Author Archives: SHG

The Clash Between Competence and Inclusion

From  Lowering the Bar comes this story of a law student suing Southern Illinois Law School for denying her readmittance because of a low GPA.  “Lisa Dawn Rittenhouse ended up with a 1.948 GPA, and law school rules apparently provide that only those with a 1.95 or better will be invited back for another year.”

A low GPA, on its surface, sounds like a good reason to cut the student free, but the story doesn’t end there.  It seems that she suffers from certain disabilities, and that her low GPA is a product of this.  But it doesn’t end there either, as shown here:


But Rittenhouse says that her low scores are due to disability, not a lack of ability.  She claims she suffers from bipolar disorder,  hyperactivity, ADHD, and dyslexia.  One or more of these disorders may or may not explain why Rittenhouse’s complaint describes ADHD as “Attention Span Deficit Disorder” and says it contributed to her “low grape point average.”  She alleges that she has one or more impairments that substantially limits here [sic] ability to perform” and that the school’s failure to accommodate her was a violation of the “Americans for [sic] Disabilities Act.”

So she made every gaff in the book.  I suppose there’s a certain irony, if not exactly humor, to be found here.
But there’s another issue hidden inside this story that makes it impossible to laugh at the irony. 

Students with learning disabilities are entitled to receive an education, including the accommodations and modifications that allow them to overcome their disability and achieve the educational success.  But where does this end?

Clearly, we want LD students to reach their fullest potential, both as a matter of propriety and for the societal benefit of having them as contributing members.  But their fullest potential does not mean that they will be able to accomplish whatever they want when their skills, as limited by their disabilities, fall short.  This is a sad truth, but truth nonetheless.  Would anyone want a blind brain surgeon operating on them?  Clearly, being blind does not limit intelligence or drive, but it is a very real disability that impacts on one’s ability to perform certain tasks.  There’s just no way around it. 

Lisa Dawn Rittenhouse says that she suffers from bipolar disorder, ADHD and dyslexia.  None of these, standing alone, precludes the possibility that she can be a successful lawyer.  The dyslexia, while it may present some barriers in effective writing, should not present an insurmountable hurdle that her ideas and arguments cannot shine through.  After all, misspellings happen to all of us, and we survive (with the help of spellcheck, or better yet, a good editor). 

But given the content of her work shown above, she isn’t going to cut it as a lawyer.  While we must have a societal policy to support the learning disabled to fulfill their potential, there must also be a point where accommodations end. 

I have a problem finding humor in Lisa Dawn Rittenhouse’s “low grape point average.”  It just isn’t funny to me that there are people who struggle to achieve their dreams, but are hampered by disabilities.  In fact, I admire their struggle to overcome their disabilities, their refusal to be defined by what they can’t do and their efforts to push through their limitations to succeed.  But I cannot see her being a lawyer, and putting the fate of another person into her hands. 

San Francisco (Not Frisco) Criminal Defense Lawyers To Be Heard

Frank Z. Leidman has been kind enough to  post here about a protest in support of the Pakistani lawyers who have risked their own safety and security to fight the budding dictatorship in Pakistan.  I want to make sure that everyone sees this:


The Criminal Trial Lawyers Association of Northern California, the Bar Association of San Francisco, and the Office of the San Francisco Public Defender will demonstrate this Friday, November 9, 2007 at Noon at the San Francisco Federal Building in solidarity with the Pakistani lawyers.

As lawyers, we tend to be awfully good at making noise amongst ourselves about things that we disagree with or don’t believe in.  Getting off our butts and actually doing something, not as good.

The opportunity to show solidarity with our counterparts in Pakistan may not be the same as going there and standing side by side with them, but it’s critically important that we do something to show our country, our President and the world that we share the belief that the law is what separates democracy from totalitarianism.  I applaud Frank and the San Francisco bar for standing up and being counted.

While there has been no word on similar demonstrations in New York, I’ve forwarded Frank’s comment to Dan Arshack, President of the NYSACDL, in the hope that it will inspire a similar demonstration in New York.  I will speak to Dan today to see how this can be quickly organized.

While Pakistan may be a world away, what is happening there could not be closer to us, both in the existential sense as well as the very real sense, though somewhat more subtle as we are beaten into non-existence through laws like the USA Patriot Act and FISA, which was an outrage until things got so much worse that FISA began to look good.

