Author Archives: SHG

Too Much Applause For Aimless Rambling

There’s a natural tendency to be part of the choir.  We want to be positive, praise success and support those with whom we share the bond of the “good fight.”  But we need to be cautious about applauding things that are undeserving to avoid sending the wrong message.  Such is my issue with Mark Bennett’s post, Winning Despite Yourself.

In an effort to avoid any mention of a lawyer who has never lost a criminal case, and thus upset alumni of the modestly-name Trial Lawyers College, the underlying praise was for winning a case by the mechanism of aimless rambling.  Let me be blunt:  I do not endorse aimless rambling as a trial strategy.

Nor, prior to this post and its comments, have I ever heard anyone else endorse aimless rambling as a trial strategy.  So what gives? 

As one commenter noted (in slightly different language), if you can’t dazzle them with brilliance, baffle them with bullshit.  It’s a cute phrase, but not exactly a crowning glory.  While red herrings and smoke and mirrors has a place in our repertoire, it is hardly the product of aimlessness.  When properly used, it diverts attention from damning evidence and seeks to confuse the critical point.  It’s an art.

Bennett applauds the fact of the win, notwithstanding some critical views of the lawyer, and reminds us that it’s better to win despite a less than stellar performance than to lose with panache.  Point well taken.  Our job is not feel good about our work when the verdict comes in, but to win the case for our client.  We must never take our eye off the ball.

And regardless of how good or bad we do, the lawyer gets credit for the win, and takes the weight for the loss.  But this isn’t about acknowledging the victory.  That much is a given.  This is about applauding the effort in our post mortem.  If we blind ourselves from those things we could have done better merely because we won, we gain nothing from the experience except a notch on our gun.

Moreover, do we really want to applaud the win in itself?  We aren’t pro-criminal, and sometimes our interests as members of society are well-served by a defendant being convicted.  Mind you, that’s not our concern when we are the lawyers, but when we are bystanders, we aren’t any different than anyone else who wants a society where we are all safe from violence, free from fraud and secure in our homes. 

So while it may be an understandable reaction for criminal defense lawyers to automatically fall on the side of an acquittal, that doesn’t raise the quality of representation when it falls short.  We should applaud a job well done, and recognize (and admit) a job done less than well.  Concealing it behind cute phrases, simply because the verdict was favorable, doesn’t make the representation any better or the lawyer’s aimless rambling a strategy that we want to emulate.

Biglaw: Respect is a Two-Way Street

Carolyn Elefant of  MyShingle fame takes me to task for undermining her 5 years of effort to show Biglaw that solo practitioners aren’t losers.


[W]hy are you so down on large firm lawyers? I’ve spent the past five years at MyShingle trying to fight against Biglaw attorneys’ stereotyped view of solos as hapless losers who couldn’t find a job. If we solos want to be treated with respect, then we should lead by example, and not engage in stereotyping or name calling large firm lawyers either. In my experience, there’s good and bad in every segment of the profession.

My initial reaction was “who cares” what Biglaw thinks.  But when Carolyn writes something, it’s worth thinking about.  So I did.

It dawned on me that this is really a two-part problem.  The relationship between Biglaw and solos is different for criminal defense lawyers than it is for civil lawyers.  Criminal defense lawyers are almost always small firm or solo lawyers.  Yes, Biglaw always has a couple of former AUSAs who are there to show accused CEOs how to find their way into jail cells, but they aren’t really criminal defense lawyers.  They are part of the “full service” law firm show that Biglaw can afford to put on.  Some firms also have their Biglaw partners doing some real criminal defense stuff under the Criminal Justice Act to prove their commitment to the Constitution.  Admirable, but still not the same as they aren’t taking calls from street guys who need an abogado.

Civil practice is different, especially civil litigation.  They do engage Biglaw in the daily course of their work, and they do care that Biglaw looks down on them like “hapless losers,” as Carolyn elegantly puts it.  Indeed, the Biglaw strategy when the Goliaths are litigating against the Davids is to paper them to death, the theory being that by dumping on the solos, volume always prevails.  Not only is this strategy cynical, but it’s effective.  Biglaw clients have deep pockets.  Solo’s clients only have the facts and law on their side, and we all know how little that’s worth.

Contrary to belief, this is not a failure to communicate.  It’s a clash of cultures.  Biglaw needs to believe that it reflects the virtues of the higher order of professionalism, or else it would be impossible to get all those people to forfeit their lives for a paycheck.  Solos believe that they are every bit as competent and professional, lacking only the deep-pocketed clients to finance a scorched earth strategy. 

