Author Archives: SHG

Practical Blawgosphere: The Language of Defendants’ Failure

A few days ago, Mark Bennett was awaiting the charge to his jury when he considered the pattern instruction on the defendant’s “failure to testify.”  This started a conversation around the practical blawgosphere, with Jamie Spencer at  Austin Criminal Defense Lawyer and Anne Reed at  Deliberations jumping in [edit] as well as David Tarrell at In the Moment.  Despite my intention of getting into this conversation yesterday, I never made it.  But here I am, the caboose again.

Mark’s point, which really nails the issue, addresses the language to the jury about the defendant’s “failure to testify.”


How is it even conceivable that we should allow a court, when talking to jurors, to describe a defendant’s election not to testify — the exercise of one of the rights that we, as defenders, hold sacred — as a “failure”?

Anne points out that “you’d like to see something in there about why the right is in the Constitution and why we hold it sacred, but of course defense lawyers are free to argue that.”  Indeed we would like to see the judge, rather than us, be the one to explain the significance of the 5th Amendment to the jury, but that’s not how it work. 

Jamie asked what the pattern jury instruction was in other jurisdictions.  In New York, the basic instruction is this:


The fact that the defendant did not testify is not a factor from which any inference unfavorable to the defendant may be drawn.

For a variety of reasons, I despise this instruction.  On the other hand, I’ve never seen an instruction on the defendant not testifying that I didn’t think was destructive and unfair.  I similarly hate language about “inferences” to begin with, since no juror has a clue what its supposed to mean and it just flies past them, making judges feel like they’ve done their job while jurors just shrug it off as more legalese of no consequence.

Now that we’ve covered the nuts and bolts, let’s talk business.  Bennett is absolutely right that it is an outrage that the defendant’s decision not to testify is characterized as a “failure”.  Conceptually, the exercise of a constitutional right should be sacred, and thus never serve as a negative, whether expressly or implicitly.  But of course, it is. 

When it comes to a defendant not testifying, it is always a negative to a jury.  Absent the most peculiar circumstances where it is so clear that the defendant has nothing to add, juries want to hear the defendant say, if nothing else, that they didn’t do it.  More often, they want to hear the defendant’s “side” of the case.

What’s wrong with that?  That shifts the burden from the prosecution to the defense.  The jury then chooses which story they prefer; which story has better support; which is more probably.  Note the word “probable”, because it also implicates the burden of proof, reducing it from beyond a reasonable doubt to preponderance of the evidence.  When juries can pick between two competing versions of the facts, they will pick the one that seems more likely.  This isn’t constitutionally adequate, but that’s the way it happens. 

These concepts are all intertwined, and the all suffer from the same problem.  The criminal justice system has yet to figure out a way to instruct a jury on how to consider the evidence before them.  The “failure to testify” language is a disaster.  The burden of proof charge is incomprehensible.  Juries resort to what they do in real life and just make a decision.

But it is a truism that juries want defendants to take the stand.  The common wisdom (another phrase I hate and another “thing” that doesn’t really exist) is that an innocent defendant has nothing to hide and will want to testify about his innocence.  Of course, this ignores the realities that hide in the background.  There are a number of reasons why defendants shouldn’t and don’t testify.  Some are benign, others not so.

Defendants have prior convictions that will taint them to the jury.  Judges are supposed to only allow in prior convictions if they impact on the defendant’s credibility, and in New York a Sandoval hearing is held before the start of trial.  The purpose is to assure that a defendant is not prevented from testifying (also a constitutional right, I might add) because a prior conviction will be used to suggest that he has a propensity to commit crimes.  This is enormously powerful evidence before a jury, though it has nothing to do with whether the defendant committed the crime for which he is now on trial.

But judges usually allow the prosecution to question the defendant, at least to some extent, on prior convictions that have nothing to do with credibility.  The argument is that by committing a crime, any crime, the defendant shows that he puts his self-interest above that of society, and hence would lie to a jury to put his self-interest above his oath to tell the truth.  It’s a pretty good argument, but it’s just another way of proving propensity, which is not allowed, and works to render the defendant’s right to testify a farce.  Again, if the judge uses a word other than propensity, then it isn’t propensity.  The judge said so.

