Author Archives: SHG

Florida Criminal Defense Lawyer Attacked For Blawging

Doesn’t it seem like a lot of bad things happen in Florida?  Well, there’s one new threat to add to the list.  Sean Conway, a former public defender now in private practice, may lose his license for having  critically blawged about “embattled Broward Circuit Judge Cheryl Alemán, calling her an ‘evil, unfair witch.‘ ” as reported in the South Florida Sun-Sentinel, via How Appealing, Capital Defense Weekly, and Real Lawyers Have Blogs.

“Last week, as Alemán was on trial for alleged misconduct before the Judicial Qualifications Commission, The Florida Bar signed off on its finding that Sean Conway may have violated five bar rules, including impugning the judge’s qualifications or integrity.

Clearly, this development has some serious consequences for blawgers who seek to exercise free speech by opining critically about important issues, cases, rules and public officials.  The fact that Judge Aleman may indeed be an “evil unfair witch” really isn’t relevant, as no one wants that to be the test of free speech, so don’t let the detail sidetrack the debate.

We know, as attorneys, that we live and work under conflicting ethical obligations and rules.  On the one hand, we are not to impugn the integrity of a judge.  On the other, we are obliged to aid in the public’s understanding of the law and to improve the administration of justice.  If a judge is bad, it would be wrong to conceal it.  But if we reveal it, we are wrong to impugn the judge.  Ethics is often a moving target, only to be defined by post-hoc determination of which rule some local body wants to enforce that day.

My guess is that Conway’s criticism was so harsh that it scared the crap out of the local ethics committee, to the point where they feared that if they let it go, it would open the door to venomous attacks on judges on the internet, whether fair or not, that would wreak havoc on the judiciary.  Since Judges are prohibited from defending themselves, this makes the game unfair and leaves it to the disciplinary committee to “fix” the problem.

But the flip side is that lawyers are people too, and thus have a right under the 1st Amendment to speak their minds on subjects of public importance.  No one ever told us as we were being sworn in that we would have to relinquish our constitutional rights in order to stand in the well.  And indeed, if lawyers don’t talk about judges, how would the public know what really happens in their courts?

While this is happening in South Florida, the place where hanging chads gave us a war in a country whose name most people mispronounce, it may very well have a chilling effect across the blawgosphere.  We may desire to blawg for good purposes, but how many lawyers are prepared to lose their license should they step over that wavy line?  Good sense tells us to stay away from saying anything controversial about judges, which could include dumb court decisions or bad rulings or judicial corruption.  What’s left?

The fear is that this will prove to be a cancer that spreads across the blawgosphere, and across the nation’s grievance committees.  It will be the judge’s weapon of choice for stifling online criticism of them, their practices and their decisions.  It will make blawgs incredibly boring and pointless.

I’ve never shied away from calling a judge, or a decision, they way I see them.  But then, I do it in the courtroom as well, and don’t hide behind my blawging when it comes to standing up against impropriety.  Granted, my critiques don’t involve the word “witch”, or any similar word with a different consonant.  Not because I’m afraid to do so, but because it’s uninformative and I prefer to keep the language on this blawg fairly clean. 

I don’t see my fellow criminal defense blawgers, like Bennett,  Gideon or Jon Katz, quivering in fear of a grievance either.  But what of the younger crowd, like Shawn, who aspires to the bench someday?  Would he take a chance of offending the local power structure and lose any chance of being called Young Judge Shawn?  Should he be forced to make that call?

I have no intention of changing my ways, and I would rather stop blawging than be afraid of controversy.  Of course, I’m not under threat of losing my license.  Yet.

The Blawgosphere Hits a New Low

And thankfully, it was PI lawyers, not criminal defense lawyers.  Kevin O’Keefe, an advocate of lawyers using blawgs to market their existence, at  Real Lawyers Have Blawgs has a vested interest in keeping the blawgosphere clean.  While we may quibble over whether promotional blawging impairs the purpose and credibility of the blawgosphere, at least we share the belief that it should never deliberately violate ethical precepts and prove to the world that attorneys are, indeed, the lowest form of scum.

But  Kevin found a personal injury lawyer’s blawg that went too far. 


Ran across this personal injury blog post in my RSS feeds tonight. Posted by Attorney Ryan Bradley of St. Louis.


