Author Archives: SHG

Thanks to a Wealthy Plaintiff From Disabled Students

The story appeared on the front page of the  New York Times because of the tax consequences for New Yorkers.  But there would be no story had it not been for Tom Freston, the former CEO of Viacom.

Tom Freston has a learning-disabled son.  He placed his son in a private school because the public school offered no program for him.  Every child, according to the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), is entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE).  This isn’t easy to get with a non-disabled child.  It’s a lot harder for those children who are given the option of being the class pet in an inclusion setting or left to knit pot-holders in a self-contained class.  One size fits all doesn’t work well for learning-disabled kids.

So Tom Freston sought reimbursement for the Stephen Gaynor School from the City of New York and was refused, because he hadn’t given the public school a chance to teach his child.  Therefore, the argument went, he could not say that the school was unable to provide a FAPE.  After all, without giving the school a chance, it was unfair to simply discount them, right?

But this argument, while better applied to a 30 day free trial of a toaster, doesn’t work well with living, breathing children.  First, while trying the public school on for size, harm happens.  Learning disabled children are subjected to the stigmatization and, unfortunately far too often, abuse that comes with being different. 

Second, children continue to grow up during the time that they spend giving the public school’s a chance.  They don’t get to go back and be 7 years old for a second time.  A year lost to a child is a big deal.  A year lost to a learning disabled child can be devastating.  These are critical developmental periods.  Once lost, they are gone forever and can never be recaptured, no matter what school administrators would prefer.

Third, the requisite needs of a child with a diagnosed learning disability is not nearly as mysterious as school administrators would have us believe.  Their tendency to lump children with wildly disparate needs into the same pigeonhole is a matter of necessity.  Public schools cannot provide the level of specific attention that would serve to educate each individual child with their individual learning disability.  Most administrators actually know this, but can pretend they don’t because most of the public has no idea about the educational needs of learning disabled students and can be successfully lied to at will.

So why do we owe a heartfelt thanks to Tom Freston?  Because he had the wherewithal to pursue the litigation in his son’s case, Tom F.  Having won in the Second Circuit the right to reimbursement despite not giving the public school a shot before heading to Gaynor, the Supreme Court tied 4-4 on the case, with Justice Kennedy recusing himself. 

Here’s the point.  Who other than a former CEO of Viacom could press this suit to the Supreme Court?  Most parents of LD kids struggle to provide for their basic needs.  It is not inexpensive to pay for top quality therapy (as opposed to the loosey-goosey stuff that passes for therapy at many schools).  But for people like Tom Freston, the only side with enough juice to fight its way to the top are the school districts, because they are living off the never-ending stream of tax dollars.

Rather than question why someone as wealthy as Tom Freston would expect tuition reimbursement for the education of his son, consider that he too pays his taxes and is entitled to the services that society claims to provide.  Because of his wealth, untold numbers of parents who lack the wherewithal to make the challenge will benefit from an interpretation of the IDEA that does not require a parent to watch in silence as his or her child suffers death by a thousand knives while waiting to prove that the public school cannot possibly provide a FAPE.

And if you think the cost of providing an education to LD children is expensive now, wait until you find out the cost of supporting uneducated LD adults who could have been contributing members of society but for the failure of schools to be able to teach them.  An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure, and we stand to be crushed under the weight of our educational system’s shocking neglect of learning disabled students.

So thank you, Tom Freston.  Your efforts are greatly appreciated.

Why All The Fuss About Law Porn?

While  some prefer to question the name, “Law Porn” has become a serious bone of contention for academics.  It seems mostly amusing to me until I read  Dean Chen’s post about how he expects it to become the institutional norm.  Worse yet, the reason for this happening is not because law schools think it’s really cool, but because the school that doesn’t employ Law Porn will be viewed as too poor to be worthy of significance.

Law Porn is the Rolex watch of law schools, too gaudy to be taken seriously, yet obvious enough to send the message that it can wear its importance on its wrist.

