Author Archives: SHG

The Last Week of December, 2007

Crime never sleeps.  But the courts tend to snooze a bit.  There are two down times every year as a result of the same forces that drive the rest of humanity.  The month of August is generally dead, because judges go on vacation or seminars or a combination thereof.  And then there’s the week between Christmas and New Years.

No matter what is happening, this week is dead.  There are no trials.  No one would have the balls to call for a jury panel this week.  There are no court appearances.  There may be the occasional arraignment, assuming somebody has done something bad enough to get themselves busted during a week that almost no one gets arrested, but otherwise the hallways are empty and the courtrooms are quiet.  Even lawyers are away on vacation.  Because they work so hard they need it.

For those defendants whose crimes preclude them from being with their families over the holidays, they will sit in jail this week.  No one in the system is thinking about them this week.

It’s a good time to get that work done that requires some extra time and quiet.  It’s a great week to read transcripts and work on an appeal.  But that would interfere with vacation, or perhaps just doing nothing without feeling guilty about it. 

Because of the needs of the system, criminal defense lawyers tend to fashion their vacation schedules around the  courts.  Not that we don’t take other vacations as well, but why be here, ready for work, when there’s no judge screaming for your head or demanding your readiness for trial. 

For the first time in about 2 decades, I am happy to say that I am not going away this week.  For many years, my standard was to leave on Christmas day, a wonderful day for travel since everybody else is already where they are supposed to be, and see family living far away.  This year, I’m staying home.  It’s a thrill to have nowhere to go, and to know that I have a week that is absolutely, totally dead.

There isn’t likely to be much news this week either.  But that doesn’t mean I won’t find something to post about, though it may well be less controversial than usual.  The whole Christmas thing makes it unseemly to be too critical about anything at the moment, as if it betrays an ugliness of spirit.  It may not be my religious holiday, but there’s nothing wrong with the concept of peace on earth, goodwill toward others.  

So I will be around here this week, posting as usual.  But I’m going to try to be a little more circumspect about the tone of my posts in the spirit of the holidays.  I hope it doesn’t kill me.

Imus — The “I” Stands for Irrelevant

As we all know, Don Imus is back on air, following the “nappy headed ho” stupidity.  But it’s different this time.

Imus became “something” because of his irreverence at a time when he was pushing the envelope.  He was cutting edge then, and it gave him a huge audience.  Imus was big and a lot of people listened.

But Imus grew up and his envelope pushing became quite mainstream.  But he still had an audience.  Because of that, he was able to get some big name people to come on his show.  He was such a softball interviewer that he made Larry King seem risky, but he got the big names and so we listened.

Imus doesn’t have anybody important on his show now.  I gather that he’s a pariah, and no one is willing to take the chance of being associated with someone who calls Rutgers Basketball players “nappy headed hos.”  So the Imus show is now all about Imus.  I’m sorry to say, but Imus is a bore.

His mumbling, pointless meandering may have meant something when there were people on his show who mattered, but Imus doesn’t matter.  He stopped mattering a long time ago, and I guess I never noticed because of his guests.  But now it’s impossible not to notice.  I listen for brief periods at a time, before turning to some other station that has something really desirable on it, like the news or 60s rock.  Actually, anything other than Imus.

It’s really too bad that what Imus once brought to the air is now gone.  He’s unlikely to venture too far with the envelope given the way he got his head handed to him by the Rev. Al, who Imus was foolish enough to engage.  Imus must want to stay on that straight and narrow that will rehabilitate him and make him acceptable to political society.  Maybe that will happen, since politicians are usually willing to forgive and forget anything as long as it provides them with greater benefit than detriment.

But will Imus hold on long enough to be accepted back into the bossom of important guests?  I doubt it.  Who wants to spend their time listening to someone who has rendered himself wholly irrelevant?  What a waste of good air time.  I’d rather listen to Curtis and Kuby again, and I was never enthralled with that show.

A Sick Internet Prank, A Dead Kid and A Father Convicted

It started as a stupid prank, where an online message came to 17 year old Daniel Cicciaro’s attention that somebody was going to rape his girlfriend, Jenny Martin.  He decided it was Aaron White, and went to White’s house to protect Jenny Martin’s honor.  Ah, the hormonal machismo of youth.

