Author Archives: SHG

The Battle Lines Are Drawn!

There’s a war erupting in the blawgosphere.  My next door neighbor, Houston criminal defense lawyer Mark Bennett of Defending People, has made abundantly clear his feelings on the subject of snitching. In fact, he’s put it into his  retainer agreement that he’s not going to do it.

Now, Norm Pattis, Connecticut’s answer to Johnny Cochran, goes for blood, arguing that any lawyer who refuses to  counsel his client on becoming a rat has failed his duty to his client.


Lawyers who refuse to permit their clients to cooperate with the Government, announcing, sometimes in a retainer agreement, that they will withdraw if the client wants to cooperate, are only doing part of their job.

This is a very touchy subject, obviously.   My position tends to be closer to Mark’s.  Much closer than Norm’s.  While I agree that the lawyer is obliged to inform his client that becoming a rat is an option that may well be the only way to get out from under the onerous burdens of the federal sentencing guidelines, I won’t do it.  If he wants to be a snitch, he will have to find some other lawyer more suited to the job.  It’s not what I do.

Norm takes issue with my position.


Criminal court is a place of fierce emotions and it draws passionate lawyers. But refusing to work with clients in whose interest it is to cooperate is putting the lawyer’s interest, his passion, his vision of himself, first. That should never be done. Clients need options and lawyers willing to stand by them regardless of what the client chooses.

Standing by your client is a fine sentiment, but so is knowing your limitations.  I cannot agree that refusing to represent clients who flip is abandonment, particularly when you are up front about it.  They know at the outset where the line is drawn.  Defendant’s have a choice when represented by private counsel.  Just as the client has the right to discharge us at any time, we too maintain the right to draw lines.  This is such a line.

But Norm’s point that cooperation is part of the repertoire of criminal defense is well taken.  It may well be the only way for a defendant to save himself from 30 years in prison.  Should the defendant die in the slammer because the attorney doesn’t like cooperation?  Clearly not.  But does that mean that the trial lawyer is obliged to change hats and become the rat lawyer?

Tough question. 

You’re Nobody ’til Somebody Spams You

Spam, spam, spam, spam.  I’m a big Monty Python fan, so I have a finely honed appreciation of spam.

But I’ve been getting spammed like crazy on my comments since yesterday.  It appears I’ve hit the big-time.  I’m spam-worthy.

I will do my best to keep up with the spammers so that I can leave comments unmoderated and let readers post whatever they want.  But I still ask the big question:  Why do spammers think people who read blawgs are in desperate need of Cialis and Viagra? 

The Upside of Gouging the Poor

Reporting on one of the most absurd studies conceived,  Volokh Conspiracy supports the bright side of Usury.  Yes, usury, the charging of unlawful rates of interest for lending money.  On our side of the fence, we call this loan-sharking, but in the Wall Street Journal, it’s simply sound business practice, and the usurers become “poverty alleviation charities.”

It sounds so much better when it comes from the WSJ, doesn’t it?

So what was this study?  There were two groups in South Africa, one receiving payday loans with a 200% interest rate and the others getting squat.  Long story short, the ones who received the usurious loans were happier, healthier and better off than the ones who got squat were dead from starvation less happy.

And this study, according to the WSJ and Volokh, prove that usurious loans are really a good thing for the poor.  And not so bad for the lender, either.

Rarely does one hear of such a ridiculous theory that fails, in almost every respect, to account for the phenomenon that it’s better to be gouged and fed then to not be fed at all.  Of course, the argument is that since no one will loan money to the poor unless they receive 200% interest, and since the poor are better off receiving a loan than receiving nothing, usury provides a better result than the alternative of no money and certain misery.

There are few things more pleasant than an approach that justifies and legitimizes taking advantage of the misery of others for fun and profit.  But then again, what is the Wall Street Journal if not a record of acts of great humanitarianism.  Now, if only the mob had thought of conducting a study.

