Author Archives: SHG

Slow Blawg on a Busy Week

Simple Justice is running a little slower than normal this week because I’m on trial (or “in trial” as Texans feel compelled to say, for some unknown reason).  Without the ability to keep abreast of the news, the decisions, the debates and Britney Spears’ learning the ropes of motherhood, we will not have the number or breadth of posts this week that one can usually find here. 

The trial should be over Friday (I hope) and then I can turn my attention back to the important work of blawging.  Stay tuned.

Ladies and Gentlemen of the Jury, I’m a Tier 1 Grad

The obsession at Above The Law with this whole Tier thing about law schools at first seems a bit funny, but as I’ve followed it, most notably the attitudes reflected in the comments by Tier ! law students and graduates, it’s become clear that this is a serious disease.

For the most part, the blawg is focused on what top law firms pay to their new associates, not to mention their bonuses and perks.  It also does its’ best to poke fun at the foibles of these same firms, including the drama inside the lives of the self-important.

Yesterday, David Lat (the primary enabler of this Tier elitism and former AUSA) posted Non-Top-Tier Lawyer of the Day. a New York criminal defense lawyer named Ben Bronfman.  This is part of Lat’s non-Top-Tier week (which has now gone on for two weeks).  The comments, by the same Tier 1 students who hungrily seek proof of their existence, was that Ben’s success proves the point: He’s the exception of being successful coming from a Tier 4 law school.

In the course of puffing their self-importance, these children actually post about how any student attending a Tier 3 or 4 law school is a blithering idiot, barely worthy of living no less practicing law.  They joke about how the “good” firms don’t interview at the law schools, and the only hope of employment is with the local sanitation company, assuming their back is stronger than their mind.

Are we breeding a group of banal pseudo-elitists who actually believe that their Tier 1 school makes them exceptional?  Are the schools feeding this delusion, or is it just goofy kids with low self-esteem who need to sound off at Lat’s website because they can’t find any other place where they feel important?  In the beginning, I thought (hoped?) that this phenomenon was a inside joke, thinking that these students couldn’t possibly be serious.  I’ve come to the conclusion that they are serious, as is Lat, that they believe they are some better breed by virtue of their law school.  And so, it’s time for a little chat about it.

Dear Tier 1 students, I am sure that your mothers and fathers are very proud of you, and that you worked hard to achieve admission and/or graduation from your law school.  But about a week after you graduate, no one will give a damn what school you went to.  Except perhaps you and your mommy.

Ben Bronfman is a great trial lawyer because he is a great trial lawyer, not because of his law school.  And he’s hardly the exception to the rule.  There is no trial lawyer that I know of who will stand up before the jury and announce, I went to a Tier 1 law school.  Wanna know why?  Because no one cares.

Once you’re past this juvenile absorption with school, you have a whole life and career ahead of you.  Either you produce or you don’t.  When you stand before a jury, you don’t get extra points because of your school tie.  Chances are the judge didn’t go to a Tier 1 school.  Chances are your adversary didn’t either.  And you can bet that the jury doesn’t even know what a Tier 1 law school is.  No one will care, and whatever comfort you take from your important law school will immediately fade when you mumble your first inept question on cross-examination.

When I gave testimony before a New York Congressional committee a few years ago about public confidence in judicial elections, one comment I made was the in consequences of candidate bios.  “Will people vote for a judge because he went to Harvard?” I asked.  The sitting judges on the committee laughed and laughed.  “He’d do better around here,” one responded, “if he went to Fordham.”  That was as true as it gets. 

To the Biglaw firms at your first interview, the Tier ranking may be all-important.  But that’s where it ends.  And the worst news is, chances are you, little Tier 1 law school children, will never make equity partner and will be out on the street in 5 years begging some Tier 3 to let you have some desk space in his office.  You see, after law school, the lower Tier law students go out and become lawyers, while you Tier 1 kids are busy playing clerks in the library or hiding behind the reflected glow of judicial clerkships.  They are honing the skills while you are pretending you have some.  They are grooming their clients while you are praying to meet one.