The odd thing about law porn is that no one, at least as far as I can tell, argues that it’s a good thing, or a fair representation of a law school’s worth.  To a person, Law Porn is despised.  And so, why does Dean Chen speculate that it will become the bread and butter promotional tool to garner alumni love (in hard currency) for the future?

It strikes me that this either reflects a secret pleasure within the academic community, which is quite real but so far beneath the dignity of these scholars that they could never openly admit they like it, or they think so little of the rest of us that they believe this crap necessary to suck in us alums, too vapid to realize that shiny things lack substance.

Are we that vapid?  Does it take a glossy, four-color brochure hyping inconsequential matters as if they were in serious contention for the Nobel Prize to capture our hearts, minds and wallets? 

It suggests to me that lawyers are as deeply concerned with where their law school ranks in that U.S. News & World Reports tierism thing as law students and law professors.  Self-esteem is inextricably woven into the rankings, making us better lawyers for having gone to a tier 1 school.  And since we feel that way about our school, then . . . what?  We donate more?  We care more?  We donate more?  I see I’m repeating myself, but that’s because it can only be about money.

Jim Chen points out that Law Porn is expensive.  It costs a lot to create and reproduce.  It costs a lot to send out.  It’s money that isn’t spent on other things, like law professor salaries.  It’s money that has to be recaptured from somewhere.  Can you guess where that might be? 

Like everyone else, my mail brings a wealth of shiny brochures.  I don’t distinguish the ones that are supposed to be meaningful to me from the mere common solicitations.  The motives of the sender do not enter into the decision-making process; they all go into recycling before they ever hit my desk.  So if anyone sees my name on a list of people to be sent Law Porn, you can take it off and save the dollar.  I bet this is true of a lot of lawyers.  While I appreciate the education I received from my law school (or more truthfully, from certain professors at my law school), no shiny brochure is going to change my memories or cause my chest to swell with pride. 

Does it do it for you?

Gate-Keeping Long After The Horse Has Left

A truly remarkable thing happened in Maryland.   Judge Susan Souder agreed to take a look at a long-time scientific sacred cow of law enforcement and found it wanting. 

As noted by my virtual next-door neighbor, Mark Bennett, the wheels started rolling in the aftermath of the  Brandon Mayfield disaster, resulting in an investigation by the FBI’s Office of the Inspector General.  It found its way to Judge Souder’s bench in a capital murder case, Maryland v. Bryan Rose.  In a long and deliberate opinion, Judge Souder deconstructed fingerprint identification ridge by oily ridge.

What makes this so remarkable is that law-enforcement, prosecutors and courts have relied on fingerprints for 100 years.  This “science” has become so well established in our system, and the mind of the public, that it was beyond doubt.  The notion of challenging fingerprinting at Frye hearing borders on ludicrous.  And yet, it happened.

Had Spanish law enforcement authorities not eschewed the FBI’s determination that Brandon Mayfield, lawyer, honorably discharged American war veteran, Muslim, was a terrorist bomber, the sequence of events would never have happened.  Never.  But they did, thankfully.

Judges are charged with the function of being the “gate-keeper” of reliable evidence at trial.  Most people think that the jury is left to distinguish good allegations of fact from bad, but there is a primary function that must first happen before evidence is presented to the jury.  It’s purpose is to prevent junk that smells like fact from being introduced at trial, and then letting a jury decide whether to accept it.  Trials are not well-suited for these sort of determinations, as they are tangential to the main issue and invariably exceed a jury’s ability to distinguish commonly-accepted but entirely erroneously “fact” from establishable fact.

The problem is that most judges do not take their gate-keeper function seriously.  It has happened to me, many times, and has no doubt happened to every other lawyer who actually tries cases.  We raise, argue, implore judges to open their minds to the possibility that some piece of evidence, whether scientific or otherwise, is nothing more than worthless junk that will be given undue weight by a jury because it comports with “common wisdom” or “common sense.” 

Why are judges so reluctant to even consider such a challenge?  Initially, judges are generally stingy with their time.  While they generally couldn’t care less how much of our time is wasted, they consider their time very precious and will not spend it on a hearing that they deem, in advance, futile. 

