Author Archives: SHG

Miss Manners in Court

The practical blawgosphere needs an opinion from Miss Manners.  The question has been posed by Young Shawn about whether civility in the courtroom is dead, here and here.  Shawn’s not too happy about, and wonders why parents didn’t teach their children well.

The complaint reflects two separate civility issues.  The first is civility in the performance of the practice of law.  Shawn posts about a rude young prosecutor, swelling with self-importance, who has forgotten to behave like a human being with criminal defense lawyers. 

Shawn’s second post on the subject is about civility in general, although his angst comes from conduct that happened in a courtroom.  This is the general please and thank you type of civility, where you don’t jump the line or bump into people without saying excuse me.

Mark Bennett has jumped into the fray to tell Shawn that by letting these people get to him, he is giving away his power to control himself to others, letting their conduct dictate how he feels.  Very zen-like.

It’s not my job to teach manners to adults. If you’re over 14 years old and don’t know to say “please,” “thank you,” and “I’m sorry,” I’m not going to civilize you. I’m not even going to try. If you push onto the elevator before I get off, I’m not even going to scowl. If you cut me off in traffic, you won’t be seeing the finger. It’ll just waste my time and annoy you. I’m out of the business of teaching grownups lessons.


From a mental health perspective, I’m sure that Mark’s position is better.  But like Shawn, I’d have a hard time shrugging it off.  Like Shawn, it would annoy me and I would be inclined to do something about it.  Perhaps it will be a waste of time, and annoy the annoyer, but if I don’t do anything, then I’m just a passive enabler.  I don’t care to be an enabler, and I don’t like people invading my personal space.

I agree with Mark that we’re unlikely to teach grown-ups manners if they don’t know them already.  But I assume that most of them do know them, but have forgotten that they bear some responsibility to use them.  It may be that some lawyers are a tad aggressive, and this translates into behaviors that are socially inappropriate.  The occasional reminder won’t do them any harm.  Annoy them? Probably, but is that really my primary concern?

As for the lack of civility in the practice of law, that’s another issue.  The failure of lawyers to show common courtesy impacts on my ability to do my job.  Phone calls not returned, cases not called in turn, dismissive attitudes in front of my client, all affect me as lawyer.  That is not tolerable.  When I address these problems, I don’t do so to teach another lawyer/prosecutor a lesson, but for self-preservation.  I couldn’t care less if the get it or not, but I care immensely that my ability to represent my client is not impaired and my time on the clock is not wasted. 

So who’s got the right answer?  Calm, zen-like Mr. Bennett, or angry young man Shawn (along with angry old man me)?  I don’t know, but as the song says, I’ve got to be me.

The Advocate’s Dilemma: His Own Words

The sad story of the prosecution of Philip Russell has taken another dangerous twist along the prosecution path.  As has been discussed in previous posts, here, here, and here, Philip Russell is the Connecticut criminal defense lawyer indicted for a SOX violation stemming from the destruction of evidence of child porn at the behest of his client, Christ Church, when there was neither charges nor investigation pending.

Now, according to this AP story, federal prosecutors have filed a brief using Russell’s prior legal word and advocacy to show that he knew or should have known that an investigation was forthcoming.  Even more specifically, they will use a tape of Russell in an earlier case where he argues that child pornography should be turned over to federal authorities.

This new twist in the government’s approach creates two separate and significant problems.  The first is the separation between what a person says in his role as lawyer, the legal representative of another person, and his personal views.  The second is the higher level of attributed criminal responsibility that the feds are urging, which would make criminal defense lawyers a target of potential criminal liability than any other discrete group because of their unique position of standing between accused and the government.  In other words, we know things that other people don’t about bad things that happen in the world, and the government wants to make us responsible to them for our increased level of knowledge.

As attorneys, we spend our days arguing on behalf of our clients.  We don’t necessarily agree with what our clients have done. Indeed, we often find their conduct horrible, but that’s the nature of our job.  We don’t limit our representation to “happy” criminal cases, and our representation is hardly a sanction of crime or criminal.  It is a constitutionally necessary role, and we fulfill it without thought that any reasonable person would make the mistake of confusing our work with our personal view of right and wrong, morality or legality. 

