Author Archives: SHG

Is Ann Coulter Worth This Much Thought?

A few days ago, I posted about Ann Coulter’s interview by Donny Deutsch.   Naturally, others followed, like Volokh Conspiracy and PrawfsBlawg.  While neither credited Simple Justice for breaking the story in the Blawgosphere, such banal omissions happen in academia from time to time.

But the intellectuals have taken the approach that Coulter should not be viewed as offensive, but rather as misunderstood.  At PrawfsBlawg (note the credit for the following quotation);

From an intra-faith perspective, one might question whether Coulter was speaking out of a genuine Christian spirit of faith and humility, or whether she was trivializing her own faith by using it as a talking point or, worse, as a vehicle in the age-old game of “From an intra-faith perspective, one might question whether Coulter was speaking out of a genuine Christian spirit of faith and humility, or whether she was trivializing her own faith by using it as a talking point or, worse, as a vehicle in the age-old game of “epater le bourgeois.”  .” 

So it just the age-old game of “epater le bourgeois,” is it?  I looked it up.  It means “to shock the middle class.”  So this was a planned connivance to make people like me sit up and take notice of her shocking revelation? 

Volokh, on the other hand, rationalizes the underpinnings of a prosteletizing religion to exclaim that this is to be expected, and Coulter was merely being impolite in saying so.  But the thought was, well, okey dokey, since that’s what Christians believe.

So, I’ve decided to ponder long and hard on the subject, lacking any French phrases to characterize it that will show me to be the bon vivant that hides beneath my coarse exterior.  Done.  Here’s what I’ve come up with.

It doesn’t really matter whether this was a true believer publicly stating closely held religious beliefs, or whether this was a scheming conniver using a shocking statement to position herself as the darling of the religious right.  Ann Coulter is not worth this much thought.  She certainly isn’t worth deep analysis, though I can’t fault law professors for doing so considering there’s no new Harry Potter book for them to spend their time on.

For me, the answer is clear.  She is an obvious media slut, saying outrageous things to promote herself to the farthest fringes of the right wing.  But her commentary is presented in such an awkward, non-thought-provoking way as to suggest that she lacks the capacity to scheme, but merely to open her mouth and let dumb stuff come out. 

If she had a pro-Christian purpose to her statements, she could have phrased her comments in a way that would clearly show her purpose.  I believe she’s smart enough to have realized this, and experienced enough with the media to accomplished it. 

So, having managed to present herself and her comments in a way that lacked any of the finesse of making a valid point on behalf of a prosteletizing religion to express a fair religious belief, and instead taking the gutter route, she gets no free pass in being offense.  Ann Coulter is just an ordinary, offensive big mouth. 

But this does beg a more important question:  Why do they keep putting her on the air to spew her crap?

Just How Many Die in Custody?

One of the things that our government is pretty good about is keeping track of things.  And Gideon found in his email yesterday (amongst other things) an email announcing a “special report presents the first findings from the law enforcement collection of the Deaths in Custody Reporting Program (DCRP).” I didn’t even know there was a DCRP.

This special report is, well, special indeed.  It has collected information about deaths in police custody from “over 40 states,” meaning that the pair of statisticians adding up the subject decided to call it quits when they hit the last pinkie.  Highlights of the report are:


  • Homicides by law enforcement officers made up 55% (1,095) of all deaths during arrests by State and local agencies. Eleven homicides were committed by other persons present at the scene.
  • No other cause of death was reported half as often as homicide. Drug and alcohol intoxication accounted for 13% of all deaths, followed by suicides (12%), accidental injuries (7%), and illness or natural causes (6%).
  • Three-quarters of the law enforcement homicides reported to DCRP involved arrests for a violent crime. Except for suicides (51%), violent offenders were involved in less than 30% of all other causes of death. Public-order offenders accounted for 8% of homicides, followed by property (4%) and drug offenders (2%).