So is Carolyn right, that my denigrating some of the Biglaw sacred cows harms the cause of solos?  Well, I refuse to yield on the subject of paying associates outrageous salaries and bonuses in the quest of corralling the next big rainmaker.  But she may have something when she argues that there is good and bad in every segment of the profession.  After all, I post generically, and it would be too long and boring to run through every lawyer in New York to discuss the personal virtues of each.  Not that I would even know anything about them.

But I find Carolyn persuasive that my harping on Biglaw’s negatives does little to bring the profession together.  Given how all of us are viewed as societal pariahs, the profession would certainly benefit from a little greater cohesiveness, and perhaps even some thoughtful cooperation to start trying to avoid the knee-jerk antagonistic reactions to all disputes.  Hey, we might even get real people to start believing that lawyers can be useful instead of an instrument of misery.  Some of us actually think that we can help people, if we can just be a little more reasonable.

But I respond to Carolyn’s challenge with one of my own.  Respect is a two-way street.  Why is it that we, the small firms and solos that make up the bulk of the legal profession, should go to Biglaw on bended knee and ask for their approval? 

It seems that this view betrays a bias that, perhaps, Biglaw really is better, and so we must go to them, hat in hand.  At minimum, it suggests that we need them more than they need us.  After all, there aren’t too many Biglaw blawgs trying to foster respect with solos.

Carolyn’s blawg is dedicated to the proposition that small and solo practice offers a viable alternative to the high-pressure, endless hours and serf-like treatment of lawyers in Biglaw.  She provides a roadmap to success and happiness for the solo practitioner, including achieving financial success through the marketing of one’s legal services, when they hang out their shingle.  To do this, Carolyn has to get Biglaw folks to get over their bias against solos, since nobody wants to be one of those “hapless losers” who can’t get hired by, or cut it in, Biglaw.

Carolyn offers a huge service to that segment of the bar.  In fact, I doubt they deserve her help.  While solos have their issues too, few of us regret our choice (and for many it was indeed a choice) to eschew Biglaw for a life where we control our time and fate.  But in deference to her efforts, I will do my utmost to tone down any perceived denigration of Biglaw and foster a more cooperative spirit.  And I’ll sit here and wait for them to do the same. 

If they are as smart as they think they are, they will worry less about what a hapless solo like me has to say and spend more time over at  MyShingle learning that solos can be every bit as professional, intelligent and effective as Biglaw, but that we get to enjoy a lifestyle that they can only dream about.

Addendum:  I just got word that Thacher Proffitt & Wood has announced that they were laying off 50 associates.  In keeping my promise to Carolyn to be kinder and gentler to Biglaw, let me say I feel your pain. 

Felder Feels For “Challenged” Judge (plus Another!)

Raoul Lionel Felder still isn’t on the same page as the rest of the Commission on Judicial Conduct.  This time, the Chairman’s issue was over-empathy, according to the New York Lawyer.


“We cannot claim to be a civilized and caring society, and yet, in our actions, not enfold into our judgments, where pertinent, the terrible burdens that others must bear in order to traverse the landscape of life,”

Now this is the sort of statement that would warm the heart of any defense lawyer, since it so dearly reflects our concern for the human condition.  But Raoul was a bit misguided in the target of his concern.  You see, he was writing about non-lawyer Valatie Village and Kinderhook Town Justice Edward J. Williams, who was before the Commission after four prior public disciplinary actions, this time for engaging in ex parte communications with a state trooper on a case before him.

Raoul’s chairmanship of the Commission has been rocky from the start.  He is, of course, a well-known flamboyant New York City matrimonial lawyer (who occasionally claims to be a criminal defense lawyer as well, when needed to justify a TV appearance).  And the Commission has shown its tendency to  beat up on non-lawyer Village Justice, because they’re such easier targets than Supremes.  But that doesn’t mean that they don’t deserve the discipline.

Here, Chairman Felder complains that the rest of his Commission refuses take into account the “human condition” when doing its job.  Justice Williams, you see, is “a quadriplegic facing ‘often insurmountable, sometimes humiliating’ challenges in daily life.”  What did the others think?


The rest of the commission, in a footnote to the majority decision released yesterday, found that Mr. Felder’s concurring opinion “inappropriately relies on matters not in the record regarding Judge Williams’ personal life.”

