Author Archives: SHG

The “Jack Bauer” Scenario

A reader  commented yesterday about the President’s need to do whatever he had to do to protect Americans.  Ironically, he invoked television as the medium for transmitting the message that we should live in a kinder, gentler world, where we can abide the Constitution.

People get killed and murdered by terrorists in real life every day, if you only experience that on television, trust me, it is not the same. Thankfully, we don’t, too often, experience that fear of death and torture here. But what if there had been not only 9/11, but also, 9/12, and 9/13 and 9/14…..until even 10/19/07??? Do you think you would feel the same way? I doubt it.

The irony, of course, stems from the fact that his view mirrors the television show “24”, as the reader argues that the President must have the power to do anything and everything necessary to protect us from terrorists.


Would you want him to say at a public hearing that no matter what the circumstances are, e.g. there is a nuclear bomb in NYC that will go off if 2 hours and the guy being questioned you are 99.9% knows where the bomb is, we would be unwilling to do what is necessary to get the information to stop the nuke??


Didn’t Jack have a chainsaw at the guy’s head during this scene?  I love the show too.  I never miss an episode if I can help it, though I always wonder how Jack can manage to not go to the bathroom for so long.  Now that’s something.

But why does it make so much more sense when Jack Bauer does it on a television show then it does in real life?  Why do people like me keep harping on the Constitution, and limited Presidential power?  Why don’t I “get it”?

In the TV show “24”, we see into the hearts and minds of the characters.  We watch as they agonize over the tough decisions, but ultimately make the right choice necessary to protect society.  We trust them, because we know that we can.  Because it’s a TV show.  Because a writer somewhere decided to let us see into the minds of characters, so we know who to love and hate, trust and distrust. 

This is not a TV show.  We cannot see into the hearts and minds of the people who some think should be “leaders” and others think should be “servants”.  We do not trust them.  The reason we do not trust them is that they have not proven themselves trustworthy.

In the example, the reader speaks of “doing what is necessary” when the President is 99.9% sure that some guy knows where the bomb is.  We were 99.9% sure that we knew that Iraq had weapons of mass destruction.  The government is 99.9% sure of everything.  And yet it gets things wrong.  All the time. 

Whether the President is trustworthy or not is a personal matter, beyond our knowledge or control.  I don’t know him personally.  I bet the reader doesn’t either.   But even with people I do know personally, and I do trust, I would not give that degree of power.  I may trust them, but they aren’t always right.  Nor am I always right.  Sure, I try, and I mean well, but sometimes I’m wrong. 

People in power, even a little bit of power, tend to confuse authority with being right.  The burden of responsibility plays a peculiar game with their mind, forcing them not only to make decisions, but to believe that their decisions are better than anyone else’s.  Some make snap decisions and other belabor the decisions, but when a decision is ultimately made, it becomes the immutably right decision.  We see this on every level of government.  And we see that when the decision is wrong, the consequences can be disastrous.

In the “Jack Bauer” world, we know the right call from the wrong one.  TV can do that for us.  And so, we root for the right call, even though it involves doing things that are otherwise wrong.  The “end justifies the means” because we know what the end will be.  In the real world, things never work out quite that well. 

For 218 years, the Constitution has worked pretty well for us.  When presidents have ignored the Constitution, such as creating Japanese internment camps or the Vietnam War, we’ve ended up regretting the choice.  My bet is on the Constitution.  While the “Jack Bauer” scenario may one day come to pass, I would prefer to watch it on TV then be the wrongly accused fellow in the chair watching Jack come at me with a chainsaw.

Steal This Post

Abbie Hoffman wrote a book in 1971 called “Steal This Book.”  It embodied the yippie view of life, reject authority of all types.  This was anarchy, and 1971 was a good year for anarchy.

But Abbie could never have dreamed back then of the potential for anarchy that the internet would someday present.  In the marketplace of ideas, there’s no way to stop a thief.  But that hasn’t stopped some from trying.

