As noted on Freakonomics, crime is down. Not only is it down, but it’s been going down for a decade. That stats are there, though you would hardly know it since we read about the horrific crimes that happen with such frequency that one can’t help but be left with the impression that crime is rampant. It’s not.
In the criminal defense business, we see falling crime rates happening in real time. The end of year indictment numbers in New York are in the 4 digits, like Indictment Number 6347/2007. Ten years ago, the last indictment of the year would have been closer to 29641/1997. That’s an awful lot of business off the table for criminal defense lawyers. Sure, a jaded statement, but we can’t defend people who aren’t getting arrested, now can we?
But the gross numbers only tell part of the story. The nature of crime has shifted. Serious crime, such as homicides and major drug cases, are substantially down. The “quality” cases are few and far between. This is good for society, bad for lawyers and problematic for those poor miscreants who get arrested for junk offenses.
In the old days, police and prosecutorial resources were focused on big cases, the ones on the upper end of the felony spectrum. There were only so many prosecutors to go around, and they weren’t going to waste them on small potatoes, like simple weapons possessions or dime bag heroin sales. These lower level cases were throw-aways, move them in and out and clear out the dockets for the players. With cops tied up closing murder cases, who can bother with your garden variety assaults.
But today, there isn’t enough big stuff to keep the State busy. When society was adrift in crime, they added tons of resources to combat the “plague” of crime. Budgets bulged. Courtrooms were opened. Prosecutors were hired. The State was ready. So when things shifted, and knowing that no arm of government ever says that they have more money or staff than they need, so did the focus.
Without big guys to go after, they prosecutors make every offense the most vile crime in the world. Jail time is demanded on misdemeanors that would have gotten 12 hours of community service a decade ago. Drunk driving is the new murder. Crimes that nobody thought twice about have become the greatest threat to civilization since the Wii. This is what happens when they don’t have enough to do.
While criminal defense lawyers may bemoan the lack of quality cases, since defendants see less need for our services when they aren’t facing the rest of their natural lives in prison, the sharp decline in real crime over the past 10 years is a good thing for America. But maybe it’s time to readjust our perspective on the allocation of scarce resources, rather than turn jaywalking into a capital offense. Just because we have extra room in our prisons these days doesn’t mean that we need to fill it.
Author Archives: SHG
The 437 Most Important Rules for Blawging Blawgers Who Blawg
The end of the year is a wonderful time to make lists, and lots of people have done so. But not me. There are so many lists already that there’s nothing left to make another list about. So instead of making a list (I was only joshing abut the 437), I’m going to offer my most thoughtful comment about a list made by another blawger, Susan Cartier Leibel, of Build A Solo Practice.
I do this not merely because she’s put together one darn good list, but because I want to win her “I want to be a solo because ______” contest (here’s my entry; pretty good, right?), and I’m trying desperately to kiss up after banging her a bit on her anti-Avvo rampage. You know how some people hold a grudge, right? Well, not Susan. Nope. She’s a much bigger person than that. It would be beneath her dignity to hold a grudge against me and not make me the winner of the contest. Is it working yet? Geez, I hope so.
Anyway, Susan has posted her list of 7 Things I hate about Avvo Things I learned in 2007, and I think it is one terrific list. I didn’t learn nearly that much in 2007. In fact, I can’t even remember most of 2007. Or 2004. Years 2005 through 6 are pretty clear, though, but not much happened during that time that really matters, so it’s hardly worth mentioning.
Back to Susan’s list. This is my favorite (for real, no kidding around now) one:
3. If you are afraid to be who you really are, don’t be on the internet. You cannot maintain falsity if you are using the internet. It is exhausting to create a persona and it simply cannot be realistically sustained for any length of time. And once you are outed, your reputation is damaged in perpetuity in digitized form. You don’t need everyone to be a client in order to be successful, just the clients who can relate to the lawyer or business person that you legitimately are.
Wussy. That’s right. Susan is calling you a wussy, a girlie man, a liberal, a pantywaist, is you don’t have the balls to take the weight for whatever you’ve got to say. You go, Girl! And she’s right.