In other words, even Judge Williams knew better than to argue that his quadriplegia somehow made him engage in ex parte communications. 

There was one dissenter to the Commission’s decision to censure Judge Williams, member Richard Emory.  No, he didn’t “share his pain.”  To the contrary, he voted for removal, based upon the fact that this was the fifth time the Commission sustained charges against Judge Williams.  As for his disability, Emory found that Williams’ decision not to play the disability card was the judge’s most redeeming virtue.  “Regrettably, Mr. Felder has inappropriately chosen to play that card for him.”

Lest we forget about the bottom line while pondering Raoul’s concern for the human condition, the guy is a judge who seems to never learn a lesson about how behave.  We’re all sorry that he’s a quad.  We’re sorry that anybody is a quad.  But a judge is still a judge, even if he’s a quad, and there’s simply no connection between being a quadriplegic and having ex parte’s with cops.

The concept was summed up best by the Commission’s administrator, Bob Tembeckjian:

“It made no difference to the victims of the judge’s misconduct that he is in a wheelchair,” Mr. Tembeckjian said. “This case was simply about the judge’s ethical, not physical, limitations.”

While one can well admire Raoul’s fully developed sense of empathy for Judge Williams, one would hope that he would have a similarly well developed sense of concern for Judge Williams’ victims.

ADDENDUM:  And then there’s Robert Restaino, the Niagra Falls Judge who held everybody in contempt and actually jailed 46 people when a cellphone rang in his courtroom.  And again, Chairman Raoul’s sole dissent, accepting Restaino’s argument that he had personal problems that caused him to “snap”.  Uh, and does the good judge feel sorry for the defendants he locked up who might have had “personal problems” because he snapped?

I am informed by a reliable source that Restaino, contrary to Raoul’s views, was a major hump, and no one will be sorry to see him off the bench.  Except Raoul.

More on the Value of Indigent Defense

With a hat tip to Newsday letter writer (scroll down to the second letter), attorney Jeffrey Myles Klein, comes this small bit of information that says so much about the relative worth of criminal defense and our society’s commitment to Gideon.

Suffolk County, New York, is a pretty wealthy area, but also an area burdened with ridiculously high taxes (much like my very own, beloved Nassau County).  Still, there are certain obligations that a government undertakes in this country.  These are American obligations, every bit as real and important as the ones young men and women die for in foreign lands.  But here at home, we can’t seem to find them worthy enough for our sacrifice.

Suffolk County Executive Steve Levy has  vetoed from the budget $300,000 earmarked for raises for attorneys in the Legal Aid Society.  After all, they’re lawyers for criminals.  Who cares?  Seriously.  Who cares?  What will the employees of the Legal Aid Society do if they can’t pay the rent or feed their kids.  Who cares?  Let them go to work for a real law firm and make the big bucks, like all the other attorneys.  As we can all attest.

And this is why I have  issues with paying first year associates the big bucks.  There are people doing the  unpleasant work that society is required to do, and the worth of their efforts is demonstrated in a veto.  They aren’t in the job to get rich, and that sure isn’t going to happen under any circumstance, but they should be paid enough to survive in the ordinary course.  Where’s a  Judy Kaye op-ed when you need one?

Not that this bears any direct nexus, but it does effectively provide the needed juxtaposition for Levy’s veto:  Simultaneous with the veto of LAS raises comes the allocation of more than $300,000 for the lump sum payout for a single Suffolk County Police Officer.  Sure, he’s entitled to the payout and any other contractual benefits provided by the collective bargaining agreement.  And lest any cops’ wife opine, “it’s a very hard job.”  As if the Legal Aid Society lawyers are hanging out at their desks all day eating bon bons and watching their stock portfolios move downward.

Greybear wrote a comment here about how money isn’t the primary motivator for the type of person inclined to being a legal aid lawyer.  Fully agreed.  But their children still want to eat.  Every single day.  These are well-educated, hard-working lawyers who fulfill a necessary mission in a criminal justice system that would stop dead without them.  Should they personally have to suffer for society’s disdain for their work?

A Picture Is Worth A Conviction

Anne Reed provides yet another stunning post at Deliberations, this time addressing the  impact of gruesome crime photographs on the likelihood of conviction.


“Jurors presented with gruesome evidence, such as descriptions or images of torture and mutilation, are up to five times more likely to convict a defendant than jurors not privy to such evidence,” a recent press release about his work says.

