Author Archives: SHG

Old Media Says Blawgs Are For Dawgs

LexBlog Marketing Guru Kevin O’Keefe, of Real Lawyers Have Blogs isn’t putting up with being dissed by New York Times Executive Editor Bill Keller.  Keller writes that “new media” (that means blogs) will never challenge old media (that means the New York Times, because you don’t get much older than the Times).  Why?  Because they are trustworthy.  We just make stuff up.

But that’s not all.  Old media ferrets out news.  It creates stories, while blogs just repeat them.


He says “What is absent from the vast array of new media outlets is, first and foremost, the great engine of newsgathering – the people who witness events, ferret out information, supply context and explanation.”

Kevin’s not buying.  But then, LexBlog’s business is selling.  Specifically, selling “turnkey weblog solutions.”  So, Kevin may have a bit of an interest in disagreeing with Keller’s assessment, just like Keller’s got a bit of an interest in knocking the blog phenomenon.  I love it when business models clash.

So Kevin comes right back at Keller:


Give us a five years and 75,000 more law blogs and we practicing lawyers, law professors, and law students will be doing a lot of reporting. And a force to reckoned with if we are not incorporated into legal newspapers and magazines.

Sigh.  Five years and 75,000 more law blogs?  That’s a lot of posts and a whole lotta blawgs.  So who is reading all these blawgs?  Who is writing all these blawgs?  What the hell are they getting out of all this?   Seriously, can you imagine scanning 75,000 blawgs a day?  A week? Whatever? 

It’s absurd, as it is to believe that there are 75,000 people who are going to bring substantive content to the web.  Sure, the guys sitting around their office waiting for the phone to ring might as well start a blawg about how they’re the best thing since sliced bread, but they’re going to can that crap as soon as they realize that they’ve wasted a ton of time and haven’t made a dime.  Every lawyer will have a blawg for one month. 

Now I have no horse in the turnkey blog biz, so I can come at this as an honest broker.  Keller is wrong.  Granted, the Times comes at info dissemination with ascribed credibility.  After all, it IS the New York Times.  But that doesn’t mean that blawgs can’t compete, or at least take some of the wind out of their sails.   Blawgs can attain credibility over time, and prove every bit as trustworthy as a newspaper (some may say more so). 

But blawgs have something that the old media will never have.  We can publish far faster than they can.  We are quick and nimble, and we have no bureaucracy that will stymie our ability to address issue in real time and with full and frank discussion.  They are a business, and have a business-like approach. Blawgs just lay it out, fearlessly and frankly.  Take that, Keller!

On the other hand, I can’t say that I agree with Kevin’s vision of the future, aside from the ludicrous idea that anybody needs 75,000 blawgs.  The act of news gathering takes time, effort and access.  The people who do it need to eat.  If they are spending their time gathering news like reporters, then they aren’t practicing law and earning a living.  This is a problem.  You can only be in one place at a time (unless you are an amoeba). 

Then there’s the writing dilemma.  Most lawyers can’t write worth a darn.  So even if they come up with interesting content, they manage to turn the sexiest bit of news into a bore.  Buying a blawg doesn’t mean you know how to write, or that anyone will want to read anything to put out there.  Didn’t anybody tell you about this before you gave them the credit card?

While Kevin is probably right that 75,000 lawyers will give blawging a try, 74,597 will give it up after a month or so and go back to their spouses and children.  Saturating a market, a concept that seems to come into play a lot around here lately, helps no one.  Except people selling blawgs.

Just so you know, I was asked to be “interviewed” by a guy named Rob from LexBlog for a “Q&A” piece.  He Q’d and I A’d.  I emailed it back to him and haven’t heard a word since.  He may have punked me, even though my answers were (naturally) brilliant and fascinating.  But my answers pretty much express what I’m posting now about the blawgosphere.  Of course, whether they ever see the light of day on LexBlog has yet to be seen.  [edit in] Rob has now  posted my Q on Kevin’s blog, so  read it here and I take back my snarky “punked” comment (and anything else stupid I may have said from the beginning of time until now, as long as I’m taking things back).

