Author Archives: SHG

Roy Black: Simple Justice Nailed It!

Well, not in so many words, but who’s going to quibble over something like that.  In this  New York Lawyer piece about my ersatz good buddy, Joe Francis, or Girls Gone Wild fame, my gut reaction was confirmed.  You remember Joe?  He was the subject of an attempt to scam Simple Justice into  blawging for the cause a while back.

Joe has a bunch of legal problems, ranging from the expected tax evasion to using video of underage girls in his soft-core porn business.  He was framed, he’ll tell you. 

But the good thing about making $29 Million off young women willing to bare their breasts, as well as engage in other things that I assure you will not please their parents, is that you can afford to hire Roy Black as your attorney. 

You would think that Joe Francis would show his attorney a little respect.  But no.  Joe has decided to launch a web media campaign to prove his innocence, because “Marketing is what I do best.”


Joe Francis, 34, engineered the ad campaign to gain support from any audience that will listen to his twisted legal story, which began in Panama City Beach in 2003 and now has him in a Nevada jail cell.

So what does his lawyer think of this scheme?  Not much, apparently.


His attorney, Miami uber-lawyer Roy Black, jokes that Francis might be less self destructive if he were classified as an enemy combatant.   “That way he wouldn’t have access to a phone,” said Black.

But with a client who is so determined to “market” his way to freedom, the road can get rocky.

“Joe and I have had numerous yelling contests over this and I keep telling him how he’s screwing up his case.” Black said. “I’m sure the state and federal prosecutors are going to use some of the things he says against him.”

And so I feel honored that Joe Francis felt that Simple Justice was such a powerful presence in the blawgosphere that we were a part of his marketing campaign, despite advice of counsel.  And for  those kids who couldn’t smell a rat when I received the simple, innocent email request to help poor Joe Francis, take a lesson from Roy Black.  Listen to Greenfield.

No Science to Policing

Barry Scheck, embarrassingly described as “Famed O.J. Simpson lawyer,” testified before a Georgia House study committee that police need to have a prescribed protocol in conducting eyewitness identifications, according to an AP story reported in the New York Lawyer.

A recent survey by the Georgia Innocence Project found that 83 percent of 296 police departments surveyed had no written protocol in place governing how to conduct lineups.


Barry, who would be better described as the head of the Innocence Project at Cardozo Law School, or perhaps the leading legal authority on the use of DNA to free innocent people wrongly convicted on flawed eyewitness identifications, stated that “The criminal justice system has to become more scientific in areas where we can prevent errors.”  The Georgia study comes after 6 men were freed after years in jail when DNA was used to prove their innocence. 

The absence of written protocol for conducting identifications is shocking, given how DNA has proven beyond any doubt whatsoever that eyewitness identifications are fraught with error.  On the other hand, given how cops are reluctant to adopt, and even more reluctant to actually employ, scientific protocols that might get in the way to their nailing the bad guy to the wall, it comes as no surprise at all.

There is no longer any question that the traditional line-up, not to mention show-up, photo-array, whatever, is about as useful a tool as the 5 point fingerprint.  What was pronounced to be fool-proof is now just a show for fools.  It’s good to see Georgia doing something to change it, and particularly good to see someone as knowledgeable and dedicated as Barry Scheck called to testify.  Now if only the rest of the country followed suit, perhaps we could put this sorry chapter of conclusive police work to rest.

Bad Work at the Supreme Court

On the heels of  my post about how money and rigor keeps cases from making their way to the Supreme Court, comes scathing criticism by Eugene Volokh of the respondent-defendant’s brief.

What a Bad Supreme Court Brief: I just finished reading Williams’ brief in U.S. v. Williams , and it’s pretty shoddy.


The title may not be particularly witty, but it does catch your eye.  If for nothing else, to make sure it isn’t your brief he’s writing about. 

The Williams case is a child porn case.  There are four (count ’em, 4) lawyers listed on the cover.  And the brief is replete with misspellings, grammar and syntax errors.  Worse yet, the argument is poorly constructed, redundant and unpersuasive.  It’s one of those briefs where the lawyers think if you repeat the same platitudes over and over, no one will notice that you’re fly is open. 

