Author Archives: SHG

Broken Courts – Non-Lawyer Judges Must Go

One of New York’s peccadilloes is that you don’t have to be a lawyer to be a judge in our local courts.  This was the focus of a series of New York Times articles, calling them “tiny courts” with “abuses of law and power.”

These are New York’s town and village courts, or justice courts, as the 1,250 of them are widely known. In the public imagination, they are quaint holdovers from a bygone era, handling nothing weightier than traffic tickets and small claims. They get a roll of the eyes from lawyers who amuse one another with tales of incompetent small-town justices.

The NYT quote is a little misleading (as newspaper reporters too often are) in that these justice courts have preliminary jurisdiction over serious criminal case, including murder, setting bail and pre-indictment proceedings.  In other words, these non-lawyer judges preside over people’s lives in the most serious situations as well as the trivial.

These aren’t the places where big-time New York lawyers practice, but where ordinary people go in large numbers outside of the cities to deal with their more mundane problems and issues.  So while they aren’t likely to be involved in any precedent setting cases, the impact of justice courts run be non-lawyers on the lives of ordinary people can be pervasive.

The argument in favor of keeping this archaic system is that the qualities that make up a good judge, being fair, independent and ethical, are personal ones, unrelated to a legal education.  There is a deeper federalist sense to it, however, where tiny governments run towns and villages like little clique fiefdoms with little people swelling with petty power want to maintain iron-clad control over their tiny piece of earth.

The stories of abuse of power, gross impropriety and ignorance in New York’s tiny courts are rampant.

And several people in the small town of Dannemora were intimidated by their longtime justice, Thomas R. Buckley, a phone-company repairman who cursed at defendants and jailed them without bail or a trial, state disciplinary officials found. Feuding with a neighbor over her dog’s running loose, he threatened to jail her and ordered the dog killed.

“I just follow my own common sense,” Mr. Buckley, in an interview, said of his 13 years on the bench. “And the hell with the law.”

This is a fairly typical example of the problems faced in a justice court.  But that’s not to say that the locals aren’t happy this way, as shown in this 1994 article detailing the example of Laurence Hancock, then 83, a non-lawyer judge in Dutchess County.

When he was first elected in 1937, he conducted court in his mother’s kitchen, was paid $5 a case and settled a half-dozen civil complaints each week. These days, there is a gleaming courthouse in town and Mr. Hancock dons a black robe before hearing a nearly endless stream of cases. But little else has changed in 56 years: Judge Hancock still pounds his fist like a gavel and throws his voice like a punch. And the voters are clearly satisfied with his decisions; he has won 14 consecutive elections, including several races against lawyers.

The judge becomes a known quantity and is often respected by his neighbors, who are hardly put off by the fact that justice is meted out by one of their own.  They tend to reflect a sense of rough justice that meets the expectations of the locals, who generally fair well in court with their neighbor on the bench as long as they are all friends.

On the flip side, things don’t always go as well for others passing through the jurisdiction, or those who aren’t friendly with the judge or reigning regime.  But then, one could well argue that the same is true with lawyer judges, who have proven that they too can show favoritism, demonstrate inappropriate temperament and engage in wrongful, even criminal conduct.  A law degree hardly make a person immune from abusing power.

Faced with the New York Times series and the multitude of examples of justice gone awry, Chief Judge Judith Kaye issued  an action plan (pdf) to deal with justice courts in November, 2006.  This action plan created a new position of a “supervisory judge” to oversee the justice courts and their non-lawyer judges.  But avoiding controversy, non-lawyer judges remained in place.

In October, 2006, President Barry Kamins of the New York City Bar Association formed a task force to consider the justice courts and the systems “action plan.”  Last month, the task force issued  its report.