Further, they recognize that the evidence involved is usually critical to the prosecution, and a negative outcome for the prosecution means that the defendant walks.  It’s not that judges are so result-oriented that this outcome would break their hearts (though that is true with unfortunate frequency), but that they do not want to be personally responsible for this outcome.  In other words, if the jury acquits, fine.  But they aren’t going to put their butt on the line to toss the case.  Doing such a thing is bad for business when you’re a judge, and dependent on the largess of government for advancement.

So Judge Susan Souder took a huge personal risk in her Bryan Rose decision.  Her profile was raised enormously, but she had no idea whether she would be excoriated for letting a murderer go, or revered for her detailed and deliberate dissection of the ACE-V methodology of fingerprint identification.  Would she make her reputation, or kill it? 

Why would a judge take such a huge risk?  The simple answer is because that’s her job.  It a judge lacks the fortitude to make tough decisions, then she has no business wearing a robe.  But, of course, the simple answer rarely suffices.  Had it not been for the fortuitous FBI screw-up in the Brandon Mayfield case, there would have been no crack to wedge in a Frye hearing, and no government-created evidence to bolster the defense’s position. 

Had the defense retained an expert to perform the same analysis of ACE-V that appeared in the OIG report, would it have been sufficient?  Not likely.  Not likely to have been sufficient to even get a hearing, no less prevail at the hearing.  The fact that the primary analysis of fault of the ACE-V method came from the government itself was critical to getting the judge to take her gate-keeping function seriously.  It also helped that this was a capital murder case, as Judge Souder expressly noted up front that “Death is Different.” 

What does this mean for the rest of us?  The message seems quite clear.  For the mundane prosecution of a non-capital case, whether it be drugs, rape or even murder, the likelihood that the court will follow the well-trodden path remains strong.  Without extrinsic evidence that comes from a source that the court cannot easily ignore, common wisdom will trump deliberate wisdom every time.  While the Bryan Rose decision was a huge victory over junk science, the confluence of events that gave rise to it doesn’t happen too often. 

We may argue that this decision should open the eyes of judges across the nation to the idea that current scientific thought is often determined later to be nothing more than voodoo, and that they should give real consideration to the scientific methodology that is used daily to prove facts before allowing the jury to be told that guilt has been proven to a scientific certainty. 

But this would require a depth of thought, understanding and healthy skepticism that is missing in most courtrooms.  And would be highly unlikely to enhance the careers of most judges.  It’s wonderful that Judge Susan Souder took the chance for Bryan Rose.  It’s unlikely that it will happen again any time soon.

Help Wanted: LawProfs, No Experience Desired

As Louisville Law School Dean  Jim Chen warms the cockles of my heart by  suggesting there is intelligent life in law schools, along comes some  Harvard dilettante to break it in two.  This guy, Daryl Levinson (no, the other brother Daryl), has this to say in “The Record,” the independent Harvard Law School newspaper, about who gets to be a law professor:


Even practical legal experience is not a good predictor of scholarly ability, and, Levinson noted, “is pretty nearly disqualifying.” Levinson pointed out that today’s younger professors have no significant practical experience, and that if they tried to become involved in the world, “the world would probably recoil in horror.”

Yes, you read that right.  We don’t want no stinkin’ lawyers teaching kids to be lawyers.  We want scholars.  In fact, if some professor shows up at your jail cell to offer assistance, scream for the guards to take this mutt away.  Unless her name is Jennifer, in which case you can chat her up a bit.

Did I miss something in the “law porn” (don’t ask, it’s way too controversial) brochure that neglected to mention what they think they’re doing at that fancy Tier 1.729 law school?  Seriously, guys, is there anything law schools can possibly do to further disconnect from their mission? 

It has become painfully clear that law schools do not want to be law schools.  They do everything in their power to not be law schools.  How long will it take before the top law schools in the country figure out that they would do far better in their scholarly endeavors if they could just convince the students to stay home, mail in their checks and home-study their way to the bar exam, assuming the students feel compelled to take it. 