But what if your defendant is just kinda dumb, inarticulate, uneducated or plain old angry?  There are long list of traits that make for a bad witness, and you know that the prosecutor is going to pound on the defendant on cross to get him to explode.  What if the defendant is addicted, and will start to shake mid-way through testimony, and go into withdrawal?   There are many ways in which a defendant, having nothing to do with the crime, can commit suicide on the stand.  Many just make horrible witnesses, and we have to weigh whether we want the jury to just think he’s a bad guy or know it for sure after seeing him testify.

So the defendant can’t testify, but he can’t not testify either, since he’s going to get skewered either way by this “failure to testify” language, or even just pointing it out (think big neon sign over the defendant’s head) for the jury that the defendant could have testified but elected not to testify. 

There is no easy answer to these problems.  There is no hard answer either, as far as I’ve seen.  There are choices between the lesser of numerous evils.  None of them are in the defendant’s favor if you have a defendant who, for whatever reason, cannot take the stand.  What a surprise.

Best Argument of the Day

From the  Judicial Reports story about 2d Circuit’s rejection of government’s appeal on the Christie Todd Whitman statment, after 9/11, that the air was safe for people to go back to their homes and schools.

The Justice Department argued that the lawsuit would set a dangerous precedent: after national disasters, public officials would worry that their words of reassurance would open them up to personal liability. “If you speak, you will be potentially held liable,” an attorney said. “Then the clear message for government officials is to say nothing.”

You could always just tell the truth, right?  Nah.

Liptak is Back in my Doghouse

So much sentencing news yesterday, but the big question is, What Does Liptak Have to Say?

Sadly, Adam fell flat again on this one.  Man, I can’t begin to tell you how disappointed I am in Adam.  After his  disastrously bad piece on the bright side of the death penalty, he was clawing his way back to credibility.  And now this New York Times piece.  Adam, Adam, Adam.  What are you thinking, man?

Unfortunately, Liptak took his usual thorough review of all sides by including the thoughts of 2 law professors and a United States Attorney.  Fortunately, one of those lawprofs is Douglas Berman of Sentencing Policy and Law, who at least knows what he’s talking about.  But it still provides the academic perspective.  What about the trenches?

Then, Adam takes a hard right turn off the SCOTUS path toward the Guidelines Commission, because three pro-defense decisions by the Supreme Court these days isn’t important enough to write about.  This morning, the Guidelines Commission is supposed to decide whether the revised crack guidelines should be made retroactive, notwithstanding Hillary’s opposition.

The connection is that these sentencing decisions, where the Supreme Court in Kimbrough made clear that the prospective change in the crack guidelines makes it hard to defend holding about 20,000 people to their sentences based upon a now-discredited 100 to 1 sentencing disparity ratio is total garbage intellectually unsound.

So where does Adam turn for a quote?


“We are going to see an influx of the very people who are most likely to re-offend and are most likely to upset these fragile neighborhoods,” Gretchen C. F. Shappert, the United States attorney in Charlotte, N.C., told the commission.

“The impact of 19,500 defendants in the criminal justice system will be profound,” Ms. Shappert continued. “That is 25 percent of all defendants who were sentenced in federal court in 2006 and represents 10 percent of the entire criminal population” in federal prisons.

And for a different perspective . . . zip.  zero.  nada.  nothing.  silence.  Now I’m not of the view that there are always two sides to every story, but there is definitely a view other than the government’s when it comes to the retroactivity of the crack guidelines.  Not to mention, there are some practical matters that come into play as far as Liptak’s discussion of Gall and Kimbrough.  But you wouldn’t know it to read him today.

It’s not that Liptak doesn’t write an interesting column.  It’s just that it belongs on Fox or the New York Post instead of the New York Times.  Here’s an irony.  When I spellcheck my posts, Liptak always comes up as lapdog.  I wonder what spellcheck knows that I don’t.