So Daniel Cicciaro, following some heated telephone calls, and four friends then drove to Aaron White’s house.  To do what remains unclear, but they were coming from a party, and all full of anger and chivalry.  A bad combination. 

They arrived at the White house, only a few minutes away.  There were racial epithets, profanity and threats. 

Aaron’s father, John, came outside.  He had a .32 Berretta in his hands.  According to John White, Cicciaro either tried to grab it or swat it away, and it went off.  Daniel Cicciaro was shot in the face.  He died.  John White claimed he was trying to protect his family from a white “lynch mob.” 

He was  convicted yesterday of second degree manslaughter.  The jury was  deadlocked the day before, and received the typical coercive Allen charge, making sure they realized that despite their deadlock, they would be kept in that jury room all weekend, the same one before Christmas that the rest of us are enjoying, until they reached a verdict.  Then a Christmas miracle occurred; they reached a compromise verdict.  The jury found White guilty.

The prosecution argued that John White need only have locked the doors, called the police and the situation would have been diffused.  By going outside with a gun in his hand, he created the explosive situation that ended a 17 year old’s life. 

The defense, led by Fred Brewington, a long-time civil rights activist attorney, was a black-white affair, with the Cicciaro gang made out to be a lynch mob out of the old south, and John White a lone black man trying to protect his family.  

There was much wrong this case, not the least of which was how it reflected certain ethnic and cultural divisions that many refuse to believe persists in suburbia.  Indeed, it’s difficult to even write about this case because of the cultural stereotypes involved.  And by ignoring them, the real dynamic of this case is lost.

Jenny Martin, the girlfriend of dead Daniel Cicciaro, told the New York Post that she wants John White to receive the maximum punishment possible, which is why we don’t leave sentencing decisions to stupid little girls.  She can’t perceive how this was so very wrong all around.

In a perfect world, the prosecutor was quite correct that John White should never have walked out of his house that night with a gun to confront a group of young men.  The situation had all the necessary elements for an explosion, and it should come as no surprise that the explosion happened.

Should John White have been convicted?  


  Penal Law § 125.15 Manslaughter in the second degree.
    A person is guilty of manslaughter in the second degree when:
    1. He recklessly causes the death of another person . . .
    Manslaughter in the second degree is a class C felony.

Recklessly is defined as:


Penal Law § 15.05 Culpability; definitions of culpable mental states.
    The following definitions are applicable to this chapter:
        3. “Recklessly.” A person acts recklessly with respect to a result  or
  to  a circumstance described by a statute defining an offense when he is
  aware of and consciously disregards a substantial and unjustifiable risk
  that such result will occur or that such circumstance exists.  The  risk
  must  be  of such nature and degree that disregard thereof constitutes a
  gross deviation from the standard of conduct that  a  reasonable  person
  would observe in the situation.  A person who creates such a risk but is
  unaware  thereof  solely  by  reason of voluntary intoxication also acts
  recklessly with respect thereto.

So you have the complete picture, a Class C felony for a first offender is eligible for probation.  For John White to be guilty, he must have possess the mental state where he was aware of and consciously disregarded a substantial and unjustifiable risk that his conduct would result in Daniel Cicciaro’s death. 

That John White’s decision to go outside with a gun in his hand was a bad one is beyond question.  But was it a gross deviation from the standard of conduct that a reasonable person would observe?  To be guilty of the crime for which he was convicted, he must not merely have made a poor choice, but a choice that was so bad, so far from what a reasonable person would do, that the risk he created constituted a gross deviation.

But a young man ended up dead.  And racial prejudice was inflamed.  And a hardworking father of a boy who did nothing wrong is now convicted.  And it’s all because of some stupid internet prank. 

Can we see John White’s decision to protect his family from these young men who had no business, nor cause, to approach his house “like” a lynch mob as being either within, or at least relatively close, to a reasonable decision under the circumstances.  I think so. 

But I also see this as being at the confluence of where poor choices, stupidity, immaturity, racial hatred, denial of racial hatred and ego meet.  This was a horrible case for all involved. 

Criminal Procedure: They Have GOT to Be Kidding!