Though I write this post with some attempt at humor, I am in reality sickened by this misguided, pompous approach to “teaching” the law.  I put “teaching” in quotations because the lawprofs are not only not ashamed of their base failure, but proud of their disdain, their contempt, their open and notorious rejection, of teaching.  They are above teaching.  They are . . . scholars.

My inclination here is to indulge in yet more snide, snarky and sarcastic commentary about the lost boys (and girls) who comprise the corps de philologus, but I could not possibly present a more demeaning explanation than Daryl Levinson (no, the other brother Daryl) does himself at the bottom of the article:


Question and Answer with Prof. Levinson



Q: So how easy is it to get a job as a law professor?

A: There are two ways to read the numbers. The discouraging interpretation is that out of 1,000 applications for teaching positions last year, 150 were hired. On the other hand, out of that 1,000 you can automatically throw out about half because they didn’t go to a top 20 law school (that’s just how the academic world works), and you can throw out another twenty-five percent because they didn’t attend this presentation and have no idea what it takes to be a law professor – maybe they think they like teaching, but not scholarship, or maybe they’ve been practicing for a long time and think it would be nice to retire into a professorship. So when you look at the pool of viable, serious candidates, and the students in that pool who graduated from Harvard Law, virtually all of those applicants got academic positions of some sort.



Q: What’s hardest: getting the entry-level job, getting the next job, or getting tenure?

A: Tenure is relatively easy – presumptively everyone gets it, and those who don’t are the exception, not the rule. In the schools with the strictest requirements, about one out of every four professors don’t get tenure. More important is getting the entry-level job, than to care about where that job is. There is plenty of mobility, and some of the lowest ranked schools have faculty indistinguishable from the faculty at Harvard or Yale. Chances are once you get your first job, you’ll be able to move someplace geographically preferable, or with a higher rank.



Q: What if you have geographical limitations? What are your chances then?

A: Levinson noted that there are about 200 law schools in the country, so it shouldn’t really be a problem unless your limitation means, for example, that you can only work in Idaho. April Stockfleet, the OCS advisor on careers in legal teaching, warned students against mentioning a geographical limitation on their AALS application, however. She said schools may interpret this as being too picky.



Q: How do you get a fellowship?

A: Fellowships require a “watered down” set of the same things law schools look for: a good reference from a professor, a well-developed idea, and other indicia of whether you can pull it off, including any papers you wrote during law school and other ways you spent your time as a student.



Q: What constitutes good legal scholarship?

A: Legal scholarship is very heterogeneous. There is less doctrinal scholarship these days, although there is still a fair amount of it. Increasingly there are policy papers and interdisciplinary papers. The tools that students are formally taught in law school tend to be inadequate, since students basically just learn case analysis. You likely need to do more than that, but you can only get a sense of what “that” is by reading scholarship. Most would say your best bet is to be interdisciplinary.



Q: If you are going to be a law professor, do you have to teach any 1L classes?

A: No. Usually it’s a good idea to be able to teach a class that lots of people want to take, or that most law schools offer, in addition to one covering your obscure research interest. Generally, professors teach at least one “meat and potatoes” class, but this doesn’t have to b a first year class – it could be an upper-level class near the area of your expertise.



Q: What should students do during their summers?

A: Whatever they want. The highest value experience is probably a summer writing fellowship, which can also be paired with another job. You can also do something non-academic to see what it’s like and make sure you wouldn’t be happier doing that, at least for a while.



Q: How important are clerkships?

A: Clerkships are important less as a credential, and more for the time and space they give you. The fact that you see so many professors with clerkships is probably more a result of correlation than causation.



Q: Do law schools care what firm you worked at?

A: Not at all. In fact, it might be better to go to a terrible firm than one like Cravath, because chances are you will have more time to write at the terrible firm. You’re going to get expertise in document review, but not much else. This won’t disqualify you, but it will just be a neutral fact about you.



Q: What’s the salary range for law professors, from the lowest-ranked school to the top school?

