Author Archives: SHG

Mandatory Attendance Lands Simple Justice in the National Law Journal

While I’ve done more than my time in the media, my little blawg is still a media virgin.   Until now.  The September 24th issue of the National Law Journal will carry a story about the running debate (you remember it, don’t you?) over mandatory law school attendance.

The story is really more about the efforts of the law profs over at Co-Op who have come up with the new battle cry, Law Students Are Adults!  Catchy, right?  They have a great pic of Dave Hoffman, and another prof, Rafael Pardo, who agrees with me that law students should actually go to law school.  No picture of me, but knowing what I look like, that’s understandable.

But ever the nay-sayer, they tossed Simple Justice into the piece for a little balance.  After all, it’s all about fair and balanced here at Simple Justice.  Ahem.

LawBizBlog to Blawgers: You’re All Just a Bunch of Mercenaries

Ed Poll of LawBizBlog takes issue with my disagreeable post about using ghostwriters to blawg.  After chastising me for putting words in his mouth, Ed writes: 
Lawyers use the blawging process to communicate their existence to the world – to express their expertise so as to make prospective clients aware of them … and, hopefully, to become clients. If this is true, and I believe it to be and can point to many examples, then it is a marketing tool.


Gee whiz, and I put words in your mouth? 

I’m absolutely sure that there are bloggers (or blawgers, as I prefer) who write (or pay someone else to write for them, as Ed promotes) as a marketing tool.  But Ed, you’re a marketer.  You see the world and all its wonderful things as merely potential marketing tools.  Pretty flowers, and significant concepts, are mere weapons for the marketer to sell, sell, sell. 

But don’t project your view on me.  I realize that your focus may not allow you to see any purpose to doing anything if not to market, but that small world in yours, not mine.  And there are others who, like me, don’t sit down at their computer every day to try to figure out some new way to sell themselves to potential clients by writing on their blawg.  Yes, some do, but not all.

I don’t begrudge the market savvy lawyer his effort to use a blawg to promote himself.  But don’t begrudge the rest of us our blawging for the sake of expression.  There really are pure hearts in this blawgosphere who post for no better reason than to right wrongs, express views and find an outlet for our opinions. 

So why does your position on hiring a ghostwriter to blog for an attorney give rise to such a strong reaction here?  Because it demeans what those of us who are not soulless self-aggrandizing scamming marketers do, and calls into question the entire blawgosphere, both in motive and content.  Must I prove to readers that I really wrote what appears after my name?  Must my bona fides in expressing opinions be suspect because some marketer is out there telling attorneys that blawgs are nothing more than client-grabbers? 

In fact, maybe I’m some out of work journalist wannabe writing this for some guy named Greenfield who wants to pretend that he really gives a damn and these are really his views, reducing everything here to some fictional world of self-promotion via the pretense of anti-self-promotion.  Talk about Machiavellian!  I’m a genius.

This is not like a brief written by an associate under my name, as you try to spin in your example.  Work product for a client is not an expression of personal opinion designed to reflect the views, opinions and inherent credibility of a specific person.  It is work for hire for the purpose of presenting a client’s argument.  This blawg is not.  This blawg purports to be written by my hand, you can bet your bottom dollar that’s exactly what it is.  If my associate wants to write something, he can go to Overlawyered and try his hand.  This blawg is mine.

So here’s the bottom line, Ed.  There will always be people who will take something that is offered at face value and turn it into a cynical scam for the purpose of personal gain and at the expense of credibility. This is big business in Nigeria, by the way.  But don’t project that manipulative motive on me.  You write for your purposes.  I’ll write for mine.  But don’t taint my efforts as being some happy mercenary scheme designed to suck in clients.  Not everyone falls into that little world where nothing is done if not for personal gain.

“But I Meant To Kill Him” and Other Explanations

A few days ago, I posted about the partial reversal in People v. Flores.  Some other blogs pick up on it, like Windypundit, and  Newsday published a story on the case.  It took a few days, but then Mike Cernovich sent the link over to Orin Kerr at the Volokh Conspiracy, and suddenly there was a huge flurry of interest in the case.  Apparently, Volokh has a few more readers than Simple Justice.  Go figure.

While it’s great that word about this systemic fiasco is spreading, there is a proportionate spread of misapprehension as the story broadens to lawyers from other jurisdictions and non-lawyers, and consequential trend toward “solutions” that don’t apply.