This blew me away.  As  announced by Orin Kerr, the new third edition of LaFave, Israel, King & Kerr’s Criminal Procedure treatise consists of 7 volumes.  Yikes! SEVEN!  Yes, you read that right.  Seven volumes.

And not little thin volumes.  No sir.  Seven volumes big thick volumes, with most volumes nearly a thousand pages.  The index to these seven volumes is 31 pages long.  I swear it!  The Table of Contents is here.  See for yourself!

So who exactly is supposed to read these seven volumes?  Not me, baby.  Oh no.  I don’t have a spare month of my life with nothing doing, not to mention my total absence of interest.  It’s not that I’m disinterested in learning more about criminal procedure per se, but I went limp just thinking about reading this treatise.

Any lawyers out there rushing out to buy these 7 volumes?  Raise your hands.  Not one.  Wait, I think I see one.  Nope, he was just scratching something.

What about law students, devotees of criminal procedure hoping to land that job with the Legal Aid Society.  Are you kids ready to shell out $689.50 to get that third edition on your shelf?  You’re gonna need a very thick shelf, you know.  No, dad says screw it, become a transactional lawyer.  He’s not laying out the money after just buying you that Wii for Christmas.  Enough is enough.

So if lawyers aren’t buying, and law students aren’t buying, who is?  My guess is that this is going to be one of those sets that gets a place of honor in the law school library.  Doesn’t US News rate law schools on the number of volumes in the library, so it pays to make it a seven volume treatise rather than six, and watch that law school rating plummet?  I can hear them now at Harvard, going “thank God they used up enough words to make that a set of seven, and keep us from falling to Tier 2, so our students will never get decent criminal law jobs.”  Yeah, I’m sure that conversation is happening.

And don’t think that it eluded me that this seven volume set is announced right before Christmas.  What to get that lawyer who has nothing but wants everything?  Oh yes, she’ll be so thrilled.  Order now and we guarantee delivery.  Heck, they’ll probably have somebody bring it to your door personally, since you’ll be the only actual living human being ordering.

Seriously, who buys this and why?  Were you guys sitting around, having a few emptying a keg of beer and just got out of control?  I know you have to realize how ludicrous it is to put out a 7 volume treatise.  So tell me, what were you thinking?

Final Grades, For Students and Lawyers

Since classes are over and finals completed, the lawprofs have turned to discussions of grading.  They are naturally concerned about fairness, predictability and the ease of getting through those essays so they don’t miss the opening kickoff.  They’re only human. 

Michael O’Hear, my newest favorite crimlaw prof, explains his grading rubric, but goes on to ponder what to do about students who hit the various points on the rubric, yet don’t seem to “get it.”  I was very glad that he recognized this detail, because the “get it” part is what makes an effective lawyer. 

With some regularity, an attorney will stand up and start to speak to the court and, for some inexplicable reason, demonstrate by what he raises and what he omits, that he just doesn’t “get it.”  By definition, he passed the bar exam, so the problem isn’t that he’s not smart enough to be a lawyer (talk about a low threshold).  There’s just something wrong, missing, there.  Some synapses just don’t fire the same way as other people’s.

In my experience, there are quite a few people whose thought processes are slightly askew.  Most of them end up as our clients.  A few become are colleagues.  A few become judges, which speaks more to the process of becoming a judge than anything else.

To a large extent, these lawyers work for institutions.  Often public defenders offices, scraping for manpower willing to serve for a salary that hovers around the poverty level.  There are also a few who find themselves positions within the court system, working as backroom court attorneys where they escape individualized scrutiny by judges who have to sign their names to the decisions they come up with.  This is often the route taken for those who end up on the bench, having managed to toil for years without anyone getting angry enough, or perhaps not evening noticing their existence, until they have enough time in the system to make the list of filler candidates for judgeship.

I’ve come to the conclusion that the bar exam does nothing to weed out potential lawyers who are unable to reason in a way that serves their clients interests well.  There are just too many of them who end up with a ticket to practice.  They make bad lawyers.  They make even worse judges. 

So reading about the lawprof’s dilemma, where these very same people while in law school are noted by some professor as not quite getting it, was quite curious.  It struck me as an opportune time to ascertain who these individuals are and to do something about it.