Volokh received a surprise slap for this piece from some of his readers who found his critique to be in bad taste.”  When he pushed the envelope, the slap stung worse as readers raised the ugly specter that Volokh was being “disingenuous”.  After all, when was the last time a law professor publicly excoriated another law professor for academic writing that, well, stunk?  His defenders pointed out one need not criticize every work to be justified in criticizing any work.

Whether Eugene Volokh is disingenuous is best left to those more familiar with his sacred cows.  He is right, however, that when you submit a brief to the Supreme Court of the United States, you should expect scrutiny.  This is the big game, ladies and gentlemen.  This is not an opportunity to see whether spellcheck is as good as Bill Gates says it is. 

The Williams brief demonstrates the danger of a lawyer (or a group of lawyers) taking a case to the Supreme Court when unprepared to do so.  It is inconceivable that this gang of four could not be bothered to check the spelling of their brief.  That they lacked the capacity to write cogent sentences is another matter.  Their inability to present a well-reasoned argument is, well, very troubling.  Sure, next week there will be TV commercial airing in Coral Gables about how they are the only local criminal defense lawyers who have been to the big dance.  I doubt they will mention how their brief caused a bit of a stir. 

So how did they get there?  Well, apparently kiddie porn pays well, but doesn’t impart the level of judgment needed to select the right lawyer for an appearance before the Supremes.  But the issue raised obviously piqued someone’s interest.  And if the constitutionality of the underlying law is going to be decided for all of us, my preference is that we have better representation.  Notably, this is the respondent’s brief, meaning that these guys won in the Circuit and the losers sought cert.  Still, whether they are representing the appellant or respondent, this is not amatuer hour. 

So yes, Eugene, I think you were absolutely right to note publicly that this brief was poor.  Whether you needed to be so offensive about it is another matter, but that’s part of the game when you play in the big leagues as well.  My point in discussing this is to show the back-story in how bad law happens when bad work finds its way to the top. 

I will not, and cannot, say that the lawyers for Williams are not brilliant lawyers.  Under other circumstances.  I don’t know them and they may well be great lawyers.  But this brief was not great.  Not even close.  So when the stars align, and you get the opportunity to present your case to the Supremes, this is the time to play your “A” game.  If you are not up to it, then find someone else who is.  But don’t, for the sake of all of us, show up with a brief like this.  There is no excuse.  It has got to be the best it can be, and this brief was junior varsity at best.

The Twisted Case of Lt. Cmdr. Matthew Diaz

David Tarrell at  In The Moment posts about Navy Lt. Cmdr. Matthew Diaz, a Jag officer at Gitmo who tried to blow the whistle.  His story appears in the New York Times, and presents a cautionary tale as the War on Terror drags on.

As a military lawyer stationed at Guantanamo Bay, Diaz found himself in a quandary.

Diaz’s indignation at the government’s policies had been building since he arrived at Guantánamo. He did not doubt that there were dangerous men there. But he had come to believe that the Pentagon was misrepresenting how the detainees were treated and the threat some of them posed. As a lawyer, he found the recalcitrance of the White House indefensible. The Supreme Court had spoken. Why could’t the administration go before a judge and show why these men should be held indefinitely and without charge? “I feel like I’m on the wrong side,” he confided to a couple of the lawyers who were representing Guantánamo prisoners.


So Diaz decided to do something about it.  He printed out the information about the 551 inmates and sent them in a Valentines card to Barbara Olshansky, a lawyer he had never met at the Center for Constitutional Rights. 

Olshansky had no clue why someone would do this.  When she received the information, she thought it was a joke.  You know how those lefty lawyers are a bunch of jokesters. Laughter became suspicion, as lawyers at the center thought that they were being set up by the government.  This sort of thing could happen.

Upon reflection, they notified the judge hearing their Gitmo challenges.  The judge’s courtroom deputy was asked if Olshansky could send it over for safekeeping.  Instead, she was told to turn it over to Justice.  The Center received a visit from the FBI, to whom they turned over the information.