A: There isn’t very clear data on this. However, as a general rule, law professor salaries will track, or be slightly below, law firm associate salaries in the same market, but without the huge raise you get as a partner, of course. The salaries are much closer to those of associates even up to seventh and eighth-years, than to Arts & Sciences faculty salaries.



Q: What do you most dislike about being a professor?

A: It’s a bad job for people who don’t like a lack of structure. It’s also bad for people who like to make a difference in the real world. Increasingly, this is an ivory tower profession.

If you made it this far, you too can be a Harvard Law Professor, provided you lack any competency in any area remotely resembling the practice of law.

208 and Counting

UPDATE:  Make that 209!  Another one in Dallas today, Eugene Ivory Henton, per Grits for Breakfast.
********

That’s the number, according to Barry Scheck, of people exonerated based upon DNA.  The latest is Willie “Pete” Williams, according to CNN.  After nearly 22 years in prison, Williams walked free.

The story sounds remarkably like every other one.  Three eyewitnesses testified that Williams was a rapist.  Three eyewitnesses were wrong.  Oops.

But in jail, Williams was hardly the model prisoner.  He was angry and bitter.  He fought with guards and other inmates.  By the logic of wrongful conviction, his post-conviction conduct should have mandated additional punishment, or at the very least justified the portion of the 45 year sentence he served.  After all, what right does an innocent man have to be angry and bitter about being convicted of a crime he didn’t commit?  It may not be perfect, but it’s the best system on the face of the earth, right?  Just keep repeating that.

Notably, this George release comes on the heals of Barry’s testimony before a Georgia legislative study group to require scientifically verified protocols in identification procedures, as I posted about here only 2 days ago.  Maggie, the Georgia maven, commented that police opposed the adoption of valid protocols because eyewitness IDs are never wrong, and required protocols would interfere with police investigations.  Of course, the cops wouldn’t want to be hampered by not arresting innocent people.

Hopefully, some good will come from Williams’ exoneration, and the Georgia legislature will learn just how reliable eyewitness IDs, and police opinions, really are.

Slime in Cayuga County DA Campaign

Cayuga County, New York, is a pastoral place.  Fields.  Trees.  And one blithering slimebag, happy to wallow in the scum to win an election.

Jon Budelmann is the current first assistant, having climbed to the pinnacle of associate professor of criminal justice at Cayuga Community College and worked his way up the chain to first assistant in his 13 years at the Cayuga DA’s office.  He’s even an Eagle Scout.  But he wants to be DA, and he wants to make sure his opponent, Michael Bass, a criminal defense lawyer, is punished for being evil.

How do you make sure everyone knows that your criminal defense lawyer is evil?  Check out Budelmann’s commercial.  As Budelmann says about himself, “One of Jon’s strong points is communication.”  Apparently, integrity isn’t in that very short list of strong points.

Putting a crime victim into a commercial, standing alone, is fair game.  But using the crime victim to announce that the opponent was the lawyer who represented his attacker for the purpose of suggesting that one candidate stands for crime and criminals is a disgrace.  Is it Budelmann’s position that criminal defense lawyers endorse crime?  Or does he just want to send that message in his slut-like effort to win.

Is this what Associate Professor Budelmann teaches the students of CCC?  That prosecutors are good, and defense lawyers have no place on earth?  Or is it that a defense lawyer, by doing his job, is the enemy of society? 

Budelmann is slime.  If you happen to live in Cayuga County, good luck.

Update:  The following letter was submitted on behalf of the NYSACDL to the local news papers in Cayuga County.

Jon Budelmann, who is running for  District  Attorney of Cayuga County has plunged his campaign into an ethical morass. His recent advertisement suggests that his opponent is in someway less fit to be District Attorney because he has represented people charged with crimes. Has Budelmann completely lost his senses? How can an attorney, no less a career prosecutor, be so wrapped up in his zeal to win at any cost that he loses sight of the basic values which make our country so great. Mike Bass, who is running against Budelmann behaved in the highest and most honorable tradition of American justice by serving as a defense attorney.He follows in the proud tradition of our second President, John Adams, a former criminal defense attorney, who recounted his defense of British soldiers tried in American courts as the pinnacle of his legal career.

