Author Archives: SHG

Some Like It Orally

It’s not like I look for things to post about that involve lawprof Michael O’Hear, but he keeps coming up with stuff that pique my interest.  This time he posts about giving law school exams orally rather than in writing over at PrawfsBlawg.  Plus, how could I resist a post title like this?

O’Hear’s basic question is a matter of fundamental fairness:


I’ve never seen a good principled reason why the former students should be systematically disadvantaged relative to the latter at exam time. Ideally, I think that students whose strengths lie in oral expression should have an equal opportunity to demonstrate their mastery of course content in a medium in which they are comfortable.

By former, he refers to those who are more orally adept, while latter are the writers.  He then launches into a variety of issues to address, such as anonymity (remember “they’ve given you a number and taken ‘way your name” from Secret Agent Man?) and reaction to non-verbal cues during oral examinations.  The written exam would deny the student the ability to watch his lawprofs’ smile or frown as he answers questions, thus allowing him to shimmy and shake in accordance with the feedback.

But, as a practical fellow, I have an issue with O’Hear’s issue.  Lawyers must be skilled in writing and oral argument.  These are both practical skills that we use daily, and often without knowing which will be commanded by a court at any given moment.  It’s not like we can tell the judge who says, “get me a brief by tomorrow morning,” that we reluctantly decline because we favor arguing the point orally.  The same is true when the judge asks, “Why?”  She wants an answer now, and is not likely to respond well when we say, “But I’d much rather write you a memo on the issue, your Honor.”

It’s this kind of coddling by lawprofs to the wants and desires of law students that is giving rise to their confusion when they finally get down to the work of being a lawyer.  If lawprofs send the message that they have a choice as to what skillset they will be required to use when put to the test as a lawyer, they are going to be sorely disappointed by judges who are less accommodating.  Worse yet, their clients are going to be downright miserable when they fail to fulfill their purpose in court because they lack the facility to produce.  Nobody wants to hear that the former students, now lawyers, can’t write and argue orally because law school let them slip through without developing both skills.

I completely understand that law students may think it unfair that they are forced to be tested on substantive law via their weaker skill.  Law students think everything is unfair.  They wear whining like a fashion accessory.  But the practice of law demands the ability to make a point and persuade, whether it be in writing or by oral argument.  We all know this, right?  So let’s stop playing with students’ heads by giving them the impression that they have a choice in the matter and make them develop all the skills needed to practice law.  Their future clients will thank you for it.  Eventually, so will they.

Blame the ABA, Not the Law Schools

A few rants have (ahem) somehow found their way to the front page here about how law schools fail to teach students to be lawyers.  Naturally, I pin the blame on the schools and the lawprofs.  Could I be wrong?

From Susan Cartier Liebel at Build A Solo Practice, a comment from lawyer Edward Weist has turned the argument upside down.  Susan has taken the comment and presented it as a “guest blogger” post because it presents such a wealth of information about the how and why of law school direction.  Apparently, the genesis isn’t geriatric inertia as one would assume, but none other than the famed Beauty Pageant promoter, the American Bar Association.

Weist, who practices in Massachusetts, provides a detailed explanation of the constraints placed on law schools (and hence, law students):


ABA rules governing the accreditation of law schools—and, effectively, their graduates’ ability to sit for the bar on a nationwide basis—effectively mandate separation between the legal academy and the real world of practice.  Point your browser to the ABA’s published standards for law schools.  Standard 402 and interpretation 402-4 strongly discourage the use of even full-time faculty with significant outside practices (e.g., ongoing real-world contact).  Standard 304(f) provides for the adoption of rules limiting full-time students’ compensated part-time work (presumably for paying clients) during the academic year to 20 hours per week.

That sucks.  So law schools can’t use practicing lawyers to teach and won’t let students learn outside the classroom.  The old double-whammy.  I really wish I knew that when I was in law school, working a 60 hour week for a lawyer (and you can bet I expected to be paid).  I was bad.  I broke the rule.  Ignorance is no excuse, you know.  I’m so ashamed.  But I’m not giving the $3.25 an hour back.

