the ACLU represents ideas and positions, not particularized victims for personal compensation.  And surprisingly, there is no attorney who simply floats around the country taking on the cause of individuals harmed as a matter of principle listed in the phone book.

You might think that my purpose here is to explain why Packratt is wrong or misguided.  While there is much askew in his vision of what went wrong here, not to mention to grand irony that he would have never read his own blog had he not lived the experience.  There is no explaining away this anomaly, as it is precisely why he cannot find justice, whether his version or otherwise.  Everything changes when it happens to you, Packratt.  But it only changes for you, not for everyone else.

As for attorneys, we see it daily.  It angers us, and we wish we could cure these ills, but we also realize that it is an ongoing, constant fight.  Each individual’s situation does not become the central focus of our lives, to the exclusion of the hundred others in the same circumstances.  Packratt’s job is to write technical white papers, and I assume that you enjoy a paycheck for doing so.  Yet you begrudge attorney for not taking on your situation pro bono? 

The sad truth is that you are one of the many, and based on what I’ve read on your blog, your approach would scare off any lawyer who might be inclined to consider taking on your case, whether pro bono or for a reduced fee.  You are dogmatic.  We are practical.  You have lived an injustice.  There are a million injustices, and you are one of them. 

But Packratt is absolutely right.  There should be a way for someone who had experienced victimization at the hands of the police to achieve redress.  The legal system, with attorneys expecting to be paid, is not a good method for accomplishing this.  People in Packratt’s situation have nowhere to turn.  The mistaken fingers pointed at the ACLU are just wrong.  People who know nothing often make poor suggestions, which just seem to exacerbate the frustration.  There should be a place for Packratt to go for vindication of his rights without expense to him.  

But if there was, it too would be deluged with the thousand of angry, frustrated people who belief that their rights have been trampled, and that they, and they alone, have suffered the most egregious injury ever.  Packratt, I am not belittling what happened to you.  I am trying to give you some context to appreciate that everyone who has suffered like you believes that theirs is so horrific as to demand the attention of the world, rather than just another example of the nightmare of our government, police and legal system.  This really doesn’t express my point well, but I’m trying.  As I say, there should be a better way for you.

In a particularly good case, with a helpful and appropriate plaintiff, there are lawyers who will take the case on a contingent fee with only expenses paid up front.  Why Packratt cannot find such an attorney I do not know.  But this has been a huge learning experience for him, and he has already suffered a great deal by the dissembling of his secure world.  It was good that the criminal charges against him were dismissed.  I hope that he can find an attorney to represent him in an action against the appropriate parties. 

It would likely help if he steps back and stops demanding that others feel what he felt, and join in his anger and outrage that there is a wide world out there that bears no resemblance to the one he was comfortable in before this happened.  Remember, everything changes when it happens to you, Packratt. 

Pet Peeve of a Prosecutor: People

Kent Scheidegger of  Crime and Consequences posts about one of his pet peeves, what he calls the “asymmetric application of attorneys’ fee awards” stemming from people who challenge the government for violating the Constitution and their civil rights.  What pisses Kent off is


the way attorneys’ fees are awarded when people sue the government, asking courts to overturn policy decisions made through the democratic process. When plaintiffs win, they get attorneys’ fee awards routinely, while the government almost never gets an award for the cost of defending its perfectly legitimate, constitutional decision from an unwarranted attack.

Putting aside for the moment Kent’s value judgment, that whatever pops into the mind of the executive or legislative branch of government is sacrosanct, and by definition “perfectly legitimate” because he’s a company guy and the company says so, it’s impossible to say whether Kent is just blind or totally disingenuous. 

The government and the people are not the equivalent entities.  One serves the other.  Since this sentence may confuse Ken, I mean that the government serves the people.  The people do not exist to give the government someone to abuse for pleasure. 