Would-be District Attorneys should not be heard to impugn the values of the thousands of dedicated men and women who daily make our criminal justice system work by representing those charged with crimes. Criminal defense attorneys assure that those in a position of power are pressured to follow the rule of law and ethical conduct. But then Budelmann knows that. There is perhaps no higher calling than to be asked to stand beside a person at what may be the nadir of their life and provide a bulwark against overzealous prosecutors. Demanding and assuring the delivery of all of the rights that our forefathers guaranteed to each of us is what criminal defense lawyers do every day. It’s what everyone of us would want if we or a member of our family were so unfortunate as to be charged with a crime.

We take no position as to who might make a better prosecutor in Cayuga County. We do however, like everyone else in Cayuga County, hope that who ever is elected has demonstrated a deep and well earned appreciation of the value that  a zealous defense brings to the search for justice in our courts.

Daniel N. Arshack, is President of the New York State Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers.

Was Texas Judge “Killer” Keller On To Something?

Co-Op contributor Frank Pasquale put Texas Court of Criminal Appeals  Judge Sharon Keller back in the saddle again by questioning whether she had a choice given “the Supreme Court’s  5-4 decision in Bowles v. Russell ,” which “ dismiss[ed] the appeal of a convicted murderer because it had been filed two days late, even though it had met a separate deadline set by the trial judge.”

While coming a little late to the Killer Keller party, already the subject of castigation at  Grits for Breakfast and Defending People, news of Judge Keller’s slamming the courthouse doors shut at 5 finally reached the New York Times.  Thus, the question arose:  Was Judge Keller just following orders?

First, the simple answer.  No.  Federal filing has nothing whatsoever to do with the filing requirements of the Republic of Texas, a sovereign nation state.  As an aside, the Keller issue had to do with the doors closing at 5, not filing a few days late.  In Texas, there was an assigned judge sitting in chambers awaiting the papers, unaware that the presiding judge had ordered the courthouse doors shut and locked tight.

But Bowles is worth a look all on its own for a different reason.  As opined by Justice Thomas, the “taking of an appeal within the prescribed time is ‘mandatory and jurisdictional,” over Justice Souter’s dissent that this rule has been repudiated no less than three times.  Maybe Justice Thomas was away on his book and television tour didn’t get the memo?

This cavalier attitude toward killing people has got to raise some concerns.  When filing requirements trump the review of a death sentence, we have reached the epitome of callousness.  This is a system of justice run by grocery clerks, whose adoration of the rules exceeds all reason.  When life and death are taken so lightly that a few hours, or even a few days, allows people to sleep soundly knowing that they’ve done their job, we are on the cusp of losing our humanity.  Perhaps it’s already gone.

We see this elevation of rules over substance everywhere.  It’s not that rules have no place, as they allow us to function in an orderly fashion.  But there are some things that are more important than blanket rules, and are sufficiently unique that they overcome the need to rules so strict that we would rather wrongly put a person to death than allow a rule to be bent or broken.  Life doesn’t always happen in such an orderly fashion that it can accommodate the rules.  Nor, apparently, does death.

But what’s so wrong with having immutable rules, even when it relates to death?  Actual innocence.  Have we learned nothing from DNA reversals, where a decade or two later a defendant is exonerated?  Are we so willing to ignore the fact that are system is less than perfect, such that we make horrific mistakes?  And yet, the innocent person, like the guilty, gets shut out of the courthouse because of these rules.  Some people think this is the price we have to pay for our “free” society.  Until it’s someone they care about who finds themselves standing on the wrong side of the courthouse doors.

Practical Blawgosphere: What Higazy was Really All About

The  hoopla surrounding the  Higazy v. Templeton decision at the Second Circuit and Willow Grove, PA, appellate lawyer Howard Bashman focused on whether Blawger Bashman was  really a journalist when he refused the circuit clerk’s, Catherine O’Hagan Wolfe, request to pull down the decision because it inadvertently revealed secret government information.