The title of the post was:


[Name of injury victim] Sustains Personal Injury In Car Wreck on I-70 Near Earth City Expressway in St. Louis County; St. Louis Missouri Personal Injury Law Firm Gives Free Legal Advice to Car Accident Victims :: Missouri Accident Lawyer Blog

The post goes on to directly solicit the victim or his family to call the law firm for legal advice.  Hi-tech ambulance chasing, with the victim’s name used and the implication is that he either does, or seeks to, represent the victim.

Turkewitz spells it out this way:

Thus, he goes beyond the mere advertising, and into outright solicitation of an individual. Even if he is ethically secure on First Amendment grounds, what the has done certainly appears scummy and is a close cousin to sending a solicitation in the mail to the house. Or picking up the phone and calling. Or sending a person to the house. Or the hospital. You know where I’m gong with this. Solicitation is but one step removed from actual ambulance chasing.

One step removed might be generous in the digital age when physical presence behind the ambulance isn’t necessary.  This feeds into every negative stereotype of lawyers, with the only difference being the adaptation of the internet as the delivery mechanism.

Then Kevin, ever the crusader for safe marketing, found another :


Seattle plaintiff’s lawyer Mike Meyers writes about accidents naming seriously injured people he does not represent ‘with the intent of reaching accident victims or the people who care about them.’


…I want them–or someone who cares about them–to call our office and get the help they deserve rather than being manipulated by a well trained adjuster to settle their claim short of full value. It’s as simple as that.

Lets turn this sucker to the side and see how it would work for criminal defense lawyers.  Assume some fictional defendant gets busted.  We can call her “Bartha Stewart.”  She’s loaded, and representing her would be akin to being born a trust-fund baby.  Some blawging lawyer, who we’ll call named “Mob Rovillo,” sees the headline over his morning cup’o’joe, and says, “I want that case.”

Ten minutes later, the headline to the post on his blawg, I’m The Best White Collar Defender EVER!, reads:

Bartha Stewart Busted.  Rovillo Is The ONLY Lawyer Who Can Beat the Rap!  Call Me Now, Bartha!

Now let’s assume this isn’t a parody, but he’s serious.  The body of the post goes on to state that he’s the only competent lawyer for this case, and the rest are lying, cheating, incompetent scuzzbuckets.  Okay, this example may be laughable because of its ineffectiveness, but the point remains that it has the potential to prove to our many detractors that criminal defense lawyers are indeed scum.

More importantly, I can see something along these lines being one possible future for the blawgosphere.  Let’s face it, there are many lawyers starting blawgs with the hope that they will prove the marketing panacea of the future.  It’s a small step for them to go the “direct solicitation” route.  But if they do, and if no one calls them on it, these efforts will turn the blawgosphere into proof that lawyer haters, in general, and criminal defense lawyer haters, in particular, need to show that we are the evil people they believe us to be.

Kudos to Kevin and Turk for finding these miscreants and calling them what they are.  And thank God it was the PI sluts, and not some criminal defense lawyer, who decided to take the first leap into the gutter.

Criminal Defense Lawyer of the Year, 2007

It’s that time of year when we look back and take note of what mattered and what didn’t.  The  ABA Journal has done it’s job, making AG, Alberto Gonzalez, it’s Lawyer of the Year for 2007 (and Michael Mukasey its Lawyer of the Year for 2008, just in case the world explodes before next December). 

But these Beauty Pageants have little to do with real criminal defense lawyers who serve their clients in the trenches.  Indeed, even when someone gives an award to a criminal defense lawyer, it’s almost always because of who he or she is rather than what he or she has done.  Big name, high-profile lawyers receive plenty of attention, while the efforts in the trenches for defendant’s whose cases don’t make the front page go unnoticed.

So, I have decided to try something totally different.  I am taking nominations for Criminal Defense Lawyer of the Year, 2007.  This will not be a Beauty Pageant for the usual suspects, the big name lawyers in the high-profile cases, but rather the unsung heroes in the trenches, doing the dirty work that flies under the radar. 

Please nominate a criminal defense lawyer who has done something to deserve recognition.  Please let us know what it is that he or she has done.  Do not feel constrained to limit yourself to lawyers who made headlines.  The winner will be judged by the worth of his or her efforts in the scheme of our duty to zealously represent those accused of crimes.