I (and just about everyone else) has had some great fun ridiculing the pompous cyberbully  Dozier.  Now there’s word of a website, Inventer Link, that claims that you can’t look at its source code or you will have to pluck your eyes out or some such nonsense.  The site is inconsequential, the point is not.  Claim of ownership and an effort to find some way to protect oneself from having one’s guts spilled all over the internet has driven these ninnies to extremes.  Instead of protecting themselves, they have proven themselves to be empty windbags.  They are impotent to stop anyone, and the harder they try, the clearer that becomes.

Worse yet, the louder one tries to stop others on the web from stealing their “book”, the more widespread the theft becomes.  Dozier is now ridiculed in 37 different languages.  It is possible that the name will become synonymous with internet impotency and legal failure.  Ironic, eh?

The flip side, however, presents far greater virtue and a much smoother path.  I received a very kind email from a reader who asked if I would permit him to use one of my posts in his law practice.  He thought enough of what I had written that he wanted to hand it out to clients as a tool in his practice.  I was deeply flattered by his request, and even more appreciative of the fact that he sought permission to do so.

Simple Justice is copyrighted.  Even the name is a registered trademark.  But I have no plans to hunt you down if you print something that I’ve written out and use it.  I write it and click on a button and it suddenly appears here, for all to see.  If I didn’t want you to see it, I wouldn’t do that.  It adds (in my wildest dreams) to the body of ideas in the world and some of these ideas will be worthy of repetition.  That’s why we have ideas.  If no one wants to use them, then they really aren’t worth very much.

It was my pleasure to give permission to this lawyer to use my post.  It is my hope that what I write here occasionally helps someone and contributes to the discourse.  I try to write clearly so that I can communicate my thoughts to a wide array of people.  Some tell me that I am blunt.  Guilty.  But at least I try to have something to say, and if you want to steal one of my posts, then apparently I must.

There are many things from 1971 that have not panned out quite the way we expected.  Instead of a population that questions authority, there is a huge segment of our society that trusts authority so deeply and blindly that they are willing, no happy, to hand over the power to torture them, eavesdrop on them, watch them in their bedroom and even hand over their life.  If you asked me back then, I never would have believe this possible.  Times change.

But at least they haven’t shut down the marketplace of ideas, where people can speak their minds and disagree with that huge segment of society that wants to make sure we never “Steal this Book.”

Mr. Mukasey Finds His Groove

I’ve been pretty supportive of Judge Michael Mukasey’s nomination for Attorney General.  I  posted about him before it was announced, while he was being  dissected by the media, and as he was  first subjected to Senate interrogation.  While these haven’t been my most popular posts, I felt they were important enough, and that I had enough of a personal perspective about Judge Mukasey, to merit my continued attention.

I don’t feel as good about it today.  According to the New York Times, Judge Mukasey’s second day of questioning by the Senate Judiciary Committee went very differently than his first.  The bright line of day 1 blurred into a semantic position on day 2.  Suddenly, while torture was still wrong, what constituted torture became all fuzzy and equivocal.

Pushed by Senator Patrick Leahy, the powers of the President, subject to the law on day 1, became subject to interpretation of the law on day 2.   No longer did Judge Mukasey offer clear, precise answers to discrete questions. 

The nominee was asked whether something happened between day 1 and day 2.


“In your answers yesterday, there was a very bright line on questions of torture and the ability of an executive, or inability of an executive, to ignore the law,” Mr. Leahy said. “That seems nowhere near as bright a line today, and maybe I just don’t understand.”


“I don’t know whether you received some criticism from anybody in the administration last night after your testimony,” he said, “but I sensed a difference, and a number of people here, Republican and Democratic alike, have sensed a difference.”



