Just over a month ago, I posted about the vicious crime of Standing. No, not standing, as in standing to sue. Just plain old standing, as in hanging around with your feet in the same place. This was the case of Matthew Jones, believed by police to be a serial stander, presenting a clear and present danger to all civilized people traversing Times Square. At least according to Police Officer Momen Attia, who finally captured Jones in the act of standing.
Following heated argument before the court, a decision has finally come down, per Talkleft. Matthew Jones is free! Matthew Jones is free!
The Court of Appeals, in its 6 page decision, held:
Something more than a mere inconvenience of pedestrians is required to support the charge. Otherwise, any person who happens to stop on a sidewalk — whether to greet another, to seek directions or simply to regain one’s bearings — would be subject to prosecution under this statute.
So here is the real question. It took the Court of Appeals, the highest court in the State of New York, to figure this out? Holidays are supposed to be festive. Somehow, they tend to raise a surprising number of problems. Whether with family, or gifts, things happen that suck the joy out of the good times. But Thanksgiving is different. It’s always been the one holiday where people seem to come together. Eric is very witty. But he’s right. In this business, criminal defense, we meet a lot of people who have problems. Some well deserved, but others not. We see the impact on families, on children, that other people who can enjoy their anti-criminal polemics from the comfort and security of a wood-paneled office do not. Would it be possible for those of you who spend the rest of the year hating people to open up your hearts for once and feel a little empathy for others? At the very least, be thankful that you’re not them. Judicial Reports posted the second in a series called Concealed Witness about the withholding of information from the defense in order for the prosecution to gain advantage at trial. It includes a sidebar polemic by yours truly on the games played with Brady material in New York courts. This is an important lesson to Legislators, which naturally few learned. The view from the trenches is rarely the same as the view from the great hall of the Legislature. The law of unintended consequences will always trump good intentions. New York certainly shouldn’t have laws that the District Attorneys wouldn’t care for, right? After all, the criteria for a good law is “what does the DA think about it?” This should give you some clue as to what the unintended consequences of open file discovery, even if it were to make it through the Legislature, might bring. It’s about time. One of my biggest concerns given the numbers of autistic children (and adults) is that they are frequently misapprehended by police to be engaging in criminal conduct, or refusing to obey police orders, when they are limited by their disability. According to this Newsday story, finally the police are being brought into the dialogue. It’s hard enough to live with autism, or with someone who is autistic (and I use this word in its broadest meaning). You can love them all you want, but they require a lot of work and attention in everything they do. It’s just how it is. But one of the things that we need not tolerate is autistic children being killed by police because they “didn’t obey” police instructions. We don’t kill people because they are disabled, and the nature of autism impairs the ability to process commands, under stressful conditions, making it the perfect storm for tragedy. There is no doubt in my mind that police do not want to harm an autistic person. But they do want to go home to their own family every night, and that means that they will invariably err on the side of doing what protects them over being particularly concerned for the welfare of the perceived “bad guy.” One of the keys to this program is to take a moment to observe and identify an autistic person before pulling the trigger. This will prove more difficult than you think, since stepping back and observing is an invitation for disaster for police. You see, if the person is not autistic, but just your plain old vanilla miscreant, this gives the perp the opportunity to pull a gun and blow the officer’s head off. Not a good outcome. So how should the officer identify the individual who does not pose an immediate threat, and whom he should first observe rather than take a defensive posture? Other than to say that it’s a decision that has to be made on a case by case basis, there are no rules that I can think of. There are many instances where a police officer has the opportunity to stand back, observe and determine whether the person he is dealing with is disabled or not. The criminal defense blawgosphere has gone bananas over the knee-jerk resort to tasers as a substitute for waiting out a situation. Hopefully, with a disabled child in mind, police will find waiting a little more palatable. With even more hope, police will envision what it will mean if they harm an autistic child for no better reason than the kid didn’t drop when they screamed. Does any cop really want to go to bed that night with that picture in his head? Protect our children. Especially the disabled children. Learn about them, anticipate them and do not harm them. Please. Edit. Note: There has been significant interest in this post over the past couple of days, and I have no idea why. A comment or