Author Archives: SHG

When the Expert Knows Everything

Stephen Gustitus at the Defense Perspective posts about a study from UC Berkeley about how the credibility of the over-confident witness is easily destroyed when he makes a mistake.  Since the defense usually has no witnesses to events willing to step forward or testify, the most likely witnesses are the defendant and the defense expert.

Stephen’s post got me thinking about defense experts.  Just the word “expert” makes me wince.  They scare me.  Mostly, they scare me because they’re mine and when they take the stand, the defense is saddled with whatever they say and whoever they are.  It isn’t always pretty.  I’m always more comfortable ripping apart someone else’s witness than watching someone else rip apart mine.

My first problem with experts is that they want to sell me, the defense lawyer hiring their services, on how wonderful they are as an expert in order to justify the ridiculous fees they charge for testifying.  By ridiculous, I mean many times what they would charge for the same amount of time spent “doing” whatever it is they will be testifying about.  They love to tell you about how their brilliance won this case and that, and how the prosecutor wilted in the face of their devastating testimony. 

As soon as I hear this, I start to shake.  This expert wants to be the shining knight who rides in to save the day.  He knows everything.  More than anyone (incuding me), he’s going to get on that stand and there’s no stopping what comes flying out of his mouth.  The problem of witness cockiness isn’t an issue with this kind of person; it’s an inevitability. 

Sometimes, the issues in a case are clear enough that you know what you will need from an expert far in advance.  This allows you time to find exactly the right expert for your case, and to send the overly-cocky expert packing.  In a perfect world, we have plenty of time to find, interview and prep our experts, and sufficient funding to retain exactly the right expert for our case.  Not only will our expert possess the right credentials, and have the best substantive knowledge of the issue, but he will bring gravitas, sincerity and humility to the witness stand.  When this happens, it’s a thing of beauty.

But we are frequently faced with unknown testimony at trial, where we don’t know that the prosecution will bring in an expert or the particular thrust of the prosecution’s case on an area where expert testimony by the defendant will be proper.  This doesn’t happen this way in all jurisdictions.  It does in New York, where our discovery rules are useless and we are frequently sand-bagged at trial.  In New York, you just learn to live with it because you don’t have a choice.

When this happens, you are left to find an expert in the middle of trial, often overnight for testimony the next day.  This complicates matters.  At this point, you struggle to find anyone who you can get into the courtroom the next day, has the basic qualifications to be allowed to testify as an expert and will provide the testimony you need. 

You prep the expert whenever you can find the time, often in the evening or early morning.  This is when you learn about how the cockiness is going to come out, how they are going to take the stand and pontificate about how they know everything.  Your immediate reaction is to send them packing.  This is not a person you want testifying for your side.

They start making overbroad and hyperbolic assertions, which makes them easy targets on cross.  They don’t answer your questions, but instruct you on matters that they think are important.  They don’t take direction well.  Sometimes, they don’t take direction at all.  And they can’t see that they don’t come off as brilliant and irrefutable.  They come off as obnoxious blowhards.

In preparing experts under these circumstances, the criminal defense lawyer walks a fine line.  If we try to force them to tone it down, we risk their being insulted that we don’t appreciate their brilliance and their walking off the job, leaving us without a witness.  On the other hand, if we are not sufficiently clear and forceful about the problems with their substantive testimony or their demeanor, we risk the cocky expert who can potentially sink the defense.  Putting the blowhard on the stand as your witness reflects on the entire defense, and the jury’s dislike of your expert translates to the jury’s dislike of the lawyer, and ultimately, the defendant.

If you’re hoping that I have a solution for the cocky expert, I’m about to disappoint you.  When I find myself in the position of having to find and prep a last minute expert, I just pray that he doesn’t screw it up.  My defendant may have no idea that the demeanor of an expert counts, and they tend to like the overbearing expert because his confidence in himself instills confidence in the defendant.  But once you put the expert on the stand, there’s little you can do to control him.  Just pray that he paid some attention to you, and that he will demonstrate a little humility on direct before it’s rammed down his throat on cross.