One of the basic rights that people have is to question (except when it comes to speeding tickets, in which case they get tasered) and challenge the government when it makes rules, policies and laws that limit the legitimate freedom of people to pursue life, liberty and happiness.  It doesn’t mean that they will invariably win, since freedom is only one interest at stake, together with equality and order (if that paradigm suits your tastes), but that they get to try.  Without fear of being crushed financially for challenging the government.

And guess what, Kent?  You don’t have to personally approve of the things that matter to other people.  Whether you think it’s silly, trivial or inconsequential has nothing to do with it.  Perhaps you are not the ultimate arbiter of what matters in the world?  Each of these litigants is a human being who, for whatever reason, feels strongly enough about something to petition the courts for redress against the government.  This is how we do things in America.  Get used to it.

But this post is about Kent’s pet peeve, and he’s allowed to be annoyed by whatever he wants, no matter how foolish, misguided or vacuous.  And I will fight to the death for your right to be vacuous, Kent.  Even when it demonstrates such a wholesale lack of understanding or appreciation of the role of government relative to the people.

But I do have to tell you one of my pet peeves:  The people with your pet peeves are allowed to hold jobs where they can exercise discretion as to the lives of others.  Hey, we’re all allowed to have pet peeves, right?

What Should Criminal Defense Lawyers Sip on New Year’s Eve?

Lawprof Stephen Bainbridge has a blog devoted to wine and another somewhat related to law, if you squint a little when you read it.  If he can do it, so can I.  I know a little something about wine.  Don’t ask why.  It’s none of your business.

Today, we will discuss the subject of champagne, the traditional beverage of the huddled masses on New Year’s Eve.  I watched a segment this morning on one of the networks where they conducted a “non-scientific” test of champagnes to determine whether it was worth it to spend big bucks on the big names.  It was idiotic.

The test was done on the “posh” upper east side of Manhattan (as opposed to the upper east side with homeless people lying on steam grates to keep from freezing to death) at a wine store.  Random people were asked to test three wines, one an Italian sparkling wine, one an inexpensive bottle and the last Dom Perignon. 

Now, DP (as those who can’t afford Crystal call it) is grossly overrated to begin with, so the very nature of the test was flawed.  People who don’t know wine go for the name they recognize as being “expensive”, and hence good.  This is why God created marketing.  I’m not saying you can’t enjoy DP.  I’m saying that if you do, you reveal yourself as being pretentious yet tasteless.

Surprisingly, in this blind taste test, most preferred the sweet Italian spumante to the DP.  This is like asking people off the street if they prefer the taste of Osetra caviar to hotdogs.  The latter takes much less practice to enjoy, as proven by 270 million toddlers.

Roederer Crystal is a superb champagne, but its image has been tarnished by the hippy hoppers who swill it to prove that they will not hold on to their hard-earned income any longer than is absolutely necessary.  These are the same people who consider stretch hummers a sign of refinement.  If this is your self image, then Crystal is for you.  If you just happen to appreciate exceptional champagne, then drink Crystal in private, so no one will attempt to persuade you to trade in your Prius for an H2 (the H3 is unworthy of even minor recognition, by all accounts).

But this does not mean that there are not excellent Champagnes available at reasonable prices.  The reason you don’t know about them is that wine snobs would never be willing to admit that they liked a $15 bottle of champagne for fear of ridicule.  That’s right, there is such a thing as wine snobs, Bainbridge.

Before revealing my champagne recommendation, I ask you to take note of the truism that all champagnes taste fine after the third or fourth bottle, unless you are drinking with at least one other person, in which case it may take a little longer.  Do not let this influence your decision.  It is a false impression, similar to the idea that Miller is the champagne of bottled beer. 

So when you go out to purchase a beverage for Tuesday evenings festivities, whether you are in Texas or the United States, and wish to show your closest and dearest friends that you are possessed of exceptional taste without being a show-off wastrel, my recommendation is Gruet. 

Gruet uses “methode champenoise” to produce an excellent French sparkling wine at an exceptionally reasonable price.  Don’t confuse it with the New Mexico version.  By selecting Gruet, you will demonstrate not only your excellent taste in fine wine, but your genius in going outside the box to find a champagne that even a public defender can afford.  Enjoy.