Breaking News From Delhi

Rahul Jindal  has announced that he doesn’t want me to be angry at him in this festive season, so he’s offered this conciliatory view of criminal defense.


I have seen young parents worry about the influence of crime on impressionable minds, that practicing criminal law can, in extreme cases, also have its effects is a new one!

Now I don’t have a clue what this means, but since it’s coming from “the destination for knowledge driven industries and call-centers,” it must mean something important. 

You too can have your briefs ghost-written with such prosaic clarity in India.  But not if you only want to spend peanuts. 

As for Rahul’s offer to outsource my secretarial services to India to expand my limited American use of idioms to become more “international”, I just chatted with some gal from Bangalore named Charlene, who informed me something, though I couldn’t understand because of the accent. 

I’m thinking that I really don’t want my client’s one phone call going to Charlene.   But fear not, Rahul.  I’m not angry with you at all.  You probably just misunderstood because of my accent.

Tasers Are Safe Because Johns Hopkins Says So

I received an email from Dan Walter about a petition he is circulating to put an end to Johns Hopkins endorsement of the Taser. 


Johns Hopkins Medicine in Baltimore acts as a paid adviser to this scandal-plagued company: “Dr. Hugh Calkins, Professor of Medicine and Director of the Arrhythmia Service at Johns Hopkins Hospital, concluded,’I have had an opportunity to review the studies and the results of the studies confirm the general safety of the TASER devices…”

The Johns Hopkins name adds some pretty heavy weight to the “We heart Tasers” crowd.  Cha-ching. When functioning properly, meaning that they don’t kill the victim, they have been called a form of torture by a United Nations committee.  When things don’t work as well and the victim dies, they are tantamount to a death penalty.  Is this really the sort of thing that Johns Hopkins should put its name to for a wad of cash?  If you think not, then you might want to sign Dan’s petition.

As any reader here knows, I’ve had some issues with the taser, and with those taser-lovers who promote the idea that the taser is the cure-all for law enforcement.  But, that doesn’t mean that I support the elimination of tasers from the law enforcement arsenal.  Sorry to those who will find this shocking, but let me explain.

There is no doubt in my mind that a taser is hardly as safe as its proponents (and those who suck hard on the teet of Taser International, right Bernie Kerik?) would claim.  It can, and does, result in death at times, an unwarranted and inexcusable result.

But I’ve spent too many years seeing clients die at the hands of police to be so simple in my view.  My biggest problem with tasers is their inappropriate use by police.  They have become the easy substitute for doing their job, the weapon of choice to show citizens who’s the boss.  They are the billy club, the brass knuckles, the rubber hose.  The issue is the use of tasers as a show of force when there is no lawful or rational reason to use force at all. 

It’s just too damn easy to taser someone rather than do their job.  Cops are supposed to use their voice and reason to diffuse a situation and avoid force and violence.  Tasers change that, since they can zap anybody who annoys them with seeming impunity.  And cops are annoyed by pretty much everybody who doesn’t bow and scrape.  This is what’s wrong with tasers.  Toleration of this improper use must stop.  Tasers are still weapons, and no improper use of force should be tolerable to any civilized people.  Or cops for that matter.

But here’s the rub.  I would still prefer that a cop zap a person with a taser than shoot them in the head with a 9mm bullet.  The chance of surviving the taser is far, far greater.  And I am very partial to people surviving their encounters with police.  Without the taser (or some other not-always-lethal alternative), I fear that cops will go back to the old days when they pulled out their handgun first and asked questions later.  Remember, the old “furtive gesture” excuse.  Cops can always come up with an explanation for their killing someone that can’t be refuted by pulling out one of those great old police saws about conduct that no one but them ever sees.

If there was a safer way, a truly non-lethal weapon, that would allow people to survive their police encounter, I would lead the march against tasers.  They are hardly safe, and it is outrageous that some Johns Hopkins doc would prostitute himself to say so.  But they remain a better alternative than a Glock.  And that’s the best I can say about tasers.