Update:  A snippet from a post by Bob Ambrogi at  Legal Blog Watch that just fits into this post so well:


Notably, Thomas responds to critics who said she should have used an expert witness at trial. She planned to, she says, but then could not afford the expert’s fees. She explains:



“I did have an expert. This expert did inspect my computer and was going to testify for me at trial. That was originally the plan, until I couldn’t come up with the money for my expert during the trial. Another thing most people don’t know is the defendant is responsible for paying expert witnesses their hourly rate during the trial and providing for their food and board while at the trial. My attorney was able to secure that expert witness at a very reasonable rate, but I wasn’t able to afford this rate during the entire trial.”


Experts.  Sigh.

2007 Best Law Blog Update

In case you were wondering, Simple Justice is  killing them, if you think of murder as the end product of rolling on the floor laughing your . . . well, you get the picture.

As I write, it’s a shoot-out between Above the Law, David Lat’s salacious site about Biglaw salaries, financed by some headhunter company called lateral file, and the Volokh Conspiracy, a group blog by libertarian lawprofs who think Alberto Gonzalez was a weenie.  As for Simple Justice, we’re in 9th place. 

On the bright side, Sui Generis comes in at a respectable 8th with more than twice the votes we have.  That’s because Niki is a whole lot better looking than me.  Big deal.

Remember, you can vote once every 24 hours from every computer you (and everyone you know) have.  Consider it a mercy vote, since I’m desperate not to come in dead last and thus humiliate the criminal defense blawgosphere while the neo-cons win the day.  Click the Weblog Awards button on the left and vote, vote, vote!  Hey, if Volokh can hype this thing daily, why can’t I?

The Unworthy Opponent

It’s not that I have a horse in this race, or that I am personally charged with discrediting scoundrels across the land, but this just plain old offends me.  What, you ask?  The final round to advertisements by my good ol’ friend, Jon Budelmann. 

It seems that Budelmann was feeling some heat for his acting like human garbage (Am I being harsh? Yes. Upon reflection, this was too harsh) inappropriately, so he put out two new commercials to leave nothing to doubt.  They can be found  here and here.

               His opponent, when working as a criminal defense attorney, tried “every trick in the book.”

That, voters of Cayuga County, is because he’s a criminal defense attorney, one step below the devil.  Evil lawyer.  Evil. 

This crap was tried in the last Binghamton, NY mayoral race, but the residents of the metropolis smacked the jerk silly for trying to smear a candidate because he served as a criminal defense attorney.  But will it work in Auburn?

Well, according the very conservative Auburn Citizen, usually addressing the vital concerns of sidewalk cracks and stray cows:


We must admit to being disappointed in Bass’ attempts to create scandal where there is none.

We agree Budelmann should not have run an advertisement in which a crime victim, John Turner (who works as an independent contractor for this newspaper), thanks Budelmann for putting his attacker away and points out that Bass represented the attacker.

But no reasonable person can watch this advertisement and conclude that Budelmann believes some defendants shouldn’t have a right to counsel, as Bass has tried to suggest.

That wasn’t what Bass tried to suggest.  He tried to suggest that Budelmann’s ad was an overt effort to paint criminal defenders as the facilitators of perpetrators of heinous crime.  So is the Citizen saying that although Budelmann was wrong, they’re disappointed in Bass?  Well, yeah, that’s exactly what it says, provided you don’t get caught somewhere in the middle of the logical gap.  Sheesh, if it doesn’t involve a cow, the Auburn Citizen is over its head.

Let this be as stated as clearly as possible.  Criminal defense attorneys are a necessary and important part of the criminal justice system.  They serve the public interest as much as any prosecutor.  Good, ethical prosecutors know this.  Budelmann and his ilk can bite me.   Now it’s up to the good people of Cayuga County to decide whether they are as stupid as Budelmann treats them.

The Economics of Baiting the Rat Trap

Mark Draughn, our Windypundit, may not be a lawyer, but he is one smart cookie.  The snitching debate here, and oozing around the blawgosphere, has captured his attention, and he’s decided to take a look from the outside looking in and figure out why, by economic analysis, anybody would want to use a lawyer like  Bennett (or me) rather than Pattis.

