Often, more fascinating than the news itself are the reactions. Criminal defense lawyers win or lose based on their ability to gage the reactions of others, barely known to them. While we may feel or react in a certain way to events around us, and even trying to gage our reactions is akin to cat-herding, it is critical that we have a feel for the reactions of others. On the tasing (tasering?) of
Andrew Meyer, 21 year old journalism student at the University of Florida, how far did I miss the mark?
Yesterday’s
post, with videos included, expressed my outrage at the use of force. Not because this is the most heinous use of force that I’ve ever known about, or even because it was so unusual that police use force to subdue a person for convenience (indeed, tasers are used for that purpose with relative frequency), but because we rarely get a videotaped view of what happened from 32 different angles. Capturing the actual event makes it so much more vivid and indisputable that we get to live it rather than hear about it.
But that’s just me. How did others react? Apparently, not everyone thought this was such a horrible thing. In fact, some people not only thought that the police were right, but took too long to nail the kid and should have taken him down a lot earlier. Why would they think this? Because, as expressly stated, he was a “jerk”.
My angst comes from some of the comments at
Concurring Opinions to this story. My impression was that readers of Co-Op are a more academically oriented bunch. They reflect law professors and students, interested in the law from the learned perspective rather than the practical. I often rag on Co-Op for that reason, but the truth is that I admire the academic view most of the time and think that it brings additional dimension to the practical world that is often missing.
So, it was shocking to find in the comments to the Co-Op post two basic trains of thought. First, they were disinclined to question police decisions. Second, they simply accepted the general proposition that if the speaker was a jerk, there was no issue with using extreme force against him. Both of these propositions strike me as so fundamentally wrong, and ignorant, that I can only pray that these commenters are not law professors in whose hands rest students’ minds. Indeed, I would be comfortable knowing that these were chronically unemployed former police officers who are now duly incarcerated with occasional access to the internet. Anything else just plain scares me.
So in turn, let’s take a gander at the ‘tudes. The reluctance to challenge police decisions comes first. Why? What possible explanation exists for putting the power of life and death, harm and safety, freedom and imprisonment, into the hands of a hundred thousand individuals that are above scrutiny?
Police have a difficult job. They are called upon to make decisions about many things, the use of force among them, as part of their job. It’s not an easy job, and even harder when one expects them to do it right. So who are we to play Monday morning quarterback?
Police officers know, from the minute they enter the Academy, that it’s a tough job with high expectations. They are taught to make difficult decisions, and are made to understand that the power they are given by society will be under constant scrutiny. If they can’t handle the job, then they ought to be something else (like lawyers?). But to suggest that they get a “free pass” because they hold a position of enormous responsibility is to entirely miss the point.
Police, like doctors and lawyers and engineers, should be subject to constant scrutiny. No one should hold the power to do harm to others without scrutiny. Who better to oversee than men and women with guns, shields and the right to use them on the citizens of the United States. The very concept that they are above “second-guessing” is a wholesale abdication of responsibility. They are precisely why such a thing as second-guessing exists. No society can place the power to strike, shoot, seize, or even taser, another person above reproach.
And then we come to the jerk factor. It is universally acknowledged that Andrew Meyer behaved poorly, although there are few opportunities for the public to ask truly uncomfortable questions of high office holders these days, and there is nothing more American that holding a politician’s feet to the fire. But that aside, there are a myriad of allegations of rude behavior, pushing to the front of the line, interrupting another questioner, pedantic speechifying, refusing to yield the floor, and of course the most curious complaint of all, failing to comply with a directive from the police. While some of the anti-Meyer allegations did not appear on any video that I saw, I can accept the idea that Andrew Meyer behaved like a jerk.
Now that the jerk factor is established (or at least accepted), what does that mean? Is behaving poorly an invitation to violence? Does it give the police the right to arrest? What about beat with clubs? Pushing to the front of the line allegation seems to have upset many. In my experience, this happens with relative frequency in school lunch lines. Should these third graders be arrested? Tackled to the ground and handcuffed for pushing? And if they yell out loud as five cops take them down, is pushing to the front enough justification for a good tasering?
But it’s not just pushing to the front, you say. He also interrupted another speaker. Fair enough. So how much violence does that invite? If we have a push plus an interruption, is that worthy of a sound thrashing? And what about the rude questioning? Push plus interruption plus rude questioning equals a forcible arrest, right? But we’re not done yet, you note. Andrew Meyer was TOLD to stop and didn’t. He did not comply.
There we have the crux of the matter. Andy had it in his hands to avoid the violence. All he had to do was comply. Compliance to authority is the difference between an unsatisfying political rant and a tasering. Finally, we arrive at the bottom line. The commenters have chosen the path of least resistance, compliance, and have elevated it above all other reactions.
The docile response to police assertion of authority is almost always the smartest path. The only time it doesn’t work out too well is when the police are about to put a bullet between your eyes and, despite the fact that compliance will make the police infinitely happier, you will end up dead no matter what you do. Then, resistance seems the better route. But otherwise, do not resist authority and all will be well.
This idea, that we must not resist authority, is the only proper course of action when faced with an order by police is perhaps the singular most unAmerican concept there can be. If accepted, we become a nation of lapdogs, compliant to a fault and submissive to the very powers that our nation was formed to fight. If one respects the Constitution and the ideals that our founding fathers sought to instill in a nascent country, then one cannot possible accept submission to authority as the only viable course.
Mind you, one points has been left out of the discussion about Andrew Meyer. He was exercising his first amendment right of free speech to express himself in a fashion that was clearly unpopular in that room and to the police who were charged with maintaining order. What hap
pened that day, up until the moment that Meyer was unceremoniously tasered, was the classic clash of law and order. This situation should be presented to every law student for the next 50 years to reflect how the 1st Amendment creates a conflict with orderly process, and what it means to have a government that cannot stop unpopular political speech. The very discomfort of Andrew Meyer’s handling of his time in front of the microphone was precisely what the framers of the Constitution had in mind when challenging the new government, like the old of King George, to put a muzzle on speech it didn’t like. And then we watched as the police, with the power given them by society, did exactly that.
And when it was over, and he was on the ground, and he was handcuffed, a female police officer calmly and deliberately placed a semi-non-lethal device, that causes great pain, against Andrew Meyer and, without any further ado, inflicted that great pain. And then the only sound to be heard was Andrew Meyer’s screams of pain and the gasps of the audience.
I wonder how many U of F students will remember what happened 20 years from now. And when confronted with the choice of whether to submit to authority or resist, will think of the screams of pain of Andrew Meyer, and decide not to exercise their right to express their disagreement with a high office holder in the United States government. But for the commenters at Co-Op, it’s all worth it. After all, the guy was a jerk.