Of course, this isn’t a complete absolution for law schools.  It doesn’t explain why actual legal experience is the kiss of death for a lawprof position, if the purpose of a lawprof is to teach law students.  If it’s to produce a steady stream of scholarly articles for obscure student-edited law reviews that bear no rational nexus to the practice of law, then the absence of real-world experienced lawprofs makes more sense.

On the flip-side, if law schools are aware of these accreditation rules (and I must believe they are), then what have they been doing to correct or update those pieces that fail to serve the interests of students in preparing them to join the ranks of attorneys?  I’ve heard no law school cry for an ABA summit to change the rules.  The silence tells me that the schools really aren’t looking for a way to alter the status quo.  Things must be just fine the way they are.

Frankly, in the grand scheme of issues to be confronted by law schools and the legal community, the lack of preparedness of law students isn’t my top issue.  Given the situation in the current legal community (and bearing in mind that I’m an avid reader of  Above the Law so I know when I’m in the presence of a judicial “superhottie”), the foremost problem is that law schools are churning out far more new lawyers than society and the legal community need or can absorb. 

Even the ones that will get to spend their first few months at Biglaw, enjoying the in-house nail salons and other critical perks, will soon learn this truth.  And all the legal experience in the world isn’t going to bring comfort in an environment this competitive.  Hey, when Biglaw partners are being de-equitized for non-production, you know that no one is safe.

But that doesn’t mean we don’t fix what we can.  Maybe it’s time for an ABA summit to reconsider the limits placed on schools and students to address changing times, needs and views.  I’m game.  Any law schools interested?

A Judge Who Understands His Job

From Newsday, Nassau County Court Judge Richard LaPera has laid it out the way it should be.  It would have been so easy to collapse and let the slings and arrows of the grief-stricken family push him to disavow his sentencing commitment on a plea offer to a truly heinous killer.  But he didn’t.  And it’s worthy of notice.

The case involved the murder of Denise Fox.  It was a bad murder, with her body found in Evan Marshall’s basement and her severed head in his car trunk. 

Judge LaPera heard the prosecutor and family on sentencing.  They urged him to reject the plea and give Marshall a straight life sentence so that he would never have the chance of seeing the outside of a prison again.  They’re point was clear.


“How brutal does a crime have to be, or how dangerous does a killer have to be to warrant just punishment as provided by law?” said Fox’s husband, Jay, in court Wednesday.

When these words come from the husband of the victim, it’s hard not to pay attention.  But Judge LaPera stood firm, not because he was at all sympathetic to the defendant.  Indeed, there was nothing to be sympathetic about.  Rather, he understood two things that the family did not.


“I agree that he should not be released from prison, and it is my experience that he will not be paroled,” LaPera said. “But it is my sincere belief that this is the best resolution to a most difficult situation.”

Judge LaPera recognized that despite the anger, there were issues that could not be ignored.


But LaPera said the brutality of the crime is not what defines first-degree murder. To prove first-degree murder, prosecutors would have had to show that Marshall murdered Fox, 57, while committing a burglary, and LaPera said there wasn’t sufficient evidence of that. He said there also wasn’t enough evidence to prove that Marshall committed first-degree assault when he hit Melville lawyer Cynthia Kouril with his car, hours before he murdered Fox.

I know Cindy Kouril, a former AUSA and a fine lawyer and person.  Her involvement in this case bears no connection to the murder, but it’s weird to have her play any role at all in such a horrible situation.

The judge also knew that the family had no idea what pain would go through, what memories would be stirred, by a trial in this case.  He spared them horrible trauma, but they didn’t realize it.  Without living through it, they would never realize that he did the right thing by them. 

Judge LaPera demonstrated integrity, empathy and justice by not changing his decision.  He fulfilled his duty to the People of the State of New York in the most honorable fashion.

Judge Richard LaPera will be retiring at the end of this month.  I wonder what role this played in his choice, not having to face the voters ever again and being free to exercise his authority without fear of reprisal.  Whoever gets to sit on Judge LaPera’s bench would do well to consider his decision in this case.

LexBlog Asks, Simple Justice Answers

As I  posted yesterday, Rob from LexBlog asked me if I would agree to an “interview” following the discussion with Kevin O’Keefe from Real Lawyers Have Blogs.  We did this Q&A thing, and when it didn’t appear online, I assumed that Rob was just messing with me.  But I was wrong.  It just took a little longer than anticipated for my interview to make it to the surface.  And here it is.