The blawgosphere is filled with tough guys posting their nonsense, and they’re all named “anon”. Yeah, right. You’re tough. Like a bowl of tough, quivering, scaredy-cat jello, you’re tough. We laugh at you. Hah!
But Susan is really aiming this at the blawgomeisters who are so deathly scared of posting something that might scare away a potential client. After all, God forbid that a potential client thinks you actually believe in something, have passion for something, have a set of balls. Nobody would want THAT in a lawyer.
So here’s my 2 cents to add to Susan’s post about “outing”, which I think presents a needlessly confused sexual orientation to her already striking point. If you try to be someone you’re not, then there’s a chance that you will be me. Do you have any idea how confusing that would be? There’s not a chance in the world that I am going to let you take over my house, or even go near the Healey, so there’s no point in even dreaming that you’re going to drive the Healey if you are pretending to be me. It’s not happening.
That’s right. This is the Healey that you will never drive, even if you aren’t you and become me. Never, I say.
Besides, if you are busy trying to be someone other than who you really are, you’ve squandered an opportunity to let other know that there’s some substance to you. People admire substance. Let others in the blawgosphere know who you are, come to admire you for what you contribute, and then find out to your shock and surprise that the real you has something to offer the rest of us and the real clients who need a real lawyer to represent them in their real life. Try it. You never know.
David Tarrell, Criminal Defense Lawyer of the Year 2007
David Tarrell is a recent immigrant (from Omaha, wherever that is) to the practical blawgosphere with his blawg, In The Moment. He came onto my radar with a post about a rather routine court appearance where the judge insisted on having a chat directly with his client.
It probably wouldn’t have done any harm if David had just kept his mouth shut and let the talk happen. The episode would have passed without incident, and no one would have thought twice about it. But David was the lawyer, and as the lawyer, stood in that wonderful spot in the well right between the judge and the defendant.
David politely sought to get the judge to direct her attention to him, rather than the defendant. The judge spoke to David like he was some gnat bothering her, to be swatted away so she could get on with whatever it was she wanted to do, unaffected by his existence. David was not so easily deterred.
Rather than demonstrate a modicum of respect for the role David played in the courtroom and the legal system as defense counsel, the judge immediately threatened him with contempt for his refusal to “be still.” David again had a choice to make. He could back off, and confirm the judge’s belief that he was inconsequential in his role as defense counsel. Or he could stand firm and do his job, at the risk of being held in contempt. David stood his ground.
It’s not that this incident reflects a picture perfect response to an overreaching judge, or an incident that one hopes to create through intransigence or disrespect. It was simply a brief snapshot of how a lawyer, without any reason to anticipate a confrontation, finds himself forced to make a decision as to whether he wants to fulfill his role in the scheme of the criminal justice system or play dead to appease a judge or just avoid confrontation at the expense of his client. This represents the sort of everyday decisions that defense lawyers are required to make, and David’s choice, as a young lawyer faced with potentially harsh consequences, showed the fortitude that reflects the finest of the criminal defense bar.
And so, David Tarrell is our Criminal Defense Lawyer of the Year 2007.
Here is a copy of the transcript from David’s confrontation:
(At 11:45 a.m., on January 26, 2006 in the Separate Juvenile Court for Douglas County, Nebraska, before the HONORABLE ELIZABETH G. CRNKOVICH, with Ms. Kristin Huber appearing on behalf of the State; with Mr. David Tarrell appearing on behalf of the minor child; and with the minor child Larry ****** being personally present with his mother, the following proceedings were had: )
THE COURT: What’s the matter, Larry?LARRY ******: (nodded head)
Mrs. ******: She’s talking to you.
LARRY ******: I said nothing.
Mrs. *****: No you didn’t.
THE COURT: No, you didn’t. When I walked in, you’re very—it was – I don’t want to start anything, but I, I want you to know that, that you—you’ve got the judge you’ve have and—Mr. Tarrell, can I talk to your client for a moment?
MR. TARRELL: Well, I—
THE COURT: Can I talk to him, please, for a minute?