While the tone of the report is even, the meaning is significant.  Non-lawyer judges have fundamentally ignored all the “niceties” of the Constitution, law and procedure that we squabble about every day.  Indigent defense is virtually non-existent.  The cop who made the arrest or issued the ticket is tapped to negotiate and prosecute the case, and this would be a local cop with whom the judge is quite cozy and comfortable.  Since the justice courts often meet only a once a month, preliminary hearings (without lawyers or interpreters) will happen when they get around to it.  The list goes on.

The concepts of due process, constitutional protections and even what constitutes basic fairness to either the untrained sensibilities of non-lawyer justices or the tyranny of the power-hungry locals.  Of course, they don’t see it that way.  There is a sublime irony in ignorance; you don’t know what you don’t know.

While locals may enjoy, indeed prefer, rough justice as meted out by one of their own, and believe that the law should not be so complicated that it requires years of schooling and experience before one is prepared to deliver it, non-lawyer justices are not up to the task if we expect justice, as we understand it, to happen.

Unfortunately, the task force report accommodates the lack of political will of New York’s court system and Legislature in ridding the state of this farce.  Rather than calling for the elimination of non-lawyer justices, it attempts to provide a work-around in criminal matters that would transfer criminal cases to real courts with real judges.  See Recommendation 1, page 31.  According to one’s standpoint, this reflects a practical acceptance of the fact that New York is not going to buck the desires of locals to maintain control over their courts, or an abdication of responsibility to assure that a court system function in a manner consistent with the law and Constitution.

There are some practical problems with requiring justice courts to have lawyer judges, primarily stemming from the lack of lawyers in rural upstate counties willing to serve (since it impacts on a lawyer’s ability to represent clients before those courts).  But these problems seem to militate more in favor of eliminating courts that can’t function properly rather than accommodating them.

There are a few inevitable conclusions that must be made in light of the overwhelming evidence from numerous sources.  First, non-lawyer judges are unable to perform their function consistent with the law and Constitution.  They simply don’t know how, even if they are so inclined, and there is no quickie training solution that will provide these justices with the training and experience necessary to mete out justice in any cognizable fashion.

Second, the desire for local justice reflects a serious threat in a constitutional democracy.  Justice is not what the local residents want at any given time against any given defendant.  The year of one’s life in jail in an upstate county is still a year in jail.  The garage mechanic, or housewife, or librarian justice is not equipped to sentence another person to incarceration based upon local feelings of rage or retribution.

Third, and most importantly, the entire concept of local government bears a closer resemblance to a “banana republic” than a Jeffersonian image of America.  While local residents may willingly subject themselves to incompetent and ignorant management of their affairs, and the taxation that pays for it, defendants before their courts have no voice in the decision.  It is fundamentally wrong to subject people to a system of justice with the same power as a legitimate system but neither the qualifications nor competence to fulfill its mission.

It is time to put an end to non-lawyer justices in New York.  It is time for the Chief Judge to stop pretending to be a politician and start acting like the head of a legitimate court system.  And it is time for the New York State Legislature to demonstrate the political will to end a dangerous archaic system.

Of course, this won’t happen.  No one has the will to tell the unpleasant truth.  Instead, we pander to the lowest common denominator.  Again.

Dennis Kozlowski’s Conviction Affirmed

In a 4-0 decision, the Appellate Division, First Debarment  affirmed the convictions of L. Dennis Kowzlowski and Mark H. Swartz.  Newsday, in fine journalistic tradition, had this to say :


A state appeals court said Thursday it disagreed, upholding the 2005 convictions of ex-CEO Kozlowski and former finance chief Swartz. Their massive theft and purchases of such luxuries as a $6,000 shower curtain came to symbolize corporate excess and cupidity.

It’s always the shower curtain.

There’s nothing particularly notable about the decision, almost entirely based on the court’s determination that the evidence of guilt was sufficient to show not only the procedural requirements of the gazillion dollar bonuses were not met, but that the defendants had no substantive entitlement to the money regardless.  Of course, it didn’t help that they took a bunch of forgivable loans for one purpose, spent them on silly nouveau riche stuff and looked damn foolish.

