Author Archives: SHG

The Sanctity of Privilege versus Big Signs

Over at Grits for Breakfast, the question was posed whether it was wrong that defendants awaiting trial should have their telephone calls with their lawyers recorded.  When I first read the post, it struck me as a no-brainer.  But the wealth of comments changed my mind.

What was the sticking point to the commenters who saw no problem here?  That there were big signs over the inmate telephones informing that the calls were recorded.  And so the battle lines are drawn:  Attorney-client privilege versus big signs.

To assist the big sign advocates, I’m going to type this post particularly slowly in the hope that they will keep up.  Constitutional rights are not subject to big signs. 

Inmates awaiting trial are not yet guilty.  They have rights.  One of those rights is the right to counsel.  Within that right is the right to communicate with counsel.  And within that right is the right to keep that communication confidential.  In other words, they can speak with their lawyer without anyone else listening. 

Now there are signs over the telephones in almost every institution warning that calls may be recorded.  All attorneys know this.  But those signs apply to calls to anyone other than a lawyer.  All attorneys believe this.  So do clients.  And we tell them that the institution cannot record or listen in on our calls.  Just because they put up signs, and institute policies, does not mean that they get to record attorney phone calls. 

It’s not to say that attorneys discuss strategy on the prison phone without any thought that someone over there might “mistakenly” listen in, but there’s a very real problem that cannot be ignored.  They just won’t let our clients out of jail so they can come to our office and have a chat with us whenever we need to speak with them.  We ask.  They say no.  What to do?

Well, there are times when we need a critical piece of information in order to do our job.  Critics of privilege would suggest that we go to the jail and talk face to face (assuming that the attorney visiting rooms aren’t bugged).  But that’s a naive option at times.  Around here, some jails are quite a distance away, and take a looooong time to get into and then another loooooong time before our clients are brought down, and to ask a single question can take 5 hours out of a lawyer’s day.  It’s not feasible. 

So, talking on the phone is the only viable option.  Does that mean we take our client’s confidentiality for granted?  Not exactly, though we depend on the prisons following the rules.  That they may not is always in our minds, and so we try to be as circumspect as possible.  Sometimes, this isn’t very circumspect.

But the jails know this.  They know that attorney speak with clients.  They know that clients use the telephones to speak with their attorney.  They know that they are not supposed to record, or listen in, on defendants and attorneys talking.  They know this is wrong.  And most importantly, they know that putting up big signs does not fundamentally alter anything, thus relieving them of the duty to honor the Constitution.

So the big sign rule that makes so many of you feel that forewarned makes it fair game is a total crock.  Big signs don’t trump the Constitution.  Little ones don’t either.  And nobody has the right to record a telephone conversation between attorney and client.  End of story.

Michael Mukasey, the Next AG?

The latest front-runner in the Attorney General race is former Chief Judge of the Southern District of New York, Michael B. Mukasey.  Judge Mukasey retired from his life-tenured position less than a year ago to pursue a quiet, pastoral New York life-style in Biglaw.   Having the good fortune of being a New York lawyer and knowing Judge Mukasey, it only seemed appropriate that I chime in on the subject.  After all, former AUSA Andrew McCarthy (another old adversary of mine)  took his shot in the National Review.  Now, I want to add my support for Judge Mukasey.

During his last year on the bench, I had a case before Judge Mukasey.  It went through a hard-fought suppression hearing, where my client risked the enhancement for obstruction of justice by doing the unthinkable, challenging the veracity of a federal agent.  The defendant, who had a criminal history level of 4, was tired of letting cops and agents lie about what happened without anyone taking them to task.  He was getting on in years, and wanted to take a stand.  It was a dream for a criminal defense lawyer, being in the position of fighting the good fight, risking everything for the truth with a client who knew which end was up and still willing to take his chances. 

My experience before Judge Mukasey left me with three distinct impressions.  First, he was highly intelligent.  Second, he was a judge of integrity.  Third, he was definite federal judge material, meant in that slightly sarcastic yet pejorative sense.

Before going down the path I just opened, let me remind you that it is highly unlikely that President Bush is out searching for the next Ramsey Clark to finish up the AG term, so let’s not get too crazy about the idea that the next AG is going to be someone with a bent toward Order rather than Law.  