It’s about time that we recognize the extraordinary accomplishments of our brethren in the trenches.  Now it’s up to you to submit your nomination, via the comments, and acknowledge the exceptional work done every day by men and women who have never made the front page of the newspaper.  Let’s do it.

So They’re on Steroids — What Now? (Updated)

I doubt there is anyone who can name a soldier who died yesterday in Iraq, but  we all know that a bunch of “star” professional baseball players took “performance enhancing drugs.”  We know that the “powers” charged with keeping baseball clean didn’t do a very good job of it.  We’re shocked and disappointed?

Though I’m not a baseball fan, as I see it as a sport for people who think soccer is too fast paced, I know enough about the game to surmise that anybody who gets paid $100,000 any time his bat touches a ball is going to do whatever he has to do to keep that ATM working.  At least we can thank God that nobody playing football or basketball has ever touched steroids.

Does this mean that all the stars are criminals?  Does this wipe out the last 20 years of World Series wins, or the records broken?  Does this mean that the game is a fraud and they’re all cheaters? 

Consider what our beloved baseball stars would be doing if there was no big league contract in their pockets.  For the most part, they were poor kids from poor neighborhoods who showed athletic promise.  A turn to the left and they could have been in prison.  A turn to the right and they are behind the counter at a bodega.  Straight ahead and they get a zillion dollars.  Which sounds best to you?

So they go for the money and the glory and the applause.  Can you blame them for wanting to be a sports hero?  I can’t.  And if steroids make the difference between hitting the ball out of the park or throwing 100 miles per hour, and having a brief and unremarkable career, are you shocked they took the risk?  Remember, people shoot heroin and don’t even get a big league contract out of it.  So steroids will harm them?  So will starvation.

The question now is whether this revelation (I’m shocked. Shocked!) will mean that end of professional sports as we know it.  After all, how can we now compare Barry Bonds with Babe Ruth.  Or Roger Clemens with Roger Maris.  It may yet turn out that professional wrestling is the only honest sport around.

The situation is not fixable, per se.  We can’t undo the past 20 years and create some proportionality scale that will let us make sense of today’s drug enhanced box scores with those of past heroes.  Nor, as Senator Mitchell implored, would we do well by rounding all these stars up and putting them in prison for their drug use.  Of course, that makes our imprisoning all the other, no-star, drug users seem a little less than fair, but that’s only if a lack of intellectual integrity bothers you.

There is no good way out of this situation for anyone, sports icon or fan.  But there’s a real problem with the 100,000 kids injecting steroids to be just like their heroes.  Or perhaps the 1,000,000 taking some other drug because they never had the sports prowess to make steroids their drug of choice. 

As much as I want to find it in my heart to worry my head off about baseball players, this silly mess just doesn’t merit that level of concern.  Maybe Bud Selig can fine them all half their salaries since they started in the game and turn that money over to groups that will use it to deal with all the kids who have taken to drugs, whether anabolic or not, to soothe their angst for not having the inherent gifts that our sports heroes possess.  They can keep their records and world series’ rings, as long as they make it right with society.  That would work for me.

Addendum:  Interesting post by Jeffrey Lipshaw at Concurring Opinions noting the misuse at WSJ Blog and elsewhere of claims that the Mitchell Report is a smear job based on “hearsay”.  Taint no hearsay (other than the fact this obviously isn’t happening in a court of law) when the information comes from the fellow who’s jabbing the needles in himself.  This doesn’t make it true, or above question, since it hasn’t been put through the rigors of cross-examination, but it surely isn’t hearsay.

Anything That Fits, They’ll Print

After another round of threatening, pleading and cajoling, the issue of judicial pay raised for New York’s judges came back to the editorial page of the  New York Times this week.  As Eric the Turk noted, Chief Judge Judy Kaye flip-flopped on the judiciary suing the State, again.  If she doesn’t sue, she may  write another hard-hitting, scathing op-ed.

The problem with going to the mattresses too many times is that, no matter how right you are or how persuasive your arguments, when the Legislature just doesn’t succumb, it soon becomes clear that you’re shooting blanks.  Poor judges, so much money spent to get elected, so much authority within the confines of a majestic courtroom, and so little appreciation anywhere else.