In order to do that job effectively, as the government demands we do when they administer an oath to us that requires us to fulfill our constitutional mandate, we develop arguments and strategies designed to serve our clients’ goals.  A viable strategy in one case may be the opposite of the strategy we employ in another.  In this line of work, it is hardly disingenuous to make conflicting arguments in different cases.  It’s often a necessity, and zealous representation would require no less.  I’ve never heard a judge criticize us for arguing different theories in different cases.  They may not find us particularly persuasive when that happens, but never disingenuous.

The government, alas, thinks otherwise.  They want to use our words as advocate to pin us to the wall as human being.  When we argue on behalf of a client, according to the government, our words become a reflection of our personal views and they want lawyers held personally responsible for behaving consistently with positions taken on behalf of clients.  This makes for some very bad mojo, since we can’t argue for clients if our words will come back to bite us on our personal butt.

Also in our jobs, we learn things.  We learn lots of things, many of which are unsavory.  Our clients have often done bad things, whether different from what the prosecutors’ think, or worse.  Sometimes far worse.  This too is the nature of the job.  We learn where bodies are buried, sometimes literally, and we are forbidden to speak of it.

But the Russell prosecutors want to speculate on the bad things that are hidden away in a lawyer’s head.  Since he’s represented child porn defendants before, he has special knowledge about such things that increase his measure of understanding of the crime, investigation and prosecution.  Where an ordinary person would have no reason to believe that a particular instance of wrongdoing would result in an investigation, or would have no reason to know that a piece of evidence would “foreseeability” become the target of federal agents, the attorney would.  He knows things, according to the prosecution, and his liability should be increased based upon the things he knows.

Does Russell know things?  I’m sure he does.  But exactly what he knows should never be the subject of speculation by the prosecution or the Court.  Does he know that people sometimes get investigated?  Who doesn’t?  Does the government know how many people who commit crimes never get investigated?  Aha!  Got ’em there.  They have no idea how “foreseeable” an investigation and prosecution may be, because they only know about the ones they go after.  Criminal defense lawyers know about the ones that get away.  The prosecution’s theory here is based upon the flawed assumption that they know what Russell knows.  They don’t.  The judge doesn’t.  And they never will.

But there’s a bigger issue at stake here.  Criminal defense lawyers stand in a weird spot, between the law and the criminal, putting them at peculiar risk of being viewed externally as coming too close to the line in the course of doing their job.  It happened here.  It’s happened elsewhere.  The lines is often far blurrier than outsiders realize, since they lack the view from the criminal defense lawyer’s perspective.  Remember, we know more about the defendant’s side than others. 

Prosecutors think that they know it all.  They think they have unearthed all the nasty secrets and have a global view of wrongdoing.  They sometimes do, but more often don’t.  And even when they have all the information in front of them, they still don’t grasp the significance because they lack the experience to fully appreciate what they are looking at.  Remember, prosecutors are often white bread kids who’ve never seen life from the street side.  They don’t teach that at Harvard Law School.  Maybe they should.

The upshot of the Russell prosecution is to create an entirely new standard of criminal liability especially for criminal defense lawyers, putting us in far greater jeopardy of perceived criminal involvement than any other discrete group in America.  Do you think that might have a chilling effect on our ability to represent defendants?

Law Schools Are Not Dinosaurs

If you thought you’d heard that last about this year’s hem length at law schools, you’re sadly mistaken. Dave Hoffman at  Concurring Opinions, the sounding board for novel approaches to legal education, has posed the big question:  Why bother at all?

This question follows Rush and Matsuo’s paper, Does Law School Curriculum Affect Bar Examination Passage? An Empirical Analysis of the Factors Which Were Related to Bar Examination Passage between 2001 and 2006 at a Midwestern Law School.  With a title like this, who could help but rush to read it?  The problem, you see, is that bar exam passage has become a critical sticking point for schools that want to maintain their prominence in the Tier system.

What’s the Tier system?  Don’t feel bad.  I had no clue what this was about either, until David Lat at Above The Law rubbed my nose in it with his posts explaining that anyone who doesn’t go to a Tier 1 law school is destined to be a janitor somewhere.  I am now ashamed of my legal education.  Who knew?

But getting back to our point, apparently law schools have learned that their curriculum isn’t doing much to get their graduates through the bar exam, so they have resorted to making “marginal” students take courses directly related to passing the bar.  And it’s not helping.  The question is thus begged, now what?