Windy asks, what’s in it for the client when the lawyer refuses to represents rats?  At first blush, it would appear that Norm’s position, that cooperation is one of the weapons in the criminal defense lawyer’s arsenal and it is wrong to refuse to use every resource to help a client, would bring his all the clients.  The converse, that any defendant who chooses to be represented by a lawyer who doesn’t do snitches must, be definition, be stupid.

Of course, it doesn’t work out that way, so Windy figures there must be another reason why defendants would choose a no-snitch lawyer.  He comes up with two rationales:  Signaling and Commitment. 

By signaling, Windy means that it’s a way of letting others know that while defendant is facing 30 years, he’s not going to flip.  His friends, family and benefactors get the message, and can breathe a sigh of relief.

By commitment, Windy is saying that a defendant has, by virtue of retaining the rat-free lawyer, made a overt commitment to fighting rather than snitching.

I told you Mark is one smart cookie.  He’s quite correct, but his theory needs a little bit of tweaking to fit properly.  Both signaling and commitment are sides of the same coin.  To appreciate how they work, one needs to understand how certain aspects of a defense comes together.

When a defendant is arrested and selects a lawyer known to flip his clients, this will become the strategy of choice for the government.  They will hold out the carrot of easy cooperation (but no promises!) to get your client to flip, and similarly use the stick of horrible plea offers and extreme accusations to prevent the defendant from fighting.  The government isn’t stupid either. 

When snitching is off the table, the tenor of the case is substantially different.  They know they’re in for a fight.  They know that the lawyer is not going to play dead, but will come in with every other weapon a’blazing.  The plea offer will be better, usually far, far better, when the only potential avenues are plea or trial.  They will charge the defendant differently when they know they are going to have to actually prove their case at trial, thus reducing the potential sentence. 

The government gets no free passes with the no-snitch lawyer.  If they blow off discovery or motions, or are sloppy, or deceptive, they stand to get the butt handed to them down the road at trial.  Since they know that trial is coming, they have to deal with the defense requests and demands seriously up front.  This means that the defendant will have better, harder information earlier, and whatever decisions are subsequently made will be based on real information rather than the prosecutorial hyperbole that the government might otherwise spoon-feed the defense.

But what of others, under Windy’s “signaling” factor?  There are two types of “others”, including the other gangsters who will sleep better knowing that a defendant won’t be a rat.  The more important “others” are co-defendants.  One of the primary impacts of snitching is that one’s co-defendant can almost always do far more harm to your client than the government can.  While you’re putting up the fight with the guy in front of you, the guy behind you is stabbing you in the back.  One fight can be won.  The second front (or back) is the one that brings everyone down.

I posted about a tale of two conspiracies.  This was the message.  Once the defendants turn rat, the defense comes apart at the seams.  When a defendant retains a no-rat lawyer, he signals to his co-defendants that he is in it for the long haul.  This means that they don’t need to spend the prosecution watching their backs, and if all of the defendants can hold together and resist the urge to implode the defense, they can fight. 

Similarly, the opposite is true.  When a defendant hires a lawyer known to have his own coffee-mug at the U.S. Attorney’s office, the foot-race to cooperate first is on.  Signaling happens in both directions, and the defendant who wants to fight the charges learns, just as his co-defendant would, that his brother-in-whatever is going to sell him out to save his own skin.  What point is there for an innocent defendant to do everything in his power to mount an effective defense if he is certain that his co-defendant will be the star witness against him at trial? 

Guilt has little to do with the decision when fear of the unknown is the driving force.  We have constructed a system when saving one’s own butt at the expense of others is the primary motivator.  Does anyone really doubt that a defendant will fudge a few details if it saves him 30 years in prison?  Of course, rarely does snitching result in avoiding prison, but the 30 years may come down to a mere 10.  But defendants only learn of that detail at the end of the case, well after they’ve sold their soul.

Windy’s final point is fascinating.  By his estimation, the no-rat lawyer would appeal more to the gangster, while the snitch lawyer would appeal more to the white collar defendant.  To a large extent, I find that to be true, but for different reasons.  Gangsters have a better understanding of the downside of life.  They understand that their bling comes from doing bad things, and they don’t cry as much about it when they get pinched.  It’s all part of the deal.