When this whole disaster began, I  took the opportunity to remind the judges that, although they deserved a raise, their quest for outside support for their predicament raised an issue.  These same people were awfully harsh on lawyers for the indigent who had gone 17 years without a raise, when they had only gone 10.  Do lawyers’ children not want to eat everyday too?

But this time, the New York Times editorial went a bit too far in their argument for raises, unintentionally demeaning those individuals who sit on the bench because of belief in public service and a need to have their lives serve a greater purpose.  Sure, they still need to get paid to feed their families, send their kids to college and buy the occasional new Toyota.  But to tie their motives to cash is undignified and misguided.


In judging, as in most lines of work, competitive salaries are important for attracting the best work force.

No. No. No.  Judging is different.  The best work force for the bench does not include those seduced by the pay.  Not merely because the pay, even with a huge raise, will still be miserable, but because the “best work force” for the position is motivated by a sincere sense of public service.

Thankfully, somebody who knows what he’s talking about  wrote the New York Times and straightened out this misguided New York Times position.


While there is no doubt that judicial raises are long overdue and mired in politics, I take issue with your assertion that “in judging, as in most lines of work, competitive salaries are important for attracting the best work force.” No one should sit in judgment of others because the money is good. To suggest that salaries are the motivator for exceptional people to assume the bench is to denigrate the integrity of the judiciary.

Not to mention that, even with a raise, the salaries will still fall significantly below that of a first year associate, including bonus, at any major law firm. Judges must be paid appropriately, and never again left to beg for crumbs from the politicians. But not because they are only in it for the money.

Of course the judiciary needs a pay raise.  This entire situation has been unseemly and wrong.  But in the desperation to move the Legislature off its conflicted, self-serving backside, let’s not drag the judiciary off the bench and into the gutter.  We may not think that every judge is perfect, but we aspire to a legal system where they are worthy or, and receive, everyone’s respect. 

Smart guy, whoever wrote that letter to the New York Times.  Too bad it only appears in the online edition and they didn’t have room to put it into the print edition (like they said they were going to).

72,000 Law Review Articles

According to Jeff Harrison at MoneyLaw, that’s the number of law review articles produced by lawprofs over the past 10 years.  I kid you not.  72,000.  And climbing.  And that’s without adding in the books they write.

To what end?  According to Lucky Jim, “. . . along the knife-edge dividing the conceivably-just-about-relevant from the irreducibly, immitigably, irrelevant.”   Other than to prove scholarliness and productivity amongst one’s peers, and to help their law school ranking, not even other lawprofs can bother to read them.


One hundred thousand offerings by law professors. Tons and tons of law review pages, ink, and now, of course, down-loaded pages just in case the article may come in handy. If you down-load as casually as I do, these are send to recycling about a year later often after not much more than a skim.

Should trees die so lawprofs have something to do at night?  I think not.  In fact, I think it’s a terrible waste that so many good thoughts and carefully drawn sentences are wasted on the dusty desks of other lawprofs.  Since I’m not a lawprof, I must posit that they write because they must if they want to keep their standing amongst academics.  But does it serve any greater good?  Not if there are so many articles that no one can read them.

But it doesn’t have to be this way.  It’s a shame to waste all these fine minds on writing articles that no one will read, and certainly not the “irreducibly, immitigably, irrelevant” articles. 

As Harrison proposes more rigorous standards for publication, to reduce the sheer number to something more manageable (not to mention useful), what are the others to do?  How about go out into the real world and apply their formidable talents to the representation of people who are otherwise shut out of the legal system?  Certainly, there are the poor criminal defendants entitled to counsel by Gideon.  But what of the civil litigants for whom legislatures and courts create many important rights and causes of action, but the cost of vindicating those rights is so disproportionate that it will never happen.

Consider, for example, the Tom F. case, which was financed by a wealthy parent but was of huge importance to less wealthy families who would never otherwise have been able to afford to litigate a case like that all the way to the Supreme Court.  There are plenty of cases like this, where enormously important rights are at stake, but subject to financial ability to litigate.  It’s perfect.

It’s not that some law review articles don’t enhance our understanding of the law, or influence its future direction.  But 72,000?  Too many words with far too little relevance.  Consider this option, going out into the real world and putting your energies toward helping real people with real problems in the real world.  Now that’s relevant.