While it comes as no surprise that photos of the body inflame a juror’s passion, the efforts to keep these horrific photographs from the eyes of the jury almost always fall on deaf ears.  It may because they similarly inflame the judge (who’s usually only human), or it may be the good faith belief that the defendant should not be allowed to insulate himself from the evidence of the crime by precluding the jury from seeing what truly happened.

The problem, of course, is that these gruesome photographs and vivid descriptions of horrible images have nothing to do with who committed the crime.  There is seldom any argument that the crime occurred, or that it was indeed horrific.  Rather, the issue is whether the defendant is the person who committed this terrible crime.

The line between the issues gets blurred to the point that the jury, angered beyond reason by the nature of the terrible deed and feeling the normal human compulsion to make someone pay for this crime, takes it out on the defendant.  After all, he is the one the police and the prosecutor say did it.  He is the only one they can take it out on.  And somebody has to pay.

While we have long been constrained to argue the obvious without anything beyond anecdotal support, Anne now brings us a study with some hard data to show that the impact of showing a jury these gruesome photos is to increase the possibility of a wrongful conviction fivefold.  Since the photographs provide no material evidence that the defendant was the perpetrator of the crime, but will nonetheless increase the likelihood of conviction so substantially, it makes clear that the use of these pictures serves to substantially improve the chances of conviction for reasons entirely unrelated to evidence that the defendant committed the crime.

Maybe, particularly in light of the ongoing revelations about the wrongful convictions of innocents as shown by subsequent DNA testing, just maybe a court will consider the possibility that putting horrible photographs of an undisputed issue in front of a jury is wrong.  Kudos to Anne for another incredibly helpful find.

Liptak’s Redemption – Judges Giving Away Money

Last week, I was  pretty hard on Adam Liptak for his exceptionally vapid yet inflammatory piece on a non-existent debate on the efficacy of the death penalty.  Fortunately for society, his attempt to create an issue was ignored in all quarters.

This week, however, Liptak redeems himself with  a fascinating piece, and actually brings some substance to his writing, about the use of left-over class action monies by district court judges.  The lesson here is that Adam should stick to topics with which he is more familiar, and then he does a fine job.  But for now, he’s out of the dog house.

Has anyone wondered what becomes of those millions of dollars put into a fund by Mel Weiss, after he’s already gotten his share of the booty, for the benefit of the class?  It seems that plenty of people ignore the class action claim form, likely under the belief that the $12.58 isn’t worth the 5 hours it will take to fill out the forms, collect the paperwork from 12 years ago and ship it all off to the administrator with the promise of hearing something, maybe, eventually.


Judges all over the country have gotten into the business of doling out leftover class-action settlement money, sometimes to organizations only tangentially related to the subject of the lawsuit.

Judges are turning into grant administrators, and some of them are starting to enjoy it.

Well, this certainly opens up a new line of questioning during the Senate hearings.  But this gives rise to some very interesting issues.  Very interesting indeed.  Let’s start at the top.  Who’s money is this? 

The funds have been taken away from the bad guy, so it can’t be given back even if left unclaimed.  The claimants haven’t come forward to take it, so the court can’t distribute it amongst the unknown class members.  But there are the known class members, the named plaintiffs.  And there is the Public Fisc.  And then there are the good causes.  The favored use is for the judge to distribute the excess funds to “good causes.”


Class-action lawyers call these creative uses of settlement money “cy pres,” from the French expression “cy pres comme possible,” or “as near as possible.” They borrowed the term from the law of charitable trusts. If, say, a charity that was specified in a will no longer exists, the law sometimes allows the estate’s money to be used for a similar cause under the cy pres doctrine.

And what’s wrong with judges taking money from bad guys and giving it to good causes?  Plenty.  First, this was not the purpose for which the law authorized the funds to be taken.  When we disconnect the remedy from the right, courts are left without their legitimacy and are exercising naked power.  Courts should not be allowed to do this.  It’s not enough that the bad guy has been punished.  There has to be a connection between the money taken and where it ends up.  Government can’t just take money away from people (or entities) and then gift it away at the whim of the court.  At least not with a straight face.

Distributing the excess funds amongst the known plaintiffs/claimants seems to reconnect the remedy with the right (or wrong, if you prefer).  But this solution has been rejected because it would “provide a windfall to the relatively few [individuals] who had made claims.”