White collar defendants are innocent.  No matter how much money they stole, or who they hurt, they don’t see how that becomes their fault.  But even more than being innocent, they tend to be focused entirely on the bottom line.  While they insist on day 1 that they have done nothing wrong and demand that we win, a week later they want to know how to cut their losses.  Many just aren’t built for fighting, and when lawyers can’t give them a guarantee as if they were plumbers, and their wives are crying, and the feds just seized their yachts, a sudden urge for finality sweeps over them.  The quickest, easiest way to achieve a sense of finality is to snitch.  Further, it puts them inside the government, where the AUSA’s where school ties and sensible shoes.  They feel more comfortable in these surroundings, as if they are back on the side of truth and justice.

But this need for finality almost always changes soon afterward.  Once they come to terms with the fact that they’ve just given up all hope of winning, and that they are going to have to plead guilty and do some time, their smile fades.  They become morose.  They realize that they have just given their innocence away for free. 

Unfortunately, by the time they realize this, it’s too late.  The same desperation that drove them into the arms of the government now drives them to find a way out.  They grasp at straws. They wonder why all the Republican politicians to whom their campaign contributions were directed no longer answer their phone calls. 

They demand (they do a lot of demanding) the lawyer “fix” the mess they’ve made for themselves.  But the la
wyer’s been paid.  His job is done.  The white collar defendant is now firmly and irrevocably a rat.  His future is married to the government, and he finds his bride doesn’t love him as much as he hoped.  But there’s no divorce.  Till death do us part.

If John Ashcroft Says So, Then . . .

With the backing of New York Democratic Senator Chuck Schumer, the confirmation of Michael Mukasey will go to the full Senate, where he will be confirmed.  Schumer’s support comes with a simple explanation.  The AG nominee could have been a lot worse.  Faint praise.  I had hoped this would go very differently.

But why does it really matter?  After all, Judge Mukasey will be AG for about 12 minutes total before a new administration steps in with its own people.  Thankfully, John Ashcroft stuck his head out of his big fat hole yesterday to remind us why the AG counts.  In a New York Times op-ed, Ashcroft wrote to support immunity for telecoms who made the government’s life easier.

The immunity of telecoms for bending over to accommodate the Department of Justice and its campaign to wiretap “to protect us” from whatever it is they want us to be afraid of at any given moment has not received the attention it should.  It’s a big issue, and this may be the only way to spank industry for happily becoming a willing conspirator in the end of privacy.  Ashcroft explains:


Whatever one feels about the underlying intelligence activities or the legal basis on which they were initially established, it would be unfair and contrary to the interests of the United States to allow litigation that tries to hold private telecommunications companies liable for them.

Mind you, it’s not like our government, dedicated to freedom as it is, let us know that this was happening at the time.  It has to be secret, you know, or the terrorists win (or some such nonsense).  So when we learn of governmental indiscretion, there are only a few ways to deal with it.  One way is to go after those who facilitated it.  Not just to win some money, but to teach a lesson, to them and to those other entities that will be asked to “serve their country” in the future.

Have you seen those nice corporate statements about how company’s “care about our privacy?”  They ask us all sorts of personal information, and tell us how they will protect it for us.  We use them to keep our telephones working (in this instance), and our bank accounts, and our purchases, and our mortgages.  We understand why they might need so much of our personal information, but we expect them to live up to their word.  We expect them not to give it up for the asking.

Here, the asking was done by the government.  The President said they should do so.  The Attorney General said is was okay.  These are high governmental officials.  Ask them, they’ll tell you.  And when a high government official says “jump”, companies ask “how high?”


To deny immunity under these circumstances would be extraordinarily unfair to any cooperating carriers. By what principle of justice should anyone face potentially ruinous liability for cooperating with intelligence activities that are authorized by the president and whose legality has been reviewed and approved by our most senior legal officials?

So what do we expect of those corporations that control the means of giving the government carte blanch access to our private lives?  We expect them to say no.  We expect them to say that say that they will comply with a court order to do so, but not a mere demand from the executive branch.  We expect them to stand behind their promises and refuse the voluntary request that they be nice and compliant with our privacy.