But there is one interesting aspect.  Here’s the list of lawyers for the appellants: 


Martin & Obermaier, New York (John S. Martin of counsel) and Stephen E. Kaufman, P.C., New York (Stephen E. Kaufman and Andrew Kaufman of counsel) and Bryan Cave, LLP, New York (James R. DeVita, Austin V. Campriello, Beth Brandler, Cari Sommer and Kathryn E. Gebert of counsel), for L. Dennis Kozlowski appellant.

Stillman, Friedman & Shechtman, P.C., New York (Nathaniel Z. Marmur, Michael J. Grudberg, Lara A. Shalov and Mary Margulis-Ohnuma of counsel), for Mark H. Swartz appellant.

Here’s the lawyers for the respondent:

Robert M. Morgenthau, District Attorney, New York
(Amyjane Rettew and Gina Mignola of counsel), for respondent.

There aren’t enough seats at the appellant’s table in the First Department for that many lawyers, including former federal judge John Martin and former United States Attorney Otto Obermaier.  Big guns got beat by some public servants.  I wonder what happened to the shower curtain?  No, I didn’t change sides, I just find it interesting when the whitest shoes in criminal defense get all scuffed.

Lindsey Lohan Serves 84 Minutes

Lindsey Lohan, who was cute as the dickins in the Parent Trap, was ordered to serve a 24 hours sentence as part of a plea agreement to cover two DUI.  She turned herself in at 10:30 a.m. and was out 84 minutes later.  Justice, apparently, was served.

Lohan was quoted as saying, “Thank God.  I left the Ferrari running.”  She immediately quaffed down some warm apple cider and vowed to return to the fine young woman she was before she left Long Island for her new left coast home, Sodom.

Coincidentally, I am wearing shoes purchased the same year that Lindsey Lohan was born.  My shoes are still a comfortable fit and look pretty good with the occasional shine.  Same with you, Lindsey?

Note:  This apparently happened yesterday.  I promise hereinafter to keep better abreast of celebrity happenings. Me bad.

Note To Schumer: Judges Don’t Have To Be Prosecutors

The way it works, senators recommend people to the executive for appointment as judges within their states.  In New York, the senior senator gets 3 to the junior senator’s 1.  Our junior senator, of course, is the vivacious Hillary Clinton, the quintessential New Yorker now running against Rudy Guiliani, some rube from wherever people marry their second cousin.  Oops.  Well, they will be running against each other soon, anyway.

What is most important about New York’s senators is that they are both Democrats.  This means that they will scour the countryside looking for judicial appointee candidates that reflect the finest of Democratic traditions.

So why are all the people selected either Biglaw or prosecutors?  Hey Chuck, there are other people out here too. 

Today, I note that Charles (that’s what Chuck’s called in the media) Schumer announced the nomination of Cathy Seibel, deputy to Southern District U.S. Attorney Michael Garcia, for a judgeship in the Southern District of New York.  Now I don’t know Cathy Seibel, and I’m sure she’s eminently qualified, but she’s a prosecutor.  Chuck, you’re a Democrat.  Would it kill you, Chuck, to think outside the box?

Sure, I can appreciate that President Bush isn’t going to take well to anybody whose view of criminal justice is shy of Attila the Hun.  After all, what are the chances he’s going to appoint some activist, liberal, pinko commie judge, right?  But why do you have enable this? 

Thinking back, when George W. Bush was governor, we still didn’t have anyone who wasn’t a prosecutor or Biglaw nominated for the New York City federal bench.  How do you explain that one, Mr. Democratic Senator? 

Lots of talk about the constitution when you’re shooting at the other side, but when you have the ability to do something about it, you’re picking judges off the same list that Alfonse D’Amato was using when he was in your shoes.  Of course, even Al was more concerned about getting a fair criminal trial in New York, if only for selfish family reasons.

