Author Archives: SHG

The Perfect Imperfection of Juries

Ken Lammers at Crimlaw, a former defense lawyer who went over to the dark side, provides a great post about a trial where the jury got almost everything right.  Everything but the one obvious, no possible way he could lose, clear as a bell, detail that the defendant was proven to be a habitual offender.  This wasn’t supposed to be an issue.  It couldn’t possibly be an issue.  And yet the jury got it completely wrong.

You gotta love juries.  Well, actually you don’t, but you do.  We spend so much time talking about juries because they are always the wild card.  Sure, there’s the potential of getting a cop to admit on cross that he lied through his teeth, set up the defendants and planted to dope.  Yeah, that happens a lot.

But even if we do get the cop to break down in paroxysm of guilt, what if the jury isn’t paying attention?  What if they misunderstood what just happened in front of their face.  What if they just don’t care?

That great old saw about the jury system, “it may not be perfect, but it’s the best there is” is a load of crap.  It’s another one of those great platitudes for the unwashed to make them feel comfortable with a system that doesn’t work.  We (lawyers) are really good at coming up with saying that cover the warts of the system.  We’re not nearly as good at fixing the system.

No, I’m not suggesting that judges would be better.  I agree with the anti-Federalists (Republicans) that the entrenched governmental aristocracy would then be empowered to use the courts as the enforcement arm of their political policies.  Thomas Jefferson had a very healthy fear of government.  Even back then, he understood that the desire for self-perpetuation overwhelmed, or perhaps dictated, one’s view of right and wrong.  Jefferson placed his faith in the common man, with the caveat that the tyranny of the majority had to be kept in check. 

But juries are an animal all to themselves.  We try cases before them in the hope that they are hearing what we are hearing.  Of course, we have a finely attuned ear for testimonial discrepancies, which we believe matter.  Do they?  When we catch a witness, we exploit it as much as the judge will allow.  Will they think it’s such a big deal?  When witnesses resist answering a question, or give a non-responsive answer to weasel their way out of saying something that hurts their position, we realize exactly what they are doing.  Do juries?

The group dynamic of a jury happens outside our hearing.  It happens in the jury room, where the twelve of them do their very best to invent nuclear fusion.  I believe that juries try very hard to do the right thing.  I just have trouble believing that it works.  Somebody in the jury room says something in a very authoritative voice, and the dynamic is formed.  The others nod their head, and then the group goes down a road together trying to consider the case within the framed paradigm.  What if that very authoritative voice was wrong.  Just completely off the wall?  Totally missing the point, or trying to outsmart the case? 

There’s no one in that jury room listening to the jurors going off into the stratosphere, who can then steer them back on track.  There no one to explain, “No, you just made an assumption that is totally off base and the whole discussion then went awry.” 

This doesn’t happen?  Enjoy the great pleasure of a focus group, and watch how the bunch of them take off on some bizarre tangent that suddenly becomes truth in the eyes of the group, and directs the group’s attention into some dark place that no one would have anticipated they would go.  It’s worse than shocking.  It’s enough to make one wonder why we bother in the first place.

One of the great secrets of jury deliberations is that they have the right to engage in nullification.  Nullification means that, even though they are instructed by the judge that they must follow the law as he gives it to them, they actually have the right to ignore the judge completely and do whatever they want.  No one can stop them.  It’s their absolute right, even though judges instruct them otherwise.

Whether juries actually follow the judge’s instructions is another mystery.  Imagine sitting on a jury and having some guy talk to you for an hour in a foreign language.  No questions,  No translations.  Just sound emitting from a guy wearing black.  What would that mean to you?

Jury instructions are argued by lawyers all the time.  We parse the most minute details, their meanings and implications.  To what end?  They make for great appellate arguments after a conviction.  But do they matter?  Do they matter at all?  What group of non-lawyers is capable of hearing them and able to individually process every word, simultaneously analyzing it in the most minute detail?  It really is a goofy concept.

So Ken, with his slam-dunk issue, got slam-dunked by his jury.  Don’t feel too bad for Ken, because it goes the other way 97.3 % of the time (except in the Bronx).  One day I’ll write about trying cases in the Bronx, which violates everything said about trying cases anywhere else.  Ken found his situation strange enough to post about it.  I understand.

