Author Archives: SHG

Are You Listening? They ARE Spying on US (Update)

Every time the government claims that the only reason they need the FISA Court, then the USA Patriot Act, then liability protection for Telecoms, is to protect us from terrorism, it makes me cringe.  I know a slippery slope when I see one.  Worse yet, when the pickings are too easy, the government can’t control itself from taking advantage.

And so,  the story in the New York Times comes as no surprise.  But it is a huge story.  It is the story of how the government has reached the bottom of that slippery slope and, as predicted, has found itself incapable of exercising its professed self-control to limit its flagrantly illegal and unconstitutional conduct to terrorists, the external threat whose very mention strikes fear in the heart of people who need no constitutional protections.


Remember those quaint days when government needed to get warrants for wiretaps and pen registers?  Ah, the litigation we used to enjoy over those creatures of statute.  But no need no more.  The electronic and technology revolutions, coupled with the joy of fighting terrorism, has left the government with a mere flip of the switch to convert its terrorism-fighting apparatus into your basic crime-fighting apparatus.  No muss.  No fuss.  No warrants.


To detect narcotics trafficking, for example, the government has been collecting the phone records of thousands of Americans and others inside the United States who call people in Latin America, according to several government officials who spoke on the condition of anonymity because the program remains classified. But in 2004, one major phone carrier balked at turning over its customers’ records. Worried about possible privacy violations or public relations problems, company executives declined to help the operation, which has not been previously disclosed.

We long ago expressed our concerns and fears that the war on terrorism would encompass the war on drugs (and every other war, except the one on poverty).  Never, swore the government.  We would only apply these critically necessary ways to circumvent the Constitution to fighting terrorism.  Trust us.

And trust them we did.  As a nation, we trusted and supported the enactment of a law so horribly disastrous to the fabric of our constitutional democracy that it led the laws of this nation down the slippery slope to perdition.  This law, with all-time best marketing acronym ever, the USA Patriot Act (which stands for “Unoting and Strengthening America by Providing Appropriate Tools Required to Intercept and Obstruct Terrorism Act of 2001 (Public Law 107-56), was enacted without debate 45 days after September 11, 2001.  No one in Congress had actually read through the law, but its stated purpose was to fight terrorism.  And nobody, after 9/11, was coming out against fighting terrorism. 

While a handful of crazies decried the way the law impaired civil rights and constitutional protections, the majority hailed it as a way to fight “domestic terrorism.”  Their government promised that they would never, NEVER, use the law for an improper purpose.  And a complacent, compliant, afraid population believed. 

Well, the New York Times has quietly informed us that we have, and have had for a number of years, a full-blown domestic spying operation going on, that is busy spying on anything that could benefit from being a little spied on.  That may be you, or your friend, or you teacher.  Or maybe not, but you won’t know, because there will be no warrants, no oversight, no approvals.  They are openly conceding that they are, and have been, doing exactly what they swore they weren’t going to do.

I’m sure that some pro-government scholar will be happy to explain the nexus between drug dealing and funding terrorism, such that they can justify reaching beyond the practical boundaries of Terrorism to address the rampant garden variety crime that is used to fund it.  These are the types of arguments and positions that really cause a great swell of pride in me, that we have been able to educate American’s to the point where they can fabricate a rationale that will allow the government to do anything it wants to any person at any time without constraint. 

What does not shock me is that it’s happening.  I always thought it would.  In fact, I was certain that the government couldn’t control itself the second the door was open to secret domestic spying.  What does shock me as how casually it appears in the New York Times.  And how this isn’t the lead story in every newscast across the nation. 


“We See You When You’re Sleeping”
“We Know If You’ve Been Bad or Good”
“We Know When Your Housekeeper Called Chile”


It’s such a seasonal story too.  But is the government’s biggest concern that this story leaked out and they are about to make it into a major motion picture?  Nope.  It’s that  they desperately want Telecom immunity so they can get and keep the phone companies complicit.

“The intelligence community cannot go it alone,” Mike McConnell, the director of national intelligence, wrote in a New York Times Op-Ed article Monday urging Congress to pass the immunity provision. “Those in the private sector who stand by us in times of national security emergencies deserve thanks, not lawsuits.”

