Author Archives: SHG

Another Modest Proposal

As the practice of criminal defense law faces increasing financial pressures, I find myself wondering when the Biglaw and corporate honchos are going to realize that there is a huge, untapped resource out there.  Don’t just pooh-pooh me right away. 

These are the people who think that first year associates (for the uninitiated, kids about 12 minutes out of law school) merit salaries of $160,000, plus $50,000 bonuses and special bonuses of another $60,000, not to mention a variety of perks that would embarrass Dennis Kozlowski.  They tend to be fairly smart individuals, and generally hard-working.  What they are not is competent.  They cannot yet do anything other than sit in a library and research, or look at documents for typos and erroneous citation form.

The hope of the Biglaw partnership is that they will, over time, develop into “their kind” of lawyer.  They will learn to do big deals.  They will learn to handle corporate clients.  They will not cringe at the sight of 10,000 pages of documents to be reviewed.  After all, somebody has to do this stuff, and they want someone who will do it the Biglaw way. 

These are slaves in the making, or as others prefer to call them, an investment in the future.  Few will ever become stars.  Few will become Biglaw partners.  Few will be rainmakers, the most important of all.  But to have your first choice of the best and the brightest in the hope that you’ll somehow snag that future star, they invest in law review editors from the best schools in the hope that they’ve gotten the cream of the crop.

To a fairly large extent, this tradition-laden approach is an example of being unable to see the forest through the trees.  I’ve gotten to know some Biglaw partners over the years.  Some are great lawyers.  Others, not so.  Some are real asses, still kvelling about their Harvard diploma as if to say that they’ve never done a damn thing worthwhile in the 30 years since. 

But they are so caught up in the mechanics that brought them to Biglaw that it has never dawned on them that maybe, just maybe, they have passed on some relatively cheap talent and missed a huge opportunity.  I know it’s heresy, but bear with me.

Consider that public defenders, coming out of law school, are thrown into the lion’s den, left to stand before a court determined to toss their client in jail.  They have little other than their wits to stop them.  A few months of this and they gain skills that no genius in the library is ever going to attain.  They are tested by fire.  Can your associate withstand say that?

Consider that the difference in intelligence between the best first year associate you’ve ever had and an effective young trial lawyer is meaningless.  The job is to represent clients, not compare IQ scores.  Not to mention, try giving one of your geniuses the Wisconsin Card Sorting Test.  I bet a young public defender will kick butt every time.

Consider that public defenders do all of this for a fraction of the salary you pay to your cite checker, and without a bonus.  They can pick up their own suits at the dry cleaners.  I know, they’re too busy to spend the time, but they will find a way.  That’s the difference.  These are men and women who learn how to do things rather than learn how to expect others to do things for them.

There is a world full of great lawyers out there.  It consists of public defenders, and prosecutors as well.  Then there are experienced lawyers who somehow prove their skill day after day, despite never having the experience of holding your briefcase.  While Biglaw throws obscene amounts of (other people’s) money in the hope of scarfing up a franchise quarterback in the draft, there are winning players all around you who would produce 100 times the worth of these inchoate stars.  You know this because they already do it.

Take of the blinders and take a hard look at the talent in the trenches.  Do you really think a room full of overpaid, overpuffed kids can compete?  I realize that this would require a fundamental shift in thinking, something that stodgy old lawfirms find nearly impossible to do, as well as an admission that many years of throwing good money after bad was just an incredibly foolish mistake (and thus demonstrative proof that you aren’t as smart as you want everyone to believe).  But you know I’m right.

One day, someone is going to be an innovator and “discover” a world of untapped, proven talent.  Their productivity and skill levels will dwarf anything that Biglaw has ever seen, and will enthrall their corporate sponsors by reducing costs while simultaneously increasing lawfirm profits, and most importantly, will bring a measure of legal success and effectiveness that Biglaw (in its secret inside moments knows) has rarely achieved. 

I just want it on record that I said so first.

What Becomes of the Innocents?

The New York Times has a follow-up story on the innocent men released from prison after many years of wrongful incarceration.  These are the DNA releasees, the ones who do 20 or more years for crimes they didn’t commit.  These are the ones who are exonerated.  Our beloved system’s grand mistakes.

A lot of effort is put into proving their innocence, as well it should be.  And the day they come out of prison, they are the media darlings and Kings for a Day.  What we didn’t know is what happened to them afterward.  The Times tries to give us a hint:


About one-third of them, like Mr. Ochoa, found ways to get a stable footing in the world. But about one-sixth of them, like Mr. Bibbins, found themselves back in prison or suffering from drug or alcohol addiction.  