email to let me in on the reason would be much appreciated. Thanks. While Chief Judge Judith Kaye is busy writing op-ed pieces deploring the low pay for judges in New York, the New York State Commission on Judicial Conduct has been busy too, according to the New York Lawyer. The New York State Commission on Judicial Conduct opened more investigations in 2006 and had more matters pending against judges than at any time in its 29-year history, according to its annual report, which was released Thursday [11/15/07]. New York has a lot of judges, so it’s not a terrible shock that there are a few who have turned out badly, though one would hope that the process can weed out the really bad ones before we give them the power to destroy people’s lives or do grave harm. But the numbers before the Commission are really shockingly high: Overall, the commission received 1,500 complaints against judges last year. Since 1992, an average of 1,440 complaints have been filed annually against the state’s 3,400 judges and town and village justices. To put these numbers into context, bear in mind that the Commission doesn’t get involved in bad decisions by judges, but only in violations of the Code of Judicial Conduct. It’s not that difficult a Code to follow, and if someone puts themselves into the position of being a judge of others, one would think they could figure out how to conduct themselves. But here’s a statistic that is particularly disturbing: “Of the complaints, 314 were against town and village justices – 80 lawyers and 234 nonlawyers.” Following this to the end result, only 14 judges received public sanctions in 2006, and of those 14, ten were non-lawyer justices. I’ve already expressed my views on the continuation of the archaic use of non-lawyers as judges in local courts. They have to go. But these numbers tell a very disturbing story about the rest of the system. One way to look at them is to conclude that most judicial complaints are meritless (the Commission dismissed 72% off the top) and that of the complaints pursued, impropriety by sitting lawyer judges is nearly non-existence (4 public sanctions out of 1,500 complaints covering 3400 judges). I have trouble with this interpretation. Having talked about the work of this Commission, as well as having talked about the work of other bar committees that deal with judges (like those that approve judicial candidates, including sitting judges, for election), there is no doubt in my mind that the deference shown sitting judges, particularly the more powerful ones (Yes, Virginia, there are more powerful judges) allows impropriety to be swept under the carpet. Non-lawyer local justices get called on the carpet for two reasons. First, they are far more likely to violate the Code because they have no concept of judicial ethics than lawyer judges. Second, they have no clout. There is no backlash from burning a non-lawyer local justice. They are powerless in the scheme of the court system. Easy picken’s, if you will. “Real” judges, on the other hand, are not so easy. When complaints against them are pursued, they get pissed. And when they get pissed, the get even. That’s the great thing about being a judge; you have the power to get even. If a complaint is filed that isn’t going to bring a judge down, then expect to have one angry judge on your hands. Indeed, this is one of the reasons that the number of complaints is surprising in itself. Few lawyers will file complaints against a judge unless they are prepared to see their careers ruined and clients crushed. You’ve got to feel very strongly before taking on a burden like that. For those of us in the trenches, we see and hear a lot of things from the bench that make us cringe. From the “soft-core” improprieties of inappropriate temperament to covert bias, judges are untouchable. To grieve is to commit professional suicide, because the Commission isn’t going out on a limb over anything that subjective or lightweight. Nobody is going to spit in the face of an angry bear, unless you want your head torn off. This is not to suggest that there is rampant impropriety happening across the courtrooms of New York. The vast majority of judges I’ve been before are honorable, ethical and appropriate. While I occasionally disagree with their rulings (okay, often disagree), I cannot fault them at all for the performance of their office. But there are some who have demeaned the bench by their conduct, and never been called on the carpet. There shouldn’t be any. Bear in mind, these are judges we are talking about, and it is hardly too much to expect that they be above reproach. Even when they don’t feel like it and have no fear that the Commission on Judicial Conduct would ever have the guts to challenge them. UPDATE: Two more judges publicly censured, both non-lawyers. “Since 1978, the commission has censured 263 judges, 187 of them town or village justices.” Shocking. A couple of days ago, I received emails from a few different readers asking my what I thought about a story in the New York Times about how cops in New Jersey, particularly Trenton and Newark, are being told to make their cases without using civilian witnesses. Even Governor Corzine is in on this. The reason, according to the Times is On first blush, the story suggests that Jersey police and prosecutors are acting out of an excess of caution and concern for civilian witnesses, to protect them from harm. If so, this was a good thing. After all, these are ordinary people coming forward to help