Author Archives: SHG

Gotbaum Update: The Best Defense

Like clockwork, when things go very wrong, the law enforcement crisis machinery goes into high gear to find some way to blame the victim.  And so, the Smearing of Carol Ann Gotbaum begins.  If done well, no one asks the right questions about what went wrong.

The 108 pages of details from the Phoenix Police Department are spread across the New York Times story.  Carol Ann’s husband, Noah, made phone calls to tell them that Carol Ann was in a “fragile state.”  His purpose was to ask that they be gentle with her, but the smear is that she was some sort of suicidal nutjob.  He mentioned once that she was “suicidal”, and that suddenly becomes prominent to suggest that killed herself. 

Naturally, alcoholism is prominently littered throughout.  Why?  Because this smears her by creating the image of a low-life, evil person.  While we often speak of alcoholism as a disease, we still see addiction as a character flaw and sign of human worthlessness. 

Then, they promote the extraordinary efforts to save Carol Ann’s life.  After they found her dead.  The image of the brave officer trying to resuscitate her, suffering the vomit of this demented alcoholic to breath life back into her body, is vivid.  No mention at all of the mouth guard that prevents this from happening, and is always available in police offices, stations and vehicles.  They had a automated defibrillator, and they must have had the mouth guard that prevented this as well.  No mention of it, however.  Nor question from the reporter.

This was a superb effort by the Phoenix Police to take charge of the story and deflect attention from the two real issues.  Why did they need to physically seize, arrest and manhandle Carol Ann Gotbaum, and how did she die in their custody?  Nothing in this report has any bearing on these issues.  These are the smears, not the answers.

Aside to Betsy:  You’ve been an official for a long time, justifying and explaining how government is really here to help people despite the collateral damage and misery it tends to cause.  Does it feel different when it’s your own daughter?  Facile rationalizations by official people, like you, have long insulated police from the responsibility for knee-jerk, simplistic, mindless and usually violent action, to the point where they believe that “following policy” absolves them from responsibility for the death of people.  Is this still good enough for you?

Carol Ann was causing a “disturbance” at the airport.  Notwithstanding the horrible image painted by the police to smear her memory, we still have no idea whether she was justified in being upset about how she was treated when they refused to let her board the plane.  People are allowed to get upset, and sometimes they make their point loudly.  Sometimes they are right to do so, because people aren’t required to be sheep, submitting to the dictates of an airline ticket counter person who can have an enormous impact on a situation without the slightest care in the world.

But maybe Carol Ann was completely wrong to get upset.  Maybe she had no cause at all to raise a ruckus, to scream and disturb all the people around her.  Then what?  Seized, cuffed, arrested, on the ground, knee in the back, grabbed by the arms so hard that finger bruises appear.  Was the need to physically remove Carol Ann from the eyes and ears of others sufficient to do this? 

There are many who say yes, that’s exactly what happens when you don’t comply.  When someone screams and acts crazy, and refuses to calm down when the police tell you to stop, you invite arrest.  When you don’t comply, you give up your right to not be taken physically by police.  And you give up your right to complain about it.  That’s what it means to live in a civilized society.

At some point, we have lost the idea that force begets force.  If a person threatens the safety of another, then they must be restrained.  But if they disturb another, without presenting an imminent threat of harm, what compels the use of force?  Annoyance does not beget force.  Force begets force.  How did we lose this concept?

Worse yet, the immediate use of force to quell disturbance has become acceptable.  Even when force is appropriate, should it be used before efforts are exhausted to calm the situation short of force?  Not any more.  When the police claim that they tried to calm Carol Ann down, they fail to describe how exactly they did so and what happened to make it necessary to end the calming process and begin the use of force.  The reason for this is clear.  They told her to calm down, and when she didn’t, well,  they tried.  Out came the cuffs.

This theme seems to be repeated in almost every citizen-police encounter these days.  If the citizen does not immediately comply with the command of a police officer, the police are justified in resorting to force to seize control of the situation.  Would another 5 minutes of letting the disturbance dissipate have changed things for the cop?  It would have changed things for Carol Ann Gotbaum, who would still be alive.

Note to Self:  Obey police, no matter how right I think I am in my position, so I can go home and see my family again. 

And so, we have an ugly, vomiting Carol Ann, forcibly seized by the Phoenix Police in full crisis smear mode.  Next up, how did she die?  Stay tuned for the next episode, competing autopsies.