(Note to Gruet Champagne people:  You can send a case to my office at your leisure for this unsolicited endorsement.)

Parole Is Again a Political Football

During the Pataki years, the idea of parole became something of an inside joke.  Under New York’s indeterminate sentencing structure, a judge would sentence a defendant to a term of, say, 15 to life for an A-1 felony with the expectation that if he behaved and made some use of his prison time, he would be paroled after 15 years. 

This changed under Gov. Pataki, when the parole board began operating like a super-judge, deciding that 15 to life wasn’t harsh enough and, based solely on the nature of the underlying offense, denying parole wholesale in order to assure that defendants prison terms would run an extra 5 or 10 years beyond what the judge imposed.

According to the New York Times, our Democratic Governor, and former hard-line prosecutor, Eliot Spitzer, has no greater faith in the judiciary than his predecessor.  Inmates sued to compel the parole board to follow the law and put an end to their practice of refusing to release prisoners on parole because they decided that the judges’ sentences weren’t harsh enough.  The issue was about to be settled, when word was floated to the media.  That was the end of that.

Long-time President of the Patrolmans Benevolent Association, Patrick Lynch, did his job.  He went public and pushed the buttons that makes people get nervous and stupid.  Don’t blame Lynch for it, as it’s not his job to be fair to anyone other than his cops.  He never had been fair or thoughtful, and that’s what cops love most about him.


Patrick J. Lynch, president of the Patrolmens Benevolent Association in New York City, who said, “Violent felons should not be eligible for parole, and cop killers should stay incarcerated for life.”

Who can argue with such logic?  Well, aside form the idea that if “violent felons” receive the same sentence as “cop killers,” then the law has provided an incentive to kill cops rather than not.  But Lynch isn’t there to promote sound sentencing policy.  He’s there to speak for the cops, and embarrass public officials into pandering to the people who can’t be bothered to think very hard. 

So, the suit against the State continues, with the inmates being given class status.

The lawsuit by the inmates charged that prisoners eligible for parole were denied their constitutional rights during the Pataki administration because of what they said was the board’s unwritten policy of rejecting parole in most of the cases solely because of the severity of the crime. The lawsuit said the board failed to also take into account, as required, the degree of remorse or rehabilitation or the likelihood that the inmate would commit another crime if released.

What is crucial in understanding the point of this suit is that it is not, as Lynch would suggest, about what sentence a violent felon or even a cop killer should receive.  The sentence is imposed by a judge, who is part of that good old third branch of government, the judiciary. 

The reason the judge is in a third branch is to protect the ability to make a reasoned determination from the transitory whims of the public that force politicians in other branches to ignore or violate the law and Constitution to appease the electorate and win their hearts of the ignorant.  They would also try to win their minds, but the prize is too small to be worth the effort.

So long before a prisoner appears before the parole board, an arm of the executive branch of government, a judge has exercised her function by imposing sentence.  It is not the job of the parole board to pass judgment on the severity of the sentence.  In fact, they are precluded from doing so by their mandate.


In the spring . . . Mr. Spitzer’s new chairman of the State Parole Board, George B. Alexander, reminded his fellow commissioners that they were obligated to consider the potential for rehabilitation, remorse and recidivism as well as the severity of the original crime.

The point of an open back-ended sentence is that there be a stick available should prisoners act badly in prison, fail to use the time to try to improve their lot and consider how their anti-social conduct affected others.  These are the legitimate objectives of a sentence, even though most people think of a sentence as merely a punishment, unrelated to any other purpose.  An “eye for an eye” approach.

So it appears that New York, by electing a Democrat, might have a chance of correcting an expensive and ill-conceived approach to this affront to the authority of the judiciary, the Constitution and the intelligence of its citizens.  Instead, we are back to a governor who feels more comfortable appeasing his old friends, the PBA and the voters who can be easily bought with some “tough on crime” posturing.  SNAFU.