What else can we do to support our government.  We exist to serve it.

Update:  Lest we demonstrate concern that our beloved United States Government is using its anti-terrorism excuse to ignore the Constitution and use it to gather general crime information domestically,  Overlawyered has concocted this to be a scheme by trial lawyers to line their pockets instead of protecting our constitutional rights from the government using telecoms as unlawful enablers.  Must some good stuff they’re smoking over at the American Enterprise Institute holiday party.

Nominations Open For Criminal Defense Lawyer of the Year 2007

Just a reminder that we are soliciting nominations for Criminal Defense Lawyer of the Year 2007.  Remember, this is not about the biggest, most important newsmaker or Big Name lawyer, but about regular lawyers who toil in the trenches day in and day out, without the recognition their efforts deserve.

While a few terrific nominations have already come in, I’ve got to believe that there are more of you out there who have a criminal defense lawyer whose efforts are worthy of note.  I would expect that every reader here has colleague or lawyer who inspired them, served them, represented them, helped them or just stood up to injustice or impropriety, not to make headlines but because it was the right thing to do.  This is your chance to recognize them, and by doing so, recognize the work of criminal defense lawyers on behalf of the accused.

Make your  nominations here and let everyone know about a deserving criminal defense lawyer.

Judges Afraid, Congress Annoyed

With perhaps the biggest week in sentencing decisions since 1987 just behind us, it was time for someone to tell us why this was a bad thing for defendants.  That’s why we have the New York Times.   Liptak’s column presents some interesting interviews and claims that provide a different perspective on what we (mistakenly?) thought was good thing. No, a great thing.

No, Adam doesn’t argue that crack-crazed convicts will be let out en masse to wreak crime and havoc on the street.  Quite the opposite.  He calls federal sentencing “draconian”, a word that finds its way into almost every defense lawyer’s explanation of the guidelines.

But he also calls the effect of the Supreme Court’s decisions “tinkering”.  To explain, he quotes former federal judge, not Utah Law School professor, Paul Cassell:


“The mandatory minimums are so draconian,” he said. “I’m a believer in a good guidelines system. And I would much rather trade a much tougher guidelines system and get rid of mandatory minimums.”

Say what?  He wants to trade off tougher guidelines for mandatory minimums?  I didn’t know that we were horse-trading between bad and worse, and that we had to give up any hope on fair, proportional, individualized sentencing in order to accomplish any change at all. 

According to Liptak, sentencing is just too hard for federal judges without guidelines.  Too personally painful.  By the use of guidelines, it removes the rending of their sympathetic hearts and allows them to perform this difficult task.

For context, Liptak turned to new Chief Judge of the Ninth Circuit, Alex Kozinski.  You may remember this photo of him partying with Libertarian Gene Volokh at the Federalist Society bacchanalia.  I’m not entirely sure, but I believe that his hand is raised in a gang greeting, or he’s trying to get people to call in and vote for him for American idol.



So how does Judge Kozinski feel about sentencing?


“Somehow I felt it was wrong for one human being to have that much power over another,” Judge Alex Kozinski, now the chief judge of the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, in San Francisco, wrote of the days before the guidelines were in force and judges had vast discretion. Writing in The Federal Sentencing Reporter in 1999, he said the experience was so traumatic as to feel like “almost an act of sacrilege.”

Well, it’s no walk in the park for defendants either, you know.  But the judge appears to be responding well, despite his trauma.  But how did he feel about the guidelines?


The guidelines were a sort of relief, Judge Kozinski said. They established relatively narrow ranges and “presumably take into account all those factors I don’t feel competent to weigh: punishment, deterrence, rehabilitation, harm to society, contrition — they’re all engineered into the machine; all I have to do is wind the key.”

So the qualification for the federal bench in San Francisco is key winding?  I would feel much better if the Chief Judge felt competent to apply 3553(a) to sentencing.  It just seems so . . . crucial. [Note to Adam Liptak: Didn’t it strike you as disturbing that the Chief Judge of the 9th Circuit doesn’t feel competent to fulfill a fundamental duty of his position?]

With all these changes being thrust upon them, how are things sitting with Congress?  Not well, according to Liptak.