Now let’s clear something up right off the bat.  I didn’t know they were going to use a picture of me in the post.  Nobody said anything about a picture.  If Rob had told me, I would have given him a better picture.  This is the one I prefer:

http://images.google.com/imgres?imgurl=http://www.afterimagegallery.com/satterwhiteredford.jpg&imgrefurl=http://www.afterimagegallery.com/satterwhiteredford.htm&h=969&w=700&sz=201&hl=en&start=4&sig2=KTdu2W8y3R8jOzenC2-Dew&tbnid=0EZYLHZys4lMkM:&tbnh=148&tbnw=107&eid=ZglXR9DWJpaMeKGXmMYO&prev=

I think it speaks for itself.  I don’t know where they got that picture of some ugly guy for Kevin’s blog, but this is what I really look like.  Yup.  That’s right.

As for the Q&A, I can only answer the questions I was asked.  So there are probably a bunch of people just dying to read something a little more incisive.  Here are the questions that I wasn’t asked, but should have been.

Q:  If you were a tree, what tree would you be?
A:  Huh?  You’re kidding, right?
Q:  When you lose a big case that you really thought you were going to win, how does it feel?
A:  Lose?  I’m sorry, can you define that word?  It’s unfamiliar to me.
Q:  What’s your favorite color?
A:  Go back to lose.  What makes you think I lose?  What did Bennett tell you?
Q:  Did you always want to be a criminal defense lawyer?
A:  No, when I was little, I wanted to be a fireman.
Q:  So what happened?
A:  What happened with what?  The case you think I lost?  What case is that?
Q:  Your blog seems to be schizophrenic.  Are you serious or are you being sarcastic when you post?
A:  I’m always serious, even when I’m being sarcastic.
Q:  When you started blogging, did you think you were going to end up in all these contests?
A:  I thought I would have a total readership of 3; maybe 2 if my wife was pissed at me.
Q:  Do you plan to keep blogging on Simple Justice forever?
A:  Not likely, since I figure that I won’t live that long. 
Q:  What would make you stop blogging?
A:  Another interview like this, or a decent offer to replace Adam Liptac at the times to do a column on criminal justice issues.  Bill Keller, are you listening?  Call me!

And so, all the potentially fascinating things about me that you really want to know fall by the wayside.  Instead, I’m relegated to some puffery about whether blogging is going to change the practice of law as we know it.  The answer, by the way, is that it most assuredly will, as long as you continue to read all the truly wonderful things I post on Simple Justice.  Well, maybe it won’t do squat for you, but it will sure make me feel a lot better.  And isn’t that really what blogging is all about?

A Little Help, Please

Mark Bennett, the Texas tornado, is “in” trial (what we call “on” trial, but they have to be different).  And as any trial lawyer knows, when you’re on trial, you need a little help from your friends to cover the calendar on other cases.  This is the sort of thing that you can ask a friend to do, if she’s going to be in the courthouse anyway.  It’s not a big deal, but has to get done.  And it’s not difficult to do, but then, it can be.

This falls under the heading of professional courtesy.  We do a favor because we know that we will need it back someday.  But a favor is only a favor if you do it right.  When you need someone to cover a case, you don’t need them to show up a few hours late and let your client forfeit bail and get a bench warrant.  Clients really hate it when stuff like this happens.

We talked about professional courtesy before around the practical blawgosphere, but usually in terms of being treated poorly by some snot-nosed prosecutor who wants to flex his arrogance.  This is about burning your own friends. 

It used to be that all favors went into the bank.  We made a deposit when someone needed a hand, and then a withdrawal when it was our turn to need some help.  Everyone understood that favors were banked, and everyone realized that we all benefited from being able to count on friends to help.  But this isn’t the way anymore.

Mark posts about how he, when doing a favor, will go out of his way to make sure that it’s done right, promptly and makes the person for whom the favor is done look good.  In other words, he tries to help, not merely repay a lent-hand begrudgingly.  That’s the right way to do it.  That has always been my way as well.