It actually happened to me at my first hearing, before an Administrative Law Judge in New York City.  My adversary announced at one point, referring to me, that “obviously my learned opponent did not have the benefit of being on Harvard Law Review…”  After I had my say, where I conceded that I didn’t attend Harvard, but nonetheless expected that the law that applied to the case was the same regardless of school attended, the ALJ proceeded to rip my adversary’s throat out.  After the hearing was over, the ALJ told me that he went to the same law school as me.  There’s a lesson here for the self-important.  Do you get it?

So while all you Tier 1 students should be very proud of yourselves, get over it.  You are not a superior clan, just a bunch of kids trying to parlay your moment in the sun into a desperate attempt to prove that you are entitled to a wonderful and fruitful life.  You are not necessarily going to be a better lawyer, nor even a happier lawyer.  And the Tier 3 and 4 students are not a step shy of drooling morons, hoping to land a position shining your shoes.  Nor is that insular Biglaw world going to prove to be your Mecca.  A few will survive there, and Biglaw is often the worse for its lack of great lawyers because of its focus on Tier 3 and 4 students.  But they go with the odds, knowing that they will miss many who they would be well-advised to consider.

Get over it.  Whether or not you ever become a real lawyer is up to you, no matter what law school you attend.  It’s a brief moment in time, and nothing more.  When you stand before that jury, and announce that you’re a Tier 1 law grad, there will be silence followed by a laugh in the room.  The Tier 1 ship will have left the port, and you’re now going to have to prove yourself as a lawyer.

Betsy Gotbaum’s Daughter in Law Dies in Custody. How?

The news broke yesterday that NYC Public Advocate Betsy Gotbaum’s daughter in law, Carol Ann Gotbaum, died in a Phoenix airport holding cell, where she was left alone in handcuffs.

According to what’s know at the moment, police believe she may have strangled herself.

How is it possible that this could happen?  She was “disruptive” in an airport and ended up dead.  Death is not the punishment for being disruptive.  Death is not the outcome of being taken into custody.  And why was she cuffed inside a cell anyway?

A lot of questions.  Whether we ever understand how this happened (as opposed to getting a version that makes sense, but never truly answers anything) has yet to be seen.  But this isn’t supposed to happen. 

Being taken into custody should not mean that someone ends up dead. 

DNA Bringing Reforms, and Some Cops Just Hate It

The New York Times reports that all but 8 states give inmates some degree of DNA access to prove innocence.  This, according to Peter Neufeld of the Innocence Project, reflects the greatest reform in criminal justice in the last 40 years. 

It’s not just DNA, however.  It’s changes in eyewitness identification procedures, recording of statements and confessions, all of the “hard” evidence that has put hundreds of thousands of defendants in prison for many years.  But it comes from the 207 innocent defendants who were exonerated because of DNA.  Without DNA, they would be guilty, guilty, guilty, and the system would go on with business as usual.

So are the police happy to know that they are no longer arresting innocent people?  Not exactly.


“Simply put, these two bills create loopholes for defendants to get an edge in court on technicalities,” according to a letter from the sheriffs’ organization to the California Commission on the Fair Administration of Justice. The association also opposed a state bill that would create guidelines for suspect lineups.


There’s the tension.  To some, innocence is a technicality.  And all the changes add burdens to the job.  When laws require cops to do things in specific ways, whether sequential line-ups, or recording confessions, they’re viewed as traps for the unwary cop to blow a solid bust.  In other words, it’s all about the cop, not the innocent person.

“I’m not fond of legislation,” said Lieutenant Patenaude, the Massachusetts police commander. “I’ve been asked to review bills in several states, and I haven’t seen one that mirrors the best practices that we’ve put out here. I’d like to see police agencies mold the procedures instead of legislatures or courts.”


After all, who knows better what cops can do than cops, right?  Again, it’s all about the cop. 

