Author Archives: SHG

A Lawyer Who Blew It, But Learned

Louis Cyrus got 20 to life for an armed robbery of a Duane Reade Pharmacy.  What he didn’t get was effective assistance of counsel at trial.  According to the New York Law Journal, his lawyer, Edward Land, was ecstatic.


Mr. Land said in an interview last week that he was “delighted” the court had ordered a new trial for Mr. Cyrus. At the time the case was tried in the fall of 2003, Mr. Land said, “I was relatively inexperienced in handling felony cases” and “my performance” was not the “effective assistance of counsel Mr. Cyrus was entitled to.”

Justice Luis Gonzalez at the Appellate Division, First Department, wrote a scathing decision, detailing Land’s incompetent representation at the suppression hearing and trial.  Most egregious, according to Justice Gonzalez, was defense counsel’s raising the existence of a video of the robbery that he had never seen, asking a police officer what was on the video.  Ouch.


First, with respect to the police testimony about the videotape, we find that counsel committed egregious and prejudicial error in failing to investigate the contents of the videotape, and then, without knowing what was on it, inadvertently opening the door to damaging testimony by Harper about its contents.

I suppose that he was hoping for one of those Perry Mason moments, with the cop breaking down on the stand and admitting that the videotape showed the defendant unarmed, possibly even giving out candy to children and tossing the proceeds into a Salvation Army kettle.  No such luck.  The testimony fell on the defendant like a ton of bricks.  Yes there was a video.  Yes I saw it.  Yes, it showed the defendant brandishing a box cutter as he tried to escape from the store.  And this came out on cross.

Mind you, the post trial motion to vacate by new assigned counsel was denied by the trial judge, Justice Bruce Allen, who:


[R]ejected Mr. Cyrus’ posttrial motion for a new trial, finding that, although aspects of Mr. Land’s performance were “troubling,” overall he “made appropriate motions,” conducted “vigorous” cross examinations and “presented a coherent, if ultimately futile, defense.”

This is instructive.  No matter how badly and ineffectively an attorney performs, there is always something a judge can say that will give the rhetorical appearance that he met the minimal standards for effective assistance of counsel.  Essentially, Justice Allen said that Land was breathing and asked a couple of questions, and that’s all the Constitution promises a defendant. 

But at least Ed Land recognizes that he lost the case.  In a  letter to the Editor of the Law Journal, Land writes:


[T]he Appellate Division, First Department held that I rendered ineffective assistance of counsel at trial and I am delighted that Louis Cyrus has been granted a new trial. On the whole, I am in agreement with the appellate court that I did not provide the effective assistance of counsel Mr. Cyrus was entitled to. That was due to my relative inexperience in October 2003 in trying felony cases, and I would not make those same “rookie” mistakes again.

Of course, this tells us little of what mistakes he would make today, given his vast experience of four more years, but you have to give him credit for not trying to put his reputation ahead of his client.  At least he got that right.

What comes across loud and clear was that Ed Land had no business trying a case yet.  He was not up to the job.  While he admits it now, the defendant has already spent 5 years in prison awaiting his conviction being vacated.  Had he been convicted for petty larceny, meaning that he stole from Duane Reade but did not have a weapon (as the defendant testified at trial), he faced a max sentence of 1 year.  And no, for those of you asking, he can’t bank the four extra years and apply them to his next crime.

This case begs the question of how Edward Land ended up trying this case.  Neither the articles or decision state whether Land was retained, Legal Aid or assigned, but the implication is that he was assigned counsel.  According to Avvo, there is only one Edward Land in New York.  His rating states there is “no concern” about Edward Land, who has been admitted to practice for 17 years.  What he was doing during that time is unclear, but it certainly wasn’t trying felony cases.  If this isn’t the right Edward Land, I sincerely apologize, but I can’t find another Edward Land to pin it on.

It’s hard, if not impossible, to understand how Land got onto the 18B panel, given his lack of experience in criminal defense.  Yet, he apparently did, and decided to find out whether he had any skills as a trial lawyer at Cyrus’ expense.  This means that the defendant, relying on his right to counsel under Gideon, got hosed by a system that gave him a lawyer, but not a lawyer capable of rendering effective assistance.  This is worse than no lawyer at all, and shows the gap between promise and delivery. 