I’ve helped out a lot of lawyers over the years.  I have always done my absolute best work for them, so that they always looked good for my having been involved.  Sometimes it was covering a case.  More often, it was representing them or a family member at a discount or in an emergency.  When I’m doing a favor, I do it with the same zeal and effort as my best-paying client ever.  Maybe even more.  I would hate to let a friend down.

So you would think that I’m fairly rich in the favor bank department, right?  Not so, apparently.  At least, not any more.  There are some youngish lawyers whose children were fed because of my referrals who can’t seem to find the time to cover a case for me when I’m on trial.  There is another who charged me twice what anybody in the world would pay him to get some documents for me, because he knew that I get higher fees than him. 

A couple of days ago, I received a call from a lawyer I didn’t know.  He told me he was assigned an appeal for a co-defendant of my client.  It takes a while for assignments to be made, and in this case it was about 8 months since the sentence.  I had already completed and filed my appellant’s brief. 

He told me that he received a letter from his client.  The letter said that his co-defendant, my client, had a family with the resources to hire “one of the best appellate lawyers in the whole country.”  It went on to say that his client “had no money and was stuck with him.”  Obviously, this client knew how to make friends and influence people.  We had a big laugh about the letter.

I told this lawyer that the appeals had some common arguments that applied to both defendants, as well as some that didn’t.  Since I was way ahead of him, I told him that I would send over my brief and that he was welcome to use as much of it as he wanted.  Moreover, when I received the respondent’s brief, I would send that over as well.  This is a huge benefit, as it gives him the heads up as to their argument before he writes his brief, and allows him to deal with their points in advance.

The point of this tale is that we, lawyers on the same side of the fence, need to extend a hand to each other as a matter of professional courtesy and to help our clients.  We need each other.  We do better when we help each other.  But when help becomes a one way street, the favor bank goes bankrupt.  This is a terrible shame.  If you owe me a favor and won’t repay, then I’m going to remember it and adjust my favors accordingly. 

I hate to do this, and don’t plan to stop helping others.  But we need to remember about the favor bank, and stop the selfishness.  No more one way streets.  And to those kids who think that the world owes them a hand, but they have no obligation to repay the favor, you’re going to find out how difficult survival in the courthouse can be when you mistakenly think that you’re the center of the universe.  If you can’t help others for the right reason, then chalk it up to a debt that’s come due.  But do it, and do it right.

Isn’t One Murderer Enough?

Adam Liptak raised the issue of the uniquely American felony murder rule in this New York Times piece.  Since he writes for public consumption, he framed the problem in terms of why a guy who let another guy borrow a car to commit a felony should be convicted for murder.  It seems that in the course of a burglary of a pot dealer, the guy who borrowed the car killed the dealer’s daughter.

This isn’t your typical felony murder scenario.  In Liptak’s story, the car lender was nowhere in sight when the felony, no less the murder, went down.  Moreover, he was in position to affect what happened at the crime.  He loaned a car, and the implication is that he knew that the car was being borrowed to go commit a crime.  Certainly not a good thing, but how bad is the question.

The argument against the lender was simple:


A prosecutor explained the theory to the jury at Mr. Holle’s trial in Pensacola in 2004. “No car, no crime,” said the prosecutor, David Rimmer. “No car, no consequences. No car, no murder.”

Sounds good on the surface.  But the same could be said for air or food.  No air to breath, no crime.  No food to eat, no crime.  I could go on, but the point is clear.  The problem is one of intent and proportionality.  The person who facilitates a felony is not a hero.  Indeed, he’s a criminal.  But is he a murderer?

Still, victims groups and prosecutors want to make as many people responsible for murder as possible.  The reason is clear.  If there is a deterrent effect, then the broader you spread the pain, the more effective the deterrence.  But deterrence is only one aspect of criminal justice.  When the crime is dissociated from the intent and act, then it makes the law absurd.  This attenuation makes it impossible to for deterrence to work, unless the message is never facilitate any offense and then you don’t have to worry about it.

Liptak omits from his article the necessary component that the murder be a foreseeable consequence.  It’s not a major omission, since courts routinely leap over this because they can always find some rhetorical view that makes it foreseeable.  To a large extent, it’s true.  But foreseeability isn’t the same thing as intent.  We can imagine a lot of different things happening, but that doesn’t mean we want (or have any say) in them happening.

