Author Archives: SHG

The Pain in the Back Row

Anne Read at Deliberations hosts Blawg Review # 127 this week, and its spectacular.  Anne’s theme is (shockingly) juror types, and she’s pegged me as the “talkative type in the back row” because I post too damned many pieces.  I think she means “pain in the butt,” but is too cultured to ever write such a thing. 

What a great job Anne has done, particularly in a Blawg Review season of brilliant highs and crashing lows.  But Anne always does a great job, and is really one of the few “must reads” in the blawgosphere.

As for me, I apologize for posting so much.  It’s just that there is so much to write about, so write I must.  If you find it too much (or too boring), you can just skip over it, but I want you to know that it will make me very sad if I write something and no one reads it.  But don’t let my shameless effort at being pathetic sway you.  If you only have time to read one thing today, go to Deliberations and read Blawg Review # 127.

Documents for the Undocumented

Gov. Eliot Spitzer has decided to let illegal aliens have drivers licenses, per New York Legal Update.  This feeds into one of the most hotly debated, and angrily disputed, areas around New York.  When it comes to undocumented aliens, the nice name, there is a huge division amongst otherwise good people.  There are a lot of people who truly hate illegals and see any concession to their existence as a precursor to the downfall of civilization.

They have a point.  As waves of illegals flood a geographic area, and they do tend to come in waves where they group together in a ghetto-like fashion, the impact on every aspect of quality of life is pervasive.  When it began to happen in a downtown area close to where I lived some years ago, with Salvadorians hanging out on the street until the wee hours of the night, urinating as needed and commenting in inappropriate ways to women passing by, there was a call for blood.

Mind you, I have no idea whether these people were totally legal emigres or illegal aliens, but it’s so much easier to characterize them all as illegals when you want to focus your anger at them.  The one clear point was that they were culturally different, and that their culture conflicted with that of the people who lived there happily (?) before they arrived.  And so they are angry.  Very angry.

There aren’t many advocacy groups with political clout standing up for undocumented aliens.  Like criminal defendants, they serve a much better purpose as the butt of political grandstanding.  So why then has Gov. Spitzer decided to become their champion? 

Because there are interest groups with a whole lotta clout standing up for the rights of insurance companies.  By products of undocumented aliens, and the push to keep them further underground by denying them legal recognition, is the inability to legally own and operate a car.  Here’s one fact nobody can dispute:  There’s no way to survive without a car around here.  So if you can’t own and operate one legally, then you do so illegally. 

Aha, say the illegal haters.  Yet more criminal conduct.  Another reason to hunt them down and shoot deport them.  Perhaps, but in the meantime, we have a more personal (meaning, touching our lives) problem.  We do not want them behind the wheel of a 2000 pound weapon if they can’t handle it or can’t understand the rules of our road.  We do not want them to drive without insurance.  Not because we feel kindly toward them, but for self-preservation. 

If undocumented aliens can lawfully obtain a license, we gain a few benefits.  First, they are tested to make sure they have the basic skills needed to drive.  You might think this is trivial, but being a keen observer of driving technique, this is a real concern.  Granted, it is a very low bar, but I’ll take whatever i can get.

Second, if an accident happens (as they invariably do), whether someone is injured or just some fender bender, there will be a better chance of compensation.  As with driving skills, this is hardly a perfect cure since they remain undocumented and generally like to hide under the radar regardless of whether they have insurance.  Plus, there has long been a misunderstanding of how insurance works, exactly, so that they pay for the initial binder to get the car registered, then never pay the premiums after that since they see no point in throwing hard earned money after pointless insurance.  I’ve had the discussion many times with clients, who never understood the concept.

Third, there is a much greater likelihood that undocumented aliens will not flee when something goes wrong, whether it is an accident or a pursuing cop.  Another discussion that I’ve had with clients for years is how they flee from the police, not because of whatever thing happened in the cops mind, but because they are undocumented and fear deportation.  Half the time they have no clue why the cop is after them; they just know that they don’t want to get caught.

Is Gov. Spitzer a leader in the forefront of sound immigration police?  I don’t know that we can go that far, but I’m willing to bet that he hears the Insurance lobby loud and clear.  There will no doubt be the backlash that Spitzer will make New York a haven for illegals with his ultra-liberal policies.  What’s next, 40 acres and a mule?  Perhaps they will flock to New York from around the country seeking a drivers license.  But until we figure out a better way to deal with undocumented aliens, and since we desperately need to have a group that good old boys can spit at whenever they don’t win the lottery and have run out of beer, or well-groomed suburban homeowners when their lawn needs trimming and they just had their nails done, it’s a start.

