Author Archives: SHG

When You Stop Kissing Up

In a lighthearted comment, Nicole Black, the Queen of the New York Bloggers at Sui Generis and Legal Antics, wrote:

Scott, I bet you’d kiss some mean derrière at the SC

This brought me back to my early days arguing before the court.  Whether the trial or appellate court, a young lawyer looks up at the judge(s) with some degree of awe.  Your hands sweat.  Your stomach feels queasy.  You organize and reorganize your thoughts, repeating the opening line of your argument over and over.  You stand up to speak, hoping that whatever comes out of your mouth doesn’t include the small pieces of the sandwich you had for lunch.

But that was then.  As you age (gracefully), things change.  Men and women who were friends, co-counsel, adversaries, law secretaries, people with whom you had ordinary relationships, take the bench.  Judges who you got to know at the trial court level, when they may have been more indiscreet or insecure, move up the food chain to the appellate court.  Judges go from being JUDGES to people. 

When you look in their eyes, they are people you know.  After your first 50 bar association dinners, when you sat at the table and watched them drink a bit too much and start to warble bad Irish folk songs, awe is no longer the word you would use to describe them.  Similarly, they get to know you.  You aren’t some anonymous lawyer, an unfamiliar face in another pinstripe suit, making pointless sounds when your turn is called.

When I argue an appeal, I stand before a panel of judges that have a different job than me, but are no different than me.  We have shared the experience of life in the trenches.  I don’t argue at them any more.  I talk to them.  I look at them and they are the same people they were when we were all younger.  I know that some of them don’t have a clue about an area of law, but want to do the right thing.  I know that others hate particular argument, and they know that I know.

When they raise an issue that’s specious to see if they can mess with me, I have the authority to throw it back at them.  Rarely will they do this, because they know that I’m not a 30 year old lawyer inclined to take any gruff.  And never will I fail to answer any legitimate question with a direct response.  The minute I start to beat around the bush or avoid the thrust of their challenge, I’ve conceded that I’m not up to the task. 

Some lawyers are painfully obsequious before the court.  Watching them bow and scrape, with every other word “respectfully”, makes me sick.  They are judges, not gods.  They have a job to do, but they are not of a better ilk than anyone else in the courtroom.  If they do their job well, they will see your position with clarity, both its strengths and weaknesses.  It’s my job to make sure that they see that the strengths overcome the weaknesses. 

My purpose is to have a seat at the table when the judges conference my appeal.  I’ve earned it.  When they talk about what to do, they have to pass muster in my eyes the same as I have to pass muster in theirs.  They know that my opinion of the state of the law is every bit as worthy as theirs.  It doesn’t mean that I will necessarily win, but it does mean that I am to be taken seriously and given credence, just like when we sat at the same table and had a beer and talked about the law.

Is the Supreme Court different?  Well, never having had a beer with Nino Scalia, I can’t claim to be able to look him in the eye and connect with the old days.  But he’s the same judge as the one I had lunch with yesterday, as far as I’m concerned.  In fact, one of the things that I find most remarkable about Supreme Court arguments is that the justices tend to be remarkably pragmatic in their questioning.  While the lawyers take stabs at pseudo-intellectualism in an effort to impress, the justices appear strangely ordinary in their vision.  No, I don’t see my voice squeaking or my hands sweating.  I can speak to Justice Scalia as easily as any other judge.  We all put our pants on one leg at a time, though he has four law clerks to help him.

Lawyers who kiss derrières have no seat at the table.  They are just happy to get out of the room alive.  They are in awe of the court.  I respect the court, but demand that the court respect me as well.  That’s what comes of experience.

Who Gets To Define Torture?

My ersatz nominee for Attorney General, former SDNY Chief Judge Michael Mukasey, is back in the new again.  According to the New York Times, he responded to a letter from Democratic Senators who asked a simple question:  Is waterboarding torture?