I have no issue for those who want to monetize their time online.  It’s the American way.  But blawging isn’t the next gold rush, and after the hype fades away, it will find its real level in the cosmos of new media.  The only question is who will be left standing in the blawgosphere when that time comes.

You Didn’t Listen And Now You Too Are A Lawyer

From that  wag Lat comes this piece of important news:  Joining the 91,000 individuals who claim to be practicing lawyers in the City of New York will be an additional 10,907!  Misery loves company.

And where do all these new lawyers think they are going to work?  According to the New York Sun :

“There isn’t going to be a decrease in demand for the very best talent, but that doesn’t indicate much at all,” Mr. Zaremski said. “There are plenty of attorneys who are happy to accept very low-level, mind-numbing positions doing whatever’s at the bottom of the barrel.”

The surplus of lawyers has created an entire industry that places attorneys in law firms on a temporary basis, Mr. Zaremski said.

Now I’m not entirely clear what is meant by “the very best talent,” since none of these newbies have as yet had an opportunity to demonstrate any talent as a lawyer.  But I’m sure the honchos at Biglaw know what they’re doing when they dole out a couple hundred thou per head to that select group of future rainmakers.  Of course, the competition for these Biglaw, big money positions will be fierce, particularly since Biglaw is suddenly telling the less-than-stellar first year youths that they may not have a future there and should consider a different position.

But what of the rest?  Well, there’s always public defense or consumer interest law.  Oh, wait a sec.  There’s no funding for these jobs, and my guess is that a lot of these new lawyers have loans to pay and want to eat on a fairly regular basis.  So that won’t work.

Perhaps they can hop on the solo freight train and shingle their way to fame and fortune.  Except law schools don’t teach them to actually practice law, making their ability to go forth and prosper a little limited.  They could always put ads on Craigslist and do felony pleas for $100 a pop.  If you can get 50 of those week, there’s some good money to be made.

It’s not like we haven’t  talked about what you yung’ins are getting into.  Yet you just keep flooding the market.  New lawyers, all bright eyed and bushy tailed, showing up at our doorsteps expecting us to appreciate your enthusiasm and “give you a chance,” as if it’s our fault that you made the decision to go into a profession that is being crushed by its own weight. 

So here’s the scoop, in my personal effort to help young attorneys.  If you can’t find a job with Biglaw making a those big bucks that you dreamed about when you should have been dreaming about torts, or if you don’t feel the calling to forgo the big bucks and want instead to use your education to help people, then there probably isn’t much of a future for you in the law.  I don’t care what mommy told you about being a professional, or how proud daddy is of your accomplishment. 

New York City has 1 lawyer for every 3 people already (my math may be off, but consider the hyperbole as a tool to make a point).  It doesn’t need another 10,907 new lawyers looking to make their bones.  And guess what?  Next year, there will be another 10,000 new lawyers, right on your heels, trying to get your job if you’re lucky enough to find one. 

Go find a real job.  Something that’s productive.  Societally useful.  Something that provides a decent income.  It’s just not going to be the law.  Don’t say I didn’t tell you.

Muslim Travel Alert From The Second Circuit

Sawsaan Tabaa misunderstood.  He thought that being an American meant that you could travel to Toronto and then return without being treated like a criminal.  Well, that was in the old days, according to the Second Circuit in Tabaa v. Chertoff.  By the way, you remember Michael Chertoff, don’t you?  He was the second best choice for Homeland Security Tzar, right after Bernie Kerik.  Now there’s high praise.

Tabaa went to a conference in Toronto with 4 other United States citizens who, as it happened, were Muslim.  Customs and Border Protection (now known by the really cool acronym “ICE” to make bad guys shiver, but they gave them really goofy looking badges that look like they came from Badges-r-Us) had “information” that people who knew someone who’s cousin had a mailman who once carried a letter from a potential terrorist would be at the conference.  That, of course, meant that they were all potential terrorists.