MR. TARRELL: Yeah, I’m – you know, I’m—
THE COURT: Thank you.
MR. TARRELL: Judge, you know—
THE COURT: Thank you, I’m just going to visit with him for a second.
MR. TARRELL: Judge, you know what—
THE COURT: You- Just a moment. Mr. Tarrell, if you do not be still, I’ll find you in contempt.
MR. TARRELL: You can find me in contempt.
THE COURT: All right.
MR. TARRELL: I think it’s important that I talk to my client, okay, Judge.
THE COURT: All right. Just a moment. Just a moment.
MR. TARRELL: If you want me to play a role here, then let me play that role.
THE COURT: I’d like a sheriff please, thank you.
MR. TARRELL: I think it’s important for me—
THE COURT: Just a moment. If you open your mouth, I will incarcerate you; do you understand?
MR. TARRELL: I think I should get a chance.
THE COURT: All right. I’m finding you in contempt of court because you have refused to follow the court’s order to be still. I need a sheriff.
(Deputy sheriffs entered the courtroom at this time)
[Note: When the sheriffs came in, they were responding to a “panic button” so three of them ran into the courtroom, the first one holding a taser. When they saw a calm situation, with everyone sitting in their seats, they looked surprised. So I stood up in my seat, and stuck my hands out behind me so they could cuff me. I was thinking at the time that the judge probably wanted me to beg to not be arrested, so I was “calling her bluff” by doing this. When I did this, she slammed her hand down on the bench and screamed the next line at me. The rest of the conversation is a battle over the record, as she’s trying to make it seem as if I’m not complying with her orders and I’m trying to show everything that is going on]
THE COURT: Sir, Mr. Tarrell, sit down, sit down in your seat now.
MR. TARRELL: Your honor–
THE COURT: Sit down and be still, sit down. I have three deputies here. I am ordering you this last time to sit in that chair. Are you refusing?
MR. TARRELL: Your honor, I need to make a record.
THE COURT: Are you refusing? Yes or no?
MR. TARRELL: I will sit down in the chair, but I need to make a record.
THE COURT: Thank you. We have a clear record here.
MR. TARRELL: I don’t think we do.
THE COURT: You are in contempt of this court. I am ordering the deputies to take you back at this moment.
MR. TARRELL: Your honor, what I want to put on the record is—
THE COURT: Deputies, now.
MR. TARRELL: I think I should—
THE COURT: Stop, we do not have a record. I have ordered him to be removed.
MR. TARRELL: It doesn’t have to be this way.
THE COURT: I know that sir, it didn’t have to be this way.
MR. TARRELL: I’d like to try to play the role that you want me to play.
THE COURT: Go, go.
MR. TARRELL: Okay. I’m not going to be intimidated by you. I’m trying to do my job, the job you asked me to do. Now, please put that on the record. It’s not fair.
(MR. TARRELL exited the courtroom at this time)THE DEPUTY: Would you like me to stay ,or?
THE COURT: No, I’m not having any difficulty with anybody else. I was just going to have a conversation with the young man.
THE DEPUTY: Sure. If you needed me to stay. I was just asking.
THE COURT: No, that’s fine. Just hang on to Mr. Tarrell for a moment, please.
Young man, I’d like to explain where I was beginning, but under the circumstances, it would not be appropriate because your lawyer doesn’t need to be with you. Let me say that you remain in good hands in terms of your legal representation. I think there was just clearly something else going on , and the court has a responsibility to maintain its authority, so I’m going to take a recess. You may be excused.
(a brief recess was taken and all parties exited the courtroom.)[Note: they took me into the back room, where they book prisoners into jail. The deputies all treated me very well and it seemed like they hated to be doing what she told them to do. I was wearing an antique watch and one deputy offered to keep it safe for me as they told me to take it off for processing into jail. I had my shoes, tie, and watch off when the judge called the sheriff’s phone and told them to bring me back into the courtroom]
(the proceedings reconvened with only Mr. Tarrell present in the courtroom.)
THE COURT: Mr. Tarrell, are you ready to listen for just a moment?
MR. TARRELL: Sure.