And then there was the trial judge, doing what he had to do to preserve his conviction when he, of all people, knew that the defendant got hosed right in front of him.  So once again, we have a decision that, on its face, would give the appearance of a win for the defendant, but in harsh reality demonstrates a system that failed at every turn, with the defendant paying the price of his crime five times over.  This was a better day than if the conviction was affirmed, but this was not a good day for the criminal justice system.

A Juror Capitulated, As Predicted, in White Conviction

It didn’t take long for juror number 4, Francois Larche, to go public.  To hear him, he’s the victim.  I doubt John White agrees.  White, of course, was convicted of manslaughter 2.  Larche, who says he does not believe White was guilty, was part of the jury that convicted him.

Following deliberations in this case, it was patently obvious that the conviction was the result of a collapse, following the coercive Allen charge, the weekend and the upcoming Christmas holiday.  As I wrote immediately after the verdict was returned:


He was  convicted yesterday of second degree manslaughter.  The jury was  deadlocked the day before, and received the typical coercive Allen charge, making sure they realized that despite their deadlock, they would be kept in that jury room all weekend, the same one before Christmas that the rest of us are enjoying, until they reached a verdict.  Then a Christmas miracle occurred; they reached a compromise verdict.  The jury found White guilty.

It was only matter of time before guilt overcame the juror(s) whose self-doubt and weakness caused them collapse into a pile of jello and go along with the majority, desperate to get back to their jobs, families and shopping obligations.

It’s not that Francois Larche is an evil person, despite Norm’s deserved disdain, but that he was weak and unsure of whether he felt strongly enough to face down 10 other jurors.  Weakness in the face of pressure is not an attractive trait; it’s just not that abnormal either.  Even though twelve is a relatively arbitrary number of people who have to agree on something, each of the twelve functions as a part of, and independent of, the whole.  It is intentional that the decision must be unanimous, rather than a simple majority or even plurality.  When it is not unanimous, the defendant doesn’t get the full jury of 12 to which he’s entitled.

But Larche isn’t the first juror to feel pressured.  And the internal pressure of a jury is part of the dynamic that is supposed to make the system work.  The problem is when a jury tells a judge that it’s hung, as happened here, and the judge keeps pushing until she gets a verdict that was so flagrantly a produce of coercion that no one (even me) could miss it. 

Sometimes, the weak juror wants to hide from his failure to stand up.  Other time, like here, the juror comes forward to seek absolution by publicly admitting his weakness and then blaming it on others. 

Weakness is not a crime.  Unfortunately, it is part and parcel of the jury system.  It takes a very strong person to stand up to 11 others and hold his ground.  The judge’s instructions are designed to make the 12th juror collapse and give in to the will of the 11.  It is designed to suggest that if they hang, they have failed to State.  It is intended to coerce a reluctant juror to give up his heartfelt belief to the will of the others.  It says it’s not, but it really is.  Judges don’t want a retrial.  They want a verdict.

And so Judge Barbara Kahn used the weekend and holiday to twist a couple of arms in the jury room.  She knew it when she did it, as did everyone else I suspect.  You would have to be pretty darn thick to have no understood and appreciate what she was doing with her Allen charge.

As for John White, the max he can receive is 5-15 years, but rest assured that his sentence will be nothing close to that.  As a first offender on a class “C” felony, under the very peculiar circumstances of this case, I would expect him to receive 5 years probation.  The worst I can imagine is a split, with 6 months in jail and the balance on probation.  White’s no danger to anyone, and there was something rather heroic in his defense of his son, innocent of any wrongdoing, against some angry kids screaming racial epithets. 

So Francios Larche does not get to claim victimhood in this case.  There were too many victims already, and he took an oath to perform one function, hold out for his true beliefs.  He is a coward, but not a particularly unusual coward.  A rather run-of-the-mill coward.  A basic weakling.  And his coming forward to announce his weakness to the world hardly makes him a better person.  Just a weakling who wants attention.

Judge Barbara Kahn, on the other hand, knew what she was doing when the gave that coercive Allen charge.  She may think that a sentence of probation squares things between her and White.  I think not.