Mr. Mukasey noted that Congress has not explicitly banned waterboarding by the C.I.A., though it was outlawed for use by the military in the Detainee Treatment Act of 2005. That left room for interpretation as to whether waterboarding or any other technique is prohibited as “cruel, inhuman or degrading” treatment, he wrote.


“Legal questions must be answered based solely on the actual facts, circumstances and legal standards presented,” he wrote.


Now you can’t argue with his proposition that legal questions must be answered based on actual facts, though more than a few federal judges have, in my experienced, jumped to assumptions about the “actual facts” based upon whatever position the government took.  But that was then, this is now.

The problem with defining torture is that it’s subjective.  What is cruel?  Is it something that offends are sensibilities as being the infliction of pain, fear or distress beyond what a civilized person would deem reasonable?  See how we’re back to subjective limits. 

What about inhuman?  Given what people have done to each other, my guess is that nothing is inhuman.  Drawing and quartering was a respectable punishment at one time.  Want to give that some thought?

So what element of the “actual facts” is holding Mukasey back from saying the words that Waterboarding is torture?  My guess is that he’s walking into a situation where is smells a rat, where the CIA and the other initials that run our government are doing things that we won’t find palatable, and he doesn’t want to end up on wikipedia as Alberto Gonzalez’s protégé.  He’s trying so very hard to skirt the issue.

So, let’s turn to the experts.


Waterboarding has also been a flash point among Republican presidential candidates. Last week, after Rudolph W. Giuliani, the former New York mayor, said he was not sure about waterboarding because he thought “the liberal media” might not have described it properly.

Maybe it’s just people from New York who don’t know what Waterboarding is all about?  Rudy knows pretty much everything about everything.  Ask him.  He’ll tell you.  But like Judge Mukasey, he don’t know nothing about no Waterboarding.  Then again, he rooted for the Red Sox, proving once and for all that he don’t know nothing about baseball either.


Senator John McCain of Arizona, who was tortured as a prisoner in North Vietnam, shot back, saying it was a torture method used since the Spanish Inquisition.

Now Senator McCain knows something about torture.  Unlike Rudy, he didn’t have to read about it in the New York Post.  Maybe the “actual facts” do make the difference when it comes to the law.  In my book, John McCain’s idea of what constitutes torture carries a lot of weight.  When Rudy, or Judge Mukasey, or anyone else in the current administration, has had the opportunity to experience what John McCain went through at the Hanoi Hilton, then they can equivocate and parse the legalese as to how to define torture.  In the meantime, McCain wins.

Judge Mukasey, if you want to look to the “actual facts,” have a beer with John McCain and ask him.  Then just answer the question so we can know whether you’re the same man you were on the bench, or whether you drank the Washington cool-aid.  America is tired of watching the D.C. version of Dancing with the Stars.  Stop dancing.

If would help, by the way, if we stopped calling it “waterboarding” and started calling it “simulated death by drowning.”  I realize that it takes up more space in the newspaper this way, and it certainly doesn’t sound as “kewl”, but it’s time to recognize Orwellian spin for what it is.

Book Review: The Future of Reputation

Professor Dan Solove, of  Concurring Opinions fame, presents a fully conceived vision of permanent purgatory in his new book, The Future of Reputation.  For someone who came a little late to the blogosphere, Dan’s accumulation of anecdotes to demonstrate the potential danger of the internet kept my rapt attention.  No, it wasn’t a matter of great humor or spellbinding story-telling, but more like watching car crash after car crash that happened on the corner where I’ve just moved in.  It scared me.

The book is divided in two, with the first half a remarkably thorough exploration of how and why the internet poses problems and issues that are beyond in breadth anything humankind has faced before.  The thoughtful expositions are interspersed with tales of disaster from the web, enough to hold your interest as you try to get your arms around the myriad ways in which gossip, rumor and shaming have wreaked havoc on undeserving individuals.

For parents, particularly those who don’t have a full appreciation of the power of the internet, the first half of Reputation is a must read.  While most can grasp the implications of junior posting inappropriate photos of himself, or writing something he considers funny at 15, there is much more to fear.  When he tries to get a job some day, how many parents have considered the implications of a well-behaved junior being inadvertently skewered by some friend who years before?  With photos!