And so American citizen Tabaa became potential bad guy Tabaa.  And was treated to the way our Customs and Border guys deal with potential bad guys.  They were detained for hours, interrogated, frisked, fingerprinted and photographed.  This was the procedure set up for suspected terrorists, except there was no mention of waterboarding.

So Mr. Tabaa did what any red-blooded American would do under the circumstances.  He sued.  He sued for violations of the Administrative Procedure Act, First and Fourth Amendments and the Religious Freedom Restoration Act.  He operated under the theory that if you don’t do anything wrong, you basically have a right to go about your life without being subjected to federal detention as a suspected terrorist.  Even Muslims.  How silly is that?

And the Circuit opinion, by Judge Straub, excoriates the government for its shocking and baseless abuse of United States citizens by protecting their fundamental right to be left alone when there is no basis whatsoever to suspect that they are engaged in any wrongdoing whatsoever . . . not.  This is where all those great lines about our vaunted freedoms that lawyers and judges love to spout saddens me deeply.  Platitudes are wonderful, but only if they actually mean something and aren’t used to fill in the empty spaces between rulings that violate the very precepts they are supposed to protect.

The real Second Circuit opinion demonstrates how our judiciary is there to protect us from the red terrorist threat.  Tabaa loses because the actions undertaken were “narrowly tailored to achieve the compelling governmental interest in preventing terrorists from entering the United States.” 

Bear in mind that this isn’t a complaint about your typical border search, where you need to prove your identity and the government gets to check your bags to make sure you aren’t sneaking an extra bottle of Chivas across the border.  The acknowledged basis was Tabaa’s attendance of the “Reviving the Islamic Spirit Conference.”  No more, no less.  Thus, the message is clear:  Attend a religious conference and, if it happens to be about Islam and you happen to be an American citizen of the Muslim faith, the government has a compelling governmental interest that trumps every right you thought the Constitution and laws gave you.

My favorite line in the opinion is found in footnote 1, where the Court states that “in an abundance of caution,” it reviewed ex parte and in camera the classified information so that an independent determination could be made that he agents “uncontradicted” allegations were sufficient.  So how exactly does one contradict statements based upon “classified information” that is only known through an ex parte and in camera examination?  Well, that’s justice for you.  It may not be perfect, but it’s the best system there is.  Right?  Not if you’re Muslim.

We Don’t Need No Stinkin’ Conviction

For criminal defense lawyers, this story is, unfortunately, too familiar.  For others, it usually comes as surprise.  In United States v. Freeman, via one of the most depressing reads in the blawgosphere, Second Circuit Blog (because of subject matter, not any morose approach to the law or writing), our beloved Second Circuit Court of Appeals reminds us that an acquittal of murder charges is a mere technicality on the road to sentencing.

Michael Freeman went to trial on a five count indictment, the first three for drugs and the last two for murder.  He lost on the drug counts, but beat the murder.  Sounds good so far.  But SDNY Judge Loretta Preska wasn’t buying.  While the jury may have bought into that “beyond a reasonable doubt” nonsense, Judge Preska’s view was that Freeman committed the murders by “a preponderance of the evidence,” which is legal jargon for “he probably did it.” 

So what, you ask?  Well, says the Circuit, that’s all you need to sentence Freeman for the murders despite the acquittal.  You see, the sentencing judge is allowed to take into account all “relevant conduct,” more legal jargon for whatever the judge really thinks the defendant did.  That includes “acquitted conduct,” with the proviso that the judge “considers the jury’s acquittal” when determining a “reasonable sentence.” 