Poisoning The Well

Bernie Kerik’s white-shoe criminal defense lawyer, Kenneth Breen, tried a new tact last week.  He argued to Southern District Judge Stephen Robinson that prosecutors “poisoned the well”   According to this Newsday report, Breen complained that the government, in a letter submitted to the court, argued:


that the statements — about the money behind Kerik’s renovations and a loan application — would not be covered by the lawyer-client privilege because they constituted obstruction of justice and were conveyed to prosecutors during plea negotiations.

The defense position was that they should not have disclosed the statements in a public document, since they statements had yet to be held admissible and the cat was now out of the bag.  It’s a well-taken point, but it was taken in the wrong direction.  Breen pushed the position that the release of these statements had tainted the jury pool and denied Bernie the ability to obtain a fair trial.

The prosecutor’s response is precious: Defense arguments are “entirely baseless and unfounded.”  In case you are wondering, no, the defense could never get away with a response that is wholly conclusory and devoid of any substance whatsoever.  Only the prosecution gets to make statements like this, so don’t try this at home.

Now, this prosecution is happening in the Southern District of New York.  There are more media outlets here than anywhere else on earth.  We have at least one daily newspaper for every 12 citizens, and each newspaper has to come up with lots of stories every day to fill up all those otherwise blank pages.  So, there tends to be plenty of “crime” news every day, because the media follows the sacred creed, if it bleeds, it leads.  Also, if you were appointed by Guiliani, you get a colonoscopy.  That sorta rhymes, right?

Needless to say, the defense argument was rejected and Breen got smacked.  Here’s a point that every criminal defense lawyer who does high profile work in New York City knows:  It’s almost impossible to poison the well in the Big Apple.  Why?  First, we have too much poison, and second we have too big a well.

The human brain has mutated to the point where it can input critically important information and hold it for 30 seconds, and then excrete it out the other end.  This is particularly necessary with criminal information, because there is another sensational crime every 30 second.  In the scheme of things, news about Kerik is small potatoes, filler or fluff.  At least for now.  Bernie is now just a has-been screw up who is accused of second-rate graft.  If it wasn’t for Guiliani, no one would know he was alive.

But the defense aspect of this case shows why white-shoe ex-prosecutors don’t necessarily adapt well to the defense side of the well.  There may well be a time when jury taint becomes a real issue in this prosecution, with Rudy still in the running for the Republican nomination despite his love-costs as Mayor.  It’s possible that Rudy could actually get the nomination.  At that time, his judgment about Bernie Kerik, tossed off as a lousy job of vetting at the moment, may become the subject of major scrutiny. 

Should that happen, and it’s a real possibility, then Bernie Kerik may have a real argument about a tainted jury pool.  While the argument had no chance now, and indeed wasn’t even close to being a viable argument given Bernie’s status as a gnat in the Guiliani story, it was silly to waste it.  There aren’t that many weapons in the criminal defense lawyer’s arsenal that you go around blowing them for nothing. 

It appears that Kenneth Breen is operating under the common mistaken belief that he’s still got the weight of the government propping him up.  He thinks he can make arguments that consist solely of words like “baseless and unfounded” and get away with it.  Nope.  That’s for prosecutors, not the defense.  We act strategically, and we have to avoid wasting ammunition firing at shadows.  There aren’t that many bullets in our gun.

It’s nice to be a federal prosecutor, with a never-ending stock of weapons to use against a defendant.  But if you want to be a criminal defense lawyer, you need to understand that the courts are no longer your best friends and that you can no longer close your eyes and shoot wildly, hoping to hit something.

Stay tuned for more of “The White Shoe Criminal Defense Follies,” and see how Biglaw handles trench warfare.

Utah Taser Video: The Cop Perspective

Orin Kerr, GW criminal lawprof at Volokh, parses the Utah Taser video  shown here to explain why he believes it can be reasonable (and unreasonable) based upon perspective.  It’s important to remember that Volokh is a conservative libertarian blog, and that Kerr is reputed to be a scholar on the subject of criminal law, and has many lawyerish young minds to mold. 