If you’re anywhere near San Francisco and have any belief in democracy, the rule of law and the Constitution, join the lawyers of San Francisco.  The more people, the more effective the demonstration will be. 

Lesson from the Beatles, “Help”

So tomorrow is the final day of voting for Best Blog.  Anyone who’s voted (or looked) knows that we’re not going tp win.  The big guys are thousands of votes ahead of Simple Justice.  Right now, we’re trying to save face and avoid abject embrassment.  So, in the immortal words of the Beatles, HELP!

Vote.  Vote early and often.  Vote today so you can vote against tomorrow.  Remember, Simple Justice isn’t going to win this beauty pagaent, but let’s at least make a respectable showing.  And thanks to both of you who voted for Simple Justice. 

The 2007 Weblog Awards

Putting the Legal World in Perspective

Just in case you aren’t glued to your computer awaiting  Above the Law’s latest post on Law Firm Bonus Watch, I’m here to help.

Now, before I give you the good stuff, there are a few things to bear in mind.  First, what you will see is not the salary paid to little boy and girl lawyers, but just the bonus.  This is on top of the salary, for those of you who have never heard the word “bonus” and “salary” in the same sentence.

Second, this is not the top of the line bonus.  I decided against telling you about the really good bonuses, because it would just be cruel.  No, this is a second stringer, a wannabe, bonuses for losers, so to speak.  These are not the ones putting the order in on the Ferrari Enzo.  Nope.  These are the ones who have to suffer with a Lambo (which everybody knows is a car for people who are not Ferrari-worthy).

And third, the boys and girls who get these bonuses also tend to be the beneficiaries of various charities from their investment banker friends, because they are just nice people who receive sad and pathetic paychecks.

So you PDs, indigent defenders, right up through top of the line private retained guys,  check out how the other half lives:

This entry was posted in Uncategorized on by .

Ugly Case With A Common Flaw

The Phelps/Westboro Baptist Church protests against the war, as God’s retribution for America’s toleration of homosexuals, disgust many.  These are the folks who protest at the funerals of those killed in Iraq, turning the private funerals, and the grief of families who have lost a son or daughter, into circuses in furtherance of their bizarre cause.  It offends my sensibilities.  But that’s not the point of this post.

Volokh has linked to an article in the Omaha World-Herald (now there’s a curious name for a newspaper) about charges levied in Sarpy County Court against Shirley Phelps-Roper for mutilation of the flag, contributing to the delinquency of a minor and negligent child abuse.  The latter charges relate to Phelps-Roper for “making” her 10 year old son step on the American flag.

Her attorney, Bassel El-Kasaby, requested particulars of the charges. 


Deputy Sarpy County Attorney Marc Delman resisted El-Kasaby’s request, saying he didn’t want to limit the basis for the charges.

Delman told the judge that Phelps-Roper had “cleanly, openly and notoriously” made her son step on an American flag while her church protested at the funeral of William Bailey.

While most of the blawgosphere focuses on the issue of flag desecration, clearly  free speech no matter how much you don’t like it, my concern is for the nuts and bolts of this prosecution.  Not because they are so unique, but rather so common.  Except that it’s happening in a case receiving some degree of public attention.

The prosecutor objects to giving particulars of the charges.  The prosecutor says he doesn’t want to “limit the basis for the charges.”  While things like this don’t concern “big picture” guys like Eugene Volokh, these reflect the daily battle of defense lawyers in the trenches.

How exactly does one defend against a moving target?  If the prosecution refuses to be pinned down to what exactly a defendant is accused of doing, how is a defendant to defend?  This is not a phenomenon that happens in cases such as Phelps-Roper, where they want to nail her for something, and can’t quite figure out how to circumvent the Constitution and facts to turn lawful conduct into a crime. 

This happens all the time.  In fact, it is commonplace in federal court for AUSA to refuse to provide particulars under the argument that it would “prejudice the Government’s case.”  How telling the truth would be prejudicial has yet to be explained to me, but rarely will a District Court judge make them do it.  Very rarely, as least around these parts.