This doesn’t mean that judge has to hang her head and sentence the defendant only for the crimes for which he’s been convicted.  This means that the judge needs to state, in a clear Stentorian voice, that she has “fully considered the fact that the jury acquitted the defendant of the crime of murder,” and then sentence him for it anyway.  The trick is to pepper the opinion with the word “reasonable” as many times as possible, thereby rhetorically proving  that the judge has, indeed, been reasonable.  If a decision has four or five “reasonable” thrown in, that’s pretty much conclusive.

The problem with sentencing a defendant based upon “acquitted conduct,” or even uncharged conduct that is never proven but merely tossed into the Presentence Investigation Report by a loose-lipped agent or AUSA to make sure that the sentencing judge has the full flavor of a defendant, is that it kinda makes the whole point of trial a farce.  The good news, Mr. Defendant, is that we won the murder charge.  The bad news is that they are going to execute you on Tuesday anyway.

So the point of a trial would be what?  That’s right.  As long as you get convicted of something, thus making you eligible for a lovely stay in a federal penitentiary, courtesy of the United States of America, you may well have your visit extended based upon anything the prosecutors threw against the wall. 

The sophistry of sentencing on acquitted conduct is one of the most anti-American concepts that can be imagined.  I can’t imagine, Justice Scalia, that Jimbo Madison would have wanted it that way.  And yet, it is part of the scorched earth that makes up federal criminal practice.  Remind me again about that freedom that we’re fighting for in Iraq?

The Blue Wall Revisited (Again)

David Giacalone at f/k/a posts about one of my personal favorites, The Blue Wall of Silence.  He was prompted by “venerable, inveterate, often pointedly insightful, curmudgeon, Carl Strock” of the Schenectady, NY, Sunday Gazette piece, “ Open letter to Sch’dy’s good cops” (Dec. 2, 2007).   Haiku/s aside, I never pass up an opportunity like this.

The thrust of Strock’s piece is that the moldy “one bad apple” theory, pulled out whenever a cop gets caught doing whatever cops get caught doing, doesn’t hold water.  It seems that the peer pressure that keeps the Blue Wall from crumbling comes from majority pressure, not “one bad apple.”  After all, if a dirty cop was an anomaly, all the good cops would have no problem ratting him out and getting him tossed off the job.  Then, there would only be good, honest, trustworthy cops left behind, and no need for a Blue Wall to begin with.

The problem isn’t them, however.  It’s us.  It’s the public’s refusal (denial?) that we have a problem with these men and women in Blue to whom we have reposed enormous power and authority.  We give them shields and guns (not to mention tasers) and set them loose on society.  Could we possibly allow this to happen if we accepted the premise that they could go out there and do wrong?  That would be nuts.  So we believe that they are there to protect and serve, regardless of the evidence to the contrary.

What does the Blue Wall protect?  It may be as significant as major theft or rape, or perhaps excessive force (your honor, my fist was attacked by the defendant’s face), petty theft, favoritism and cronyism (it was just a cup o’ Joe and a dozen donuts) down to what I believe to be the most pervasive wrongdoing, testilying.  Nothing screws up a decent cross-examination worse than a truthful cop, even when the truth presents “issues”.

If these acts of official misconduct and crime weren’t the norm, why would any cop fear ridding his department of that “one bad apple?”  Indeed, the peer pressure would be exactly the opposite, with the majority of good cops pressuring the one bad cop to mend his ways or get out.  Why would the majority want to be tainted by “one bad apple?” 

Not satisfied?  Consider then the most obvious case in recent memory, Abner Louima.  Four cops tried.  One ultimately left holding the bag, after the others get shown the love reserved only for law enforcement by the Second Circuit.  Justice was done, right?

As Justin Volpe (you remember him, don’t you?  The sort of cop who took enormous pride in showing how he could use a toilet plunger handle to teach some Haitian who’s the boss) walked out of the precinct bathroom, he waved his bloody plunger for all his brothers to see.  Huzzah!  The conquering hero proved his mettle to a precinct full of officers, with shields and guns, sworn to uphold the law and Constitution. 