So here’s the problem.  What’s wrong with traditional murder charges, without the felony murder rule, for the prosecution of a homicide?  Each player suffers the consequences justified by his conduct and mens rea.  To the extent that a person has broken the law, he is charged with the offense that be proven.  What’s the need for the shortcut that circumvents all traditional purposes to the creation of crimes?

The guy who killed the pot dealer’s daughter gets tried for his conduct.  Murder.  A crime was committed and a perpetrator was caught, tried and punished.  Isn’t this enough?  This is the person who, whether intentionally or with conscious disregard, killed a person.  We already have laws that make this a crime, and those laws are pretty clear and effective. 

As for the guy who loaned a car to commit a burglary, he suffers the consequences of his conduct too.  It just isn’t murder. 

The Price of Fame

Sometimes it pays to check your spam.  I came across an email from the ABA in there, from a fellow named Howard Kaplan.  He does something for the ABA, though he never tells me what  it is.  I could have probably looked at the  ABA Journal website to find out, but it wasn’t important enough to take the few second to do.

But his email had some promise.  It seems that there’s yet another contest in offing from the ABA.  This time, it sounds important, the 2008 Silver Gavel Awards.  These awards“recognize outstanding efforts to foster the American public’s understanding of law, legal institutions, and the role of law in government, society and culture.”  Well, now we’re talking business.  This is no Beauty Pageant.  This is hardcore.  And there’s nothing I want to do more than foster the public’s understanding of law, for better or worse.

The email goes on to say why they invite applicants for this year’s 51st annual award.  51 years?  Why, that’s older than most of my clothing, and all of my shoes, so it’s got some age to it (meaning gravitas, since things don’t last that long if they don’t count for anything).  But what’s with this “invite applicants?” 

Here’s my first issue.  If you have to apply for an honor, then it isn’t an honor.  It’s like children screaming “look at me, look at me” in order to be the big kahuna.  One might say that by inviting someone to apply, they’ve already made the effort and now turn it over to the “applicant” to choose the piece that she feels best reflects his work.  While a little too facile for a pseudo-cynic like me, I might be willing to accept this explanation but for one thing.  And that brings me to point number 2.

The New ABA Motto:  “Defending Liberty, Pursuing Justice, Making a Buck Wherever It Can.”

That’s right.  Not only do you have to apply for the Award, but you have to PAY to apply.  From the email,  “The entry fee is $75, except for Television News, which is $125.”  Entry fee.  Sigh (this is the third time I’ve sighed in a post in two days).  So this is what it comes down to.  Entry fees.

Now some will say, “You cheap bastard.  Pay the fee, it won’t break you.”  True, it won’t.  But pay to be considered for an award?  There’s the rub.

Now I can understand why they make television news pay (and pay more, I might add).  It’s a profit-making venture.  They win an award and get to promote it to show how legitimate and significant their show is.  They they can charge more for commercial time and make more money.  It’s an investment.

But blawgs aren’t money-makers.  This is for love, and as the Beatles told me, “your love doesn’t pay my bills.”  I can’t monetize their award any more than I can monetize this blawg.  Nobody reads Simple Justice because of an award; they read because there’s something they feel like reading.  And the minutes they stop feeling that way, they split.  It’s the nature of the beast, and it works just fine for me.

So, to my new email pal Howard, if you see something here that you think ought to get a 2008 Silver Gavel Award, send it on over.  But don’t wait by the mailbox for my check, because it’s not coming.  I don’t pay for the glory of applying for Awards.  It’s not the amount, but the idea.  The price of fame with the ABA is just too high for me.

Simple Justice Is Just Average Ugly

Having made a sufficient stink around the blawgosphere about the pending ABA Beauty Pageant, to the point where  Walter Olson is even posting about it on his Point of Law blawg (where he’s willing to make snide remarks in order to insulate his  Overlawyered blawg, which is in 1st place in the “Corporate Teet” category [I hope he’s got a sense of humor]).

As my critics suggested, actually tripped all over themselves to be the first to scream, when it comes to a beauty pageant, we ugly. 


U – G – L – Y, You ain’t got no alibi, You UGLY!