David Tarrell provides a compelling glimpse into the background of Diaz, whose father was convicted of capital murder, and jumps into the fray to support Diaz’s suicidal leap of conscience.  Diaz did not come to the decision to act until more than 6 months had passed since the Supreme Court’s Rasul decision, holding that the Gitmo detainees were entitled to legal representation to challenge their detention in U.S. courts, and the government was still stonewalling.  Diaz found himself on the wrong side and, believing that if he didn’t act, no one would, took matters into his own hands.

I would very much like to write, at this point, that Diaz is an American hero for having bucked the military, given life to the Supreme Court’s Rasul decision, and fought a government that he believed was violating the law.  I would like to, but I can’t.

I don’t doubt Diaz’s claim that there was no way up the chain of command that would have altered the government’s decision to stonewall the defense lawyers seeking information about the Gitmo detainees.  He had no lawful means to act to achieve the outcome he sought. Aside from his covert (and ill-conceived) plan to send the CCR lawyer a Valentines card, he was stuck.  Frustration, coupled with a personal sense of morality, drove him to this act.

But Matthew Diaz was not like some corporate whistleblower.  He wasn’t a defense attorney whose sole obligation was zealous defense of his client.  Matthew Diaz was a Lieutenant Commander in the United States Navy.  He was an officer in the military.  He picked his side, and upon putting on the uniform, undertook certain bedrock obligations that are larger than his personal vision of right and wrong at any given moment.

While I find myself critical of much that has happened with our military since about 1963, and have been happy to openly criticize it at will, I do not wear a uniform.  I have the right to criticize it, and I compromise no obligation by doing so.  Indeed, I can argue that I fulfill my duty as an American citizen by challenging my government when I disagree with it.  A soldier compromises that opportunity.  A soldier knows this when he selects fatigues over a suit and tie. 

The military cannot function without discipline and following orders.  We are not talking about orders to commit a crime or an atrocity.  We are talking about orders that, for better or worse, reflect a position being argued at the highest levels of government, and challenged in the courts of the nation.  One thing a soldier, of a Jag Lt. Comdr. cannot do, is make the choice to disobey orders whenever there is personal disagreement.  Worse yet, to disobey orders and thus, by the hand of a single person, make choices for the entirety of the American government. 

The matter was in the courts, being fought hard by civilian lawyers.  The matter was in the media, being questioned hard.  These are the mechanisms, for better or worse, that are used to challenge, question and hopefully overcome wrongful governmental conduct.  Was there an injustice going down at Gitmo?  I wouldn’t even begin to question to that, as I have no doubt that it was very wrong.  But the world is fraught with injustice, and it is through the mechanisms that society has developed that we continue the fight to right the wrongs.  What cannot happen is the breakdown of our quasi-potent institutions whenever things don’t happen the way we want, or don’t happen quickly enough to suit us. 

If Matthew Diaz wore anything other than a uniform, I would not hesitate to applaud his act of conscience.  But once he chose Navy dress whites, the obligation that goes with the uniform trumps his right to act upon personal choices.  He knew that.  He chose the uniform.  He violated his obligation.  As wrong as our government can be, Matthew Diaz was more wrong.

Retroactivity of Crack Guidelines Correction

Families Against Mandatory Minimums(FAMM) is engaged in a letter writing campaign to the United States Sentencing Commission to make its amendment to normalize the sentencing disparity between crack and powdered cocaine retroactive.

Last April, the  United States Sentencing Commission discovered that the 100 to 1 disparity between crack cocaine, favored by the poor, minorities and inner city folk, should be changed to mirror the sentencing guidelines for powdered cocaine, favored by whites, the wealthy and celebrities.  Better late then never, right?

But these amendments, scheduled to take effect November 1, 2007, have yet to be made retroactive, leaving almost 20,000 people in federal prisons who would otherwise have the opportunity to seek a sentence reduction based upon this change.

The argument in favor of not making the amendments retroactive, I assume, is that the draconian sentencing structure was in force at the time they committed the crime, and enjoying the greatest of legal weapons, the legal fiction, they knew of the harsh penalties and still chose to commit the crime.  Clean, simple and ridiculously wrong. (Apologies to Mencken). 

To presume that defendants appreciate the nuanced application of the United States Sentencing Guidelines, and hence flaunted them when committing any crime, no less a drug crime, is just plain silly.  Sure, they know it’s illegal.  But the actual consequences?  Most lawyers couldn’t tell you what they are without looking them up.