  • Notable is that this report is limited to state and local law enforcement.  Also notable (and can be found starting at page 9 of the pdf of the complete statistical analysis) is the grand prize winner for the state that kills more people in custody than any other. . .

    Texas!

    Your prize, Texas is a fabulous, fun-filled trip to beautiful, sunny California, the number 2 state for deaths in custody!

    And what of Arizona, where Carol Ann Gotbaum was recently reduced to a statistic?  Way down the list, though I’m sure that doesn’t make her mother feel any better about it.

    The Ugly Back Side of Blawging

    Sure, blawging looks glamorous.  But there are some issues that the casual reader can’t see on the page.  These aren’t funny issues.  These are the sort of things that make one wonder why we bother.  It certainly isn’t for the money or fame.

    Another Blawger posted about a very controversial local subject yesterday.  There was absolutely no doubt that he raised a very important point in the post, and was absolutely, unquestionably correct in his stance.  While he received well-deserved praise from some (including me), he also learned first-hand of the hatred and venom that exists out there.

    I’m not sure that my blawger friend wants me to give up his coordinate, so for now I’m going to leave out the who.  If he gives me the go ahead, I’ll add it in later.  The object of this venom was Gideon at A Public Defender because of this post.

    The internet, while full of information, remains a relatively anonymous place.  Sure, we can figure out who people are if we really want to, but people feel that sense of anonymity that fuels road rage.  It’s also the great equalizer, with the most brilliant and most moronic able to post with the same degree of authority.  Since we don’t know who you are, we can’t assess whether you know what you’re talking about or you’re clueless and just making stuff up.  Some people like to use big words to prove their mettle.  Others prefer smaller words but big ideas.

    And then there are some who want to curse at you.  And threaten you.  This is what happened to that blawger yesterday.  He now has enemies.  Because he stook up against the popular but fearful and ignorant position held by those whose emotions have overcome their reason, he has become the object of their hatred.

    He has risen above, secure in the knowledge that these hate-filled emails reflect the venting of those who feel empowered and powerless.  No sleep was lost last night worrying about a knock on the door and a lynch mob in the front yard.  But it isn’t pleasant to find oneself the object of hatred by the fearful mob.

    Sui Generis Is Running Another Contest!

    At Sui Generis, Nicole Black, frustrated game show host that she is, has decided to run the latest and greatest of blawgospheric Contests.  Who’s the best New York Blawger and What’s the Best New York Blawg.

    Having been honored by a couple of my fellow blawgers and been nominated for the contest (and, I add, without any under the table payments from me at all), I ask any fans of Simple Justice to stop by Sui Generis when the polling opens and vote, vote, vote.  Vote early and often.  Vote on every computer you have (and any you can get your hands on).  The important thing is to vote.  For Simple Justice.

    It’s not that I care about the recognition.  I really want to win a copy of Sairo Rao’s book.  Do this for me and I promise to stop making fun of Texas.  For at least a week.  Maybe.  Do I ever ask you to do anything for me?  Just this one thing.  Would it kill you?


    For the Best New York Blawg contest:


    Chambermaid


    First place receives a signed copy of attorney Sairo Rao’s witty novel, Chambermaid, about a young attorney’s eventful year as a clerk for a Federal Court Judge.

    Crminal Lottery: Winners and Losers

    Scott Henson at Grits for Breakfast posted about a fascinating analogy used by a Texas prosecutor to explain why a defendant was treated with so harshly.  He likened it to winning the reverse lottery, where the likelihood of getting caught was slim, arrested slim, prosecuted slim, convicted slim and sentenced to hard time slimmer still. 

    But every now and then, someone enters the Texas Criminal Justice Reverse Lottery, and they are the Big Time Loser. And its those Big Time Losers who encourage others not to enter the Texas Criminal Justice Reverse Lottery.


    While the flip attitude toward justice raises some eyebrows, the game-like justification for why it happens to those “Big Time Losers” is what catches ones attention. 