There are several bills kicking around Congress meant to harmonize cocaine sentencing laws. But, perhaps perversely, the Supreme Court’s decisions last Monday may make Congressional action less likely. Letting judges have too much discretion does not sit well with some legislators, and that discretion can be controlled through mandatory minimums.

Aha!  Many of us wondered why that paragon of judicial activism, Antonin Scalia, joined hands with the left wing of the court to sing Kumbaya.  it’s now becoming clear.  This was a conspiracy to preserve mandatory minimums, which Congress was on the secret verge of obliterating in a fit of propriety, as so often happens in an election year.

Now, Congress is miffed that the Supreme Court beat them to it, showing up their soft-on-crime credentials.  Does this mean that Congress will shelve its secret plans to do away with mandatory minimums in a fit of pique at the Supreme Court.  Not necessarily.


It is hardly clear, moreover, that judges are itching to employ their new discretion even in the context of the guidelines. Many judges say that sentencing is the hardest part of the job. It wears on the soul.

There’s still hope.  All we need is a vast majority of the federal bench refusing to exercise sound discretion in sentencing following this latest round of Supreme Court decisions, thus saving wear and tear on their souls, and leaving the good work to Congress.  But don’t hold your breath.

Is Plea Bargaining Just Another Form of ADR?

Over at PrawfsBlawg, Marquette lawprof Michael O’Hear has come up with yet another paradigm shift in criminal law.  He poses the question of whether plea bargaining is just another form of dispute resolution.


Is it useful to think about plea bargaining as a form of alternative dispute resolution, in the same vein as the mediation or arbitration of civil disputes, or do the particular moral or procedural imperatives of criminal justice mean that analogies to private dispute resolution are unhelpful or misleading?

To test the waters, O’Hear partnered up with an ADR prof, Andrea Schneider, to put on interdisciplinary conferences to explore the subject.  Three panels were held on the following topics”



  • Bargaining in the Shadow of the Law—The Relationship Between the Structure of the Criminal Law and Negotiated Outcomes;

  • Effects of Cognitive Biases on Plea Negotiation;

  • Victims, Apology, and Restorative Justice in Criminal Procedure.

Yes, the same sort of panel topics that lawyers in the trenches think about every day.  In fact, a prosecutor, a PD and I were chatting about these exact subjects over a beer just the other day, until we were interrupted by a judge inquiring whether he left his robe on the bar stool.

Given the nature and make-up of the interdisciplinary panels, it should come as no shock to learn that the outcome was that plea bargaining is indeed merely another form of dispute resolution, and that it was “helpful and appropriate” to view plea bargaining in that way.

The conferences naturally resulted in a papers that will appear in Marquette Law Review.  While the complete article is not yet available, the abstract can be found here.  It states:


Although the study of plea bargaining would seem, by its nature, to invite interdisciplinary collaboration between criminal law and dispute resolution scholars, there has been remarkably little cross-fertilization between the fields. In this Essay, we discuss the suitability of conceptualizing plea bargaining as a form of dispute resolution and describe some of the useful things that criminal law scholars might learn from dispute resolution scholars, and vice versa.

While I’m hesitant to prejudge a scholarly work, two things pop out at me immediately.  First, the fact that this began as an interdisciplinary effort suggests that it was a self-fulfilling prophecy.  After all, what were they going to talk about with all those ADR profs if they decided on day 1 that plea bargaining had nothing to do with dispute resolution?

Second, the law review article is expressly directed toward “criminal law and dispute resolution scholars.”  Is there anybody missing from that list.  Oh, say, prosecutors, defense lawyers, judges and defendants?  All the people who are actually involved in the dynamic? 

We know that lawprof O’Hear is a big fan of plea bargaining, not to mention fond of kinder, gentler prosecutors.  Remember, this is the lawprof who wrote the following:


“The trick is to find ways of injecting the values of voice, neutrality, and respect into the plea bargaining process without robbing plea bargaining of its efficiency advantages over the trial process.”

So it should come as no surprise that he has a strong interest in making plea bargaining appear more benign, societally-friendly, than the brutish but necessary beast we know it to be.  I see the panel about victims, but where’s the one about innocent defendants?  Perhaps the good professor has yet to meet any of them?