Fairness to New Lawyers

Via the New York Lawyer, first year associates are closing in on $200,000 a year.  If there are anything that could drive legal services away from Biglaw and into the hands of small firms and solos, this should be it.

With Williams & Connolly raising its first year’s salaries to $180,000, it’s only a matter of time.  Can anyone tell me what could possibly explain this phenomenon?  The compulsive draw of Biglaw for the “best and brightest” of law school graduates, or the competition to show that your firm can pay more than their firm? 

Let’s talk just between us.  First year associates are near useless as lawyers.  They are incapable of producing useful legal work, and at best churn out wasteful hours of memos stating the obvious at great length in order to produce the requisite number of hours.  Sure, they think they’re doing a bang-up job, but that’s only because they have no clue of the utility of their efforts. 

Still, somebody is paying for this time.  Hour by hour, there is a client being billed somewhere for some kid to carry a briefcase around the hallway.  It must be just fine with Biglaw clients to pay some top partner $1000+ an hour on top of a posse of kids following her around, nipping at her heels, fetching coffee and taking notes, so that every hour of actual legal work ends up costing the Biglaw clients $3,750.

To what end is this shocking waste of money?  Well, it let’s Biglaw associates buy stuff that they otherwise couldn’t afford.  After all, didn’t mommy promise a Mercedes Benz or a Condo by age 24?  Of course, I can’t blame these first year associates for the joys of excessive pay.  They didn’t go on strike for higher wages and better working conditions (like in-house nail salons and a concierge to pick up their dry cleaning).  Biglaw offers and they need only accept.

On the other hand, you have the second tier grads who may get an interview but never seem to get the job.  While everybody thinks they are going to be some rich lawyer, the reality hits home when there’s no summer associates position for them at Biglaw.  No firm picnics or ballgame outings.  It’s going to be their lot in life to have to work for a living, and then only at a fraction of what their brethren make.

But they do have an advantage in one regard, that the coddled first years will never know.  They will be forced to become lawyers or starve.  Having just addressed the “fairness” issue of Avvo’s ratings on newbie solos, noting the complaint that their lack of experience will show up on Avvo as a lack of experience, they will be constrained to find a way to get themselves some clients, work their little butts off to learn their craft and impress those clients, and then bootstrap that into a budding legal career. 

Necessity is the mother of invention.  Working lawyers will find a way to impress their clients because it will be necessary if they want to eat tomorrow.  They will have to prove their mettle if they want to claw their way up the food chain to success and, perhaps, even prominence.  There’s nothing wrong with this.

On the Biglaw side of the lane, these income-enhanced first year associates will not develop the skills needed to succeed as independent lawyers.  In a few years, they will learn that they either do not want to spend their lives as someone else’s legal-serf or that they have no future in Biglaw, meaning that their grades in law school didn’t turn out to be as much of a predictor of Biglaw success as their masters had hoped.  Hey, you need to kiss a lot of frogs to find a prince.  It happens.

By that time, their solo buddies will have gone far down the road to self-sufficiency, and will possess a practice and lifestyle that the Biglaw guys can only dream of. 

For the lawyers online who have a position to promote, telling the truth about the ups and downs of the legal profession isn’t always easy.  It’s not easy being a solo, particularly when you are starting from scratch, lack any client base or reputation in the legal community and have no trust fund to keep gas in the Ferrari as your practice together.  Don’t whine about.  You aren’t the first one to struggle, and you won’t be the last.

These fine talks from lawyerprenuers about how you to can become a star overnight by following three easy steps isn’t going to offer any magic solution.  Developing a practice takes time, effort and sacrifice.  Everyone who gets a law degree is not going to succeed.  Some don’t have the skill.  Others can’t stand the job.  And some aren’t willing to do the work necessary to become a good lawyer.  This is how it should be. 

Most of us have to prove our worth to our clients every day.  We make money the old fashioned way:  We earn it.  Is it fair that Biglaw associates will get $200k while everyone else has to struggle to bring work in the door?  Of course not, but whoever told you that this was a business about fairness was pulling your leg.  The law may be an honorable profession, but it’s surely no free ride.