The argument for retroactivity is far more compelling, particularly in light of the Sentencing Commission’s conclusions that this disparity is terribly wrong.  One could always ponder why it took them forever to realize it, but let’s leave that alone for now.  If it is wrong now, it was wrong before.  It is a wrong perpetrated by a failed sentencing scheme, then why would they not correct their error for those already subject to a sentence that they now find to be grossly disproportionate?

While we cannot revive a defendant wrongly put to death, we can correct the sentence of prisoners still serving their overlong sentence.  To leave someone in prison who, had they been sentenced after an arbitrary date, would have received a substantially different sentence, is unfair, disproportionate and reduces the legitimate purposes of sentencing to a farce.

And before any rugged-individualists get too bent out of shape about it, we are not talking about opening the prison doors so all the crackheads can walk out.  They will be resentenced to stiff sentences (including the mandatory minimums that you love so dearly), just not as stiff at the 100 to 1 sentencing disparity would require.

If you support retroactivity, go to the FAMM website and see what you can do to remind the Sentencing Commissioners that the error was theirs, and they have an opportunity to do the right thing. 

Supreme Court Mechanics

With so much discussion amongst the blawgs about the relative merits of Supreme Court clerkships, Supreme Court Justices, and now the Supreme Court mafia, it seemed appropriate to consider Supreme Court mechanics.  Lawyers are obsessed with the Supreme Court for somewhat obvious reasons.  It’s the big time.  Our chance at immortality.  Our chance to win the big decision that will change the law for decades, maybe even centuries, to come. 

The miserable truth is that few will ever sit in that well.  While most don’t belong there, given the damage they could cause society, even those who do will never have cause to put on a clean white shirt and listen for their name to be called.

Many who read the opening will jump to the assumption that few lawyers have cases worthy of Supreme attention, and that is why I write this.  While somewhat true, they are wrong about the bottom line.  The problem about which I write is not case-worthiness, but mechanics.  For the ivory tower and a handful of Biglaw guys, this doesn’t present an issue.  The reason is that the ivory tower guys don’t actually do a lot of law, and the handful of Biglaw guys have the real deep pockets that allows them to do whatever they please.

In the low world of lawyering in the trenches, clients hope to prevail at the lowest possible level.  To this end, they are willing to pay (if at all) for the best chance at trial.  By the time a first level appeal is over, the client is usually tapped out and/or too tired to keep up the fight.  The lawyer frequently has burned out on the case as well by then.  It’s hard to keep up the level of intensity and interest needed to mount the fight over and over.

When we find ourselves with the right client and the right cause, and want to pursue the big issue to the top of the legal food chain, we still have to deal with reality.  We work for a living.  Office rent has to get paid, and the telephone company is funny about its bills.  Few people have the wherewithal to make it to the fourth court, if in state court.  It’s only third if the case is federal, but those cases cost far more to begin with, with the same ultimate result. 

There are plenty of cases that present issues that may be SCOTUS worthy.  They may, in fact, be cases where the facts are right, the law is right.  The stars are aligned.  Except for one little star twinkling until it burns itself out.  That’s the client’s star.  It burned so hot and bright in the beginning, and then it was gone.

For those lawyers (and former Supreme Court law clerks) who focus so hard on “the word” out of D.C., most “real law” happens in the little courts.  These courts don’t pay particularly close attention to the big pronouncements.  These courts rarely make it onto anyone’s radar.  They are dirty, ugly courts where dirty, ugly clients and their dirty, ugly lawyers spend their days doing dirty, ugly law. 

Few lawyers will ever become a member of the Supreme Court mafia, a group of elite lawyers who apparently not only get to appear and argue before the Supreme Court on a regular basis, but also affect the ever-decreasing docket of the court.  What are these lawyers invited to the party, when others are not?  Money.  They have the corporate sponsorship behind them to put on a full Court press.  While I have no doubt these lawyers possess the appropriate skill level to justify their membership in this group, without the financial fuel to drive their efforts forward, they would be sitting with the rest of us in the visitors section.