Initially, Orin runs through what the cop did wrong, and how from the taser victim’s perspective he did nothing wrong beyond being noncompliant.  Orin notes that the cop failed to inform the driver what was happening and what the consequences of his actions would be if he failed to comply.  Ultimately, the cop fails to warn the driver that he is in imminent fear of being tasered (tased? As in “don’t tase me bro?”).

Then we get to the interesting part of Kerr’s analysis.


Watch the video again, and this time focus closely on the 2:30 to 2:40 window. The officer has just ordered the driver out of the car so he can arrest him for failing to sign the ticket promising to pay or appear. The driver sees that the officer has the weapon out and is ordering him to submit to the officer’s authority. But the driver makes perfectly clear he is not going to submit.

Already, there are a few flaws in the description.  Orin projects reasoning onto the cops orders, but the cop doesn’t tell the driver why he is being ordered out of the car or that his arrest is imminent.  So how does Orin know the cop’s purpose?  Maybe he ordered him out of the car to teach the driver a little lesson in obedience?

Next, Orin notes that the cop has his taser out.  To Orin, this indicates that the cop is sending the message to the driver that he should comply or bear the consequences.  Does a show of force send that message to an ordinary person, who presents no threat to the officer?  Or just a cop prop that no reasonable person would suspect would ever be used in the absence of any threat to the officer.

But here’s where Orin’s analysis goes seriously wrong:


Watch the driver’s hands during this dialogue. Police officers are all about the hands during traffic stops; they want to see them, and they want them out in the open where they can’t be grabbing a weapon. When an officer is pointing a weapon at a suspect, his greatest fear will be that the suspect has a weapon on him that he’ll try to use; getting control of the situation is essential. So he’s going to be paying close attention to the driver’s hands.

It’s true that a cop always wants to see the person’s hands.  So where is the direction to take his hands out of his pockets?  Where is the explanation of why the cop may have any reason in the world to be concerned about the driver’s otherwise normal actions under a stressful situation?  It is not reasonable to expect the driver to read the cop’s mind.  Nor is it reasonable to expect an ordinary person to think about such matters under stressful conditions.  Nor is it reasonable to expect an ordinary person to suspect that common, everyday motions (putting one’s hands in one’s pockets) will evoke violence from a police officer.  Normal people don’t think this way.


In this case, the driver does everything wrong with his hands. At the 2:30 mark, he puts his right hand in his right pocket; his right arm is opposite the officer, so the officer can’t see what he’s doing. Even though the officer has the taser drawn and is pointing it directly at the driver, the driver turns to face the officer and then starts walking away, yelling “what the heck is wrong with you?” and keeping his hand near his pocket. At 2:36, the driver seems to be fishing for something in his pocket while still walking away from the officer to get more distance between himself and the taser. Two seconds later, the officer fires the taser.

This is where it becomes clear that the academic’s view lacks practical connection with reality.  It’s not just the hands.  It’s the bulge.  The minutes the driver exited the vehicle, the cop eyeballed the guy for a bulge, the telltale sign of a weapon.  Guns are big and heavy.  People who have never seen or held a gun don’t realize that they are big and heavy.  Check the waistband and the pockets for the bulge.  Check under the arms.  No bulge, it’s safe. 

The cop isn’t afraid that the driver is going to reach into his pocket and throw loose change at him.  The only reason for a cop to be concerned is a weapon.  There could be a small pocket knife, but the cop already has the taser out and aimed, so he’s not worried that the driver will reach him with a pocket knife.  There’s no chance of that happening.  But most importantly, and regardless of what the driver is doing with his hands, there’s no bulge.

Why does it matter that a known criminal law scholar like Orin makes such rookie mistakes in his analysis?  Because there are a lot of lawyers, and some of them will be your judge someday and others may be on your jury, who think they are learning about “real-life” criminal law from him.  Orin, in a tone so reasonable that it’s difficult not to even conceive of challenging, says:


In sum, what makes the video so interesting is that the driver and the officer seem to be inhabiting totally different worlds. The driver is in the first world and the officer is in the second. I think we would all agree that the officer did a terrible job in the traffic stop on the whole; that guy needs a desk job pronto. But I tend to think that reasonable people could disagree on whether the use of force itself was unreasonable.