So instead, the solution was for a United States District Judge to hand-pick causes, law schools, hospitals and the like to receive the benefit. 

This strikes me as not merely wrong, but insane.  Initially, why would it be a “windfall” to give the damages to the individuals who were injured?  If it’s because their injuries didn’t merit the amount used to fund the class payout, that’s none of the court’s business.  It’s a settlement fund.  The defendant elected to give up the money to the class, and the class consists of whoever decided to make a claim.  It’s the claimants money.  Every penny of it (except Mel’s piece).  If it is a windfall, so what?  It’s their windfall, not the judge’s to dole out like a Saudi prince.

As Professor Issacharoff, the main author of the American Law Institute draft on the subject says, “I don’t care how much good you want to do. Do it with your own money, not someone else’s money.”  It doesn’t matter that the causes are good, or places where “we” like the money to go.  It matter that it’s not the judge’s to give.

Even to those of us who are charitably minded, if the settlement was with a gun manufacturer, would we be thrilled with the judge giving millions to the NRA for handgun education?  So don’t let the end blind you from the means. 


“You’re taking money from someone who does not deserve to have it — the defendant — and you’re putting it to a public good,” said Peter F. Langrock, a Vermont lawyer who spoke with pride about using money from the settlement of an environmental class-action suit in Alaska to finance a high school science program.

And were the Vermont school district taxpayers harmed.  What about my school district’s taxpayers?  They were certainly “harmed” to the same extent, if one is going to try to provide some logical nexus for the handout.  Just because someone likes the end result doesn’t make it legitimate.

The worst part about this scheme is that lawyers stand outside the courtroom door with hats in hand for their client causes.  There is little as unseemly than judges being courted by their alma mater for a handout.  Since when is it in a federal judge’s job description to decide the worthiness of charitable causes with other people’s money?  This is scandalous.


But the new judicial role does not fit well with the old one. “It is,” Professor Issacharoff said, “an invitation to wild corruption of the judicial process.”

You bet.  And a begrudging tip of the hat to Adam Liptak from outing this situation.  Maybe I’ve been too hard on him.

You Can’t Possibly Lose

When I hear a judge allocute a defendant, I always cringe.  Allocution is what New York lawyers call the spiel given to a defendant before taking a plea.  It is a speech, with the occasional “yes” from the defendant, about all the rights afforded him or her by our laws and Constitution, diligently protected by our courts. It starts with the right not to be convicted unless 12 people agree to the right to present a defense, and all the rights in between.  Standing there, it sounds like a lot of rights.

I cringe because the allocution makes it sound like it’s impossible to lose.  Seriously, when I hear the judge run down the laundry list of rights, it sounds so overwhelmingly one-sided that I never understand why a defendant cops a plea after hearing it.  If it were me, I would say, “Whoa, ya Hona, I changed my mind.  I want all them rights.  Ain’t nobody gonna convict me with all those rights on my side.”  Of course, it doesn’t quite work out that way most of the time.

With this same sense of wonder, I read  this note (pdf) in the Georgetown Law Review by 3L Martin A. Hewitt.  The gist of it is about compulsory process and its relationship with Crawford v. Washington.  In the introduction, Hewitt runs through the gamut of constitutional protections that are due each defendant.

It is an excellent brief, appropriately notated, recitation of the basic rights afforded by the Constitution.  Pity poor Mr. Hewitt, who apparently believes too much.  And people tell me that I’m too negative about law reviews.


For instance, evidence obtained through an unconstitutional search and seizure may not be admitted against him; he may not be forced to testify against himself; the government must disclose to him favorable material evidence prior to trial; and certain statements may not be admitted against him unless he has an opportunity to cross-examine the speaker.

Well, those are the rules, right?  I certainly can’t fault Mr. Hewitt for his correct statement of the defendant’s rights.  Except that his statement of the black letter law omits a few of the exceptions, and the common problems that seem to invariably get in the way of things working out as clearly as he would have it.

But the point of his note is to raise compulsory process as an underused right in the Constitution.  Specifically, Mr. Hewitt points out that it is not merely the right to subpoena witnesses, but part of the right to present a defense.  It is a constitutional entitlement to the defense “that relevant evidence should generally be admissible absent strong reasons for its exclusion.“

I get the sense that Mr. Hewitt has never had the pleasure of walking up 17 flights in a public housing project where the elevators haven’t worked since the blackout of ’77, each landing smeared with urine and feces, to find a man known only by his nickname, “El Gordo,” who sometimes stays at his baby-mama’s apartment, also used as a stash house. 