How big a problem is this?  Consider:


In a 2005 study, a University of Michigan Law School professor, Samuel R. Gross, estimated that 340 prisoners sentenced from 1989 to 2003 had been exonerated. Of those, 205 were convicted of murder and 121 of rape. Half of the wrongful murder convictions and 88 percent of the wrongful rape convictions included false eyewitness identification, the study found.



Note that this is about DNA, and the crimes of murder and rape.  The problem is that DNA evidence doesn’t impact a whole bunch of crimes, leaving the vast majority a wasteland where the same eyewitness ID evidence that doesn’t work too well in murder and rape to be the primary evidence for putting defendants away.  If eyewitness IDs are unreliable, then they are unreliable when DNA is unavailable.  

This means that literally tens of thousands of innocent people are likely sitting in cells across the country based on faulty eyewitness IDs and no DNA to save them.  Houston, we’ve got a problem.  

As the article points out, not all police are antagonistic toward reform, and appreciate that the current system is less than adequate to assure that innocent people aren’t being convicted on bad evidence.  But those who view these reforms as “technicalities” rather than tools to separate the innocent from the guilty, even if the cops who arrest them think otherwise, are going to make implementation rough going.

If the police aren’t on board with this whole “not convicting the innocent” thing, then it’s going to troubling to implement and change the practice on the street.  Cops are known to testify that they acts in a textbook fashion when, in fact, they did things the way they always have.  They will make excuses about whey the confession wasn’t recorded, or what happened in the sequential line-up, or why DNA couldn’t be collected.  It’s not that cops are still testilying.  But a little fudging here and there, well, gets the job done.

The idea that legislative bodies are coming to grips with their end of the responsibility of reforming criminal justice is an important thing, particularly after two generations of creating new crimes and more inflexible penalties.  If they can get the foot soldiers in the war on crime to go along with it, then maybe we’ll have something.  It seems the only time they really care is when it’s one of their own.  Of course, then, innocence doesn’t matter much to them either.
 

Another First Monday in October

As expected, the New York Times has an editorial about what tomorrow, the opening of the new Supreme Court session, will bring.  Naturally, they’ve got the Court all pegged into the inevitable three “wings”, the liberals, the conservatives and Justice Kennedy.  With all due respect to the Sulzberger wing, I disagree.

First, there is no liberal wing.  When Justice John Paul Stevens is considered the arch-liberal on the court (with apologies to Ruth Bader Ginsberg), you’ve got to seriously consider how one defines liberal.  This wing would have been the conservative wing 50 years ago, deemed unfeeling and uncompassionate in its views toward the accused, blacks, women and civil rights in general.  They are only liberal in comparison, not in ideology.

And there’s no conservative wing.  There is Justice Antonin Scalia, the radical thinker, and a few others guys who hang out with him.  It must be nice to have four votes on the Supreme Court, and you have got to give the guy credit for having philosophically dwarfed the two newest members.  As for Justice Clarence Thomas, fuhgeddaboutit.  If you have nothing nice to say. . .

And poor Justice Kennedy, the swing vote, has a target painted across his forehead.  While being the swing vote brings enormous power, it also carries terrible pressures.  I can see the other 7 justices bringing him brownies each morning to curry the day’s favor.  Of course, no one should go through life without a philosophical anchor, even if you will never want for munchies.

Much to the chagrin of my brethren and sistren, Nino Scalia has invariably proven to be the key to the future.  Not because he commands the gang of four, but because his vision is so radical that it brings the law full circle.  If anyone on the Supreme Court has the ability to create consensus as to the big picture, it has to be Justice Scalia.  If the point can be argued to bring it within his framework, then there’s hope.

And the big picture is the one that’s ben a problem.  The Supreme Court used to issue decisions in cases whose names meant something.  Gideon.  Miranda. Brown v. Board of Education (and yes, Plessy v. Ferguson).  These are names that every school child knows.  These embody ideals that are big.  They are clear and unwavering statements of American law.

