From Lowering the Bar comes this story of a law student suing Southern Illinois Law School for denying her readmittance because of a low GPA. “Lisa Dawn Rittenhouse ended up with a 1.948 GPA, and law school rules apparently provide that only those with a 1.95 or better will be invited back for another year.”
A low GPA, on its surface, sounds like a good reason to cut the student free, but the story doesn’t end there. It seems that she suffers from certain disabilities, and that her low GPA is a product of this. But it doesn’t end there either, as shown here:
But Rittenhouse says that her low scores are due to disability, not a lack of ability. She claims she suffers from bipolar disorder, hyperactivity, ADHD, and dyslexia. One or more of these disorders may or may not explain why Rittenhouse’s complaint describes ADHD as “Attention Span Deficit Disorder” and says it contributed to her “low grape point average.” She alleges that she has one or more impairments that substantially limits here [sic] ability to perform” and that the school’s failure to accommodate her was a violation of the “Americans for [sic] Disabilities Act.”
So she made every gaff in the book. I suppose there’s a certain irony, if not exactly humor, to be found here.
But there’s another issue hidden inside this story that makes it impossible to laugh at the irony.
Students with learning disabilities are entitled to receive an education, including the accommodations and modifications that allow them to overcome their disability and achieve the educational success. But where does this end?
Clearly, we want LD students to reach their fullest potential, both as a matter of propriety and for the societal benefit of having them as contributing members. But their fullest potential does not mean that they will be able to accomplish whatever they want when their skills, as limited by their disabilities, fall short. This is a sad truth, but truth nonetheless. Would anyone want a blind brain surgeon operating on them? Clearly, being blind does not limit intelligence or drive, but it is a very real disability that impacts on one’s ability to perform certain tasks. There’s just no way around it.
Lisa Dawn Rittenhouse says that she suffers from bipolar disorder, ADHD and dyslexia. None of these, standing alone, precludes the possibility that she can be a successful lawyer. The dyslexia, while it may present some barriers in effective writing, should not present an insurmountable hurdle that her ideas and arguments cannot shine through. After all, misspellings happen to all of us, and we survive (with the help of spellcheck, or better yet, a good editor).
But given the content of her work shown above, she isn’t going to cut it as a lawyer. While we must have a societal policy to support the learning disabled to fulfill their potential, there must also be a point where accommodations end.
I have a problem finding humor in Lisa Dawn Rittenhouse’s “low grape point average.” It just isn’t funny to me that there are people who struggle to achieve their dreams, but are hampered by disabilities. In fact, I admire their struggle to overcome their disabilities, their refusal to be defined by what they can’t do and their efforts to push through their limitations to succeed. But I cannot see her being a lawyer, and putting the fate of another person into her hands.

This entry was posted in