Author Archives: SHG

Who Is Adam Liptak And What Is He Doing?

I was a big fan of  Adam Liptak’s  columns in the New York Times.  But my fanaticism has worn thin.  This week, it wore out.

First, I wondered who Adam Liptak is.  Obviously, he’s a guy writing a column for the Times, but what does he bring to the table that justifies him writing a column for the Times.  After all, it’s a pretty influential gig, and frankly I’d never heard of him except for his column.  So, I did what any self-respecting hard-working lawyer would do to investigate a subject.  I clicked on his  biography page on the Times website.  This is what I learned:



Mr. Liptak returned to Yale for a law degree, graduating in 1988. During law school, he worked as a summer clerk in the The New York Times Company’s legal department. After graduating, he spent four years at Cahill Gordon & Reindel, a New York City law firm, as a litigation associate specializing in First Amendment matters.





In 1992, he returned to The Times’s legal department, spending a decade advising The Times and the company’s other newspapers, television stations and new media properties on defamation, privacy, news gathering and related issues, and he frequently litigated media and commercial cases.


Yale.  Cahill Gordon.  The Times.  Okay, he’s no dummy. 

So why did he write the piece,  “ Does Death Penalty Save Lives? A New Debate “?  When I first saw this piece, I thought to myself that this is big, huge even, given the political climate around the death penalty and coming from none other than the Grey Lady herself.  But as I read the piece, and read it again, I realized that there  was here.  It was designed to incite dispute and inflame passions, but it didn’t say anything.  My problem is that Liptak has raised tossed a red flag in front of a bull over nothing.  Who the hell is this guy?  Oops, I already asked that, didn’t I?

Nowhere in this column does Liptak provide the slightest clue about the basis for, and hence the merit of, the economists’ claim that there is a decrease in homicide rates commensurate with an increase in executions.  It’s an incendiary claim, and it cannot be made without showing the evidence.  But Liptak presents the bald conclusion, bolstered by somebody’s personal political anti-death penalty agendas (to show lack of bias), and gives us zero information as to how this inflammatory conclusion was reached.  Who the hell is this guy?  Yeah, I know.

On the back end of the piece, Liptak includes this nugget:

The studies have been the subject of sharp criticism, much of it from legal scholars who say that the theories of economists do not apply to the violent world of crime and punishment. Critics of the studies say they are based on faulty premises, insufficient data and flawed methodologies.

So is there any validity to this study that just tossed a match into an ammo dump?  Who knows?  After all, these are economists, not legal scholars, and we can’t begin to discern the legitimacy of their studies from the column.  Maybe they have something.  Maybe not.  But don’t throw the debate open without putting the beef on the table.

So let’s bottom line it.  Liptak writes in the New York Times that there is a real debate based upon scientific studies that the death penalty may save lives.  But there is nothing in this story upon which the reader can begin to decide whether this is true or total nonsense.  If you’re going to inflame a controversial situation, then at least write a story with some substance.  Don’t just throw bombs.

I am really not an Adam Liptak fan at the moment.

Ex-Judge David Gross Sentenced

When Nassau County District Court Judge David Gross  was arrested in one of the most bizarre and ridiculous schemes I’ve ever heard of, it was hard to believe.  Last Friday, he  was sentenced to 33 months, the bottom of the guidelines.

When you’re a judge committing crimes, you need to say something at sentence.  This is what David Gross had to say:


“I stand before [the court] a broken man, full of remorse, guilt, shame and regret,” said Mr. Gross, adding that law was his life-long passion.

He said a turbulent life led him to befriend individuals involved in organized crime.

“My despair and frustration led me to seek distraction in a fantasy life,” the ex-judge said.

What’s he talking about?  What “turbulent life” drove him to “seek distraction in a fantasy life?”  No word on that in the story, but talk like this disturbs me well beyond the incredibly stupid crime that he committed. 

David Gross was an elected judge.  Ironically, United States District Court Judge Arthur Spatt, who was about to sentence Gross, had this to say:

The office of district judge, Judge Spatt said, “was one that I myself never attained, even though I tried three times. The position of a judge in our society is a prized achievement and brings with it the responsibility of total integrity and honesty.”

Spatt ran for the job three times.  He lost.  Gross ran for the job once.  He won.  Not a good showing for the voters of Nassau County, one of the most politically-bound places on earth.  If the prevailing party put Mickey Mouse on the ballot, we’d be calling “him” your honor.  It’s that simple.