    General deterrence is a legitimate sentencing factor.  Courts have said so, and that makes it so.  Whether general deterrence actually serves to deter is a matter for sociologists to ponder, but for lawyers’ purposes, we take it as the court gives it. 

    But general deterrence is not the only factor.  Court tell us that as well.  So the big winner of the reverse lottery does not become the poster boy for all criminals.  Each and every defendant stands before the court by him or herself, to be sentenced for what he or she did.  While the nature of punishment serves to fulfill the deterrence piece, we don’t dump on any single individual because we hate criminals and need a whipping boy to compensate for our general sense of inadequacy toward law enforcement.

    The Texas prosecutor who came up with this smarmy analogy thought he was being cute.  This is the kind of answer one gives at a cocktail party to impress the opposite sex with one’s wit and brilliance.  But guys like this actually have a role that affects other peoples’ lives, which takes some of the fun out of it.  I hope he went home alone from that cocktail party.  As a deterrent from making foolish analogies.

    By this theory, any time a prosecutor has the ability to nail some defendant good, he should seize that opportunity and make sure that the guy not only gets convicted of the worst possible crime, but receives a sentence so totally disproportionate to the offense that all the criminals who hear about it are left breathless.  Certainly, that will put a major dent in crime, as we all know that criminals put a great deal of thought into their commission of crime before hand, weighing the costs against the benefits, before deciding whether to move forward.  This well conceived analysis would certainly benefit by raising the back end price, thus shifting the equation away from the unlikelihood of getting caught by the cops to the severe consequences if, despite the favorable odds, one gets pinched.

    Wait a sec.  I just remembered.  Cost/benefit analyses are only done by non-criminals and MBA students.  Criminals have a nasty habit of not thinking.  Some aren’t capable.  For others, it makes their head hurt.  One theme that runs through my representation of people charged with crimes over the past 25 years is the total absence of thought in making the decision to do wrong.  The answer to the perennial question, “what were you thinking?”  “I wasn’t.”

    So that reduces the social utility of deterrence to a great way to keep the lapsed middle-manager from deciding to rob a bank when his bonus comes up short.  But it does little for the 99% of crime done by the thoughtless. 

    Ultimately, we are left with a game played by prosecutors (some, not all), who take it out on the individual defendant that is so easily nailed that he is helpless.  The analogy is wrong; it isn’t a reverse lottery.  It’s shooting fish in a barrel.  Better yet, it’s the answer to why a dog licks himself (with gross thoughts of Sarah Silverman). 

    Ironically, the prosecutor’s description of the lottery process is so far off base as to be laughable.  Where are all these criminals getting away with everything, running amok, scoffing at the prospect of getting caught, convicted and sentenced to prison?  Our prisons are bursting at the seams.  As Grits notes, it hasn’t done a thing to keep crime down in Texas, but it is great for the private Texas prison industry. 

    The good news is that not all prosecutors think this way.  Most would have the good sense to keep their mouths shut if they did.  And some actually understand that they are dealing with people.

    Ann Coulter Wants Me To Be “Perfected”

    Today must be conservative hottie day at Simple Justice, since we’re now going from former NFL cheerleader cum hatemonger Wendy Murphy to the diva herself, Ann Coulter.  On the Donny Deutsch’s CNBC show,  The Big Idea, Coulter explained here thoughts :


    COULTER: No, we think — we just want Jews to be perfected, as they say.


    DEUTSCH: Wow, you didn’t really say that, did you?


    COULTER: Yes. That is what Christianity is. We believe the Old Testament, but ours is more like Federal Express. You have to obey laws. We know we’re all sinners —


    DEUTSCH: In my old days, I would have argued — when you say something absurd like that, there’s no —


    COULTER: What’s absurd?


    DEUTSCH: Jews are going to be perfected. I’m going to go off and try to perfect myself —


    COULTER: Well, that’s what the New Testament says.