What Has Avvo Done For / To You? (Updated)

My  recent post about the  Avvo lawyer rating website generated a surprising amount of angst among lawyers whose views I respect.  It also brought out  Grant Conrad from Avvo to defend the service, which just seemed to get the Anti-Avvo even more worked up.

When Avvo first launched, I challenged the concept in a series of posts:



Despite all the words that were spilled about Avvo, it remained my view that it was a silly effort of limited viability at best and of little consequence to lawyers.  Well, I must have gotten that all wrong, given how much anger it has generated in Susan Cartier Leibel  here and Grant D. Griffiths.  On the flip side, Carolyn Elefant  rejects the notion that Avvo has it in for solos and Kevin O’Keefe is  resigned to the fact that Avvo’s here to stay.

The centerpiece of the Avvo ratings is the single numerical rating given a lawyer, supposedly reflecting an aggregate of competency and ethics.  Essentially everyone agrees, including Avvo, that this number is meaningless and silly.  While Avvo initially contended that this was a valid number, it has since  disclaimed its significance and tacitly acknowledges that it is a meaningless gimmick that should not be used to make a decision on whether to retain a lawyer.  This, of course, is my interpretation of Avvo’s limp, qualified endorsement of its own rating system.

While I see the issue that arises from the potential abuse of the Avvo comment system from clients and other lawyers, which can produce flame wars of inaccurate information or allegations that can falsely harm a lawyer’s reputation, this is a flaw of the internet itself.  Anybody can post anything about anybody if they want to cause someone harm.  Ultimately, whether it’s posted at Avvo or elsewhere, internet shaming is a part of online reality, as was fully explained by Dan Solove in his book, the Future of Reputation.  And should this happen at Avvo, at least there’s someone there to complain to about who will vet the comment and remove it.

But there’s some other issue going on that is just not making it into my dense head.  Susan and Grant are of the view that Avvo is harmful to small firms and solos, and favors large firms, for people looking for an attorney.  Why this should be eludes me.  No one will tell me why this is so, leaving me to ponder the question of what I’m missing here.

The idea of lawyer ratings is nothing new, as  Martindale-Hubbell has been doing it forever.  The idea of using the internet as a way of locating lawyers is, of course, relatively new, but having perused a variety of lawyer websites, it is already obviously subject to  disgraceful abuse by scoundrels who will post some incredibly stupid crap about themselves to mislead potential clients to hire them. 

As far as I’m aware, potential clients still have no meaningful way to find and assess the competency of lawyers, and Avvo has added little to this problem.  Talk of “transparency” is overstated, as the real qualities that clients seek in lawyers cannot be quantified by a matrix or imparted by comments, friend or foe.  Avvo may be something, but it’s not much of something.  The endorsement of Avvo by the Wall Street Journal tends to give it greater credibility, but it’s not like the WSJ has a clue, given that it appears to be in favor of anything that allows lawyers to be searchable, including the slimy Super Lawyers show pony promotion.

So what gives?  Why should Avvo evoke this much emotion?  Has anybody (I mean anybody) been retained because of Avvo?  Has anybody lost a client because of it?  Has it made a dent in anyone’s practice?  Inquiring minds want to know.

Update:  Susan has posted a comment at  My Shingle that explains, finally, the root of the problem:


And when a new solo who is not yet published, who does not have a significant web presence or the ability to pay for a significant web presence in the beginning and/or has only been practicing for a year, who is already fighting professional prejudice and limited knowledge of marketing is now numerically ranked lower and even branded ‘use extreme caution’ through a ‘secret’ numerical ratings system,

Now, we can finally have a real discussion about this, though I doubt that Susan is going to like what I have to say.  There a reason why “new solos” and/or lawyers who have “only been practicing for a year” are not going to be ranked as highly as experienced and proven lawyers:  They haven’t yet earned it.  That’s one of the points in favor of Avvo. 

Experienced lawyers have an advantage over new lawyers.  True, being new doesn’t make you a bad lawyer, but it also doesn’t make you as good a lawyer as you’re going to be 10 years down the road.  I cannot agree that potential clients should be denied the knowledge that the lawyer they are considering lacks significant experience.  It is a factor in the decision-making process, and it should be a factor.  