If the attorney general of the United States says that an intelligence-gathering operation has been determined to be lawful, a company should be able to rely on that determination.

Even more important than the inherent unfairness of requiring companies to second-guess executive-branch legal judgments are the acute dangers to which it would expose the country. One of our nation’s most important comparative advantages over our adversaries is the creativity and robustness of the private sector. To cut ourselves off from that advantage would amount to a form of unilateral disarmament.

Ashcroft makes it clear: Corporate America is, in his eyes, a weapon of the executive branch, to be pulled out and used whenever the attorney general decides its ripe.  In the world of Ashcroft, there is only one real branch of government, and it is without limitation.  If the Department of Justice was prevented from using the assets of corporate American at will, it would be “a form of unilateral disarmament.” 

The consequences of this pathetic flag-wrapping are unlimited.  The government wants unbridled power to invade the privacy of any individual or group at will, and if reliance on the demand is sufficient to gain immunity, there is no business in America that will ever say no to the invasion of privacy again. Indeed, as with every act of government since 9/11, its justification is grounded in the government’s on-going exploitation of fear and couching compliance as an act of patriotism.


Assuming that the country’s communications companies helped the National Security Agency track Qaeda operatives and other terrorists after being assured that their conduct was lawful, they acted as patriots, not privacy violators.

Ashcroft’s day at the helm is over.  Michael Mukasey will be steering the ship of Justice, though he’s managed to make it this far without ever hearing of Chinese water torture.  He will assume the power to snap his fingers and make our privacy disappear.

Do I trust Michael Mukasey to safeguard my privacy better than John Ashcroft?  Yes, I sincerely do, but then again, my comparison sets a very, very low bar.  Nothing Ashcroft wrote makes me think that a decision by a neutral magistrate would endanger national security.  And nothing makes me think that the Justice-Corporate Complex is any less a threat to America than external attack.  The rot of ideals from the inside will pose a far more lasting threat to the foundation of our Constitution than any attack by foreign enemies.

Practical Blawgosphere: Can We Compete?

As some of you know,  Simple Justice was honored to be name as a finalist in the competition for Best Law Weblog 2007.  You will see a button on the left about it. 

Other finalists are major players in the blawgosphere.  These are the blogs of law professors, and the salacious elites.  They have been around for a long time, and have a lot of very dedicated fans.  They are going to eat me alive.  In the scheme of this popularity contest, we can’t compete.

How Simple Justice found itself in this company is hard to answer.  But it’s my belief that it represents the small, dedicated group that has formed what Mark Bennett coined the practical blawgosphere.  We are the practicing lawyers who blawg about the real world of lawyering.  We reflect small areas of practice, and we will never attain the greatness of a Volokh Conspiracy or the dirty pleasures of Above the Law. 

These other blawgs represent broader interest groups than inhabitants of the practical blawgosphere could ever amass.  And their numbers reflect it.  The biggest day of readership I’ve ever had at Simple Justice was when Orin Kerr at Volokh posted a link to the Flores decision here. 

So while it’s an honor to receive recognition, I do so on behalf of my brothers and sisters in the trenches, who spend some time posting on their blawgs to enrich the lives and understanding of others.  I am even more honored to be in their company, to be included in their blogroll and links, and to have their knowledge and experience to draw from in trying to come up with something worth saying every day.  These are my heroes (in no particular order):

Mark Bennett, Gideon, Jamie Spencer, Anne Reed, Shawn Matlock, Malum, Jon Katz, Robert Guest, Eric Turkewitz, Andrew Bluestone, Skelly, David Tarrell, Scott Henson, Norm Pattis, Ken Lammers, Stephen Gustitus and my co-finalist,  Nicole Black, without whose help Simple Justice might never have gotten off the ground.
 
We are not competitors for the eyes and minds of readers.  We are all small pieces to a puzzle that, when put together, hopefully adds up to something worthwhile.  Simple Justice will never be able to compete with the big boys, but we awfully damned proud to be part of the practical blawgosphere. 

If you want to vote, consider it a vote for this sordid group of misbegotten lawyers who toil to produce something for others to read.  I consider my good fortune to be a finalist to be a direct reflection of the efforts of my friends in the blawgosphere, because without them I would have nothing useful to say.