Practical Blawgosphere: New Life to Pre-Sentence Memos

While the more scholarly parse the words of  Gall and  Kimbrough for hidden meanings and secret tests far better than I can, the bottom line for the practicing lawyer is that the ball is now in our court to make good use of this new-found opportunity to better serve our clients.

Prior to Booker, the bulk of the criminal defense lawyers’ effort was directed toward arguing where, in the narrow window of the Guidelines range, our client would be sentenced.  Sure, there were times when we were able to argue for a downward departure, whether because of a specific unusual circumstance or a Koons Heartland approach, but this was the exception, and even then a stretch most of the time.  The occasional Fatico hearing was worth the risk, but this too was a major exception.  Our fight was limited to the bottom of the range, and that was the best we could hope for.

At least for the moment, things have now changed.  The pre-sentence machinery, that had ground to a virtual halt back in 1987 when the Guidelines were finally upheld, needs to be retooled to address the potential to convince a sentencing judge that, while the mandatory minimums can’t be ignored, everything else is fair play.

The use of pre-sentence memoranda is suddenly back.  Not the typical letters that were sent to the judge explaining what a great guy the defendant is, or how painful this will be to his family and friends.  Not the handful of letters from the usual suspects about the defendant’s kindness and generosity.  That stuff never persuaded anybody before, and it’s certainly not going to get you a sentencing victory now.  The one thing that the Supreme Court decisions made clear, at least to me, is that you need to give the court some hard ammunition if you want to achieve a significant reduction off the guidelines.

In the past, when the opportunity presented itself, I have put together major pre-sentence memoranda that served to chronicle the life of a defendant, from its start to the day of sentence.  These memos can be a huge undertaking, requiring hours of interviews and as much writing as an appellate brief.  But they serve to provide a sentencing court with a full understanding of the human being whose life they are about to decide.  It humanizes the defendant far beyond anything we can say.  It explains the path that landed them in court.  It shows the full dimension of their life, that they did good things and had people who loved them, as well as the problems and shortcomings that created the person before the court.

This is not a simple endeavor.  It’s very time-consuming, and can be quite expensive.  It will almost always involve some sort of medical or psychological testing and assessment, with a report that explains its impact on the defendant’s life, decision-making, impulse control, etc. 

Then there are the letters of support.  These can either be enormously helpful, or a total waste of time.  It’s up to the lawyer to explain and direct the letter writers to prepare meaningful letters providing hard information that will have an impact on the judge.  Telling the defendant to get some letters together is generally a waste of time and effort.  A letter from the church pastor about how the defendant comes to church every Sunday is useless, yet this is what most defendants think they should provide.  In their minds, this is an important person who might sway the judge.  To the judge, this is a form letter that brings no information to the table. 

Prepare instructions for the defendant to give to his letter writers, telling them to state how they know the defendant and for how long.  Tell them to provide specific actual experiences to support their assertion that the defendant is a good person.  They must include a name and address on the letter, as well as write legibly or, better yet, type the letter.  They have to sign it.  And critically, they should not argue that the defendant is innocent.  He’s being sentenced, so that horse has left the barn.  Instead, ask for consideration of the good the defendant has done or the troubles he has faced.

The letter and medical/psychological report then have to be integrated into the body of the memorandum.  Use of quotes to support your arguments are extremely helpful.  This means, of course, that you need the letters and reports before you prepare the memo, so that all pieces create a positive synergy that culminates in a report that is stronger than its individual pieces. 

The memo needs to proceed to focus on the legitimate sentencing factors, meaning that you follow the statutory criteria,18 USC 3553(a) and caselaw considerations.  Apply your arguments directly to the factors that the court needs to justify a lower sentence than the guidelines would dictate, and that will give the court a basis to explain its decision for purposes of appellate review. 

As both Gall and Kimbrough make clear, the district judge must still be able to provide an explanation for the sentence imposed, with the guidelines as the baseline consideration.  If you fail to provide hard reasoning for the deviation from the guidelines your seeking, your giving the judge nothing to work with and exposing her to reversal.  She knows this, and so must you. 

The window of opportunity is now open.  It’s up to criminal defense lawyers to now fulfill their responsibility by using the opportunity created by these decisions to its fullest.  Since sentence may be the most important battle one fights in federal court, there is no excuse for not putting in the degree of effort and attention that it deserves.