Dan does a superb job of explaining the interrelationships that give rise to potential, and permanent, harm.  With such important stories as “dog poop girl,” even kids will eventually get the drift that their online activity can cause massive damage, unintended or very much intended, that spirals out of control.  Indeed, Dan drives the “spiraling out of control” theme home throughout the first half of the book, making it clear that there is absolutely no assurance that anything posted online can be “unposted” if scurrilous, false or you just happen to change your mind. 

To the extent the book bogs down in theory, as Dan tends to repeat his very clearly written points a second or third time, just to be sure you got it, there’s always another great story on the next page to keep you plowing ahead.  While it sometimes feels disorganized, it’s more a product of the synergistic nature of the problems, making the headaches difficult to neatly categorize.  One can’t help but wonder how many new, unanticipated problems are waiting around the corner.

The first half of the book is quite a cautionary tale, to be read and digested by anyone who posts online, or knows anyone who posts online, or doesn’t know anyone and rarely leaves the house.  The point is, no one is safe, and Dan backs up the claim with example after example.  The only reason the stories are funny is because they aren’t about you.  Yet.

The second half of the book is an effort to find a way to address the plethora of problems.  Given the breadth of issues, complicated by the myriad of people who are potentially involved, the mere idea that the problems are subject to resolution may be somewhat arrogant.  Still, Dan gives it a shot.  Alas, the answers do not come as easily, or as successfully, as the problems.

Reputation does a thorough and convincing job of explaining existing law, and its inadequacy to deal with the nature of these new problems.  Unfortunately, Dan’s “radical” ways to deal with these problems offers little of practical use.  And frankly, they aren’t too radical.  If anything, Dan’s solutions seem underwhelming given the enormity of the potential problems.

Boiled down, Dan would require putative plaintiffs and defendants to engage in informal efforts to resolve problems (mediation and/or arbitration) before litigation.  How would one compel this?  Who would mediate?  What would happen with the ongoing ruination of a person’s life while they were awaiting an appointment with a mediator?  There are no answers.

The next step would be litigation, recognizing new torts and rights with a balancing act intended to accommodate the degree of harm, permanence, disproportionality, falsehood, abuse, privacy, etc.  But oddly, Dan interjects one hard point into this otherwise fuzzy conceptual paradigm, that damages should be capped because bloggers generally don’t have much money.  This betrays Dan’s politics in the guise of avoiding the chilling of free speech.  Of course, it ignores the degree of harm done to the victim (hence, the amount of damages), not to mention the ability to get blood from a rock.  If you can’t do the time, don’t do the crime.

While The Future of Reputation may not produce any viable cure, it is more than worthwhile to read to understand and appreciate the illness.  Reputation makes it evident that we who live in the age of the internet have much more at risk than we realize, and to the extent it’s possible, it is up to us, our friends and acquaintances, and even our enemies, to create a new set of norms that will allow us to survive with some vestige of privacy, and maybe even some dignity, intact.  For this alone, Reputation is important and should be read by parents, children, and especially anyone who thinks this could never touch them.

Does Connecticut Pay Attention?

Quietly, one of the stalwarts of the criminal blawgosphere has returned.  Norm Pattis of the now defunct Crime & Federalism has opened a solo shop down the road called, imaginatively, Norm Pattis.  

I started out writing this to address Norm’s post from yesterday, Mandatory Three Strikes A Bad Idea, as if this hasn’t been tried, debated and proven a failure elsewhere years ago, and has suddenly struck the lawmakers of CT as a novel idea.  To understand this, you need to realize that while CT sits just above the cultural Mecca of New York, it has only two sources of information.  The first is the Hartford Courant, which is limited to its one real city, maintained solely to prove that not everyone in Connecticut is white and wealthy.  And the second is the Wall Street Journal, widely distributed to everyone outside of Hartford because, well, everyone in Connecticut (except Hartford) is white and wealthy.  Are you surprised that they think 3 strike laws are a new invention?