The Client Lied. Now What?

Young Shawn Matlock posts about getting burned in a federal case because his client decided not to mention a few details about his prior criminal history.  For those unfamiliar, federal sentencing falls under the “advisory” United States Sentencing Guidelines, which sets out a matrix for the sentence range.  On one side is the offense level.  On the other is the criminal history points.  It used to be hated by federal judges and defense lawyers alike for relegating judges to the role of administrative assistant at the sentence.  It has since been embraced by those who decided that “advisory” means “unless hell freezes over.”

But this isn’t meant as a diatribe about the sentencing guidelines, and so we return to Shawn’s issue.  Shawn did everything he could think of to make sure he had a complete understanding of his client’s background.  He asked the client.  He checked his criminal background (the client had a common name, making it difficult to determine if he had the right guy).  He asked his client again.  Shawn was satisfied that he had done his due diligence.

Shawn also appreciated how the federal sentencing guidelines worked:

The Guidelines are essentially a big grid which takes into account the crime charged as well as the defendant’s criminal history to arrive at a sentence. It sounds simple, and in reality, once you get the hang of how to manipulate the Guidelines, it can be. But the key to successfully doing that is information.


I don’t think Shawn means the words “manipulate”, but rather how to use the guidelines to determine the proper sentence range.  Manipulate suggests that the guidelines can be played, and while a strong understanding of the interplay of the various guidelines can enable a lawyer to fight for a more favorable application or a departure (a showing the guideline considerations do not adequately take the clients case or circumstances into account), the guidelines cannot be “played”.

Comfortable with his information, Shawn’s client takes the plea.  And when the Presentence Report appears, shock and dismay.  The client got body-slammed for 140 months extra.  That’s right, 11 years, 8 months more than he thought.  Shawn is not happy.  I bet the client isn’t too thrilled either. 

What went wrong.  Clearly, the client lied.  By understating his criminal history, the client put his lawyer in the position of being the dopiest guy in the room.  No lawyer wants to be in that position, and no client should want his lawyer in that position.  And there is no question that the client’s failure to inform his lawyer was the root cause of the problem.  But this is not the end of the story.

This apocryphal tale has a little ways to go.  That a client has lied to his lawyer is nothing new.  Even the most honest of clients doesn’t always understand his criminal history.  They aren’t sure how a misdemeanor versus a felony plays out, and they tend to judge the significance of this past by the length of the actual sentence rather than the designation of the offense by potential sentence.  When the plead to multiple charges and get a concurrent sentence, they feel it should only count as one crime.  Of course, their feelings on the subject are irrelevant.  It gets counted the way the guidelines say it gets counted, even if the client doesn’t think it should.

Another potential pitfall is one the offense level side of the grid, where the defense understanding of the guidelines calculations may well differ (and differ greatly) with the government’s.  For example, a defendant in a drug conspiracy case may believe he’s only responsible for the quantity of drugs he knows about, while the government will view him as liable for a far greater quantity based on their theory of the conspiracy.  The defendant may honestly know nothing at all about the additional drugs, but that’s the nature of conspiracy.  And it may not be apparent from the indictment how vast the government sees the conspiracy.  Without knowing this, the exposure for the defendant could change dramatically, and the defendant will have no clue why.

Much as I hate to say this, a step was missed.  It was a critical step.  A plea on behalf of his client cannot be based upon only the defendant’s view of the guidelines.  I hesitate to suggest that this applies to Shawn’s situation, as there are differences in practice in different districts, and what happens in one may not happen in another.  So this should be taken as suggestive, and not a criticism of Shawn per se.

Despite best efforts, and I have no doubt that Shawn was diligent on his side of the equation, a criminal defense lawyer must know that he cannot rely on his knowledge and understanding of the case and client alone.  We’re just half the equation.  But information from the defendant should never been considered sufficient.