About half, like Mr. Williams, had experiences somewhere between those extremes, drifting from job to job and leaning on their family, lawyers or friends for housing and other support.

This should come as no surprise.  What about 20 years in prison gives rise to the expectation of a sudden, miraculous transition back into society.  Innocent or guilty, it’s a tough road.  Bear in mind that many of the wrongly imprisoned weren’t Rhodes Scholars before they were accused, and aren’t likely to be much better situated on the way out the door.

Imagine what they put on the job application for experience.  It’s really not the sort of thing that makes a potential employer see your potential for future success.  Still, you would think that society would have some greater sympathy for people who suffered 20 years of imprisonment so that the rest of us could pretend that our system wasn’t totally full of crap.  After all, these are the people who fell on the sword (pushed may be a more appropriate description) so that the rest of us could sleep better at night.  

“It’s ridiculous,” said Vincent Moto, exonerated in 1996 of a rape conviction after serving almost nine years in Pennsylvania. “They have programs for drug dealers who get out of prison. They have programs for people who really do commit crimes. People get out and go in halfway houses and have all kinds of support. There are housing programs for them, job placement for them. But for the innocent, they have nothing.”

That’s not entirely accurate.  There is the money.  The imprisoned innocents receive a payment for the years they spent in jail because they system erred.  But while this may seem like a windfall to those who believe it could never happen to them, the compensation is not nearly as much of a given as many of us suppose.

Given the hodgepodge of state compensation laws, an exonerated prisoner’s chances of receiving any significant sum depend on the state where he was convicted and whether he can find a lawyer willing to litigate a difficult case. One man who served three years in California sued and won $7.9 million. Another, who had served 16 ½ years in Texas, filed a compensation claim and received $27,850.

If the outcome depends on the violation of civil rights, compensation may well not be in the cards.  The sad truth is that there was no civil rights abuse, overzealous prosecutors or police, concealment of evidence or conspiracy to deceive a jury.  The conviction was the product of an imprecise system, a system that is overly dependent on poor evidence such as eyewitness identification that produces poor results.  Who do you blame when a witness believes what he or she says, but is simply wrong?

All the speeches in the world about what a great legal system we have does nothing to bring comfort to the wrongly convicted.   It’s hard to imagine how a juror would feel knowing that he or she voted to put an innocent man in prison for 20 years, ignoring the defense pleas and going with the flow.  It seemed so right at the time, and everybody else agreed he was guilty too.  It’s so easy to be wrong when there are 11 other people agreeing with you.  No personal responsibility for the decision.

Yet, juries continue to be juries, assuming that the defendant must be guilty or the police wouldn’t have arrested him and the prosecutor wouldn’t have brought the case to trial. 

For those of us who have the pleasure of spending our days trying to persuade jurors that they should not convict our clients, we try not to think about what happens to the innocents who are convicted and imprisoned.  It would make our jobs impossible.  But I really want everyone else to think about them. 

If that’s not depressing enough, the ones in the Times article are the lucky ones.  They had DNA and the Innocence Project to free them.  What about the tens of thousand of others where there is no DNA to prove them innocent?  Just the same old mistake-fraught system that we pretend is the best there is.  We should send all of them a thank-you card for carrying sitting in prison so the rest of us can sleep at night, secure in the knowledge that justice has been done.

Crocs and the Law

The first time I ever saw a pair of Crocs was when a left coast client came into my office.  He wore bright yellow Crocs, plastic shoes with holes in them.  It’s impossible not to notice when a man wears bright yellow things on his feet.  I can’t be sure, but I believe that the word “fruitcake” passed my lips very softly as he walked into my office.

He had flown out from LA to be in court that morning in the Southern District of New York before none other than inchoate AG Michael Mukasey.  I explained in my calm, supportive way that Crocs would not have been my choice of footwear on a defendant for federal court.  At least not a defendant who was free.  He explained that they were all the rage in LA.  I welcomed him to New York.

My being about 5 minutes behind on all things fashion kept me from appreciating that I was in the presence of cutting edge shoes.  It didn’t really matter at that moment, since it was not the shoe, but the color, that drew my attention.  No one wears bright yellow if they don’t want everyone to notice.  This client was nothing if not a peacock.

So now the shareholders in the company that makes Crocs are suing. According to the Denver Post, there is a special name for these litigants:  Idiots.  Naturally,  Overlawyered loves this one, but they’re right on the money this time.  It’s difficult to conceive of a suit with less justification than this, blaming Crocs for having bought stock in a company that makes a very interesting and novel shoe that couldn’t sustain its meteoric stock climb.  It would have made more sense to sue every American who didn’t own a pair. 