Love Them Car Chases

From Grits for Breakfast, the debate on whether high speed pursuit by police lives.  The clash is between a Houston cop, Jason, and Catonya at 2 With Spirit.
Jason, a Houston police officer who blogs at Cigars, Donuts and Coffee, opines that “I have never seen an instance where a pursuit was terminated that the criminal slowed down and obeyed the traffic laws. When the police stop chasing, the criminal will continue fleeing at high speeds.”

This is a fascinating comment because of its underlying assumptions.  First, that cops have a need to initiate high speed pursuit at all, and second that capturing the criminal is what it’s all about. 

Jason uses the word “criminal” to describe his prey.  Are we talking about a speeder?  No one likes traffic infractions, and they certainly present a danger to others.  But to characterize them as criminals suggests that these “criminals” could be mass murderers on their way to slaughter some innocent child.  Unlikely.  If it was a murderer on his way to slaughter a child, my thoughts would be different.  But I’m unconvinced that this comprises the bulk of subjects of high speed pursuit.

So what does Catonya think about all this?

“There are over one quarter million police pursuits annually nationwide. Each year there are over 300 documented deaths in high speed pursuits; an average of one death per day Overall, 57,000 persons are killed or severely injured annually in the United States alone. One in four pursuits results in a crash-the majority of high speed drivers are young males-chases have lasted from one minute to several hours-covered a distance of 100 yards to almost 200 miles. On an annual basis, deaths resulting from high speed chase incidents exceed deaths related to police discharge of firearms. Los Angeles alone recorded 7,000 police pursuits; 1,200 injuries to innocent victims; another 980 injuries to police officers in the latest annual statistics. Los Angeles has one potentially deadly pursuit every 4 1/2 hours-resulting in 1,000 deaths and injuries a year. One-third of all high speed chase deaths are innocent bystanders. About 10 percent of high speed chases are begun by felons while the vast majority begin from a simple traffic stop for a minor infraction. ” PursuitWatch.org


Lots of people dying for very little.  Lots of innocent bystanders.  Lots of kids running away from a minor infraction so Mommy doesn’t ground them.  Lots of cops who don’t drive nearly as well as they think they do. 

If you get the call one night that your child is lying dead on the street because of a high speed pursuit after a speeder, where someone lost control of their vehicle and crashed into some innocent bystanders, will you take comfort in knowing that the police were doing their job by making sure that no speeder got away?

Based on my experience, I think cops just like high speed pursuit.  It’s fun to drive fast, and one of the real benefits to being on the job.  These are generally young men, many of whom have an affection for cars and racing.  There are few occupations, aside from Nascar driver, that allow one to legally speed.  Cop is one.  It can be a very boring job at times, but it does have its benefits.

Another aspect of high speed pursuit, particularly when we’re talking about chasing a “perp” whose wrongdoing is monumentally inconsequential is just the natural cop need to teach a lesson to people who “just don’t listen.”  Since a taser won’t do any good when the other guy is in a car, high speed pursuit is the only recourse.  After all, if the perp gets away, the cop can’t show him who’s boss and that you don’t mess with a cop.

Ironically, I can’t help but wonder why the cop doesn’t just take down the vehicle description and plate and call his brothers to go find the perp.  Most of the time, they can figure out where the owner lives or can have another cop position himself farther down the road that the perp is on to intercept him later, after things have calmed down.  While this won’t work all the time, is the risk that a speeder will get away really that horrible an outcome, when compared to the alternative of death?

I suspect that there are cops who comprehend that the product of a high speed pursuit, death of an innocent bystander for example, is worse than the “risk” that the perp will get away.  They understand the need for rules of engagement, and disengagement.  They can remove the ego element in the name of not risking the death of others.

Over the years, cars have become faster.  Both cop cars and regular cars can easily hit speeds that are beyond the skills of most drivers.  Many roads can’t accommodate these speeds, and fleeing drivers rarely take notice of the signs telling them to slow down for a curve ahead.  High speed pursuit is always a risk.

I can appreciate as well as the next guy that we love car chases.  Movies with car chases, at least good ones, always seem to do well.  As a society, this is the stuff that gets our blood pumping and makes us whisper “cool” under our breath.  But movies aren’t real life, and Keanu Reeves always manages to survive to be in some other movie.  That isn’t necessarily true in the real world.  I am not prepared to approve of cops engaging in high speed pursuit if it means my kid may die.  It’s just not worth it.