THE COURT: All right. No. 1, my experience with you has been that you are a fine and dedicated lawyer who more than adequately represents your clients in juvenile court, and that impression has not changed.
No. 2, it matters not your opinion of the court in a professional way because the fact remains that I am the judge in this court and when I issue a command, it is required to follow that command.
Now, what you did not know is what I observed when I walked in, and I made an effort to relate to and communicate with your client merely to set the stage so that we could proceed. I do understand, because I also observed this, you were attempting to communicate with him, and I have no doubt that you were trying to tell him, hey, shape up, so that he would not then get himself in trouble with the court. However, the court had a handle on it, and the court was addressing your client. Everything that transpired from that point when I asked you to cease was contemptuous of the court and, I must suggest, of this particular Judge, and I will not tolerate it.
Now, you stated truly that it didn’t have to lead to this, and I agree with you. But you have to reflect that not once but at least six times in the course of ten minutes you refused to follow a directive of this court, either to be still and/or to sit down. I did not escalate this.
I do not wish to find you in contempt. I do not wish to incarcerate you. I do not wish to have this kind of exaggerated incident happen again . It doesn’t serve you, it doesn’t serve the bench, and it doesn’t serve the kids and the families.
Now, I took a recess. This may not be the time to address the two boys and their family. I am happy to continue it until after lunch when calm and reason can prevail or to another day. I will give you an opportunity to talk to your clients. I will allow you to leave freely and without the deputy. You may be excused.
(12: 06 p.m. adjournment accordingly)
Who Needs Starr Jones When We’ve Got Ken
Ken Lammers of CrimLaw is the newest TV star of the blawgosphere. Sure, he may not look like George Clooney, but then not many of us do. In his latest iteration, CLTV, Ken brings us a podcast of what’s going on in the practical blawgosphere, and does it with panache. You go, Ken!
Some of you may think that this is an easy thing to do. Nah Uh. Not only has Ken put a great deal of effort into the production values (I love the 911 intro), but it’s not easy getting that folksy, natural atmosphere that makes you just want to convict whenever Ken starts talking. It’s a gift, and I have no doubt that there’s a cable channel out there somewhere that’s going to snatch him up any day now. So watch the video now, before he’s a big star doing shoe commercials, and you can say that you knew him “when”.
Click here to see the video that my stinky program can’t make work. I guess it doesn’t like me. So get some popcorn and then watch the video. By the way guys, this is great for date night, so you may want to kick back and have a little bubbly on hand. Just in case.
27CDB6E-AE6D-11cf-96B8-444553540000>
On a side note, Ken mentions my little blawg (near the end, after all the important big time blawgs have been exhausted), and dredges up my “Official Woman” post from last summer, about 497 posts ago. So either Ken doesn’t stop by here too often, or he just didn’t think much of anything I’ve posted since then. Well, I’ll just have to try harder to get something onto Ken’s radar.
Personal note to Ken: Horizontal stripes? Shame on you.
Blawging is Easy, Right?
Kevin O’Keefe, who (as he likes to say) has some skin in this race, takes issue with the New York Times (who doesn’t?) at Real Lawyers Have Blogs. It seems that writer Marci Alboher, after writing that blogs are a great marketing tool for lawyers, which Kevin liked a lot, went a spoiled the mood by posting that blogging takes a lot of work. This made Kevin sad.
Hence, the latest salvo from Kevin was that Marci “exaggerated” the effort needed to produce a good blawg. I’m with Kevin, and Marci used to be smart and good-looking but now is an evil woman. Not only is blogging (Kevin hates the new-fangled specialty word “blawg” for law blogs, so I’m going with Kevin’s version) easy, but it’s fun to do!
A Harvard Business School newsletter talked of one post a week for a business blog. I preach that with LexBlog’s hundreds of lawyer clients who are blogging. I also tell them to try get their blog posts down to half hour or so. Many spend more time, but that’s because they are enjoying the process and growing their network and business as a result of their blogging.
A half hour once a week. That’s all it takes. And you too can be a blogger (note spelling). It’s kinda like those thigh-buster things that Suzanne Summers hawked on late night TV that only took a half hour once a week and you too can get a role on a sitcom.