The Judge Mukasey I knew would never had allowed me to waffle like this under his questioning.  He would have nailed me to the wall, and properly so.  Hiding behind semantic distinctions is exactly the sort of garbage positions that his predecessor did, although Alberto also had a remarkably poor memory when push came to shove. 

But Judge Mukasey knows nothing about what is delightfully called “waterboarding,” a water torture method that is given a name to make it sound like an Olympic sport.  Are we to believe that he was not prepped on the various interrogation techniques that would, without a shadow of a doubt, be the subject of his questioning?  Judge Mukasey responded to questioning by stating:

“I don’t know what is involved in the technique,” Mr. Mukasey replied. “If waterboarding is torture, torture is not constitutional.”


See it for yourself.




This answer is not credible.  It’s not even remotely credible.  This is very disappointing, since the Senate Judiciary Committee will approve the nomination and send it to the full Senate for fast-track approval.  And Judge Mukasey said something that no one can reasonably believe to be true.  Today is a new day.  I hope the Mukasey that appears for questioning will be the one I think was nominated for AG, and not the one who showed up yesterday.

A little more of day 2 that might prove disconcerting.

What to Do When You’re a Jew

Every once in a while, you come face to face with the disconcerting news that people who don’t know you, are otherwise generally nice enough and who you view as regular people, hold a covert view of you that you are a bad and dishonest person.  Anne Reed’s  Deliberations post did that for me today.

I am Jewish.  Not much of a Jew by religious standards, but most assuredly a Jew nonetheless.  God and I have an understanding, and we’re cool with it.  But to the outside world, or as Jews of my generation had beaten into us during our youth, when Hitler comes, you will be at the head of the line.  I got the message.

Anne brings us statistics that shock me.  I admit that I did not realize how others felt below the surface.  I work regularly with black and Hispanic lawyers and clients, and don’t think much different of them than I think of anyone else.  They aren’t colors, but people.  Some are smarter than others.  Some are nicer than others.  They are whoever they are.  Now I wonder:  What am I to them?

Here’s the details:

[T]he survey asked . . . whether respondents agreed with a list of “index” questions. Here is the percent of respondents who said each of the following statements is “probably true”:

  • 50% say Jews stick together more than other Americans.
  • 32% say Jews always like to be at the head of things.
  • 33% say Jews are more loyal to Israel than America.
  • 15% say Jews have too much power in the U.S. today.
  • 17% say Jews have too much control and influence on Wall Street.
  • 19% say Jews have too much power in the business world.
  • 15% say Jews have a lot of irritating faults.
  • 15% say Jews are more willing than others to use shady practices to get what they want.
  • 15% say Jewish business people are so shrewd that others don’t have a fair chance at competition.
  • 12% say Jews don’t care what happens to anyone but their own kind.
  • 12% say Jews are not just as honest as other businesspeople.

Fourteen percent of respondents said that six or more of these statements were probably true, making them “unquestionably anti-Semitic” as the ADL defines that term. That number is down from 17% in 2002.

They [the ADL] did find that negative Jewish stereotypes were highest among people 65 and older (24%, twice the rate of any younger group), African-Americans (36%), and Hispanics, especially those born outside the U.S. (29% and 35% respectively).



This study relates to jurors perception of Jewish lawyers.  Anne’s point was to show that a jury attributed better qualities to a lawyer who was obviously of Irish descent than a lawyer who was obviously Jewish.  This is a problem.

In New York City, there are a lot of Jewish lawyers.  There are also a lot of black and Hispanic jurors.  Are we doing our clients a disservice by representing them?  Is my religion yet another hurdle that they have to get over to receive justice at the hands of a jury? 

In the past weeks, we’ve  posted about that Icon of Conservative Love, Ann Coulter, and her desire to “perfect” me, as well as  my reaction to the over-intellectualization of Coulter’s mumbling.  (Note:  Anne saw this as my view that she wasn’t worth my attention.  I apologize for being so unclear.  My point was that Ann Coulter was unworthy of such overblown analysis by others who sought a deeper understanding of Coulter’s purpose.  There was nothing deep, in my view, about it, and she is unworthy of in-depth analysis).