law enforcement arrest and prosecute criminals, and law enforcement owes them a duty of care to protect them from any harm that may result from their helping law enforcement, and the rest of society, by testifying against violent people. As one State Police detective said: I didn’t post about this story right away because something felt wrong about it. The surface story certainly seemed plausible enough, but it didn’t have the smell of the real story. So I decided to hold off and give it some more thought. Use witnesses sparingly. Let the big case go in favor of the smaller case where witnesses aren’t needed. The only message that can be taken from this “strategy” is that witness intimidation is an effective tool in preventing defendants from being convicted of crimes. So this story stands for the proposition that its easier for police to abdicate responsibility for doing their job than it is to keep witnesses off the stand. Could a better answer be to manage and direct law enforcement to protect the public from harm? Not so simple, you say? Very true, but is it better to keep violent criminals on the street rather than face the embarrassment of a failure of policing? Just announced by the New York Lawyer, SUNY Binghamton University President Lois DeFleur said that she has been in ongoing talks with State University of New York (SUNY) officials and with the American Bar Association about the school. The proposal would need the approval of the governor and the state’s education department. Why? Our children aren’t miserable enough? There aren’t enough students competing for handful of Biglaw jobs that pay 47 times a first year associate’s worth? There aren’t enough lawyers fighting over the rotten carcass of a PI plaintiff? Society needs many thing. But not another law school. (link) Eugene Volokh (www): SHG: I guess I’m not really inclined to respond further, given the tenor of your more recent comment. 11.19.2007 10:59pm Apparently, I’ve hurt his feelings and he’s not going to tell me. Is it because I challenged his assertions? Is it because I called him “Gene”? Is it because he’s so used to the adoration of the libertarian wing of the conservatives who take for granted that if he says so, it must be? Maybe it was the picture I posted of him all dolled up at the Federalist fête? I thought he looked pretty good in the photo. But still no answer to the question. So now I’m rude? Apparently so, because short answer from his fans demonstrating their adoration are fine, but from some low-life practicing lawyer like me is rude. This is a shame. The Volokh Conspiracy comes up with some very interesting posts and links, and because of the libertarian/conservative/Republican political bent, it offers much to discuss. It’s too bad that Eugene Volokh would rather hide then stand behind his comments. Oh well. Another lawprof who likes to ask questions but can’t answer them. I really am sorry that it turned out this way.
The fact that the arraigning judge refused to dismiss this ridiculous complaint comes as no surprise. As I’ve tried to make clear over and over again, there are too many judges whose primary goal on the bench is to avoid getting their face on the front page of the New York Post as “New Yorks Biggest Criminal Loving Judge,” and you can never go wrong by erring on the side of the prosecution.
In case you think this is a criticism of lower court judges, consider the fact that the appeals court affirmed the refusal to dismiss. Really. How can you blame the arraigning judge when the next level applauds the decision? And after all, isn’t New York really a safer, more pleasant place to be when we get all those serial standings off the street? Just ask Rudy.
Seriously, the fact that it required three years and three levels of courts to reach the conclusion that was so painfully obvious to everyone (especially those of us who have themselves had occasion to “stand” in Times Square) is a disgrace. The system worked, but the price of reaching an obvious decision was shockingly astronomical. If the law is to command public respect, it has got to do better than this.
And if you have nothing to be thankful for today before, now you can rejoice in the knowledge that you, like Matt Jones, can stand in Times Square without fear. This is important, given the fact that many thousands of people will be doing exactly that while watching the Thanksgiving Parade. Our holding cells aren’t nearly big enough to deal with this mass disobedience.
Rudy Guiliani with unidentified New York (former) Senior Senator and another (in white) belived to be Puff Daddy engaged in Criminal Standing, as well as various fashion violations.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized on . Can We Agree on Thanksgiving?
None of the things that tend to separate us comes into play on Thanksgiving. At least not at my house. Granted, there was the time my sister in law made the sweet potatoes with marshmallows, even though she was asked not to. It sucked. But we could laugh at it. She was always good for a laugh, as long as we kept it where it belonged (behind her back). No hurt feelings needed on Thanksgiving.
Eric the Turk wrote on his blawg (where his holiday present is not doing the Personal Injury Law Round-Up anymore because it was a lot of work and nobody appreciated him)It’s a safe bet that anyone reading this blog is more fortunate than most of the world’s population. So it’s a good time to count your blessings.
And be thankful you’re not a turkey.