Well, maybe it takes a little more than that. See, here’s the rub. If you are blawging (oops, spelling relapse) as an outlet to express your views on subjects that interest you, then you really don’t do it to promote yourself or your law practice, and neither “rules” nor hits drive you. But if your purpose is to market, then there’s a catch.
If you post once a week, nobody will notice. If you post nothing of substance, then nobody will ever return. If you simply replicate some bit of news or someone else’s post and call it your own, then there’s no reason for you to bother. No one is going to pay attention to your blog if you give them no reason to do so.
Time is a commodity. We all have things to do, and reading blawgs isn’t always the most important thing on our list. Sure, plenty of people enjoy reading blawgs, and find it an excellent way to keep abreast of news and commentary, but why would these people spend their time checking out a blog that posts sporadically or has nothing to add to the conversation?
There are a number of blawgs around the practical blawgosphere that I really enjoy, but don’t post regularly. I’m sorry to say that they fall off my list of daily reads because of this. I go back to those blawgs that I find interesting and have something new on a regular basis. It’s just a matter of the allocation of scarce resources, time.
I realize that everyone doesn’t post with the “alarming” frequency that I do. For me, this not only comes very easily, but I enjoy writing very much. I would do this even if there was no such thing as blawgs (and I did for many years, ghostwriting op-eds and letter to the editor for others). In the same half hour that somebody not inclined toward writing will create a single post, I can do a half dozen.
But that’s me, and means nothing for you. If this doesn’t come easily to you, or doesn’t fill a desire to express views, then this is tedious. I can’t imagine a day when there isn’t something that I want to write about. The news is filled with matters of consequence, and a news-junkie like me can’t stop his dancing fingers from putting words to computer screen. Whether the words are any good is a subject for debate, but it fulfills my purposes and apparently there are a bunch of people who come back here regularly to read what I write, whether because they agree or just want to rubber-neck my personal car crash.
If you want to make a dent in the blawgosphere, you’re going to need to put in some effort. Not just the effort of producing content, but content that someone else will care enough about to look at and content that appears with sufficient regularity that people will come back to see what you have to say.
Once a week is not going to cut it if you want people to read your stuff and pay attention to you. You then become relegated to the trash heap of lawyers trying to establish an obvious marketing presence on the internet by doing the bare minimum to pretend that you have something meaningful to say. No one is fooled by this, and no one will bother coming back for a second look. Worse still, you brand yourself as self-promoter, attempting to weasel in to the blawgosphere without having the goods to justify your bandwidth. Once that happens, the chances of anyone taking you seriously are over.
The blawgosphere can be a tough neighborhood. It rewards those who consistently provide worthwhile content, but those who try to play it for self-aggrandizement are quickly branded as worthless and will soon find that they wasted their time and money. If you really are a lawyer with something to add to the conversation, then why would you even consider trying to game the blawgosphere with a post once a week in orde to pretend that you’re a blogger? Why bother? Because you’re “too busy?” Nonsense. Busy people find time to do whatever they need to do. If you’re that busy, then you’re probably not as good at what you do as you think.
So Kevin is absolutely right. Blogging is easy. And the blawgosphere will let you know whether you will survive. And if you need a good example of content that keeps readers coming back, read Kevin’s blog, Real Lawyers Have Blogs. You know that he does a little more than put up one post a week. Kevin knows what he’s doing.
Marty Tankleff Free on Bail
He’s now 36 years old. He was 17 when his parents were murdered. Today, following the reversal of his conviction and grant of a new trial, the New York Times reports that he has been released on $1,000,000 bond, posted by his relatives.
Here’s Marty going in.
Here’s Marty coming out.
Out is definitely better than in. By the way, that’s Bob Gottlieb, Marty’s original trial lawyer standing with him in the picture. Bob used to be younger too.
The DA has announced that he’s going to retry that case. He figures that even if he loses, he had Tankleff in prison for 17 years. But he’ll have an awfully hard time putting witnesses together again, and he’ll look particularly bad and vindictive if the defense kicks his butt.