What does Mr. Hewitt believe runs through the mind of El Gordo when you explain to him that coming forward to tell the truth about his “business” will allow your innocent client to go free?  Noting the glock in his belt, does Mr. Hewitt recognize the impact of a single piece of paper with the word “subpoena” on it on El Gordo?  Will he be sufficiently afraid of possible contempt adjudication, plus a $50 fine?

So when you the judge asks if the defense has any witnesses, who will you call before the jury?  Inexplicably, El Gordo has not made it down to court.  We have our defendant, grasping our arm so hard it hurts, and whispering that they are liars.  Liars!  But our client has 3 prior felonies, and the judge has already ruled that the prosecution can question him about them since “he has placed his own interests above that of society,” even though they have no bearing on credibility per se. 

But let’s indulge Mr. Hewitt’s notion that compulsory process is a powerful right afforded the defense.  El Gordo is in custody, and he’s produced at our trial.  We’ve got him there in the holding pens.  We can put him on the stand.  But do we?

What does El Gordo have to say?  That he’s a bad dude and our client is an angel?  What are the chances that El Gordo is going to take the fall, admit to new crimes to save our client from conviction?  El Gordo’s not talking to us.  His lawyer won’t let him.  Why should he?  Nothing good will come of it for El Gordo, who’s already in enough trouble trying to fight his own case. 

But he’s an unavailable witness, you say?  This allows us to put into evidence statements taken from El Gordo, right?  And who took those statements?  Well, the only person who could force El Gordo to talk was the cop who nabbed him.  Remarkably, there’s nothing exculpatory for our client in his carefully typewritten notes.  The original hand-written notes can’t be found.  No matter, since the cop says that they are exactly the same.  The cop says so.  Can you prove otherwise?

There is a reason, Mr. Hewitt, why compulsory process is an underused right.  It offers nothing of practical value in the trenches.  And there’s a reason why all those other rights sound so darn good yet do so darn little to save a criminal defendant.  The harsh reality is that they are observed in the breach.  There are a zillion exceptions that swallow every rule.  There is a judge who need only say, “nah”, and the right disappears. 

The trick to being a good lawyer is realizing when a gap appears, the kind that allows a right to actually be used to the defendant’s benefit.  It happens, and with surprising frequency if you’ve got your eyes open and know what you’re looking for.  But I wouldn’t counsel anyone to go to trial because he has the right to compulsory process.  El Gordo just isn’t that reliable.

It’s not that Mr. Hewitt didn’t write a fine note in a top-notch law review.  It just doesn’t have any practical application in the trenches.  If only courts would function the way law schools would have them function, law reviews would have relevance.  Unfortunately, they don’t.

Tasers Don’t Care If You’re Canadian

Not to  pile on to the poor. misbegotten taser.  Again.  But  3 more taser deaths in Canada in recent weeks.  This time, it was an agitated shopper.  The story is familiar.


Robert Knipstrom, 36, died in a hospital after two officers used pepper spray, a Taser and their batons to subdue the British Columbia resident. Police earlier said Knipstrom was extremely agitated, aggressive and combative with the two officers who responded.

If they use the words “extremely agitated, aggressive and combative,” does it serve to eliminate the need for any factual explanation of what he did to deserve death?  I know, I know.  That’s just the criminal defense lawyer talking.  I’m just not inclined to accept the police conclusory version in lieu of facts.  Go figure.

What do we learn from this?  That tasers in Canada are no more non-lethal than tasers in the United States.  I would say it has something to do with Canadian stamina, but one of the fellows was Polish coming off a plane in Toronto.  He didn’t even speak Canadian.  But he died like one.

In the past, we posted about the taser being somewhat less the benign weapon that it’s portrayed by police (and its makers) to be.  While it remains a better substitute than hot lead when the time comes that force is required, it clearly hasn’t been the safe, non-lethal weapon that it’s promoted to be.  It can, and does, kill.  Not all the time.  Not even most of the time.  But sometimes.  And if you happen to be that “sometimes” person, all the other times when it doesn’t cause death really won’t matter much to you (or your kids, for that matter).