While Dave first notes that the study ignores a minor detail, that many law professors aren’t members of the bar in the state where their school is situated, and can teach to a test that they’ve never taken (or haven’t taken in 30 years?), he nonetheless asks what courses, if not bar courses, should students take?

The first response comes from his fellow faculty members, all warm and fuzzy: “select courses that are challenging and intrinsically interesting.”  But even Dave knows what a load of crap that is, and questions its usefulness.  And ultimately, it leads to the big question, “is there a point to law school beyond sorting students?”

In the spirit of trying to be helpful wherever possible, I feel compelled to jump in here.  Yes, there is a point.  Here are my top 10 reasons for keeping law schools:

10.   I suffered through it, so all new lawyers should have to suffer too.

9.     Without law schools, all those law professors would be out of work, and they have families to feed, you know.

8.     Law firms wouldn’t have a clue who to hire at $190,000 per year if there were no Tier rankings.

7.     Men and woman have become famous by “authoring” books that do nothing but reprint decisions written by other people, and no one would know them without law schools forcing kids to buy their books.

6.     Courts would be left to their own devices without the insight provided by law review articles explaining how the law applies to real people.

5.     Generations of law school alumni have given their hard earned dollars to get their names inscribed on various items of furniture, which will be wasted without law schools.

4.     Where else would you get to see future judges vomiting their brains out during a party?

3.     Former Assistant United States Attorneys need a place to call home when they can’t get a job at Biglaw.

2.     Where else could David Boise get an honorary doctorate?

And the number 1 reason to keep law schools:

To teach men and women how to be lawyers.

No need to thank me for the answer, Dave.  I consider it a duty.

Cops Gone Wild – When Cop Writes Cop

Hat tip to Robert Guest for turning me on to this great website, copswritingcops.com.  We all know that one of the perks of being a law enforcement officer (referred to as a LEO over at cops) is that neither you, your wife or kids, get a ticket, right?  Well, apparently that’s not always the case.  There are some LEOs who don’t respect the brotherhood’s mandate of professional courtesy.

So what happens when one cop “writes” another cop?  They get nominated for “Dick of the Month!”  Forgive my potty-mouth writing, but that’s what they call it.  And since I’m going to be using actual law enforcement lingo in this post, all sensitive readers who wish to avoid such references should cover their eyes immediately.

There is a surprisingly long list here of complaints about one LEO writing another, providing an extraordinary insight into the working of the cop mind.  Here’s a random cop post:

I would like to nominate Officer Mike Buzan from Crete,IL as a “DICK.”  Recently Ofc Buzan wrote a Lansing,IL police officer.  And of course this was after a rookie officer (Taylor) arrested a Lansing Police Officer’s wife on a suspended license (Emissions)-And he has been talked to, and advised that we do not arrest or write cops or their wives. 
Heres the situation:  The Ofc. from Lansing was riding his motorcycle.  He “popped” a wheely and landed up dumping his bike and crashing.  Not the smartest thing to do, but no property damage and no one injured; including the Lansing Officer.  The situation could of been resolved with a simple 10-50 report.  But No, Officer Buzan who has been a police officer for about 18 years decides the Lansing Officer will get not one ticket, but TWO tickets.  Officer Buzan is well known (not well liked) at The Crete P.D. as being someone who thinks he should “police” the police. 

Just a couple of months ago he decided he should tattle on two new officers for “going out of their patrol zones.”  What were these two officer’s crimes?  They had lunch with a new recruit who was in town for the weekend, and about to graduate the academy.  He also likes to report officers who might have an expired license plate or any other minor policy violation he sticks his nose into.  This is the tip of the iceberg, but make no mistakes this guy would write his own mother.

As you can see, when cops like Mike Buzan go bad, they go real bad.  This Buzan is a bad seed.  He does his job.  He expects other cops to do their job.  He takes his oath seriously.  He stays on the job even when it would be more fun to party with other cops.  Bad to the bone.  B’B’B’B’B’B’B’Bad. 