Plea bargaining is an ugly business.  It’s hardly arms length, because the parties involved rarely, if ever, have equal bargaining power.  In concept ADR is a relatively cooperative effort to resolve disputes.  Ask any defendant if he would rather be engaged in plea bargaining or just go home and call the whole thing off.  It’s a coercive approach, offering the defendant the lesser of two evils.  Either role the dice and possibly go to prison for life, whether your innocent or guilty, or take the 20 year offer and cut your losses, again whether your innocent or guilty.

In a bizarre sense, the idea that plea bargaining reflects some sort of “settlement” is true, but there is no similarity between the dynamics of plea bargaining and any other form of dispute resolution that I can think of.  I have a hard time imagining that they won’t come up with some ridiculous model that would make sense only to someone hellbent on creating one, who doesn’t have to look a client in the eyes and explain why, even though they are innocent, they have to leave their children for the next 20 years.  But I wouldn’t want to prejudge their scholarly work, would I? 

Picking Nits on Sunday

I was originally going to title this post “The Attack of the Killer Mice,” but was afraid of stirring up mouse lovers everywhere.  Mind you, I am not one of them.  I don’t know if any mouse lovers even read blawgs on Sundays.  It seems that the rest of the blawgosphere is out drinking lattes, because I feel like the only guy posting anything over the weekend.  Hello, anybody home?  But since I blawg for fun, who cares, right?

In the recent past, a post of mine was subject to careful scrutiny.  One aspect, which provided tangential support to my position, was wrong as written.  I could have, and probably should have, made it clearer and far more precise, but blawging requires a certain degree of brevity (something with which I have occasional problems, as Gideon often notes), and I cut to the chase.  This left me open to some nit-picking, and my nits were indeed picked.

But something else happened that disturbed me about it.  My initial visceral reaction was to reach through the computer screen and grab someone by the scruff of their neck.  I decided not to do this, because it’s a highly ineffective way to convince someone of the error of their ways and it’s really bad for the computer screen.  Instead, I chose to ignore it.  At least for the moment.

When points get lifted from a post, repeated without context, words changed and rearranged, and then passed along to tertiary readers, there’s always a chance that something gets lost in translation.  That happened to me.  But the upshot was the end-reader, lacking the clarity of thought or comprehension to recognize that they had moved the goal post, were using somebody else’s ball and still have no clue what they were talking about, concluded that I was a blithering idiot, utterly lacking in credibility and dressed funny.

They were, in large measure, way off base.  Granted, I sometimes wear mismatching clothing around the house, but that’s really nobody’s business but my own. 

As to the rest of it, I can only suggest that they go back to the source, try to grasp the fundamental point and recognize that this isn’t a law review article, with citations and footnotes for every point.  Yes, we support our positions with some short hand that will not bear up, as written, under intense scrutiny.  So sue me.  If I went on at length on every supporting detail raised, my posts would be ten times as long as even more boring.  Is that what you want?

My son loves to remind me that stupidity is not a handicap.  He uses the phrase to explain why non-disabled people don’t get to park in handicap parking spots just because their easier, they’ll “only be a minute” or available when there are no other spots within 12 feet of the door.  I wonder where he learned that?  He can say this because we don’t park in handicap parking spots.  It’s more difficult to read someone calling me an incredible moron when they are basing in on a total misapprehension of third-hand, butchered information.  But we can’t expect everyone to be a careful reader or have basic clarity of thought.

But I urge readers to be cautious in their jumping to unwarranted conclusions, particularly in attacking people, when they have failed to do their own due diligence and demonstrated a sufficient knowledge to justify their knee-jerk conclusions.  Some people are just too darn critical.  They should be more tolerant and understanding.  Like me. 

What’s a Comma Between Friends? (Updated)

The second amendment is hot.  It’s been hot for a long time, but it’s really hot now, with the Supreme Court  agreeing to hear District of Columbia . Heller, after Judge Laurence H. Silberman  struck down the D.C. gun law, holding that the right to bear arms is individual, not collective.

There has been a ton written about this, and it is certainly an issue that raises the cackles of people on either side of the fence.  But one of the funniest, and most enlightening, perspectives comes from an  op-ed piece in the New York Times by Adam Freedman, who writes the Legal Lingo column for the New York Law Journal magazine.