But, as I was writing, Norm Pattis went and turned my whole morning upside down with his new post, today’s post, about one of my favorite subjects in the world, Robert Malthus.  For anyone unfamiliar, this is an excerpt from Norm’s post explaining Malthusian theory:


“The power of population is so superior to the power of the earth to produce subsistence for man, that premature death must in some shape or other visit the human race. The vices of mankind are active and able ministers of depopulation. They are the precursors in the great army of destruction, and often finish the dreadful work themselves. But should they fail in this war of extermination, sickly seasons, epidemics, pestilence, and plague advance in terrific array, and sweep off their thousands and tens of thousands. Should success be still incomplete, gigantic inevitable famine stalks in the rear, and with one mighty blow levels the population with the food of the world.”

Fascinating, isn’t it?  But Malthus, writing during the Irish potato famine, was not without his detractors, including Jonathon Swift, who penned his satirical “A Modest Proposal” (the 1729 version of Soylent Green) in response.

While my appreciation of Malthus’ point is substantially less literal than Norm’s, and I’ve long believed that while some of the details may change, his point remains valid, Norm’s connection of Malthusian theory to Global Warming today should make everyone pause and think long and hard.

Man, it’s great to have Norm back and posting.  This is great stuff.

Is It Us or Them?

A debate was started amongst the literati over at  Volokh Conspiracy as to the miserable failure of competency in the criminal law realm when it comes to winning the Big Game (that’s the United States Supreme Court who might confuse it with the Patriots vs. Colts game this coming Sunday).

Orin Kerr lays out the problem this way:


 I would guess that’s the major problem in criminal defense cases. Lazarus states at the top of page 95 that criminal defense lawyers sometimes decline assistance from Supreme Court experts, preferring to “go it alone,” and that this can lead to a major gap in advocacy quality between the government and the defense. But the underlying problem is that the clients will tend not to know any better. A young and uneducated criminal defendant serving 30-to-life in a maximum security prison isn’t likely to be a specialist in appellate practice. He isn’t likely to know that he should ask his trial lawyer to step aside and find top-notch appellate advocates out there eager to represent him for free.

So the loaded question is, who’s more ridiculously obstinate and ignorant, us or our clients?  No objections here, so sit down and save it for the real court.

Clearly, the debate is loaded against us.  By the lawprof’s calculations, there is a small cabal of lawyers qualified to bring cases before the Supreme Court.  They “know” the secret handshake.  We don’t.  They “know” the secret password.  We don’t.  They are big-time SCOTUS lawyers.  We are . . . mere lawyers.

Is Orin Kerr right?  While there are many criminal defense lawyers who will do the occasional appeal, and do it poorly, in the ordinary course of practice, is even the best among us out of his league when it comes to the Big Game (see above).  Is there no one since Thurgood Marshall who can command the respect of the Justices (and, if I understand Orin correctly, the more important law clerks who gate-keep their bosses)?

Orin notes how big corps are able to hire the big guns to steer their cases through cert and into the Supreme Court Reports.  When it comes to our kind of client, however, these same Mandarins will take the case for free just for the glory.  Why are we so pig-headed that we won’t use them?  After all, these are the Big Guys. 

One reaction to Orin’s post was how someone becomes a member of the SCOTUS cabal if it’s wrong to argue a first case.  This is, of course, the perpetual conundrum of how to get a credit card if you don’t have any credit.  The difference here, unbeknownst to the academics, is that few of us will ever get a second shot to argue before the Supremes, so that our first (and only) effort is not a prelude to future greatness, but our one chance to prove our mettle.

Perhaps there is a middle ground that Orin has missed.  Perhaps the problem is not that some lawyers have eschewed the cabal, but that they just aren’t up to the task on their own.  Other lawyers, who have substantially more experience before the Circuits, state high courts, will do better for the same reason that anyone does better, more experience.  His point, that pig-headed criminal defense solo-type lawyers are willing to sacrifice their clients and the state of the law for their one shot at glory even though they lack the experience and skill necessary to make an adequate showing, may have some merit.  Just not as much breadth as he thinks.