Not a single man or woman came forward.  No one grabbed Volpe and arrested him.  No one told Volpe that he was wrong.  And when the feces hit the fan, every single one of them buried their heads in their forms and pretended that it had nothing to do with them. 

Why is Louima such an important, valuable example?  Because this was a situation that went in a different direction than your typical excessive force case.  Usually, it was a cop “tuning up” a reluctant skel to teach them some manners.  A few blows to the head and the job is done.  The skel survives, no worse for wear, and society is better off for it as far as the cops are concerned.  Somebody had to teach him a lesson, right?

But what Justin Volpe did to Abner Louima was sick.  It was man on man sexual torture.  It could make even a hardened cop puke, thinking about what had just happened in that bathroom.  This was not your typical abuse.  And still, the silence in the 70th Precinct was deafening. 

The public was aghast by what happened to Abner Louima.  Just like it was aghast at Serpico, the Dirty 30 and the many police scandals before it.  But we got over it, and no systemic changes happened.  Why?  Because it was just “one bad apple.” 

Strock’s attempt to remind us of our devils is valuable, and proof that curmudgeons (and cynics) are merely idealists dressed in wolf’s clothing.  But we never seem to learn anything from these scandals or the pieces written about them.  Apparently, the only thing stronger than the Blue Wall of Silence is our denial that it exists and shields a paramilitary operation that threatens all of us.

Hillary Says “Hang ’em High!”

Well, not exactly.  But the former First Lady has announced, per Ben Smith at Politico, by way of Talkleft, that she is against retroactivity of the small reduction in the crack (cocaine base, as people who prefer the word “waterboarding” like to call it) guidelines.

Now we all know that Hillary is a very smart woman, so she must have thought long and hard before making a decision that will affect the lives of 20,000 people directly, and perhaps another hundred thousand through one degree of separation.  And what would this deeply deliberated rationale be?

“In principle I have problems with retroactivity,” she said. “It’s something a lot of communities will be concerned about as well.”

An interesting principle.  A lot of communities will “be concerned,” and we wouldn’t want that.  So the principle is to let 20,000 people suffer rather than have to do the right thing and have communities (which is Hillary code for voters) “be concerned.”  It warms my heart to know that Hillary is guided by principles.  Well, maybe not the same principles that one might hope guide a Democratic candidate for President, or somebody running for the local school board for that matter, but principles nonetheless.  After all, it would just be horrible to think she was no more than a cynical manipulative politician will to sell out anything or anyone to win an election.

But what do real Democrats think of Hillary’s position?  This comment to Jeralyn’s post is revealing:

She doesn’t want the retroactive immunity to become a political football and distract from the heart of the issue, eliminating the discrepancy.  Well, you won’t like that, but it shows political seasoning, IMO.

So if I understand the point correctly, and it frankly has the smell of reality to it, real Democrats appreciate her saltiness by not letting the fact that 20,000 people will stay in prison for years distract her from the “heart of the issue,” eliminating the discrepancy.  But didn’t the guidelines change (which did not, by the way, “eliminate” the discrepancy, it just reduced it slightly), already go through and was effective as of November 1st?  So that deals done, and the only issue still on the table is retroactivity.  But we wouldn’t want to distract anyone by acting  like, oh, a Democrat.

I’ve spent a lot of time lately helping my daughter with her high school political science AP course this year.  One of her questions was to ask me to explain the difference between Republicans and Democrats.  I told her to ask her mother.

And Norm  agrees with me about Hillary, even though he used to think she was one swell First Lady.

Prosecutors: Champions of the Poor and Downtrodden

Marquette Criminal Law Professor Michael O’Hear, who has recently come  under scrutiny here for the curious assertion that we need to make plea bargaining feel more like a trial so defendants can enjoy the “truth-finding” function of a court before they go to prison, has come up with a new theory.

He tells the story of how he’s invited 4 individuals who actually practice criminal law into his classes to talk to his students, and how one, a prosecutor, moved him.