First, make no mistake about it, everyone connected with the Flores trial has a finger deep into this failure.  From prosecutor to defense lawyers to judge to court clerk, each one played an important role in securing a failure.  For those who want to blame one side or the other, there are no heroes in this trial (except possibly the data input clerk who spilled the beans).

Second, for those screaming that someone should notify the “state bar association,” welcome to New York.  The New York State Bar Association plays no role in attorney licensing or discipline, and is merely a membership association with exorbitant dues.  Attorney discipline is handled by the Appellate Divisions, of which there are 4 Departments covering different geographic areas in New York State.  Each has its own disciplinary committee, that investigates and recommends sanctions.  The process is private until such time as a public sanction (either public censure or disbarment) is issued.  It can’t be assumed that the Second Department has or has not referred the attorneys in this matter to the committee, and there’s no way to find out since it is a confidential process. 

That said, complaints to the disciplinary committees with regard to misconduct by prosecutors has routinely been dismissed out of hand.  One complaint, against former Westchester District Attorney and bride of a convicted felon, Jeanine Pirro, based upon improper media comments immediately following an arrest (meaning that there was a ton of indisputable evidence of impropriety) was unceremoniously tossed.  So the many outraged commenters may be filled with righteous indignation, but unless you happen to sit on the appropriate disciplinary committee, don’t expect much.  This, unfortunately, reflects another systemic problem.

And for those of you still reading, now a little New York law.  Flores was charged with two counts of Murder in the Second, one under the theory of intentional murder and another under the theory of depraved indifference murder.  During the pendency of the case, the Court of Appeals (New York’s highest court) decided People v. Payne.  This was a blockbuster decision that changed the legal landscape for murder prosecutions.

The Payne decision held that “depraved indifference,” which had invariably been charged together with intentional murder as a backup, could almost never co-exist with an intentional murder because it reflected a distinct mental state.  Before Payne, the view of depraved indifference was that it related to the circumstances surrounding the murder rather than the mental state of the defendant.  This blew a major hole in murder indictments across New York, where depraved indifference was charged to cover a potential failure of proof on intent and provide a compromise to a jury.  Mind you, it was still Murder in the Second Degree, same sentence and same impact, but juries tend to like to compromise because it makes them feel more reasonable.

Also, the current District Attorney of Nassau County, New York, Kathleen Rice, has come under attack for what happened here.  Indeed she should, but only to the extent of decisions made while she was in office.  When this case was tried, the District Attorney was Denis Dillon, a former Democrat turned Republic in a county where the last remaining Republican machine held ironclad control until broken by Tom Suozzi in 2001.  Partisan politics in Nassau County is vicious, and one should not put too much stock in any allegations by one side against the other. 

Kathleen Rice was a former Kings County (Brooklyn) Assistant District Attorney who had moved on to the United States Attorney’s office in Philadelphia.  She was plucked from obscurity by Suozzi to run against District Attorney-for-life Dillon, and rode Suozzi’s coattails to victory.  While she played no role during the period when Flores was tried and sentenced, her office made the decision to pursue an affirmance on appeal of the Flores conviction.  But more than that, knowing that appellate attorney Dick Barbuto would not be appearing for oral argument, Rice’s office still appeared and argued.  This never happens.  Except in this case.

Finally, there has been some criticism of Barbuto for his not “finding somebody to argue” when he couldn’t because of his loss of sight.  This criticism is misguided.  Dick Barbuto did not learn that the Appellate Division would not adjourn oral argument until one day before, when he was told that “oral argument is a privilege, not a right, and the Court doesn’t need argument anyway.” 

Despite the fact that Barbuto was going through his twelfth eye surgery to regain his sight (not that nice lasik stuff, but real eye surgery with scalpels and needles), he nonetheless considered having someone try to pick up the pieces and argue the case.  Aside from the logistical problem of getting briefs to someone for argument the next day, having them read and familiarize themselves with the case and the law, and prepare for argument, a strategic decision was made that the appellate brief for Flores was very strong and the Second Department was very rarely moved by oral argument, its refusal to permit an adjournment, under the very peculiar circumstances presented, would create an additional appellate issue in the event of an affirmance.  Thus, while it wouldn’t be expected that a commenter on a blog would either know this much, or think this hard, about what to do, Dick Barbuto bears no blame here.