There are two ways to take a plea, by agreement or an open plea.  Rarely do I advocate for a plea agreement anymore, as the sentencing guidelines have generally eliminated any benefit to doing so.  They limit what we can argue at sentence, while providing little if any “give-back” to the defendant.  Many lawyers still use them because that’s what they’re used to.  Once indoctrinated, they have a hard time breaking out of the mold.  Un;ess there is some substantial benefit to a defendant, why agree?  You can lose the right to argue for a downward departure, to appeal, to contest the PSR.  If the government wants that, it has to pay for it.

But before a plea can happen, or even before I will allow a client to commit to a plea, there is one thing that I will always do.  Always.  I insist that the government set forth its position on the application of the sentencing guidelines to this client in this case in writing for the purpose of the defendant relying on them in reaching his decision to take a plea.  How can a plea be “knowing, voluntary and intelligent” when a primary piece of information is missing (hint, hint, Shawn).

In the case of a plea agreement, the government’s full status of the sentencing ramifications of the plea must be included.  If there is a disputed application, it must be noted in the agreement as being in dispute and subject to argument at the time of sentence.  The government doesn’t like to do this, but usually will if the lawyer is insistent.  And if they won’t agree to leave an application in dispute, then the defendant must decide whether the agreement provides sufficient benefit to be locked in.  But locking in the government is the key.  How can a client decide to take a plea without a full appreciation of its consequences?

In an open plea, meaning a plea to the indictment where there is no agreement between the defense and government as to anything, and where sentencing is to be a slugfest though guilt is determined, the government will still provide its position on the application of the guidelines in writing in something called a Pimentel letter.  United States v. Pimentel, 932 F.2d 1029 (2d Cir. 1991).  While the defense may not, and need not, agree with the government’s view of how the guidelines should be applied (including the criminal history points), we need to know what the government’s position is.  Before a decision is made.

The government, like the Probation Officer, has access to information about defendants that criminal defense lawyers do not.  Our clients may lie to us, but the government doesn’t look to our clients for information.  They get it themselves.  For some odd reason, they don’t trust defendants to be honest and accurate.  But this is our avenue to information that would otherwise smack us upside the head later.  Shawn got smacked upside the head.  It clearly hurt.

Mark Bennett (ironically) posts about how some V6 lawyer who had been retained by one of his client to handle a federal case, and was clearly beyond his knowledge and skill level.  Or as Mark puts it, waaaaaaaaaaaaaay over his head.  There are lawyers who have no business taking cases for which they are not qualified.  One can blame the client for picking a bad lawyer, but again, clients’ judgment can’t be trusted.  It’s tough to do the best for your client.  But that is our obligation, even when our clients have lied to us.

The Price of Sharing

Jammie Thomas from Minnesota was a good sharer.  She shared 24 songs on a file sharing website called Kazaa.  The price?  $9,250 per song, for a grand total of $220,000.  I guess mother was wrong about being a good sharer.

The Recording Industry Association of America went after Jammie hard for violating copyright laws by uploading her songs to the website under the theory of “making available” songs for distribution and reproduction.  This theory would hold the uploader liable regardless of whether any song was in fact shared, meaning whether anyone took the uploaded song and then downloaded it. 

Jammie is appealing the ruling on this issue with a split of authority, critics arguing that it leads to grave mischief given the potential for accidental uploading and computer sharing.  Significantly, this is a strict liability statute, so intent plays no role and need not be proven.

Years ago, I represented a bootlegger in music and movies, back in the quaint old days when they were analog and duplicated on machines one at a time.  While this is a civil cause of action, the penalties are so draconian that it was overwhelming.  In fact, it was so overwhelming as to be laughable.  Try to get a $220,000 out of some of my clients!  Hah!  Talk about trying to get blood from a rock.

This was one of those peculiar situations where the industry does its own policing, having its own investigators find the culprits and bring them to justice under laws designed to allow them to do impose criminal-like punishments under civil-law circumstances.  It’s purpose was to protect the integrity of the industry, which must depend on the revenues from sale of records and movies to pay for artists to create more records and movies (not to mention gold-plated Hummers and Crystal champagne).  Hey, if they have a hit, they’re entitled to squander their earnings any way they want.  This is America, after all.