This will probably come off as elitist, but it’s not intended that way.  The nature of our work as lawyers encompasses two things that cannot be ignored:  We need to be capable of communicating an argument to another person in an effective way, and we hold the lives of real people in our hands.  In other words, it’s not about us, but about what we can do for our clients.

Making arguments that seem to us to be perfectly reasonable, logical and persuasive, yet fail to make a dent with the judge or jury, is a waste.  Convincing ourselves that we’re brilliant is pointless.   We need to be effective with the decision-maker. 

Putting someone’s life in the hands of an ineffective person is simply wrong, particularly when they have no choice in the matter.  When an indigent defendant is assigned a lawyer, he takes what he gets.  If he gets a dud, the defendant, his spouse, his children, all suffer the consequences.  If he selects a dud, we can accept the argument that he made his bed.  When he’s given no option, then we have failed to provide him with meaningful representation.  Not from a legal standpoint, perhaps, since meeting the Strickland standard can be accomplished with a rock dressed in a suit and tie, but from a human standard.  It’s not right to relegate a human being to a loser lawyer.

This is the point where my position gets a little fuzzy.  When the law student’s essay shows signs that you’ve got a person whose thought processes are a little askew, it should raise a red flag.  This may well be a very intelligent person, but perhaps not quite right for a career in the law.  Once he or she gets past law school, there is no mechanism to weed him or her out and safeguard the unsuspecting defendant who may end up with this person as his lawyer.  The only chance to deal with this logic-challenged individual is before he’s given the opportunity to pass the bar. 

Lawprofs, you know who I’m talking about.  You know there are kids whose minds simply reason in a different way than other students.  Their reasoning just fails.  They argue zealously, but to no avail.  You explain patiently, but they just don’t get it.  I’m not saying they are bad people, or even that they don’t have great things to offer society via their unusual view of logic.  I am saying that they are not appropriate candidates to be lawyers, and that they should never hold other people’s lives in their hands.

At no other point in their budding legal careers will there be an opportunity to point them in a different direction, where their talents will be put to better use and they will be prevented from unwittingly harming others.  The challenge is to identify these individuals and divert them from the universe of the law.  I know that this may conflict with the inclusive vision of the lawyer pool, and could be subject to abuse by lawprofs with political issues, but a mechanism needs to exist to protect the client who may someday come to rely on this individual to save their lives.

You know who they are.  Can you do something about it?

Society in Jail (Or How I Came to Love The Warrant)

By Jeffrey A. Tucker
Originally published at  mises.org for the Ludwig von Mises Institute and posted here with permission.
This is the second in a series of essays by Jeffrey Tucker, reflecting a non-lawyer’s view of the system from the inside out.  While you read this post, I suggest you hum “Alice’s Restaurant” to yourself.

“What are you in for?” the inmate of Lee County jail asked the new prisoner.


“Rolling through a stop sign in my subdivision,” answered the new inmate, to gales of laughter from others languishing in the same cell.


As they laugh, crumbs from their hard, dry sandwiches — distributed by the wardens twice per day — flew from their mouths to add to the debris of filth on the floor that was ground up by the cracked plastic sleeping mats and absorbed by the old, thin blankets inmates use to keep warm in this cold and wet 8×8 room.


The new inmate today joined the 500 prisoners, among whom were some of the most violent threats to society — but also people who, like Inmate 501, are no threat to anyone.


He had been trying to make his one phone call, to which you are supposedly entitled when you land in the big house. The phone would only call collect, even for local calls. That meant that it couldn’t call cell phones. Most local services don’t even have collect-call options anymore. So you dial and dial but the phone might as well be a prop on the wall. There is no way out.


There is also no way for you to be called, by anyone. You have no cell phone. No laptop. No book. No watch, and there is no clock on the wall. No one knows what time it is. No one who does know will tell you. Not even a single scrap of paper are you allowed to take into the cell after your arrest. You can only stand there in your paper-thin prison clothes and plastic sandals.


“Man, this is jail,” someone screamed as the new inmate tried to dial for the tenth time. “Jail! Phones don’t work in JAIL!”