Come on, Senator Schumer.  Be a Democrat already.  There is a whole world of lawyers who aren’t Biglaw or prosecutors who would bring ideals to the bench that you are supposed to support.  Give them a try.

Criminal Law, Or Law At All?

One of my favorite readers, Other Steve, scolded me for being so down about the practice of law.  He wrote that I was harping on the “sad reality” of it all, but never opined whether OS (as I like to call him) should become a criminal defense lawyer or not.  I admit, I’ve been a bit negative lately.

David Giacalone at  f/k/a suggested that my low expectations of lawyers reflects a deeper negativity than his.  Don’t you love negativity contests?  Given enough time, one has the chance to see things change.  From my experience, things have changed for the worse.  In criminal law.  In law.  But my low expectations mask my idealism. 

The reason I write about the “sad reality” is that I wake up every morning hoping for better.  I write this dopey blawg every day because I want to contribute to better.  I want to be part of the solution instead of the problem.  The official world that actually runs stuff doesn’t like people like me because of this.  They just want to maintain sufficient credibility that the world is doing fine to keep their important positions.  I point out problems that they would prefer not be noticed.

But OS asks a good question, and as difficult as it may be, I should try to give him a worthy answer.  Other Steve, why be a lawyer at all?  I was checking out  Moneylaw and saw this link to Paul Gowder’s  Law and Letters post.  He makes some very good points. 

When I was in college, law school was the option for kids who couldn’t hack medical school but wanted to be a professional so they could enjoy a reasonably comfortable life.  We were promised respect and a good living.  At the time, the law was still a profession, though changes were clearly happening and, in retrospect, we were already pretty far down the slippery slope already.

The practice of law, in my eyes, has been divided into two distinct realms.  One is the business of law, as reflected by Norm Pattis’  Lady DUI billboard and lawyers taking $1,500 felonies to try to pay the rent.  The other is the moral high ground, the truest purpose of law, to serve our society.

The business of law is ugly and rotten.  Worse yet, there just aren’t that many lawyers making that comfortable living they were promised, and the price they pay for the big bucks at Biglaw is very steep indeed.  Want to ever see your children again?  It’s hard to do when you’re cranking out 20 billable hours a day, with any misstep being the precursor to being tossed out on your equity partner ear by your comparably avaricious brothers and sisters.

And what of the righteous?  Look around you.  They bang, and bang, and bang their heads against a very hard, cold, impenetrable wall every day.  Sure, we crow about the rare victory, but for every one of those is 10,000 cuts by the knives of stupidity, arrogance, laziness, pompousness and the fundamental lack of caring. 

We write about fighting the good fight.  We sometimes spout the platitudes that bring warmth and comfort to the quiet, huddled masses.  We try to give hope.  But we know that for all our efforts and persistence, most of the poor unfortunates who fall into the grasp of the law will end up miserable for one reason or another.

So, Other Steve, should you become a criminal defense lawyer.  Absolutely.  Not because you’re going to get rich.  Not because you will become part of a system that imparts justice and fairness to our society.  These are pipe dreams.  Myths. 

Do it because if you don’t, then the game is over.  If young men and women who still believe in doing the right thing for the right reason decide that there is no place for them in the law, then we have lost the war and succumbed to the lowest common denominator in our society.  I told you I was really an idealist.

Plus, there is nothing more fun that trying a case once you know what you’re doing.  And nobody other than a hard-nosed criminal defense lawyer really tries cases anymore, no matter what they claim.

Taking Note of Charging the Jury

In a mixed metaphor of law, Gideon at  A Public Defender picks up a piece by  David Feige of Bronx Defenders about a juror speaking out after a trial conviction.  According to the Staten Island Advance, a teenager was convicted of gang assault because at least half the jury misunderstood the court’s charge.

The newspaper story includes this bizarre paragraph:


Note-taking by jurors is at the discretion of a trial judge, and like many of his colleagues, [Judge] Collini doesn’t allow it. He asks jurors to rely on their observations of witnesses and their recollection of testimony.