Superlawyers with Cheese, Please

When you pour your first cup of coffee this morning and pull out the New York Times Magazine, you’ll find it a bit heavier than normal.  That’s right.  Right there in the middle, past a fascinating cover story about Senior Associate Supreme Court Justice  John Paul Stevens, there is a monster advertising supplement for (ta da) Superlawyers!  Super Lawyers.  Super.  The best.  The best of the best.  The creme de la creme.  In four color glossy almost-candid photos.

Sigh.  This one truly pains me, as there are many friends of mine in there.  Men and women I like and respect.  There are also some lawyers who suck, and a few I’ve never even heard of.  Since I know most lawyers who practice criminal defense around these parts, it’s hard to imagine many Superlawyers whose names are unknown, but there they are.

Like most lawyers (I suppose), I’ve gotten the letter from Superlawyers that begins, “Congatulations! You have been nominated . . . ”  I file it with my Nigerian lottery notifications.  Apparently, that’s not true of all lawyers.  To each his own.

So what’s this Superlawyers all about?  According to Larry Bodine’s LawMarketing Blog, it’s about an appeal to ego.
When I am advising a law firm on marketing, and see that they’ve put their Super Lawyers selection on their Web site or in a press release, I recommend they immediately remove them.  They are embarrassing themselves.  They are advertising to the world that the only ranking they can get into is one that sells advertising. They are announcing how insecure they are that their ego needs to be propped up with apparent praise.

Ouch.  During a lunch with fellow marketers, Bodine says, “The marketers laughed, and then sighed about how easily the lawyers were fooled.  All it took was one shot at their egos and the were ready to pay money to be in a meaningless directory.”  Are lawyers that fragile?

There is no doubt that an advertising scheme like Superlawyers plays on the ego of lawyers, but in some respects it’s understandable.  An AV rating from Martindale Hubbell really doesn’t do much to distinguish a lawyer, and certainly lacks the pizazz of Super Lawyer.  You’ve never seen AV Man flying through the air with a cape, have you?

Ernie the Attorney was proud of himself for being a Super Lawyer, though it appears that he bought into the rhetoric without knowing that others simply bought in.

They sent us a letter that three of our lawyers had been chosen,” said the director of a prominent Ohio law firm.  “One was retired and another was dead.”  So much for their rigorous selection criteria.  “So I called up and said I wanted three different lawyers in the directory.  They said ‘OK.'”  Again, so much for their rigorous selection criteria.


One of the problems is that lawyers, looking for a way to distinguish themselves, may not be as scrupulous in vetting their “awards” as they should be.  Ernie probably is a Super Lawyer, but not because he was listed in the advertisement.  But if you really are a super lawyer, how do you let people know?

In New Jersey, Super Lawyers has been outlawed.  It was deemed unethical and a scam on the public.  Whether it’s any more of a scam than any other lawyer advertising is unclear, but the superlative nature of the list does tend to suggest a great deal about a lawyer that may not be exactly accurate.  Still, being part of the Super Lawyer advertisement doesn’t mean you aren’t a great lawyer either.

I chose to toss my Superlawyer notification.  I toss a lot of this stuff.  My AV rating from Martindale means something, I think, and I put stuff like this on my website because it’s all lawyers have available.  But Superlawyers was way over the top for me, and apparently for a number of other criminal defense lawyers I know who are far, far better than some of the people who decided to pay the fare and get their mugs into the New York Times Magazine today.  

I won’t criticize those lawyers who decided that it was worth the money to become a Superlawyer.  Every good criminal defense lawyer fights for the few top cases that come along, and wants any edge they can get.  There just aren’t that many really good cases.  Maybe I’ll bite when I get the advertisement to be a “Really, Really Super Lawyer.”  After all, if it is says “really” twice, it must be true.

As Many Clients as Possible

Yesterday, I received a call from a potential new client who had “found” me by my website.  After speaking with him for a bit, he asked about my fee.  It was clear from our conversation that he would be unable to pay my fee, and his question was awkward.  Calls like these are disturbing, and I shot off an email to Mark Bennett complaining about how technology has changed how clients come to me, but mostly for the worst.  I believe my email may have generated Mark’s post, If You Have to Ask . . .

