There’s a war erupting in the blawgosphere. My next door neighbor, Houston criminal defense lawyer Mark Bennett of Defending People, has made abundantly clear his feelings on the subject of snitching. In fact, he’s put it into his retainer agreement that he’s not going to do it.
Now, Norm Pattis, Connecticut’s answer to Johnny Cochran, goes for blood, arguing that any lawyer who refuses to counsel his client on becoming a rat has failed his duty to his client.
Lawyers who refuse to permit their clients to cooperate with the Government, announcing, sometimes in a retainer agreement, that they will withdraw if the client wants to cooperate, are only doing part of their job.
This is a very touchy subject, obviously. My position tends to be closer to Mark’s. Much closer than Norm’s. While I agree that the lawyer is obliged to inform his client that becoming a rat is an option that may well be the only way to get out from under the onerous burdens of the federal sentencing guidelines, I won’t do it. If he wants to be a snitch, he will have to find some other lawyer more suited to the job. It’s not what I do.
Norm takes issue with my position.
Criminal court is a place of fierce emotions and it draws passionate lawyers. But refusing to work with clients in whose interest it is to cooperate is putting the lawyer’s interest, his passion, his vision of himself, first. That should never be done. Clients need options and lawyers willing to stand by them regardless of what the client chooses.
Standing by your client is a fine sentiment, but so is knowing your limitations. I cannot agree that refusing to represent clients who flip is abandonment, particularly when you are up front about it. They know at the outset where the line is drawn. Defendant’s have a choice when represented by private counsel. Just as the client has the right to discharge us at any time, we too maintain the right to draw lines. This is such a line.
But Norm’s point that cooperation is part of the repertoire of criminal defense is well taken. It may well be the only way for a defendant to save himself from 30 years in prison. Should the defendant die in the slammer because the attorney doesn’t like cooperation? Clearly not. But does that mean that the trial lawyer is obliged to change hats and become the rat lawyer?
Tough question.