But how does a person who is so psychologically fragile, so badly messed up, get to wear the black robe?  Do we need to put judicial candidates through some serious psych testing before they get to lick envelopes in the party HQ, and earn their way onto the ballot?

I never had a case before David Gross, but I met him and talked to him socially while he was on the bench.  He seemed like a good guy.  There were no overt signs of such deep desperation that he would be unable to resist the compulsion to engage in criminal conduct in his “fantasy life.”  What other judges have a “fantasy life” to overcome their “despair and desperation,” and just how sick and warped are these fantasies. 

These judges are given the power and duty to make decisions about the lives of other human beings.  The responsibility is huge.  The obligation to do so appropriately is huge.  Does this case suggest that the types of people who are seeking the position need to come under far more scrutiny by far less political people before they can be trusted to sit in judgment of others?  I believe it does. 

That David Gross made it onto the bench is an indictment of a system, not just a man.  There are no excuses that make this okay.  We cannot have judges living out their fantasy lives in black robes, and we cannot have a system that is incapable of distinguishing the good and competent people from the warped and criminal ones.  It’s just not good enough.

Reader Mailbag

A new feature that I’m introducing today, and may be repeatedly daily, weekly or may never be repeated again, is the reader mailbag.  This consists of emails I’ve received or wanted to receive, and feel like posting about.  If you have questions for the Reader Mailbag, feel free to send them.  Whether or not I respond depends entirely on my mood at any given time.

And now, for our inaugural email:


Greenfield,

Why do you write so much?  I can’t keep up with it because I have a life.  Have you ever considered getting one?

Very nice thing to write to me.  I can’t wait to get a call to get your butt out of the lockup after one of your drunken Federalist bacchanalias.

Here’s the deal.  I post between 0 and 6 pieces a day.  Some days, it’s a struggle.  Most, I could write about a dozen posts and still have more to say.  My problem is that I like to write and do so relatively quickly.  I spend about an hour a day on this blawg, and since I wake up in the middle of the night (as I have for years) and there’s nothing much else to do, this seemed as good a way to spend my time as any.

Before this blawg, I used to ghost write editorials, op-eds and letters to the editor for a number of organizations and individuals who wants to appear to have something meaningful to say but lacked either the mind or the hand to make it happen.  Since I can crank these things out, and have the occasional viewpoint that might be of interest to others, it was a natural for me.

I grant you that I post more than most other blawgs, including those groups blawgs that take 10 lawprofs to get a handful of posts out a day.  Sorry.  If it’s too much, then don’t read it.  What else can I do?  Just scroll down on my front page and see what, if anything interests you.  But I have a hard enough time already trying to keep my posts down to around 4 a day.  There are just too many things I feel like writing about.  In fact, I probably leave about 4 posts on the table every day just to avoid being a monumental bore.  According to my darling wife, I may not be very successful on that last count, but I’m trying.


Greenfield,

Your blawg is like the ugliest, lowest tech blawg in the whole blawgosphere.  Would it kill you to put a little effort into making it look better.  Also, which one is you in the pic in the upper left corner?

Now, I am embarrassed to admit this, but I’m really a techno-Philistine.  My purpose was to put something in writing, and it never dawned on me when I started that my blogging program stunk.  What did I know?  I don’t even have an iPhone.  I assume that I could do a whole lot better with some of the programs used by others, who know something about technology, have a better eye for design or just got better advice than I did in the first place.  But I don’t and I didn’t.  Mea culpa. 

The problem now is that the time and energy it would take to change things would conflict with my adoration of inertia.  Sure, I could turn to someone smarter and more savvy than I to make Simple Justice soar, but then I would have to spend time thinking about things that just don’t matter to me.  So my solution is to stick with content and blow off appearance.  One day I’ll do something about, if I’m not too busy staring at those pigs in the sky.  Until then, cut me a break and live with it.

Well, that covers the full extent of my emails that I want to post about.  Keep those cards and letters coming.

What’s Your Score?

Norm Pattis posts about The Sporting Theory of Trial.  Every trial lawyer who has been around long enough to forget his last trial knows about this one.  It’s the one where some wag challenges you to tell the world what your “score” is.

What score?  That’s how many cases you won.  How many notches on the gun you’ve racked up.  You see, people think that we’re baseball players and they want to know if we’re Barry Bonds (A Rod?) or some utility outfielder in the minors.  Just check the back of our baseball cards for our stats and you’ll know whether we’re any good, right?