Historically, my clients come to me by referral only.  Whether client referral or lawyer referral, they have a fairly decent idea of the nature of my practice as well as the relative cost of my services.  In my 25 years practicing criminal defense, I have never advertised.  Not only do I find advertising demeaning (yeah, I’m old school, as I’ve conceded many times here), but I’ve founded it more troublesome than productive to seek out clients who are more concerned with price than quality.  I don’t think less of them for it, but that I’m not the right lawyer for them.

One day last February, when I didn’t have much to do, I decided to try my hand at putting together a website.  It wasn’t constructed with much forethought, more on a lark.  I had run across many criminal defense lawyer websites and found most of them to be far worse than crass.  For the most part, they were flagrantly unethical.  Designed to suggest outcome (“I will win your case!  I’ve won millions of cases!), the goal of these websites is clear.  They want to suck in as many potential clients as possible, without discrimination.  They cry out VOLUME!

Such is the nature of the internet.  It cannot discriminate between the attorney who provides quality and the one who seeks volume.  After all, no website screams “I’m a lousy lawyer, but I’m cheap!”  For this reason, I’ve complained quite a bit about the use of websites, their limitations, their self-aggrandizing deceptiveness and their potential for changing the way clients relate to lawyers.

My website is poor.  I put it together in about 15 minutes, without any particular model in mind.  It made me uncomfortable as I did it, and I kept thinking that these were 15 minutes of my life that I would never get back.  My wife looked around at other criminal defense lawyer websites, and couldn’t find any that she liked.  She was trying to help me not look like too much of a schmuck on mine.  She finally gave up.

Lacking much that seems appropriate for the main page, I decided to put up a picture of me.  That turned into a fiasco.  Like most fathers, I have plenty of photos of my kids, both alone and with my wife.  But someone has to shoot the picture, and so there are no pictures of me.  Except the occasional swimming suit pic at the beach, and no one wants to see one of those. 

So I went in search of a photograph.  Unlike other lawyers who do a lot of TV commentary work, I never get a copy of the tape showing me on the small screen, so I had no stills of me looking serious and important.  Finally, I found a group shot of me at a NYSACDL dinner with a few lawyer friends where I looked quite happy.  A few drinks will do that to you.  I edited out the better looking lawyers and stuck what was left on my website.  My wife hates that photo too, but it was the best I could do.

The upshot of my website has been calls like the one I received yesterday.  It was a low-level case.  Serious to the person involved, but not particularly serious in the scheme of my practice.  That wouldn’t matter a bit to me, as I treat every case the same, but the call came from a nice fellow who would do well to use public defender.  Websites draw people who don’t know where to turn, and don’t understand why some lawyers don’t have a price list. 

Significant cases don’t find criminal defense lawyers on the internet.  They speak with people and get names. Whether this works much better is debatable, but it’s how it’s done.  It’s very different for other fields of law, like personal injury, where they want to get as many cases in the door as possible so that they can pick the cherries and set the rest adrift.  If a criminal defense lawyer tries to get as many people in the door as possible, by definition he will not be a lawyer with enough time to handle his clients properly.  It’s just a matter of logistics, and the number of hours in the day doesn’t change.  Clients like to pretend that the laws of time and physics don’t apply to them, but of course they do and hiding one’s head in the sand isn’t going to change that.

So if anyone out there has an idea of how a website can be used to communicate what a lawyer like me does, I would like to know.  Note to web promoters:  This is not an invitation to tout your service; We get all your junk mail and already know that you have no answer to this question. 

I don’t enjoy turning away people who are in trouble.  It’s not in my nature.  But I just don’t see how a website reaches the sort of clients that I represent, and helps those who have serious cases and need serious representation to find high quality representation.  Conversely, I represent so many clients who went to some schlock lawyer first, who blew many opportunities, before realizing that they were being poorly represented and finally found their way to me.  Many of these clients were referred by their real estate lawyer to some dolt with whom they went to law school who promised to kick back a third for the referral.  How do these defendant learn the difference?  I have no answer to this question.

The Academic Freedom Fascists

From the New York Times via Volokh, protests have broken out at Stanford University against appointment of Donald H. Rumsfeld, the former defense secretary, as a distinguished visiting fellow at the Hoover Institution.  As David Bernstein wryly notes,

[W]ith regard to Hoover: “They can have any fascist they want there, and they do… We’ve never protested before but this seems to be egregious.” Ah, the voice of reason. I guess, say, George Schultz is just “any fascist,” but Rumsfeld is an egregious one.