Then, just yesterday, a local fixture, Nobel prize winner James Watson,  denigrated an entire continent because of their skin color.  If you’ve read anything by Dr. Watson, you will know that he’s a science maniac (I was going to use the word “nazi”, but changed my mind).  Jim Watson believes that ethics, political correctness, and all the penumbras that go along, interfere with proper analytical consideration and are destructive to scientific advancement.  He believes in science untainted by sentimentalism.  This is, in my view, both intellectually honest from a scientific-purist perspective, but dangerous.  Very dangerous.

Applying Dr. Watson’s purist approach to Anne’s statistical revelation, Jewish lawyers are in a bad place.  If we are to put our clients’ interests ahead of our own, as we are sworn to do, then our duty seems clear.  We must not appear before juries on behalf of a client.  By simple virtue of our appearance, in our full Jewishness, we add to the burden our clients face, making their circumstances worse and adding to the likelihood of their conviction because of juror bias. 

On the other hand, I’ve had clients of color come to my officer and tell me that they are there because they want a “Jew lawyer.”  It always makes me chuckle, as if my being Jewish gave them a leg up.  When I would ask them why, just for sport, they would tell me it was because Jews were smart, and they wanted a smart lawyer.  I admit, I didn’t inform them otherwise. 

When I try a case, I never consider what role, if any, my religion plays.  Now I must.  But it’s unclear to me what to do about it, since I don’t know if there is anything I can do about it.

Hanging Around in Times Square

Busted.  Only in New York could hanging around in Times Square end up being a crime.  Thanks to this New York Times article, a case that would otherwise make no one’s radar is now a cause.  How it made it all the way to the Court of Appeals without anyone noticing is anyone’s guess, but it’s out there now.

It seems that a Brooklyn guy was chatting up some friends in Times Square at around 2:00 am.  While this may be late in some latitudes, this is prime time in Manhattan, “the city that never sleeps.”  Matthew Jones was told by  one of New York’s Finest, Momen Attia, to move it along.  I know, it’s old school, but cops still like telling people to move it along.  It’s just their little way of reminding the natives that they are in control.

But Matt did the unthinkable.  He ignored the direction.  This miscreant refused a direct order from a cop.  If this sort of disobedience was allowed, New York City would fall into immediate anarchy.  We can’t have that.  So the police officer asserted his authority, and Matt decided to high-tail it back to Brooklyn.  Kids from Brooklyn learn early that wearing Keds helps you to jump higher and run faster.  He was testing the common wisdom.

Officer Attia nabbed the perp, but his “flailing” arms made it difficult to cuff him.  Ta da!  Resisting arrest.  Now it was getting serious.  If Matt could write a song, I smell another Alice’s Restaurant in our future.

Brooklyn’s favorite son ends up at 100 Centre Street, Manhattan’s tawdry version of the Palais de Justice, for arraignment.  His attorney argues that standing in Times Square talking to someone is not a crime.  The prosecutrix argues that he was blocking pedestrians, forcing them to walk all the way around him, and that the proof of the pudding was that Matthew caught the attention of Officer Attia.  If he wasn’t baaaad, why would the officer have noticed?  It was a compelling argument, and the arraignment judge refused to dismiss.

Matt, ever the pragmatic Brooklynite, copped a plea to time served and walk out.  But there was this nagging problem (problems tend to do that after you’ve gotten your “time served” sentence), and so he appealed.  The Appellate Term  ruled against him, holding that standing in Times Square was facially sufficient for a charge of disorderly conduct.  In a back slap, the court dismissed his detailed arguments by stating  they were “matters which were best left for the trial that defendant eschewed through his guilty plea.”  But one judge dissented.