If the RIAA was limited to actual damages, it just wouldn’t pay to police the bootleggers.  But when Congress enacted this industry protection, it was a different era.  There was no such thing as digital uploads.  There was no such thing as file sharing.  The law was directed at people like my client, who was a real, honest-to-God bootlegger.  My guy was stealing copyrighted songs and movies for resale.  He was doing it for money.  He knew what he was doing, took the risk and got caught. 

Proportionality of penalty was an issue, as always, but at least my client came by his punishment honestly.  He deserved to get nailed.  He wasn’t crying about it, and nobody was crying for him.  But as noted, intent is not a part of the equation here.  The uploader need not be malevolent, nor motivated by profit.  It just needs to happen. 

And because it’s civil, it need only be proven by a preponderance of the evidence, not beyond a reasonable doubt.  This means that they don’t have to prove that even if Jammie’s roommate, kid brother or friend shared the computer, Jammie is still more likely than not to have done the uploading.  That’s all it takes.

This case presents a good example of two independent problems.  The first is the use of civil law to perform the function of criminal law.  Why do I say that?  Because the penalty, while not imprisonment, is so severe and automatic that it is inherently punitive.  It crosses the line between civil and criminal in impact, without providing the protections required of criminal laws. 

The second problem is that it was a law developed in the age of analog that is now applied in the age of digital.  When my client violated the copyright, there was no doubt that he knew what he was doing.  Does a teenager today appreciate the full potential of copyright violations by sharing a song with a friend’s MP3?  Even if they do, does society really want to turn that many teenagers into pseudo-criminals?  Maybe so.  Maybe the word has spread far enough after the Napster fiasco that every teen should be well aware that this is something they are not allowed to do. 

Even if Congress decides that teens are sufficiently evil today by dint of their malignant uploading, one still needs to question whether the penalty, $9,250 per song for Jammie, that was deliberately punitive (and goes to the RIAA, remember, under the theory that they have to pay for their private police force to investigate these crimes infringements), for my old-time bootlegger is still appropriate for Jammie.

Considering how pervasive file sharing has become, and how teenagers have used their ingenuity to avoid both paying for their songs and avoiding wholesale prosecution, my guess is that the RIAA is feeling a real need to make some high profile scares to remind kids that they too can end up like Jammie if they upload/download songs.  Frankly, it’s understandable.  But perhaps the issue needs to be reexamined by Congress to decide whether this is the best, or even the right, way of dealing with the problem. 

Somehow, I don’t think either Congress, or the RIAA, really wants to come down that hard on a generation of Ipod babies, who will someday have votes to cast and income to spend.  But I could be very wrong about this.

Squaring Blackwater and Sovereignty

As Congress investigates, we learn.  Lately, they have been investigating a company called Blackwater.  Some think it sounds like backwater; I think it sounds like Black Ops.  Freudian?  No matter.  I had a bunch of questions that I was hoping would be asked and answered, but they weren’t.  This leaves me confused.  What else is new?

First, why does the state department have a billion dollar contract with Blackwater, a private company, to protect American officials in Iraq?  Don’t we have a bunch of people in uniform over there already being paid to serve American interests?  Are private contractors needed because our Army can’t do it?  If our Army can’t do it, why don’t we hire Blackwater to fight our wars and disband the Army.  It’s very expensive to have an Army, you know.  The cost of all those medals alone is staggering.

Second, if Blackwater is a private company, why is it okay for them to shoot people?  Would it be okay if Argentina sent some private security guards to protect their officials in the United States and they went around shooting people?  Does it matter to an innocent bystander, a child perhaps, whether the bullet comes from an official gun or an unofficial gun?  I understand that things are crazy in Iraq and, under those conditions, mistakes will happen.  But will the dead child be as understanding as I am?

Third, if Iraq is a sovereign nation with a government and borders, why is Blackwater not subject to its laws?  If the Argentinian private security force shot someone on East 46th Street, outside of a certain steakhouse, would we not expect the police to investigate and, perhaps, prosecute under our law?  So why is Blackwater beyond the reach of Iraqi law? 