Let’s see what we have gotten out of the Supreme Court lately.  Blakely? Booker? Crawford?  Hell, they can’t even get a single circuit court to just follow them without griping. 

Some would argue that the problem is the 5-4 division that comes out on all the really interesting decisions, making the “strength” of the ruling suspect and suggesting that the definition of “constitutionality” will change every time a new justice comes on board.  Do you think that Chief Justice Roberts, who will be with us for the next 70 to 80 years, really meant it when he said he was a big fan of precedent?

While the lack of a cohesive court certainly doesn’t help matters, I don’t think that’s their biggest problem.  For me, the problem is lack of perceived clarity.  Far too much time is spent on the rationale, and far too little on the rule.  Since the Supreme Court has no one to answer to (except a few southern preachers), it really doesn’t need to spend 38 pages explaining the why of its decision, and thus giving every legal scholar and appellate court judge an opportunity to find one word that, in their learned opinion, changes everything about the holding. 

Let’s face it, the real game for Supreme Court watchers is how to undo the holding.  What word can they parse that will allow the exception to swallow, muddy, cloud or obfuscate the rule? 

So here’s my advice for a fruitful and successful Supreme Court term.  Starting tomorrow, all arguments must be couched in terms of original intent.  No more of that nonsensical outcome-oriented stuff or the good of society, or the warm and fuzzy “right and wrong” approach.  Bearing in mind that George Washington had no desire for presidential fiat (other than Jay’s Treaty, which favors the avoidance of war), this shouldn’t be too hard to do.  Bone up on your history and find some Jefferson quote that the commerce clause shouldn’t apply to French defendants.  Whatever.

Second, every oral argument must include a Johnny Cochran moment, where the entire point is wrapped up in a single sentence, preferably one that rhymes.  “If the witness ain’t there, then he can’t get the chair.”  This will enable the justices to latch onto something to put into their decision and clarify the rule.  And all decisions hereinafter should include the sentence, “If the Circuits disagree, then they can all bite me!”  That should make it clear.  And finally, no more wiggle words in Supreme Court decisions.  Even if it means that Justice Kennedy won’t go along.  People, if you’re not going to say something, then what’s the point?

Now go out and do some justice.  We could sure use some.

Arbitration Gets a Bad Rap

A report by Public Citizen comes front and center in Legal Blog Watch, skewering credit card mandatory arbitration though the National Arbitration Forum.  Called “The Arbitration Trap,” it tells of how this purportedly neutral arbiter is really a captive of the credit card issuer.  The allegations include:


  • In more than 19,000 cases involving NAF arbitrators, 94.7 percent were decided in favor of the credit-card company.
  • The decision to file for arbitration is made by the company, not the consumer, in 99.6 percent of cases.
  • A small group of just 28 arbitrators handled nine out of every 10 NAF cases in California, ruling for the credit-card company 95 percent of the time.
  • A Harvard law professor was blackballed as an arbitrator after she awarded a consumer $48,000.

This is a disgrace, whether true or not (and I have little doubt that it’s accurate), because of how it drags a concept that is crucial for the public benefit into the mud because of greed. 

Arbitration, in its conceptual form, has the potential to be the saving grace of our civil legal system.  The Courts do not present a truly viable option for the majority of money disputes that arise, whether because of the cost of litigating, including the ubiquitous attorneys fees, or the length of time required to reach conclusion, or the end product of an empty judgment.

Binding neutral arbitration offers an alternative, to the extent that arbitration doesn’t try to emulate the worst of courts.  And it’s failing miserably to fulfill its potential.  Why must this be?

The businesses that offer arbitration services (and you can never forget that they ARE businesses) want that constant stream of revenue that comes from having a captive client.  Here, it’s a credit card company.  It could just as easily be a car company, or a brokerage house,  It doesn’t really matter who the client is.  It matters that they can capture the revenue stream of the arbitration company.  Once that happens, they own it.