So now the case of the Standing Gabber of Times Square has gone to Albany, where the State’s highest court heard argument yesterday.  Even the court’s newest judge from upstate, Eugene F. Pigott, Jr., pondered the obvious:

“All I could think of was a bunch of lawyers from the New York City Bar Association standing around trying to figure out where to have lunch,” Judge Pigott said. (The association has offices a block and a half from Times Square.)


Talk about a crime waiting to happen.  Is it just me, or does anyone else wonder why it takes three levels of courts and more than three (3) years for so many brilliant minds to finally see the obvious?  There has got to be a better use of all these resources than this.

As for Police Officer Momen Attia, rumor has it that he is being considered as the daytime host for the game show, “Deal or No Deal.”  Some new twists are being considered for the show.

Do Not Call

No, this is not about the “do not call” list, which is about to  expire for those of us who signed up in the first round and has since been gamed by callers who hide behind purported charities, or surveys or just won’t tell you who they are.  This is a bit closer to home.

A call came in to my office yesterday from a woman in Maryland.  She seemed quite polite at first.  She didn’t want to tell me who she was, but made it clear that she was simply calling because she had a question.  When the phone rang as I was walking past, I grabbed it and spoke with her. 

After a few preliminary questions that got nowhere, such as who are you and what are you calling about, she made her purpose clear.  She wanted legal advice.  She was asserting her right to call me up, ask a question and get an answer.  She told me she found me on the internet, and therefore wanted an answer to her question.  Forget the non-sequitor, she wanted an answer.

While I explained that I am an attorney, and that people retained me to be their attorney, at which point they get to ask questions and I answer them, she acted as if I was a moron.  Did I not understand that she just had a question and wanted an answer?  Why was I wasting her time with this “I’m a lawyer” mumbo-jumbo? 

Thereupon, I told her that lawyers get paid to answer legal questions.  My caller then informed me that “I was an asshole,” and hung up the telephone. 

This happens pretty regularly.  There is a sense of entitlement to a lawyers’ time to “just answer a question.”

Abraham Lincoln said, “A lawyer’s time and advice are his stock in trade.”  While a bit simplistic, the point is accurate.  People come to us with questions, and we try to answer them. It’s one of the things that lawyers do for a living.  We are not the free legal helpline, available for the price of a phone call.  At least this caller didn’t call collect.  That’s happened too.

Because of Simple Justice, I receive a lot of calls from people who want to ask me a question.  Not because they want to retain my services as an attorney to represent them, as they call from states whose license plates appear in New York on only the rarest of occasions.  Just a question.  Well, to be blunt, answering a question is representation.  If your purpose in calling is to “just ask a question,” don’t.  It’s not going to happen.  I’m not being rude, or uppity.  It is what I do for a living.  And it’s not just you.  I could spend a lot of time on the phone talking to people who just want to ask a question.  Except then I would have no time to represent my clients, and my family would go hungry. 

As noted in the box on the sidebar, Simple Justice is not giving legal advice.  This is commentary.  But please note that I’ve added a new box.  It says:



  • Before You Call For Advice


    I’m sorry that it’s come to this, but the volume of calls I receive makes this necessary. Before anyone calls me for legal advice, please understand that I am a lawyer, and as such, I represent clients for a fee. I am not a free nationwide legal helpline. If that disappoints you, I apologize, but I do not give out free legal advice.

  • If this offends you, as it likely will those people who believe that they have the right to call me and have their questions answered upon demand, I apologize.  But it has gone too far, and I really don’t appreciate being cursed at because I won’t do as you demand.  Perhaps other lawyers with blawgs will be happy to field your questions, but if this is your purpose in contacting me, please do not call.

    The Up and Down of Lawyering Up

    “Lawyering Up” is the phrase used by cops when someone they want to talk to gets a lawyer.  It’s a fascinating thing to watch as the police try to do everything in their power to keep a suspect from lawyering up before they have a chance to get what they want.  But the flip side is equally fascinating, because the mere act of lawyering up is absolute proof that the suspect is guilty.  The theory is, if a suspect lawyers up, then he must be guilty because innocent people don’t need lawyers.