I realize that you are out there pumping the solo route, and it has many things to offer the lawyer who isn’t cut out of Biglaw cloth or needs flexibility.  I understand that your efforts are geared toward showing the solos can be every bit as good a lawyer as the large firms.  But the truth remains that unproven lawyers are just that: unproven.  We were all there once, and we worked our way up the food chain.  You earn your way to recognition, one client at a time.  No one is entitled to conceal their lack of proven ability or experience. 

While this is hardly an endorsement of Avvo, it is similarly not a basis for condemnation.  Avvo is a stupid, useless way to pick a lawyer, but doesn’t present a danger to anyone.  If a lawyer has yet to gain any accomplishments worthy of note, then let them do so.  But to complain that Avvo is wrong because it reveals a lack of experience or accomplishment is the one thing for which Avvo can’t be faulted.  It’s up to us, every lawyer, to make the effort to prove our worth with every client, every day.  And when we do this, no one will care about Avvo anyway, because they will seek our representation because of what we do, not because of what Avvo (or anyone else) has to say about us.

Peace On Earth

It was my plan to wake up this morning, Christmas 2007, and post about how on this one day, no one was killed or maimed.  But that wasn’t to be as the New York Times reports moments ago of an explosion in Iraq, a suicide bomber killing 22 in Baghdad.  Pope Benedict XVI gave a beautiful  homily that God “came to restore beauty and dignity to creation, to the universe.”

Soup kitchens in Manhattan served more than  1000 meals to homeless New Yorkers, but they will still be homeless after they eat.  President Bush called  10 service members in Iraq to thank them for their sacrifice, but they will still be in Iraq after the call.  The defense department’s  norad system can be used to track Santa’s progress.  If you celebrate Christmas, I hope he made his way to your house and brought things that will bring joy to your children.   Wall Street bonuses are bigger than ever, but the financial markets are unkind to everyone else.  Maybe your child’s prayer for a Wii will go unfulfilled if your bonus didn’t come in yet.

For anyone familiar with Simple Justice, you know that children hold a very special place with me.  If you do nothing else today, bring love to your children and all children.  They are good.  They are the future.  We are beyond hope, but they are our hope.  If we teach them well, they will make their world better than ours.

My first thought was to include Handel’s Messiah at the end of this post, but we aren’t quite ready for it.  Instead, I think the video is more appropriate for today.  We cannot stop the world from turning and doing whatever it must do, but we can spend one day trying to bring peace to our own lives, our families and those around us.  Merry Christmas and peace be with you.


Lawyers Appreciate . . . Integrity

Another meme.  Another meme.  From Carolyn Elefant of My Shingle, I’ve been tagged for the Second Annual Lawyers Appreciate meme.

I can’t imagine the fabulous wealth and glory I would possess, if only I didn’t possess integrity.  This is a profession business where far too many people put their own interests ahead of the people they are sworn to help.  They deny it.  They excuse it.  They rationalize it away.  But the simple fact from Simple Justice is that the core of a good lawyer is integrity, the willingness to sacrifice our personal benefit or gain at the expense of our clients.

With that thought in mind, I now have the dubious honor of tagging a few other poor souls of my own, and I pick Mark Bennett at Defending People, Gideon at A Public Defender, Norm Pattis  a/k/a Mother Mary and Young Shawn Matlock, Republican Savant.  Each, a paragon of integrity in his own right.  What do you guys appreciate?

Why Yes, I Am Offended By Huckabee

From Ol’  Norm Pattis comes this bit of garbage from the heartland.  I feel confident that there will be wide swathes of America who will see absolutely nothing wrong with this Huckabee advertisement, and indeed will see me as some nasty New York Jew for even questioning its beautiful, peaceful, heartfelt message of deeply held religious reverie.  To those of you who think this way, bite me. 

You are entitled to keep whatever religious ferver you want in your hearts, in your homes, in your churches and in your children.  But keep you religion out of my public offices.  Religion is personal.  Religion is not scam to be played to tug at your heartstrings, as if the other guys are all satan-lovers and he’s the choice of true believers.