I have a great deal of difficulty squaring the rhetoric with the reality.  It seems to me that there is no Iraq.  Not really.  If there was, it would be a sovereign nation that would have a say in who gets to shoot their people.   Granted, our Army is all over the place, but thankfully not an occupying force.  But if it is not an occupying force, and we are not their colonial rulers, then who’s in charge over there?  If we are “helping” them, who are we helping? 

While we can support our country, right or wrong, because we are patriots, there remains a question as to whether that extends to these private security guys with guns and bullets and the apparent right to shoot at will.  If no one is stopping them, and if they are in someone else’s country but not subject to any restraint over there, then we have a fairly large conceptual gap in Iraq. 

I wish Rummy were still on board, because I know that he would be able to explain all of this to me.  Instead, this falls into that hole of “unknown unkowns” that makes no sense.  And if we are just pretending that there’s a real Iraq over there, when there is no Iraq left and we are indeed colonial rulers, can’t we at least do a better job of it?  At least then we can crush resistance and maintain a steady flow of inexpensive oil.  If we’re going to stay there “until the job is done,” let’s make it work for us no matter how cynical all our prior efforts at justifying this war become.  Otherwise, we not only look foolish and lose young Americans, but nobody is any the better for it.  Except Blackwater.

We Know Everything About You

It’s Columbus Day, a day to ponder the miracle of discovery to some, or the day to celebrate undocumented immigration to others.  Choosing the discovery theme, because otherwise this would be just another day the courts are closed for me, it presents an opportunity to write about personal privacy and what we’ve lost.

Over at Healthblawg, there’s a post about Microsoft’s new HealthVault.  This is a nice, neutral subject, and hence a good way to enter this discussion without the baggage that 9/11 terrorist fearmongers bring to the table.  After all, I’m not a terrorist.  You’re not a terrorist (you aren’t, right?).  We can all agree that we are against terrorism. 

But we have all seen a doctor at some point, even if only briefly.  And that physician wrote down stuff in a “chart”, a piece of paper where the doc records information about us.  I never looked at my “chart”, and I really don’t know what is in there.  I did watch over her shoulder one day, but it didn’t make any sense to me and, frankly, I couldn’t read her handwriting anyway.  But I’m okay with the fact that she wrote it down, because next time I see her she will remember me and why I came there before.  And I trust her to write things down accurately.  Why would she lie?

So while it’s okay that my doctor keeps my medical info on hand, I really don’t want her showing it to my next door neighbor.  He’s a nice guy, and I like him a lot, but he really doesn’t need to know it.  And when he asks me “How are you?” and I say “Fine”, I don’t want him correcting me.  My “fine” should be good enough for him.

But the truth is that I have no secrets.  Not anymore.  Maybe my neighbor doesn’t know my cholesterol level, but the government does.  Or at least it does if it want to know.  It knows all about me, and you, because we are ordinary citizens living ordinary lives the way ordinary people do. 

We see doctors.  We have charts.  We use banks.  Our children to go school.  We use cellphones.  We use computers (some more than others).  We have licenses.  All kinds of licenses.  We file tax returns.  We buy houses.  We just buy.  Clothing, cars, food, books.  We use credit cards to buy these things.  We leave a huge trail behind us as we go through life, detailing the commonplace nuts and bolts of our daily travels.

Science has become very good at taking snippets of our lives and piecing them together to draw rather broad conclusions about what we do and who we are.  It can’t stop AIDS, but it can make a computer that can listen in on your cellphone conversations for key words that will alert another computer that you are up to no good.  It can even listen to your conversation when the phone isn’t on.  Too bad that in the scheme of scientific priorities, this is higher than curing disease.

There are benefits to being able to know everything, just in case the government needs to.  They can use it to protect us.  But this applies more to us ordinary people than to people who are bent on wreaking havoc and destruction.  They are more cautious than the rest of us about the trail they leave behind.  We aren’t cautious at all.  We don’t think we have any reason to be cautious, and it isn’t worth the effort.