What are they suing about?  Adjectives.

The suit cites statements like this one that Snyder made as Crocs released its second-quarter earnings this year: “We continue to witness robust demand for our expanded footwear collection.” I love that word “robust,” which I think entered the corporate lexicon about seven years ago, sounds really cool and means absolutely nothing.

They come in robust colors and are worn by robust people who drink robust coffee.  I love business jargon.  I noodle about it all the time.  I have a lot of friends who are investment banker types (an occupation my father neglected to mention to me as a youth, much to my detriment), and they all talk like this.  I never know what they are talking about.

These Crocs are quite remarkable shoes, and I say that as someone who has no particular feelings about footwear beyond the need for a decent fit (think bespoke).  How often do we get something truly novel, remarkably comfortable and so endearingly peculiar in appearance that they couldn’t be mistaken for anything else.  They are perfect for kids, for the beach or garden, and present an attitude of fashion carelessness that belies a heightened sense of function over form.  I think Crocs are here for good, provided they don’t suffer from fad burnout and take on the undeserved negative connotation that wearing them suggests a fashion statement.

I still maintain that Crocs are not the smart choice of footwear for a federal defendant going to court.  Maybe those detained, but not to show respect to the judge.  More importantly, they come in many colors.  No one should wear bright yellow unless his purpose is to draw everyone’s attention and implicitly suggest the need for a competency hearing. 

If You Really Want to Understand Autism

For those of us who care about children and recognize that autism presents one of the biggest issues, both legal as well as practical, facing education and society, we would desperately like to understand what it is to be autistic.  The problem, of course, is our inability to envision a world that doesn’t fit into our own paradigm.  By definition, our paradigm is “normal” and the world of the autistic isn’t.

But there is an  op-ed piece in Newsday today that expresses rather well the world of an autistic young man, who is clearly very articulate.  I can’t vouch that his experience is the same as anyone else’s with an autism spectrum diagnosis because I wouldn’t have a clue.  But having striven to both better understand what this is about, and to explain it in my terribly inept fashion from time to time, I found this piece compelling.

The writer immediately breaks through certain myths and assumptions about autism and learning disabilities.  He is intelligent and fully capable of expressing his ideas (That’s right, all autistic and learning disabled people are not subnormal intelligence).  Moreover, his metacognitive skills are highly developed, and he understands without apparent anger how he has been stigmatized all his life for being autistic.

If I have anything critical to say about this op-ed, it’s that it stops far too soon.  There is so much more I would like to know, even if it’s only one person’s experience and may not reflect the full spectrum of autistic people.  It’s better to gain some understanding than none.

Moreover, while we are making efforts to bring some clue about autism into the world of law enforcement and the law, and little by little inroads are being made, the world of autistic spectrum disorder is not going to wait for the rest of us to get with the program.  It is happening, and it’s happening at an amazing pace.  We can either ramp up our understanding all around or we’ll be “tsking” about the tragedies that should never have happened. 

Some of the tragedies will come from law enforcement’s inability to really comprehend what autistic children are all about .  After all, they can barely grasp the concept of deaf people, likely to be shot for not obeying the verbal commands of a scared and angry cop.  How then can we expect something as amorphous as autism to have a meaningful place on their radar?

But the consequence for the education and social utility of this huge number of children in society is at stake.  Do we ship them all off to some island where they won’t get in the way of “normal” people, or do we start acknowledging their existence and make the effort to subsume them into a society that doesn’t know how to deal with them or even who they are.  This is a great piece, and worth the minute of your time.

This One’s Gonna Be Ugly

Geoffrey Feiger is going to trial.  According to the indictment, he and his partner, Vernon Johnson funneled $127,000 into the John Edwards campaign.  Talk about a bad guy (and a waste of money).

But Feiger is a high-flying lawyer, and showboat who has drawn as much attention to himself as almost any man could handle.  Any man, this is, except Gerry Spence.  Now I’m  riffing off Norm on this, because of the Gerry Spence piece of this.  You see, Norm never writes the name “Gerry Spense” without including the phrase, “who boasts he’s never lost a criminal case.”  I laugh out loud every time I read this.

Gerry Spence is one of those larger than life characters.  He’s built a cult around him of lawyers who have become so captivated by his tales that he is the closest thing to a lawyer-God there is.  Others, like Norm (who I believe sat around the Gerry Spence campfire with his face covered in war paint) have fallen off the wagon.  Some people need heroes, larger-than-life beings who inspire them.  Gerry Spence is such a hero to many, but he unabashedly lets everyone know that he is the hero, the man who you should be inspired by.