The District Attorney, Thomas Spota, may want to view it from a different perspective. Give Marty some plea that cuts him loose immediately, and then tell the media what a great job you did protecting the public from the innocent. It could work. The good people of Suffolk County, New York, have other things to worry about these days than Marty Tankleff.
U.S Military: Torture Confessions Are AOK!
Lt. Commander Andrew Williams resigned his commission in the United States Navy. It seems that his pride in serving in the Judge Advocate General’s Corps waned after the CIA destroyed videotapes and Brigadier General Hartmann, chief legal adviser at the Pentagon’s Office of Military Commissions, was unable to say that the Military Commissions instituted to try enemy combatants would not use statements obtained through “waterboarding”, which used to be known as torture before it was adopted by the United States as “enhanced interrogation techniques.”
Williams, 43, felt that Hartmann was admitting torture is now an acceptable interrogation technique in the United States — an admission that did not sit well with him.
“There was this saying in the Marines: ‘We don’t lie, cheat or steal, or tolerate people who do,’ ” Williams said. “And that sort of echoed through the Navy.”
But Hartmann isn’t Navy, and he’s still wearing the uniform proudly. Williams doesn’t expect his resignation letter to cause anyone in the military to lose sleep, but it allows him to sleep a little better.
“Thank you General Hartmann for finally admitting the United States is now part of a long tradition of torturers going back to the Inquisition. In the middle ages the Inquisition called waterboarding “toca” and used it with great success. In colonial times, it was used by the Dutch East India Company during the Amboyna Massacre of 1623.
“Waterboarding was used by the Nazi Gestapo and the feared Japanese Kempeitai. In World War II, our grandfathers had the wisdom to convict Japanese Officer Yukio Asano of waterboarding and other torture practices in 1947 giving him 15 years hard labor. Waterboarding was practiced by the Khmer Rouge at the infamous Tuol Sleng prison. Most recently, the United States Army court martialed a soldier for the practice in 1968 during the Vietnam conflict.”
But it’s all different now, apparently, since it’s now the United States employing torture to get what it wants. Since we’re the good guys, and whatever we use it for will be for good (not evil, like the Nazis), everything is okay.
Of course, when Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-South Carolina) asked General Hartmann whether he would feel the same if it was the Iranian government “waterboarding” American servicemen to get information, Hartmann responded, “I am not prepared to answer that question.” Is this guy a leader or what?
And just in case you think Williams is some lefty sushi-eating, chardonnay-drinking, AirAmerica-loving, pinko, need I mention (per the ongoing tale at Volokh) of Col. Morris Davis, who used to be chief prosecutor of the Gitmo Tribunals but quit because he believed the tribunals to be a kangaroo court, duking it out with Brig. Gen. Hartmann, responds to Hartmann’s congressional testimony:
Hartmann says the military commissions are consistent with an American military justice system that is the envy of the world. Apparently he’s privy to some worldwide polling data I haven’t seen, because it appears to me military commissions have created worldwide enmity, not envy. To overcome that, there must be two assurances from the highest levels: One, that evidence derived from waterboarding will not be introduced before a military commission, and two, that all reasonable efforts to keep the proceedings open to the media and other observers will be exhausted before closing any portion of any trial. That’s the minimum American justice demands.
I might consider adding a little commentary to the above, but it would only detract from things said better than I possibly could. These are high-ranking legal officers of the American military resigning rather than participating in, or being party to, what this nation is attempting to pass off the our citizens and the world as justice. They love their country enough to resign and speak truth rather than be party to the death of American justice.
Some View

I don’t know if this pic is real or not. But then, it doesn’t really matter to me.
What’s the Deal in Texas?
Texas executed 62 [edit: 62% of all people executed in the US, a total of 26 people] people last year, when no other state executed more than 3, says the New York Times. There is something very wrong with that.
Why does Texas like to kill people? Is it something in the water, or perhaps it’s the culture of tough-guy justice? Sure, “he needed killin'” is a defense in Texas, and nowhere else, but the disparity in the numbers is just way too big to explain.