But if you think hell hath no fury like a cop written, see what they have to say when they win “Dick of the Month”

T. Rossi, Palisades Police

Rebut –
Listen I give all cops breaks no matter what town or state they are from. I don’t know why you make a mockery out of cops who do the right thing. I have been trying to locate the ass—e from NYC who wrote this shi- about me. I feel that this whole thing is bull—t and that you are putting good reputations to shi-. I am for getting shit bags off the streets and not cops and family members. The cop who wrote in that said I gave his wife a ticket is bullshi-. My guess is that he is trying to ride the bandwagon or she never gave me the card until after the ticket was written. And we know at that point its too late. The incident that happened nearly 3 years ago was all bull. I gave that guy numerous options to leave his car on the side of the road. He elected to call me an asshole and said that ” The cops up here are Fuc–d up”. That is the story if you really want it. I was trying to not tow the guys car and show him professional courtesy and he calls me an asshole for doing my job. Not only that but you post me on the website as being a prick. As far as cops who know me and who get pulled over by me know they will continue to get breaks and professional courtesy as I expect the same for my family. But as far as Mr. “Yada Yada” who posted all of this bullshit he is in my book the asshole of the year. I believe that is his last name but I have it written down somewhere.

Scorching, eh?  Curious that LEO Rossi avoids writing in full certain curse words, but has no issue about “getting shit bags off the street and not cops and family members.”  The initial reference, in case you haven’t guessed yet, would be non-LEOs who don’t happen to have a cop in their immediate family.  They, by definition, are presumptively bad people, while Officer Rossi protests his Award by proclaiming his goodness, “I give all cops breaks!”  Bravo, Officer Rossi.  It’s good to know that the lives of the good people who believe that you are on the job to protect and serve come in a distant second to your protecting the brotherhood from the ravages of obeying the law.

I must admit, it’s quite amusing to read cops lambasting, and defending, one another for committing offenses in the first place, and then compounding it by proclaiming how they ignore their duty.  Not that anyone will be surprised or shocked by this revelation of one of the worst kept secrets in law enforcement, but that it’s so brazenly discussed and cops are so, well, proud of themselves for it.  And so, for those of us not sufficiently fortunate to enjoy membership in the brotherhood of those entitled to break the law with impunity, you can always buy those FOP license plate badges on eBay.  After all, if it’s good for cops, it’s good for America.

Girls Gone Wild Wants ME?

This has probably happened to other blawgers, but it’s a first for me.  Yesterday, out of the blue, I received an email from some guy named Brian about a fellow named Joe Francis, the owner of something called Girls Gone Wild.  GGW is apparently some sort of soft-core porn with college girls (or thereabouts, as it turns out).

This is the email:

Scott,

Have you ever heard of a man imprisoned indefinitely over his negotiating tactics in a civil arbitration?

That’s exactly what’s happened to Joe Francis of “Girls Gone Wild” fame. Truly, it is “Justice Gone Wild.” I’d like to point you to the facts of this case, which has had Joe Francis incarcerated since April.

My hope is that an influential law blogger or two will write something about it. There will be some major activity in the case in a couple of weeks.

Joe and his advisers have started www.meetjoefrancis.com to advocate for justice in his case. A summary of the facts is also below.

Thanks for reading.


Following this email was a lengthy description of the Joe Francis debacle, obviously prepared by some PR person desperate to get his meal ticket back.  I read the whole magillah, and there were enough holes in this story to drive a fleet of Mack trucks through.  But of course, it wasn’t prepared by a lawyer and so full of flagrant spin and self-serving rationalizations that it was impossible to get it past the sniff test.

Mind you, this doesn’t mean that Joe Francis, whatever his true situation might be, is not unjustly imprisoned.  He may well be (or maybe not), but one couldn’t tell from this flagrant attempt at spin.

So I had to figure out what to do about this.  While it’s a great thing when someone tips you off to an interesting case, this wasn’t a tip.  This was an overt solicitation to use my blawg in furtherance of this Brian’s scheme.  It’s like using a friendly reporter to put out a scam story.  Was Simple Justice for sale (even if they weren’t offering payment)?

So I wrote Brian back that while I planned to post about this, it probably wasn’t what he had in mind.  I informed him first that I’m a lawyer before blawger, and if he wants my help to advocate for his client, then he is free to retain me.  But that my blawg was not a free substitute for my professional services.  I then told Brian my thoughts about the efficacy of his recital of events, exactly as I did above. 

The more I thought about Brian’s email, the angrier I became.  Is the blawgosphere just another place for paid PR spinmeister wannabes to try to flatter blawgers into doing their dirty work?  Note the “influential law blogger” part of the email; a bit of an appeal to ego?  There was nothing legit about this guy’s approach, and while one could view his email as a good faith effort to get interest in the Joe Francis case in the blawgosphere, his PR spin approach made the whole deal stink.