If I’m an arbitration company and you give me 90% of my revenue, I need you.  My Mercedes payment is due every month, and I need your business or I’ll have to drive a Yugo.  I don’t want to drive a Yugo. It’s unbecoming of an important person like an Arbitration company owner.  So I will kiss any part of your anatomy you want to keep those checks coming.

You don’t like an arbitrator because she’s fair?  She’s gone.  You don’t want to pay out more than $12 this week?  Done.    We need to let the consumer win one once in a while to give the appearance of fairness, without ever hurting you too badly?  We understand.  Just keep them checks a’rolling in, and we’ll make sure that your happy.

This is a gross subversion of a truly important dispute resolution model.  It’s not that it is fundamentally wrong (which it is), but that it has spoiled the publics’ vision and understanding of a legitimate model and thus denied them of a viable alternative because you, Mr. Arbitration company owner, are a greedy, disgraceful mutt.  You’ve taken something good and made it evil.  You’ve hurt us all for a dollar in your pocket.

But there is a way out.  Courts must refuse to endorse, compel and enforce arbitration clauses and awards that are not demonstrably fair.  They must clean out this rats nest of scum that has taken control of the arbitration field.  The captive arbitrator model must die, as it corrupts. 

Society should not be denied inexpensive, expeditious resolution of claims because the skels who own the show can’t be trusted.  Arbitration should not be forever tainted because the businesses that run them have perverted the model.  This can, and must, be stopped.  The word “arbitration” should be rehabilitated because it is a good thing, no, a great thing, for society.  It can be done. 

The Limits on Plea Options

Of the many frustrating aspects of criminal defense, the client’s pleading eyes when she comes to understand that there are only so many options available.  More often than not, the brain doesn’t register this harsh truth, and the same question is asked at numerous points during the case:  “Can’t you get me a better plea?”

The call came yesterday.  I knew what was coming as soon as I got on the phone.  My client’s voice gave it away, that depressed, moaning sound that told me she was in a bad place and desperately wanted a way out.  This is a sad case, where she’s penned in by the interplay of various laws and her prior conviction.  The charge against her is downright stupid, but we have plenty of stupid applications of law in the criminal courthouse.  Her case is definitely triable, but no slam dunk.  The DA has a tape recording, which makes him feel like Superman.  Put it all together and it’s a recipe for misery for the defendant.

“Can’t you get me a better plea?”  The real question is, “There’s got to be another option here.”  The plea offer in this case is a plea to the top count with the minimum sentence available under law to a predicate felon.  In New York, a person with a prior felony conviction is called a predicate felon, and the law mandates that if convicted, a pred must do State prison time (at least a year upstate).  In her case, the minimum sentence would be 2 to 4 years.  It’s a lot of time for a stupid crime, and her predicate conviction was for a malum prohibitum offense as well.  In other words, she’s never done anything venal or malicious.  Just stupid, a theme in her life. 

But the law is the law.  She would love a sentence of probation (because she tells me she will never be stupid again).  Whether or not this puts off the inevitable is not the issue at the moment, because probation is not available.  As deeply as she wants it, I cannot get it for her.  It is not possible.  If she asks me 10 more times, it still won’t be available. 

An old lady on the street corner told her that somebody else got probation for what she’s accused of, so my client told me I should be able to get it for her too if I’m any good as a lawyer.  If I had a nickel for every time somebody told me the legal advice they received from an old lady on the corner . . .  I’m not bothered by the challenge to my abilities.  It’s the pain talking, and I understand the pain.  But it still doesn’t change anything.

The options crystallize as the case proceeds.  The plea offer is made.  Often, on the eve of trial, the plea offer will change once they know we’re serious about going to trial.  But not always.  Sometimes, when the offer includes the lowest available sentence, there’s no place left to go.  In this particular case, there could be no plea offer that would satisfy my client’s request.  It simply can’t be done.