I was struck by this prosecutor’s response to my standard lead-off question: “So, why did you become a prosecutor?” His reply, which must have surprised some of the students, emphasized his interest in working with poor people. He observed that, contrary to common perceptions, the population of victims with whom prosecutors work (at least in a large urban jurisdiction like his) is almost indistinguishable from the population of defendants with whom the public defenders work. He plainly views his job in social justice terms, as a way of providing services for some of the most desperately needy people in the community.

Hey, that’s what the man said.  And it would come as no surprise to me that he believes it.  I had a friend in law school who was as lefty as they come.  I’m talking painfully left, the type who would make you want to join the Federalist Society because she was so off the wall.  And, surprise, she went to work for the prosecution, setting off some gestalt bone in her head that allowed her to rationalize her paycheck with her politics in exactly the same way.

If we take a deeper look, maybe we can make some sense of this.  It is undoubtedly true that poor people are more likely to be the victims of street crime than anyone else.  Hence, to be party to the prosecution of street crime is to help the poor people who would otherwise be the victims of this crime.  So the underlying idea isn’t that far-fetched.

The problem is that the practice doesn’t necessarily match the theory.  The day to day work of a prosecutor is trying to put people in jail.  It is not to go out on the street, feeling the pain of the victims and helping them to get their lives back together.  It’s standing in a courtroom offering arguments as to why defendant after defendant should be punished.  In fact, rarely does a prosecutor have any reason to meet a victim, until it’s time to prep for trial.  And as we know, trials are few and far between.

The suggestion is also made that the prosecutor helps the poor by making more reasonable decisions as to prosecution and disposition of defendants.  In other words, a prosecutor can show leniency, proportionality and concern for a poor defendant by his choices, and a prosecutor who is concerned for the welfare of the poor can use the power of his office help defendants, or at least hurt them less than another prosecutor.

There is some truth to this, and all criminal defense lawyers know prosecutors who are more reasonable, and easier to deal with, than others.  When we get a decent prosecutor on a case, we appreciate the fact that our client stands a fighting chance, whether it be their handling of discovery, Brady, or disposition.  But in the continuum of prosecutors, decent people are still not “friends” of the defendant; They are more reasonable than prosecutors who want to put every defendant they meet to death. 

Moreover, prosecutors are not free agents.  They work in District Attorneys or United States Attorneys offices, with internal policies that dictate the limits of their authority.  There are constraints.  They do not have a free hand to cut defendants loose whenever it suits their personal fancy.  To suggest that prosecutors can apply their own vision of justice to their caseload is absurd.  They can do so, but only if they want to be unemployed a week later.

So, Professor O’Hear spins another yarn that simply bears little connection to reality.  This is not to say that prosecutors are bad, or that they do not perform a vital function in the legal system and society.  Indeed, they are a crucial player in an orderly society, and we all want to go to sleep at night believing that our homes will be safe from intruders and our children protected.  We want prosecutors (not to mention police) to do their jobs, for without them we would be at constant risk.  Praise be the hard-working, honest prosecutor.

And if every official in the criminal justice system performed his function properly, it would benefit all members of society, the poor included.  But that’s a long way from being the champion of the poor.  It is no more the prosecutors’ function to be the champion of the poor than it is to be the avenging angel of the rich. 

What is most telling about O’Hear’s post is his uncritical view of the prosecutor’s statement.  If the prosecutor says so, then it must be.  Hardly a scholarly analysis.  So here’s another take, Professor.  We each believe what we need to believe to do what we do everyday, pretending that we are doing the right thing for the right reasons.  If one guy wants to believe that he prosecutes for the benefit of the poor and downtrodden, and it allow him to sleep easier, so be it.  But saying so doesn’t make it true. 

Consider whether a lawprof should use their position with students to engage in the promotion of facile rationalizations when deciding where to start their career.  There is nothing wrong with being a prosecutor.  It is a necessary and important job.  But they should prosecute because they believe in the function, not because someone sold them the they will really be the hero of the poor, because they will find yourself living a lie and be very unhappy and disappointed in their choice.