So what did Brian have to say about my response?

You were written as a blogger, not as counsel. If your blog is simply a business generating tool for your practice, that’s great. But it doesn’t go out of its way to disclose that.

[Wow, did you miss the point on this one]

Joe Francis is well represented by Roy Black, as a casual web search will show. As defense counsel, you know that the appropriate defense of a client includes all legal and productive methods, in and outside the courtroom.

[I should have researched your request?  As for appropriate defense, that’s for the lawyer, not the flak, to decide] 

We are asking simply that people do their own investigation, sort out the facts, and make their own decision. The document you read is an outline of the facts, not a legal brief. And yes, it was done by a PR person.  

[Funny, that’s not what you asked me in the first email]

I trust that further research will help clarify your thinking on this.

[Probably, but why would I spend my time researching so that I can pimp for you?]

Well, I guess he only wants to buy my blawging services and not my legal services?  Who can blame him, with Roy Black as counsel and blawgs as free publicity, available for the asking.  It was my mistake for not thoroughly researching the facts behind an unsolicited email from a flak who seeks to use my blawg to hype his client.  It’s amazing how a fellow can come with hat in hand for free “advocacy” blawg services, and end up trying to win friends by being offensive.  C’est la vie.

I really don’t know if Joe Francis has been railroaded.  I don’t care for Girls Gone Wild, to tell you the truth.  I really hate people who try to blow smoke up my butt and then insult me for noticing.  That doesn’t mean I won’t post later about Joe Francis and end up his biggest supporter.  But not today.

Silent Submission Under Miranda

A fascinating Miranda decision via Volokh Conspiracy by way of Appellate Law & Practice, from the First Circuit Court of Appeals in United States v. Thogsophaporn.

Facts: Defendant is taken into custody and read his rights. The defendant is asked to waive his rights but he declines. An investigator then sits down in the small interview room with the defendant in silence for five minutes, three to five feet away from him, until the defendant asks for some water. The investigator brings it to him, and then the defendant asks what is going on. The investigator responds that the defendant knows what is going on, and the defendant asks if the police want to talk about him ratting on a cocaine dealer. The investigator then brings up the fact that his colleagues want to talk to him, and the defendant then agrees to talk and waives his rights and confesses.

So does it come in?  In the First Circuit, silence is golden.  At least for the prosecution.  The Court held that the police fastidiously honored the defendant’s right of silence, and gave him silence in return.  Since the defendant, not the police, reinitiated communication, he could not hide behind Miranda.

To a lot of folks, this would seem to be police work at its finest.  To others, this would be substituting brute psychological force for the good old rubber hose.  Orin Kerr says that this decision set his BS detector off in a big way, but others questioned whether any rule could be crafted to do away with subtle psychological pressure.  The latter point, however, reminds one of the “Christian burial speech” case, which didn’t let the desire for a bright line test get in the way of prohibiting what was clearly on the wrong side of the line.

The bottom line for practitioners is that defendants must be told to be silent, no matter how painful it may be to do or how awkward the situation feels.  Of course, we know that few can actually follow instructions to begin with, and fewer still don’t try to out-think both the cops and their lawyers by mouthing something that seems brilliant to them at the moment but will later serve to cut them off at the knees on trial.  And so we keep pounding it home:  Remain silent.  No matter what.  Silent.  Silent.  Silent.  And hope for the best.

Rethinking Marijuana Today

Robert Guest at I Was The State posts that marijuana arrests, according to FBI statistics have reached an all-time high (forgive the pun).  This will not be a post about legalization of marijuana, so if that’s what you want to read, you can stop here.

George Bush toked some, as did Barak Obama and Newt Gingrich.  It was illegal then, and it’s illegal now.  The difference between these guys and 826,000 other people is that they weren’t arrested for it last year.  Had they been arrested, it’s unlikely that they would be where they are now. 

We need to separate the fact that marijuana is a despised drug, noting that it is perceived as being so heinous that even medical use had been met with rejection, with the stark reality that almost everyone alive today under 60 and over 16 years of age has tried it.  If we are to exclude people from running for office, or holding a job, or enjoying the multitude of opportunities that our nation has to offer, because they have smoked marijuana, we’re going to have very few people left.