UPDATE:  I’ve just learned that there is one factual error in my original post and the Newsday story on this case.  The original ADA, Martin Meaney, was demoted prior to trial and was replaced by ADA Greg Turkin, who was subsequently fired when Kathleen Rice took office.

Jerk in the First Degree

Often, more fascinating than the news itself are the reactions.  Criminal defense lawyers win or lose based on their ability to gage the reactions of others, barely known to them.  While we may feel or react in a certain way to events around us, and even trying to gage our reactions is akin to cat-herding, it is critical that we have a feel for the reactions of others.  On the tasing (tasering?) of Andrew Meyer, 21 year old journalism student at the University of Florida, how far did I miss the mark?

Yesterday’s post, with videos included, expressed my outrage at the use of force.  Not because this is the most heinous use of force that I’ve ever known about, or even because it was so unusual that police use force to subdue a person for convenience (indeed, tasers are used for that purpose with relative frequency), but because we rarely get a videotaped view of what happened from 32 different angles.  Capturing the actual event makes it so much more vivid and indisputable that we get to live it rather than hear about it.

But that’s just me. How did others react?  Apparently, not everyone thought this was such a horrible thing.  In fact, some people not only thought that the police were right, but took too long to nail the kid and should have taken him down a lot earlier.  Why would they think this?  Because, as expressly stated, he was a “jerk”.

My angst comes from some of the comments at Concurring Opinions to this story.  My impression was that readers of Co-Op are a more academically oriented bunch.  They reflect law professors and students, interested in the law from the learned perspective rather than the practical.  I often rag on Co-Op for that reason, but the truth is that I admire the academic view most of the time and think that it brings additional dimension to the practical world that is often missing.

So, it was shocking to find in the comments to the Co-Op post two basic trains of thought.  First, they were disinclined to question police decisions.  Second, they simply accepted the general proposition that if the speaker was a jerk, there was no issue with using extreme force against him.  Both of these propositions strike me as so fundamentally wrong, and ignorant, that I can only pray that these commenters are not law professors in whose hands rest students’ minds.  Indeed, I would be comfortable knowing that these were chronically unemployed former police officers who are now duly incarcerated with occasional access to the internet.  Anything else just plain scares me.

So in turn, let’s take a gander at the ‘tudes.  The reluctance to challenge police decisions comes first.  Why?  What possible explanation exists for putting the power of life and death, harm and safety, freedom and imprisonment, into the hands of a hundred thousand individuals that are above scrutiny? 

Police have a difficult job.  They are called upon to make decisions about many things, the use of force among them, as part of their job.  It’s not an easy job, and even harder when one expects them to do it right.  So who are we to play Monday morning quarterback? 

Police officers know, from the minute they enter the Academy, that it’s a tough job with high expectations.  They are taught to make difficult decisions, and are made to understand that the power they are given by society will be under constant scrutiny.  If they can’t handle the job, then they ought to be something else (like lawyers?).   But to suggest that they get a “free pass” because they hold a position of enormous responsibility is to entirely miss the point. 

Police, like doctors and lawyers and engineers, should be subject to constant scrutiny.  No one should hold the power to do harm to others without scrutiny.  Who better to oversee than men and women with guns, shields and the right to use them on the citizens of the United States.  The very concept that they are above “second-guessing” is a wholesale abdication of responsibility.  They are precisely why such a thing as second-guessing exists.  No society can place the power to strike, shoot, seize, or even taser, another person above reproach.

And then we come to the jerk factor.  It is universally acknowledged that Andrew Meyer behaved poorly, although there are few opportunities for the public to ask truly uncomfortable questions of high office holders these days, and there is nothing more American that holding a politician’s feet to the fire.  But that aside, there are a myriad of allegations of rude behavior, pushing to the front of the line, interrupting another questioner, pedantic speechifying, refusing to yield the floor, and of course the most curious complaint of all, failing to comply with a directive from the police.  While some of the anti-Meyer allegations did not appear on any video that I saw, I can accept the idea that Andrew Meyer behaved like a jerk.

Now that the jerk factor is established (or at least accepted), what does that mean?  Is behaving poorly an invitation to violence?  Does it give the police the right to arrest?  What about beat with clubs?  Pushing to the front of the line allegation seems to have upset many.  In my experience, this happens with relative frequency in school lunch lines.  Should these third graders be arrested?  Tackled to the ground and handcuffed for pushing?  And if they yell out loud as five cops take them down, is pushing to the front enough justification for a good tasering?