And I’m offended, you should be twice as pissed.  This yokel has pulled out religion to pander for your vote, as if you are so stupid that you’ll be swallowed up in all the nice music and warm glow of the background and believe that Jesus supports his candidacy.  He is playing religion as if it’s some magic cure for erectile dysfunction.  Is that what your religion means to you?

How pathetic that this man’s religion means so little to him that he will use it to manipulate people.  Yes, I am offended.  I hope you are too.

Is Cigna A Murderer?

The death of 17 year old Nataline Sarkisyan while waiting for Cigna Insurance to change it’s position and approve a liver transplant is a tragedy.  The death of any 17 year old is a tragedy.  But tragic outcomes do not murderers make.

The Sarkisyan family is represented by a lawyer named Mark Geragos.  Mark is a well know lawyer, though belied by the ugly detail that his clients seem to consistently do very poorly.  He’s  making headlines claiming that Cigna should be prosecuted for murder.  He’s good at making headlines.  He’s good at being on Larry King, though he had gone largely underground following his Scott Peterson fiasco and the inexplicably horrific representation of Winona Ryder, a case that any rookie PD could have handled better.

This situation presents another example of why important issues that become entwined with terrible tragedies end up producing confusing and, usually, unhelpful discussions.

There are two significant, and conflicting, interests at stake here.  The first is the more obvious.  Insurance companies, despite their cries of poverty, are raking in extraordinary amounts of money, paying their CEOs astounding bonuses, and cutting back fees or stiffing health care providers regularly.  It’s extremely difficult to ignore this when assessing the virtues of health insurer decision-making.

The second consideration, however, is sometimes overlooked.  In spreading out resourced, insurers are supposed to make the best use of resources for the broadest range of people possible.  In other words, if it approves a million dollar procedure, that’s a million dollars that becomes unavailable for prenatal health care for poor women.  It’s the allocation of scare resources, and due to the ever-growing universe of high-risk, low-success and mind-blowingly expensive procedures, providing the “chance of life” to one person means denying the routine care needed by many.

Given the cost of health insurance, there are many people who view it as a huge well from which they are entitled to dip at any time for any reason.  Some people want MRIs at the drop of a hat, and somebody has to pay for those MRIs.  You know that the CEO of Cigna can afford it.  Can we afford to pay for every whim, no matter how unlikely or inappropriate a last-ditch procedure may be?  We hate to see anyone denied any chance at survival, as it offends our humanity.  But would we give up our own health for it?

As I said, the second consideration would hold far more weight if it wasn’t burdened with the fact that insurance companies are siphoning off so much of our health care dollars into their own pockets.  They are, in my view, piggish.  Whether they require regulation is a political matter, as is the whole issue of whether it should be taken out of the sphere of profit-making altogether. 

But back to Mark Geragos, trying to milk his return to the limelight for all it’s worth.  I’m not qualified to say that a liver transplant was not the absolutely proper treatment, and that Cigna initial denial was not improper at all.  And I am certainly not one to defend insurance carriers’ callous treatment of its insureds, or health care providers for that matter.  But while calls for a murder prosecution may make for a great headline for a lawyer inclined to grab whatever he can get his hands on, I fail to see how the concept of criminal liability squares with the concept of risk assessment.

Perhaps the tragedy of Nataline Sarkisyan’s death will spur action to provide a more rational distribution of health care, guided by acceptable cost-benefit analysis rather than arbitrary knee-jerk refusal to pay a dime more than an insurance carrier believes it can get away with.  This would be a good think.  A murder prosecution, on the other hand, will just make matters worse, putting yet another weapon in the carriers’ arsenal to blame the legal system for all its problems and jack up premiums for the rest of us while still skimping at every possible turn.  Because that’s what insurers are supposed to do.

WSJ: Avvo Is The Source

Via Kevin O’Keefe at Real Lawyers Have Blogs, my favorite source for free Wall Street Journal content, comes this surprising report that the Wall Street Journal, that bastion of conservative judgment in a frothy sea of new ideas, endorses Avvo, the lawyer rating website that  just beat back the  silly Seattle lawsuit to shut it down.  It was a curious win, with the Judge calling Avvo concept “ludicrous“, but you take your wins as you get them.