Chances are slim that anyone will read this post, since this is one of those days that people find better things to do than sit at their computer. So I assume that I’m writing this for myself and maybe the 3 other people who will spend a few minutes online today. And the likelihood that anyone who should read this will do so is slim to none. Oh well. It costs me nothing to try.
By any measure, I have much to be thankful for. By the measure of what I see through my professional eyes, I do not deserve to be so blessed. I hope that the same it true for all of you. There is terrible misery in the world, and by dint of your being able to read this post, you do not have to feel it. Please have a happy Thanksgiving.
UPDATE: It’s a gorgeous day on Long Island, sunny at mid 60s. After watching my buddy Joe Tac doing the TV rounds on the Natalee Holloway disappearance, I’m taking the Austin Healey out for a breath of fresh air. I really do have much to be thankful for. I urge everyone to go out, get a classic British car, and drive a little. There’s no better way to clear your head. This entry was posted in Uncategorized on .
Open File Discovery – Better But Not Perfect
Notably, some District Attorneys provide, voluntarily, open file discovery even though the law doesn’t demand it. Open file discovery “is the practice of allowing the defense virtually unrestricted access to the case file — ideally, immediately after indictment — and limiting pretrial motion practice to disputes over suppression of evidence and other genuinely debatable matters.”
In New York, discovery is governed by statute (Criminal Procedure Law 240.20), which provides a short list of what the prosecution is required to provide and a request/refusal/motion system for obtaining it. Those offices that don’t voluntarily engage in open file discovery tend to use a mechanism called a Voluntary Disclosure Form (VDF), which is turned over to the defense with the indictment. It’s pretty much a fill in the blanks form that substitutes for real discovery. Moreover, it’s often marked to let you know that there are lab reports, with the notation that they will be turned over later, either upon request or at the prosecutor’s convenience.
Supreme Court Justice Jim Yates provides an explanation of what was intended when this discovery statute was written. He should know. He wrote it way back when. So you know, Judge Yates is one of the best judges we have in Manhattan. We haven’t always seen things eye to eye, and in fact had one huge blow-up on a case where he had granted my preclusion motion one day (he was right to do so), then reversed himself the next day. On day 1 he told the prosecutor he was drawing a line in the sand. The next day, when he reversed himself, I threw his words back at him and he told me, “That’s why the line is in sand, with one sweep of the hand, it disappears.” What do you do about a judge with such a facile use of metaphors?
Judge Yates was disgusted by the way his discovery statute had been undermined. It had been the intent to encourage and expect meaningful disclosure, but with prosecutors using disclosure as a weapon, and judges unwilling to buck powerful district attorneys, it became a unwieldy limit on the defense.Yates blamed this outcome on a “fundamental disagreement” among his colleagues: “The majority of judges take the view that unless it’s required to be turned over under the statute, they don’t have the authority to order the prosecution to turn it over.”
This is not, he said, what the law’s authors intended: “What we built was a floor, not a ceiling. The idea was not to restrict discovery, but [that has been] the net effect. If I’d thought it would be read [this] way, I would never have helped write it.”
What’s worse, and unsaid in the piece, is that practice doesn’t even fulfill the minimal expectations of the discovery statute. While a VDF may work with a particularly generous Assistant District Attorney or truly garden variety case, it has largely turned into a substitute for judicial involvement in compliance with the discovery process. Disclosure is just one more thing taken off the judge’s plate and left entirely to the discretion of the prosecution.
If the VDF has no lab or ballistics report noted, for example, but the case necessarily suggests that there has to be one, the defense moves for an order requiring disclosure or precluding its introduction at trial. The court simply ignores the motion, saying “whatever is in the VDF satisfies the prosecution’s discovery obligation.” At trial, a year later and before another judge, the reports naturally appear. Other than a potential scolding for what they should have done, the defense gets sandbagged and there’s no sanction for the prosecution.
A solution to the fiasco called discovery has been offered by a former Brooklyn ADA, now State Assemblyman, Joseph Lentol (D-Kings County), chair of the Code Committee. He has proposed versions of a bill, A-1119, that would liberalize discovery. He’s done so annually for a decade. His bill has never made it out of committee.