Consider, for a second, who in the relevant age group hasn’t given marijuana a test drive.  My sense is that these are people so far out of the mainstream of society that they couldn’t possibly relate to the regular people.  No doubt there will be some (many?) to dispute this, and tell how they have never touched the stuff and how they are indeed mainstream and proud of it.  But the claim is only as good as the source, and anyone who has managed to live their life without any whiff of marijuana is unlikely to see themselves as others would.

America is viewed by Europeans as being an immature society, full of repression and child-like notions of morality.  America, on the other hand, views the Europeans as jaded and declining from moral decay.  But they have a point when it comes to our expectations of the purity of public figures and role models.  Much of America demands that our politicians be better than they are, be the person they wish they could be but never will. 

We attribute a moral virtue to ourselves that is undeserved under the theory that if we did something bad and no one knows about it, it never happened.  We let our mind play a convenient trick, washing away our sins so that we can hold ourselves out as paragons to others.  As somebody once said, “let he who is without sin cast the first stone.”  Point well taken.

Should the winner and the loser in the game of life be determined by the very good fortune of not getting caught?  Should judges who sit on high pass judgment on those who have done no different than they themselves did when surrounded by friends who could keep a secret?  We need to come to grips with this moral hypocrisy.  As we learn daily, our ever-increasing  malum prohibitum obsession with order has brought the most upright into the same club as the most downlow.  We now have a crime for everyone, and while many are well deserved, many more simply reflect life-style choices that are pervasive yet forbidden.

If we cannot get beyond our Puritan past to a point where we can do wrong and not be tainted forever, there will be few of us around who can lay honest claim to virtue, and those who can will then be tainted by their odd failure to have experienced the normal culture shared by the rest of America.  We really need to grow up about this.  With 826,0000 Americans were arrested for marijuana last year, we’re just taking too many people off the table for no good reason.

When Your Reach Exceeds Your Grasp

An email came across my desk from a lawyer I don’t know saying that he scored a big case and, after requesting discovery, received a truckload of wiretap applications, extensions and returns.  He asked if anybody could give him a primer in wiretap motions.  He knew when he took the case that there were wires involved, but hadn’t given it any thought until they landed on his desk.  What should he do now, since he’s never had a wire case before.

Oh my God.  Welcome to amateur hour at the Courthouse. 

This is a recurring theme in criminal defense.  Less experienced lawyers need to learn sometime about the more complex areas of criminal law, such as wiretaps, but not this way.  The email told me a few things about this fellow.  First, he lacked an experienced mentor to help him navigate through new areas and issues.  Whether this was because of physical isolation or unlikability, I don’t know, but he had no one to turn to for help.  Second, he didn’t hesitate to undertake a responsibility to zealously defend a client in a case that he was not yet capable of handling. 

A distant third point is that he probably took a fee for the case that was a tenth of what it would have been for a lawyer experienced in lengthy wire cases, since he lacked any clue about what was involved and the excruciating amount of detail work involved in years worth of wires, applications, etc.  The impact of this is seen a little down the road, when the inexperienced lawyer is not only unable to deal with the case in hand, but feels that unhappiness that comes with the epiphany that he is looking at a ton of work and has been grossly underpaid (in his mind).  Of course, if he had understood the nature of the work involved, he would have charged significantly more but still wouldn’t be competent to do the work.

Every time this situation arises, I shake my head.  It’s not the client’s fault for picking the wrong lawyer, though I suspect that some will disagree with my view.  Clients seldom have a way to distinguish legal skill levels, and select a lawyer on either price or likability, but not competency.  The fault lies on the other side of the equation, the lawyer.  She knows what she knows, and what she doesn’t know.  She has the ability to tell the client that a particular case is outside her scope of knowledge and experience.  She can tell the client that she may not be the right lawyer for the case, or at the least that she’s never done a particular type of case before and she’ll be going to school on this one.

More experienced lawyers tend to demonstrate a greater willingness to let a case go if it’s not right for them.  This is likely because of two things, their experience in taking on cases that, for whatever reason, don’t blend well with their practice and end up being unpleasant, unsuccessful or unproductive cases.  If the experienced lawyer doesn’t like doing mountains of paperwork, they will pass on an appeal or a wire case, for example.

The experienced lawyer also has a greater selection of cases to chose from, so that he doesn’t need to take on every case that comes through his door.  While the volume and quality of work today isn’t what it used to be for private lawyers, they still have enough to do to turn away cases that aren’t right.  I see less experienced lawyers (and high volume lawyers) take every case, and I mean EVERY case, that comes in, regardless of anything.  These are the ones who won’t let a client with a grand in his pocket walk out the door in a murder case.  This is a train wreck waiting to happen.