It will likely be years until the class action reaches a decision.  That should bring a smile to Patrick Lynch’s face.

The New York Football Giants Win The Big Game!

The talk on sports radio this week was how foolish Tom Coughlin would be if he played his started against the New England Patriots, risking injury and a loss in the wild card playoff game against the Tampa Bay Bucs.  I listened to this drivel, but knew that Coughlin would never consider blowing off a game.  This was football.  You just go out and play.

It’s been hard being a Giants fan.  Sure, they have the occasional great quarter of football, but they haven’t play a great game since they beat the Minnesota Vikings 41-0 in the 2001 playoffs.  When they win, it’s ugly.  It’s by the skin of their teeth.

Eli Manning hasn’t been as bad a quarterback as most people say.  The problem is that he’s not as good as everyone hoped.  He’s a Manning, but he’s no Peyton.  He does a yeoman’s job week after week, but he will never be a franchise player.  There will be no songs about him when he’s gone.

There were the Ray Handley years, with the ridiculous looking “Authentic Giants NFL Clothing” and losing.  This was the hardest time I can recall being a Giants fan. 

There have been bright spots over the years.  Tiki was a great player, despite the criticism of his off-field comments.  Lawrence Taylor was in a league of his own, but it’s been a very long time since he dumped Joe Theisman.



It’s unlikely that the NFL will ever have another Lawrence Taylor.  Michael Strahan comes close, but is not quite the powerhouse that Taylor presented on defense.  While the Giants defense has done well sacking quarterbacks this year, and Oci is poised to replace Strahan, it will always be in the tradition of Taylor.

Last night, the Giants played the Patriots.  If the Giants won, the game would be good for a week of sports radio talk and then forgotten.  Nobody cares about a team that almost had a perfect season.  It only matters if they accomplished it.  They did.  Brady is possibly the most likable guy who ever led a team.  Like Joe Montana, without flash.  He just seems to work hard, keep his head down, and push through whatever wall is in front of him to win games.  It is in the best tradition of the game.  He is a great quarterback.

But there will be plenty of people extolling Brady’s virtues.  Today is for the Giants.  Their 38-35 loss to the Pats was the best football the Giants have played in years.  More importantly, it was the best football they have played, and it was against a great team.  I could not have been prouder of the Giants.

They came to play, and play they did.  The focus and energy and will were palpable.  They aren’t the most talented football team around, and as already noted, they are led by a quarterback who will never meet expectations.  But they rose to the occasion.  They played above themselves.  They played this “meaningless” game like they were real football players.  It was thrilling to watch.

Sure, there was that one series in the fourth quarter where the old Giants were back.  Eli dropped the snap.  Toomer dropped the pass.  Eli floated one for an interception.  Eli waste two out of the last four minutes doing . . . nothing.  But they played football.  A whole game of it. 

The best team won the game.  Of this, there can be no doubt.  The Patriots are a great team, and may well prove to be the best team of all-time if they can parlay their perfect season into a Super Bowl win.  But the New York Football Giants won the Big Game too, by proving that they are better than they really are, and showing the fortitude to play above their abilities in the Big Game.  It was a great game, and I was proud last night to be a Giants fan.

There’s No Privacy in Cellphone Nation

Question:  What’s worse than the feds being able to track your whereabouts and know what you’re doing through your cellphone?

Answer:  Marketers doing it.

It was no doubt inevitable that our nation of imaginative folks would find a way to turn the utility of a cellphone against us.  It just a matter of time.  According to this report, it’s all but a done deal, with cellphone companies set to make a fortune from marketers as soon as they can figure out some way to do it without pissing all their customers off.  Thankfully, no one has explained to them that if they all do it at the same time, then customers can be as angry as they want, but will have no place to turn for privacy.  Oh nuts.  I hope no one read that last thing.