Well, this upset Norm a bit, as well it should.  This is not a sporting event, and we’re not players out there in a fair game.  We don’t mind this fact, since it’s what we signed up for, but we really hate having to explain ourselves over and over.


Not long ago a potential client asked me my won-loss record. I told him, truthfully, that I had no idea. I know I’ve tried more than 100 cases, but I do not recall many verdicts. Of those I recall, some surprised me. I’ve won cases I thought I would lose, and I have lost cases I expected to win. I can’t promise any client that a won-loss record will shed any light on the outcome of his or her case. Each case is different. Sometimes a mountain of facts can yield only a valley of despair. All a client can and should expect is dedication and hard work.

Potential clients ask questions like this all the time.  You can’t blame them for wanting something firm to grasp, as their lives are on the line and they want the greatest assurance possible that they are making the right choice, not to mention that you’re worth what you’re asking.  How better than to get the box scores?

But Norm (as usual) is right.  We don’t play on a level field.  Some cases are relatively easy, some are very difficult.  Some go better than expected and others go worse.  Some of us take on the most serious cases while others just plead ’em out as soon as the money runs dry.

If you want to know whether the lawyer is any good, there are two questions to ask yourself.  Does he know what he’s doing and will he fight for me to the end.  Other than that, the score card means nothing.  You’re hiring a lawyer for his or her “dedication and hard work,” as Norm says, and I would add his or her skills.  That’s what we have to offer.  If a lawyer can remember his score, chances are that he hasn’t been around long enough to remember or he’s just full of baloney.  Hey, you wouldn’t know if it was true anyway.

Building The Practical Law School

Susan Cartier Liebel at Build a Solo Practice points out a survey by The National Jurist that tells us that the things that law students want are a little different than the things that lawprofs want out of a law school. Well, there’s a shock.

Does anybody but  Jim Chen notice that the gap between what law schools are supposed to do and what the schools are seeking to do is growing?  If you make an effort to stay on top of the things that lawprofs are concerned with, versus what people who have a slim sense of reality about the future of the legal “profession” (and I use that word cautiously), you can’t help but recognize that law schools have gone way down a path where they are no longer connected to a mission that has anything to do with preparing students to become lawyers. 

Who supports this direction, other than the law schools themselves?  Apparently, Biglaw does, for they seek out the handful of students from the grandest of the grand law schools and pay them salaries and bonuses (and extra bonuses) that bear no relation to any skills, competence or services.  Somehow, Biglaw convinces themselves (and their corporate clients) that paying some kid who knows zip about the law more money per hour than the multinational CFO gets is a sound business practice. 

But that still leaves the vast majority of law students at all those embarrassingly lower tier schools out in the cold.  These schools, like the grandest of the grand they hope to emulate and, if the stars align, join in the U.S News and World Reports rankings so that they too can puff out their tweed-covered chests and speak in scholarly tones, have no reason to exist.  They can’t get their grads into Biglaw, but still fail to teach their students how to be lawyers.

And so Susan has inspired me to come up with an entirely new concept in law schools:  The Practical Law School.  I plan to name it “Scott’s Law School.”  It will have more buildings than any other law school in the world.  Each of my buildings already exists and has the word “courthouse” in its name.  My lawprofs will be forbidden to publish in law reviews, because no one except other lawprofs read them anyway. All scholarly publications will have a caption on them and be submitted to a judge for “peer review.”

Students won’t be required to send in LSATs for admission.  They need only show up on a daily basis, dressed appropriately for our courtrooms classrooms, and meet the established criteria for paying attention, answering questions when asked and keenly observing what happens around them.  A lecture will be held daily over the lunch break where they will be expected to discuss how to win a case.  If they can find their way to the courtroom without getting lost while holding a heavy briefcase, they get an A for year 1.  By year 2, they should be able to figure out how to win a case.  Year 3 will be crunch time.  The students must demonstrate mastery of dealing with clients, judges and adversaries and be capable of developing a strategy that serves their clients needs.  Students can specialize in Year 3 through the use of going only to specific buildings, floors and courtrooms where particular areas of law are practiced.

There will be no tuition for my law school.  But if you can’t cut it, or act obnoxiously or unethically, I’ll know right away and the student will be sent packing.  It won’t be easy to make it through Scott’s Law School, but at the end, you will be able to be a lawyer. 