There was a time when we boarded a plane to fly to another city in America and did not have to prove our identity.  I think about those days whenever I enter an airport.  It was one of the perks of being an American, the freedom to move about the country at will because I was an American and it was my right.  Not so anymore.  Is it a big deal to have to show my drivers license to some security guard I don’t know?  Not really, but the loss of freedom doesn’t happen in one shot.  It’s death by a thousand knives. 

And so Microsoft, the only entity that knows more about every individual in American than the government, has developed HealthVault.  The name suggests that our medical information is safe with them.  After all, it’s in a vault.  But who has the keys to the vault?  I suppose that Microsoft will have them.  And I’m sure the government either has them, or can get them.  Insurance companies will no doubt demand them, or refuse to pay the obligatory 12 cents on the dollar. 

Every time I read a story about how somebody “goofed” and left the back door to a vault open, I chuckle.  No, it isn’t funny, but I just love irony and find it wherever I can.  When we call customer service and find out that somebody named “Stewart” in Bangalore knows all about us, I wonder just how tight the security is over there.  Do they have parties in Bangalore where they talk about my issues with pottery barn? 

Then there’s the lost laptop problem, where we are “required” to tell our deepest personal information despite its utter irrelevancy because “that’s our policy.”  But when some new-hire twinkie forgets the notebook computer at Starbucks, this top secret private information about 27 million people is now floating out there.  Some vault, right?

I don’t plan on uploading my health records into Bill Gate’s vault.  Frankly, I’m in excellent health, as anyone can see.  No one needs to know more about my health than that.  And I want to keep a few secrets for myself.  For those of you who believe that privacy is an anachronism, and that your personal safety is at risk if the government cannot immediately access every piece of information about every person in the United States, do whatever you have to do with your health care records.  I’m sure that young Stewart in Bangalore cares deeply about your privacy.

Chutzpah File; Prosecutor Sues Wrongly Convicted Man

What happens to a man who was wrongly convicted of murder, served 11 years in prison, and is subsequently exonerated?  He gets sued by the prosecutor.  Nice.

Via Lat, this Kansas City story about Dennis Fritz, yet another defendant proven innocent by the availability of DNA to overcome our profoundly imperfect criminal justice system, tells of how the prosecutor felt maligned by Fritz’s book, Journey Toward Justice, about his experience.

The prosecutor’s response?  “I did the best I could with the available evidence.”  Well, that settles it.  After all, it’s really all about the prosecutor feeling good about himself, and if some innocent guy has to spend 11 years in prison, so what.

Adding to the shame, John Grisham also wrote a book about the case, though focusing more on Fritz’s co-defendant, Ron Williamson.  Grisham is getting sued as well, but I’m guessing he can afford better lawyers than Fritz.  And a little publicity like this won’t hurt book sale any.

While the story, up to now, sounds totally ridiculous, bear in mind that it provides no insight into what Fritz had to say about the prosecutor, and may have attributed some factual conduct to him that is arguably libelous.  But there are just some positions that are so facially disingenuous that you have to laugh.  After all, when you convict an innocent man for murder and put him in jail for 11 years, you really should cut him a little slack if he gets angry with you.  I’m betting the next jury will.

Taking the Corporate Apologists to Task

Yesterday, this post about the fundamentally disgusting and disgraceful sexual abuse and humiliation of an 18 year old woman touched on the tangential issue of the reactionary “tort reform” provocateurs blaming the victim and her lawyers.  The young woman, Louise Ogborn, sued the venerable institution of McDonalds, which Ted Frank of Overlawyered calls a “tertiary innocent victim.”

A jury returned a verdict against McDonalds in the total amount of $6.1 Million, including a $5 Million punitive damage award.  As one of the Overlawyered sycophantic commenters notes, this is proof that jurors are ignorant unemployed or elderly people who feel good about themselves because they are “GIVING free money away.” (his caps, not mine).

While most of what appears at Overlawyered can be laughed at as being the rantings of a fringe element view of the evils of the civil law system, as expressed by people who enjoy a paycheck from such thoughtful groups as the American Enterprise Institute (What? You thought they weren’t paid for writing this drecht?), this time they’ve gone too far.