What comes as shock is the Journal’s acceptance of Avvo as a viable source of information.


At a time when the judicial system is under increasing scrutiny, the courtroom performances and verdicts of its practitioners would seem a reasonable object of public interest. For those shopping for legal counsel, an online rating service might at least provide some measure of transparency in an otherwise opaque profession.

The site, called Avvo, does for lawyers what any number of magazines and Web sites have been doing for other professions for years. Magazines regularly publish stories that rank an area’s doctors and dentists. There are rating sites and blogs for the ‘best’ hairstylists, manicurists, restaurants and movie theaters. Almost any consumer product or service these days is sorted and ranked.

Professional ego aside, it’s hard to see why lawyers or judges should be any different.

(Quote lifted wholesale from Kevin).  While you can’t argue with the concept of transparency in selecting a lawyer, or the fact that lawyers are an “otherwise opaque profession,” the position offers absolutely no logical connection between the interests at stake and what Avvo provides.  Just because viable information is hard to come by doesn’t mean that any information, regardless of validity, methodology or accuracy, is better than nothing.

Now I have no personal beef with Avvo, particularly since I’m not displeased with my Avvo rating.  Of course, Avvo representatives have personally sat at counsel table with me through my trials, watched me voir dire, open, cross and close, countless times.  They read my appellate briefs, and parse my pre-trial motions.  So when Avvo says that I’m a perfect “10”, they know exactly what they’re talking about.  I’m all about transparency.

But I’m not quite sure that Avvo ratings are as valid for others as they are for me.  After all, there are only so many Avvo people available to spend countless hours with lawyers assessing their skills.  So unlike me, most lawyers get rated based upon the most vapid and insignificant information, or no information at all. 

For those who read blawgs, Avvo’s existence is well known, and it’s likely that many have already claimed their ratings, inserted some information that will personalize it to some limited extent.  After all, even by inputting the handful of things that Avvo deems significant, it fails to consider the skills that distinguish a good lawyer from a bar association sycophant.  You would think that the WSJ would demand more.

Of course, the WSJ has apparently taken the position that any information is better than none, as shown by its endorsement of such gimmicks as “magazines and websites” promoting various “best of” lists.  Maybe this is just free market politics run amok, or the ugly groundwork preceding real transparency.

Regardless, for all the lawyers who have yet to claim their Avvo ratings, or don’t understand why their name is on the internet when they didn’t ask for it, there is one thing that’s clear.  Websites like Avvo are here to stay, and to the extent that anyone will ever want to check up on you, you might as well look the best you can.  True, it doesn’t make you a better lawyer or give your clients any better chance of prevailing, but you can bet your bottom dollar that the sleazy lawyers are busy puffing up their Avvo ratings, so the good lawyers should as well.

In the end, it will all be another wash, since potential clients will still be unable to tell if their counsel of choice is any good or not.  But given how little one can put on one’s website, and how little meaning any of this has on a lawyer’s ability to serve his clients, and how self-promotion has toppled professionalism and dignity as the hallmark of the legal profession, don’t be left out in the cold.  If you won’t do it for me, do it for the Wall Street Journal in the name of transparency.

Why Does Our Legal System Value Money Over Life?

While the platitudes have always shown a fondness for the criminal justice system, such as “it’s better that 100 guilty men go free than 1 innocent man is convicted,” the sad truth is that the criminal justice system is the ugly stepchild of the legal system.  This week, we will explore some of the differences.

It comes as a shock to criminal defendants to learn that there is essentially no such thing as discovery in criminal cases.  In New York, there are two discovery mechanisms available to the defense, a “bill of particulars” and a laundry list of pedestrian items for “discovery and inspection” set forth in Criminal Procedure Law  240.20.  The former is routinely ignored, with a response that essentially states that all information the prosecution is required to disclose is already contained in the accusatory instrument.  The latter is simply a joke, with so little information that it makes a Spartan blush.

Compare this with civil litigation.  There are depositions (also known as Examinations Before Trial, or EBTs), which are oral examinations under oath.  The lawyer from one side gets to ask the parties and witnesses of the other questions, and they are obligated to answer.  These can last for hours, days or more.  Depositions in criminal cases?  Nada in New York.