Noting that the “odds are really stacked against the defense,” his solution is to require open file discovery in all cases. This has been embraced by some as the new panacea to level the playing field. Others disagree:Senator Dale Volker (R-Depew), a former cop and current chair of the New York Senate Codes Committee, tells a surprisingly similar story. “Personally, I think there’s some work we could do on discovery, but [Lentol’s bill] would open up discovery so much that the District Attorneys would never go for it,” he said. “I think what the [DA’s] are concerned with is once you open up the whole discovery process, if [they feel] they’re not able to give information and the law says they must, they’d be in trouble. Don’t kid yourself, there are cases where turning over everything is not a good idea.”
Given current experience, no judge will ever be bothered overseeing discovery again should open file discovery happen, leaving the process entirely in the hands of the prosecutor. The “open file” will swiftly turn into the portion of the file that the ADA deems to be what he wants the defense to see, and any document that somehow doesn’t make it into his “file” at the time it’s turned over, well, new stuff shows up at trial all the time. It happens, according to the ADAs. It’s not like they intended to conceal anything, right?
What becomes of the duty to exercise due diligence to seek out and obtain specifics that are required for the preparation of the defense? Even assuming you get to see what the ADA has already put in his file, the mechanism is lost for having a court compel the prosecution to affirmatively provide whatever is not there. Bear in mind, there’s no incentive for the ADA to go out of his way to seek reports that hurt his case, even though these are the reports that help the defense and keep innocent people from being convicted. How does one compel the prosecution to obtain the rap sheet for its primary witness at trial? Beats me, under this panacea.
But isn’t open file discovery better than what we have now? Well, in many ways it is. At least we have a decent shot of getting the same discovery that we would get if they made a serious effort to comply with the existing discovery statute, plus whatever extra stuff that found its way into the file.
The problem I see is that discovery reform, desperately needed if anybody cares at all about keeping innocent people from being convicted, happens only once every few generations. As Judge Yates learned, even the best laid plans go awry, and the last effort was a miserable failure. The next try needs to recognize the “real life” flaws of the system in order to correct them, rather than the “pretend” flaws that assume the system will function with the good faith of all involved.
In other words, we need to stop “trusting” the little boys and girls in the DAs offices with making decisions that impact innocent people and create a system where judges play a serous role and both have, and are forced to use, their power to sanction the concealment of discovery materials. All three players in the courtroom need to be engaged in the proceedings, not just the prosecutors picking and choosing what to hand over to the begging defense lawyers. And as long as judges refuse to preclude the admission of concealed evidence or testimony for fear of upsetting the omnipotent District Attorneys or making the front page of the New York Post, then there is no statute that can save the system.
So while I applaud Assemblyman Joe Lentol for trying, an open file discovery statute is not going to cure what ails the system. And as long as Senators like Dale Volker control their chamber, you can bet your bottom dollar that there will be a warm welcome for the District Attorneys views on the subject in Albany.
Looking for a statutory solution in Albany is part of the problem, because the truth is that we really don’t need the unwilling politicians’ involvement to make this work. What we need are judges who take an active role under the current law to put the teeth back in the discovery duty, hold the prosecutors feet to the fire by imposing sanctions for non-compliance, and recognizing a constitutional due process duty to disclose that trumps the statutory duty. As Judge Yates said, the law was intended as a minimum, not a maximum, obligation.
So if New York’s judges could focus on doing a little more to assure fairness in discovery rather than getting a pay raise, perhaps we could fix this problem? Oh please. We’ll be right back to business as usual, with the defense dangling at the whim of the prosecution and the judges pretending that they have nothing to do with it. Police To Be Trained To Identify Autism
Solove’s “Reputation” Already Coming in Handy
In the meantime, a friend came to me with a problem. One of his kids is doing the facebook thing, writing stuff that will most assuredly come back to haunt this child. It will happen soon. It will happen in the future. My friend sees it and understands it, but can’t stop it. He has lectured, scolded, admonished his kid to stop. He has explained in dulcet tones how this is not a good thing, in a non-judgmental way. He has punished his child. He has banned his child from using the computer. He has failed to save his child from a terrible mistake.
The only upside to the situation is that his kid is very smart (in some ways) and inclined to read. I urged my friend to get Dan’s book. No, the legal issues discussed will not capture a child’s attention, but the stories of damage to people’s lives may well hit home.
So am I writing this because I want to promote Reputation? In a way, yes. This book is one of the most effective tools I’ve seen to enlighten people, and hopefully kids, as to the potential damage they are causing themselves.