A Tale of Two Conspiracies

It started in Bronx Supreme Court, with 26 defendants and almost two years worth of wiretaps.  The wires captured plenty of chatter, including a call from me to my mother to wish her happy birthday on my ride home from an arraignment.  I was using my client’s cellphone because the battery was dead on mine.  In the course of my day’s work, I had forgotten all about my mother’s birthday, and my experience was that this was a very bad thing to do.  So I borrowed the phone and called.  She was very happy I did.

In the transcripts, I was noted as “criminal lawyer” and Mom was “unidentified female.”  The call bore the notation “possible code for narcotics.”  What a laugh I got out of that one.  The judge too.  He had a mother as well.

I represented the lead defendant.  We were able to find lawyers for all 26 defendants in the case, and the lawyers all knew each other.  While there were numerous big names on the case, they were all happy to let me do the heavy lifting and ride my coattails on the wiretap motions.  We held the group together, united in the belief that we could beat the case.  Not one defendant flipped.  Not one lawyer suggested that their client should flip.  They were facing 25 years to life, but they held firm.

Of the 26 defendants, one had a few grams of coke on him when he was picked up.  He got a bullet (local slang for a year).  The rest, including my lead defendant, walked.  It was a glorious outcome, and was the product of two things:  Hard work and the fact that the defendants stuck it out.

A year later, the defendants had a reunion.  Not at a nice hotel catering hall, but in the marshals’ holding cell at Foley Square.  The feds took the conspiracy, under the reverse silver platter doctrine, since they could.  It would have been a terrible shame to let all those perfectly good eavesdropping warrants go to waste.

This time, the defendants in the case were tapped out.  The cost of defending in the Bronx, and the loss of income during the course of the case, left most of them without the wherewithal to retain that exceptional group of lawyers who had done so well for them the first time around.  So, lawyers were appointed to represent them.  Others hired inexpensive lawyers with their limited funds. 

By the arraignment, a few defendants were missing.  By the next appearance, a few more.  Within a few months, there were only 3 of us left in the well.  We looked at each other with the recognition that what the government couldn’t do to our clients, their friends could.  We were sunk.  There was nothing left.

After getting a huge win on a motion to sever, I was able to create some real leverage for my client.  But he was a smart client and understood that the trial would be a parade of his closest and most trusted friends, all working for the other side.  He asked me, and I told him, that the only reasonable thing to do with his newfound leverage was to save himself.  He knew that I wasn’t the lawyer to do it, and thanked me for my efforts.  A new lawyer took over the case from me within a few days and when the judge asked me why I was seeking to be relieved, I explained that the defendant had chosen a different direction.  She graciously understood.

Would we have beaten back the conspiracy a second time in federal court?  Who knows.  But we never got the chance to find out.  The case was deeply flawed.  The eavesdropping was problematic.  There was little regard for the Constitution.  But none of this mattered once the defendants got on line outside the US Attorney’s office.

From what I’m told, this group of 26 defendants produced more than 100 prosecutions.  Some drew in friends and relatives of others.  Some included individuals who were innocent or peripheral to the claimed conspiracies.  It doesn’t matter.  Once swept into the net, fear overcomes their will to challenge.  I don’t know how many generations of prosecutions grew from this original group of 26, but it could easily include 1000 other defendants, or more. 

I wonder how many constitutional violations were ignored in the process.  After all, the government need not worry to much about the Constitution, or even the proof, when they have a long line of defendants outside their office waiting to talk.

Will The Good Guys Ever Win?

Susan Cartier Liebel comments to my lament about the law schools obsession with ranking:


This will change. It has to because the paying customer, yes, the student, will demand it. The holdouts, the committee members, those tenured professors who have not been engaged in the practice of law since tuition was affordable, hold the publication criteria out like a necklace of garlic to keep the ‘practicing’ attorneys outside the hallowed halls. But it will change.

Will this change?  Susan’s post makes perfect sense in a rational world, where the consumer (in this case the law student) drives the market.  But is it really the stodgy old tenured professors who are the stalwarts of the old ways?