Was the use of force “reasonable” from the officer’s perspective?  Only if one lives in a fantasy world where one deliberately closes one’s eyes to both the reality of police work and the fundamental expectation that police do not go around using force against citizens because they, the cops, are screw-ups.  No Orin, I can’t agree that it was reasonable.  And I can’t agree that your efforts to “explain” the cop’s perspective demonstrate that you take a fair and reasonable view of police/citizen encounters.  You blew this one big time.

Addendum:  Orin Kerr replies here.  If there’s anything in there, or in the comments, that you would like to address, leave a comment here and we’ll do what we can. 

Lawyers: Not Even In The Game

This post at the  New York Lawyer is one of the funniest, and truest, I’ve ever seen.  In the universe of big money and status, the very tip-top of the Biglaw stratosphere fetches for the Wall Streeters.  And it’s a hoot to watch.  Not being amongst the lawyerazzi who need to swing a part of their anatomy to prove their manhood, I’ve spent some time watching the “well-to-do” do what they do.  And believe me, lawyers are so far down the ladder that they aren’t even in the game.

The first part of this article, about the private school auction, tells it all.  And if you haven’t been to one of these shindigs, let me tell you:  It is the most shocking thing you will ever see.  I remember the first one I went to, where one of the items they were auctioning off was the use of a parent’s private jet for a weekend.  The parent was a big name fashion designer that everybody knows. 

The guy sitting next to me bid.  And bid again.  And bid some more.  And won the jet for a weekend for $139,000.  That’s the right amount of zeros.  So I turned to my dinner neighbor and said, “I hope you have someplace to go.”  Hahaha.  I’m such a card.  He casually turns to me and say, “I wouldn’t fly in his piece of sh*t if my life depended on it,” and then took a sip of wine.

What?  You didn’t like that story?  Then try this one.  In the silent auction preceding the big live one, there were 4 tickets for a poptart superstar at Jones Beach.  My daughter would really like this, I thought, so I bid.  My bid (in my humble opinion) was pretty high, but it was a good cause.  Cut to the end of the silent auction.  Not only did I not win, but the winning bid was 10 times my bid, and my bid was 10 times the value of the tickets. 

But the story isn’t over.  The next day, my daughter gets a call from one of her best friends at school.  “Would you like to see [poptart] with me?  My daddy won tickets last night at the Gala!”  How much better could it get for me?  Her daddy, but the way, was an investment banker.

There are a lot of investment bankers around where I live.  They only talk to me when they need a question answered or one of their kids gets nabbed for being a very important kid of an investment banker.  Other than that, lawyers are just beneath their dignity.  Even my neighbor, Mel Weiss, is too small potatoes to be worthy of talking to.  We are the hired help.

I could have been a investment banker.  Except, I never even knew such a thing existed until college, and didn’t have a clue what they did until after law school.  Nobody in my lower middle class Jewish neighborhood had ever heard of investment banking.  We’re all still scratching our heads, trying to figure out how that could be.

So when we, the lawyers of the world, look at the Biglaw partners as sitting at the top of the financial pyramid for lawyers, at least we can take comfort in knowing that the law pyramid is merely the footrest for the hedge fund managers, who look at Biglaw bonuses as lunch money for the truly well-paid.

SCOTUS Endorses Rejection of Crack Sentencing Disparity

UPDATE:  Don’t bother reading this post, as there are much better reviews of these extremely important decisions at  SCOTUSBlog and cross-posted by lawprof Douglas Berman at Sentencing Law and Policy, plus numerous other links to analyses (good and bad). 