In their blind support of big business over all else, they have demeaned a young woman who was subjected to a strip search in the back room of a McDonalds restaurant, where she worked, by her manager.  She was then subjected, still held in captivity in the back room, to a naked spanking and then forced to perform oral sex on the McDonalds manager’s fiance.  She was forced to do jumping jacks, naked, to see if stolen items would fall out of her body.  She cried and pleaded to be let out, but remained captive in that back room of McDonalds for hours. 

McDonalds knew that there was someone, pretending to be a cop, targeting fast food restaurants for this specific purpose.  McDonalds claims it sent out a mass email to its managers.  The manager claims she never saw any such email.  The manager said that the caller “knew the lingo” and was convincing that the manager had to follow his directions.  The manager was the boss of this young woman.  The manager held her in custody in the back room of McDonalds.  The manager was the living, breathing representative of his “tertiary innocent victim,” McDonalds. 

I can appreciate as well as the next guy that Overlawyered serves its big business masters by spinning any significant lawsuit into an unwarranted attack on corporate America.  But this time it did so at the expense of a young woman who was subject to conduct that would make any human being wretch.  This time the Overlawyered thinkers have gone so deep into the sewers that they have covered themselves in the detritus that cannot be washed away.

While Overlawyered never had much credibility with anyone who wasn’t already a card-holding member of the hallelujah chorus of corporate apologists, it now proves beyond any doubt that it will sacrifice any pretense at humanity to push its agenda of the victimization of corporate America, just because some evil, money-grubbing 18 year old had the audacity to expect that she would be able to go home from her job at McDonalds that day without having been kidnapped, strip-searched, sexually abused and humiliated at the hands of her employer. 
This went way too far over the line.  Overlawyered is a disgrace.  And I sincerely hope that Ted Frank has no daughter who might someday be subjected to what happened to Louise Ogborn.  If you have a moment, please let Ted Frank know how you feel about his attack on Louis Ogborn.

Gotbaum 3: New York Media Is the Problem

While we’ve been focusing up to now on the silly detail that Carol Ann Gotbaum wound up dead in a Phoenix airport holding cell, the Arizona Republic has focused on the real issue, the liberal New York media.  In this editorial, the Republic explains how that vanguard of liberal politics, The New York Post, has rushed to condemn the police and medical examiner and all of Arizona.

The villains, alas, are less fleshed out. They are not New Yorkers, after all. They are not kin to Betsy Gotbaum, the second-highest-ranking elected official in New York City. They are not related to a prominent New York labor leader. They are the denizens of a faraway place in the desert.

But, as characterized in the New York media today, we know they are brutes. And, likely, in league with the Maricopa County medical examiner and who knows how many other corrupt locals-with- badges in the cover-up of a patently heinous crime.


Adding to the “don’t blame Arizona” frenzy is a retired New York City police officer, Kevin Gray, who writes how wonderful it is to see a newspaper support police.  He writes: “If your editorial is indicative of the overall support found in Arizona for law enforcement, could you accept the immediate lateral transfer of 40,000 overworked and underpaid members of the NYPD?”  We are awaiting an answer.

The Gotbaums have retained an attorney, Michael Manning, to speak for the family while they show their respect for Carol Ann Gotbaum during the traditional period of mourning.  For now, they remain silent.  But while the spin machine works overtime to smear her and thereby show that regardless of what failings happened in the Phoenix airport, it doesn’t matter because she was a dirty, filthy, vomiting, alcoholic, New Yorker (and we all know the evils associated with being a New Yorker).

Manning has sought to slow down the official whitewash, trying to stay a step ahead of the facts by promoting how concerned and well-intended these fine Arizona officials were in their efforts to stop this woman.  The Republic editorial throws in a few claims that have somehow failed to make the rounds anywhere else:  It describes Carol Ann Gotbaum as one of those “out-of-control airline passengers who scream and rent asunder their own clothes as they demand entry to a departing aircraft.”

So the Phoenix cops were compelled to physically seize her to prevent her from “renting asunder her own clothes?”  This was a clothing intervention?  That’s novel.