Full Disclosure:  I’ve never argued a case before the United States Supreme Court.  I would like to though.  On the other hand, I’ve argued cases along with co-counsel who happened to be law professors at Tier 1 Law Schools.  I wasn’t impressed.  But I don’t mind them riding my coattails.  They probably need more experience.

Last One Out, Shut The Door

There is some pride in announcing that the New York  Capital Defenders Office has gone out of business.  Now that the Court of Appeals has decided People v. Taylor, following the death penalty statute’s having been declared unconstitutional in 2004, its work it done.

The state of criminal law in New York is hardly perfect.  Far from perfect, in fact.  Very, very far.  But we got one thing right.  We no longer have a death penalty.  Compare that to Texas, where they put people to death with such regularity that it barely makes a ripple in a judicial day’s work.  There is a line that the courts of New York will not cross, and this is it.

As the Capital Defenders wind down operations, there is one person whose name is largely unknown but to whom we all owe a debt of gratitude.  He is the Executive Director of the office, Kevin M. Doyle. 

When government puts its collective minds together to come up with a solution, the result is rarely a good one.  At best, we hope for mediocrity (right, Brownie?).  At worst, we await news of the scandal or task force to figure out why it failed so miserably.  With the Capital Defenders, they finally nail it.  Kevin Doyle’s work has been superb.  In fact, I can’t imagine anyone doing a better job than Kevin. 

Under Kevin’s command, not on human being was executed in the State of New York.  Because of Kevin’s efforts, most prosecutors were persuaded not to pursue death as the punishment.  Kevin’s leadership resulted in the statute being held unconstitutional, and Kevin is ultimately responsible for the best news of all, that there is no longer a need in the State of New York for an Office of the Capital Defender.  It is a tribute to Kevin Doyle.

Rarely does a void become a monument to the skill, dedication and success of a person.  And I’m sure that Kevin would be the first to argue that this was a group effort by Kevin and the staff of attorneys he put together to fight the good fight, and I have no doubt that’s true.  Still, there is one person in charge, who will bear the consequences of failure, and should enjoy the appreciation of success.  Kevin has earned our appreciation.

Thank you, Kevin M. Doyle, for a job so very well done.  New York is a better place for your efforts.

The Magic of Rape

David Copperfield is an illusionist, not a magician.  But he used to be a real person.  I knew him when we were kids, way back when.  He wasn’t called David Copperfield then, but Dave Kotkin.  We went to the Mildred B. Moss Elementary School (named Washington School until Principal Moss retired) in Metuchen, New Jersey, where we played in a dustbowl-like playground.  His two front teeth were chipped, and he got the nickname “Fang”.  It was a pretty cool nickname.

Dave was a remarkably ordinary kid.  Smart and geeky.  Not too smart, but still geeky.  To suggest that he would someday become a sex symbol would have been laughable.  Talk about an extreme makeover.  But he took an interest in magic, and developed an act for children’s birthday parties.  I remember when he announced that he was going to take the stage name “David Copperfield.”  I thought it was stupid.  What did I know?  The other option was something like “The Great Davido,” which sounded much more magician-like to me.

David Copperfield has had a fantastic career.  He reached the pinnacle of the illusionist world, with his name immediately recognizable world-wide.  He has accumulated great wealth.  He’s become the sex symbol, despite all rumors to the contrary.  He had something to do with Claudia Schiffer, thought it was never clear to me what that was.

And after all that, David Copperfield finds himself the object of suspicion and accusation.  With two barrels blazing, the FBI raided his Las Vegas warehouse and made known to the world that he has been accused of rape.  The FBI couldn’t bear the initial sparsity of information, and so some nameless source chatted up the  Seattle Times to spill the secret grand jury news.  Like  Talkleft, it bothers me that grand jury secrecy is a one way street. 