From everything I’ve seen, the young turks are far more protective of the new elitism than anyone else.  They have come to the job for a different purpose than the Prof. Kingsfields; they are scholars.  They have gone through the law professor meat market, or beauty pageant (whichever analogy better suits you), where their law school pedigree got them past the first cut.

Today’s law professors, more so than years ago, see their role as authors of learned writings. They  would prefer that the “school” part be eliminated completely.  Intellectual curiosity is vaulted as the primary value to be sought in a new law professor.  But unmentioned is the absolute belief that one’s intellect is unworthy if it was unable to get the Beauty from Idaho into Harvard.  What strikes me time and again is the absence of any mention of interest or ability to train young men and women to be lawyers.  They  argue against students going to classes.

What do law students  have to say about this?  They no longer want to go to classes.  They find classes worthless, professors boring and disengaged.  Law school is viewed as a pointless obligation on the path to Biglaw salaries.  They are not interested in learning how to practice law, but how to  get a job with an obscenely high salary. 

The elitism propagated by the lawprofs is reflected in the attitudes of the students.  Neither sees much point in the other, except as a means to an end.  For the lawprofs, it’s publication to bring their school to the top tier of the rankings, or keep it there while the others are nipping at your heels.  For the students, it is to get Biglaw to hire them so they too can make the $190,000 first year salaries.

Where are the young public defenders, environmental lawyers, consumer-rights lawyers?  Who cares, because they are just the losers in the law school game of upping the rankings and making the big money that proves self-worth. 

The same rational system that would put the consumers in charge would similar value the services of lawyers who provide the greatest social utility highest.  As the incredible popularity of blawgs like  Above the Law makes abundantly clear, winners and losers in the law school game are based on whether they get the big bonus.  There’s no mention of ability or service or purpose, but there’s post after post about how much money they will make if they come from a Tier 1 school and get a Biglaw job.

So will the consumers of law schools demand that lawprofs put down their law reviews and start giving a damn about their classes, their students and what type of inchoate lawyers they are turning loose on the world?  Not if the young turk professors have anything to say about it, and not if the students think that their profs efforts in elevating their school’s ranking has the potential to land them a Biglaw job. 

In fairness, there is a contrarian point of view promoted by MoneyLaw, where they aspire to end the Beauty Pageant and elitism for its own sake.  But even there, the internal struggle between hope and reality is clear and disappointing.  While disavowing that the Tier 1 pedigree is a first cut necessity for anyone desiring to become a law professor, the stats show that the interest at the meat market is still for those with only the best law schools in their background.  But not because of the law school name; because they lack any other viable criteria to determine who has the most intellectual curiosity.  And the little detail about who has something to offer students remains unmentioned.

Welcome Class, I’m Your CrimLaw Prof

Update:  I don’t usually think that my snarkier posts are so obtuse as to be confusing, but apparently I was wrong about this one.  On Adjunct Law Prof Blog, this post was taken to be “advertising” for a adjunct professor position.  I left them a comment that they may (ahem) have missed the point of the post, but since they moderate comments over there, it has yet to show up. now appears and addresses any confusion.  In any event, let me be clear that this was not a solicitation for an adjunct lawprof job.  Now if anybody needs a full prof…
_____________

These are not words that are likely to be spoken by me.  Not because I wouldn’t want to teach law students (as Bennett calls me the frustrated professor), but because no law school would hire the likes of me.

My criminal defense brethren and sistren don’t understand why I bother posting about law schools, students and profs.  It’s a subject that interests me more as I age (mellow?) because the coming generations of lawyers and judges need to be prepared to fulfill the promises that people like me and those before me fought for.  I am concerned that a vital group of lawyers will be understaffed, unprepared and unwilling to walk into the well of a court and fight.

At prawfsblawg, Eduardo Penlaver asks why law schools and lawyers are so obsessed with ratings of law schools and law firms.  We’re not.  You are.  Real lawyers couldn’t care less, because the day after you graduate, no one gives a hoot where you went to school.  The only question is whether you can produce.  Unless, of course, you are hired by Biglaw to be a perpetual law clerk at $190k a year, while PDs try cases and hope to make $60k if funding comes through.