But the issue really isn’t the taser itself.  The issue is the use of the taser at the drop of a hat.  Police officers, who obviously buy into the taser as a quick, easy fix for any problem that takes more than 30 seconds to resolve, so they can get back before the coffee cools down, need to grasp that a taser is a cure-all.  Resort to taser without provocation or justification has become the norm.  This is a very bad thing, and must be stopped.

The rule of thumb is that when a police officer issues a command, you obey immediately or get (and deserve) a good beating.  That’s the price for disobedience, and it’s their lot in life to teach the rest of us some manners.  But the club has given way to the taser.  It leaves no marks and is far less likely to cause repetitive stress injury to the officer.  Note that the offensive individual has neither threatened nor harmed anyone.  He has, however, committed the sin of disrespect.

And so, the police officer initiates the cure for a disobedient (which in police jargon is called “aggressive”) person.  Zaaaaap.  That’ll show ’em.  And how.  The cop has no intention of killing anyone.  It was just a lesson, and it was supposed to be harmless.  That’s what they said.  Oh my, what do we do now.  The guy’s dead!

While police departments love to have policies that are utterly ignored on the road and cited with impunity in the press, here’s one that might help us all out a bit.  Tasers should never be used except under situations where deadly force would be justified.  It the situation does not legitimately call for the use of deadly force, then there is no reason to use any force. 

Tasers are not benign.  Unless, Mr. Officer, you want to go home tonight with a dead body on your conscience, don’t use it.  Sure, that means that you will have to wait around much longer until the situation calms down.  It means you will have to think and perhaps even use your wits.  There may even be times that you will have to assess the situation like the taught you at the academy, and deliberate over how best to resolve the situation without the use of force.  But at least you won’t kill anybody.  At least not today.  And everybody gets to go home alive when it’s all over.

The Death of Writing

Dave Hoffman at  Concurring Opinions posts a video of a law student symbolically shooting his legal research memo.  In the video, he complains that it represents two week of his life, and it “killed him.”  Boo hoo.

If this young man was as good at writing as he is at shooting a piece of paper with a rifle from 20 feet away (I’m sure every shooter in Texas will be most impressed with this feat), I would urge his future clients to run, run like the wind, because you’re going to hang.

Writing is one of the most important things lawyers do.  We think clearly (if we learned anything in law school) and then communicate our clear thoughts in equally clear ways, whether written or oral.  In other words, we write.  If we can’t write, and write clearly and persuasively, we can’t do our job.  I don’t mean we can’t do it well.  I mean we can’t do it at all.

You cannot be a lawyer and not be capable of writing.  I know, there are plenty of lawyers around today who think otherwise, but they are wrong.  I am right.  They are not really lawyers if they cannot write.  They are pretenders, using whatever crafty means they can to avoid performing a basic function of their job.  They may think that they’ve found a way to circumvent their duty to their clients effectively, but they’re wrong.  They have left out a necessary component of their skillset.  We know it.  The judges know it.  You aren’t fooling anyone.

We’re not talking about writing something like this blawg.  This is for fun.  This is of-the-cuff, rambling, uncited and obviously unedited.  This is fluff stuff, barely worth the bandwidth.  This is neither put to the test of a thoroughly thought out, bullet proof expression of fully-conceived concepts, nor necessarily intended to persuade anyone of anything.  This is not legal writing.

Legal writing is what we do to save other people’s lives.  Legal writing is the written expression of our function as advocates, a necessary prong in the practice of law.  We cannot fulfill our function if we can’t write.

Having had the pleasure of reading law student briefs, most notably in moot court competitions where the briefs are supposed to be written by the “best and brightest” who anticipate  earning large sums of money the following year from Biglaw, I have to tell you that they’re poor.  Most aspire to be poor, in fact.  They stink.

How is it possible that students manage to make it to the third year of law school without learning how to write a sentence?  My guess is that educational theorists have managed to coddle the ability to write out of our educational system in their quest to make elevate students’ achievements by lowering the bar.  But that’s a discussion for another day.  The point is that students are graduating from law school without the facility to write.

Think about it this way, guys.  Writing is means of communicating all those brilliant ideas you think you have to another person.  It matters that you are able to write in complete sentences, and that they result in paragraphs with purpose, ending up in fully conceived ideas that serve to enlighten the reader.  Every word, sentence and paragraph should have a purpose. 

If you find it difficult to do this, work on it.  Work very hard on it.  It’s your job.  More importantly, your clients depend on you to be able to do this.  And no, writing isn’t about your feeling “good” about your work, but about someone else understanding what you’ve written and being persuaded by it.  That’s legal writing.