The magic of an accusation of rape is that once made, it is nearly impossible to make disappear.  Even for David Copperfield.

It wasn’t bad enough that, after the raid on his warehouse, they made sure the media found out that they found $2 Mil in cash.  For a guy who makes as much as Dave, he’s allowed to keep as much cash as he pleases.  It’s not like he’s running some side-biz that he’s trying to hide from the IRS.  After the first $50 Million a year, the taxes don’t really matter all that much.  But the hint is that something nefarious is going on with David Copperfield, since neither your nor I keep that much cash lying around.  Then again, my income was a little shy of David’s last year.  Let’s just say we aren’t in the same bracket.

As the story slowly trickles out of the Seattle Field Office, my concern for Dave grows.  There is no accusation that is so morally impugning as rape.  Once tagged, it remains a stain that cannot be easily cleansed.  Will anyone look at Kobe the same again?  For an ordinary person, he only becomes a pariah within the smaller community that knows and cares.  For a person with celebrity like Dave’s, the impact is different.

So far, he has handled it with dignity.  His attorney, David Chesnoff, is doing his best to keep it down to a dull roar, knowing too well that his efforts to quell the accusations not only limit what he will be able to do when the full story comes out, but the more he says the louder the story becomes.  By giving the boring attorney answers, he hopes the media will find nothing worthy to print, and go away.  At least for now.  It’s the best he can do.

David Copperfield is no kid anymore.  If he wants women, my bet is he can get them.  At the very least, anybody with his own island in the Bahamas is a very good looking guy.  I learned that from a short, dumpy but very successful lawyer who informed me that he was 6 feet tall when he stood atop his money.  That would make David Copperfield a giant.

It would be impossible to comment about what happened in the Bahamas as yet, because the information is spotty and one-sided.  It strikes me as hard to imagine that David Copperfield would commit rape; that he would have any reason to go to such horrific extremes.  I have a hard time understanding why David Copperfield would bother to fly a 21 year old girl to his island to begin with.  She was beautiful?  There are a lot of beautiful women.  

According to the FBI story, she claims to have been approached by David’s entourage the moment she stepped into an auditorium.  This makes sense if the entourage looks for an attractive audience member to use during the show, seating her in a special place so David can call her onstage when needed.  But how does it go from a stage in Seattle to an island in the Bahamas?  Both the need and desire element seem quite fuzzy to me.

I also have difficulty with the idea that Dave Kotkin would do such a thing.  Granted, there’s been a lot of water under the bridge since I last saw him.  Would he remember who I was?  I haven’t a clue.  I forget people all the time, and I assume he does too.  He probably meets more people than I do. 

But this was no kid who dreamed of world hegemony when I knew him.  He wasn’t on a power trip.  Dave was good, regular guy.  It’s not that the allegations are impossible.  Very little is impossible.  But I’m not inclined to buy into any of this without a whole lot more.  It would be a horrible shame if Dave Kotkin, a good kid from Metuchen who succeeded on his own merits, was impugned by backdoor whispers out of Seattle.  At the moment, the allegations against David Copperfield are only an illusion.  Don’t forget that.

Skakel Revisited: The Mickey Sherman Conundrum

Michael Skakel had it all going for him.  Rich family.  Decades between a murder and a prosecution.  The ability to hire the best and brightest legal counsel available.  Enter Mickey Sherman.

Mickey has a smile that will light up a room.  He is disarming and charming.  He has reached that upper echelon of lawyers who do big time cases.  He was a regular on Larry King, and there was always a seat available for him at Regine’s. 

But Mickey lost Skakel.  For many, that’s enough.

Norm Pattis, formerly of the now-defunct Crime & Federalism, raises a better points at his new blog.


The next meaningful chapter in this saga will be a habeas corpus petition alleging ineffective assistance of counsel against Sherman. It will be a painful chapter in the history of the Connecticut bar. Sherman is a member of the well-heeled and clubby fraternity of high-rollers. Someone will have to attack Mickey to save Mr. Skakel.