So Inmate 501 stood for an unknown number of hours, hoping that he would be bailed out by his wife and kids who had seen him handcuffed and dragged away from home after Sunday brunch. He also hoped that this would happen before he needed to use the toilet, which was filthy and frontally exposed to everyone, including the women coming and going.


The saga began last October, when he rolled through the same stop sign in front of a private swimming pool that he and fifty others roll through several times per day. He thought he had paid the ticket but he hadn’t, and the court date came and went. He received no other notices.


But something interesting was brewing in local politics after he received the ticket. The local newspapers ran a series that claimed to unearth ticket-fixing going on in the Auburn city government. It seems that some friends of powerful people were getting their tickets dismissed. Auburn was already known for its lax enforcement but this had the whiff of corruption.


The papers lacked details but there were hints that the whole story was a result of a dispute between an elected official and an appointed city manager. The city manager later resigned or was kicked out.


The suggestion of corruption was enough to attract the attention of the FBI, which made some inquiries. The combination of the media pressure and FBI curiosity was enough to force a change in city policy. The new policy in Auburn would be total crackdown on ticket violators, particularly those that didn’t pay and didn’t show up to their court dates.


Now, usually people who don’t show up for court dates for petty issues such as this are just contacted and eventually pay. But technically, they can also be arrested, just as this person was. When the city government is under pressure to show that it is not corrupt but good and clean and tough on crime, the result is that the fine print becomes a license for just about anything.


So in the last several months, the city has been busy issuing warrants for people who have outstanding tickets of any sort. Cops have been tracking down people in their workplaces, homes, on the streets or anywhere, and treating them all like violent offenders.


The new prisoner, for example, who had never been arrested in his life, still had discolored marks on his wrists where the handcuffs had been slapped on.


We tend to think of the law as some sort of oiled machine that works according to the regulations. The truth is that the law is administered by people with a great deal of discretion over how others are treated. The wardens and correctional officials can choose to humiliate a person in whatever way they want. They can put you in prison clothes that fit or in some that are way too tight. They can tell you the time or not. Leave you to languish or make a call for you. They can insult you and lie about your status or be kind.


The only sure way to elicit something approaching humane behavior from them is to crawl and beg like a dog. You are worse than a slave, because you have nothing of value to offer your new owners. You are worse than an animal in a zoo because you are of no value to your captors. They really don’t care if you live or die. Those who do care cannot help.


No one has more discretion than the judge, who holds your life in his hands. You are dependent on his mood of the moment. If he lets you off easy, he considers himself benevolent. If he sentences you to 10 years or a life in prison, he is only doing his job. It’s always your fault for not having been sufficiently subservient at the outset.


The dramatic change in Inmate 501’s life occurred in the course of minutes. All it took was a knock on the door. It mattered not at all that the supposed crime was completely innocuous. Once you are on the wrong side of the law, your life is officially worth nothing to anyone but those who can do little or nothing to help you.


People talk of government compassion. But there is no compassion in jail, which is where anyone who resists the state — even in the smallest way — ultimately ends up. People talk of social justice but to implement it means requiring everyone to make a choice: obey or face humiliation and servitude.


Yes, people can “file grievances” or “sue,” and that is always the first thought of anyone who finds himself in the hands of captors. But to whom do you appeal? Whom do you sue? You are here again appealing to the same class of people, the same group of coercive agents, who have robbed you of your freedom. Your rights extend only as far as your masters allow them to extend.


People who criticize government as nothing but beating, killing, and hanging — to use Mises’s phrase — are sometime accused of using exaggerated and hyperbolic language. Surely government is more than that and is not always that. Something as simple as a stop sign doesn’t beat you or kill you!


And yet, what the critics of government mean is that all law, even that which appears to be a mere guideline and a help, must ultimately be enforced at the point of a gun. It represents a threat to obey or lose all freedom.


This insight applies to all law, whether it results from a Constitution, legislation, or appears out of nothing more than a regulatory body. Every regulation, no matter how small is enforced at the point of the gun. Every tax can result in handcuffing and jailing and even killing those who fail to fork over. Hidden behind each mandate is an armed tough in jackboots and a bulletproof vest who is prepared to beat and kill to serve the state and its laws.