Since the right to bear arms is not holding on by a comma, Freedman points out a few grammatical issues that few of us would know about, or care to know about.


In the 18th century, punctuation marks were as common as medicinal leeches and just about as scientific. Commas and other marks evolved from a variety of symbols meant to denote pauses in speaking. For centuries, punctuation was as chaotic as individual speech patterns.

The situation was even worse in the law, where a long English tradition held that punctuation marks were not actually part of statutes (and, therefore, courts could not consider punctuation when interpreting them). Not surprisingly, lawmakers took a devil-may-care approach to punctuation. Often, the whole business of punctuation was left to the discretion of scriveners, who liked to show their chops by inserting as many varied marks as possible.

Proof that in the end, secretaries run the world.  But what of a world where copy machines had yet to exist?

Another problem with trying to find meaning in the Second Amendment’s commas is that nobody is certain how many commas it is supposed to have. The version that ended up in the National Archives has three, but that may be a fluke. Legal historians note that some states ratified a two-comma version. At least one recent law journal article refers to a four-comma version.

Can you see a plurality developing on the Supreme Court based on the number of commas in the versions that the states actually ratified?  You’ve got to admit, that would be a hoot, with Scalia lambasting Ginsburg because of her lack of “comma sense.” 

So Freedman offers a solution to the potential comma wars that will rock the very foundation of our legal system:


The best way to make sense of the Second Amendment is to take away all the commas (which, I know, means that only outlaws will have commas).

Read the whole piece.  It’s very funny, very informative and will give you a reason to enjoy the Supreme Court’s decision, no matter what it will be.

Update:  Gene Volokh  rips the humor from this piece by arguing that Feedman employs a non sequitur in his piece.  Way to suck the fun out of everything, Eugene.  If you’re going to roam the Times looking for every picky little   non sequitur, then why don’t we all just put on sour pusses and eat prunes.

When The Lone Holdout is a Racist

Jury was out 2 days on a simple buy and bust, where the cops’ testimony was all over the place.  Finally a verdict:  Not Guilty.  But afterward, some jurors want to talk to the defense lawyer.  He’s told that the foreperson started deliberations with the statement, “He’s black, so he must be guilty.”

Granted, the end result was that the lone holdout, the foreperson, finally gave up her racist view.  Granted, the right verdict was reached.  Sure, the defendant sat in jail for more than a year awaiting trial, since he couldn’t make bail.  His kids lost a father.  His wife lost a husband.  But those are the normal consequences of getting mixed up in our “almost perfect” criminal justice system.

But what to do about the closet racist?  This was the question posed by the criminal defense lawyer who tried this case.  Despite his victory, he was sickened when he learned that this was the reason he sat there waiting for a verdict for 2 days.  So much risk.  Even winning, the penalty to the defendant was unacceptably harsh.  But then, despite his best efforts, a racist found here way into the first seat. 

There were many reactions to the question posed from lawyers and jury consultants who both commiserated and suggested that through the use of a series of voir dire questions, he would have significantly increased his chances of ascertaining the juror’s racist views.  This should come as no surprise to anyone who follows such matters, as we know that there is plenty of effort put into the science of determining how to get a fair jury.  Some people (including me) have questioned the validity of this science, but there’s no reason to open old wounds for this post because there was another sabot tossed into the gears of jury selection.

The question was posed:  So how do you manage to ask 5 questions of each of the 16 jurors in the box to determine if they’re racist (putting aside that you also have a few questions on other subjects, such as do they love cops and hate defendants), when you have a total of 20 minutes to question the panel?

Screeching halt.  Hold on a sec.  We forgot all about that.  We don’t always get hours and days to question individual jurors in garden variety cases.  Sure, the high profile murder cases let you pick a jury forever, but a buy and bust case is a 2 day trial, and you’ve got half a day to pick the jury. 

In a typical New York state court felony trial, the judge will tell you how much leeway you have to do voir dire.  Sure, you can argue for more time, and push the envelope while your standing before the panel, but eventually patience runs thin and the judge wants to get a jury selected and move on to trial.  After all trials are about witnesses and evidence, not just picking the jury.  Push the envelope too far and the judge will say something to cut you off at the knees.  Believe me, it isn’t pretty when that happens.