While Texas has been forging ahead with capital punishment, many other states have been moving away from it. New Jersey abolished the death penalty this month, and other states have been considering doing the same thing. Illinois made headlines a few years ago when its governor, troubled about the number of innocent people who had been sent to death row, put in place a moratorium on executions.
Does this concern anyone in the Texas legislature? What about the voting public?
There has been a tidal wave of DNA exonerations, in which it has been scientifically proved that the wrong people had been sentenced to death. There is also increasing awareness that even methods of execution considered relatively humane impose considerable suffering on the condemned
Does this give anyone in Texas pause to consider whether putting 62 people to death is a great idea?
The New York Times thinks that Texas is long overdue for a debate. But what do the people of Texas think? For one thing, I bet they couldn’t care less what the editorial board of the New York Times thinks. Maybe they even prefer to go the opposite direction of what the Times has to say, just out of spite. I can’t see a bunch of folk in Dallas quivering because the New York Times thinks ill of them.
But none of this explains why Texas, as opposed to everywhere else in the United States, puts so many people to death. Are Texans that different from the rest of us? Does life mean so little down there? Or are you that harsh and unforgiving? And the biggest question, are you proud of yourselves for it?
Hey, all you Texas boys and girls, enlighten this northeast Yankee. Y’all sound kinda wacky.
Predatory Borrowers Have No One To Blame
I hate it when Ted Frank is right, but he nailed it this time. At Overlawyered, he posts about the politicians new whipping boy, “predatory lenders.” It’s a good choice for candidates, since there are a lot more people hurt by the mortgage crisis than made a living selling them, and it’s always best for candidates to back the crowd with the bigger numbers.
But this debate has been outcome oriented from the start. There is no doubt that people are suffering as a result of teaser rates increasing and home values dropping. Unfortunately, this toxic combination doesn’t tell us anything about fault for the problem. Lenders didn’t go to people’s homes and force them to take out mortgages for 110% of appraised value. Lenders didn’t force subprime borrowers, who otherwise couldn’t get a loan if their lives depended on it, to take loans that they couldn’t afford to pay.
We’ve been through this before. When you bite off more than you can chew, it’s not someone else’s fault. We feel terrible for people who are losing their homes, and there are no doubt people who are sympathetic in this mess. But for those who bought houses when they had no money for a downpayment, this was a boon. How else can you buy a house when you don’t have a dime in the bank? How else can you pull big bucks out of a house to pay for vacations and cars? Isn’t it every American’s right to live free and drive a Mercedes?
So it all came crashing down one day. Hey, they were more than happy to take that bet when home values were increasing, and it looked like the house they purchased for zero down was a cash machine. And when they refinanced to pull the ever-increasing equity out of their house and spend it on . . . something, they weren’t complaining then.
So what did these lenders do that makes them “predatory”? They offered subprime loans to subprime borrowers? They gave people a choice, and people took them up on it. Now, borrowers cry that they didn’t know, they didn’t understand. Perhaps not, though I frankly doubt it. The plan was to keep refinancing every time the loan converted and game the system through the perpetual use of teaser rates. The gravy train would never end.
And didn’t their lawyers tell them what they were buying into? In New York, the common practice is for borrowers to use a lawyer during a mortgage transaction. But it seems that a lot of these borrowers didn’t want to spend the money on a lawyer, and flew solo. And who’s choice was that?
Did the lenders offer products that were ill-suited for many borrowers? Sure. In fact, some of these products with ballooning rates would have choked any horse when the bill came. But if the crunch never came, these same borrowers would have enjoyed a free ride forever. But it did come, and they got caught in the squeeze. No one guaranteed them a right to make bad choices and never suffer the consequences.
So while we may be sympathetic toward these borrowers, let’s not vilify the wrong party and let’s not shift the burden of these bad choices to the people who saved their money, mortgaged carefully and thoughtfully, and have the ability to weather the storm. Fiscal prudence isn’t a crime either, and it’s time we stopped rewarding foolish risk by laying blame where it doesn’t belong. America may be the land of opportunity, but there’s no guarantee that bad choices have no consequences.