Then there are interrogatories, which are the written form of depositions, to be responded to in writing and under oath.  There there are document demands, where a party demands every document ever produced from the other side.  This is done in advance of depositions, so that the documents become the subject of questioning, as well as the absence of documents which then becomes the subject of additional demands and lots of arguing. 

In civil proceedings, the scope of  CPLR Article 31 discovery is breathtaking.  It covers everything that can in any way be argued might either be “material and necessary” to a cause of action or defense, or anything that might conceivably lead to something that would be material.  Short of the waistband of your Jockeys, everything is fair game.  Civil lawyers litigate for years over discovery issues, and argue how the world will stop turning if they don’t get a copy of little Johnny’s orthodontics records. 

In criminal law, you get squat.  You learn nothing about the evidence against your client, or what the witnesses will say.  You get the most cursory details of the allegations, and too often the flip answer from prosecutors that if you want to know what happened during the alleged crime, “just ask your client.”  This response is one of the key ways of knowing that your prosecutor is particularly unlikeable person.

Whereas a civil trial is structured for the purpose of having no secrets, criminal defense lawyers go into trial blind.  Our clients ask us, and rightfully so, what’s going to happen.  What will the witnesses say.  What if they lie?  How can we put together evidence to show that a witness is lying when you have no idea what a witness will say on the stand?  The best answer is that we try desperately to anticipate, and prepare based upon anticipation.  Because we just don’t know what will happen.

One of my running jokes is that the worst thing that can happen at trial is for the cops to tell the truth.  We’re never prepared for that. 

There are always a series of reforms in the works to improve criminal discovery.  The reason they are always in the works is that they never resolve the problem.  There is a force at work that seeks to intentionally deny the defense a fair fight, a level playing field. 

One of my personal favorite responses to specific discovery demands comes from my good buddies at the United States Attorneys Office for the Southern District of New York.  Before I tell you, bear in mind that federal discovery is a little different than state, with  Rule 16 governing and barely a pretense of a bill of particulars.  When you specifically ask for a piece of factual information that would give you half a chance of understanding why they’ve indicted your client, the answer is “that it would unduly prejudice the government to disclose the information sought by the defense.” 

Now think about that; By disclosing the allegations of fact the government believes to be true, they would be prejudiced.  How are you prejudiced by the truth?  There’s only one way, it would make it a fairer fight.  Anything that would give the defense a fair chance to address the charges would prejudice the government’s right to convict.  Try that in a civil proceeding, and the same judge would hand you your butt. 

But ultimately we do get the bulk of discovery in criminal proceedings, right?  Well, sorta.  In state court it’s called “Rosario” material (from People v. Rosario, 9 NY2d 286 [1961]), and in federal court it’s called “3500” or “Jencks Act” material.  It’s a dump of paper at the very last second, usual after the jury’s been sworn, but sometimes not until the witness has completed his direct testimony. 

This material consists of prior written statements of witnesses.  It doesn’t consist of prior statements of anyone who is not called as a witness, like people who saw something different or disagreed with the cops assessment.  While some may scream ‘Brady”, that’s just a figment of your imagination.  Brady material, or evidence that tends to show that the defendant did not commit the crime, is whatever a prosecutor decides it is, and if he thinks no one will ever know it exists, chances are that you’ll never see it.

In other words, you’re in the midst of trial with about a million things to do, your attention supposedly focused on the trial itself and that’s when they dump all the paper on you.  Accident?  Not likely.  Is there something in there that requires investigation?  Too bad.  Too late.  Proceed, counselor.

Why this disparity between discovery in criminal proceedings versus civil?  It’s about whose money is at risk versus whose life is at risk.  The power behind the respective interests has given us a shockingly different approach, and it is clear that criminal defendants have no champions when its comes to fairness.  Sure, we win when it comes to platitudes, but we’re not even in the game when it comes to reality. 

Why is the discovery system structured for complete discovery in civil cases, but designed to sandbag the defense in criminal cases?  Because our legal system values the money to be won or lost higher than it does the lives of the human beings.