And Another Meme Bites The Dust

A week ago, I had never even heard of a meme. When I learned that the dreaded meme was going around, I wasn’t sure what it meant.  I asked Bennett what it was.  “It’s like a social virus,” he told me.  Vague, yet unattractive. 

Over the past week, the meme was started by the anonymous Editor of Blawg Review with his/her choice of 10 blawgs that are “simply the best.”  Simple Justice wasn’t on the list.  But as the meme wound its way through the blawgosphere, we finally showed up on a few lists, saving me from total humiliation and tagging me to add to the meme.  So here is my list:

1.  Mark Bennett, Defending People: The Art and Science of Criminal Defense Trial Lawyering
2.  Gideon, a public defender
3.  Eric Turkewitz, New York Personal Injury Law Blog
4.  Andrew Bluestone, New York Attorneyl Malpractice Blog
5.  Nicole Black, Sui Generis
6.  Anne Reed, Deliberations
7.  Scott Henson, Grits for Breakfast
7.  Jon Katz, Underdog
8.  Robert Guest, I Was The State
9. Dave Hoffman, et al., Concurring Opinions
10. Young Shawn Matlock, I’m A Republican Criminal Defense Lawyer

On any given day, there are about a dozen other blawgs that would be on the list as well.  But unlike another of my favorites, Skelly at Arbitrary and Capricious, I’m not going to lose any sleep over it. 

Death Penalty Meets Closed Doors

Eric Turkewitz was kind enough to send me the link to this Talkleft post about how Texas Judge Sharon Keller closed the courthouse at 5:00 pm on September 25, the day that Michael Richard was to be put to death.  Though there were other judges in there, including the judge assigned to deal with an emergency stay application, Richard’s lawyers couldn’t get inside with their papers.  Michael Richard was executed.

Judge Cheryl Johnson is quoted in the Houston Chronicle as saying:

“And I was angry,” she said. “If I’m in charge of the execution, I ought to have known about those things, and I ought to have been asked whether I was willing to stay late and accept those filings.”


On its surface, this situation is either absurd or reflects what becomes of human beings when, as in Texas, executions become so commonplace that the idea of missing cocktails at the club was more than Judge Keller could take. 

If the Talkleft post is the protagonist, then this Beldar reaction is the antagonist.  His knee-jerk reaction, which he fastidiously denies to be knee-jerk by asserting the he wants to know more about the “real story,” is to question whether the attorneys asked that the courthouse doors remain open.  While professing the potential for shock and dismay, if the story turns out to be true, Beldar won’t go there unless Judge Keller says so.  Judge Johnson, apparently, can’t be trusted.

Perhaps this is a Texas thing that a New Yorker like me just doesn’t “get”.  Isn’t an execution of a human being a big enough thing to make sure its handled properly?  Is it so mundane that a judge doesn’t pay any special attention to it?  Is there EVER an excuse for closing the doors to the courthouse to a man about to be killed by the State? 

It seems to me that a judge should have been available to Richards’ attorneys at every second, and perhaps should have kept an open line (if not lent the lawyers a desk in the judge’s chambers) to facilitate a last minute stay.  Perhaps it would have been for naught, with the last ditch effort rebuffed. but at least the opportunity was available.  With the doors locked at 5, the ballgame was over.

Granted that Texas executes people with regularity, making the event far more casual than my parochial sensibilities can appreciate.  I suppose this is what happens following the institutionalization of executions.  But it makes me yearn for a re-release of Phil Ochs song, “Outside of a Small Circle of Friends.”  Sorry Beldar, but there is no excuse for a judge to be so callous on the eve of an execution, no matter whether the attorneys asked to keep the doors open the right way or not. 

Obama Won’t Be Pinned

A while back, Andy Rooney of 60 Minutes fame did one of his famous rants about politicians wearing American flag pins.  It didn’t seem to have much impact.  Flag pins remained firmly affixed to lapels across the country, proving with certainty one’s love of country.

Obama has announced that he will no longer succumb to this submission to the pin.  Obama will not wear a pin as a sign of “true patriotism.”





While Orin Kerr at Volokh Conspiracy discovers the “true meaning” of the pin announcement, no one has yet considered what really matters:  Men wearing jewelry.

My grandmother used to get “all dolled up” whenever she had a reason to leave the house.  It involved getting her hair done at the beauty parlor (talk about a waste of money), putting on her best dress and pinning a cameo to her breast.  “Why?”  “Because that’s what women do when they go out,” my mother informed me.  Fair enough.  I learned early on that women adorned themselves with jewelry.  Men did not.   And so, my sensibilities were formed. 