Spence set up a world dedicated to himself in Wyoming.  It’s one of the few places big enough to fit his ego.  It’s also one of the few places where you can still wear a fringed cowboy-type jacket and not have people make fun of you.  Not that anyone would make fun of Gerry Spence, because he’s, well, Gerry Spence.

But can is there a Detroit Courtroom big enough for Gerry?  Remember, it’s not like he gets to have the whole courtroom for himself, either, as he’s got a client with no small ego of his own.  I envision Gerry and Geoffrey discussing how they plan to split up the relative ego space in the courtroom between them.  I see Gerry winning the lion’s share, because he is a bigger hero than Feiger.  Did I mention that he brags that he’s never lost a criminal case?

When this mutt of a trial begins, I can see talking heads trying to explain what’s going on in United States District Court judge Paul Borman’s courtroom.  Will any of them have the guts to talk about the clash of the titan egos?  This could be precious.

Bear in mind that Gerry Spence was the lawyer who represented Imelda Marcos, the steward of all footwear, in the Southern District of New York.  After the jury returned a verdict of not guilty, one was asked whether it was because of Gery Spence.  The response was it was despite Gerry Spence.  Ouch. 

Cases like this are the equivalent of soap operas for lawyers.  The players are so puffed up and self-important that we watch just to see them crash.  If all goes well, this could be one of the ugliest trials ever, edging out even the OJ1 trial (see, I already anticipate the Vegas trial with baited breath).  This case has all the makings of an Academy Award winner.  How cool is that!

Addendum:  I’ve been chastised by Jon Katz for spreading vicous gossip about Gerry Spence’s ego.  There are some (perhaps many) who believe that Gerry Spence is the best there is, and that what I view as ego is hard-earned self-worth.  Maybe he is.  Maybe Gerry Spence is the best criminal defense lawyer alive today.  Maybe he is the best ever.  I’m not sure how one would determine that, but it’s possible.

But, Jon questioned why I would post something negative about Gerry.  I suppose he’s right, that there’s no particular reason why I need to post something negative about another criminal defense lawyer.  My only response is that I can be critical about prosecutors, judges, lawprofs, whoever, and see it as hypocritical to refuse to do the same merely because someone is on my side of the fence.

While we may be taught that it is wrong to spread vicious gossip, we are also told to be modest in all things.  They go hand in hand.

Strange Doings on the Federal Bench

The  Deseret Morning News interviewed Paul Cassell, a District Court judge in Utah who, at age 42 and after a mere 5 1/2 years on the bench, resigned in frustration.  Judge Cassell, you may recall, was the first to revisit the unconstitutionality of the sentencing guidelines in Croxford in 2004, a precursor to Booker.  He expressed strong opposition to mandatory minimums.  Despite his tender years and a lifetime appointment, he was precisely the sort of judge we pray for, balanced and deeply concerned about the law being captive to politics.


“There’s a kind of ratchet effect where the Republicans will say, ‘We want a five-year mandatory minimum sentence,’ and Democrats will say, ‘We’ll up you, we want a 10-year mandatory minimum sentence,’ and you have people ratcheting up sentences to the point where any reasonable observer would think we’ve gone too high, but there’s no political incentive to undo the mischief.”

Paul Cassell found himself constrained by his view of the role of a district court judge and his sense of justice and fairness.  Even within this role, he pushed the envelope, challenging the government’s prosecution of an illegal immigrant for “identity theft” when he used a social security number to get a job, like millions of others, but was prosecuted as if it were to steal money. 


“One of the frustrations about being a trial court judge is that you never set broad principles of law; of course, that’s reserved for the appellate courts. … When I was there for 5 1/2 years, I began to think that maybe I would have more effect in moving the law in a way that I think is desirable by doing appellate litigation.”

What is fascinating is that there are judges, even on the federal bench, who view their life as having a greater purpose.  It isn’t about the prestige, or the money they aren’t earning, but about the good they are doing.  But if the sense is that the position of a United States District Court Judge is inadequate to have a meaningful positive impact, then what our society is in deeper trouble than we think.

I came across Paul Cassell’s interview on Volokh, where Orin Kerr, a George Washington Law School criminal law professor, makes clear in the comments his disagreement with Judge Cassell’s “activist” leanings.  The view over there is that judges are grocery clerks, charged with making sure that everything on their list is checked off before imposing the sentence found on the guidelines grid.  From this perspective, Paul Cassell was indeed an activist, and perhaps a bad judge.  There is no room in this vision of the judiciary for the exercise of discretion to the ends of justice. 