And by the way, we won’t have any department to help you get jobs.  If you were any good at Scott’s Law School, you won’t need one.

Keep The Junk Science To Yourself

Between the  Washington Post and 60 Minutes, the word is now out that bullet lead analysis, used for 40 years to put people away, is garbage.  Well, there’s a shock.  Yet another surprise from the FBI Lab, “the best forensic lab in the world,” that has no science behind it. 

It sounded like it made scientific sense.  There was this official feel to it, that the lead in bullets was metallurgically certain to show that a bullet came from a particular batch or box of bullets.  Whenever somebody with an official scientific title uses words like metallurgy, it’s impossible to believe that they just made the whole thing up.  Hey, it’s not like us lawyers know what happens inside those little black boxes.

But the fact that another domino falls in the forensic science path to conviction isn’t the end of the story.  The story goes on because our friends at the FBI, the ones who are there to protect us from injustice, neglected to let us know that they’ve been using junk science for the last 4 decades.  Oddly,  a letter was sent out to police, prosecutors and criminal defense organizations.   

Put aside the issue of whether sending a letter to an association is the same as sending it to the lawyer who represents the defendant, because it wouldn’t matter anyway.  You see, the letter didn’t tell you that the science was junk and the testimony false.  They left out that part.  Nowhere does the letter let the cat out of the bag.  It didn’t mention that bullet lead analysis was officially debunked, but merely that the FBI “will no longer conduct the examination of bullet lead.”  Not quite the same thing.

Why?  Well, the head of the FBI lab apparently didn’t think it was his place to expose the fraud to the people harmed by it, but he was happy to admit it on 60 Minutes: 


Tobin says the Quantico lab was the only place in the country that did bullet lead analysis, and the assertion that you could actually match a bullet fragment to a specific batch or box of bullets went unchallenged for 40 years — until Tobin retired in 1998 and decided to do his own study, discovering that the basic premise had never actually been scientifically tested.

“FBI lab personnel testified that you could match these fragments to this bullet,” Kroft remarks.

“Yes, that’s correct,” Tobin says.

Asked what he found out, Tobin tells Kroft, “It hadn’t been based on science at all, but rather had been based on subjective belief for over four decades.”

“So what you’re saying is that this is junk science?” Kroft asks.

“That’s correct,” Tobin says. “It’s worthless as a forensic tool.”


Note that it’s not just  inadequate. It is worthless, as in they made the whole thing up.  Oops. Sorry.  Never mind 40 years of testimony.  It was worthless.  Our mistake.  I’m sure they feel just as bad as all the people in jail for that period of time.  Why am I being so sarcastic?  Because I believe this is true of much of the purported science and expert testimony that is proffered at trial to convict people where the evidence of guilt doesn’t exist, and that the players in the system are more than happy to turn a blind eye to garbage testimony rather than demand that this extremely harmful evidence be subject to serious scrutiny before it become ingrained in criminal justice culture.

Personally, I’ve never had a case where bullet lead analysis was used.  But if you did, or do, now would be a good time to reach out and do something about it. 

It is my practice at trial to question the underpinnings of scientific and expert testimony for validity.  Judges find this terribly annoying when it relates to long held beliefs.  If some other court let it in, it must be good science.  And when it’s debunked, nobody seems to feel all that bad about the fact that they were “had”.  I find this disturbing.  No one else in the courtroom seems to be bothered at all.  I’m no scientist, but I refuse to disengage my brain whenever some “expert” takes the stand and says so.

So even if you this lead bullet analysis has no application to you, consider this as yet another warning shot across the bow of the prosecutions adoration of junk science.  Juries love to blame science when they rush to convict.  And all you judges who are so enamored with science, perhaps you will begin to take some of those objections and requests for hearings just a wee bit more seriously.  Please.

Thanks to reader Adam Militello, Buffalo Law School 2007, for the heads up on this story.

Too Tough In The Media Can Also Be A Problem

I’ve avoided the Barry Bonds steroid indictment (up to now) because baseball isn’t my thing.  But this report from the  San Francisco Chronicle (thanks to  Eric the Turk for bringing it to my attention) is worth discussing, not so much because of the Bonds connection, but as a lesson in handling the media while defending a high profile case.