Unlike the big show in Washington, many people pass through the hallways of local courts.  They may well be people like your parents or siblings, or their friends and neighbors, but this isn’t the law you teach about in law school or you aspire to practice.  Ah, the glory of being the hero in Gideon or Miranda.  But that’s the lawyer equivalent of winning the lottery.  If you want interesting people with interesting cases, go down to your local courthouse and sit in a courtroom for a while.  Maybe then you’ll understand why these cases never make it to the Supreme Court.

Police and the Disabled

Jon Katz at  Underdog unearthed an old blawg post from  Deaf Law Blog about police firing on a deaf driver because he didn’t obey their commands.  They shouted at the driver in English and Spanish, and then fired.

Disabilities, such as those affecting hearing and sight, are fairly easy for the abled to comprehend.  You can’t order a blind person to see or a deaf person to hear.  Not if you’re a cop.  Not even if you’re a judge.  And not if you’re a parent.

But there is a spectrum of disabilities that are far harder to appreciate and comprehend, particularly when dealing with children, and they have enormous potential to wreak havoc.  Consider developmentally-disabled children who may lash out in school against teachers, aides and other students, when they are given commands that conflict with whatever way their brains are wired.  Often brought on by the adults running the show, these students react in a relatively predictable fashion, predictable to someone who understands their issues and recognizes the cues that bring on frustration, even terror.

All too often, when something happens that will cause a child to act out in a violent fashion, the teacher or school will contact police to deal with the situation.  This is caused by the confluence of events, with teachers refusing to deal with violence, zero-tolerance policies, lack of understanding of the child, inability or refusal to recognize that it is the teacher’s failure to understand what causes the child to become violent.

When the police arrive, they have no idea, nor any particular reason to have any idea, of the impact of the child’s developmental disability.  They will treat the student like any other, giving orders and demanding compliance upon pain of arrest and even violence.  Of course, this creates a collision course, since the developmentally disabled child is incapable of understanding, and therefore complying, with the commands. Indeed, screaming commands under frantic circumstances will almost invariably exacerbate the situation, creating the scenario for tragedy.

Unlike a blind or deaf student, with whom a teacher has far greater understanding of the disability and can provide police with an explanation of why the student cannot do whatever he or she is being ordered to do, many teachers lack a sufficient understanding to either recognize the student’s limitations or convey that information quickly and effectively to police.  In other words, there is no way to alert police to the real problem.

It should also be noted that this potentially tragic scenario isn’t limited to school settings.  The developmentally disabled also go out in the real world, and confront the same problems on their own.  They don’t necessarily have any outward signs of disability, like funny-looking faces or tattoos on their foreheads, and there is nothing to overtly alert police that they should be treated differently than anyone else.

While there is no magic bullet solution to this situation, there are some things that should be done to limit the potential for harm to these children.  For those who live in smaller communities, parents should bring their children to visit their local police department.  Create a level of comfort between child and police officers (which will alleviate a degree of fear) and introduce the child to the officers.  Once the officers meet and get some clue that the child has issues, they will both be sensitized to the potential problems and aware of your child’s special needs.  The time to do this is before a problem arises.  After may be too late.

It is also critical that parents sit down with school officials, teachers and aides to discuss what may bring on violent or aggressive behavior, such as transitions, disruption of routine and over-stimulation (i.e., loud noises, disruptive classrooms, fire drills).  Inappropriate reactions by developmentally-disabled children are to be anticipated, and by planning ahead for them, a parent can protect his child from the “surprise” when they do.

With significant numbers of children with ADHD, autism, Fragile X Syndrome in classrooms, and that is where they will be placed based upon the legal preference for inclusion, schools and police need to be prepared to deal with them properly.  But ultimately, it is always the parents who must make sure that their children are safe.

Law School Problem Solving 301: The Law School

Previously, I’ve written about the  professors and the students.  Now it’s time for the law schools.

As we all know, lawprofs have blawgs and love to write about what they do.  This has proven quite informative for me, as my understanding of what lawprofs believe their job to be differs from theirs.  In a new post at Volokh Conspiracy, this issue was made plain in a post by Jim Chen, Dean of the University of Louisville Law School about whether a Supreme Court clerkship is overvalued as a credential for a law school professor.