And so, the email goes out asking for help.  While some experienced lawyers will try to offer advice in the belief that by doing so they are helping a defendant who would otherwise crash and burn with this inexperienced lawyer, it doesn’t help.  A lawyer can’t gain sufficient expertise by a 5 sentence email to render effective assistance of counsel.  They are doing no one a favor, but facilitating incompetence.  There is only one good answer to an email like this:  Give your client his money back and send him to a lawyer capable of handling his case.  Of course, that email would do no good either, because it’s just not going to happen.

So here comes the admonition.  If you’re not yet ready for prime time, and you have no experienced lawyer ready, willing and able to partner up with you to guide you through the rocky shoals, then you can’t take the case.  Don’t let your reach exceed your grasp.

Voir Dire Aftermath

As any reader of Simple Justice knows, I am a huge fan of Anne Reeds Deliberations.  While not quite a student of voir dire, no trial lawyer can ignore this critical phase of a trial.  Indeed, cruising the practical lawgosphere, one sees many posts about voir dire, what to look for, how to get there and what it all means.

But I have a secret question.  How has it all worked out for you?  Despite my best efforts at getting potential jurors to open up, to tell me what they think and to give me a chance to see what they really think about things, I still don’t believe that I have usually managed to achieve very much in voir dire.  At the end of the day, I don’t really know my sitting jurors well enough to say that I have selected a fair panel.

Over the years, I’ve tried the different routes.  I’ve done questionnaires where allowed.  I’ve used a jury consultant, which was one of the most expensive mistakes I’ve ever made.  I’ve asked open-ended questions, and closed.  I’ve been as charming as I can muster to engage the panelists and try to make them want to talk to me.  After all of this, I’ve learned little.

Judges rarely seem to take voir dire seriously, or want to let me take it seriously.  They are almost always satisfied when they can get a juror to mouth the words that he or she “can be fair.”  “Well, there you go,” they tell me.  “The guy says he can be fair, what more do you want?”

We spend most of our time on the more vocal panelists.  At least we get some reaction and it saves us from standing up there doing all the talking, while the jury panel looks at us without muttering a word.  They gaze without blinking, without speaking, and wait out there time.  Some smile at us, as if they know better than to give us the wink but want us to know something.  What is the message?  Are they for us, or are they trying to sucker us in so that they can slam dunk the defense?  I’m never quite sure.

Defendants often get gut feelings about jurors, but if you question them as to why, it usually turns out to be some simplistic analysis based on objective information.  If the panelist has a friend who’s a cop, they want the guy off.  When you tell them that people who are close to cops almost always know that cops lie on the stand all the time (and brag about it to their friends), the defendant suddenly changes his mind and loves the juror.  But then you tell them that there’s no guarantee that this is what’s going on in the juror’s mind, and they want him off again. 

The jury consultant route is very tempting to a defendant.  They love the idea that there’s someone out there who has a magic way to read the minds of jurors and tell him exactly who to pick and who to bump.  It’s not cheap to get a person to sit at the defense table with a bunch of letters after their name, but if they can topload the jury with friendlies, it’s worth it.  In fact, defendant’s often think the jury consultant fee is a better bet than the legal fee, since criminal defense lawyers offer no guarantees and certainly no magic bullets.  But when the trial is over and things didn’t work out exactly as expected, the jury consultant points at the lawyer and says, “Hey, I can only do so much.” 

Having spent a lot of time with psychs of either persuasion, I’m less than impressed with their insight.  They can be wackier than anyone else in the room, and bizarrely secure in their belief that they understand other people based on a few words and a couple of “deep” questions.  It seems closer to voodoo than science, and it disturbs me that they suggest that they have an ability that belongs only Madame Zuwonga, the Mind Reader.

From my seat at the table, I believe that the best I am able to accomplish is to get the worst of the worst off the panel.  We root out the more overtly biased, usually because they tell us who they are.  But the quiet ones fall under the radar.  It seems like everyone has experience with police these days, and everyone knows someone who has been a criminal defendant or is sitting in a prison cell. 