    DEUTSCH: Ann Coulter, author of “If Democrats Had Any Brains, They’d Be Republicans,” and if Ann Coulter had any brains, she would not say Jews need to be perfected. I’m offended by that personally. And we’ll have more “Big Idea” when we come back.



    Perhaps some of the deep thinkers who believe (Yeeeessssss, I believe, Hallelujah!) that Ann Coulter speaks the truth would like to tell us more about how the Jews need to be “perfected”.  I really want to know.

    Update:  Another take on Coulter from Volokh Conspiracy.  While a sober analysis of Ann Coulter’s “intent”, does David Bernstein completely miss how disinhibited Coulter is in expressing her ideals?  He calls says it’s “polite not to declare the superiority of one’s religion, and the inferiority of one’s neighbors.”  That doesn’t cut it for me.  Polite refers to saying “please” and “thank you.”  Not to promoting religious hegemony.

    Just in case you’ve forgotten about the lovely Ann Coulter, here’s a little reminder:



    What To Make of Thomas Sowell?

    Thomas Sowell, economist and Senior Fellow at The Hoover Institute at Stanford University, wrote this piece about Nifong and the Duke Case. 

    Is there a deeper, more nefarious meaning to this, or do all good people, regardless of political persuasion, ultimately agree that this was a grievous wrong.  If at first you say to yourself, the answer is obvious, then you will be surprised to learn that this opinion piece is already generating widespread debate as to whether it is a Machiavellian ploy to undermine and impugn academic freedom by shifting the blame from the obvious villain, Mike Nifong, to those who jumped immediately onto the bandwagon of guilty rich white boys in furtherance of their political agenda.

    Or maybe there’s no message here beyond the words written. 

    Wendy Murphy is Hot, Hot, Hot!

    Someone asked me yesterday if I had read Wendy Murphy’s book, And Justice for Some.  I didn’t even know that she had written a book.  I asked if it was about the Duke Lacrosse players and Wendy’s role as supplicant to the alter of Nifong.  Nope, in fact, it doesn’t even mention the Duke case, even though Wendy was given a cot in Bill O’Reilly’s office so she could be ever-ready to spew.  Why should Nancy Grace have all the fun?

    This book, apparently, is supposed to be some insiders guide to the lies and tricks of criminal defense lawyers and their pocket buddy judges in getting the guilty off.  Well, that peaked piqued my interest.  After all, if there are good tricks to be learned, shouldn’t I learn them?  Just for academic purposes, I assure you.

    So my research began, and the first thing I saw was this picture of Wendy on the cover of the book looking, well, pretty good.  Hair sweeping back in the wind, which isn’t easy to have happen naturally when you take a photograph indoors.  But this is a serious person, “a Visiting Scholar at Harvard Law School . . . and teaches an advanced seminar on sexual violence at the New England School of Law in Boston.”  Do you think somebody who teaches at law school is going to demean herself with a beauty shot on the cover?  I don’t.  She’s just a hottie.

    And so it came as no surprise that, as the bottom of her book website bio, this little tidbit is revealed:  She’s a former NFL cheerleader!  It’s not like Greta can say that.  I wonder what team?  No matter.  Wendy Murphy is a renaissance woman.  She does it all. 

    But then came the downside.  It seems that KC Johnson, in his brilliant blawg Durham-In-Wonderland, was enticed by the wonder of Wendy Murphy as well.  And well before me (and with good reason, given Wendy’s omnipresence on the Mike Nifong side of truth and justice ).  So KC did a short spin through the life of Wendy.

    Murphy’s bizarre claims to USA Today prompted me to perform a Lexis/Nexis search of her myriad case-related appearances. The results were deeply disturbing. In addition to the outrageous quotes highlighted above, on at least 18 occasions over the past nine months, Murphy has made demonstrably untrue statements. She also has engaged in a pattern of wholly unfounded speculation and has routinely denigrated due process.


    The results of KCs efforts are quite damning.  I can’t explain this, but Wendy Murphy no longer looks that good to me.