But Orin includes a fascinating paragraph that struck me as significant:


Incidentally, Cassell is one of five federal judges with superlative academic credentials who recently resigned or announced plans to resign either after only a short period of service or when still relatively young. I believe Cassell is now 47, and he resigned in 2007 after 5 and 1/2 years of service. The other four are Mark Filip (41, served for 3 years, now a nominee to become Deputy AG), David Levi (resigned in 2006 at the age of 55 after 17 years on the bench to become Dean of Duke), Michael Luttig (resigned in 2006 at 51 after 15 years on the bench to become GC of Boeing), and Michael Chertoff (resigned in 2005 after 2 years at age 53 to become Secretary of Homeland Security).

Becoming a federal judge used to be considered the crowning glory at the end of a significant legal career.  One did not assume the bench until one had accumulated a lifetime of legal experience.  There have been a number of judges within the districts of the Second Circuit who sat for brief periods, such as Kenneth Conboy, Abraham Sofaer and Louis Freeh, who also fit within the group.  Conboy, of course, left to take a partnership with Latham & Watkins, complaining he couldn’t live on a federal judges’ salary.  Sofaer and Freeh went to Washington to serve in the executive branch.

For many years, the change in the nature of judicial appointees has been cause for concern.  Rather than view the position as the end of a legal career, judgeships have become a parallel track for lawyers who are young, sometimes bringing very shallow experience to the bench, and with greater aspirations for the future.  This, in my view, defeats the purpose of life tenure and the intentions of the founding fathers to create a branch of government that need not appease the others.

This is not to say that judges whose entire careers were spent within a United States Attorney’s office make bad judges.  Consider EDNY Judge John Gleeson, who has been extraordinary in his refusal to bow to the sacred cows of Washington and has demonstrated a remarkable sense of justice. 

But contrast this with Jack Weinstein, an old-timer who has shown how a federal judge can adjudicate without fear of reprisal.  Reversal, perhaps, but not reprisal.  And then there’s SDNY Judge Harold Baer, who was threatened with excommunication for suppressing evidence because he considered the views held by Hispanics in New York City and, after the firestorm, reversed himself to avoid potential impeachment.

When young judges take the bench, with dreams of using it as a jumping off point for something bigger, they forfeit the ability to use the power of a life appointment because it will harm their chances of higher office or a pot of gold at the end.  Whatever their aim, being a federal district court judge doesn’t appear to be nearly enough to satisfy them.  This presents a terrible problem for those of us who depend on their independence and the exercise of their authority without fear of how it will affect the next step of their career.

Whether Judge Cassell’s decision to leave the bench for academia and appellate advocacy will prove to be the right move, considering what many believe to be the misguided view that he can have greater freedom and impact on the outside than he did on the inside, I hope he finds what he’s searching for.  He was one of the good ones, and could have been one of the great ones if he stuck to his bench.

There is one additional irony in this discussion.  My view of this problem is from the trenches, where lawyers try to save lives one at a time.  Orin Kerr’s view is from the tower, looking down at the federal judiciary and their adherence to their role in the grand Federalist scheme.  If Orin is right, then the best we can hope for are district court judges with their grocery lists, as their roles are not to do justice in each individual case but to mechanically apply the decisions of Congress as dictated by the circuits and Supreme Court.  If they do their jobs right, per Orin, they will be nothing more than cogs in the wheels of the law, a very unsatisfying image.

For those of us who walk into courtrooms to do battle for real people in real cases, each “cog” means the world to us.  We desperately hope that every federal judge brings a sense of justice and fairness to each case, and not merely a grocery list.  If it is not their job to hear what we have to say, to consider the merit and propriety of our positions and arguments and to make decisions that will affect people’s lives forever, then we are wasting our time in court.  It hurts all of us when we lose a judge like Paul Cassell, because he brought this to the bench, and he’s wrong about being able to make an impact on the inside.  If only he had thought about it from the point of view of being their until the end of his legal career, he would have been empowered to be exactly the sort of judge he wanted to be.  And we would have wanted him to be.

Those Who Can’t Should Control Themselves

Those who can, do.  Thoss who can’t, talk about those who can. 

We posted about Michael Rains and his penchant for  strong statements to the media.  Not surprisingly, the media attention surrounding Barry Bonds (who I believe to be a baseball player of some renown) continues to swirl, and includes Rains in its tempest.  And so, the salacious New York Times reports.