But it’s not just pushing to the front, you say.  He also interrupted another speaker.  Fair enough.  So how much violence does that invite?  If we have a push plus an interruption, is that worthy of a sound thrashing?  And what about the rude questioning?  Push plus interruption plus rude questioning equals a forcible arrest, right?  But we’re not done yet, you note.  Andrew Meyer was TOLD to stop and didn’t.  He did not comply.

There we have the crux of the matter.  Andy had it in his hands to avoid the violence.  All he had to do was comply.  Compliance to authority is the difference between an unsatisfying political rant and a tasering.  Finally, we arrive at the bottom line.  The commenters have chosen the path of least resistance, compliance, and have elevated it above all other reactions.

The docile response to police assertion of authority is almost always the smartest path.  The only time it doesn’t work out too well is when the police are about to put a bullet between your eyes and, despite the fact that compliance will make the police infinitely happier, you will end up dead no matter what you do.  Then, resistance seems the better route.  But otherwise, do not resist authority and all will be well.

This idea, that we must not resist authority, is the only proper course of action when faced with an order by police is perhaps the singular most unAmerican concept there can be.  If accepted, we become a nation of lapdogs, compliant to a fault and submissive to the very powers that our nation was formed to fight.  If one respects the Constitution and the ideals that our founding fathers sought to instill in a nascent country, then one cannot possible accept submission to authority as the only viable course.

Mind you, one points has been left out of the discussion about Andrew Meyer.  He was exercising his first amendment right of free speech to express himself in a fashion that was clearly unpopular in that room and to the police who were charged with maintaining order.  What hap
pened that day, up until the moment that Meyer was unceremoniously tasered, was the classic clash of law and order.  This situation should be presented to every law student for the next 50 years to reflect how the 1st Amendment creates a conflict with orderly process, and what it means to have a government that cannot stop unpopular political speech.  The very discomfort of Andrew Meyer’s handling of his time in front of the microphone was precisely what the framers of the Constitution had in mind when challenging the new government, like the old of King George, to put a muzzle on speech it didn’t like.  And then we watched as the police, with the power given them by society, did exactly that. 

And when it was over, and he was on the ground, and he was handcuffed, a female police officer calmly and deliberately placed a semi-non-lethal device, that causes great pain, against Andrew Meyer and, without any further ado, inflicted that great pain.  And then the only sound to be heard was Andrew Meyer’s screams of pain and the gasps of the audience.

I wonder how many U of F students will remember what happened 20 years from now.  And when confronted with the choice of whether to submit to authority or resist, will think of the screams of pain of Andrew Meyer, and decide not to exercise their right to express their disagreement with a high office holder in the United States government.  But for the commenters at Co-Op, it’s all worth it.  After all, the guy was a jerk.

Elimination of Annoyances by Force

In an absolutely remarkable video (courtesy of Underdog), an annoying and disruptive audience member challenges Senator John Kerry, until the forces of law and order decide to protect the sensitive ears of a Senator and his audience by forcibly seizing the questioner, wrestling him to the ground, hand-cuffing him and, because this kid just didn’t have the common courtesy of shutting his mouth on demand, was tasered.  You MUST watch this video.





Jon Katz at Underdog has written previously on the inappropriate use of Tasers, and the police misapprehension that a Taser is just an easy way to shut people down when they have the audacity to not do whatever cops tell them to do.

This video clip is shocking.  Sure, the speaker was annoying.  He was disruptive.  It was not his platform to monopolize.  He was rude.  But that doesn’t mean he should be subjected to being tasered for it. 

Was any of this necessary?  Did they need to wrestle him to the floor and handcuff him?  Was he threatening anyone with harm or violence, or was he talking too long, too loud and too aggressively to make the others comfortable? 

The speaker was clearly rude, and the video shows the crowd support the police putting an end to his rant.  But this devolved so quickly into the physical, and then into a physical assault on the speaker.  He assaulted no one.  He threatened no one with physical harm.  It is an outrage that those people in whom we vest the power to use force against others will do so just because they can.  And so casually. 

As the news stories develop, this comment has come out:
Orlando said university police would conduct an internal investigation.

“The police department does have a standard procedure for when they use force, including when they use a Taser,” Orlando said. “That is what the internal investigation would address — whether the proper procedures were followed, whether the officers acted appropriately.”