There are a fairly good number of college and law school students who read blawgs, including this one. Some of you think you are very smart. In some way, you probably are. But don’t extrapolate your academic success into overarching brilliance. We all have our lapses. One of those lapses may be that you write about yourselves and your lives now under the misguided belief that what strikes you as humorous or cool today will apply with equal force forever. It will not.
For the females, postings about sexual exploits or proclivities will haunt you some day (as will tattoos, for that matter). Rule of thumb: If it’s not something you would say to your father, don’t post it on the internet. For the males, a stupors of any sort are not nearly as funny as you think and, frankly, don’t show off any talent that will impress anyone over 12 years of age.
Criminal defense lawyers are constantly harping on the right to remain silent. This applies to anything you might post on the internet as well. If you half the brains you think you have, then stop posting stupid crap about yourself. If you need to know why, read Dan’s book. Judges Gone Bad
Concern For Witnesses Or Admission Of Failure
In cities struggling with gang-related crimes, like Trenton and Newark, detectives said that even on the infrequent occasions when they find civilian witnesses who might be willing to testify, investigators are wary about pressuring them to appear in court. That reluctance is based on a fear that the authorities might not be able to protect witnesses from retaliation.
“If you push someone and they agree to testify, now they’re your responsibility,” he said. “You’ve got to keep them from disappearing or getting hurt. Can we protect them? Maybe. But God forbid that two years later you have to tell someone their husband or father got killed. I don’t want to have to live with that.”
While I don’t doubt that police officers and prosecutors are capable of empathy (yes, they are human too), I’ve spent enough time representing witnesses to crimes to know that they are generally viewed as “cogs in the wheels of justice” more than people. Note that we’re not talking about victims of crimes, but rather witnesses. There’s a difference. Victims are sometimes taken under wing. Witnesses are just part of the tool kit to build cases.
Then it dawned on me that this was not a story about police concern for others, for civilian witnesses, but a story about the inability of law enforcement to perform its function well enough to avoid the two-prong consequence of its failure. Police both suffer the embarrassment of having people who stepped forward to testify fall off the face of the earth and lose potential future witnesses who won’t come forward because they don’t want to disappear. This is an institutional failure, not a personal one.
I’m sure individual officers would feel devastated upon learning that some witness was murdered in retaliation for giving testimony. Every murder should be abhorred, but it is always different when there is a personal connection. But the institution of law enforcement doesn’t have feelings. It takes an academic approach, considering the cost of its function versus its utility. What this story tells us is that the price is too high.
Norm opined that criminal defense lawyers should not view their function to be “against” law enforcement. Like everyone else, we rely on our government and its institutions to protect us, our families and our homes. We want police to do their job, and do it well. Of course, we want them to do it in the context of the law, to not shortcut the system because it’s faster, easier and more effective to run roughshod over the Constitution. But we are every bit as much supporters of law enforcement as anyone else. We too depend on police to protect and serve.
What this New York Times story really tells us is that the police in New Jersey have conceded that they cannot perform their function. They cannot protect citizens from crime. They have given up. It’s not that there is so much crime that they can’t handle it. There’s no suggestion that volume is the problem. I haven’t heard of a plague of murders in Newark beyond the scope of law enforcement’s capabilities. It may have something to do with the focus of law enforcement on other, more newsworthy concerns, like fighting terrorism. But the story doesn’t mention that either.
And why just New Jersey? There are inner cities across America. There are gangs across America. What makes anything different in New Jersey? These questions aren’t asked, no less answered. But New Jersey officials offer this:Some state officials who support Mr. Corzine’s proposals said that New Jersey’s witness intimidation problem had grown so complex and severe that it would take a broader effort, from both government and community leaders, to combat it.
Clearly, New Jersey needs to do something. There’s a thorn tree in the Garden State, and right now they’re just letting it grow. Another Law School. Woo Hoo!
Buffalo Binghamton is planning to open its every own, brand-spanking new . . . Law School! Situation Normal In Pretrial Release, Or Not?
So I read the report. It was a special report of the Bureau of Justice Statistics. It’s written by some people with Ph.D.s after their names. It covers a 15 year stretch, from 1990 to 2004, and the 75 largest counties (I think in the nation, though it doesn’t quite say). This is what statisticians call a pretty good sample.