    Fox Doesn’t Love Me Anymore

    I used to be a regular guest on the Fox News weekend show, Fox and Friends. A car would come by on a weekend morning and take me to the studio, where I would hang in the green room and wait until it was my turn to go on air.  I guess I was the “friends”. 

    They had those nice little danishes and bagels.  It was my favorite TV gig, because Fox was never stuffy and serious like other news programs, and I could pretty much say anything I wanted.  It was free-wheeling, no-holds-barred fun.  They gave me Fox t-shirts and a nice “fair and balanced” silk tie.  Sometimes I would bring my kids to watch so that I could spend some weekend quality time with them.

    Needless to say, I was the voice of evil.  The criminal defense lawyer who was there to be shot down.  I would be asked to explain the ridiculous, as far as they were concerned, since my side was invariably wrong.  The hosts were good people, and we had some real conversations off camera, but when the lights went on, they did their job.  Rupert Murdoch didn’t suffer dissent.

    Dissent was my role.  I was the loyal opposition, the person who would stand up only to be knocked down.  So why did I bother?  For one thing, it was fun.  No somber tones or furrowed brows.  When the lead-in was some goofy loaded question, the answer could just as easily begin, “It’s funny you ask that, because a third grader asked the same question yesterday.  Don’t worry, I’ll speak slowly just like I did then…”  Attack, parry, riposte.  No hard feelings afterward.  It was a war of wits, and there was nothing they could do to stop me on live TV, sitting right there in the studio with them.  I had as much access to the air as they did, and knew how to use it.

    One day, Fox called me to tell me that they were changing the time slot.  I used to leave around 8:00 am to go to the studio.  Now they wanted me to go at 6:00 am. 

    If this was my job, then I go when they tell me.  But it wasn’t my job.  I wasn’t being paid.  And 6:00 am is really early.  Who even watches that early?

    The calls from Fox stopped.  I receive one or two more calls after that, but wasn’t able to make it.  Then nothing.

    I still get calls from the straight news shows, but it’s not the same.  Very serious stuff, and 30 seconds to discuss serious cases without using words over 2 syllables.  Not to mention, no danish in the green room.

    I miss Fox.  I hate to admit it, but I do.  I watched Fox News the other day when they had a piece about the Lynne Stewart / Hofstra controversy.  It was tepid and silly.  The anti-Stewart position was based upon what she and others were going to say to students in the future.  Since I lack the ability to see into the future, I can’t say for sure whether the prediction will be correct, but I feel fairly confident that the guest assumed far more than anyone who knew what they were talking about would.  It seemed that they really had to stretch to find this guest, when they should have been able to find someone with a little more knowledge about the subject.  But his politics was right on target for the show, even if his facts were a little fuzzy.

    The Hofstra spokesperson seemed to be reading from a talking points memo, unconvincing and without addressing the real question.  She didn’t even challenge the apparent ability of the naysayer to see into the future.  Hello?  Neither side added to the collective debate, and it was 3 minutes of my life that I will never get back.

    I didn’t mind that I played the role of defending the indefensible at Fox.  It’s a role that I play regularly, and a challenge to make points to an audience disinclined to appreciate any point of view other than their own.  Preaching to the choir is no fun.  Yeah, I miss Fox.  I miss having some fun with my friends.  And from what I could see, they could use a little fun with their friend too.  Just not so early.

    The End of Redress: State Secrets Doctrine

    Today’s New York Times editorial, Supreme Disgrace, talks about one of those situations that makes one wonder why we bother to learn civics in school.  What happened to Khaled el-Masri could never happen, according to my understanding of America.

    Mr. Masri says he was picked up while vacationing in Macedonia in late 2003 and flown to a squalid prison in Afghanistan. He says he was questioned there about ties to terrorist groups and was beaten by his captors, some of whom were Americans. At the end of May 2004, Mr. Masri was released in a remote part of Albania without having been charged with a crime.