Michael Rains is Barry Bonds lawyer.  He knows that his client is going to draw media attention no matter what he does, or doesn’t do, and that the attention itself can cause his taint his client forever.  Once the stain attaches, it is almost impossible to wipe it away.  Even if a trial results, and Barry Bonds is found “not guilty,” he will never be found innocent.  That’s the American way.

Rains has a tough job.  He must both represent his client as a lawyer, and represent his client as a sports celebrity under the scrutiny of the media that feels no constraint of truth, accuracy or reliability.  You see, once someone says something bad about your client, the rest of the media get to repeat it and it becomes part of the myth of the story.  Not because it is true, but merely because it was said. 

The situation is very different for celebrity clients than non-celebrity clients.  The media attention doesn’t fade because the lawyer lays low and there’s nothing to report, and the harm to their reputation is going to happen as the “story” develops around them.  Trust me, the “myth” becomes your worst nightmare, even though there may be no truth to it at all.  Repetition of false information makes it more real than anything else.

So Barry Bonds placed his life in Michael Rains’ hands, and Rains came out slugging. 


From the start of the BALCO steroids scandal, Michael Rains, Barry Bonds’ aggressive defense lawyer, took a tough line.  Bonds never used steroids, Rains declared, and the former Giants star never lied to the grand jury about his drug use.  As federal agents investigated Bonds for perjury, Rains mocked the effort: The government had no evidence, he told reporters, and prosecutors would suffer a humiliating defeat if the case went to trial.

Rains’ approach was at the extreme end of the “tough lawyer” spectrum.  While not mentioned, it would come as no surprise to learn that they had a “crisis management” PR person in the background advising them to be as hard and clear as possible to counter the allegations.  Why?  Two reasons:  first, if there was any equivocation, it would be perceived as an admission of guilt and the harm to Barry Bonds career would be done.  Second, there’s no appeal from the court of public opinion.  You win or lose the first time.  Game over.

But the Chronicle article then challenges Rains’ position by offering this alternative:


The wiser course, these experts said, might be to negotiate with the government in hopes of striking a lenient plea bargain calling for little or no jail time.

From the sublime to the ridiculous.  Whoever “these experts” may be, they should lose their ticket and never be allowed anywhere near a client.  This statement is one of the most ridiculous I’ve ever seen.  “Hey, Barry, instead of challenging the allegations and making every effort to preserve your career and reputation, why not waltz down to the United States Attorney’s office and beg them to destroy your life and everything you have ever done.  It could save you a few months in prison.”  Yeah, there’s a firm grasp on priorities, not to mention the possibility that maybe he isn’t guilty.

Did Michael Rains go too far?  Probably.  There’s a line between a clear and firm denial of wrongdoing and a challenge to the government, both agents and prosecutors, to nail your client’s butt to the wall.  It is always wise to allow your adversary a back door, a way out of a confrontation without losing face.  It is similarly wise to leave yourself a back door, because you never know when you may need it.  Absolute positions tend to come back to haunt people, and are almost never necessary to make your point. 

While there are times when confronted by the media that things get contorted or misreported, and it comes out very differently than you expected.  Perhaps that happened to Michael Rains.  But if so, then it needs to be corrected through reporters who can be trusted to report fairly and accurately.  You get to know who they are with experience, and who can’t be trusted as well.

Given the circumstances, Rains may well have been too extreme in his media defense of Barry Bonds.  But then, given that Bonds’ reputation is on the line, and his primary concern is likely to be to preserve his future in baseball history rather than shave a few months off the top of a sentence, his tact was understandable.  But now that Bonds is indicted and has to deal with charges in a real court, Rains needs to reassess his strategy and find a way off the edge.  Hopefully, he thought of that as his mouth was moving in his pre-indictment statements.  If not, he’ll find that it can be a very long drop off the edge.

As for the rampant and baseless speculation as to whether Barry Bonds knowingly lied under oath, I’m in no rush to decide.  I can wait for the trial.

Teach Your Children Well

With the holidays coming up, a lot of kids from college or the ‘burbs go to New York City to see the sights and have a good time.  Most do.  Some get themselves mixed up in problems and learn that life in the big city is a little different than in their small towns, where they view themselves as sufficiently important that they can talk back to cops and throw their weight around.

What plays in your home town, where mommy or daddy are well-known and cops try harder to get along with the locals, does not play in New York City.  More importantly, the consequences of getting in trouble in the Big Apple involve a very unpleasant 24 hours, starting with the whupping you might get from a cop who doesn’t appreciate the fresh mouth of some smart-ass kid to the serious beating (or worse) that may happen in a holding cell where some regular New York City residents may have no tolerance for suburban arrogance.  This can be very serious stuff.