While there have been a ton of exceptionally good and interesting posts about conducting effective voir dire, most notably from Anne Reed at Deliberations, the utility of these recommendations in the typical trial is really in question.  We just don’t get a month to pick a jury for a 2 day trial.  No judge is going to let that happen. 

It’s perfectly understandable that people whose primary focus is jury selection discuss voir dire as if it can go on forever, delve into every area that could possibly matter, and take forever if necessary.  But this isn’t the reality that a trial lawyer faces.  Many times, we’re lucky to be able to get 2 or 3 questions out of each person in the box before time constraints force us to move on.  We often ask blanket questions of the entire panel because we know we’ll never have the time to do it individually.  And we know that we will never get a legit answer when we ask a blanket question, because people just don’t tend to respond to questions when they aren’t put to them directly.

If the answer isn’t going to be “get the judge to give you more time,” because that just isn’t going to happen, then what?  Do we end up with a closet racist in the box, despite our best efforts not to, or is there another answer?  How do we unearth something as insidious as a juror who believes that any black person on trial is guilty, given the practical constraints on jury selection?  It was a very good point, and I would very much appreciate an answer that deals with the problem under real life conditions.  Anybody?

ABA: 2007 The Year of the Blawger

Interspersed with actual information, occasional news and perhaps even a rant, comes something reflective and self-serving this time of year.  The  ABA Journal has changed it’s “Lawyer of the Year” theme to “Newsmakers of the Year,” thus making everybody a little more comfortable with highlighting Alberto Gonzalez and Mike Nifong, not to mention some of the other usual suspects.

But if you stopped reading too early (like I did, until I learned about it from Kevin), you would miss a little noticed piece that included an unusual mention in their round-up:  The Lawyer-Blogger. 

These days anybody with a penchant for the word can get on the Web and grouse. And we’ve re­served a spot here for those who do just that because 2007 was the year lawyer-bloggers—some call them blawgers—came into their own.

Sure, law blog superstars like David Lat and Tom Goldstein have been churning out content for a while now, but the last year saw a plethora of law blogs begin to insert themselves into the most significant daily news and legal issues debates alongside their counterparts in journalism and academe.

From the Duke lacrosse team fiasco in North Carolina to the high-profile “Family Secrets” Mob trial in Chi­­cago, bloggers made their presence known with a flourish, sometimes to the chagrin of the judges and lawyers involved. But the influence of the lawyer-blogger goes beyond that.

Whether by a single practitioner who wants to share his or her problems and experiences opening an office, or a BigLaw associate who wants to dish the dirt about the practice, the lawyer-bloggers are finding an audience for their work, and we salute them.

I guess I’m in there somewhere, falling below the superstars and closer to the single practitioner with a penchant to “grouse”.  It begs the question, is all this blogging going anywhere?

With the recent  Q&A for Lexblog, some thoughts have been floating around about whether blawging will have any lasting contribution, or just be an avenue for intellectual masturbation.  Sure, we have some great discussions, and even better debates (not perfect, but better than we would have without blawging). 

But it’s unclear whether blawging (I don’t think Kevin likes this word, and prefers “lawyer blogging”) is a fad or an influence, and if the latter, if it influences only the blawgosphere, lawyers or the real world.  It seems way too presumptuous and pretentious to believe that blawging has much clout as yet.  But will it someday?

The mainstream media isn’t too worried that we will steal their thunder.   Bill Keller from the New York Times says we’re a fly on their very large but callipygian buttocks.  But given the frequent lack of understanding of what they are covering, and their inability to ramp up their knowledge-base quickly enough to produce news coverage that accurately reflects its significance, we have something that old line media like the Times can’t provide.  We understand what news means relative to its context.  They rarely do, and are usually wrong. 

You would think that mainstream media would recognize the utility of blawgs to supplement their understanding of what they are reporting, but they don’t, for the most part.  My guess is that to do so would be a tacit admission that their buttocks is neither as big, nor as callipygian, as they think.  They would hate to admit that we know something that they don’t.  But we do.  Often.  And we share it for free.