Michael Manning suffers the slings and arrows of the Republic’s ire as well, smeared for his anticipated expectation of a civil law suit where he will enjoy a huge payday.  While outrageous fortune has yet to happen, Manning “quite simply needs to learn the meaning of shame.”  I bet he can handle this rebuke.

So the Republic editorial, feeling the heat from the New York media, goes on the offensive:

For the New York media, of course, fixing Phoenix cops as villains is an easy day’s work. A New York Daily News columnist actually reported New York cops would have handled the incident far more professionally. With all due respect to New York’s finest, Abner Louima, a Brooklyn resident whose close encounter in 1997 with an NYPD broomstick made a few headlines, might beg to differ.

Well, that solves the problem.  As the Arizona Republic plays the “Abner Louima” card, the death of Carol Ann Gotbaum is given its proper place in the pantheon of police evils.  All is well in Arizona, and Carol Ann Gotbaum is, inexplicably, still dead.

What to Tell Your Daughter?

The news magazine show, 20/20, did a piece last night on what happened to a young woman, Louise Ogborn, while working a late shift at McDonalds.  This was a disturbing, indeed, sickening story about how a female manager at McDonalds forced an 18 year old employee to strip because of a telephone call from someone who pretended to be a cop.

This pretense went on for hours, and the female manager later had her fiance remain with the naked employee.  The fiance remained on the phone with the pretend cop, who told him to spank the naked employee and have her perform oral sex on him.  He complied.

This situation resulted in prosecutions and a civil case against McDonalds, where a $6.1 million verdict was returned.  If you want to see the most pathetically shocking reaction to this, see Overlawyered, where the victim in the post is McDonalds, which failed to train its personnel sufficiently to protect its teenage employees from strip searches, sexual abuse and humiliation.  Their take is worthy of a post in itself, as it is one of the most disgraceful and disgusting self-serving political perspectives that I’ve ever seen.  I just want you to know this.

This story started a conversation amongst my family.  How do we instruct our children so that they don’t find themselves in the same situation as Louise Ogborn?  I have an 18 year old daughter.  I will not put into writing the thoughts that run through my head if this had happened to her.  But the question was posed, what does one do when confronted with an order by police to strip?

This didn’t call for a lawyer response, but a human one.  Do I tell my daughter to refuse to comply?  I’ve written far too much about what happens to people when the don’t do as they are told by the cops to be naive.  They don’t care about what’s legal; they demand compliance with their command or they will use force and hurt you.  Perhaps kill you.  Police have guns, clubs and tasers.  Police have the support of the public and politicians.  If you refuse their order, you suffer monumental risk.  But what if they order you to strip?

Here, the order came over the phone from a sick fraud.  But the McDonalds manager believed the fraud to be a real cop.  It doesn’t matter that it was a fraud.  It matters that it was believed to be a cop, and that the 18 year old was subject to the command, as transmitted by an adult in a superior position from a person believed to be a cop. 

But what if it really was a cop who gave the command?  What if the cop was there in person, and gave the command?  What if the cop gave the command that this young woman perform oral sex?  That could never happen?  Nonsense.  Nonsense.  Nonsense.

The options are clear.  Comply and be subject to horrific sexual abuse and humiliation, or refuse and be subject to beating, physical abuse and possibly death.  This is what we are left with today.  No matter which way we turn, we are left with no option but to suffer.  We have given so much power to the police that we can no longer protect ourselves from the police. 

The rule of thumb that I taught my children was to comply with the directions of police first, and argue the point later, after the crisis is over.  But the lesson of Louise was too much to take.  Here I am, a criminal defense lawyer, fully capable of instructing my children on the applicable law and procedures that police should employ, when they are legitimated entitled to conduct searches, including a strip search.  And I cannot explain to them what to do when things don’t happen the way they are supposed to.  I cannot tell my daughter to comply with an officer’s demand that she undress in the back seat of a patrol car upon fear of beating or arrest to cover this diseased cop’s perverted abuse of power, or death.

What do I tell my daughter?  All you people who so dearly love police that anything they say or do must be complied with, or my daughter would deserve to die, tell me what I should say?  Would you still love them so dearly if it was your daughter?