It’s not strange because of its content, but because it has nothing whatsoever to do with the problem encountered by the jury.  The juror claims that they didn’t understand the judge’s instructions.  It seems that they were quite clear that they didn’t think the defendant personally stabbed the victim.

The portion of the charge that confused the jury, which was repeated by the court at their request, strikes me as being pretty straight forward. 


Justice Robert J. Collini had instructed jurors to find Cammarano, 18, guilty of gang assault only if they determined he had stabbed 14-year-old Richard Orloski. (Emphasis added)

There are many aspects of the standard jury charge that have long seemed to render the legal fiction, that jurors understand and do what they are told, a farce.  After all, if lawyers can’t agree on what the charge on “beyond a reasonable doubt” means, how should jurors be able to do so?  But this portion seems clear and straightforward.

The strange twist in the Advance story is that the error is blamed on the judge’s decision not to permit the jurors to take notes during trial.  This is the aspect that Gideon picks up on.


With so much at stake, wouldn’t the interests of justice be best served by the jury accurately remembering the testimony? Memories are faulty, so shouldn’t we aid in their recollection by at least permitting them to take notes? What is this resistance to taking notes?

That’s one way to look at it.  On the other hand, “with so much at stake,” shouldn’t the jurors be paying close attention to the testimony and demeanor of the witnesses?  If they are busy writing, they are not listening or watching the witness. 

We put 12 people on the jury because we want 12 individuals to concur before a conviction.  If one juror takes notes of a critical statement and others don’t, that witness and his notes could become dispositive in the jury room.  He becomes a “super juror” and the others defer because he has the notes.  What if his notes are inaccurate.  Not everybody takes perfect notes.  And it is highly unlikely that notes reflect verbatim testimony.  More likely, they reflect impressions of what happened, not what actually happened.

There is always an aid for imperfect recollections in a trial.  It’s called the transcript, taken by the court reporter, and can be read back to the jury at any time, and as many times, as needed.  The jury never has to guess at what was said.

There is something special about putting words to paper, memorializing them in a way that makes them more “official”.  Just like people believe whatever appears in a newspaper, no matter how wrong or silly, they believe what’s in writing for no better reason than it is.  It could be dead wrong, but if it’s in writing, you can’t argue with it.  The judges who allow note-taking instruct the jurors not to simply accept another juror’s notes as being dispositive of what happened, but we already know that instructions don’t have their intended effect.

I’m not as big a fan of jury note-taking as Gideon.  I want them listening and paying attention, not looking at their notepad scribbling away.  It’s hard enough for a juror to digest what’s happening in front of him in real time when they are paying close attention.  When their attention is diverted, I fear that they will miss too much. 

Not that this has anything at all to do with the erroneous conviction of a Staten Island teenager for gang assault.

What To Do With Murderers?

Under New York law, the sentence for a garden variety second degree murder is fairly clear.  The lowest sentence available is 15 years to life.  The highest is 25 years to life.  One thing is clear:  He’s going to prison.  The Legislature has not given the courts any other option.

But not so in Texas.  A curiosity, since the perception we have of Texas is that there’s line waiting outside the door of the death chamber.  If a New York lawyer had to take a guess at the sentencing options for a Houston murder, we would be inclined to guess gas chamber, lethal injection, electric chair or public hanging.  Pick ’em.

Not so.  In fact, just yesterday lawprof Daniel Solove at  Concurring Opinions posted about an option that could never be had in New York:  Probation.  Imagine that, in the land of death, convicted murderers can receive probation!  According to  Dallas Morning News, even politicos didn’t realize that probation was an option for murder because it was so rare.


It happens “probably once in a hundred years,” Rep. Harold Dutton told the House Committee on Criminal Jurisprudence in March. Committee chairman Aaron Peña said he didn’t know probation as a sentence for murder was legally possible.