The protests at Stanford are designed to express that the Hoover Institution, and particularly Donald Rumsfeld, are “out of the mainstream” of thought there.  SO WHAT!

This fall back on academic freedom, which presupposes that there can be only the freedom to express one unitary point of view, is one of the most destructive ideas in understanding and addressing the problems of society.  Frankly, it just embarrassingly weak.

I don’t agree with Donald Rumsfeld, though I’ve come to better understand who he is after reading Lisa DePaulo’s interview of him in GQ.  But Donald Rumsfeld had a real impact on the lives of real people, while the academics diddle themselves to enjoy the thrills of mental masturbation.  These “freedom” protesters demand the right to shut down any voice other than theirs.  Some freedom, huh?

Worse yet, the notion that sound thought and policy is best derived from the resounding expression of commonly held ideas is just foolish.  Invite your enemy to the debate.  Let him challenge you, and let you challenge him.  The worthiest ideas prevail only when subjected to rigorous debate.

Stanford is generally revered as a bastion of learning.  High school seniors prays to be accepted there.  College seniors prays to go to their graduate programs.  This is a big time school.  so why, I wonder, is the faculty so fundamentally afraid of Don Rumsfeld or the Hoover Institution?  Worse yet, why must they resort to calling him a “fascist”, which he may well be but that isn’t the point, rather than dazzle the world with their ability to logically and rationally express themselves to show that Rumsfeld was wrong?  Is that the Stanford message to students:  If you can’t beat them in the arena of ideas, then call them bad names?

There is no doubt in my mind that Donald Rumsfeld is an ideologue, who has smugly helped to push America into a world-situation that is horribly destructive, wrong and ultimately disastrous.  I have no University to make him a fellow, but he’s welcome anytime to come to my house and be a distinguished guy here, where we can discuss and debate what he’s done and why till he cowers in anguish from my astute and irrefutable logic and persuasiveness.  I’m not afraid of Donald Rumsfeld.  Why are you, Stanford?

Keeping Your Cool

There are a number of posts around the practical blawgosphere this week about dealing with judges and prosecutors who are rude, offensive, overreaching, whatever, here (Bennett), here (Katz) and here (Matlock).  Bennett has the best quote, 

             As Paladin said, “Never draw in anger. It slows the hand.”

While I share his fascination with Paladin, he knows a lot more about the show than I do. 

I learned an important lesson about a decade ago from a great old time Bronx judge, Danny Sullivan.  Danny was one of the real judges, not one of the kiddie judges who need to buy their robes one size too big in case they grow.  Danny knew what end was up, and neither side was going to bulldoze him.  He feared nothing, as he had nothing to fear.  And to make matters worse, he was just a good man.

I was lead counsel in a big case before Danny.  It was a little daunting, as there were plenty of defendants and some had retained some very well known, and older, lawyers than me.  These lawyers didn’t know me, and there were rumblings that one of the big shots should take the lead rather than some young turk (hard to believe now that there was a time that I was considered a young turk). 

But I told them that I had it under control, and to sit back, get paid and let me do the work.  They seemed to be just fine with that. 

The ADA was a nasty will person, prematurely bald and with a tendency for his voice to rise 2 octaves when he got excited (which was often).  He was a weasel.  He was intent on winning, and he would happily connive to achieve that goal.  He’s now a defense lawyer and he asked me (after he left the DA’s office) if it was ethical to pay the hot dog guy outside the courtroom to refer him clients.  I told him “absolutely”, knowing that the hot dog guy was getting vig from at least a dozen former prosecutors already, and was making a killing off these idiots.  I know, me bad, but I couldn’t help myself from joining in the joke.

So, to impress my renown co-counsel, and to beat the living daylights out of this smarmy prosecutor, I whipped out one of my greatest motions, a 127 page wiretap motion that was (if I can brag a moment) nearly perfect, in a week.  Everyone’s head spun, especially my nemesis.

A month after arraignment, we were all back in court to argue the motion before Danny.  I did my thing, in a cool, detailed, professional manner.  And then the ADA did his, voice climbing and raising claims that were false, outrageous and deceptive.  As soon as he took a breadth, I jumped back into the fray, but this time louder, faster and with anger.

Danny put up his hand, pretended to need something from his clerk, then waved us up to the bench.  He looked at me and said, “When you started, you were smoooooooooth.  Don’t give it away.”