Alternative Ways To Understand Criminals

Some people don’t like criminals.  Go figure.  They read about them in the newspaper, or may even have the occasional personal contact with somebody who commits a crime.  The automatic reaction of the “good people” is that the “bad people” are venal miscreants.  They are evil.  They are very, very bad.

Is there anything wrong with this?  Actually, there is.  First, it allows us to pigeonhole them as if they were one-dimensional, thus dehumanizing them and allowing us to simply reject their existence.  There is nothing worthwhile about them, and hence their death or life imprisonment means nothing.  If they do something bad, they had no life beforehand where they loved their children, saved a cat in a tree, heck, saved a tree.  The entirety of their being is that one bad act.  Who needs genes like that in the pool?

Thanks to a very smart fellow (despite his occupation), Jim Chen over at Moneylaw, I’ve got some new tools to think about the people who do bad things.  In my experience, most guilty defendants aren’t really evil.  Being in a position to get to know them and understand how and why they did what they did, I know what I’m talking about.  Consider these two fundamental rules:



Hanlon’s razor. This folk aphorism reminds us: Never attribute to malice that which can be adequately explained by stupidity.

 

Clark’s Law : incompetence, if sufficiently advanced, is indistinguishable from malice.

Most guilty defendants are just stupid.  They acted on dumb impulse, and can’t possibly give a rational explanation of why they did what they did or what contemplative process led them to think it was good idea at the time.  Frequently, this is a product of an unbelievably bad education or the inability to think beyond their nose.  Usually, there is a huge cultural component that those of us who had a more typical American upbringing can’t possibly appreciate or accept as being a justification for their stupidity. 

Over my 25 years in criminal defense, I have been astounded over and over listening to my clients explain to me what happened.  It sometimes feels like being in an alternate universe, where reason and conceptual understanding don’t exist.  Some of the stories have me rolling on the floor laughing, they are just so ridiculous.  But they are very real to my clients.  It’s their alternate universe, whether I like it or not.

Sure, there are some who are truly malicious.  There are some who have no excuse, having been given every advantage and opportunity to enjoy the fruits of society without bringing harm to others.  But they are the minority. 

The majority of people who get to wear the title of criminal are really pretty sad, pathetic figures.  Pity them all you want.  For many, a little jail is an opportunity to gain a different vision of their place in society, and an opportunity to learn a trade or get a GED.  Maybe a chance to dry out, which they will never be able to do on the street.  I would like to add rehabilitation, but that just doesn’t happen in real life. 

But don’t hate them.  There but for the grace of decent parents and a viable education system go you.  We all have the potential to be truly stupid.  It doesn’t make us bad people.

The Secret Award For Best Blawg

Last week, a new Blawg award came on the scene, the ABA Blawg 100.  This wasn’t the first Blawg award or meme to spread across the blawgosphere, but this one did something a bit different.  It caused a lot of friction between blawgers.

The difference this time was, I think, twofold.  First, because it claimed to endorse the 100 top blawgs, a very large number (though only a fraction of the 3000 or so blawgs in existence), those blawgs that weren’t included felt, well, left out. 

The second difference is that it was promoted by the ABA, so rather than have the imprimatur of the blawgosphere alone, it had the American Bar Association seal of approval, like a toothpaste ad for the dental society.  While most lawyers, surprisingly to most laypeople, aren’t ABA members, it still smells to the outside world like the big cheese has stamped the left out blawgs with a big red “rejected”.  It was not a good feeling.

So what?  Well, some very fine people, with some damn fine blawgs, took umbrage.  And this caused a rift in the blawgosphere.  Truth be told, the friendships and support across the blawgosphere is a whole lot more important than being part of any 100 or getting any award.  One more truth:  A lot of the blawgs that were left out were as good if not better than the ones included.  There. I’ve said it. 