The Next Great Drain On Indigent Defense?

As any public defender will tell you, they are strapped for cash.  They need more staff.  They need to pay the staff better.  They could use some more investigators.  This is the Constitution on a shoe string, and the fact that they function at all is really remarkable.  After all, it isn’t easy to provide competent representation when you carry a caseload of 200 defendants. 

So into the allocation of scare resources steps R. Robert Samples, President of RMS Strategies, who writes  this article for the West Virginia Record.  Hat tip to  Andrew Lavoott Bluestonefor the heads up. 

According to Samples, every indigent defendant is entitled to a jury consultant.  And of course, when the defendant is indigent, we know who gets to pay.  You gotta give Samples credit for sliding his biz through the side door into the public fisc, since it isn’t every day that you get to find a whole new revenue stream for those collateral legal services to the indigent.


But consider that the State of West Virginia provides public monies for trial research for indigent clients who are being represented by the Public Defender’s Office. Our firm has conducted multiple change of venue surveys for clients of the Public Defender’s office that were funded by taxpayer dollars. In each case, the judge approved the expenditure because the indigent client is entitled-the same as everyone else-to adequate representation. And trial research, like a court-appointed attorney, is considered essential to providing this adequate representation.

But what’s in it for the lawyer?  According to Samples, if you don’t seek a jury consultant, you may be committing legal malpractice.  Legal malpractice!  Well, we certainly wouldn’t want to do that.

For most public defender offices, funding is an ongoing, daily struggle.  The harsh reality is that legislators get little bang for their political buck by announcing to their constituents that they have done a great service by allocating monies for the defense of criminals.  To put them in jail?  Woo Hoo.  To keep them from jail?  Boo.

While my feelings toward jury consultants are worse than ambivalent based upon my own experiences with their utility, they may well prove to have some potential to aid in the trial of particularly notorious and well-publicized criminal cases.  But if there’s money to be spent on jury consultants, then spend it first on adequate staffing of the PDs.  After that’s been accomplished, we can talk about bells and whistles.

As for Samples, I can’t blame any businessman for trying to drum up business.  And I will restrain myself from suggesting that your sales pitch is less than savory, as it plays on fear to suck some bucks from the bottom of the empty well.  But if it were up to me, you would be standing at the end of a long line of people whose services are far more critical to the functioning of the criminal justice system.

Science Fiction Gets The Finger

This is  the stuff that movies are made of.  Dr. Jose L. Covarrubias is a plastic surgeon who lives in Nogales on the US side but practices in Nogales on the Mexican side.  Apparently, Dr. Covarrubias has an interesting practice.

It seems this Jamaican fellow, Marc George, is a hard-working Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, drug dealer.  Having left the beautiful Caribbean island to ply his trade in the dinge of Harrisburg, he was intent on avoiding forced retirement.  George sought out the services of the good doctor to make a few minor adjustments.

Dr. C must be a very good doctor.  With very bad morals.  It kinda makes you wonder why he wasn’t on staff at Boston General, but that’s better left to a critique of managed care in America.  George was apparently trying to avoid apprehension by police for doing business too well and Dr. C agrees to make his fingerprints go away by using the skin from George’s feet.  This begs the question of what George planned to walk on afterward, but this too must remain a mystery.

Somehow, the feds learned of Dr. C’s surgical skills and brought him to Harrisburg to face the music.  Let this be a lesson for physicians:  never seek insurance reimbursement for criminal fingerprint changing.  First, the money is poor.  Second, there’s no correct code to put on the forms.  Third, you go to jail.  Then again, perhaps he was paid cash?

The good doc has entered a plea agreement with a max of 5 years and the deal requires him to provide full cooperation.  Did George think the physician was going to stand up?  In exchange. the feds dropped the conspiracy count. 


The doctor’s attorney, Stephen G. Ralls, said Covarrubias had “a lapse of judgment” and had no prior criminal record.