So what do I mean by my third distinct impression?  That Judge Mukasey, who by the way has a great sense of humor, was one of those judges who would, at the end of the day, accept the clearly manufactured testimony of a government agent as true over the sworn word of a defendant unless there was smoking gun that made it 99% that the defendant was telling the truth and there was some hard evidence upon which he could hang his hat before finding that the clearly manufactured testimony was clearly manufactured.  But it’s that 1%, that slightest of cracks, that gives me faith.  After all, the federal bench is full of judges who wouldn’t even give you that much of a chance.

In arguing before Judge Mukasey, I could see the furrow of his brow (note: furrow, not furtive, as is the word most prominently enjoyed in courts) and the internal struggle he was having in reaching his decision between the testimony of the defendant and that of the agent.  Now this was not a judge who was inclined to doubt agents, believing that they serve our nation well and protect us from the various permutations of bad people who threaten our sanctity and sovereignty.  But there is no doubt in my mind that the 1% was there, and that Judge Mukasey was struggling with it.

At the end of the day, Judge Mukasey found against the defendant, and that the clearly manufactured testimony of the agent was credible.  He eschewed my argument that the defendant, who knew his way around an arrest like nobody’s business by virtue of having an enormous amount of experience in the care and handling of defendants, would be so flustered and afraid that he would have forgotten how to properly exercise his right to counsel.  He ignored the inherent conflict between the agent’s testimony that the defendant never asked to speak with his attorney, and the undisputed fact that after 6 hours in custody, the defendant was finally permitted (and did) call his attorney to alert him to the arrest. 

Given all of this, I believe that we would be fortunate at this juncture in American government to have Michael B. Mukasey as our Attorney General.  Of my three distinct impressions, the third must be discounted because there is not a shot in hell that the United States is going to get an AG whose concern for the constitutional rights of defendants supersedes their support for law enforcement and order.  And indeed, I doubt this country is ready for such an AG, given that we have yet to get past the fear and loathing caused by 9/11 and the threat of terrorism.  Even without the political “war” on terrorism, I doubt any of us are ready to let al-Qaida come to our homes for dinner. 

So Judge Mukasey comes to us as a man of utmost integrity and intelligence.  These traits are harder to find than most people realize, and I hold them in very high regard.  I do not, for a second, doubt that Judge Mukasey will stand firm against the politization of Justice, and his foremost job as AG will be to purge the taint that Alberto brought to DOJ as another political arm of the administration.  Justice needs an honest broker, and Michael Mukasey fits the bill. 

Second, that 1% crack in the armor of pro-Order means a lot to me.  One percent is a lot more than none.  As I said before, we need to have realistic expectations of who’s under consideration for this position, and the chances of getting a bible-thumping zealot are all too high, despite Harry Reid’s public denouements.  To me, that 1% reflects a real human being and that says a lot.

So to my esteemed Senators from New York, Chuck and Hillary (I know you guys read Simple Justice daily), of the luke-warm Democrat persuasion, Judge Michael Mukasey has my support and I hope he has yours as well.  I doubt we could do better, and I’m sure we could do worse.

Beware the Crazy Client

Over time, every criminal defense lawyer will find himself facing the crazy client.*  This is not the demanding client, or even the pain-in-the-butt client, but the crazy client.   The crazy client comes in two flavors, “tutti frutti” and “Everything but the” (Ben & Jerry’s, for those who aren’t aficionados).

The “tutti frutti” (T&F) client is nuts from the word go.  They may present as paranoid or delusional, whether it be grandiosity or conspiracy.  But within minutes of speaking with them, it becomes clear that their entire world is off-kilter.  They start with stories about how they have been subjected to abuse and targeted for inexplicable hatred from the President down to the clerk at DMV.  Sometimes they will tell you, with the most earnest look in their eyes, how the gamma rays have affected them.  Other times, they will assure you that they know secrets and expect Mike Wallace to knock on their door that night to reveal their secrets to the world. 

T&F clients are so sincere when the talk to you that you begin to wonder if it’s possible that they really do have secret enemies who stalk them day and night.  We tend to be unduly empathetic in this business, and hate to jump to the conclusion that somebody is severely twisted.  But the survival instinct kicks in, and you are forced to admit that the client is nutsy-fagan. 

On the other side is the “Everything But The” (EBT) client.  This is the one who presents like a regular client; not exactly sane but hardly T&F.  Hidden beneath that ordinary exterior, however, is a crazy person just waiting to burst out.  They begin with opening phrases like, “I don’t mean to sound nuts, but…”  And then they sound totally bonkers.  Ultimately, they turn into the same client, calling constantly, telling you the stories (the same stories) that have no bearing on anything resembling reality and embellishing how the world is against them. 