What standard procedure could they possibly have that involves the calm, deliberate use of force against someone whose only offense is not jumping as high as the cops demand? 

What makes a cop think that when they say jump, people must obey like dogs or they have the right to harm them?  What right did that cop have to harm a person because he didn’t comply.  I’ve seen people charged for decades with the capital offense of disobeying a “lawful order.”  How dare people not do whatever they are told by a cop.  This is America!  If a cop tells you to get on your knees and suck, you better damn well suck or bear the consequences.   How many people must be tasered, or shot, or beaten, for their failure to do as they are told by men with guns and shields.  Just because they can.  Here’s another view:





I realize that I’ve added little to the discussion on this video, but I am just so outraged by what happened that I wanted as many people as possible to see it. 



ACLU — We Have Nothing Better to Do

With thanks for Jon Katz at Underdog, we learn that the ACLU has quietly filed an amicus brief in support of Sen. Larry Craig, challenging the Minnesota disorderly conduct law under the First Amendment.  It must have been a really, really slow day over at the ACLU.

Please don’t misunderstand.  I can appreciate why the ACLU steps forward in the ugliest of cases, for the most unsavory of defendants, in order to defend the Constitution when applied to society’s most despised members.  I admire (usually) the integrity of what they do, if not its particular application.  And I appreciate that they step forward when everyone else is stepping back, especially because these defendants lack the wherewithal to have competent representation, making their amicus involvement particularly important.

But that’s not Larry Craig.  He’s got top notch legal talent pimping his cause.  He may be ridiculed for his personal hypocrisy, but he’s hardly comparable to Nazis in Skokie (No, he’s not).   No doubt the biggest factor that played in the mind of the ACLU decision-makers was that this was a high profile (albeit legally trivial) case that would get the ACLU back to a place it hasn’t visited in a while, the public’s eye.

Is that it?  Is this a grab for headlines by the ACLU?  Then why didn’t they file this amicus brief with great fanfare, waving American flags and letting the world know that they stand behind arch-conservative Republican pseudo-homophobes just like Nazis?  And yet they didn’t.

Perhaps this was a cynical ploy to capture the heart of the Bush administration by doing everything they could to help the Republicans maintain standing in the Senate, and thereby support the administration’s Iraq war surge?  If there’s faith based funding available, then shouldn’t the ACLU show a little faith?  Sorry, but I can’t see this happening no matter how many briefs they file.

So what is the point of this amicus showing?  My best guess is that it is simply an opportunity to stand up for the First Amendment despite the despicable nature of the defendant.  But this is where I have some trouble with the ACLU.  As Larry Craig puffs his self-righteousness, there are literally thousands of defendants across America who need the help that the ACLU could bring to their case.  They lack the resources to buy top defense lawyers.  They lack the personal prestige and clout that comes with being a United States Senator.  But they are still human being, being charged under bad laws or bad applications of laws.

Hey ACLU, where are you?  Why don’t you spend your time looking for all the little shmos out there who won’t get you headlines but need some backup?  Do you care about the little guys?  Is it all about the law and the Constitution?  Well, it applies to no-name defendants just like it applies to Larry Craig. 

If the ACLU has so much free time on its hands that it can submit an amicus brief in support of Larry Craig’s guilty plea withdrawal, then this country must be serving up some great justice to every man, woman and child across America.  If not, then the ACLU better start taking a hard look around and find itself some defendants to support beyond the few high profile, easy mark targets.  Seriously, ACLU, find a better use of your time or give it up.  This case is not where you should be.

The Practical Blawgosphere: The Scam Factor

Lawbizblog raised a bit of a storm when it promoted the idea that busy lawyers should get someone else to ghostwrite their blogs.  Mark Bennett castigated the idea, as did Steve Gustitis.  My first thought was that it was so fundamentally wrong as to be unworthy of comment.  My second thought was that it required comment because it was so fundamentally wrong.

While I agree wholeheartedly with Mark and Steve, I view this from a somewhat different perspective.  To Ed Poll at Law Biz Blog, this is just another marketing opportunity for lawyers.  Nothing more.  From the law biz perspective, I suppose that’s true.  But from where I sit, this is a cynical, destructive understanding of what blawging is about and it sickens me.