Addendum:  I’ve already received an email asking what I think of sentencing mitigation specialists.  I am not a big fan.  Their approach tends to be formulaic and superficial, focusing on the issues that they are competent to address (for example, where the specialist is a psychologist, it’s all about the psychology of the defendant and there’s little mention of anything else).  Doing the job right is addressing the entire person, not just the limited perspective of a single specialty.

Judges have read these reports before and like any repetitive submissions, they lose their impact over time.  In my opinion, it is critical that each pre-sentence memo be sui generis if it’s going to serve it’s purpose.  If the judge doesn’t bother to read it, then there’s no purpose in submitting it.

Utah Taser Video, The Final Chapter (?)

The fact that we have something like a video to allow us to even discuss what happened on a Utah highway shoulder is a remarkable thing.  Before the advent of dashboard videos, we would have a defendant’s version and a cop’s version.  If this gave rise to any discussion at all, it would be a leap of faith as to which version we believed. 

Most people, in fact the vast majority, would buy the cops version.  Some would believe the cop because that’s what they are incline to do.  Others would simply go with the odds, and the odds are that the cop’s version would be more credible than the defendant’s, who we would presume to have a greater self-interest in denying wrongdoing.

Instead, we can debate what we see on the video and the reasonableness of the officer’s conduct.  This is a miracle.  It’s not perfect, as demonstrated by the many disagreements in what we see and what it means, but a miracle that we have something to see to generate debate.  If nothing else, it shows that no side is always right and that jumping to conclusions is unwarranted. 

Many of the comments here and elsewhere have questioned why, in my discussion of whether the video supports the argument that the officer had an objectively reasonable basis to believe that the driver was armed, did I ignore the many portions that demonstrate overwhelmingly that the officer had no such subjective belief.  They argued that this was a show of police bravado, the use of force to shut the driver up and impose obedience, and the entire discussion about whether he could have been armed was a silly waste of time.

The best answer I can give is that there was never any doubt, at least in my mind, that the officer used his taser to teach the driver who’s boss from the outset.  This was a given, and didn’t merit prolonged discussion.  It was clear from start to finish that once the driver refused to comply with the cop’s direction, he was going to be tasered into submission.  End of discussion.

That point decided, I turned to the more interesting issue of how so many otherwise “reasonable” people could bend over backwards to find a way to justify the unjustifiable.  Orin Kerr approached this from the purely legal perspective, employing the test that would be used by a court in assessing the propriety of the officer’s use of force.  

Orin’s focus, and that of his readers, was whether the conduct found an objectively reasonable basis, even though it was subjectively nonsense.  Mind you, they weren’t giving ground on the subjective intent piece, which was no longer in play as far as I was concerned, but the miracle of a videotape allowed us to sit back, munch on popcorn and decide whether there was an objectively reasonable basis.  It was great fun, since we weren’t in the line of taser fire. 

From a real world perspective, the defense need only address the rationale put forth by the prosecution, unless the judge is particularly activist and decides to superimpose his own views on the issue.  Of course, the defense would then be denied the opportunity to address the issue, since it would never be argued and come out of left field in the decision to smack us upside the head.  As a practical matter, we don’t raise issues against us that haven’t been raised by the prosecution, thus giving them additional ammunition to argue their position.  I have doubts that a prosecutor would argue that the tasering was justified by an objectively reasonable belief that the driver was armed because the evidence that there was no subjective belief is so overwhelming.  Thus, this entire discussion has been largely academic.

Still, we learn from all of this.  And we learn a lot.  All lawyers tend to see the world as an “us versus them” proposition, as do cops, lawprofs, and just about everyone else.  But as a criminal defense lawyer, I feel compelled to better understand what “them” is thinking and why, and then what I can do about it.  If I don’t get it, I can’t deal with it.  What I think means very little.  It’s about what others think that teaches me to be a better lawyer and allows me to be more effective.

And so the discussion raged, and I appreciate Orin’s help in making it happen, even if I get overly snippy or snarky in the process.  As a lawprof, it doesn’t matter as much to him since he won’t find himself in the trenches dealing with some cop and driver like this someday.  But I have, and very likely will again, and so will many of the other criminal defense lawyers who inhabit the practical blawgosphere. 