And what do we learn from this report? The sun rises in the morning and sets in the evening. Francisco Franco is still dead. Defendants who are out do better than defendants who are in. Defendants with high bail are more likely to stay in than defendants without bail.
About the only piece of news in the report is that there has been a trend toward bail rather than ROR, and that bail bondsmen are doing better because of it. What this means to me is that defendants are spending more of their hard “earned” money on bail bondsmen instead of criminal defense lawyers. Boo. Hiss.
I would like to tell you that the report is a fascinating read. It’s not. It’s a bore. Worse yet, it is an academic-type effort to state what every criminal defense lawyer knows and sees every day in the trenches. Big deal. This is what DOJ spends its money on.
But Volokh found this report “very interesting,” so I felt compelled to find out why. I asked him. He deflected. I asked again, sorta. This was his response:
Why does it matter? Because there are a whole lot of people who read the Volokh Conspiracy, far more than read Simple Justice, and Volokh tends to carry a big stick when it comes to being persuasive with judges. You remember judges, the men and women who make decisions about our clients. So if there’s something in this report dealing with pre-trial release of defendants that is “very interesting,” I, for one, would like to know what it is so I can understand it and address it.
No such luck. Volokh threw out the comment, and now won’t back it up. So this is a personal note to Eugene Volokh (everybody else, avert your eyes): I apologize for offending you and treating you disrespectfully. Please tell me what you find very interesting. I really want to know.
You can open your eyes now (I know, don’t say it, Matlock). If there’s going to be a significant group of people, some of whom hold sway over the pre-trial release of our clients, who are being told that they are cutting them loose too easily, too freely, to the detriment of society, then we need to know about it. If Francisco Franco is still dead, we should know that too.
I sure hope that Volokh accepts my heartfelt apology. I really do want to know what he’s thinking.
UPDATE: Volokh has surfaced! But only long enough to inform me of the following:SHG: I didn’t find your comments disturbing. I did find a comment that simply said “Non-responsive” to be rude.
In Homage To Public Defenders
Few jobs are less sexy, financially rewarding or unappreciated than being a public defender. They are the lawyers of last resort. As Gid notes, they don’t pick their clients. They get what is left over. They get the defendants that are at the bottom of the barrel. No money and little luck. Often without a chance of success, they are a sorry lot.
What got to Gideon was the talk about the won-lost record. How does a public defender explain his scorecard when he carries 200 cases at a time, most of which have absolutely no chance of a “win”, at least the way we describe it. To many, the win is a very relative thing. To public defenders, the win is to give their clients a better chance than they would have without them. Every year they chop off a sentence is a win. Sometimes they get a client with a winable case, but most of the time winning just isn’t in the cards for their clients. Can we blame the lawyer because the clients he represents come to him with insurmountable problems? And yet, sometimes they do “win”. Most of the time, they win something, and that’s pretty darn good.
At least, you might think, that these defendants, unloved by anyone else, would appreciate what the public defender does for them. Not a chance. They challenge the public defender to see if they’re worthy of representing them. They can be crazy, angry, vicious, dirty, disgusting, ignorant. It doesn’t matter. The public defender will still represent them. And will do so to the best of his ability.
Gideon writes about how fancy lawyers like Bennett, Norm and me can pick and choose our clients. While the picking aspect may be somewhat overrated, it is true. I don’t represent child molesters. I don’t represent people I don’t like. I can afford to tell them “no”. No one makes me represent anyone I don’t want to. Mind you, it never has anything to do with the seriousness of their case, or the probability of success. I take the hard cases. But it is my choice.
Gideon has no choice. Gideon takes them because no one else will and they must be represented. This doesn’t mean that every public defender is the reincarnation of Clarence Darrow. Or Mother Teresa. Some are better lawyers than others. Some are great lawyers, who just happen to chose to be public defenders because they believe in what they are doing. Some go on to become renown criminal defense lawyers. Others, not. But all do the dirty work of representing the worst amongst us, because that’s their job.
I came across an old Craigs List posting the other day. I found it on Volokh, of all places. I sent it to Gideon because it was rightfully his. It is politically incorrect, as many good things are, but expresses the reality of being a public defender awfully well. And it’s very funny to boot. But since Gideon didn’t use it, I’m taking it back and offering it here. Check it out.
To Gideon and all public defenders, we recognize and appreciate what you do for the system.