The lead is about how Barry Bonds is going to do the OJ Simpson “dream team” thing, to bring more talent onto the legal team with some familiarity with federal practice.  This is a sound idea, because it’s always better to be represented in a dog fight by someone who knows the rules of the game rather than someone who looks like a deer in the headlights. 

Part of the problem, according to the Times, is that Rains’ tough talking stance “distanced” him from the prosecution, meaning that he did not endear himself to the Assistant United States Attorneys in whose hands his client’s fate would lie.  Bonds’ business lawyer backed up Rains’ public defense of his client.


But Peter Keane, a law professor at Golden Gate University, said that it was a criminal defense lawyer’s job to maintain a working relationship with prosecutors and that Rains took the opposite approach by developing animosity with them, a strategy that caused him and Bonds to be “blindsided” by the indictment.

Really?  Funny how a prosecutor has no job to maintain a working relationship with the defense, eh?

Now I know that lawprofs can be very, very sensitive to criticism, but here’s a newsflash.  A criminal defense lawyer’s job is to represent the interests of his client.  We “work” with the prosecution, just as they “work” with us, of necessity.  Some people are easier to work with than others, and some cases lend themselves better to more cooperative ventures.  But, it is not merely to maintain a “working relationship.”

Currying favor, by the way, is not what I would call a “working relationship.”  The problem with this critique is that a target who is not looking for a sweet inside plea or cooperation has nothing to gain by his lawyer placing a higher priority on getting along than on protesting his innocence.  As Bonds wants to fight, what more effective strategy than vehemently maintaining innocence is there?  Anything less would have made for a much more pleasant prosecution, but one exceptionally lousy defense.

No one is saying that Rains should have gratuitously burned his bridges, but then no one suggests that he did.  Do we think that if Rains had played footsie with the government they would have shared the grand jury minutes with him in advance of the indictment?  Not likely.  Maintaining a working relationship with the government is like going the wrong way on a one way street.  When push comes to shove, rest assured that the government isn’t too worried about maintaining a working relationship with the defense.

Now Peter Keane should know better, as he’s got some real world experience, and I suspect that the comment attributed to him is either incomplete or out of context, because it’s hard to imagine anyone who’s ever been in the trenches would make a statement like that without enormous qualifications.  And you know there isn’t enough room in the story for those professorial-type explanations that make law review articles so fascinating.

But that’s one of the many reasons why lawyers, and law professors, need to be circumspect in what they say to the press.  Sound bites.  Only sound bites.  Did Peter Keane really mean to suggest that a criminal defense lawyers’ job is get on his knees and kiss the backside of some snot-nose kid prosecutor who will push his client off the cliff at any moment.  Sure, the nice “working relationship” lawyer will get a sweet, “sorry about that, dude” afterward, but the client is still lying lifeless at the bottom of the cliff.

Obviously, opportunities for lawprofs to get their name and brilliance out there in the media when the press is focused on lawyers who actually represent clients is difficult.  But before you pontificate on right and wrong, good and evil, and most importantly, how real lawyers should handle their cases, bear in mind that the stuff that emanates from you will be used critically against the guys who are out there in the trenches. 

You may not really care about this, and indeed you may well believe that your ivory tower perspective on how things should be done to represent actual living, breathing clients merits public airing, but remember the primary advice of any criminal defense lawyer:  You have the right to remain silent.  Use it.

OT — Black Friday is A Disease

For those of you who think that my posts tend toward rants, be advised.  This is a rant. 

This morning’s news included a segment on how the Long Island Expressway was brought to a standstill by shoppers at midnight (yes, midnight) going to the Tanger Mall outlet stores.  Ah, the $100 $10 gift card to be given to the first 100 shoppers, combined with those “midnight madness” sales.  What could be more tempting to ten thousand shoppers.

People, this is sick.  I wonder who in their right mind would go to stores that open at 4:00 a.m. on Black Friday.   It appears as if the number is too great to name.  Why?  Are you that desperate for material possession that you have lost all perspective?  Are your loved ones that avaricious that they will stop loving you if you don’t buy them a lot of things? 

I am obviously out of touch.  Not only will I not consider going out in the middle of the night for a sale, but I am not particularly inclined toward buying gifts of necessity for holidays.  Forget the commercialization of holidays.  That ship has sailed, and those of you who want to pretend that you are good believers in your faith and then debase it through consumerism, you already have to live with yourselves.  That’s your problem.

My problem is the mass hysteria that compels people to force their buying of things, all at the same time, or what?  Or your children won’t love you?  Or you spouse will find you sexually unattractive?  What terrible thing will happen to you if, on one day a year (or eight, or whatever number you feel applies) you don’t shower your loved ones in excess? 