At Moneylaw, Jeff Harrison defends his bipolar position that he would never hire anyone who thinks his Harvard degree was his most valuable asset, while admitting that he’s busy hiring Harvard grads because they are “intellectually curious.”  Hey, I’m intellectually curious.  But I work for a living.

There are a few things I could teach law students.  Not only do I have a passing familiarity with the basic crimlaw curriculum, and an interest in the theory underlying them, but I can tell them where the bodies are buried.  And how we bury the bodies.  And why.  I can instruct them how to represent a client, and how to try a case.  Frankly, there aren’t too many Harvard grads toiling in the wells with me. 

Publishing seems to be the key for professors.  But I’m a working stiff.  No ivory tower office to ponder the imaginary Ministry of Magic, or to do empirical studies on what judges where under their robes.  Worse yet, I know too many judges, and know too well that they aren’t thinking about how to promote some theoretical stance, unless then have at least 4 revolving law clerks to help them.  The rest are too busy just trying to make it through their day and decide the cases before them. 

So yes, I want to teach law students how to be lawyers.  I would be happy to publish too, but it would have to be about something that made a difference, rather than some law review article that no one save some other professors would bother to read.  While the scholars can enjoy a decent circle jerk, law schools could use a few people who want to teach kids to represent real people and produce work that may actually do some good for someone. 

Is there any law school out there that would actually want this?  I certainly won’t help your rankings in U.S News and World Reports (or any other ranking that one can google), and it’s unlikely that my presence will bring worldwide recognition to your school.  But your students will learn something.  Your students will be engaged in what I have to tell them.  Your students will finish the class better off then when they started.  You remember students, don’t you?  And I didn’t go to Harvard.  I’m just a lawyer.

If you’re interested, let me know.  I’ll be checking the mailbox. 

The Rat Paradox Explodes

Mark Bennett, Norm Pattis, Gideon, Shawn Matlock,  Scott Henson and  Malum have all weighed in.  Houston, we have a problem.

While the debate is heated, and the positions are polarized, I see a lot of cross-talk based on a lack of universal definitions.  We may not be as far apart as the record would appear.  Since we have great mutual respect for one another, we should make an effort to avoid the common theme of the criminal defense bar being incapable of agreeing on anything and see whether we can find some common ground.

To this end, I speak for myself when I state:

1.  My “rat” is the guilty criminal who can’t take the weight, so he desires to go to the US Attorney on his knees and give up his brother, mother, BFF, on this or some other offense to buy himself a 5K1.1.   My “rat” is not an innocent, wrongly arrrests, or a witness to a crime giving up information.  In my book, this person can and should cooperate with police, and I will represent him and assist him without reservation.

2.  Despite everything else, I will explain truthfully and accurately the benefits of cooperation to every client, as well as the detriments.  I will not advise them not to cooperate.  In the event that the client decides that cooperation is the direction he wishes to go, I will cooperate fully with a change in counsel and provide new counsel with every assistance possible.  I will simply not be the lawyer who walks into the U.S Attorney’s office with the defendant.  I will do nothing to interfere with the clients choice; I just won’t do it myself.

3.  When we talk about what a lawyer does during the representation of a cooperator, we talk about the client spilling his guts and perhaps even working the street for the agents to set someone else up.  We talk about the client being willing to testify for the government, and being “prepared” by the government to give that testimony.  The sole purpose of this is to obtain a 5K1.1 letter from the U.S. Attorney’s office, which removes the defendant from the clutches of the Sentencing Guidelines.  The more the defendant says, the better his 5K1.1 letter is, and the greater the benefit he achieves.  There is no skill involved.

4.  If no lawyer was willing to represent a cooperator, and defendants sought to cooperate, I might rethink my position that I do not represent cooperators.  Every defendant is entitled to, and needs representation, and if the defendant was unable to obtain representation, I would then feel it incumbent on me to provide it.  However, there are a ton of lawyers willing to take as much money as they can get from defendants to sit in the room and do the crossword puzzle while the defendant rats out his mother.  So, it does not appear that this will ever present a problem, and defendants will have no problem finding a lawyer to represent them during cooperation.

These are the groundrules that I work with.  Are we all on the same page, or are we all at each other’s throats?

Ladies and Gentlemen, what say you?