Did Skakel lose the trial because his lawyer was too busy playing celebrity?

The lure of the shining lights is powerful.  And Mickey was custom made for celebrity.  He had the look.  He had the mouth.  He was the dream defense lawyer for every cable news show in need of lunch meat to fill the hole in its sandwich.  And Mickey was born to be lunch meat.

So why didn’t Mickey, awash in Kennedy money to use every available resource to defend his client, strategically build a corps of lawyers, investigators, experts to address everything the prosecution could throw at Skakel?  Was it to save the limelight for himself?

Consider what happened to the OJ dream team.  It started with Bob Shapiro, no stranger to celebrity himself, adding some of the most recognizable names in the law to the defense side.  F. Lee Bailey.  Johnny Cochran.  Barry Scheck.  Each a star in his own right.  In fact, much more a star than poor Bob Shapiro, now entrepreneurial  founder of legalzoom.  Though well-known, Shapiro was the least well-regarded lawyer on the team.

Mickey didn’t need a team of hard-working, nose to the grind-stone lawyers.  Mickey would beat back the prosecution with his smile, charm and wit.  And then make it to Larry King in time to bask in the glow of success, after the jury foreperson announced, with a big, broad smile, “Not Guilty!”  What a party it would be then.

Except it didn’t happen.  All except the Larry King appearance.  That happened.   Despite the verdict of guilty, Mickey found the time to go on Larry King.

For most trial lawyers, revisiting our work is what happens when a client is convicted.  In a peculiar way, we hope that we did something during the course of the trial that a post-trial motion will reveal to be ineffective and thus open the door to a new trial.  We don’t need to pretend that we are perfect.  Indeed, there is no such thing as perfection at trial, just a series of non-stop choices, to be made in split-seconds, based upon inadequate information. 

Will Mickey still have that beautiful smile when asked whether he was ineffective at trial?  Stay tuned for more of Larry King!

Loser Truth

Another Sunday morning, and a lawyer’s fancy turns to defense strategy.  We have all met the client who comes to us with a story about what really happened that is just plain bad.  The client insists on his innocence.  He swears he is innocent.  We press a few of his buttons to attempt to make the client understand that innocence won’t make us work harder, doesn’t impress us and won’t get him a dinner invitation.  He doesn’t care.  He is innocent.

But his story of what happened is horrible.  It’s irrational.  It’s unmarketable.  We listen, hear the holes and logical gaps, and realize immediately that it is not a story that can be sold to a jury.  It makes him look either idiotic or insane.  Pick ’em. 

We push some more buttons, under the belief that when confronted with the reality that the story stinks, perhaps he will back off it and realize that what seemed like a brilliant story in the confines of the back seat of a police cruiser to him may not play as well in front of a jury.  Perhaps he will reconsider (assuming he hasn’t already spilled his guts to the police with this brilliant tale of woe that, in his mind, should totally exculpate him).  No dice.  It is the truth, he insists.  No, demands.  It is the truth.

There are two possibilities at this point.  First is that he is psychotic, incapable of distinguishing reality from the delusion that persists in his mind.  If this is the case, our course is clear.  Have the client evaluated for competency and deal with the outcome.  The client may not be crazy enough to be legally not responsible, but it may serve to either negate intent or mitigate sentence.  One of the things we should all have in our rolodex is the card of a great psychiatrist and neuro-psychologist.  They can be indispensable, since we aren’t competent to diagnose anybody of anything.  We should, however, be capable of knowing when an evaluation is needed.

The second is that he is indeed telling the truth, with tends to be in direct inverse proportion to the degree of insistence relative to this terrible story.  In other words, the most strenuously he insists that a bad story is true in the face of being told that his insistence will mean the demise of his defense, the more likely it is true.  This is loser truth.