    Ironically, there’s no cop who will talk to anyone when he or she is under suspicion for anything without a lawyer.  Of course, this means their guilty as sin of whatever it is they’re accused of doing, but they know the game better the civilians.  They know that it’s better to lawyer up and make everyone think they’re guilty than to talk without a lawyer and give the other cops the ability to prove it.

    The “right to counsel” doesn’t attach until a formal accusation has been filed against a defendant.  That means that the state isn’t going to give you that free lawyer they promised until you show up in court for arraignment, being asked whether you are guilty or not guilty, on the charge.  Under the Miranda warnings, you are told that you are entitled to a lawyer and one will be provided to you if you can’t afford one.  But they never say when that’s going to happen.  The answer is simple, when you get to court, which in New York City means manana.  It takes about 24 hours between arrest and arraignment.  This will not be the most pleasant 24 hours of your life.

    But the individual has the right to have his or her own lawyer step into the middle at any moment.  All you need is to have a lawyer, and assert affirmatively that you don’t want to speak with the cops until your lawyer is present.  Maybe they will let you make a telephone call, whether to your spouse or your lawyer.  Maybe not.  Maybe your lawyer will be there to get the call (which is a good reason to call someone you know to be home when you get the chance), and maybe your lawyer will go to the police precinct and smile at the cops who are trying to “get” you.  Some people have that sort of relationship with their lawyer.  Most don’t.

    If nothing else, however, the lawyer can call up the precinct and inform the officer that you are represented and that the officer is not to question you.  That’s all it really takes.  Once the cops are notified that the defendant is represented by counsel, interrogation must stop.  There is always the question of what might have been said before counsel intervened, but that has to get hashed out at a suppression hearing later in the case.

    The police hate it when someone lawyers up.  It makes their job much harder, since their job is to draw statements out of you when you are at your most vulnerable.  No matter what comes out of your mouth, it has the grave potential to hang you.  Even if you believe that what you are saying is exculpatory (meaning, shows you’re not guilty), chances are very strong that your statements will fail miserably to convince the cops to let you go and, most importantly, are likely to be your undoing.  People in custody tend to have a poor idea of what’s going to get you off, and they commit themselves to a ridiculous defense or destroy their ability to testify later.  It’s a catch-22, and there’s no way to take it back later.

    The police will apply some major psychological pressure to get you to talk.  They are trained to do so.  They have plenty of practice.  They know exactly what to say to get you to spill your guts.  First rule to know:  Police are allowed to lie to you to get you to talk.  This is what courts like to describe as an “effective law enforcement tool.”  Seems wrong?  Too bad.  That’s the law.

    One of the primary things the cops will say to you is, “if you’re not guilty, then what do you have to hide?”  Makes perfect sense, doesn’t it?  This is also a great move when they want to search your car too, and obtain consent to search when they have no basis to even ask for it. 

    Another is when you know they’ve got you (so the “not guilty” line isn’t going to fly), they say, “we’ve got you good, so the only way you can help yourself is to work with me.  I can help you.”  This evokes some sort of Stockholm syndrome reaction, where the defendant aligns himself with his new best friend, the cop, as if this cop truly cares about his wellbeing.

    One of my all-time favorites is the copy machine scam.  This is where the cops but a piece of paper in a copy machine and tell the defendant it’s a polygraph, a lie detector.  They tell the defendant that if he passes the polygraph, they will let him go.  They then ask questions, and after each one, they press the button on the copy machine.  Out comes the “polygraph’s” finding:  “Lying”.  Guess what was written on the piece of paper in the copy machine?  It’s very imaginative, and these cops should have gotten a medal for coming up with this one.