We returned to our tables and now, calmly and with a voice slightly softer than everyone else, I picked apart the significant points made by my adversary and announced that his other points were simply unworthy of further comment. 

The message was clear.  Don’t let someone else make you lose your cool.  Once that happens, they control you.  Over the years, I’ve used this lesson well.  The louder, angrier, crazier things got, whether because it was the judge or prosecutor, the calmer I became.  The softer, more dulcet my tone.  The slower my speech.  When their faces were contorted in anger, mine bore a calm demeanor, often with just the slightest hint of a peaceful smile.  Like Paladin, I would not draw in anger.

It has an extraordinary affect.  The judge or prosecutor is red-faced and out of control.  I am serene, in total control of myself and, ultimately, the courtroom.  By their loss of control, they have ceded it to me.  Try this and see it for yourself.

In the past, I’ve posted about the impact of strategic silence.  There are times when you need to express anger or outrage, and the failure to do so sends a message that something that is facially outrageous doesn’t really matter that much to you.  But when these times come, they too must be deliberate on your part and not a knee-jerk reaction because of what someone else said.  At the lawyer, you must be in control of everything that comes out of your mouth.  You are responsible for your actions and reactions, and if you let your conduct be dictated by someone else, then they control you. 

Danny passed away some years ago.  I went to his funeral, the only time I’ve ever done so with a judge with whom I didn’t have a personal relationship outside of court.  It was my way of letting him know how much I appreciated his lesson. 

When A Judge Demands Too Much

A few days ago, David Tarrell asked me to take a look at a transcript on his blog, In the Moment.  It was one of those transcripts that embodies the conundrum that all criminal defense lawyers are faced with eventually.  A judge just wanted the lawyer go away for a few minutes so that the judge could talk with the client, on the record, by herself. 

To some, this wouldn’t seem like such a big deal.  In fact, some people would admire the judge for having a judge/defendant chat.  Maybe she’s a caring judge.  Maybe she just wants to bond with the defendant.  Maybe.

But maybe a guy like David Tarrell is still a lawyer.  And maybe on of the things a judge can’t do is push the lawyer aside to do whatever she pleases.  Maybe they each have a specified role in the courtroom, and judges don’t get to tell the lawyer to just go away for a few minutes so the judge can do as she pleases.

Faced with a judge directing him to do what he, lawyer Tarrell, knows he should not, he had to make a choice.  Do I just back away and let it happen?  It probably won’t do any harm.  It’s not like the judge is going to direct the defendant to admit guilt.  But…

I know a very well known lawyer who has told me he’d never take a bullet for a client.  After all, they wouldn’t take one for him.  He’s a great lawyer.  But he would much rather make peace than face the can.  He would bend.

David Tarrell didn’t have a lot of time to ponder the situation.  The judge was blustery, demanding that he “be still.”  He tried to talk her off the edge, but every time he opened his mouth, the judge became increasingly infuriated with him.  Thankfully, she had no taser.  He wanted to make a record, but she refused to let him.  He never directly challenged her, but sought only to say what any good attorney would say under the circumstances.

The judge, like so many who are drunk with power in their courtroom, fell into that deep hole of judicial hubris.  She threatened contempt.  David stood firm, “You can find me in contempt.”  And so she did.

Once the judge threatened, the die was cast.  It was a standoff, and neither could back off.  It’s why we’re taught never to threaten to drop the bomb unless we mean to do it.  Once threatened, it has to be used if our bluff is called.

In law school, we were taught that the rule was to obey the orders of the court and appeal later.  That works under most circumstances, but not all.  It wouldn’t have worked for David.  There was no “appeal later” option available.  It was lay on the floor, prostrate, and let the judge walk all over you, or not.  Either he was a lawyer, and kept his oath to represent his client, or he was a gutless worm with a briefcase.  David chose to be a lawyer.

After. the judge did what most judges do.  Try to talk their way out of their employed threat, knowing full well that holding a lawyer in contempt has significant consequences if it comes as a result of overreaching and abuse of power. But still, the judge can’t exactly say she screwed up, and apologize.  That would be injudicious.  They want to let the lawyer go so the whole ugly incident can be swept under the carpet and forgotten, but they need to save face.  They need the lawyer to make an act of contrition, any act of contrition, so that they can be the beneficent judge and forgive their sins. 