Just out from SCOTUSblog, the Supreme Court’s 7-2 decision in Kimbrough v. United States (Opinion by Ginsberg, Thomas and Alito dissenting, Scalia concurring).  The holding, in essence, reaffirmed Booker’s holding that the United States Sentencing Guidelines are only advisory and upheld a district judge’s decision, grounded in 18 USC 3553(a) not to impose a sentence “greater than necessary” to serve legitimate sentencing objectives by rejecting the 100 to 1 crack guidelines.

[Also, decisions in  Gall (reinstating sentencing way below guidelines) and  Watson (destroys long-standing interpretation of gun “use and possess” to mean having a gun within 20 miles).  Very big day for criminal law and defendants.  Way too much to post about today, but these decisions are HUGE.]

The Court’s holding as to cocaine base, and rejection of the government’s position that the 100 to 1 ratio was required by the Anti-Drug Abuse Act of 1986 (note that this was before all criminal laws were required to have catchy pro-American acronyms), was largely due to the Sentencing Commission’s acknowledgment that the guidelines have long been severely disproportionate, based upon the wholly mistaken notion that was promoted by law enforcement back in 1986 that crack was the new killer evil drug that would destroy mankind, while powder cocaine was just a past-time at Studio 54.

Sorry about being flip here, but this could be a very significant decision.  Beyond its implications for crack, it appears to make an effort to send a message to the circuits  that the Supreme Court meant what it said in Booker, and that they should stop contorting their black-robed bodies to undermine the decision.  As long as a sentencing judge checks everything off the grocery list including the advisory Guidelines, grounds the decision 3553 language and it can pass the “reasonable” sniff test, then the sentence stands.

The door has been thrown open.  Now let’s see which judges chose to walk through.

Outsourcing To India — But Can They Handle Arraignments?

Susan Cartier Leibel at  Build a Solo Practice brings us this  guest post from “the highly animated Rahul Jindal from Delhi, India.”  No, Susan isn’t endorsing this concept, but rather providing a public service.

Rahul is the brains behind Legal Process Outsourcing, and it is actually part of the ABA Blawg 100 (apparently taking the place of  New York Personal Injury Law Blog by the Turk, which inexplicably ended up as the pathetic Blawg 101).

So while you’re thinking to yourself, how can I maintain, or (dare I dream) expand my practice, Rahul is here to tell you how you can ship your work over to “the destination for knowledge driven industries and call-centers.”  That would be India. 

Now if you think that our domestic marketing mavens are a bit pushy, Rahul is utterly without shame. 


And you can be a part of this success. Go offshore! No, I didn’t mean that you move to India yourself but rather that you think about having some people work for you and build your practice, helping you become increasingly competitive and profitable at the same time. If using offshore resources also enables you to scale up your own operations, why not?

It sounds like a party, doesn’t it?  And it probably is, except the party is over there and we aren’t invited.  We are encouraged, however, to send gifts.

But it’s cheaper at least, right?  Well, probably so, but don’t get too crazy about it.


You are in it for long and for value. As with any other relation, getting it to work to your benefit will take time and effort, so don’t nickel and dime about the rate too much. As the saying goes, if you pay only peanuts, you get only monkeys!

Peanuts and monkey?  Sounds like mixed metaphor to me, but then it’s coming from India and they may know something about monkeys that I don’t.  It’s a cultural thing.

Rahul has a series of suggestions for making your India outsourcing a pleasant and successful thing (at least for them).  My personal favorites has to do with his suggestion that you personally go to India to meet the people into whose hands your clients’ lives are placed. 


Agreed, physically seeing your vendor or his resources may not be often possible. But do it when it is possible, combine an Asian vacation with a day’s visit to your vendor’s premises. Speak to your team often. Form a relation; it matters a lot to Indian people if you ask about their family, interests and aspirations.

And there is nothing more important to my representation of clients than my outsourced “staff” know that I care deeply about them.

Rahul offers many things for the solo lawyer by outsourcing to that home of call centers, India.  But he’s not going to get my business until he offers one service notably missing:  Once I can outsource the guy doing time in prison, you’ve got something for me Rahul.  Until then, I’m just going to do my own legal work and give my clients what they believe they’re getting when they retain me to represent them.