The trick is to figure out the EBT client up front, before you take them on like you would any other client and find yourself both (1) sucked into their world of nutsiness, and (2) headed into the great big dark hole of legal representation based upon what they tell you is happening, only to find everyone else in the courtroom laughing at you because you are defending against phantoms that exist only in your EBT client’s mind.

Whether or not you want to represent the crazy client is up to you.  If you’re a PD, you likely have little choice, unless the crazy client becomes the violent client, in which case other issues kick in.  But if you’re private, it’s entirely your choice, and you need to seriously consider the drain on your time, your energy and your personal welfare is worth it.  Sometimes they actually have the ability to retain private counsel (though often they will tell you they do, but somehow can never access their Nigerian lottery winnings when they need it), but more often they will promise the world and deliver nothing.  That saves you the trouble.

On occasion, representing the crazy client can be fulfilling, mostly when you are able to get them to understand that they need psychiatric care and are able to watch them go from nutsy to normal (whatever that means) and then deal with the legal issues that arose during their crazy stage.  Again, a personal choice of how much it means to you and whether you, at the particular point in time, are prepared to take on a client for such a non-legal purpose.

But whatever you do, understand that there are plenty of crazy clients out there, and they have a certain tendency to find themselves in legal trouble.  There’s a reason for this, and it’s not your fault (as a lawyer) that the answer to their criminal issues may be far more psychological than legal.  But you can’t make the choice if you won’t, or don’t, recognize the problem. 

* The use of medical terminology in this post is a product of my long study of, and respect for, psychiatric and psychological conditions.  Don’t use these words at home!

Commentary: Tipping the Scale of Uniformity

Back in the 60’s, we fought for the right to wear jeans to school.  The ideal of freedom of expression was paramount, and we would no longer accept our parents’ and teachers’ idea of how children should dress.  We would not be bound by conformity.  Eddy Haskel was dead and the Beav wore love beads.  Right on!

And where did it get us?  Well, plenty of good came out of those days, but some things didn’t turn out exactly as planned.  When disco replaced rock, things started going south.  Designer names on shirts and jeans replaced the rebel that fought to allow jeans in the first place.  Leave it to free enterprise and marketing to accomplish what no authoritarian figure could.

As my kids return to school, I confront another year of what’s hot and what’s not.  This was never supposed to be the point.  The ability to express oneself by one’s attire was not intended to morph into the right to show one’s status by the cache of designer labels. 

But times change, and freedom of expression has become the right to show how much money Mommy or Daddy is willing to spend on clothing and accoutrements so that the kddies can prove their worth.  What a terrible shame that this is what’s happened.

Of course, the law of unintended consequences kicked in to produce a result that was not only unanticipated, but anethma to the movement that fought against uniformity.  Be careful what you wish for…  The end result (at least for now) is class division, with the wealthy showing off and the less wealthy suffering the stigma, and pressuring their hard-working parents to waste money on designer togs so that they aren’t branded as poor by their classmates.  Like every teenage girl NEEDs a Louis Vuitton pocketbook in high school.

And so I’ve come full circle.  It’s time to return to uniforms.  Perhaps not the uniforms of old, with girls in plaid jumpers and boys in shirts and ties, but a uniform to eliminate the class warfare that exists in the hallways of public schools.  There is benefit to decorum that doesn’t interfere with the educational mission.  While the “order” part of law and order is often overrated, that lack of order sometimes proves to be a problem.  The benefit of ending the tyranny of uniformity is outweighed by the stigma of Gucci-less-ness.

And so, with great pain and deep sorrow, I hereby admit that my efforts to stop the man, free the students and make the world safe for full and unfettered personal expression for students may have overshot the mark.  And if I see another teenager with the word “Juicy” printed across her butt, I’m going to puke.  Enough already.

Appeals Court Buries the Body So No One Knows

The old saw, bad facts make bad law, doesn’t apply when a case goes so far beyond bad that it can only be called bizarre.  And so there’s the Appellate Division, Second Department, decision in People v. Flores.  This case could have been an apocryphal case, a warning to all in the system of how badly things can go wrong when all the players screw up.

Instead, the Second Department buried the monumental screw ups in a one line of the decision: 

The defendant’s conviction of depraved indifference murder (see Penal Law § 125.25[2]) must be vacated, as that count of the indictment had been dismissed by another judge prior to trial and was later mistakenly submitted to the jury by the trial judge. (citations omitted)
Yes, you read it right.  “Mistakenly submitted,” a defendant stood convicted of murder.  How could that possibly happen?  Well, you would never know from the decision as it doesn’t mention a word, not a single word, of the sordid tale of incompetence that led to a wrongful murder conviction.