What are the priorities that you are teaching your children?  That love is expressed in the quantity or cost of gifts?  Are they less worthy as human beings for lack of a new fangled cellphone?  By stealing out in the middle of the night, it enables you to buy more and more for less and less, right?  Is that $29 cashmere sweater proof of your devotion?  I suppose it must be, since you found yourself stuck on the highway along with the 10,000 other shoppers afflicted with the same disease.

And you wonder what drives criminals to commit crimes for financial gain?  As worth in our society becomes increasingly (if that’s possible) connected to possessions, we are all party to the encouragement of doing whatever is necessary to accumulate things.  Even those who lack the wherewithal through honest effort want to possess things, because we bombard them with the message that this is the worth of a person. 

Instead of feeling the pressure to produce on this most important of commercial opportunities, we could buy something for our loved ones when something happens to come along on any given day of the year.  There’s nothing wrong with getting things to make our kids or spouses happy.  It’s the compulsory obligation of this particular season that brings out the sickness.  If we could bring it down about 100 notches, refocus on the meaning of the season, and stop believing that happiness and love is directly proportional to the number of boxes under a tree, we would all be a lot better off.

Certainly, I lack the persuasiveness to stop this.  But maybe one by one, we can consider what this says about our society and decide whether this reflects who we are and who we want to be.  Maybe one less person will feel compelled to commit one less robbery, and there will be one less victim in the world.  Just think about it.

End of a rant that I fully expect to be read by absolutely no one, as you will all be out shopping.  Sigh.

How Much Impact Should Victims Have?

Recently, I  posted about New York’s new efforts to reform its sentencing scheme.  Naturally, one of the points raised was increasing input from victims in the process, because this is one of the latest cool fads that shows people how our system of criminal justice involves them.  Everybody feels for victims.  Nobody wants to learn about how the system already works.  Hey, if politicians had to explain how things we worked, nobody would ever vote for them.

So what’s wrong with victims telling sentencing judges about the impact of a crime on their lives and the lives of their families?  Well, nothing per se.  The problem is that the impact on victims is already encompassed in sentencing schemes and always has been, making a victim impact statement cumulative, or piling on if you will.  Further, the offense committed is made neither better nor worse because of fortuitous subsequent events.  The offense is wrong when committed, not more wrong because of outcome.

Consider this example.  Defendant Moe intends to use a handgun to shoot victim Curley.  His intention is to kill Curley because Curley is funnier than Moe.  Moe aims his glock at Curley and pulls the trigger.  The gun fires and the bullet projects from the barrel of the gun.  It flies through the air at great velocity . . . and misses Curley.  It seems that Moe is a lousy shot.

Just then, the police rush in, grab Moe and tackle him to the ground.  They taser him a few times for fun (I just threw this in; it has nothing to do with the example).  Moe is arrested and prosecuted for attempted murder in the second degree (this is happening in New York, naturally).  The minimum sentence range for attempted murder in the second degree, an A-2 felony, is 3 to life.  We’ll use minimum sentences to compare apples to apples.

Alternatively, defendant Larry does the same, but if a much better shot than Moe and nails Curley right between the eyes.  Larry is charged with murder in the second degree, carrying a minimum sentence of 15 years to life.

Moe and Larry engaged in precisely the same conduct with precisely the same intent.  They are equally venal and culpable.  Their involvement in the crime was completed upon pulling the trigger of the gun.  Should they not, then receive exactly the same sentence?

The law answers the question “no”.  Larry has Curley’s dead body on his hands, while Moe does not.  The only reason is that Moe is a lousy shot while Larry nailed his target.  But this has nothing whatsoever to do with the nature of the crime committed.  It is solely based upon the impact to the victim.  As a result of victim impact, Larry will be punished 5 times more harshly than Moe for the same conduct.  The State Legislature already figured victim impact into the equation, long before victim impact statements became fashionable.

Built into the system is the consequence of criminal conduct.  As much as the pain caused to victims and their families by crime is enormously personal, the anticipated outcome of crime is not a surprise.  That’s why it’s a crime to begin with.  We can expect victims to explain the personal impact with detail and emotion, but should victims have an independent right to push a court to use the statutory sentence as a baseline and increase the sentence based upon the desire and ability of victims to express their personal anguish?

The true nature of victim impact statements is to give victims the impression of having a role to play in the punishment of the perpetrators of crimes against them.  It is cathartic, and helps victims to release the anger, frustration and even hatred so that they can move forward.  This is a worthy purpose, and I have no argument against a defendant being forced to stand their and be confronted by their victim, taking whatever the victim wishes to give. 