Unlike other people I know, I am not a cellphone aficionado.  I don’t turn my phone on unless I have to make a call to someone.  When my contract expires, I get whatever phone they are giving away for free that day, and feel no warmth from the status of carrying the coolest phone around.  On the contrary, I feel rather proud of my thrifty decision.

But others disagree with me.  My sister (and every member of her family) can only be reached by cellphone, limiting my conversations with her to two out of every three words spoken.  I’ve yet to miss anything consequential.  Strangely, I envision her liking this new marketing miracle.


Imagine getting pitches for rental cars and hotels the moment you land in San Francisco because an analysis of past calls suggests you tend to take week long trips there. Or if day trips to Boston are your thing, you might get an offer for cab service instead.

Are consumers going to be spooked by the idea that suddenly their phone goes beep and it’s a Starbucks offer, and they are standing next to a Starbucks?”

I can see her thinking this is the greatest thing since sliced bread, a coupon the second she needs it.  Needless to say, heavy cellphone users also tend to favor $5 cups of flavored coffee.

The cellphone industry has been reluctant to let marketers inside for fear of a backlash of privacy concerns, not to mention the potential for customers freaking out when they realize how they are being targeted.   Not that I am unconcerned about the privacy issues (indeed, I am), but I even more deeply concerned about the annoyance factor. 

The other day, I received a text message.  It was the second I’ve ever received (the first came from a young lawyer who now knows better), and it pumped some penny stock.  When my bill came, I found that I was charged 15 cents for the pleasure of the message.  Now I know it’s not much, but how in the world does some pump and dump house end up costing me money?  I told my cellphone provider that I want to block all text messages and I refuse to pay for them.  They laughed and laughed.  They must think us old-timers are just hysterically funny.

Maybe I’m just wrong on this technological breakthrough.  I certainly realize that others have so much to say to so many people that they are on their cellphones every waking moment, especially when they are driving in an SUV full of children.  Perhaps these marketing messages will just expand their joy.  Perhaps I will be the only person left in America with my cellphone off who doesn’t check his incoming messages to see whether it includes a Starbucks coupon.  I don’t know.  But I still think this is a horrible development.


Fear Not, Ohio is Safe Again

Following up on  my discussion of underutilized police and prosecution resources comes this important story from Columbus Ohio, via ABC News.



Robin Garrison, an off-duty 42-year-old firefighter, was walking in Berliner Park in Columbus, Ohio, in May when he saw a woman sunbathing topless under a tree. He approached her and they started talking and getting comfortable, the woman smiling and resting her foot on his shoulder at one point. Eventually, she asked to see Garrison’s penis; he unzipped his pants and complied. Seconds later, undercover police officers pulled up in a van and arrested Garrison


Does this not tell you that the cops in Columbus have way too much time on their hands?  Mind you, this “undercover” police woman had been there for days, just waiting for the chance to put her foot on some guy’s shoulder.  This beat sounds almost as exciting as the cop who had to hang out in the airport bathroom waiting for a Senator to toe tap.  And just like the toilet cop, she must have been trained in foot placement to induce some sicko firefighter to be overcome with penile revelation.  This is another trick that you should never try at home.

And why are the police, both underdressed officers and back up teams, spending day after day awaiting the opportunity to nab some perv with foot issues?

Law enforcement officials say that such sting operations are an extremely effective means of lowering crime rates and stopping the criminally minded before they commit worse offenses.

See how that “extremely effective means” language pops up all the time to explain why cops get to do stuff that is either wrong, deceptive or just plain stupid, and get away with it?  But at least Columbus is safe should this firefighter consider seeking out a topless sunbathing cop who might put two feet on his respective shoulders.  I shudder to think what “worse offense” he might then commit.

Lest you think that this is the sort of silly case that was tossed by an incredulous prosecutor, or slam dunked by an offended jury of tax-paying Columbians,


At Garrison’s trial, his attorney argued that it was a case of entrapment. “Columbus police utilized this topless woman to snare this man,” said Sam Shamansky. “He sees her day after day. He’s not some seedy pervert.” [Ed. Note: regular pervert?]