Before one can divine an answer, one must first decide what the job of a law school professor is.  This proved harder than you would think.  The commentary showed two very different points of view.  According to the professors (and some lawyers), the primary function of a law school professor is to be a scholar.  She should think scholarly thoughts and write scholarly works. 

According to law students (and some lawyers), the primary function of a law school professor should be to train students to become lawyers.  For many commenters, this was a ludicrous proposition.  To them, teaching law students was as de classe as it gets.  Law school was a worthless joke, and the very notion of teaching was laughable.  Law was something that students (and lawyers) either “get” or don’t, and teaching it was irrelevant.  Worse yet, those who don’t “get it” were unworthy of further thought. Poof, they disappeared.

There was also a large measure of tier-ism involved in this discussion.  Top tier law schools (you know, where the smart kids go) didn’t need teaching.  These were the creme de la creme, and they naturally “get it”.  The bottom 80% of law schools produced pedestrian lawyers, who were taught by pedestrian wannabe professors.  These students needed to be taught (since they obviously were too stupid to get it on their own), but simultaneously would never excel regardless of instruction because they were just too dumb.  Here, teaching students was fine because neither the students nor their professors would ever be significant enough to enter the ranks of the elite.

The line was clearly drawn.  Harvard Law School is a place where former Supreme Court Clerks belonged so that they could hide in their paneled office and think about important things.  Thomas M. Cooley Law School, well, not so much.  While the former commanded important scholars, the latter needed teaching school certificate holders. 

While not reaching the heights of scholarly discourse, my gut reaction to this is “bull”.  The purpose of law school is to train lawyers, not to give former Supreme Court law clerks (or anyone else) a place to send their days so they don’t have to work for a living.  We train lawyers (although we probably too many of them) to fulfill a function in society, to represent entities in their dealings or litigation to prevent society from tyranny or anarchy.  Law students are not ATM from whence law schools withdraw funds to pay for their professors scholarly endeavors.

Not to slight scholarship, but the notion that law professors’ primary function is legal scholarship is repugnant.  True scholarship will happen regardless of whether law schools promote it.  Ideas cannot be thwarted.  Forced scholarship, on the other hand, brings us such genius as law review articles on Due Process at the Ministry of Magic.  And you wonder why courts no longer look to law reviews for inspiration?

This pressure on law professors to produce scholarly works has two bad outcomes.  First, it means that law professors no longer care about teaching, for there is no reward to being a good teacher.  This failure is clearly reflected in law students’ complaints about law school.  Second, it has reduced law professors to fashion designers, moving hemlines up and down every year, just so they have something to say. 

I venture to guess that no law professor will invent cold fusion or a cure for the common cold.  Few will contribute anything of lasting substance to society in this year’s law review.  But you could make a monumental contribution by preparing young men and women to go out into the world with the skills, knowledge, ethics and willingness to zealously represent people.  Each of these students will touch the lives of many people, and if well trained, make their lives a little bit better.  Law School can and should be a part of this.  It is not beneath you, Harvard.  It wasn’t beneath  John Adams to defend the Brits who shot Crispus Attucks.  And you are no John Adams.

The Russian Front

A conversation with a friend of mine who happens to wear a elected official’s hat, together with a few others (he has a very large head), included one of his mantras, the Russian front.

This, of course, is a reference to the Germans losing World War II because they tried to fight a war on two fronts and were spread too thin.  His use of this reference is to explain why, when confronted with all the things that can and do go wrong in the course of trying to run a government, he picks his battles.  Usually, his references comes up after he’s told me about some new fiasco and I chide him on why he, Mr. Elected Official, doesn’t do something about it.  This is when he usually regrets having brought up the subject.

It must be nice to be able to pick your battles in this way.  Criminal defense lawyers rarely have this luxury.  Every defendant has a battle to fight, and expects us to fight it.  For private criminal defense lawyers, this may mean 10 or 20 battles at a time.  For a public defender, this could mean 150 battles or more at any given moment.  Every client believes that we are out there, fighting his battle.  And that’s exactly what we are obliged to do.  We can’t pick a few of our clients and fight their battles only, leaving the rest to dangle in the wind because we just don’t feel like fighting anymore.

This is not to say that we can or should fight every single point or issue, which is a foolish notion from a strategic point of view regardless of the drain on our time and resources.  I’ve written about this before, and it’s worth a second look.  But when there is a real fight to be made for a client, we have no right to back away. 