I planned to write about how to conduct yourself when you have an encounter with police, but in cruising Jon Katz’s  Underdog blog, saw this video, Busted, from flexyourrights.org.  It is quite long, but extraordinarily good.  This is a video that every high school and college student should see.  Ira Glasser, former Executive Director of the ACLU, does the hosting duties and provides a superb, easy to understand and clear explanation of what to do and how to address police encounters under a variety of circumstances.  There is only one point that I want to add to the video:  Cops are not required to tell you the truth about anything.  They can lie to you and this is perfectly legally acceptable.  Know it and get used to it.  It is what the courts call “an effective law enforcement tool.”

I seriously urge every student to watch this, and every parent to make their children watch this video.  It would also be wise to send it to your favorite social studies teacher to show their class.  It really is that good.  Below the video, I get back to the subject of surviving an arrest in the City



Having had the pleasure of representing young suburban men and women who found themselves enjoying the hospitality of the City of New York, I’ve come to develop a few rules to live by, and to assure that you will continue to live following your encounter with New York justice.  The following are my 10 rules for suburban kids to survive arrest in the Big Apple.

1.  As discussed in the video, under no circumstances are you to talk back to the cops, and never are you to touch a police officer.  Even a hand movement toward a cop will give him or her an excuse to beat you, and you should assume that they will.  You can complain all you want later about the beating, but rest assured that the courts will accept the cops’ word that you attempted to assault him or her.  The system is very protective of cops, like the NFL is of quarterbacks, and will err on the side of the cop every time.  Never do it.

2.  You are no longer an important person.  You are no longer a person.  You are now a perp.  Perps are treated like the scum of the earth.  If you try to assert your importance, or that you’re not a criminal, or that you don’t like the way you’re being treated, you are asking for lesson on where you stand in the scheme of things.  You will not like the lesson.  You may not like being “disrespected”, but you’re going to really hate being “disrespected” and beaten or purposefully humiliated. 

3.  You will be placed in a variety of holding cells along the road to arraignment.  There may be other people in the holding cells, and they are not your peers from the suburbs.  You are no longer the prom queen or the editor of the school newspaper.  You are defendant in a holding cell.  The other people in the holding cell will not admire you or show you deference.  They may see you as easy prey, and they have the ability to do your enormous harm.  Do not ask for any favors from anyone, for there is a price for everything.  Do not assert yourself to anyone.  If you try to show them how important you are, you are begging for them to show you who’s boss.  Inside a jail cell, the nice kid from the suburbs is not the boss.  Be polite to everyone but keep to yourself.  The lower your profile, the better off you will be. 

4.  If something bad happens inside a holding cell, do not expect the cops to jump in to save you.  They aren’t going to risk their safety for you.  It’s just as easy for them to pick up the pieces after its over, and remember, you are not a human being, just a perp.  One less perp in the world won’t make them lose any sleep, especially if you brought it on yourself.

5.  Maybe they will let you make a telephone call, maybe not.  This is not television.  There is little that appears on TV that bears any resemblance to real life.  If you get a call, call someone you know to be home and tell them you’ve been arrested, what time it happened, where it happened, what they “allege” you did and ask them to get you a lawyer.  This is the critical information needed to find you in a big city system.  There is nothing more you can do to help yourself, except to keep yourself alive and safe until you get to an arraignment before a judge.  Do not expect to speak with an attorney until you arrive in the courtroom.  The system is not set up for lawyers to show up at police precincts like they do on TV. 

6.  As has been repeated here and elsewhere, over and over again, memorize these magic words and repeat them every time a police officer speaks to you:  “I do not want to answer questions. I want to speak with my attorney.”  Do not change any of the words. Say them exactly this way.  These are magic words.

7.  You will be asked “pedigree” questions which you are required to answer, even though you’ve said the magic words.  This includes your name, address and basic identifying information, as well as being photographed and fingerprinted.  If you use a false name, no one will be able to find you in the system.  Before arraignment, you will meet with a representative of the criminal justice agency, part of the court system, who will ask you this information again, as well as employment information and contact information.  This information is critical to your being released from custody at arraignment.  Provide accurate information, and give a contact number of someone who they can reach to verify your information.  If you have a stable home, job (school) and they can verify what you’ve told them, they will recommend to the judge that your be released without bail. 