One can question whether a child stepping on the flag, though abhorrent to many, is any different “in kind” then a child grasping a bible or, for that matter, a Koran.  It all reflects beliefs “spoken” through conduct.  If “making” a child hold a bible endangerment?  If not, then it’s no more endangering to a child to express a belief by stepping on a flag.  I know, it doesn’t feel the same at all, but intellectual integrity sometimes requires the law to allow the bad with the good. 

So in this otherwise ugly case, with conduct that manages to offend so many people with such varying beliefs all at the same time, comes a common prosecutorial flaw.  As much as I would love to point the finger at this Omaha prosecutor and rant about how absurd his position is, it’s really just another day in the trenches, where defendants are left to guess what they are alleged to have done lest the prosecution not be “limited” by the facts.

This is Definitely NOT Legal Advice

Every blawg tries to make clear that it is not giving any individual legal advice.  We do so for liability reasons, but more importantly, because we aren’t.  We post to inform, debate, enlighten, engage.  But we post generically, and it will never be a substitute for a real lawyer hearing the particulars of a real case and rendering a real opinion.

And so, comes this endearing but frightening comment to Mark Bennett’s  post at Defending People :


[I] am the wife of a man who has been falsely accused of something awful. We have an attorney who is competent, and who I have faith in. A few weeks ago he recommended my husband take a deferred adjudication, and he almost considered it out of fear even though he is 100% innocent.We’re both the 1st in our families to graduate from college, and it would all be thrown away for false allegations. I stayed up all night looking for info. that might change his mind. I found your blog and read one that discussed what you lose when you take a deal. Long story short, I woke him up at 3:43 am and he read it. The next day he politely declined the offer. I’m praying with all my might that justice will prevail.

The fact that Mark’s discussion of the consequences of cutting a deal served to make someone think is important.  He wants to make people think, and feedback that his post served its purpose brings satisfaction.

But, a real person made a real decision that will have a monumental impact on real lives based on a blawg post.  This is frightening.  The anonymous commenter says she has faith in her lawyer, who is competent.  Not exactly an overwhelming show of support, but enough to suggest that the proper response is to discuss the issues raised by Mark’s post with the attorney before making a decision.

It is impossible to know the facts of the case, the evidence against the defendant husband or the relative impact of a plea versus a conviction after trial.  And it’s unlikely that the commenter would be capable, because of bias and fear, to accurate assess all the factors that go into making a sound decision.  The prisons are filled with innocent people.  Believing with all one’s heart and soul that being innocent somehow protects you from conviction is foolhardy.  No one wants to see an innocent person convicted.

It is hard to imagine any lawyer reading this anonymous comment to not feel for the poster, and yet not recognize that her middle-of-the-night-panic-reading-of-blawgs-in-desperation is not the way to make decisions that could forever change many lives. 

Since she obviously was seeking something beyond the advice of her lawyer, perhaps this means it’s time to find another lawyer before making the decision, someone in whom she and her husband repose unquestioned trust.  But under no circumstances, none, should any person rely on a blawg post to make a decision of this consequence.  Blawgs are not a substitute for legal advice, no matter how good, how satisfying or how deeply you want to believe.

Liveblogging A Murder Trial

The Texas Tornado, Mark Bennett, is “in” trial (sorry, but that’s how they say it in Texas), and is liveblogging his way through it.  See the posts here,  here,  here and here, and expect them to continue until the jury foreman says “not guilty.”

While this isn’t the first time someone has liveblogged a trial, the last time ended in disaster for the blogger known as the Flea.  Of course, the Flea was “on” trial, while Bennett is only “in” trial.  Not to mention, I wouldn’t put it past Mark to serve up a little disinformation just in case his prosecutor is reading his blawg at night.  A few well placed tweaks might send the prosecution into a tailspin.  Would that be wrong?  Should he not use all the tricks he has up his sleeve?

Robert Guest of I Was The State, posted a comment to Mark’s blawg:


I never feel comfortable blogging about a trial while it happens. Have you researched the issue? Is there any potential negative implications?

My guess is that it all depends on what exactly your blogging about.  If you’re spilling state secrets, then there could be a problem.  If you’re reviewing what happened during the day, with your reaction as to whether it was helpful, hurtful, neutral, then probably not.  Although, disclosing too much about your reaction to testimony or rulings could well reveal too much about what concerns you and where you might be headed.