In addition, the many readers of Volokh, which is one of the most popular and widely read blawgs around, are part of the legal dialogue that influences what happens in our real-life practices.  While it would be easy to just blow the readers off as being inconsequential, it wouldn’t be true or helpful. 

We are all part of the “system” and discussions like these which may have some impact on how people in the system think and view the world can make a difference.  We expose others to different points of view than their own, and maybe get them to crack a little on their belief that cops can do no wrong, or that blind obedience to police is a moral imperative.  Plus, we have some fun in the process.   Welcome to the practical blawgosphere.

New Opportunities Breed New Challenges

The  New York Times editorial today praises the Supreme Court’s decisions in Gall and Kimbrough for having “struck a blow for basic fairness and judicial independence.”  Indeed, there is no doubt in my mind that it was the Court’s intention to end the Circuits’ gamesmanship in circumventing the “advisory guidelines” of Booker.

But will things turn out as well as the optimistic Times editorial board thinks?  That has yet to be seen.  History teaches us that the law, and the courts that apply it, is very hard to turn around.  It wasn’t long ago that we were celebrating Booker and Fan Fan as the end of the tyranny of the Guidelines and return to sanity.  It certainly didn’t live up to expectations.

We soon learned that new rules replace old rules.  We learned that the word “advisory” would be permanently placed before the word “guidelines”, but that a guidelines sentence was inherently reasonable and a downward departure would continue to be as unreasonable as it ever was.  It became a sad joke that we would rename the dreaded guidelines while courts would continue adhering to them for dear life. 

The editorial states:


Building on a 2005 decision that held the sentencing guidelines to be advisory rather than mandatory, the new rulings affirm that the guidelines are but one factor to be considered by a trial judge in arriving at an individual sentence, and that an appeals court must have a strong reason to overturn that sentence.

Of course, had things not gone awry after Booker, there would have been no reason to affirm that advisory meant advisory.  Are these decisions clear enough that the District Court judges will be emboldened to test their newly returned power to sentence appropriately.  Are they clear enough that Circuit Court’s won’t construct new tests by which District Court’s sentences can be reversed?  What will it take for the federal courts to reject their slavish adherence to the guidelines?

Unfortunately, part of the answer can be found in the final paragraph of the editorial:


There is a danger that the new procedures outlined by the court could end up making federal sentences unfairly disparate across the country, undermining one of the important objectives of having sentencing guidelines in the first place. If that happens, Congress will have to address the problem. For the moment, the Supreme Court’s latest adjustment in sentencing strikes us as a positive development, one with much potential for advancing justice.

This is the fear.  And apparently, even the New York Times believes that the need for uniformity is greater than the need for judicial independence and case-specific sentencing.  There is only one way nationwide uniformity can be achieved, and we all know how wonderful that experiment turned out.

But is lack of uniformity, a “danger” as described by the Times, really something so terrible?  I think not.  As we know, every case is different and unique in some way.  That defendants are sentenced differently should not be feared, but assume (in the absence of particularized evidence to the contrary) to reflect the unique nature of each case.  This is a good thing, demonstrating that courts are sentencing with such a degree of specificity that each case deserves. 

The lack of uniformity will, it Gall and Kimbrough have their desired affect, soon be back.  And the proponents of sentencing grids will decry how a guy with 2 kilos of heroin in New York can get 121 months when the same fellow in Houston gets 157 months.  They will propose turning judges back into grocery clerks who will give the same sentence to every defendant, no matter what the circumstance, for the same crime.  And then the circle starts again.

I wonder what the Times editorial will say when that happens.

Reasonable Is as Reasonable Does

It seems that   this critique of Orin Kerr’s explanation of the reasonableness of his “cop’s perspective” post has generated a lot of comment over at Volokh.   Orin’s eply parsed my critique to focus on the “bulge” aspect, omitting the rest of the reasoning.  I wish he had included the rest of my argument, but I guess he focused on the part that mattered.  Although, Orin could have done the cut and paste a little more artfully.