So the choices are take the plea that you find unacceptable or go to trial.  Option 2, going to trial, presents its own problems.  First, there is the trial penalty.  If you lose, you will invariably receive a higher sentence than is being offered before trial.  While this lacks a certain degree of intellectual integrity (if you only deserve 2 years before trial, why should you deserve 5 years after?), it’s part of a system designed to induce a defendant to conserve prosecutorial and judicial resources by pleading guilty, and rewards a defendant with a lower sentence. 

But many defendant’s aren’t cut out for the fight.  The pressure of the unknown is more than they can take.  Every defendant asks the same question.  Every one.  “What’s going to happen?”  No honest lawyer can answer that question, unless the answer is that the case is so bad that there is no chance of winning.  “What are my chances?”  Another unanswerable question.  Lawyers can’t see into the future.  But clients want to believe that we know all and see all.  They need to believe that we have the answers.  After all, we’re the Lawyer.

Every client wants the option of saying, “never mind, let’s all go home and just forget about this sorry situation.”  It is not an option.  It’s facile to say that the defendant should have thought about that before they committed the crime.  It’s wrong to suggest it when the defendant did not commit the crime.  Either way, it doesn’t matter because it still isn’t an option. 

A defendant’s inability to handle the pressure, combined with massive distrust of the system, pushes most to plead guilty.  Cut your losses rather than fight to death, only to learn that death it is.  If you wonder why there are so many “innocent” people in prison, that’s why.  It’s easy for arm-chair defendants to opine that they would never plead guilty if they were innocent.  When the gun is to your head, the equation changes.  Facing years in jail, especially when you’re innocent, is a real motivator to tell a court that you’re guilty when you’re not.  Given that the system is threatening to put an innocent person in jail for years of their life, the idea of telling a little white lie that you’re guilty to save a few years seems extraordinarily trivial.  Of all the wrong things that are happening, a lie that saves an innocent person years hardly seems like a big deal.

I wish I could bring another option to the table.  In federal court, they could flip and buy their way out by making up stories about other people.  In state court (as with this client), that’s not available.  They don’t want snitches, and she’s got zero to give.  The only thing I can do is try the case to win.  I’m ready to do so, but I doubt she can handle the pressure.  She appears ready to crack.

The only saving grace is that she at least has the option of trial.  Many defendants have lawyers who talk a good game, but couldn’t try a case if their life depended on it.  They have no options at all. 

Addendum:  An astute reader has reminded me that years means “prison”, not “jail”.  I try to avoid the boredom of redundancy by varying the descriptive language in my posts, but my reader is quite correct.  If more than a year, it’s prison, not jail. 

Is Law School Really That Bad These Days?

I’ve been writing about law school issues for a while, both because somebody has to call the law profs on some of their sillier ideas as well as helping the future of the legal profession to understand what they are getting into.  But I have never felt as badly about the future of the law as I did when I read the comments to this post at Concurring Opinions.  It’s bad out there.  Far worse than I thought.  I am deeply, deeply saddened by what they say.

When I attended law school, there was no thought about whether to go to classes or read the hornbooks.  It was what we did, like it or not.  Indeed, we never considered our enjoyment of classes to be relevant on our path to becoming lawyers.  No one asked us if we liked it, and no one cared.  We could either do what we were told or find another career path. 

Today, law students are able to see into the minds of law professors by virtue of the law prof blawgs.  There were no blawgs back then, of course, as the personal computer was barely a twinkle in the eye of some kids punching cards in the underground room at Univac.  High tech was an IBM Selectric typewriter.  Professors were usually ancient (at least to us) and above reproach.  That’s why they were professors and we were students.

At some point, law students turned into consumers of legal educational services.  This was, no doubt, intended to be a good thing for them, a way in which they could help to improve the delivery of a legal education.  Clearly, it hasn’t worked out as well as planned. 

These law students are miserable.  They find law school miserable, useless and futile.  And the reason why is fascinating:  It’s not that law school is inherently flawed, but that they hate their law professors.  The say that law professors are horribly boring.  But worse, writes one law student:

I felt like I was intruding on something by asking for help. How dare me, I was missing the point. Now I know why, I was cutting into ‘scholarly production’.