One day, a Republican decided that he looked drab in his gray suit, white shirt and Nancy Regan red power tie.  The tie no longer held the pizazz it once did.  No, he needed some new way to bring out the color of his eyes. And so the American flag pin was placed on his lapel.

The pin itself was a miracle.  Like so many other things done brilliantly by our forefathers, the colors of the pin were a spectacular match for the broad spectrum of men’s clothing, blue and gray suits with white or blue shirts.  Red, white and blue.  It was a match made in heaven.  How the founding fathers could possibly have had such astute color sense is beyond my wildest imagination, but they nailed it.

The first man so pinned was a bit of dandy, but the second saw the fashion virtue for what it was, a true standout.  “Look how well that pin shows up on TV!”  Not only did he look spectacular, but he looked 110% American.  The latter recognition was the boon that pin manufacturers across China needed.  Pin was “in”.

Not only did pin wearers prove beyond any possible doubt that they were patriots, they looked sharp.  Men across Kansas and Oklahoma who had been dying for years to wear jewelry suddenly had their opening.  If real men, real Patriots, could wear a pin, so could they.  American flag tooth “fenders” couldn’t be far off.

And of course, as the Patriotic Republicans were doing it, so too did the Democratic fashion wannabe followers.  Refusing to cede the high ground on patriotism, more liberal candidates jumped into the jewelry fray.  Naturally, they first tried to play the cameo card, pinning grandma’s cameo to their breast, but the color match was atrocious and, of course, it bore a decided resemblance to Mao Zedong.  Learning quickly from this fashion faux pas, they bought a gross of flag pins and passed them out in the halls of government for all to wear.  And so the ubiquitous bipartisan pin promotion began.

Obama now says “No more pins!”  Whether or not this proves that he is true patriot can be decided elsewhere.  I’m just happy that men can go back to not wearing jewelry.  Well, maybe a tasteful diamond brooch, but that’s it.  After all, diamonds go with everything.

Practical Blawgosphere: Paying Over Time

Mark Bennett at Defending People posts about taking cases where the client wants to pay out legal fees over time.  He won’t do it.  Mark’s reasoning is that he doesn’t finance his own representation, and “if nobody you know will loan you the money to pay my fee, why would [he]?”

Mark’s rationale is sound and accurate.  Lawyers aren’t banks.  We don’t give loans to our clients so they can pay us (and conversely, we can get their case).  On the other hand, given the cost of a real criminal defense, it is usually far beyond what many clients have on hand or available to them.  Many people just aren’t readily liquid in anticipation of an arrest, and their friends and family may well be in similar shape.  It’s not that they don’t have it, or that their family doesn’t love them, but that they can’t get it in time to retain a competent lawyer. 

This leaves clients in the unfortunate position of either having to go with a lawyer who is talking “fight” but charging “plea”, or just one of the basic pretenders who won’t let a dollar bill walk out of their office.  Neither is good for the client or the profession.

While I don’t disagree with Mark in general, I approach the problem from a different direction.  My experience is that money can be the most divisive factor in a lawyer-client relationship.  Once you get past the acute phase (the arrest), clients and family settle down a bit into the painful hiatus of waiting for the case to unfold.  When the pressure is off, the sense of urgency changes.  Suddenly, your client who needed you so desperately becomes more aware of the money issues, and the pressures for money from other areas of his life. 

It’s not that the promises of payment were not heartfelt when made.  It’s that things change.  Unforeseen changes occur.  Priorities change.  At least for the moment.  And when the day comes that payment is due, the client appears in the office, face down and feet shuffling, and then comes the inevitable announcement: “I don’t have the money.”  You remind them of their promise, but the only response is “but I don’t have it.”

This creates a huge rift in the attorney-client relationship.  No longer are both part of the same team, determined to win a case.  Rather, they are now adversaries in a soured transaction.  Clients avoid calls from lawyers because they are embarrassed about nonpayment.  Lawyers spend time trying to collect their fee instead of working on the case.  Or lawyers just stop working when the fee isn’t paid.  Either way, it’s unproductive time. 

Even when clients pay up late, time and opportunity is lost, and a relationship has problems.  There is distrust and often some anger.  There were needs to be filled in the defense during the period of nonpayment that were never filled.  Investigations that were never performed because there was no money to pay for them.  Research that should have been done but wasn’t.  information needed that could not be gotten when phone calls weren’t returned.  You can’t make up for things that went undone when payments are finally made far after they were due. 