I’m truly sick and tired of those people whose view of the world centers on the mercenary.  Maybe Ed sees no point in doing anything unless there’s a sheckle in it for him.  Maybe he sits at home, along in a room, late at night, rubbing dollar bills over his body and getting excited.  I don’t know Ed, so I can only speculate from his writing that he sees the world through purely cynical eyes. 

This is not only the sort of world view that brings disrepute to lawyers (and other senscient beings), but one that reduces all of us to the lowest common denominator, feeding those who would believe that the law is merely another scam intended to separate client from his money.

I reject Ed’s view.  I am disgusted by Ed’s view.  I will not be tainted by the fact that Ed sees no point to any of this unless it produces a revenue stream.  And just because Ed thinks that there is no purpose to setting words to computer screen unless it markets one’s wares does not mean that this reflects anyone other than Ed’s point of view.

In the practical blawgosphere, we have discussed (and even had polls) on the subject of why we blawg.  Some (indeed many) are Public Defenders, who by definition have no financial interest at stake.  Others are professors who aren’t looking for clients.  Still others, private lawyers who do enjoy the largess of private clients, blawg because there are idea in our heads and we needed an outlet to express them. 

If you read these blawgs, much of what we write has nothing to do with marketing, even in the most abstract sense.  Indeed, some of our posts are anti-marketing, in which our posts are more likely to chase away potential clients than attract them.  We don’t post about how wonderful we are and why clients should hire us.  We don’t post about how we are the ginchiest lawyers in town, or how our competition is only half the lawyer we are.  We just post.  We do it because we see, hear or read things and it makes us want to write something.  We have opinions (sometimes more opinions than we should) and we feel the compulsion to express them.  And if nobody wants to read what we write, it wouldn’t change a thing.  We still write because it’s what we do.

Given the foregoing, the concept of “ghostwriting” a blawg is utterly pointless.  If you fall into the Ed camp, and carefully craft your blawg and posts to maximize its marketing impact, then have someone ghostwrite for you.  Hell, just steal posts from others and pretend that they’re yours.  What’s the difference.  It doesn’t mean a thing beyond whether you can scam some potential client into believing that the lawyer he or she thinks he sees on the blawg is worth throwing money at. 

But make no mistake.  It reduces blawging to a scam.  Must everything be reduced to a scam, to its most cynical and worthless level?  If that’s where you want to be, or where you belong, then so be it.  But stay away from here.

Johnny Unitas Busted!

Well, no.  Johnny Unitas wasn’t busted.  In fact, he’s no longer susceptible to arrest because “The Golden Arm” died in 2002.  But if he had burst into a hotel room to get back stolen mementos, you can bet your bottom dollar that he still wouldn’t have been busted.  He would have been toasted!

The more likely headline would have read, “America’s Hero Breaks Up Theft Ring,” except in the New York Post, which would have read, “Unitas Searching for Paris Hilton.”  Had it been any other football player of any repute, from Peyton Manning to Walter Peyton, they would have made him a hero for being man enough to go into a hotel room full of memento thieves and taking them back.  But not OJ.

What OJ did, or did not do, in the Vegas Hotel Room has yet to be seen.  But just as this entire scenario would have played so vastly different if it was any other player, so to was it assured that OJ would leave that hotel room as the perp.  The only question around Vegas is whether Mayor Oscar Goodman will leave office to represent OJ at trial.  Odds are currently against it, 3:2.

We have written before, notably in the Paris Hilton situation, about the “message” sent when a celebrity gets sent to jail.  OJ Simpson, however, is on the notorious side of celebrity, though likely the most famously notorious celebrity in America today. 

What’s so wrong with OJ having his antique dealer friend set up a sting to recapture stolen mementos?  Doesn’t America love self-help, especially when it means getting the bad guy and returning stolen artifacts to their rightful owner?  That’s a good thing.  Except when it’s OJ.  

Wasn’t there a gun in the room?  Well, if OJ was packing, that could change things.  But it’s beginning to look like OJ never had a gun, at least according to one witness in the room who spoke out today.  So whether there was an armed robbery, or any intent to rob anyone at all, appears to be highly suspect.

But this was OJ.  No matter what, OJ is the bad guy.  Anybody else and we’d be celebrating a Charles Bronson victory.  When it’s OJ, he’s got to be bad. 