Not surprising, really.  We’re talking about a top of the line crime.  Murder is serious stuff.  It doesn’t get any more serious.  It would seem that probation for murder would be the rarest of sentences possible, only occurring in the rarest of cases.  From my New Yorker’s perspective, where probation is generally unavailable for a simple gun possession, this is a most extraordinary sentence.  Frankly, I can’t even imagine how it’s available.

Between 2000 and 2006, probation was the sentence a total of 120 times in murder cases.  But this includes plea bargains, a benefit to prosecutors who want to use the sentence as a carrot to dangle for cooperation.  The story doesn’t say how often a defendant receives probation after a trial conviction.  You would have to believe this would happen far more rarely, since few murders give a jury (yes, the sentence would be impose by a penalty phase jury in Texas) that warm and fuzzy feeling that makes them want to put the murderer back out on the street immediately.

And by the way, the Texas Tornado, Mark Bennett, who suffered  a major blow when his client was convicted of murder a couple of days ago despite a hard-fought defense, got back on the horse the next day to try the penalty phase.  No time to feel bad about the conviction, Mark still had work to do.

Bennett’s client was convicted of murder.  His sentence: Probation.  Not too shabby.  It could never happen in New York, an enlightened state.

Practical Blawgosphere: Some Days Are Worse Than Others

Mark Bennett took a huge risk.  When he started  live-blogging his trial, he gave us a window into how things were playing out in his mind.  In the beginning, you never know how the trial is going to go, and we had no idea what the view through the window was going to show us.

As the trial proceeded, the view looked quite lovely.  Mark was making his points.  He was nailing his cross.  His adversary was getting angry and venting.  All the signs of a well-tried case.  And we all know what a well-tried case means, right?

For those of you who said to yourselves, it means “not guilty,” you haven’t been paying attention.  As Other Steve comments yesterday, I’ve been “posting a lot lately about the sad reality of criminal defense.”  There is no more painful reality of criminal defense than the bad verdict.

Those of you who don’t try cases won’t understand.  You can do everything possible.  You can do a great job, a superlative job.  And still, when the verdict comes, you stop breathing and your heart stops beating and you stand there a wait.  Then comes the verdict.

Mark’s jury came back.  The verdict was guilty. For a few seconds, it feels like someone just punched you in the chest.  You can’t breath.  You can’t believe what you just heard.  You want to hear it again to be sure.  You play it over again in your mind to make sure you heard it correctly.  Guilty.

There is an intensity and focus that happens during a trial that is beyond anything else a human can do.  I’m sure people feel it in other endeavors, but I don’t know of any.  And as you accomplish the goals you are trying to achieve, you believe that it will rationally follow that it will produce the end result that you’re seeking.  You must believe.  There is no other way to try a case than to believe.  The second you lose faith, all is lost.

But despite this belief.  despite the efforts and accomplishments, trying a case is not scored witness by witness, argument by argument.  It is a winner takes all proposition.  You can be up 27 runs to nothing and it doesn’t matter.  You can do everything right and it doesn’t matter.  Only one thing matters.  The verdict.

Maybe there was nothing that Mark could have done, or nothing that anyone could have done, that could make the men and women on that jury do anything other than convict.  Maybe the bottom line is that we live in a society that just can’t believe that anyone could be put on trial by the cops for murder if they weren’t guilty.  Maybe trial lawyers delude themselves into believing that the devastating cross was enough to show the jury the truth, when there’s nothing that could have saved the defendants. 

We rarely know what happens in the minds of the jurors.  I’ve harped on this point again and again, the last time only yesterday.  But I can tell you about what happens in the mind of the lawyer.  The trial lawyer stands before the jury naked, putting everything he has into his representation.  It’s a deeply personal contest, a referendum on him as a lawyer.  When that verdict comes in, it’s a verdict on him, not the defendant. 