In his last post, Mark writes about how he is pushing the envelope with his questions relative to the judges in limine ruling.  This might get a reaction from the judge, if he either reads the blawg or the prosecutor tells him about it.  “See, Judge, Mark’s being a bad boy.  He’s trying to skirt your ruling, Wahhhhh.”  I would think twice before giving the prosecutor any ammunition.

But I’ve get faith in Mark’s judgment.  If he’s writing about his trial, he has a reason.  If he says something, he has a reason.  And if it makes for good reading, then all is right with the world.  Knock ’em dead, Mark.  But don’t forget that when come back from court after a hard day “in” trial, the first think you do is  vote for Simple Justice for Best Blawg.  You can’t lose sight of priorities even when you’re “in” trial.

I Voted For Judge Today

Election Results:  Jon Budelmann won as District Attorney of Cayuga County.  Jeff Brown, the judge who convicted Flores of a dismissed murder charge, won, but a distant third (3 judges elected).  We get the government we deserve. 
______________

The first Tuesday in November.  The leaves falling off the trees obscured the signs falling off the telephone poles.  It’s the day when the beauty pageant we know as judicial elections comes to a close, and the citizens of New York vote for judges.  It’s not my favorite system, as I’ve noted before.

The county in which I live is not a place where I regularly practice.  So many of the people running for judge are unfamiliar to me.  A couple I’ve appeared before.  A few I know outside of the office.  There was one that I heard was a very good guy.  And there was the judge who blew the Flores case.

Frankly, I could only identify a handful of candidates that I wanted to vote for.  And I’m a lawyer.  What are others supposed to do?  

The answer is painfully obvious: They will vote their party line.  Since the party that nominated the Flores trial judge is currently predominant, he will probably win.  Would it change anything if they know about his monumental screw-up?  It doesn’t matter.  The electorate won’t know.

None of these judges will ever be up for nomination to the Supreme Court.  How many of them keep up with the appellate court decisions that apply to them is unclear.  These are working judges.  They did their time in the party HQ, stuffing envelopes, making phone calls, licking stamps, and now they are candidates to be a judge.

I didn’t vote for anyone whose name I recognized from illegal signs.  If they can’t conduct their campaign lawfully, how can they be a judge?  But then, I likely rewarded candidates for their lack of effort rather than any principled decision not to break the law.  They just didn’t have the money for signs, or decided not to make the effort.  That certainly doesn’t speak well of them.

For those of you in states where judges are appointed and think judicial elections are the panacea that will return democracy to the judiciary, check out New York.  We’re all searching for a better way.  But since we elect them here, I voted for judge today.  For better or worse, I fulfilled one of my civic duties.  God save me.

The First Thing We Do, Let’s Kill All The Lawyers

“Dick The Butcher,” a scheming killer in Shakespeare’s Henry VI, uttered these words to explain how one seizes control.  While the line has been often misused and misunderstood to suggest that this would be a benefit to society, the point wasn’t missed in Pakistan.

From Slate,


The New York Times, Washington Post, and the Wall Street Journal’s world-wide newsbox lead with the latest from Pakistan, where thousands of lawyers protested the imposition of emergency rule by President Pervez Musharraf. Hundreds of lawyers, along with political opponents and human rights activists were beaten and hauled away by police officers. Since Saturday, approximately 2,000 people have been arrested, although many say the real number is much larger.

 While the politics of crime in America continues to devolve to the point where the Constitution is viewed as a threat to society, consider the round-up of Pakistani lawyers as irrefutable proof that the law, and its proponents, are the greatest safeguard against totalitarianism we have.

To anyone who would happily hand over his rights and freedoms in blind faith to an executive branch, take a hard look.  You may love the power and politics so dearly that you have no fear that a president, whether this one or some other one in the future, could ever change the rules of our society, whether bit by bit or wholesale, to the point of a dictatorship that you refuse to believe that you could ever lose your freedom. 

Notice that our President is very angry with Musharraf.  But they’re still friends.

The first thing we do, let’s kill all the lawyers.  What we do every day, on behalf of the people you despise, we do for all of us.  Including you.