There was a time that I was inflexible about taking payments over time, and I lost more than a few cases (and upset more than a few potential clients) as a result.  I’ve become more flexible about it, mostly of necessity.  Even clients in white collar cases, with big houses, fancy cars and country club memberships, have problems getting the money together to pay the legal fee.  Sometimes, more than non-white collar defendants.  I have no desire to chase away clients or lose interesting cases.  I also have no desire to work for free.

My position these days is to work things out with potential clients to the extent it seems reasonable for both of us.  I keep a very tight rein on payments, with relatively short time frames so that things never get too far out of control.  I make it very clear what it mean to create this rift between attorney and client, and the impact to them of their failure to pay.  It becomes one more choice that they have to make in whether they want to maximize their likelihood of success or failure in defending against the charges.

For the most part, clients have been quite good at fulfilling their financial obligations, recognizing that it’s in their best interest to avoid unproductive problems (they have enough “productive” problems already).  The few who show up with heads down and feet a’shuffling are inevitable.   Then it becomes a matter of tough love.  They know the ramifications of making a promise (I always tell clients, after the payment terms are mutually agreed upon, that it is their responsibility to do what they agreed to) and not keeping it.  Their answer is always the same, they don’t have the money, and my reply is always the same, that can’t be my problem.

A Little Help, Please

Jon Katz brings us a decision from the glorious DC Court of Appeals that should give law students (and others) reason to be concerned about something other than what Tier their school is.  In Limpuangthip v. United States,   (Sept. 27, 2007), a search of a dorm at George Washington University by a dorm supervisor at the behest of campus police was approved.

My first guess (before reading the decision) would have been that the court held that the dorm supervisor was not acting as the agent of the police, and hence the search would have been by private actors.  I would have been wrong.  Instead, the court held that the University Police (special police officers, as the court preferred to call them), who were employed by the University but deputized by the metropolitan police department, were not acting in their capacity as police officers but in their capacity as University employees. 

This is one of the silliest decisions I’ve seen in a while.  Mind you not THE silliest, but one of them.  So the police notify the dorm supervisor that they received a tip that a dorm room contained drugs, requested that the super search the room, were present outside the room during the search, assisted in the collection of the evidence (with the dorm super putting the drugs into bags held by the cops), and then took over from there.

What part of this doesn’t sound like regular, garden-variety police work?  The decision is worth a read for the gymnastics that the court goes through to legalize a basic warrantless search of a dorm room.  And you thought it wasn’t hard to be an appellate judge.

Officer, Does This Refresh Your Recollection?

In almost every criminal trial, there will be police witness testifying on behalf of the prosecution.  They will be called to the stand in their “I’m testifying today” outfit, whether it’s a suit or a uniform with shiny leather, hair nicely combed and clean shaven (at least no day old growth of stubble).  They will take the seat, swear to tell the truth, and give their testimony.

But as Robert Guest points out at I Was the State, that scrubbed-up officer may not really be giving testimony.  What happens, and frankly happens in almost every case, is that the officer is repeating orally what he wrote down in his reports shortly after the arrest.

Like most of us, we do our job every day and the details, well, they begin to blur.  One defendant looks like the next.  The facts of one case become indistinguishable from another.  It all looks the same after a while.  So a year or two later, the officer has at best minimal recollection of your defendant and your case. 

The dirty little secret is that the officer didn’t come to court that day to testify without a few minutes of preparation.  He read over his reports.  He read his grand jury testimony.  He talked to his fellow officers to find out what they were going to say.  And he is magically fully familiar with the case, right?

Not exactly.  The officer may be capable of repeating what his report says, but he that’s as far as he can remember.  As Robert states, police reports are not admissible proof.  You can’t cross-examine them.  They are prepared by the officer for the purpose of supporting his actions.  They are self-serving, and they tend to be a summary of the bad stuff, just enough to make the case without giving the defendant anything. 

But a living witness can be cross-examined, and that’s why the officer is required to take the stand.  But if the officer doesn’t remember anything beyond what he wrote in his reports, then the right to cross-examine witnesses is illusory.  Ask a tough question and the officer response will run the gamut from “I can’t remember’ to some made-up response that is consistent with what he’s written down.  He’s not stupid, you know, and he did go through Police Academy training in how to be an effective witness for the prosecution.

The idea behind cross-examination is to test the witnesses memory, challenge the conclusions and bring out the details that do not support the prosecution’s theory.  This can only happen if two things occur simultaneously.  First, the police witness has to be truthful, meaning willing to answer questions honestly even if it does not help his cause.  Second, the police witness must have a fully viable memory of events, so that he can respond honestly if he so chooses.  Without either, cross-examination doesn’t work quite as well.