    Masri didn’t pick up a gun and start shooting at Americans abroad. He did what a responsible person should do, he sought redress for what was done to him.  His effort ended yesterday, when the United States Supreme Court denied review of the lower courts dismissal of his action.

    America may have done this to him, but it would not face him.  Instead, the government invoked the state secrets doctrine, which gives the United States a free pass when, in its own determination, to defend against the allegations would require the government to disclose state secrets and thus might endanger national security. 

    The beauty of this doctrine is that no one, not even the judge before whom it is invoked, knows what the government is talking about.  It’s so secret that the judge doesn’t get to learn about it, consider its merit or decide whether the claim is valid.  By the mere incantation of the words, “state secret,”  the game is over.  And now that SCOTUS has passed, Mr. Masri’s effort is at its end.

    This is judicial deference to executive fiat at its very worst.  No, the answer is not to force the government into revealing information that would truly endanger national security, although whether the claim is real or illusory is precisely the sort of thing that an Article III judge is paid to do.  How the government deems them so untrustworthy that even the judge can’t know what the government’s claim is strikes me as ridiculous.  But assuming the secret to be that sensitive, or the judge to be that untrustworthy, there are other options that would preserve American ideals of justice without putting American security at risk.

    Consider that the Constitution has created a federal judicial system for the purpose of providing an avenue of redress.  This was done to avoid the need for insurrection every time someone took issue with the government, and taking issue with the government is the legacy of America.  Our forefathers fought hard over the details of how this nation would function, and the extent or limit of federal power.  Our most revered Patriots truly believed that a strong federal government, particularly the executive, was the surest route to tyranny.  

    So when a wronged person knocks on the courthouse doors, should anyone answer?  Obviously, we either open the doors or are revealed as a country where justice is a sham, to be given only when convenient.  We hold ourselves out to the world (and to ourselves) as the beacon of justice.  And so we must live up to our promises.

    That Mr. Masri’s treatment at the hands of America both happened and went terribly wrong doesn’t seem to be subject to much dispute.  It’s the part of determining what to do about it that has caused so many problems.  His case was dismissed because the government invoked the “state secret” doctrine.   Why dismissal?  Why not just the opposite?  

    No one should be able to force the United States to reveal secrets that endanger the security of the nation.  Assuming that the courts wish to leave the determination of what constitutes a secret, and which secrets are so important that they cannot possibly be disclosed, in the hands of the executive alone, why should that mean that Mr. Masri loses?  Why are the doors slammed shut on him, rather than the party who refuses to show his cards?

    Normally, a litigant can use the power of the court to force another party to disclose evidence necessary in the prosecution or defense of a claim.  State secrets should serve as sufficient basis (assuming that they are shown to be valid) to prevent this disclosure.  But then the party refusing to disclose should bear the weight of its decision, and not shift it onto the other side. 

    Let Mr. Masri prove his case based on what he has to offer, with an inference in his favor for any undisclosed secret.  Let the government prove whatever it can that is not within the confines of its invoked “state secret” doctrine, and stand mute otherwise.  Masri will have his day in court.  The government will have its secrets.  Masri will receive whatever redress he is due under our system of justice.

    Foul, you cry?  The government has “handcuffed” in its defense because it couldn’t use the really good stuff, the state secrets, to shut Masri down?  True, perhaps, but it was the government’s considered decision to keep its secret, nor Masri’s.  In the scheme of someone having to suffer for keeping a secret, it should not be shifted onto the victim, the party who has no say in any of this, rather than the government who both did the dirty deed leading to this suit and made the choice not to defend.

    Simply put, one side has to bear the burden of losing when a real state secret is involved, and that side should be the one who made the call.  Not only does it place the burden on the decision-maker, but it is consistent with every American notion of justice and the fundamental fear that the executive, left to his own unchecked devices, will resort to tyranny.

    We learn in civics that everyone is entitled to have their day in court in America.  Not anymore.  Think of all the social studies textbooks that will have to be changed because of this.