A lapse of judgment?  Or a Mercedes payment due?   Whatever the motivation, having a plastic surgeon change swap the skin from one’s fingers for foot-dermis is, well, just creepy.

Crack Guidelines Update

Update:  For a very thorough review of the crack guidelines changes, see Young Shawn Matlock’s excellent post.  Also, rumor has it that YS will send $1 to every person who leaves a comment.  Make sure you mention that you heard about it here.

The United State Sentencing Commission’s changes in the guidelines, to reduce the sentence for cocaine base (crack) by two levels downard, go into effect today, November 1.  I’ve received numerous inquiries about this change and whether it’s retroactive.

The Commission has produced  an analysis of the impact of retroactivity of these downward changes, but it is not retroactive at this time. 

Finally, it is important to note that while the prior 100:1 ratio for crack versus powdered cocaine was determined to be wrong, it has been reduced to a 50:1 ratio, meaning that 1 gram of crack will get you the same sentence as 50 grams of powered coke.  So is it better than it was?  Well, yes.  Is it equivalent.  Not quite.  Is there a good reason for a 50 to 1 disparity between crack and coke, consider who the respective users may be?  You will have to ask your friendly local United States Sentencing Commissioner to answer that one.

A Risky Strategy That Paid Off

Via New York Lawyer, Christopher Hoover made a hard choice.  When Collin County Judge John O. Barry directed him to start trial, even though he told the judge he wasn’t ready, Hoover decided “enough.” 

Hoover represented Darrel Cannon, whose case was 8th in line for trial before Judge Barry that day.  Hoover never anticipated that the court would reach his case, and didn’t prepare.  Whether he should have or not is another matter.  The fact is he didn’t.  So when Judge Barry ordered him to trial, Hoover admitted his lack of preparation.  The Judge didn’t care.  Hoover told the judge that he wasn’t going to participate.  He told his client that he wasn’t going to participate.  And he didn’t.


“Defense counsel, although physically present in the courtroom at all the requisite times, effectively boycotted the trial proceedings and entirely failed to subject the prosecution’s case to meaningful adversarial testing,” CCA Judge Charles Holcomb wrote for the majority.

While many lawyers would love to try a stunt like this, few have the guts to actually do so.  The very notion of sitting there, one’s hands falling lifelessly at one’s side, one’s voice silent and mind drifting off to far away exotic climes while the prosecution witnesses testify, seems impossible.  But Hoover did it.

Even though a defendant cannot, theoretically, be convicted without the effective assistance of counsel, the appellate court might well have taken the position that this was a deliberate strategic move on Hoover’s part to undermine the authority of the trial judge to move the case forward to trial, and that Hoover had the ability to provide effective (not perfect, mind you, or even decent, but the lowest possible degree, “effective”) assistance of counsel.  That he made a tactical decision to sit on his hands, with the approval of his client, fulfilled the constitutional obligation to the defendant.  Conviction affirmed.

I don’t think I could ever recommend that any other lawyer take the position that Christopher Hoover took.  I have sincere doubts that it would work again.  But, I have to give Christopher Hoover of Plano, Texas, credit for having a brass pair.  Or being nuts, whichever comes first.

Don’t Bidzirk Me

Following on the heels of The Future of Reputation,  Dan Solove’s cautionary tale of the internet, comes  Eric Turkewitz’s post on Bidzirk v. Smith.  This case involved an eBay reseller’s attempt to crush an unhappy customer who posted about his experience, only to find himself embroiled in defending his words against full blown federal litigation.

Smith, pro se, won the case, but at huge personal expense.  While he is being hailed as a hero in the debate of whether bloggers are journalists and in standing up against those who would challenge our right to opine, there is no doubt that Smith would have much rather been able to say his piece and move on, without being involved in this nightmare or becoming anyone’s hero. 