8.  It takes about 24 hours to go from arrest to arraignment.  Inexplicably, callers are told that defendants will be arraigned in “a couple of hours” after arrest by the police and court personnel.  This never happens, and family members find themselves sitting in the arraignment parts (New Yorkese for courtroom) for many long, dirty, smelly hours.  By going to the courthouse prematurely, no one is home to answer the call from CJA to verify the information you’ve given.  Most importantly, your family will lose the opportunity to hire a lawyer because they fear that they will “miss” the arraignment if they don’t rush to the courthouse immediately.  Twenty-four hours from arrest to arraignment, no matter what th
ey say.

9.  If you are struck, beaten, sexually assaulted or otherwise hurt and ask to be treated, the police will take you to a city hospital where you will sit and wait for a very long time.  You will not be arraigned within the general 24 hour period, and may well take another 24 hours or more before you see a judge and have a chance to speak with an attorney or be released.  If you really require medical attention, then do whatever you have to do.  But if you are just being whiny, or have a bruise from being pistol-whipped, or a few broken fingers, these injuries will hold until you are arraigned.  After your release, you will be able to get treatment on your terms rather than theirs.  Consider whether you really want to delay arraignment before you ask for medical treatment.

10.  Once you get to arraignment, you will have a lawyer.  If someone has retained counsel, great.  If not, your lawyer will be a public defender or an assigned lawyer.  This lawyer will be given the paperwork in your case, including the complaint (the crimes you are alleged to have committed with the factual basis for the charges), your rap sheet and the CJA form.  Remember this lawyer’s name and get his or her card, even if you expect that you will hire a private lawyer later.  This enables your private lawyer to get the paperwork from the arraignment lawyer.

New York City is one of the greatest cities in the world, and everyone should have the experience of the holidays in New York.  But in the rare case that something very bad happens, it’s better to be prepared. 
. 

The Biggest Federalist Issue In Law Today

The Federalist Society knows stuff.  Apparently far more than someone like me (and I note again for the record that they did not invite me to their big celebration, though it could have just been an oversight).   How do I know this is big?  The Big One.  Mr. Big?  Because they want a constitutional amendment about it.  And you don’t amend the Constitution over small things.  That would be Democratic, like that equal rights amendment thingy.

So what is the Big One?  Is it putting innocent people to death?  Is it convicting innocent people on flawed eyewitness ID?  Is it having more people in prison than any country on the face of the earth?  Nope.

Obviously, you aren’t Federalist Society material either.  Shame.

No, the Big One, demanding an amendment to the Constitution of the United States of America is . . . relying on foreign law in American court decisions!  That’s right.  This is the gravest evil facing our society.  And you were worried about weapons of mass destruction?  Get a life.

I learned about this at Volokh, where all important Federalist news comes out when it doesn’t involved embarrassing photos (for that, I turn to Above The Law).  The argument is (in my deeply abbreviated version) that when our forefathers wrote the Constitution, they were trying to break away from foreigners and their law.  So, it only makes sense that our courts shouldn’t be allowed to rely on it. 

As I read it, I had a day dream.  Having heard oral argument at the Supreme Court in the very important action of Dog Poop Girl v.  Solove (if you read The Future of Reputation, you’ll know what I’m talking about here), Justice Greenfield (it is my dream) hears of a decision by a french court on how to remedy the disastrous issue of privacy on the internet.  In France, they call it “le internet,” but it’s really the same thing.  I read the decision and it’s brilliant.  It creates a cause of action and procedures that perfectly balances the rights and needs of all parties, including the chilling affect on everyone else on both sides.  It is perfect.

But I can’t use it.  It’s French, and the Constitution forbids my use of foreign law.  I discuss the problem with my fellow Federalist/Libertarian Justices, Bennett, Gideon, Black, Matlock, Malum, Katz, Guest and Other Steve.  We all agree that as much as the French decision solves everything, everything, our integrity precludes any reliance on foreign law. 

And you wonder why they won’t let me drink the good wine in a tuxedo at the Federalist Society soiree.  I am definitely not Federalist Society material.

Sentencing Reform – Who Needs Judges Anyway?