Well, while the old-school blawgosphere argues the merits of journalistic integrity, residents of the practical blawgosphere ask a different question.  What’s the big secret?


The appeals court later issued a new opinion with information omitted that had been filed under seal. Left out were details of Higazy’s charges, in which he claimed an FBI agent told him that if he did not cooperate, he would “make sure that Egyptian security gives [his] family hell.”

Aha.  According to the ABA Journal, this is the revelation.  So everyone who actually works in the trenches, raise your hand if you’ve ever had a client tell you that a cop or agent threatened dire consequences if they didn’t “cooperate”.  Oh my, every hand in the room is up.

Come on, Circuit.  This comes as a shock?  Sure, every agent on the stand testifies that they would never do such a thing,  It would be wrong.  It would be coercive.  It would be designed to undermine the free and voluntary will of a suspect to exercise his constitutional right to remain silent in the face of a bunch of guys with guns pointed at his head, not to mention the gun that just pistol whipped him across the left cheek because . . ., well, just because.

So Mr. Higazy was told that the agents would sic Egyptian security on his family.  Well, that’s a pretty potent threat.  Egyptian security can be remarkably unpleasant.  Just ask the Blind Sheik.  This is not the sort of threat one takes as a joke, particularly since Higazy was arrested within seconds of 9/11 when everyone was whipped into a frenzy.  Had he confessed to the Lindbergh baby kidnapping, who could blame him?

To the extent there’s any humor in this at all, it’s the naiveté that this happened for the very first time to Mr. Higazy.  Suddenly, the Circuit has discovered that bad things are done to suspects.  They are shocked. Shocked!  Welcome to our world. 

The only thing we could do to add to the naive humor would be to pretend that Higazy will change anything.  Somehow, the Circuit will mange to compartmentalize the Higazy threat and pretend that it was a one shot deal, never to be replayed with such mundane, garden-variety busts as fill the courtrooms at 500 Pearl Street every day. 

While the court’s acknowledgment that it happened this one time is better than nothing, how sad that it will devolve back into the legal fiction that the sanitized testimony of government agents in wood paneled courtrooms will conceal the fact that threats, abuse (both physical and psychological) and coercion are as alive today as when the rubber hose business was booming.  A little more sophisticated perhaps, but just as effective. 

Thankfully, Howard Bashman didn’t take down the decision.  Or admit to the Lindbergh baby kidnapping.

Justice Ginsburg’s Dissenting Motives Criticized

Orin Kerr at  Volokh criticizes Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s express purpose in dissenting in Ledbetter v. Goodyear Tire & Rubber.  According to Kerr, Ginsburg “wrote a legal opinion at least in significant part to push a different branch of government to enact a law closer to her personal policy preferences.”


It seems to me that a Justice’s job in a statutory case is to say what the statute means and no more. If you dissent, then dissent. But trying to push Congress to enact a law that you like better isn’t part of the job description.

Orin tries to make his point using the goose/gander scenario; If it’s wrong for the Legislative branch to try to tell the Judicial branch what to do, then is it not equally wrong for a Supreme Court Justice to use a dissenting opinion to “influence the outcomes of future legislation?” 

The problem with this approach, as pointed out by several commenters, is that the Legislative and Judicial branches of government are not equivalents.  Justice Ginsburg explains that the purpose of her dissent was “to attract immediate public attention and to propel legislative change.” This purpose is the problem, according to Orin, since the it is not the province of the court to propel legislative change.

But while the words come from Justice Ginsburg’s speech, they are taken out of context.



The Court’s ruling, I observed for the dissenters, ignored real-world employment practices that Title VII was meant to govern: “Sue early on,” the majority counseled, when it is uncertain whether discrimination accounts for the pay disparity you are beginning to experience, and when you may not know that men are receiving more for the same work. (Of course, you will likely lose such a less-than-fully baked case.) If you sue only when the pay disparity becomes steady and large enough to enable you to mount a winnable case, you will be cut off at the court’s threshold for suing too late. That situation, I urged, could not be what Congress intended when, in Title VII, it outlawed discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, or national origin in our Nation’s workplaces.