    As has been pointed out here and elsewhere numerous times, there is a correct way to invoke your right to counsel so that they police cannot (lawfully) question you.  State clearly and affirmatively that you do not want to answer questions and you want to speak with your attorney.  Don’t ask if you need a lawyer.  Don’t ask if you should have a lawyer.  Say “I want to speak with my attorney.”  And then clam up.  It’s simple, but suspects get it wrong constantly. 

    So what should you do when the police tell you, in that sweet and somewhat demure voice, that they just want to ask you a few questions?  There is no question whatsoever.  Lawyer up. 

    Polls Are Open

    Nicole Black has opened the polls for Best New York Blawger at Sui Generis.  Some of the blogs are already pumping and dumping, and I just don’t want to be embarassed.

    So if you have a moment and feel like it, go and vote. Thanks

    Post Mortem on the Lynne Stewart / Chicken Little Tempest

    It’s over and turned out to be, exactly as Hofstra Law School Professor  Monroe H. Freedman and Dean  Nora V. Demleitner predicted, a cautionary tale.  But  Chicken Little must cry that the  sky is falling or there will be no reason for chicken little to exist.

    For those readers who feel that knowing the facts is better than blindly hurling hyperbole or epithets to arouse base anger from the ignorant. you can always just read  this post.  But that’s only if you want facts.  If you would rather not allow facts to cloud your political agenda, you can go elsewhere.

    Mr. Mukasey Goes to Washington

    Update:  See what Judge Mukasey has to say about the US torturing prisoners. (H/T to Volokh)



    Retired United States District Court Judge Michael Mukasey goes before the Senate today.  Man, would I like to be him.  Freed from the muzzle of judicial constraint and looking forward to a terminal position, the Department of Justice is his oyster. 

    Rarely does an opportunity present itself so clearly to do the right thing.  He will be immune from the ugly politics, as he has no future beyond the Bush term in the position and can neither be pressured nor fired without bringing massive political damage to the President and the Republican Party, Judge Mukasey has the chance to clean out the decades of misguided approach to the criminalization of America that has characterized Justice.  Finally, someone is positioned to return the DOJ to a place of integrity. 

    If the DOJ is perceived to be the honest arm of the executive branch, limiting its war on terrorists, criminals, CEOs, everyone and demonstrating a deep respect for the Constitution, the contribution this will make toward restoring a nation’s respect for itself.  Michael Mukasey can be the greatest Attorney General that America has ever seen.

    Get rid of all the secret memos that redefine torture to whatever goes beyond what pain we already inflict.  Put an end to the lying and violence of government agents that we all pretend doesn’t happen but know it does.  Draw a line in the sand that the government will remain on the side of right, no matter how convenient and facile it is to get the job done if we just stick our heads in that sand and pretend we just don’t notice.

    Is Michael Mukasey the right man for this job.  I believe he can be.  I hope he is.  But ultimately, it will prove a matter of will.  Every force in Washington will push against him.  To clean up the mess, he will endure the wrath of every politician from both sides of the aisle who want to make their bones on the crime-toughness and their inventing some new way to protect their constituents from some as-yet unrecognized enemy.  Fear is the politicians friend.  Fear is used to do the unthinkable.  Michael Mukasey will have to stare this manufactured fear in the eye and say, NO.

    Ironically, my dear friends at Overlawyered posted A Nation of Lawbreakers.  It relates a Slate story about a game played by prosecutors:

    At the federal prosecutor’s office in the Southern District of New York, the staff, over beer and pretzels, used to play a darkly humorous game. Junior and senior prosecutors would sit around, and someone would name a random celebrity—say, Mother Theresa or John Lennon.

    It would then be up to the junior prosecutors to figure out a plausible crime for which to indict him or her.


    This is the America that results from decades of inventing new crimes.  For all of you who sit there, content in the knowledge that you could never be on the bad end of an indictment, are you less of a lawbreaker than Mother Theresa?  Michael Mukasey can put an end to this.  I hope he will.