It sometimes seems that we are having a conversation amongst ourselves.  Sure, others come and read our posts, as we know from the site statistics and “metrics” that blawging programs provide, but how often, why and to what end is unclear.  It could be nothing more than a way to kill an hour, or a way to find an answer to a nagging question.  Some blawgs offer far more of substance than others.  Some, like that wag Lat, offer the legal version of the Tattler, including photos, which tells you where its readers’ heads are at.

It’s really not up to the blawgers to say where any of this goes.  It’s up to the readers.  Is 2007 the Year of the Blawger (sorry Kevin, but I like the word)?  The ABA Journal says so.  But then again, the Pet Rock had its year as well. 

If reading a lawyer blog has contributed to your work, your understanding, or even just entertained you enough to come back for more, let the blawger know by leaving a comment.  While every post may not be a stroke of brilliance, and some may be downright useless, many really do add something to the broader conversation.  And it’s something you’re not going to find anywhere else other than the blawgosphere.  I bet Kevin hates that word too.  Tough.

Really Big and Butt Ugly (Updated)

Driving past a new house yesterday drove home point.  The new house, built with a spectacular view of a corner gas station, was at least 6,000 square feet.  It was a monster, the appeared to max out the buildable area on the lot.  It had the requisite double-height, palladian-windowed front entrance that has symbolized for the past decade that the resident has spent a great deal of money.  It was a monument to bad taste.

I concede that taste is personal, and don’t think that I am the final arbiter of good taste (though my taste is meticulous, as far as I’m concerned).  But we aren’t talking about housing styles that fall with a normal ambit; No, no.  This is about the faux Château, modeled after some nightmarish misconception of what Louis would have built if his snuff brought a 10 year mandatory minimum.  With faux stone, and faux cornices, and faux flying buttresses, and a little faux Emperor standing in the middle, admiring how important he must be.

There is a road in a neighboring Village that was one of the most charming around, filled with large, old colonials and farmhouses, each somehow unique in its presentation.  These homes were surrounded by mature trees and natural fauna that made one feel a rural attitude that is so rare to find this close to New York City.  Then, some wily developer got his hands on two homes on the road.

The developer tore down that charming farmhouses, stripped the land of growth and opened gaping wounds on the landscape.  But it appeared, at first, that he was building some extremely large shingle-style houses.  Large has its issues, as does the destruction of mature trees, but at least the house style wouldn’t conflict with, and scar, the other homes along this road.

Then one day, the shoe fell.  The front of these apparently shingle colonials grew faux stone.  It was reminiscent of a roadside diner of modern vintage.  A very large roadside diner.  The neighbors, many of whom I know, were aghast.  I was aghast.  More than that, I was deeply saddened by the loss of the roads character.  These new homes would be the most obvious on the road, because they were designed for “curb appeal” whereas most other roads could barely be seen from the road, with only the impression visible and the detail obscured. 

And what’s wrong with this?  The developer will (he hopes) soon sell these diner-like structures to some family that has far more money than taste, and walk away.  The neighbors will remain behind, to see the developer’s handiwork on a daily basis.  They must live with his choices.  It’s not unlike the old builders who would deliberately offend a neighborhood’s sensibilities to drive the old timers out and profit from their misery. 

The problem struck me as I read the Sunday Times real estate section story about “Teardown Country” (link to be provided when they post the story tomorrow now added).  It’s another Times story that disturbs me because they ask realtors and developers to express their views on the merits of smaller homes and the destruction of historic structures.  Shockingly, both state that the opposition to their teardowns is overblown, and that their McMansions are the cat’s meow.  Another example of careful reporting.

Homebuilding trendiness has become an artform, where developers have figured out precisely what sells to whom.  These structures are intentionally designed to appeal to people who have just come into substantial sums of money, but lack the sensibility to appreciate the beauty of form and design.  They want to show off how wealthy and successful they’ve become, and they damn well want a house that rams their importance down everyone’s throat.  To this end, they demand really big and butt ugly houses.  These are the houses that “rich people” live in, for those who have no clue about rich people.

And in the process, we lose the bucolic atmosphere and history that enriches our lives and the lives of our children.  All so somebody can show off.  But can I blame the developers for doing whatever they can to make a buck off these patsies?  Rationally, no, for that’s their job, even if it requires the sacrifice of things bigger than a quick buck. 