As legislation extends, so does the coercive arm of the state, its police powers, its jails, and its reach over society. It is like a poisonous fog that descends and grows more by the day, seeping into every nook and cranny of life: schools, businesses, homes, churches. Nowhere is exempt. The sound of the jailer’s key rattling grows louder and more ear-piercing. The culture of the jail, where people are treated worse than animals, proliferates. You can’t move without risking life or limb.


At some point in his day, Inmate 501’s heard someone holler out his name. The electronic click on the bars sounded and the door opened. He had been bailed out, $500 in cash having been extracted from his bank account and forked over to the city police. He was now free — pending payment of the ticket and another court date.


He left behind 500 others who are not so fortunate. Some of them are hardened criminals. Others are in jail for smoking pot. Others were in the same boat as he: a minor traffic violation gone wrong. None have rights. All are captive, like citizens in an occupied city where there is only violence and no law.


But how free is he really? He lives in a society where nothing takes place outside the purview of the state, which is to say that he will always live one step away from the prison cell that was his home for a day. One or two wrong moves and he has lost it all. All of society is not yet a jail such as you find in totalitarian societies or a society under occupation due to military conquest, but with every expansion of the state, the jailers get that much more power over all of us.

Their power is not always overt but it always lies in waiting. This was triggered by a zealous cop looking to fill a ticket quota, and an attempt to clean up government from corruption — prompted by a media-driven non-scandal that attracted the attention of the Feds. It resulted in personal catastrophe. We really don’t get all the government we pay for, and thank goodness. Lord protect us on the day that we do.

Passive Physical Resistance Gets A Jolt

Ah, it’s the merry holiday, good will toward man and all that stuff. Which means, it’s time for another taser video.

This time, the woman was tased at Best Buy because, according to the police chief, she was “loud and profane” at one point, or engaged in “passive physical resistance” at another.  I engage in passive physical resistance all the time.  You just can’t tell because I’m doing nothing.  Fortunately, I prefer to do it in the privacy of my own home, where the only people who feel compelled to act against me are my children, and I’ve been wise enough to deny them access to tasers. 

So here it is.  Happy holidays.  And remember, you really can get anything electronic at Best Buy!


 

Why Try The Unwinnable Case?

Mark Bennett, the Texas Tornado, posts about why he tries the unwinnable case.  Now that he’s returned from being an American in Paris, he’s got a lot of things to post about and is trying to make up for lost time.  We are all the better for it.

We’re not trying these cases for justice, and we’re not trying them to win (though arguably there’s always a chance that the prosecutor will screw something up and we’ll win, which is something to hope for). Sometimes the goal is just to make it costly and difficult for the government to put the client in a box.

Be careful with that “we” thing there, pal.  When I try a case, it’s not because I enjoy doing so (though I do) or that I just want to tweak the government’s nose.  I try because I must.  I try because I have no choice.

I go to trial because my client tells me he is innocent and wants his day in court.  I will give it to him, after fully informing him of what that means.

I go to trial because the government has left my client with no choice but to try the case.  This is typically because the plea offer is horrible, leaving the defendant without options.

My job is to fulfill my clients needs as best I can, given the circumstances.  Sometimes, it looks like the case cannot be won, but the defendant, after being fully informed of the options and recognizing that there is no option that he can live with, says, “do it.”  And I will.

But I’ve never tried a case just to screw with the government.  Even when the case is unwinnable, it is never my purpose to exact a cost from the government if they want to put my client in a box.  Mark muddies the waters somewhat by using the phrase “costly and difficult,” as it’s not clear what he means by difficult. If he means that I’m not going roll over and die because it would make the government’s job easier, then I agree.  If it means that I’m just going to make their life more difficult for its own sake, then no.

When trying the unwinnable case, the potential for prosecutorial screw-up is my primary focus and greatest hope.  And with surprising frequency, prosecutors don’t disappoint.  Between the various tentacles of the law enforcement-prosecutorial complex, there are so many opportunities for errors that I never dismiss that potential.  I remain keenly aware of any opening to exploit.  Because of this heavy emphasis, I find things when others do not.  And it doesn’t hurt to see potential openings and then do what I can to “lend a hand” to a prosecutor or cop who may elect to take a shortcut or two.