The immediate reactions to the announcement of the ABA Blawg 100 was diverse.  The named blawgs (including this one) posted that they were in.  Some posted more thoughtful things, such as the  surprise at who was left out, who else was left out, and even others who were left out.  And others still wrote about another silly beauty pageant and  bared the unbearable truth of why we have awards to begin with.  But  blonds still want to win.

Some blawgs decided  not to get involved in this intra-blawgospherical competition.  Others chose to  lobby hard for votes.  Still others decided to face directly what it meant  without fear of being accused of sour grapes, including the best explanation for what this public voting means:


Indeed. If other things were judged by such polls, Toyota would be recognized as the best carmaker, ground beef as the best cut, Gallo as the best wine, and Thomas Kinkade as the best painter. China would be accepted as the best country, Christianity as the best religion, Windows as the best operating system, and ignorance as the best mental state (coincidentally, George W. Bush would be president).

The blawgosphere exists amongst all the people who spend their time contributing to the knowledge base.  Some posts are brilliant.  Others less so, but all give the rest of us something to work with and develop a blawgversation.  Isn’t it cute how we can work “blawg” into almost any real word?  Without each other, it would be nearly impossible for anyone to find us, recognize us as being worthy of a few minutes of their time or continue to exist.  Nor would we have a whole lot to write about, since we often borrow (which sounds so much nicer than steal) ideas and links from each other. 

Blawging etiquette says that we credit the blawg from which we take things.  Most blawgs do.  Some do not.  Some blawgs are so pretentious that they would only link to other blawgs as “important” as they are.  But they aren’t above reading us low life blawgs and borrowing (there’s that word again) our thoughts, ideas and links.

The reason blawging etiquette matters is something that we don’t often mention in our blawgs, our  Technorati ranking.  This is how we find out what other blawgs link to us, and hence recognize our existence.  It’s a way of understanding that there are other people out in the real world that acknowledge our existence, so that we know our peers think that we have something worthwhile to say. 

Many blawgs, such as this one, are best described as “niche” blawgs, of interest to a limited audience.  Others capture huge audiences and have broader appeal.  Still others are part of insular groups that tend to exclude others as they circle the wagons, such as  LexBlog and the LawProfs Network.

As for me, there is no award that the blawgosphere has to offer that is more important than the community of the blawgosphere.  The friction that has developed around these awards, and surfaced with this ABA Blawg 100, isn’t worth it.  More importantly, the awards aren’t real.  They don’t mean anything.  We don’t win money or fame.  There’s no money or fame here to be won.  There’s only the support of our fellow blawgers every day that helps us to write the next post or let’s us know when we’re doing well (or poorly). 

The honor is to have friends in the blawgosphere, to have a few people read what you write, comment on it, and enjoy the give and take that comes from a community.  If awards are going to disrupt that community and make its members feel that their efforts are not worthwhile, then we’re better off without awards.  Every time somebody reads one of our posts, we win the secret award for best blawg.  That’s good enough for me.

Judy In Disguise

When Rudy spend $400,000 of money earmarked for poor defendants on his travel security, what exactly did he do?  Well, it seems that he made sure that his very good, close, personal friend Judy Nathan was very, very secure.  According Talking Points Memo, some might say a little too secure. 

It seems that Judy was given shaggerific police protection on the public dole, most notably indigent defenders, which she enjoyed for herself, her family and her friends.  According to  this report by CBSTV, Judy used New York City cops to play taxi driver for herself and anyone else who struck her fancy.  It’s good to have the police to drive you around in New York, as long as you aren’t in cuffs.

What did Rudy think of this?  Watch the video.  But first go to the bathroom so you don’t have an accident.  After all, this is the guy who wants to President.

If anyone can tell me how to snag this video so I can put it up on Simple Justice, please let me know.  I think this one’s a keeper.  And if I may add a wee bit of editorial comment, who could have possibly asked for a better babe for Rudy than Judy.  They are the perfect match!