We know it’s really not.  It just takes a few days before the shock and adrenalin wears off.  We’re heartbroken.  But losing is part of the game.  No criminal defense lawyer wins every case.  We know this rationally.  We realize that every time we roll the dice, we’re less likely to role a 7 than another number.  But we refuse to accept it because we believe that our skill, drive and will can make those dice come up 7. 

So Other Steve, this is another sad reality of criminal defense lawyering.  Despite doing everything right, we sometimes lose.  And when we do, it is unbelievably depressing.  It stinks.  I know Mark Bennett will get past it, as do we all.  But today, he must really feel like crap because he did such a great job.  Hang in there, buddy.

Eugene Volokh Must Be Goofing With Us

I must have read  this post over at the Volokh Conspiracy 3 times to make sure I read it right.  Eugene Volokh, lawprof extraordinaire, posts about Howard Dean (boo, hiss, evil Democrat) talking to the Jewish Telegraph Agency.  Here’s the excerpt:


“This country is not a theocracy,” Dean said. “There are fundamental differences between the Republican Party and the Democratic Party. The Democratic Party believes that everybody in this room ought to be comfortable being an American Jew, not just an American; that there are no bars to heaven for anybody; that we are not a one-religion nation; and that no child or member of a football team ought to be able to cringe at the last line of a prayer before going onto the field.”

Does this strike anybody as being unclear?  Well, it must be, because Volokh understood it to mean this:


Now I think I understand the message Dean is trying to convey. Many American Jews (the audience here was the United Jewish Communities’ general assembly) are uncomfortable with many traditionalist Christians’ expressed views that only Christians can go to heaven. I can understand why they are uncomfortable with those views: They worry that people who think non-Christians are going to Hell will act badly towards non-Christians in this world as well, not a certain connection but a plausible one. Dean wants to tell Jews, and others, that the Democratic Party welcomes non-Christians.

Come on, Gene.  You’re goofing on us, right?  You plucked that one word, heaven, out of context and just totally ignored everything else?  Are the rumors that Volokh is hooking up with Ann Coulter true?  Nah.  Can’t be. 

Now Eugene Volokh is a very smart guy with some very peculiar politics.  But that doesn’t mean that he can’t read English.  I mean, after all, the guy’s a lawprof.  Well, even so, that doesn’t mean he can’t read English.

So because of my libertarian tilt and general tilt toward kindness to strangers (and it doesn’t get much stranger than this), I hereby appoint myself Eugene Volokh’s sign language interpreter on behalf of Howard Dean.

Here goes.  Gene, Howard is not doing a compare and contrast between the beliefs of Jews and Christian.  He’s talking about Democrats, regardless of what their religion may be.  What he’s saying is that Democrats of any denomination should feel comfortable with their religious beliefs consistent with Democratic Party principles.
Think of “ich ben ein Berliner.”  We are all Democrats.  Get it?

If you read the rest of the quote, Howard gives it away when he says, “no child or member of a football team ought to be able to cringe at the last line of a prayer before going onto the field”  You probably don’t go to a lot of sporting events, so I’ll help you out with the analogy.  You see, somebody usually says a prayer of sorts before many of these sporting events, and they are generally very nice prayers, like “God loves our team better than their team, and so we will win this [select sporting event] because God wants us to.” Up to this point, it’s something with which every sports fan can readily agree.

But when the person saying the prayer is Christian, they sometimes tack on something at the end along the lines of, “in the name of our lord, Jesus Christ.”  Uh oh.  That’s where the cringing starts.  Why go and spoil a perfectly good prayer by making it denominationally specific?  We were all there together, feeling good, ready to kick butt in the name of the Lord, and then one phrase and all the Jews on the football team in the stands feel like you went and pulled the rug out from under them.  Was this really necessary?  It’s perfect for Church or at home, but at the stadium? 