So the primary function of law school is no longer to train new lawyers, but to serve as a vessel for the “scholarly production” of law professors?  So they can write important law review articles about due process at the Ministry of Magic in Harry Potter?

But it gets worse.  Now that law students see themselves as consumers of legal educational services, they have considered the relative worth of the price tag to the product, and found it wanting.  In a big way.  From a lawyer who left school carrying $100 thousand in debt.

I hear that at lower tier school, no recruiters show up for the bad law school coffee. How those deans and professors can sleep at night after essentially fleecing young people to support their comfy UTTERLY UNPRODUCTIVE sincures is beyond me. And their uncomprehending, smug self-satisfaction at their sandal-wearing lifestyle takes me further to the point of sputtering contempt.


This condemnation is repeated by students from the non-Tier 1 law schools.  For those unfamiliar, Tier 1 Law Schools are the top 50 named in US News and World Reports.  There is now a very clear food chain amongst law schools, and putting aside the validity of the list, it matters enormously if a law students wants to get those monstrous salaries and benefits that David Lat loves to write about at Above the Law.  It’s the legal profession’s version of society’s obsession with Paris Hilton or Britney Spears.  The Tier 1 grads sneer at their lessers, the drooling wastrels who couldn’t manage to get themselves into a “real” law school.

And apparently the important law grads are correct, as law firms that pay the big bucks see no virtue in graduates from the lower Tiers.  They don’t want them; they won’t hire them.  These students have paid their tuition under the misguided view that they can get a job after law school, work hard, become solid lawyers and enjoy a reasonably good lifestyle.  No one tells them that if they don’t go to a Tier 1 law school, the jobs will be few and the lifestyle with be struggling.  And they graduate to find that the promise was a lie, and that they sat through boring professors and took on a hundred thousand dollars in debt for nothing. 

This is a very disturbing scenario.  It appears that many in the legal profession may not be aware of the changes in law school that have happened since they left their alma maters, and the dissatisfaction that it’s caused.  Maybe it’s time we took law schools back from the professors, who haven’t done a very good job of safeguarding our future.  Maybe we need to stop the glorification of numbers in a magazine and start remembering that its the job done in front of a jury, or the coherence and effectiveness of words on a page, that make a lawyer.  Right now, the future looks bleak indeed.

The Russell Result – Hard Drive or Hard Time?

Our Connecticut law maven, Gideon, brought the blawgosphere the news about midday yesterday that Phillip Russell, whose story has been followed here for some time, bit the bullet.  Russell pleaded guilty in the United States Court for the District of Connecticut of the crime of Misprision of Felony.  Remember kids, Connecticut is in the Second Circuit, just like New York, so this is not merely a parochial anomaly, and matters to New York lawyers.

While most of us will recall this offense from law school days, it’s unlikely that we’ve heard the words since.  I can’t recall a single prosecution for misprision of felony in the past 25 years.  The elements of the crime are knowledge of the commission of a felony offense and failure to report it to law enforcement. 

From the Russell standpoint, it appears that his deal puts him at a level 11 (with a criminal history of 1), making him eligible for probation in Zone C of the United States Sentencing Guidelines.  Thus, while rolling the dice on a trial might well have been important for the rest of us, Philip just cut his exposure down to the bone.  According to an unattributed quote, Russell decided not to be a martyr for the cause.  Completely understandable.

But the cause will most assuredly suffer because of this outcome.  Indeed, the cause may suffer worse because of the Misprision plea than it would under the Sarbanes-Oxley charge, which brought the allegations far afield of the Congressional intent of SOX and implicated a whole lot of other issues that would have tied up the Circuit for a long time.  Of course, we will never know now whether this journey into SOX fantasy world would fly with the Circuit, as a plea puts the issue to bed.

Before the deal was cut, Russell’s lawyer, Robert Casale, was quoted as saying, “By virtue of the case of the United States against Philip Russell, you’re all conscripted to be agents of the government. And if you don’t act in that capacity, we’ll prosecute you.”