Last May, I wrote about  New York’s latest foray into improving criminal justice with a new sentencing reform commission.  Not to blow my own horn, but I nailed it again.  When you put together a “blue ribbon” commission of prosecutorial-types, the ones who government officials love to appoint, you get the results you expect.  I would love to claim that I’m just so darned brilliant, but it was plain from day one that the outcome of this “reform” going to hurt.

And so, let’s take a look at what our reformers have come up with, shall we?  This report rightly notes that New York’s byzantine sentencing structure is in dire need of reform.  So what’s the answer?  Simplify.

The executive summary tells us that if we simplify the sentencing scheme, it will be more “streamlined” and fair.  This, of course, sounds great.  Fair is a wonderful thing.  But then, fair is subjective.  Whose idea of fair are they talking about?

There’s an early clue:  The commission wants to “strengthen the State’s statutory and regulatory scheme for crime victims.”  Uh oh.  The commission report tells us later that crime victims need to have a more “meaningful voice” and the State needs to strengthen the “rights” of crime victims.  Are you beginning to see the direction where this reform is heading?

But the meat of the recommendation, promoted by claiming that it would make sentencing “intelligible, honest and fair,” is to change over New York’s current system of indeterminate sentences to determinate.  Simplify.

What does this mean?  It means the sentence to be imposed will be taken out of the hands of judges and placed into the hands of prosecutors.  Why?  Because 98% of all sentencing happens as a result of plea bargaining rather than trial.  And the prosecutor will now dictate a determinate sentence as part of the plea offer.

Consider the explanation of Henry Steinglass, President of the New York Criminal Bar Association:


Elimination of indeterminate sentences transfers to prosecutors the power to set the amount of prison time as a condition of pleading down to a lower level felony. For example, before the elimination of indeterminate sentencing for most “violent” felonies (enacted in 1995 and 1998), a guilty plea in a murder case with a one-level reduction to Manslaughter in the First Degree allowed the prosecutor to condition consent on an indeterminate  sentence which would usually be 8 1/3-25, 7-21 or 6-18 years in prison (assuming no predicate felony). And, even if the person receiving such a sentence was denied parole, he/she would be released (“max out”) after serving 2/3 of his sentence (16 2/3, 14 or 12 years).

The change to determinate sentencing has given prosecutors the power to choose a  sentence anywhere from 5 up to 25 years as a condition of the same one-level down  guilty plea. For example,  if the prosecutor offers a  17 year sentence, then the defense can attempt to persuade the prosecutor to offer 15 or 14 years, or some other number but, in the end, it is the prosecutor who sets the specific number of years for the sentence and the defense can either accept the final offer or go to trial. This example also indicates how the  change to determinate sentencing results in a sentence roughly equivalent to “maxing out” under the previous, indeterminate sentencing structure.

There are many who will ask what’s wrong with these “reforms”.  After all, victims’ rights are in fashion these days, and we’ve long since lost any sense of proportionality when it comes to criminals.  Frankly, we should be happy that this commission didn’t just recommend life without parole for anyone convicted of any felony at all. 

This is indeed a simple solution.  Simple means clearer and longer.  Let’s just call reform what it is, a way to put people in jail for as long as possible, according to the best judgment of an assistant district attorney.  If this is what you call reform, because there weren’t enough people in prison for enough years, then this is one great concept.

So as I anticipated, this “blue ribbon” sentencing reform commission has given us a better system that just happens to put people in prison longer under the control of the prosecution.  If we get any more “reform” in New York, expect to see the death penalty back in place.

ADDENDUM:  Holy smoke.  What was I thinking.  I apologize.  Here I am, patting myself on the back so hard that I blew it completely.  I am wrong.  There is no problem with determinate sentencing.  There is no issue with putting sentencing decisions in the hands of young prosecutors, vindictive or otherwise.  No, no, no.

The is a solution, an answer if you will, that is as “intelligent, honest and fair” as if this solution:  Don’t Plead!  It dawned on, belatedly, that Henry’s issue is no issue at all.  It presumes that everybody will do as they are doing now, pleading guilty.  There is nothing whatsoever forcing anyone to do this.  Get a good lawyer and fight.  If you didn’t do it, try it.  If you don’t like the deal, refuse it. 

Lawyers, stop taking a plea fee and start honing your cross.  Pretend you’re a real lawyer and prepare for trial.  The ADA doesn’t take you seriously?  Do you think that has something to do with the fact that you’ve never actually taken a case to verdict?  There’s no problem here.  Just announce ready for trial and then do it.