When the housing market decided to implode, it was my hope that it would put an end to this blight. Or at least slow it down.  To some extent, it has, with the smarter builders holding off to see where the market was heading.  Unfortunately, this leaves some of the dopier builders, or the less astute, still hard at work.  Building their super-sized diners where once charming neighborhoods once existed.  And the realtors think this is just fine.

Update:  A comment from a friend who know about this stuff:  “Do you ever notice that the builders who build these monsters never try to explain why they build what they build.  It’s not that builders have any taste, but they know very well, before sinking their investment into a property, that it’s much easier to sell obvious pretentiousness than to subtlety and good taste.  While good taste varies from person to person, ugly has universal amongst tasteless, tacky people.”  Like I said, he knows from whence he speaks.

Subpoena Quashed For Encryption Password

Via Volokh, Vermont Magistrate Judge Jerome Niedermeier (no relation to Douglas) has issued the first ruling to quash the government’s subpoena for a defendant to disclose (or just input) his password to give access to encrypted computer files in In re Boucher.

The facts of the case are a little quirky, making it risky that the decision will be approved by the District Court Judge.  The defendant was entering from Canada when, during a border search, agents suspected he had kiddie porn on his computer.  How they could have suspected this is unknown, so we have to put that aside.  The agent booted up the computer and searched file names, finding “40,000 images, some of which appeared to be pornographic based on the names of the files.”

Aside:  Let’s understand that we have this thing called the internet, which allows computer users across the United States to access the lowest, most disgusting garbage possible from anywhere in the world.  But we use our border agents to make sure that no one can enter the country with a computer that contains porn, lest they threaten the moral fiber of America?  Okay.  Got it.

So the agent tries to access the files, with names like “2yo getting raped during diaper change,” but he can’t open the image.  This, apparently, is what the defendant, Boucher, thinks is a cool name for a file.  But the agent places the defendant in custody, Mirandizes him, and Boucher agrees to open the files for the agent. 

Aside:  Is it possible that this is a Darwinian imperative that Boucher fulfill his sexual needs by computer, thus presenting the possibility that he not further pollute the human gene pool by procreating?  Note that while the legal issue involved is important, Boucher (and his ilk) do not reflect what I personally consider admirable traits in humanity.  Sorry for these asides, but this is why I don’t generally represent people interested in kiddie porn.  But don’t let me influence you.

Cut to the prosecution, where the government takes a mirror image of the hard drive and tries to access this cornucopia of pornography, only to find that they can’t because it’s password protected.  I know nothing about password protection, but I take it that it’s sufficiently well done (or they are sufficiently incompetent) that they can’t break the code.  So, they do what government’s do best (aside from curious searches):  Subpoena.

The defense moves to quash based on the 5th Amendment privilege, due to the act of production piece of the privilege.  This is the “admission” that he possesses the password, which necessarily goes hand in hand with his either providing it in accordance with the subpoena or (offered as an alternative by the government) accessing it for them without their learning the code. 

The Judge rejected the government’s argument that accessing the files was not testimonial, and hence the privilege didn’t apply.  The comparison is a keyed safe versus a combination safe.  The key is non-testimonial since it doesn’t involve something in the defendant’s mind.  The combo is, and does.  The Judge similarly rejected the “forgone conclusion” doctrine, since there are many files that the agent didn’t observe, even though there are some that he did.  Since the password is “pure testimonial production,” forcing Boucher to disclose it would incriminate him.

This part of the decision, one of first impression, is big and tells us how to address anything on a computer that you don’t want the government to see.  Considering that computer crimes are, by far, the fastest growing area of criminal prosecutions, this ruling provides a key consideration for the privacy of whatever we put on a hard drive, even if it is the product of a demented soul.

The downside of this decision is fact specific, because Boucher, after waiving privilege, opened files for the agent.  This detail undermines the entire act of production privilege, since he already incriminated himself by showing that he has the knowledge to access the files.  A second downside is that it’s a decision of a Magistrate Judge, which has no precedential value.  But decisions have to start somewhere.

The good news is that the Boucher decision provides a framework to protection of personal privacy on personal computers.  Hopefully, the rule will be endorsed and upheld, even if the fact specific problems result in a reversal of the order quashing the subpoena.  That would be a big win for privacy in an age when there’s little of it left.