This was a murder case that started out in Nassau County, New York.  In the normal course, the top count of depraved indifference murder was dismissed after the court inspected the grand jury minutes for sufficiency.  So far, great.  But from that point on, the case went downhill fast.

The Assistant District Attorney wasn’t very proud of this dismissal, so no one was told of it and the decision was buried in the file.  The defense attorney never bothered to mention anything to his client, and was subsequently replaced by a new attorney, who never bothered to read the file for the decision on motions.

The Court Clerk who marked the count dismissed did so in the wrong place, the wrong side of the file jacket.  When the case was sent to a new judge for trial, the new clerk looked in the correct place on the file jacket and saw nothing there.  The trial judge never read the file and didn’t know of the order dismissing the charge.  And the prosecutor never bothered to mention anything to anyone as the case went to trial.

And so the case was tried, and the defendant convicted of murder.  And no one knew.  Well, not exactly no one, as the Nassau County ADA knew that he had gotten a conviction for a dismissed count, but he was npt about to screw up a good conviction by dredging up bad memories.  

It took a court data input clerk, about a month after the conviction, to realize that something went wrong.  Very wrong.  So what does he do?  As an employee of the court system, he naturally notifies the District Attorney (who else would he tell?).  But this time, someone realizes that they have made a huge mistake and word spreads about the murder conviction on a dismissed count of an indictment.

And so, the Trial Judge promptly vacates the conviction and chastises all involved, himself included, for this shocking failure?  No, no.  The Trial Judge decides that it doesn’t matter.  A conviction is a conviction, even without a charge, and sentences the defendant to the maximum.  For good measure, he maxes out the defendant on the lesser counts as well.

Side note:  If the data input clerk had not noticed that something was wrong, the defendant would have spent the next 30 years of his life in prison for a murder conviction that could not legally exist.  No one would have ever known.  He would have never known.  And that would be that.

On appeal, the case was handled by my good buddy Dick Barbuto, who briefed the case and, during some discussions about the case, expressed incredulity at the pervasiveness of incompetence demonstrated by what happened to the defendant.  But he also expressed his fear that the Second Department, well known for the paucity of its decisions and its penchant for making swift work of ugly cases, would bury this one.

But the weirdness of this case didn’t end with submission of the brief.  Dick, the day after completing a murder trial in Virginia, temporarily lost his sight due to diabetes.  When the District Attorney’s brief came in on this case (that’s right, they decided to fight to hold on to the conviction on appeal), he couldn’t read it.  Dick was in the midst of undergoing numerous painful eye surgeries to regain his sight.  And Dick was determined not to let this case slide under the radar again.

The case was promptly set down for oral argument, and he made the simple request to adjourn oral argument
to the following month so that he could be there and argue.  After all, the District Attorney intended to argue.  The Court refused, telling him that oral argument was a privilege, not a right, and that if he couldn’t make it on the day set, then tough.  The District Attorney appeared for oral argument anyway.

And so Dick waited for a decision.  And waited.  Until yesterday, when a bunch of decisions from September 11th finally appeared on the Court Website.  Yes, the Second Department made the right decision, the only decision, by reversing the murder conviction that never was.  But nowhere in that decision does the Court tell the story of how the District Attorney, Defense Counsel and Trial Judge almost put a man in prison for a murder charge that didn’t exist.  And that’s how appeals courts bury the body so no one knows.

The End of Crime

& Federalism?  I was shocked to see a post by Mike that Crime & Federalism may be finished.  He says that Norm Pattis’ practice is too busy for him to blog anymore, and Mike is just burned out after 3 1/2 years.  “I feel like I’ve talked about everything interesting to talk about.”

C&F was one of the early, and best, criminal law blawgs.  Norm and Mike brought intelligence and balance to the blawgosphere, with real world insight.  If this is the end of C&F, it will be a great loss.

At the moment, there are numerous blawgs in the criminal law area.  Most, like Simple Justice, are relatively new.  Few have shown the staying power of a C&F, or Gideon’s A Public Defender.  Many blawgs start out gang-busters, then peter out pretty quickly.  It’s hard to write regularly.  It takes time.  It takes interest.  There’s no extrinsic benefit in doing it.