Children Dying in Adult Prisons

The New York Times has an  editorial about children who are placed in adult prisons being 36 times more likely to commit suicide than when held in youth facilities.  This is really a two part post, the first being the what and the second being the why.

A while back, I was doing legal commentary for MSNBC about the criminal justice system treating youths like adults.  My “opposition” focused, naturally, on the outcome.  The harm caused to another by a person under 18 is not different than the harm caused by an adult.  Dead is dead, of course.  So naturally, the rhetoric was about “child predators” that was designed to create an image of packs of amoral youths roaming the streets for prey.  My message lacked such a vivid image.

Even worse than adults, the sense was that when a youth has gone bad, there was no hope of redemption or rehabilitation.  While adults waited until later in life to become violent or vicious, suggesting they lived some portion of their lives as law-abiding citizens, the criminal youth were bred for crime.  There was no hope for them.

The image was fantasy, of course, crafted to create a new object of hatred so that we could all be afraid of something and pray at the alter of law enforcement to save us from this plague.  Without something to fear, how could we be controlled?  Even as the  Central Park Jogger theory of a band of roving predators fell apart, revealing the fiction that gave rise to this phenomenon, not to mention the newly coined term “wilding”, the myth had already become part of our culture.

But the offshoot of this perception of children as smaller, more evil versions of adults caused a systemic breakdown in the treatment of youth in the court system and correctional (there’s a misnomer for you) system.  Walls were broken down to keep youth and adults separate, since the system no longer felt any particular sympathy toward children, saw them as unworthy of special concern and refused to acknowledge what would happen to children in adult prison company.

So now we know.  Put children into adult prisons and the likelihood that they would rather kill themselves increases 36 times.  They don’t belong there.  The entire myth of the evil child predator is nothing more than another bogeyman set up to increase our fear and justify the excesses that we would never stand for if not for some extraordinarily effective political marketing.  And who cares if these children kill themselves anyway, right?

But why do they kill themselves?  According to the Times, it’s because they are mentally ill.


Why do so many young people kill themselves in jail? Probably because the majority of them suffer from mental illnesses that go untreated behind bars. Indeed, according to the study, as many as two-thirds of the young male detainees and three-quarters of young women detainees meet the criteria for one or more psychiatric disorders.

That youth who commit crimes, or that youth who commit suicide, are mentally ill seems almost too obvious for words.  Neither reflects the conduct of a sound and healthy mind.  It begs some questions, such as why no one noticed they suffered from psychiatric disorders before they did whatever they did to wind up in prison.  Where were the schools and teachers?  What went wrong at home that their parents saw nothing (this begs other questions, such as whether there were parents at home, or whether mommy was a junkie, etc.)?  Why didn’t the criminal defense lawyer identify a problem and deal with it?  This reflects a breakdown at every turn, leaving a child with mental illness to suffer.  None of this is acceptable.

But the mental illness answer to the suicide probability strikes me as overly facile.  It may well present the fertile ground for suicide, but doesn’t explain the trigger.  Was suicide the response to the generalized situation, or was there an event or series of events that caused such despair that suicide seemed like the only reasonable alternative?

This is where my view of life in prison may differ from the official view in which New York Times editorial board members want to believe.  These children in adult prisons are at the bottom of the food chain.  There is no nurturing (obviously) or mental health care, but there is plenty of violence and sexual abuse to go around.  Why mess with grown men when you can have a youth, physically immature and incapable of self-protection, whenever the “urge strikes.”  There ae bad people in prison, and they do bad things, especially when they are stuck in a place with only people of their own gender for as long as their minds can grasp.

There’s no one to protect children from adults in prison.  There is a society in there that develops like any other, with a pecking order based upon strength and alliances.  Survival requires people to learn how to navigate these most dangerous waters.  Children don’t stand a chance.  When we put them into adult prisons, we throw them to the sharks to be eaten alive.

While more vivid descriptions might help to convey the depth of despair this would cause a youth, I think the point is sufficiently clear.  This is a disastrous practice that is one of the most disgraceful lies that we abide in our acceptance of the belief that our system works.  The shame is that we don’t seem to care or think about it because it isn’t our child involved.  But these are still children.  Every child needs to be nurtured, and every child is capable of redemption.  They aren’t born bad.  We make them that way.