Of all the things about this story, there’s one that is unfathomable.  OJ is being held without bail.  Is that because OJ is likely to run off to Bolivia?  Almost every person in Vegas is an inherent flight risk, but of all the people in the local hoosegow, OJ is probably the only one who has no place to run.  Where would OJ go? 

If a crime was committed, and if OJ was the perpetrator of the crime, then it should be dealt with.  The same as with anyone else.  But when everything involving OJ is out of control, then it’s just plain wrong.  He was acquitted in a court and convicted in the eyes of Americans.  Get over it.  Now treat him like a real person with real rights.  Can you imagine any defendant in America who is less capable of receiving a fair trial than OJ.

It Takes a Thief

To learn how to be a thief.  According to this report, Michael W. Hobbs of Whacko, Kentucky was struggling to find a learned occupation until he began watching the Discovery Channel show, It Takes a Thief. 

This show has two ex-cons show how a house can be broken, entered and stripped in a flash.  I’ve seen it, and wondered what kind of morons would let these two guys into their homes.  They trash the place, destroy whatever they have of value, and then claim that it’s some bizarre abject lesson in how easy the house would be to a professional thief. 

And there lies the point.  What makes one a professional thief?   Does he go to college for it?  Is it to distinguish the pro from the amateur?  Perhaps it has some to do with the vocation, advocation distinction. 

Well, in Kentucky, one apparently becomes a professional thief by watching TV.   Mr. Hobbs received a 12 year sentence for his string of burglaries.  He hopes to use his time wisely, and that the series isn’t canceled during his tenure.  He hopes to eventually get a Th.D.

As If Sleeping During Trial Wasn’t Bad Enough

It used to be that New York lawyers could safely razz Texas lawyers because they put people to death while the defense lawyer slept.  Ah, the good old days.  At least sleeping lawyers were in the courtroom.

According to the Second Circuit, however, you should feel lucky if your lawyer is fast asleep.  At least he’s in the courtroom.  Azzeaz Saleh had to make do with his lawyer out to lunch.  Literally.

According to the decision, the trial judge, Richard Arcara, told counsel to return from lunch at a quarter to two.  Mr. Saleh’s lawyer, however, Matthew Pynn, somehow became confused and thought he had until 2:15 (the normal time to resume trial after lunch, by the way).  When Mr. Pynn arrived at the courtroom, a crucial witness was already on the stand and testifying about Mr. Saleh purchasing contraband cigarettes.   Mr. Pynn felt very badly, though adequately sated.

The Circuit, in its tripartite wisdom, noted that there are two prongs to the Strickland test.  It was not enough that Mr. Saleh’s lawyer had failed to appear, but that he prove that he was prejudiced by Mr. Pynn’s absence. 

In Tippins v. Walker, 77 F.3d 682 (2d Cir. 1996), a defendant sought a new trial on the grounds that his attorney slept through significant parts of the trial.

In Tippins, the circuit said it was reluctant “to extend a rule of per se prejudice in any new direction,” adding that “[o]ordinarily, episodes of inattention or slumber are perfectly amenable to analysis under the Strickland prejudice test.”

Are there that many episodes of slumber?  Am I the only one staying awake throughout trial? 

Now I can far better understand a lawyer getting back late from lunch, particularly when the time for return set by the court is unusual (as here).  It’s not excusable, but understandable.  But I have a real problem when sleeping through trial becomes so common as to be “perfectly amendable to analysis” under Strickland.

And why not make it a per se rule?  Does anyone question whether it’s wrong?  Does anyone argue that attendance by lawyers at trial is voluntary?  There are two immutable characteristics of both sleeping and showing up.  First, if you’re asleep or not there, you can’t represent your client.  Second, if you’re asleep or not present, the trial judge ought to know about it.  Thus, it can be addressed right there and then, rather than “discovered” on appeal. 

Showing prejudice, other than as a rhetorical matter, is very difficult bordering on the impossible.  After all, there’s no way to show what would have happened had the ineffectiveness not happened.  Would there have been an objection, a voir dire on the evidence, something, that would have made a difference?  How many individual things happen at trial that would affect the outcome at all?  It’s sheer speculation.

But still we expect attorneys to be attorneys, do their job, stay awake and show up, all the way through the trial.  It’s just not that hard to do.  While the Second Circuit is clearly hesitant to give defendants a back door on appeal, defendants really deserve better than this.  If the Court of Appeals won’t give it to them, then who?