Fighting gets tiresome.  It’s draining to find yourself constantly in the midst of battle.  There’s a level of focus and intensity that has to be maintained to be successful in the fight, and even the best of us can find ourselves working at less than full speed.  But what do we say to the client whose fight is lost because we didn’t give it our all?  We’re sorry, but we gave some other guy a great fight?  This doesn’t begin to cut it.  Each client gets our all, and there’s just no other way to do this job.

My friend, Mr. Elected Official, has about a zillion potential fights available to him at any given moment.  He can’t fight them all, at least not effectively, by definition.  Even if he was able to maintain the level of focus and intensity needed to be constantly in a battle, he would find himself ineffective because he was constantly fighting.  He would be perceived by other elected officials as a complainer and marginalized.  They would stop paying attention to him, and he would squander his political capital.  It’s a very different job than ours, and the dynamic works very differently. 

But the downside of this very reasonable approach is that a lot of battles that needed to be fought were ignored.  He knew things to be wrong, but chose to leave the battle to someone else.  Most of the time, no one stepped up to the plate.  I don’t know if Germany would have won World War II if they had left Russia alone and concentrated their effort on western Europe.  I do know that if you happen to be one of the people affected by something that goes awry in government, and there’s no elected official willing to stand up and help, you feel like a foot soldier in the Russian army during the Battle of Stalingrad.  Cold and alone.  No client should feel that way.

Crossing the Expert, Step By Step

Houston criminal defense lawyer Mark Bennett, at his great Blawg, Defending People, has been giving a master’s class on the cross-examination of the medical expert.

Class 1:  Dealing With the State’s Expert: One Last Question

Class 2:  Preparing to Cross-Examine the Doctor

Class 3:   The Next Step in Preparing to Cross-Examine the Doctor

I hope that Mark continues the class, as this is a critical area where too many lawyers get caught short, feeling as if they can’t do anything about expert testimony that cuts against them, other than put on their own expert to contradict the State’s.  For many, the ability to find and pay for an expert makes this option impossible, and leaves the case in the hands of the prosecution’s guy.

I want to emphasize a critical point that Mark makes in his third lecture.  While we may never gain the level of expertise that the witness possesses, we can, in a very short time, gain substantial expertise in the extremely narrow area about which she will give testimony.  This true of physicians, as well as any other legitimate expert.  The information is out there, and lawyers should neither be too afraid nor too lazy to learn it.  It is amazing what we can learn in a brief period of time about a very specific area of expertise.

Experts testify within a comfort zone.  They don’t fear cross because they believe two things: First, that they do not testify for one side or the other, but rather about the subject of their expertise.  Second, that they know enough about their area of expertise that they can handle us.

Neither of these beliefs is necessary true.  The experts frequently offer testimony as conclusive when they know quite well that it’s equivocal.  If it could support either position, based on how the expert spins the answer, or what details are conveniently left out, then the expert indeed is working for a living, and serving his employer.

Second, the expert assumes that we will use a rhetorical attack at best, never substantive.  That’s what Mark is trying to tell us.  If we try to talk circles around the expert because we are just brilliant, shoot from the hip lawyers, we are likely to get beaten, and beaten badly.  Not only will we fail to effectively deal with the expert, but we will shoot down our own credibility.  Experts do not anticipate that we will know the literature, the language, the testing capabilities and problems, all the details that make up an area of expertise. 

When experts hide behind jargon, we can unmask them.  When experts assert that tests prove something conclusively, we can show that false-positive failure rates, or how the field previously claimed conclusive proof only to later change (and often change again) their view of testing efficacy. 

And even if the expert’s belief that he is neutral and correct is accurate, there is the one thing left for us to do that is the best of all:  Turn the prosecution’s expert into our expert.  They have located, paid and prepped him.  They’ve endorse his qualifications.  If we, through our research, can find a way to have him say something that favors the defense (i.e., the wound is consistent with a number of weapons other than the .22 caliber handgun claimed by the prosecution), this can be a huge score for the defense. 

This is a great series and one that I recommend to everyone.  I thank Mark for the effort of putting it together and hope he continues the series.