He as right then.  He’s still right now.  Even more so given the plea to misprision, which goes directly to a criminal defense lawyer’s duty to protect client privilege.  All criminal defense lawyers, even Mark Bennett’s V6s, know that they have an ethical duty to keep their traps shut when they know about their client’s criminal conduct.  It goes to the very heart of the 6th Amendment, and even the staunchest Republican (especially the staunchest Republican?) wants their lawyer to devote themselves to the client first.  They all get it.  If lawyers disclose confidences about bad stuff clients do, no one can ever tell their lawyer anything bad, and lawyers can never adequately defend.  The primary weapon in the criminal defense lawyers’ arsenal is knowledge.  Without it, the lawyer is unarmed.

According to the Russell case, that is done.  We can no longer safeguard client confidences, except at risk of becoming a criminal ourselves and at risk of conviction. 

While Alberto Gonzalez may be smiling today, thinking that he’s finally contributed something to the American criminal law landscape that will be worthy of his legacy, I have to wonder if Judge Michael Mukasey is proud of what happened here.  Had Russell held out a little longer, would Judge Mukasey have seen the fundamental error of this prosecution, and put an end to it as one of the most ill-considered directions the DOJ could possibly take.  I want to think so.  I really want to.

But the problem isn’t limited to those criminal defense lawyers whom the government finds reason to believe “know something.”  All criminal defense lawyers “know something,” and everyone knows that we “know something.”  It inherent in the nature of our work.

So this gives the government a weapon to be pulled out at will and aimed at lawyers they don’t like. 

Who doesn’t the government like?  How about lawyers who fight too hard.  Lawyers who are too successful.  Lawyers who are uncooperative.  Lawyers who are too imaginative.  Lawyers who are too radical.  Lawyers who don’t advise their clients to rat.

You see, the government needs criminal defense lawyers.  They can’t convict people without them.  But they don’t need disagreeable criminal defense lawyers, just warm bodies willing to stand there and smile.  Some make the government’s day so much easier than others. 

Should we anticipate wholesale indictments of criminal defense lawyers following this case?  I wouldn’t, but I can easily foresee the surgical use of this very sharp weapon going forward.  Worse yet, one day in the future we will take it for granted that criminal defense lawyers “are required by law” to squeal on their clients.  When that day comes, remember that it started here.

Lynne Stewart – Enough Already

UPDATE:  On this site,  Lynne Stewart is called a “dyke” and lambasted for her physical  appearance.  Hey, Feminist Law Professors, would you be more interested if Lynne dressed up in a Slim Jim costume?

* * *

So Lynne Stewart is going to give a lecture at Hofstra Law School and the knee-jerk reactionaries are going bonkers. 

CONVICTED FELON!  DISBARRED LAWYER!  TERRORIST LOVER!         

Please.

Mind you, do any of these jackasses commenters know Lynne Stewart?  Do they know anything about her?  Do they know anything about the case, except what they read in the New York Post?  Of course, the WSJ is always good, because of its fastidious fairness toward radical types.

It’s one thing that people who are clueless waste a thousand words writing about Michael Mukasey.  After all, he will hold high public office and understood that the job came with a free proctology exam. 

But Lynne isn’t running for office, and didn’t ask for every reactionary showboat on the internet to peek under her dress.  If they knew Lynne, they might possibly have a clue how their shrill attacks are just ridiculous.

Notice that the loud-mouths don’t mention that Lynne was sentenced to only 28 months, and remains free on bail pending appeal. Yeah, she’s a big terrorist threat.  If she doesn’t bake you brownies instead.

I’ve know Lynne for 20 years.  My letter in support of Lynne at sentence was cited (I believe) more than any other of the 800 letters of support in her pre-sentence memorandum.  I’ve tried cases with Lynne and I’ve taken meals with Lynne.  Lynne Stewart is a friend of mine.

If you don’t know Lynne, then let it go already.  And if you did, you wouldn’t be writing such nonsense.