Yes, it’s true.  Simple Justice is currently in 5th place and falling fast, behind  Blond Ambition Justice.  It’s not like I don’t understand.  I mean, why would anybody want to read breaking news or cutting-edge commentary when you could read about behavioral issues with children on shopping trips.  Sigh.

So there you have it.  I feel like the Bruno Magli shoes of the practical blawgosphere.  I hope you’re all happy now.

Turn On, Tune In, Drop Out at Harvard

Orin Kerr at  Volokh alerts us to a great new opportunity.  None other than Harvard Law School (known as HLS to those who consider Yale Law School to be a sinkhole for the great unwashed) is initiating a program to get “practicing lawyers,” a somewhat vague yet undefined description, to come teach.

Harvard Law School, oops HLS, Dean Elena Kagan has announced in the  Harvard Law Record (I guess that should be HLR if I want to be consistent) a Visiting Assistant Professor program that will seek real lawyers to come to Harvard for 2 years in order to create credentials to enable them to put themselves in the academic job market.

The program is as yet unnamed.  According to Dean Kagan:


The program does not yet have a formal name, but Kagan noted with a laugh that “we usually name programs when someone has given money€¦so if someone wanted to donate to the program we would be happy to come up with a name.”

I bet she laughed when she said that, all the way to the bank.  However, since it’s hard to promote such an innovative program when it has no name, and since no one has as yet stepped forward to put their money on the polished mahogany table, I will call it the Greenfield Visiting Real Lawyer Program.  I know.  I just have a gift with names.

So there you have it, all you lawyers in the trenches who have pondered the question of how to get your hands on some of those young minds at Harvard La . . ., sorry, HLS.  The door’s been thrown wide open, and all you need do is trot on through.

But here’s the nagging question for me.  So you go to Harvard for a couple of years, and then what?   Whatever practice you had when packed your bags is long gone.  You know how those crazy clients expect their lawyer to be there when they get their one phone call.  After two years, what do you have left?


By the end of the program, members should be prepared to go on the general academic market. “We like to think we’re good mentors,” said Kagan, explaining that senior faculty consult with fellows on articles they write and go through a moot “job talk” that fellows use to interview for faculty positions at other schools.

So this is an on-the-job training program?  And you go from a real practicing lawyer to a “fellow”?  Aren’t “fellows” the ones who work their butts off and get paid slightly less than a rookie public defender in the hope that somebody offers them a real job.  Wait, that’s pretty much what Dean Kagan said, isn’t it.

Still, for anyone who missed the boat on the first go-round by leaving law school and actually practicing law, this is your way to get your foot in the door in legal academia, where actual experience is frowned upon by those scholarly types who believe it is better to write with big words than have a clue what they’re writing about. 

So dust off that Curriculum Vitae (that’s scholar-talk for resume) and grab your old letterman cardigan.  There’s a place for you in Cambridge, Massachusetts.  Unfortunately, you won’t be able to room with Norm Pattis, because he’s not going.

Major Defects Discovered in Prestigious SUVs

And they say blogs don’t report news. Hah!  Take this, Bill Keller!

I have discovered 3 major defects in Lincoln Navigators and Cadillac Escalades.  That’s right, you’re reading it here for the first time.  This is an exclusive.  You’re not going to find this anywhere else.

First defect is the steering.  It’s broke, and broke bad.  You see, neither of these two very expensive vehicles steer properly, as is clearly seen by the fact that they cannot be kept in their lanes.  This is particularly problematic when going around curves, where both SUVs are invariably over the double yellow lines and halfway into the lane of on-coming traffic.

The second defect is the turn signal.  Apparently, the blinkers don’t work at all on either vehicle.  My investigative reporting has failed to find a single individual who has ever seen a turn signal engaged on either of these two very large, expensive cars.

And finally, there is a very serious problem with the brakes, although this problem appears intermittent.  The brakes on these vehicles appears to work some of the time, but invariably fails when the SUVs come to stop signs, at which time they blow through at breakneck speed.  I can only imagine the horror on the faces of Escalade and Navigator drivers as their massive vehicles cause small hybrids to jam on their brakes or swerve off the road to avoid collision.

So far, now word from either Lincoln or Cadillac about the massive vehicle recalls that will no doubt be coming any day.  But stay tuned, I’ll keep you posted.