Orin has now updated his reply as follows:


UPDATE: The commenters to the thread who are firearms owners or otherwise very familiar with firearms appear to agree that Greenfield is incorrect, and that there are several popular types of handguns that would fit in the driver’s pocket without causing a visible bulge. If that’s right, I suppose it shows the dangers of characterizing disagreement as a contest between “reality” and an ivory-tower “fantasy world”; that kind of overblown rhetoric is fun to write, but it seems a bit silly if the ivory tower ends up being right.

Now this is a little disingenuous, but let’s play with it for a moment.  Of course there are some guns that are small, but this wasn’t about whether there was a tiny gun out there somewhere that could be invisible.  It was about what indicators a cop looks for when he reasonably believes that there may be a weapon involved.  My point was that hands in the pocket aren’t the key, and that cops look for the bulge. 

So let’s cut to the comments, since they are relied upon heavily:


Occasionally, when I teach carry classes, I carry more than one gun on me, just to demonstrate how easy concealment is. It can takes a bit of time to set up, and the more guns I wear, the longer it is, so when I do it, I normally do it as part of dressing before I leave home.

This one time, I had seven guns on me in various places, ranging from a little KelTec to my .44 Magnum snubby , and found that I’d left the house a little early; I stopped off for a cup of coffee at a local coffee shop. I ended up chatting with a local cop — not anybody I knew, and while I know a lot of the locals, nobody I know was there — and we ended up chatting about the carry law, which had just changed in Minnesota from “may issue” to “shall issue.”

“I’m not worried about it,” the cop said. “We’re trained to spot guns.”

“Really.”

“Sure.” He pointed at my range bag, which I’d made a point to keep near me. “If you had your gun on you instead of in there, I’d know.” 

And that, in my experience, is what constitutes reasonable to a cop.  Police are trained to look for certain indicators.  Yes, it isn’t foolproof, but it’s what a cop believes to be reasonable.

Let’s go to another comment:


The telling point for me in this episode is that after the officer had tased the victim and was handcuffing him while the victim was on the ground, and the victim was painfully complaining and questioning why the officer had tased him, the officer in responding never said that the victim shouldn’t have reached in his pocket because that raised the fear in the officer’s mind that he might be going for a gun. (And why didn’t the officer simply order the guy to take his hand out of his pocket before firing away?) Instead, the officer said in so many words, repeatedly, that the victim should have obeyed him. It was all about asserting the officer’s authority. The claim that the officer feared that the victim was going for a gun stinks of a made up after-the-fact excuse for inexcusable conduct.

And so it appears that not only was there no objective reason to believe the driver was armed, but there was no subject belief either.  This is significant in that the idea that the officer “might” have tasered the driver because he feared he was about to pull a gun out of his pocket was rank speculation.  But this discussion is theoretical, so we address the speculative as if it were true.

Most of the comment that Orin relies upon miss the point.  It is not reasonable for a police officer to assume that a person is armed based upon the absence of any indication that he has a weapon.  That there may be guns small enough to be hidden does not convert the tasering of an apparently unarmed person into a reasonable use of force. 

By that logic, it would be reasonable for a police officer to taser, or shoot to kill if he only had a gun, every citizen who put his hands in his pockets, or in his jacket, or anywhere that someone could argue a weapon could be hidden, despite the absence of instructions to the contrary and the absence of any indication that the person is armed.  The bulge was just the indicator that cops are trained to look for.  There could be other indicators that would serve the same purpose.  But the absence of any indicator at all is not sufficient evidence of a concealed weapon to taser someone, from my practical perspective.  Do I misunderstand the argument?

Sure, it would be a very protective rule for police officers.  But there would a lot of dead citizens on the ground.  And this is the message that many Volokh fans want to send.  One reader posted this question:


I have a sincere question to those who think the officer could have reasonably believed the driver was reaching for a weapon: Doesn’t that mean that if the officer didn’t have a taser, it would have been reasonable for him to shoot the driver dead?

Another answered:


 — I know that if that had happened, I would have shown the video to my three 11-year-old sons so that they would learn a very valuable lesson about the importance of being civil and not disrespecting authority.

This statement is disturbing on a number of levels.  But is it to protect his kids from vicious officers, or to teach his children to be supplicants?  After all, the importance of being civil and not disrespecting authority is the most important thing a child can learn, right?

I could be wrong (and no doubt many Volokh fans will readily say “yes”), but is this really the message you want to send, obey the cops or die?  I sincerely hope not.