Is the upper east side banker a limousine liberal or a Bush conservative?  Will one more question get me the answer, or annoy the entire panel and make them think I’m an arrogant jerk, treating them like pathetic children?  And when will the judge get bored and jump in to try and embarrass me so that I’ll sit down and let her move the case to trial?

And so I read as much as I can about voir dire, hoping to learn something that will make me more capable of selecting jurors who will be truly open to the idea that my client may not be guilty, that the police officer on the stand may not be telling the exact truth and that a not guilty verdict will not bring about the ruin of society.  I believe we keep reading and learning about voir dire because we want desperately to be more effective, but secretly fear that for all our efforts, we really accomplish very little.  Is this just me?

Mukasey: The Symptom or Disease?

The front page of today’s New York Times has a piece about Michael Mukasey’s callous treatment of Muslims held as “material witnesses” shortly after 9/11.  Although you don’t find out about it until the end of the story, the source of the secret transcript of Osama Awadallah’s treatment in the bucolic Manhattan federal court is a New York criminal defense lawyer, Jesse Berman.  Not for nothing, Jesse is one of those great lawyers who somehow didn’t find his name in the Super Lawyers advertisement.

The transcripts shows Judge Mukasey as wholly insensitive to the rights of this “witness” before him, acquitted five years later of lying to a grand jury about knowing one of the 9/11 hijackers.  Indeed, the Judge looks insensitive.  The part that struck me was

Before the hearing, Mr. Awadallah told his lawyer that he had been beaten in the federal detention center in Manhattan, producing bruises that were hidden beneath his orange prison jumpsuit. But when his lawyer told this to Judge Mukasey, the judge seemed little concerned.


“As far as the claim that he was beaten, I will tell you that he looks fine to me,” said Judge Mukasey.


That last line by Judge Mukasey just cuts me to the bone.  I think of all the times that federal judges responded in this way to what they perceived as yet another whiny complaint by a defendant that they got a boo boo because some federal agent smacked them around a bit.  I’m sure other parts of this story will stick out to other people, but this is the one that gets me.

Do I write about this story to condemn Judge Mukasey?  No, I’m afraid I don’t.  While this is hardly a compliment to Judge Mukasey’s sensitivity as a human being to the suffering inflicted on others, I see this attitude as systemic. 

When I first wrote about Judge Mukasey being the nominee for Attorney General, a few days before President Bush announced it to the world (that’s right; as my lovely and talented daughter often says, I know things), I included this phrase:  Third, he was definite federal judge material, meant in that slightly sarcastic yet pejorative sense. 

My cryptic reference now comes back to haunt me.  While there are some notable exceptions, most of the federal bench is warmed by big picture people from Biglaw backgrounds who cop the attitude that such mundane matters as defendant-beatings are beneath their sphere of concern.  Similarly, there is such a strong affinity for Order that their vision of the need for law, the protection of personal freedom, is badly skewed.  In the struggle between order and freedom, order wins every time.  That’s just federal court.

Is Michael Mukasey that rare exception, a Don Quixote tilting at the windmills of federal callousness?  Nope.  He’s a fairly mainstream federal judge.  Unlike John Paul Stevens, who father (described as a Warren Harding Republican) was arrested, tried and convicted of a crime, only to be reversed on appeal, he’s never suffered a personal “misfire” of the legal system that left him with an appreciation of what it’s like to be beaten by agents on your way to court.

Going a little off topic, perhaps the best explanation for his facial insensitivity is that federal courts (and their judges) are a poor choice for such mundane proceedings as criminal prosecutions (or material witness warrants, as a substitute for criminal prosecutions).  This is nuts and bolts work, and just not the type of stuff that most federal judges want to spend their time on.  Can you imagine, for example, Judge Mukasey telling Osama Awadallah to come into his robing room and show him the bruises?  Oddly, I can see Justice Stevens doing that, though not his predecessor, William O. Douglas.

While this affair certainly doesn’t elevate Judge Mukasey as a champion of civil liberties or a doubter of the serious consequences of the Government’s abuse of its might, I find it hard to tar and feather him for it either.  Again, did you expect President George W. Bush to go begging to Ramsey Clark?  Then you hope for the best of the potential universe of candidates, not the one person on the face of the earth who is most perfect to you.  As much as Jesse was absolutely right to bring what happened to Osama Awadallah to this country’s attention, I see it more as an indictment of the general attitude of the federal courts than Judge Mukasey alone.  And it’s a shame that it could happen in America.