This is such an old sad story, and even sadder that it happens over and over.  David Tarrell behaved in the finest tradition of the criminal defense lawyer.  He stood up for his client against an overreaching judge, prepared to suffer the personal sacrifice of contempt and jail to do the right thing.  Well done.

True Taser Talk

Tasers are getting a bum rap.  After hearing U of F jokester Andrew Meyer whine about the pain, as if shocking a person with 50,000 volts was like torture, the cockroaches are coming out of the woodwork to blame the poor, unassuming Taser for all the troubles in the world.  Well, enough is enough.  It’s time for a little Truth about Tasers.

Tasers have been used on about 600,000 times, according to police, with only about 200 deaths.  Goodness gracious!  More people die from choking on donuts in police stations.  Of course, they’re mostly police officers, but still.  When’s the last time the ACLU marched on Dunkin’ Donuts?

Six states have outlawed Tasers.  Blue states, naturally.  After all, it’s much better to have police chose between a well swung club and a well greased Glock than a painless Taser.  Painless for the police, that is.  And since they’re there to protect and serve us, shouldn’t we be concerned about our cops?  No?  Well, the next time you’re in trouble, call a criminal to come help you.  Well, maybe criminals aren’t the best measure of police conduct.  But if it works with Iraqi terrorists, why not apply it to cops at home?

The availability of Tasers has done wonders for the taxpayers as well.  The number of police officers who have suffered horrible, painful, debilitating injury (often resulting in retirement on full pension) when their closed fist was attacked by the face of some miscreant has been reduced by a full 3% since Tasers came into use.  I’m estimating that number, by the way, so don’t blame me if it’s less than 3%.  There’s no good source for this stat, so I have to go by my personal observations.

So many of the bleeding hearts have promoted the claim that police use Tasers as a convenient way of shutting down an otherwise potentially disruptive arrestee that people are forgetting that Tasers are our friend.  Just look at the videos, where calm and deliberative police are able to get a “situation” under control by merely taking a few jabs with the Taser on the cuffed perp who just can’t manage to lie there happily.  Hey, if the cops tell you to freeze, you better freeze.  After all, they’re the cops and law-abiding Americans do whatever they say. 

Need an example?  Consider the case of Long Islander David Glowczenski, whose family called the police because he was suffering a mental breakdown.

His sister, Jean Griffin, says, “We called them for safety because he was disoriented. …And an hour later he was dead.”

Glowzenski died after a confrontation in which an officer stunned him nine times with a TASER, and he wasn’t on drugs or alcohol, Andrews notes. “He committed no crime; he didn’t do anything wrong,” Griffin says.


Would they have felt better if the cops had just put a bullet between his eyes in the first place?  No, no, a thousand times no!  What was the police officer to do?  He got a call and dealt with it.  Did you think he was going to just stand around all day waiting for the guy to calm down, making sure no one else was injured in the meantime?  Puhlease.  Cops have better things to do, especially when they carry Tasers.  After all, there’s always a kitten stuck up a tree on Long Island, and there would be no one there to get the little kitty down if the cop was tied up all day waiting on disoriented people.

The poor, maligned Taser started out life as an alternative to the use of more lethal, harmful force, and has found its niche as the “go to” tool in the police officer’s belt with good reason.  It’s like the duct tape of police work, a million great uses with only the occasional unsightly death.  It’s time we stopped blaming the Taser because some video-loving kid thought he could abuse our constitutional right to speak by asking questions that were just downright unpleasant.  Whatever happened to the constitutional right to smack some smart-ass kid who doesn’t know to keep his trap shut.  Didn’t his mother ever tell him that children should be seen and not heard?

So the next time your eye-balling some cop when you’re all hopped up on liquor and angel dust, you better pray he’s got a Taser hanging from his belt.  Remember, the Taser is your friend.

The Curious Mel Weiss Prosecution

Though lacking the drama of a low-speed Bronco chase, the indictment of the King of Class Actions, Mel Weiss, following the plea of his partner, William Lerach, has sent shock waves through the civil litigation bar.  And not a few hidden chuckles, apparently, as Millberg Weiss played hardball and made an enemy here and there.

While competing law firms (and the defense firms who had the pleasure of sitting across the table) may be enjoying how the long-standing whispers of prosecution play out, those of us without a financial horse in the race should ask some questions.