In other words, it was Justice Ginsburg’s belief that the application of Title VII as held by the majority undermined the legislative purpose of the law.  While Justice Ginsburg disagreed with the majority’s interpretation of the 180 day filing requirement, her purpose was to make it patent to Congress that if the majority’s holding was different than Congress’ intent, it was now up to Congress to fix the law.

So what’s wrong with doing this?  There is a monumental difference between individual legislators using the media to castigate the Supreme Court, or its individual justices, by demeaning them personally for their decisions.  They are called “activists”, in a way that makes it sounds one step below “liberals”, a word used to describe a person hellbent on destroying the true American way of life.  These are direct attacks by members of one branch of government on another.

In the case of the Supreme Court, attacks are particularly troubling.  SCOTUS commands no armies.  It’s only weapon is integrity, the willingness of the American people to accept the premise that the Supreme Court is the final arbiter of constitutionality, or right and wrong.  We need not agree with its decision, only accept it. 

On the flip side, a dissenting opinion carries no force beyond its persuasiveness.  Justice Ginsburg can only point out what she believes to be wrong in the interpretation or application of a law.  She can’t make any Congressman or Senator bend to her will.  A dissenting justice is powerless, except in the arena of ideas.

From a functional perspective (and we are all about pragmatics here), if Justice Ginsburg is correct and the Ledbetter decision does not reflect Congressional intent, is she not also correct to alert Congress that it must fix the statute to perform the function Congress intended it to perform?  When enacted, words are chosen to effectuate certain purposes.  Sometimes, given the variety of applications, unintended consequences and changes in society over time, those words no longer serve their intended purpose. 

When the Supreme Court applies the usual tools of statutory construction, things don’t always work out as planned.  Unfortunately for the individual litigant in the losing test case, she gets screwed.  Yet another example of how the system is less than perfect.  But the point is not to perpetuate the unintended consequences, but fix them if they do not reflect the purpose of the law.  It seems to me that Justice Ginsburg has used her dissent to focus attention on what she believes to be an error in the application of the law that Congress may (or may not) want to correct.  It’s not like she wrote that legislators dress funny, smell bad or are “activists”.

What’s wrong with that?

Larry Craig on the Cutting Edge

Everyone should remember our favorite senatorial toe-tapper, Idaho Senator Larry Craig.  Courtesy of Skelly, it appears that the good Senator had criminal defense lawyer Billy Martin on retainer before the Minnesota public bathroom courtship dance. 

According to SpokesmanReview.com,


Idaho Sen. Larry Craig paid top criminal defense attorney Billy Martin and PR consultant Judy Smith $37,350 in early July, and has had them representing him since last February

So on June 11 (the date of the wide stance) and August 8 (the date of the inadvertent guilty plea), Craig had both lawyer and PR consultant (makes you think of bookends, doesn’t it?) on call.

Larry Craig is now my new hero.  Every Senator should be paying close attention to what happened here and learn something.  Have a criminal defense lawyer on retainer at all time.  It’s the new American way!

Let’s face it, when you’re a US Senator, you’re under the gun.  Media watching, constituents angry, opposition ready to jump on any mistake.  Of all people, Senators should know that there’s no way to walk down Main Street American without committing one crime or another.  Hey, you guys enacted the laws that criminalize everything short of breathing (and breathing, if it happens to include certain vapors).  If anyone should appreciate the need to keep a criminal defense lawyer in your pocket, it’s a Senator.

Larry Craig got it.  So should you. 

With this dire need in mind, I am prepared to offer this ONE DAY ONLY Senatorial discount.  Act today and your first month retainer is $1.  That’s right, only $1.  But that’s not all.  Call within the next 10 minutes and we’ll include at no additional charge a Representative of your choice.  They may not be Senators, but they can commit crimes too!  Operators are standing by!

Update:  Mark Bennett’s  one word comment at Arbitrary & Capricious sums it up nicely:  Dumbass.  That Bennett, he’s got a way with words.  lol.