Howard is saying that it’s not necessary, in order to be a Democrat, to go that extra step to exclude anyone who doesn’t share the same faith.  Howard is saying that people can have their religious beliefs without making them the cornerstone of their political beliefs.  In fact, Howard is saying that the exclusionary religious beliefs have no place in the Democratic Party.  You’re getting all this, right?

This is not a shot at Christians.  It’s a way to include anyone who is not Christian.  Sure, each of us would like it best from a religious point of view if the rest of you would just go without way of doing things, but then we would be Iran and Howard would be the Ayatollah.  We’re not and he isn’t.  Howard’s offering a Democratic Party that lets us all have our beliefs while not adopting any particular one to the exclusion of any other one. 

Still, Gene asks:


So how then can Dean assure Jews, or anyone else, that “The Democratic Party believes … that there are no bars to heaven for anybody”?

Because, as Howard said in the beginning, America is not a theocracy.  Whether one religious group believes that to be the case doesn’t matter.  This is about politics, not religion, and the Democratic Party does not subscribe the idea that this is, at its base, a Christian nation.  Was this really unclear to you? 

Now you probably don’t like the Dems all that much, and that’s okay.  But can we not try to mangle the meaning of everything, even something as innocuous as this, to try to start a religious war when the whole point is to open the doors of a political party to people regardless of their religious beliefs?  I still think you were messing with our heads.

What’s Old Is New For Criminal Defense Lawyers

Thanks to a reader (who prefers to remain nameless), comes this follow up to my post about my buddy Steve.  Talk about timely.   This article, originally from New York Magazine, quoting just about everybody who’s anybody in New York City criminal defense (except notably yours truly).  At the end of this post, I’ll tell you about the little twist.


Criminal-defense attorneys maintain that, with the exception of the most minor offenses or the most serious — and when the accused is a celebrity — actual trials are almost rare now. Changes in the legal system have given prosecutors the power to exact extraordinary penalties from defendants who choose to go to trial and lose. The deck is so stacked against defendants who plead innocent, they say, that the average defendant doesn’t have the luxury of taking his case before a jury. Why fight, when the chances of victory are small and the penalty for losing is huge? Everyone is looking for a deal.

Sound familiar so far.  Read on:


“Defense lawyers really feel like they have no job anymore. It’s like all the lawyering’s been taken out of being a lawyer,” says Ellen Yaroshefsky, a professor at Cardozo law school.

And, of course, it means that the demand for high-price legal-defense talent has dried up. Not only do the lawyers get to try cases much less often, but their fees have been steadily falling as well. Since many accused criminals know as soon as they’re arrested that they’re going to make a deal, why spend a lot of money to hire an expensive private attorney?

Your still with me, right?  So what’s my old friend Diarmuid White got to say about it?

Some of those who’ve stayed have become so uncomfortable representing cooperators that they’ve actually begun to refuse to do it. “I view my role as a criminal-defense lawyer as a buffer against the state and a watchdog on abuses by the prosecution, the police, and the judges,” says Diarmuid White, who’s been practicing nearly twenty years. “When you represent a cooperating defendant, you’re actually sitting down with the government and helping them make cases against other people, and I don’t think that’s good for our democracy. I won’t do it. I lose business, but I sleep well at night.”

Take that, Gideon.  But we’re not done yet, not be a long shot.

Even the gregarious Murray Richman has lately taken a distinctly gloomy view. “I now tell young people not to go into criminal law,” says [Murray] Richman, whose own daughter Stacey has been practicing with him for five years. “I tell them it’s a dead end, that there’s no future in the criminal-justice system for a young lawyer today. To me that’s truly, truly heartbreaking.”

“Because of what’s happened to our role in the system, nobody takes defense lawyers seriously,” says Richman. “We’re looked at as money-grubbing, mean-spirited people who are trying to screw the government and get guilty people off.”

So what’s the little twist here?  This article was published on March 10, 2002, more than 5 years ago.  And here we are, debating the same sad state of affairs.