Is this a cynical criminal defense lawyer playing the system for all it’s worth?  Well, I guess.  If you want to make it sound pejorative.  If you’re the defendant, or spouse, or child, or parent, or baby momma, you would think differently.  A more useful perspective would be to expect everyone, including those fine public servants who know that their paycheck will come every other Friday as long as the government continues to have the power to tax your sorry private sector butt, to do their jobs.  If they do, then my eagle-eyed expectation of error is for naught.

So the unwinnable case never really exists in my world, or at least not in my head.  While cases may appear unwinnable from a neutral perspective, assuming arguendo that everything happens the way it should and the trial proceeds flawlessly, I would be incapable of trying a case if I did not believe that at some point, at any moment, whenever I least expect it, something will happen that will let me blow the prosecution out of the water.

And that’s why I try the unwinnable case.  Like I said, I try it because I must.

New Orleans, An All-American City

In the wake of Hurricane Katrina, the rulings powers of New Orleans had to make some difficult decisions.  One difficult issue had to do with the demolition of 4,500 units of low income housing by the feds, who were busy trying to push 30,000 poor people out of their lovely trailer homes.  Into where, no one can say, but you can only live in a federal trailer for so long, you know.

The issue was a hot one, and hot issues bring people out to voice their opinion.  And people came out. A lot of them, and they tried to let the powerful know what they thought.

Police officers tried to keep protesters out of the Council chambers once all the seats were filled. Demonstrators tried to push through some iron gates to get in when the police used what appeared to be pepper spray and stun guns; at least two protesters needed medical treatment.

There was also a brief fight inside the chambers, and the police ejected some demonstrators. About 15 protesters were arrested, the police said, mostly on charges of disturbing the peace.

I am in no position to express a view as to who was right on the topic, but I am in a very good position to say that this is wrong.

Our republican form of government anticipates a wide swathe where the people, those insignificant little bugs that crawl all over decisions like this that impact on the powerless, get to let the powerful know how they feel.  That’s how things are supposed to work.  Important public officials get elected because of generalized public trust, but not because they are god-like on every issue that comes before them.  Sometimes, they need to be reminded that there are people out there who hold certain beliefs.  They aren’t required to pass-through the views of the public, but they can damn well pay a little attention to them.

The protesters in New Orleans sought the opportunity to be heard.  They were sprays and tased for their efforts.  They were tossed out of the meeting.  There was nowhere near enough room for those who wanted their views to be noted to find a seat to watch government in action.

Now I realize that some will say that they behaved poorly in this effort, and that they got what they deserved because they didn’t stay in a single file, or sit with their hands folded neatly across their lap, or wait patiently for their turn to speak.  These are folks who believe that order is more important than freedom when it comes to making political decisions.  It’s one view of politics. 

There are few responses to the pro-order folks, who applaud the use of force to keep the rabble down.  First, you are unAmerican.  Our forefathers appreciated the need to grab the attention of their rulers, and happily did so with guns.  When the powerful won’t pay attention to the powerless, American tradition is to make your presence known with whatever methods are available.  America wasn’t founded on order, but on freedom.  If you want to believe in America, then you have to put up with some of the messier aspects of our birthright.

Second, government does not trump the people, but is the people.  We’ve lost this concept somewhere along the line, when we started to treat public servants like rock stars.  Sure, they want us to view them as “leaders,” and we want them to be leaders, but they are entitled to lead only because we let them.  When elected officials are allowed to disconnect themselves from the people, particularly the least powerful of the people, they lose their legitimate authority to act.  I know it seems like they have all the power, but it comes from the bottom up.  Don’t every elevate the servant to the master.  But who am I to tell you that, right?

And finally, the resort to force against the protesters by police reflects a pattern that needs to stop.  We do not give police guns and shields so that they can violently quell anyone who doesn’t do as they command.  Like our political leaders, they are paid to protect and serve the public.  Those protesters are the public. 

Demanding that their public servants hear their voices is not a crime of violence, to be met with violent force by police.  When are we going to get past the idea that because cops have weapons, that means they are entitled to use them?  At least they didn’t shoot anyone.  I guess that’s a positive.