You can’t quite blame an officer for his or her lack of memory.  After all, most of us can’t remember what we ate for breakfast that morning.  But the officer can be blamed for not being honest about it.  I can only remember one time in 25 years when an officer testified that he really couldn’t remember anything about the case, and that his entirely testimony was based on his reports.  Ironically, even with this admission, the judge allowed him to testify anyway, showing open contempt for the defendant’s right to counsel and cross-examination of witnesses.  Since the trial resulted in acquittal, the ruling was never tested.  Good for the defendant, but too bad for the law.

In possibly the most cynical example I know of, and a case where I’ve just completed the appellate brief, a cop witness testified on direct that the car involved in a case was made by one marque.  After a 5 month hiatus between direct and cross (don’t ask, it’s another huge due process issue), the officer was back on the stand for cross-examination.  During this testimony, the cop insisted that the car was another brand.  Defense counsel hit this conflict hard, over and over again, in his questions.  Then the prosecutor, on redirect, tried to rehabilitate her witness, and he again insisted that the car was the second brand, not the one he said on direct.  The make of the car was critical to the issue at hand, and this testimony was huge.

So what did the judge do about it?  She waved her arm and it magically disappeared behind the veil of judicial rationalization.  The witness, she concluded, testified accurately on direct, and had simply forgotten the correct answer when he returned to the stand for cross.  No problem.  Direct was correct.  Cross was just a silly mistake. 

Perhaps the judge was precisely correct, under our secret, hidden, don’t tell the public view of what testimony is really all about.  But it was an overt display of the meaninglessness of the police officer’s testimony.  Testimony was a dog and pony show, while the players all know what really happened.  If a direct, major conflict in testimony on a critical point can just be waved away as a “mistake”, then there is no point to giving testimony at all.  And certainly no point to cross-examination.  And therefore no point to the defendant having a lawyer, since no matter what the lawyer does to undermine the prosecution’s case, it’s just a mistake.

This bit of judicial slight-of-hand will end up in front of an appellate court.  We’ll see what they have to say about it, and whether they agree that testimony is just another step we have to go through to get to the part where the judge sentences the defendant. 

Sol Wachtler Is Back!

There was once a Chief Judge of the New York Court of Appeals.  He was one hell of a judge.  While putatively Republican, he was as progressive as can be, strong on civil rights and personal freedoms.  A New York kind of Republican, if you get my drift.

And then one day, we find out that the guy went nuts.  Bonkers.  He dressed up in a cowboy hat, pretended to be a private investigator and made harassing phone calls to an ex.  It couldn’t possibly be true.  Could it?

And 15 years later, the former Chief Judge is readmitted to the bar.

Welcome to the wacky world of Sol Wachtler.  He really was a great judge.  Not a good judge, but a great one.  And then he went off the deep end and he was gone.  New York has been the worse for it.

It isn’t clear what happened.  He says its the combination of arrogance and mental illness.  Makes sense.  But it really doesn’t matter now, as chances are slim that they will let him back into the judges robing room. 

Should Sol Wachtler have been let back in the door?  If he’s cleaned up his problems, then he should.  Certainly, there are few who are better lawyers than the former Chief Judge.  Can you see him arguing about what the court meant back when?  What trial judge is going to tell Sol he doesn’t know that law.  That’s a lot of legal clout, and there aren’t many around who can do that.

It’s unclear what Sol will do with his newfound right to practice law.  He’s not a kid anymore, so he may not do much of anything (except perhaps make a little rain?).  But in any event, I can well remember the Wachtler days in Albany, and I miss them.  Did I mention that he was a great judge?  There aren’t too many of those around, so we should be nice to the few we have.  And I’m just fine with being nice to Sol Wachtler.  Welcome back.

And Now, A Snarky View of Britney, Kevin and the Kids

I realize that there isn’t enough time today to dig deep into the legal and social significance of the ruling that Britney may not be the best mother, but I can’t resist a few observations.

First, how does a judge chose between Britney Spears and Kevin whatever his name is?  What has either one done to demonstrate that she/he is fit to have custody of children?  What has either one done to demonstrate that they should be allowed anywhere near children?  And if it needs to be said, what are the chances that these children will reach puberty, and if so, grow up to be normal?