How To Undo Ineffective Assistance of Counsel At The Plea

The United States Supreme Court has granted cert in a Ninth Circuit case, Arave v. Hoffman, also found  here and  here and here, on the remedy for ineffective assistance of counsel (IAC) during plea negotiations preceding a trial, where the defendant lost.  The salient facts are that defense counsel ill-advised the defendant to reject a plea offer and go to trial.  He did.  He lost.  What to do about it?

Before getting the heart of the issue, it should be noted that the error made by the lawyer was substantive.  He advised the defendant that he could rely on Ninth Circuit precedent which would result in the sentence after conviction being held unconstitutional.  Counsel had neglected to consider a split of decision on the issue, and his reliance on favorable precedent in advising the defendant to the exclusion of unfavorable precedent created the IAC problem.  I point this out to note that the IAC claim is real and substantive, not some made-up story that existed only in the defendant’s mind.

While the facts of the Arave case are complicated, they really aren’t important in addressing the big issue here.  The positions lay out fairly clearly.  On the one side, you have the position taken by Crime and Consequences :


A plea bargain that gets a criminal off with less than he deserves is a windfall. The fact that a better lawyer might have gotten him a windfall is not a miscarriage of justice if the final result is a just verdict for the crime he actually committed. Habeas is about correcting injustices, and justice is not a game. Plea bargaining is something we barely tolerate out of necessity. It is not a right to which defendants are entitled, and not getting a deal is not an injustice.

On the other side, you have the position taken by Gideon :


Yes, there is no Constitutional right to plead guilty, but the SCOTUS has held that there is a Constitutional right to effective assistance of counsel at a critical stage of the criminal proceedings. Strickland, 466 US at 686. The plea bargaining process is and must be a critical stage of the criminal proceeding.

So should IAC at the plea stage, followed by a fair trial where the defendant lost, give the defendant a second bite at the plea offer, now looking particularly palatable in hindsight?

Gideon definitely wins the point.  To denigrate a critical stage of the prosecution, the plea-bargaining phase, by calling it a “windfall” demonstrates the fallacy of the position.  First, if the plea offer reflected a result that the prosecution believed to be sufficiently satisfactory to address the offense, then it cannot be described as a windfall, but rather a mutually beneficial outcome.  The same hindsight issue exists for the prosecution as well as the defense, since neither side knows what will happen at trial.  It reflects a calculated decision by the prosecution, covering not only the risk of acquittal but the minimum level of punishment necessary to satisfy its duty to the people. 

As Gideon correctly notes, a defendant is entitled to effective assistance of counsel at all critical stages of a criminal proceedings.  Because the subsequent step is completed, and the outcome already known, doesn’t alleviate the problem.  If the defendant is entitled to effective assistance, then there must be a remedy when his assistance is ineffective.  Not only must there be a remedy, but the remedy must be meaningful or the right is rendered a farce.  That’s how “rights” work.

Moreover, C&C distinguishes the outcome in terms of “injustice”.  Injustice is subjective, and they obviously have no problem with a defendant receiving as severe a sentence as possible.  But politics doesn’t dictate what constitutes justice or injustice.  Indeed, one may well question why the sentence offered in the plea bargain was deemed sufficient at that point, but then, because a defendant exercised his constitutional right to trial, he should be punished far more severely.  Is it justice to pay a price for the exercise of the right to trial as provided our Constitution? 

If we looked at the scenario from the opposite direction of Crime & Consequences, where the defendant is given a reduced but sufficient sentence after trial, would that constitute an injustice?   The underlying assumption by Crime & Consequences is that justice is only served by the meting out of increasingly severe sentences.  They never met a death penalty they didn’t like.  This isn’t justice.  This is just plain old politics.  Anything short of death is a gift, according to C&C, and the defendant doesn’t deserve any gifts.

On a final note, the element of the C&C analysis relating to the defendant’s having received a “fair trial” subsequent to the IAC certainly gives one the impression that the defendant has gotten all the “fairness” he deserves. 

Despite the surface appeal of this point, the issue stops dead in its tracks at the point where the foul occurred.  Like a timeout called a split second before the field goal is made, the kicking team doesn’t get to keep the 3 points.  While certainly not a game, there must be rules to assure that a system of justice fulfills its requirements at each and every stage.  If the defendant was not provided effective assistance at the plea stage, then that’s where the play stops and the penalty is assessed at the point of the foul.  The points come off the board.  That’s justice.