We are now in an ethical quandary.  If our client insists that he is innocent, and that the story went down as he relates, we are ethically bound to pursue a defense not inconsistent with his truth.  We cannot call witnesses to testify to facts that the client insists are false.  We cannot press the client to change his story for the sake of expedience.  We are locked in to a position that we believe to guarantee conviction, and a client who insists that he would rather go to prison than lie about what happened.  Why?  Because this time he is innocent, and he is going to tell the truth.

This is another of our many “nightmare” scenarios.  As criminal defense lawyers, always fighting the uphill battle, we want to provide our clients the best possible defense.  No one wants to go into battle with a hand tied behind their back.  But then, our job is to zealously represent our client within the bounds of the law.  We are not entitled to do whatever we have to do, including ignoring the client’s version of the truth because it’s a lousy story. 

Aside from the variety of weapons that are generally available, such as suppression or speedy trial, that have little to do with the defendant’s perspective on the case, we feel a bit vulnerable at this stage.  We have an “innocent” client (meaning one that refuses a plea offer even when told that his chances of prevailing are slim) and a defense theory that fails the sniff test.  Not a good situation.

At this point, many lawyers start to rationalize that whatever happens is not their fault, since the client has made his own bed.  Here’s the point:  Don’t give up.  No one wants to go to trial thinking in advance that he’s going to lose.  It’s depressing and takes all the wind out of you.  And it is a self-fulfilling prophesy.  Think you’re going to lose and indeed you will.

Consider instead that this scenario frees you from all constraints.  This is your chance to go into flights of fantasy, to go for broke.  Consider that every silver lining has a dark cloud in front of it.  And you are staring at a very dark cloud.

Your approach to the jury should encompass certain banal considerations:

Every defendant is presumed innocent, not intelligent.  Your client may have acted/reacted in a way that the jury will find to be foolish, even mind-bogglingly stupid.  We are not all geniuses.  Some people, like the defendant, are at the lowest end of the spectrum.  They are allowed to be stupid.  That’s not a crime.

So when the prosecution argues, as they invariably will, that no innocent person would behave in the fashion that the defendant did, your response is that the prosecution is wrong.  A stupid person does what stupid people do.  I call this the Forest Gump defense. 

Next, the prosecution will argue, and the jury will believe, that “normal” people (whoever they are) conduct themselves in accordance with societal norms.  When your client’s actions/reactions fall outside those norms, they become proof of guilt.  We need to paint the picture of “societal norms” that our client sees, rather than what the prosecutor or jury sees.  Interestingly, the jury may well see 12 different versions but never realize that they all see norms differently.  Chances are that none of those 12 versions will look anything like our client’s version.

Whether the defendant is a street kid or a corporate CEO, he has a peer group with peculiar standards by which his conduct is compared.  When Dennis “The Menace” Kozlowski’s $6,000 shower curtain splashed across the news, it made him sound like a classless cad.  But this was how the newly minted near-billionaire behaves, something that few of us can relate to.  So what if your client is a tacky, nouveau riche Philistine.  That’s not a crime.  A reason to ridicule, obviously, but not a crime.

Finally, the argument of last resort:  Sometimes really bizarre, unusual, extraordinarily unlikely things happen.  Whether because the defendant is weird, or a confluence of peculiar events, or one foolhearty reaction begat a series of events that under other circumstances would never occur, they do happen.  This would be the time to try to slip in, under the judge’s radar, the argument that the defendant would not be here given the wealth of evidence against him if he wasn’t innocent (objection, sustained). 

Doctors use an aphorism, “when you hear hoofbeats behind you, don’t expect to see a Zebra.”  But then, sometimes it is a Zebra.  Zebras do exist. 

These arguments are offered as examples of how you are forced off the beaten path when your client comes to you with Loser Truth.  They are hard positions to take, and have a high probability of losing. But when your client insists that he is innocent and there really was a Zebra behind him, your duty is the give him the best damn trial you can.  And from experience, I can tell you that there is enormous freedom in trying the impossible case, and this freedom empowers you to say and do things that you might never otherwise consider.  And sometimes, there really is a Zebra behind you.