In fact, I could envision a procedure where victims (of certain crimes) get to harangue defendants daily for 30 days for as long as they want, and defendants are chained to a bench and forced to sit there, silently and take it.  Victims are entitled to vent, to release their feelings and do make it as painfully clear as possible to defendants what they have done.  But this is separate from the sentence imposed.  The impact on victims is already in there.  The point is not to be disingenuous toward victims of crime, but to recognize that the cathartic opportunity has no role to play in the sentencing decision, even though it would make the decisions of judges and politicians more palatable to the public.

Indeterminate Sentencing Just Sounds Confusing

Over a PrawfsBlawg, Eduardo Penalver admits that he doesn’t get the point of a sentence of 5 to life. 


Along with all Tupac fans, I’ve heard of “twenty-five to life.”  But “five to life” seems to leave enormous room for disparity based on the sentiments of the parole board, no? 

He’s not alone in having some difficulty understanding an indeterminate sentencing scheme.  Most clients don’t get it either, though they would never admit it.  The clue is when the defendant’s babymama asks you for the third time what the potential sentence is, there’s a comprehension gap.

As a public service, I offer a stab at explaining the idea.  The concept is to give judges wider latitude in sentencing options in order to accommodate the breadth of potentially heinous conduct giving rise to the technical commission of the offense.  That statute will provide for a maximum sentence (say 7 years) with the minimum to be one third of the maximum (here, it would be 2 1/3 years, giving a sentence of 2 1/3 to 7 years in prison).  See New York Penal Law 70.00, for example.

The anticipation is that the defendant will serve 2 1/3 years if he conducts himself appropriately in prison.  The two thirds of the sentence that aren’t served are the hammer for good conduct and rehabilitation, both in prison and on parole afterward.  It’s a carrot and stick concept.

Using the 5 to life example, the statute provides for a maximum sentence of life imprisonment, meaning that the nature of the crime deserves lifetime parole supervision, or at least the potential to put the defendant back in prison for subsequent criminal conduct for the rest of his life.  But the 5 years is the relevant period of actual imprisonment, provided the defendant behaves. 

The mistaken assumption is that after 5 years, the parole board then gets to sit as a superjudge on the original crime for which the defendant was sentenced.  While  some parole boards do, in fact, abuse their authority do revisiting the original sentence to decide whether they “like” it and deem it sufficient, that is contrary to their purpose and authority.  It is not up to the parole board to judge the wisdom of the original sentence, but to determine whether the service of that sentence fulfilled its purposes of deterrence and rehabilitation.  In other words, has the defendant adjusted properly in prison and is he ready to come out and rejoin society. 

In the Warren Jeffs case, which gave rise to Eduardo’s question, the polygamous sect leader who raped and abused children was sentenced to two consecutive terms of 5 to life.  This is almost the same as a single sentence of 10 to life, except that good time reductions in the minimum sentence will likely calculate differently.  Since I’m not a Utah lawyer, I can’t say for sure or give any details off the top of my head and it’s not worth the effort to research the distinctions. 

Let’s assume that Jeffs will not be parole eligible until after he has served 4 years, 3 months of each sentence, meaning that his first parole board appearance will be after 8 years, 6 months, chopping a year and a half off the minimum sentence.  Since it’s consecutive rather than concurrent, the second sentence doesn’t start until after the first sentence is completed, and we add the two minimums together to determine his first eligibility date.

Assume further that Jeffs is a model prisoner,  He doesn’t beat up gang members or guards in prison, and has learned a useful trade (other than sect management) inside.  He appears before the parole board and they ask him if he’s learned his lesson.  He’s smart enough to say yes, as opposed to “I’ve done nothing wrong and you will all burn in hell for imprisoning God’s messenger.”   This is rarely the right thing to say to the parole board.  He is then told to keep his nose clean and sent packing.

Jeffs will then, theoretically, be subject to parole supervision, together with the conditions imposed by his parole officer, for the rest of his life.  It rarely works out this way, since parole will eventually get tired of spending its resources supervising him and cut him loose, but they at least have the ability to keep him under tabs until he dies. 

If one condition of his parole release is to stay 100 feet away from anyone under the age of 18, and he doesn’t comply, they can violate him, conduct an administrative hearing and toss his sick, warped, disgusting butt back in prison for a period of time.  So 5 is the carrot and life is the stick.  It makes some sense when the practice follows the theory.

Hope that helps, Eduardo.