This dovetails nicely with the issues raised by Reputation about how the law should address postings on the web.  What is missing from the Bidzirk case is a means by which Smith could go beyond the basic defense, and counter this suit with a counterclaim of his own.  There was nothing there for Smith to make Bidzirk’s attempt to stifle commentary cost Bidzirk something for overreaching.

It occurs to me that this would be the perfect situation for an anti-SLAPP suit.  SLAPP is an acronym for Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation, and refers to abusive lawsuits filed to impose a burden on an individual or group for exercising their right to challenge an action, generally an action involving an environmental issue.  For example, a logging company would commence a SLAPP suit against an environmental group trying to save the spotted owl, since the logging concern has enough money and juice to destroy the underfunded environmental group merely by the initiation of litigation, despite the absence of merit to the cause.

What if blogging defendants are given a cause of action in response to lawsuits brought in retaliation for the exercise of legitimate free speech online, say with statutory damages of twice the ad damnum of the SLAPP suit plus attorneys fees?  Would that do the trick?

But what of the legitimate lawsuit brought by the aggrieved plaintiff who was maligned by falsehoods, lies and malicious unjustified attacks?  Then it wouldn’t be a SLAPP suit, and this plaintiff would prevail.  But both sides would wield a potentially big club, keeping the online arms race in check.

So what do you think Dan?  Am I onto something?

The Secret of Success

From Andrew Lavoott Bluestone’s  New York Attorney Malpractice Blog comes this  great story from the  American Statesman about an accountant who has started a law biz that guarantees it can free any federal inmate. 

“A small Austin company, International Legal Services, advertises that it can free just about any federal prison inmate on appeal, even those who pleaded guilty or confessed — a dubious claim that even the most prestigious law firms would never make.”

Well, there you go.  Who needs lawyers?  My favorite part of this quote is that “even the most prestigious law firms” wouldn’t make that claim.  So what dubious claims would the most prestigious law firms make?

It seems that this former accountant, Tony Davis, having done 5 1/2 years of hard time himself, has decided that Congress screwed up back in the Truman era and that this mistake voids all federal convictions.  Hey, Jamie Spencer, sounds like you’ve got some competition down there in Austin.  Of course, Davis’ argument didn’t work for him, and has never worked for anyone else.  In fact, the 7th Circuit responded to his argument in a one sentence opinion: “This case is unbelievably frivolous,” Don’t you love it when a court’s opinion is concise?

But here’s the part that really tells us something important.  About 160 inmates have paid this fellow $17,500 for his services, generating gross revenues of $2,800,000.  That’s right, $2.8 Million.  That’s the sum of money that has been stolen from desperate men and women.  It’s also the sum of money that has been diverted from appellate and post-judgment attorneys who could potentially offer a chance at success, slim though it may be.  But then, real lawyers can’t guarantee success.

This isn’t the first scam designed to take advantage of the desperation of men and women in prison, facing long sentences with no hope of returning to their homes and families anytime soon.  They will do anything for a second (or third) chance.  No matter how ridiculous the claims, if it is presented with confidence they will pay anything for the chance. 

Adding insult to injury, I’ve seen these scams perpetrated by real lawyers, unlike this Tony Davis with his magic bullet, and steal far more than $17,500 per client.  I know of a well-known lawyer who will go to big-time defendants and sell them that for half a million, he can get an inside guy to change their time in the computer so that they can get out in a year.  Shockingly, some prisoners go for it.  Their drug money is worthless to them in prison for 30 years, so they will pay anything to get out.  Amazingly, this lawyer is still alive, no doubt a testament to his glibness.

Some wags might contend that there’s a certain poetry to someone stealing from convicted prisoners.  Perhaps even a symmetry when the thief is a lawyer.  For me, this is merely wrong, for moral, ethical and legal reasons.  Poetic justice would be that people like Tony Davis (and my well-known lawyer) should spend more time with their clients.  More time, like 30 years in the same cell.