The argument failed to sway a Franklin County Municipal Court jury that found Garrison guilty of public indecency last month. He was ordered to stay away from the park, placed on a year’s probation and fined $250.


Sleep well tonight, good people of Columbus, Ohio.  You are safe.

Tankleff’s Out, Now What?

The saga of Marty Tankleff is fascinating from a neutral perspective, as it offers insight into the anatomy of a murder case when you have 17 years to revisit every detail.  But it also offers a view of certain failings of our trial process to get to the truth.  While truth is a commodity that rarely concerns lawyers (except when it’s on their side), it’s the sort of thing that the public expects from its legal system.  At least in theory.

The Tankleff defense team now faces some very high hurdles should there be a retrial.  It’s easy to talk in the media about how some other guy committed the murder of Marty’s parents, and how his cohorts have privately told people that they were involved.  The media doesn’t have to worry about hearsay, relevancy or the 5th Amendment privilege of some guys commonly referred to in the newspapers with the derogatory characterization of “ex-cons.” 

Consider what you would do if you were in charge of the retrial.  How do you plan to compel the testimony of witnesses who you claim were involved in the murder?  While they may have talked out of court, they aren’t getting up on the stand to tell the world about it.  We know this because they have already denied it under oath.  But they are ex-cons?  So what?  Even ex-cons can assert their privilege against self-incrimination.  And the District Attorney doesn’t have to give them immunity just because it’s good for you.  After all, they could be murderers, if the defense is to be believed.

Even if the DA conferred immunity on these skels, there’s no guarantee that they are going to admit that they were involved in the murders. As of now, they aren’t under indictment and they have nothing to fear.  If they just deny involvement, game over.  Team Tankleff can’t prove they are lying.  They can try to bring in collateral evidence to show that they have said they were involved, but it’s questionable whether it would be permitted and even if it is, it’s certainly of questionable weight. 

We still have the confession problem as well.  While today, the idea of a false confession is far better understood than it could possibly have been 17 years ago, it remains an iffy proposition.  Most people would be of the view that they would not confess to a murder they didn’t commit, particularly if it involved their parents.  But Det. James McCready lied to Marty and manipulated him when he was under unbearable duress?  True, but lying to witnesses to get them to confess is a time-honored tradition in police work, like eating donuts.  As courts like to instruct jurors, it is an “effective law enforcement tool.”  So are brass knuckles.

While there are certainly a wealth of details and issues that are floating around in the sorry case of Marty Tankleff that could undermine reasonable doubt in the case against him, it is by no means a foregone conclusion that the Tankleff defense team will be able to use them at trial, and even if they can, that their use will be effective to challenge the prosecution’s case.

Ironically, it’s just been disclosed in the  New York Times that the State Investigation Commission has been secretly investigating the Suffolk County District Attorney’s handling of this case.  This has been going on for a year, according to the report, though there is no comment on what they have been doing for the year and why it would take them so long to investigate.

This could be the best thing, or the worst thing, that could happen to the Tankleff defense.  If the SIC goes public with a report of prosecutorial misconduct, police perjury, suppression of witnesses or evidence, then there will be unbearable pressure to drop the prosecution.

On the other hand, the SIC could also conclude that the prosecution did nothing wrong.  Remember, the use of lies and deception to get targets to confess is a time-honored tradition.  Would the SIC want to announce that this “effective law enforcement tool” is improper?  So, there are conflicting theories of who killed Seymour and Arlene Tankleff.  That doesn’t mean that the Suffolk County DA chose the wrong theory and prosecuted the wrong person.

Trials are supposed to be searches for the truth.  This case, should it be retried, will present some interesting issues about truth.  Perhaps it will be an opportunity for a public airing on the propriety of police duplicity and underhanded tactics by a detective who was conflicted all over the place, lied under oath and ignored evidence pointing to others, who later paid him for his services.  We’ll see how much truth our legal system will allow Marty Tankleff.  The defense has it’s work cut out for them