Full disclosure, Mel Weiss happens to be a neighbor of mine, though we rarely see him at neighborly barbecues or picnics.  I can’t say that I know him, and he didn’t have the good sense to retain me, though his attorney, Ben Branfman, is a great lawyer if you happen to be his most important client at any given time.  As long as P.Diddy doesn’t get arrested in the next year, Mel should be in good hands.  Branfman has both the skill and guts to try a case, unlike many of the lawyers for “white collar” defendants, whose primary skill is their knowledge of the fastest way to get to Saint Andrews Plaza from anywhere in Manhattan.

According to the 102 page indictment, Mel was a co-conspirator in a “kickback” scheme that paid $11 Million to a stable of “ready” plaintiffs and “concealed” the scheme with an elaborate system of “referral” fees.  Lots of loaded words in there, amply used to make Mel Weiss look like a dirty, rotten scoundrel.  And what does the Government have to say about Mel?

“This case is about protecting the integrity of the justice system,” said Debra Wong Yang, the U.S. Attorney in Los Angeles. “Class-action attorneys and plaintiffs occupy positions of trust in which they assume responsibility to tell the truth….This indictment alleges a wholesale violation of this responsibility.”

There you have it.  By indicting Mel Weiss, the integrity of the justice system will be secured.  Well, thank god for that, since nobody wants an unsecured justice system, right?

Before performing a routine lobotomy of the charges, let’s take a quick look at opportunity costs.  While an assistant United States Attorney traverses the United States in search of a 5 year old girl, six years of the government’s investigative resources go into nailing Mel and his partners.  The announced purpose for this dedication of scarce resources to the plague of class action litigation is to make our courthouses safe for the fair distribution of attorneys fees. 

As recently noted at I was the State, the government can’t afford a Drug Enforcement Administration and a Child Molester Administration.  But they have enough juice left to go after Mel Weiss.  Is it just me, or does anyone else think this particular administration’s decision to point its guns at this successful class-action law firm has anything to do with, oh, a particular agenda about “frivolous lawsuits,” that most nefarious offense to the health and safety of big business in America?

And so, numerous trees have already been murdered in pursuit of Mel Weiss for this “kickback” scheme.  According to the government, an attorney paid plaintiffs to be plaintiffs.  Shocking!  They received a percentage of the attorneys fees paid out as a subterfuge of . . . referral attorneys fees!  Very shocking!  And it involved $11 Million!  Oh Boy!  Like contestants on Wheel of Fortune, I can hear people yelling, “Big Money, Big Money,” all across America.

As former United States District Judge cum Attorney General, Michael Mukasey asked me after hearing the Government’s idea of a plea deal, “Is that a crime?”  No one, to my knowledge, has alleged that Millberg Weiss in general, or Mel Weiss in particular, sued any corporation for anything that didn’t actually happen.  No one, to my knowledge, has alleged that the allegations of corporate wrong-doing, resulting in the $250 Million in settlements, didn’t actually happen.  They just don’t like where the money went. 

As for the “Big Money,” the claim of $11 Million is, well, underwhelming.  The government has always used its most fertile imagination when it comes to assessing a loss value in criminal prosecutions.  A $5 bag of pot becomes part of a $20 Million conspiracy in a federal courtroom.  Even so, the word “million” is tossed about so often in the United States Attorneys offices around the country as to make every criminal sound like Rockefeller.  In the scheme of federal prosecution loss values, $11 Million is the tip to the cab driver.

But why, if this whole conspiracy is such a tempest in a teapot, did Bill Lerach take a plea, and former partner David Bershad the new Sammy “The Bull” Gravano turn rat?  Well, this is the sad reality of scared “white collar” defendants guided by “scared” white shoe pretend criminal defense lawyers, who just can’t face up to a fight.  It’s the domino theory “white collar,” with the Sentencing Guidelines held over the head of a sniveling pseudo-criminal, who then feeds the myth of grand conspiracies and brings his ex-brothers down with him.  It’s like shooting fish in a barrel, which is the government’s favorite way to fish.

And one additional detail.  According to the government, the Millberg firm netted “$250 Million in fees over the past 25 years.”  Do the math.  That’s $10 Million a year for the whole firm.  Mel Weiss couldn’t keep himself in shoe laces for that pittance.  It didn’t pay for the white-out needed to cover up the referral fees.  Big money?

If all this smells like a civil action, with some potential attorney disciplinary thrown in for its scare factor, at worst, then why is our government putting so much of its energy into saving the people of the United States from Mel Weiss?  Maybe it’s not the people that are being saved, but the nearest and dearest friends of our Government.  After all, what’s good for GM is good for America.