Second. attorney and media slut Gloria Allred represented a Britney bodyguard who was NOT called as a witness at the custody hearing.  So what does she do?  There’s her happy face, on TV, spilling every dirty little secret that the bodyguard has to tell on morning TV.  Britney on drugs.  Britney nude.  Britney nude on drugs.  Thank you, Gloria, for compensating for the modicum of good taste shown by this whole affair by proving that you are the lowest common denominator. 

Third, when the cute and clean school-girl turned into the rasping tramp, didn’t anyone advise this child-woman that she was really not the center of the universe?  For all the money and fame that the former generated, the latter was destined for trouble.  It seemed clear to me at the time, and I (as a father of a teenager) watched in horror as this young, and clearly immature, woman blew up her life over and over again.  Doesn’t she have parents?  Handlers?  Agents? Publicists?  Anyone with two eyes and common sense?  Not only did you let her destroy her own life, but you stood by while your meal-ticket imploded.  What were you thinking?

I see Britney Spears as a young woman in need of firm guidance.  I understand when you are that wealthy and popular, you don’t have to listen to anyone.  But there has to be someone she loves and trusts who can give her the tough love she desperately needs, even at the risk of not being given a new Mercedes every month.  Does no one near her care enough to take a bullet for this young woman?  For her sake, I hope someone will help her.

Anita Hill Learns a Lesson

It was 16 years ago when we were sitting on the edge of our seats watching the Clarence Thomas confirmation hearings.  This was an extraordinary thing.  Nobody actually watched confirmation hearings like this.  Here we were, ordinary Americans, lawyers and laypeople, staring at the TV.  And no pop celebrity anywhere on the screen.  It was a great day for democracy.

How strange to find Clarence Thomas on the telly as the new term opened.  Opening the wounds of his youth, and finally coming out of seclusion to prove that he wasn’t the wasted seat that everyone thought he was.  He wanted to emerge from Nino Scalia’s shadow, and even tell how Nino sat in his shadow on occasion.  But mostly, he wanted to use the 16 years of accumulated clout to club his archenemy to death.  Finally, Clarence Thomas could put brush the public hair off the coke can and rip Anita Hill.

Anita Hill was a whistleblower.  She took up arms against a person who had been nominated for the Supreme Court of the United States.  How much crazier can one be?  To attack a man who was about to ascend to one of the most powerful positions in the Nation, and one that he could hold for life (assuming good behavior).  This was not a good bet on her part. 

Sure, there were Democrats who sought a weapon to use at the confirmation hearings, but who wants to be the spent bullet shot in earnest, but missing its mark?  While every eye is on the bullet as to flies through the air, gleaming, flashing and deadly, it’s forgotten the minute it passes by the target.  Then, it’s just a piece of trash to be tossed out.

Anita Hill took a monumental chance by coming forward to speak publicly about what happened between her and Judge Thomas.  Sixteen years later, can anyone remember what happened to Anita Hill after Clarence Thomas was confirmed?  But we are now treated to a post-hoc view of Justice Thomas’ fond memories of his time on the Hill, and given the free rein available to a Supreme, his retaliation against his former employee who made his life miserable way back when.

Was Anita Hill telling the truth 16 years ago?  We made up our minds back then.  I’d be hard pressed to revisit it all today and gain a new perspective based upon an artfully crafted book or some facile interviews.  But then, I can remember how it all played out in the first place. 

For those too young, or too obtuse, to have followed the Thomas confirmation hearings, perhaps this book and its embedded smear campaign will turn you around.  Perhaps Clarence Thomas was able to rehabilitate his reputation these many years later to make some believe that he was indeed qualified to sit on the big bench, though no one says (even today) that he was the best choice for Supreme at the time. 

But my thoughts turn to Anita Hill, the woman who took the risk.  She had nothing to gain by standing up and exposing herself for every arrow that could be flung her way.  If her word was accepted, she wouldn’t get the Thomas seat.  There was nothing she said that would make her America’s darling.  It was an act of dedication to democracy, a selfless act.  Perhaps a foolish act, to challenge authority at its highest levels.  But she did it.  And she did it for us. 

Anita Hill took one for the team.  As a member of the team, I thank Anita Hill for her bravery and selflessness.  The team didn’t win, but without Anita Hill, we would have had no chance of challenging the enormous might of the power elite of America.  Whether we need more Clarence Thomas’ is a question for debate.  But there is no debate that we need more Anita Hills. 

If there is any lesson for Anita Hill to learn now, 16 years later, it is that we have not forgotten what she did for us, and that the passage of time has not dulled the importance of her sacrifice.