Mike writes about having said everything there is to say.  I would guess that he means that the struggle to find something that motivates him to write has overcome the desire.  This is a scary notion, though hardly surprising.  Some days, I have far more that I want to write about than hours in the day.  Other days, well, it’s harder.  But I’m still new at this, and I almost always find something that interests me.  Writing is my favorite way of expressing myself, and blawging is my outlet of choice.  How long that will be the case has yet to be seen.

But the blawgosphere will be poorer without Norm and Mike.  Even though there will be a number of criminal law blawgs around, there are some issues.  Some post infrequently, and without regular posting they fall off the radar.  Some are by lawyers without a great deal of legal experience, and reflect views and concerns that just aren’t of much interest to more seasoned lawyers.  Some are oriented toward academics, and offer little of practical value to a lawyer.  Some are self-aggrandizing, and serve primarily to market the lawyer’s services. 

None of these fit Norm and Mike.  Their stuff was good, interesting, practical and sophisticated.  It seems unlikely that Mike would post of the demise of Crime & Federalism without forethought, and so I suspect it is a fait accompli.  But I hope they will reconsider and keep the blawg alive.  And if they don’t, I want to invite them to come over here any time they want and post.  At the very least, Norm and Mike should know that their efforts are appreciated.

Panic Watch 2007

Sen. Larry Craig was granted a hearing on his motion to withdraw his guilty plea by a Minnesota court.  The hearing will be held September 26th, a mere 4 days before his self-imposed deadline of September 30th for clearing his name so he can continue to serve the airport bathrooms of Idaho as a United States Senator.

Remarkably, the hearing was granted a mere one day after the motion was filed, proving that courts can make decisions in less than a month.  Oddly, that failed to make any headlines.

The grant of a hearing suggests that there is an issue to be decided, and that the argument made by the Larry Craig defense team, that he rushed to plea in a panic over the threat of painful publicity or having to pay for a lawyer during the month-long panic-stricken period between arrest and plea, during which Sen. Craig avoided drinking liquids of any sort which might necessitate his use of toilet facilities in a public location where toe-tapping-good muzak might be blaring.





Will the Panic defense prevail?  Stay tuned.  Same bat time.  Same bat channel.  Will a judge issue a decision following his September 26th hearing in time for Larry Craig to get back into the race?  We can only hope.

How Many Years If You’re Acquitted?

The point of a trial is to separate the guilty from the not guilty.  Or so you thought.

From the New York Lawyer comes this fairy tale story of a 25 year old New Hampshire man who was tried and acquitted of assaulting a police officer while trying to get his pregnant fiancée to the hospital.  Yep, another pregnant woman on her way to the hospital story where they just didn’t show the cop enough respect.  After all, what’s more important.  Complying with the every whim of a police officer or getting a pregnant woman to the hospital.  You would think these pregnant women are, well, pregnant or something.  Sheesh.

Anyway, after a full and vigorous 15 minutes of deliberations, Nathaniel Gibbs was found not guilty.  And so, in the best fashion of American justice, Grafton County Judge Jean Burling found, by a preponderance of the evidence, that Gibbs was guilty of the crime for which he had just been acquitted.

No way?  Way.  You see, Gibbs received a suspended sentence in a prior case, and one of the conditions of that sentence was that Gibbs was required to maintain “good behavior.”

Burling she found by a preponderance of evidence that Gibbs’ assaulted an officer and disobeyed an officer — actions that violated the good behavior requirements of the previous suspended sentence.


So Nathaniel Gibbs fell into that little crack between burdens of proof and guilt and punishment.  It is essentially a given that when a violation of probation, or suspended sentence, or whatever it’s called from jurisdiction to jurisdiction, is based upon the allegation of the commission of a new crime, the disposition of the new case dictates the outcome of the old.  In other words, what happened here should never happen. 

While Judge Burling’s reasoning, her technical yet accurate application of the relative burden of proof, provides a basis to put Gibbs into the slammer, it is just so fundamentally wrong as to bring utter contempt to the legal system.  To put it nicely, it emits an unpleasant odor.

So for those inclined to believe that a trial is something we go through before putting a defendant in jail, you will be happy to know that in Grafton County, New Hampshire, nobody disrespects a police officer and gets away with it.  For everyone else, it would seem prudent to stay the hell out of Grafton County, New Hampshire.












“Since this is only your first offense, and you’ve been found not guilty, I’ll be lenient in my sentencing.”, Cartoon Bank, Cartoonbank, New Yorker Magazine, New Yorker Cartoon, New Yorker Cover, New Yorkistan, New Yorker 2008 Desk Diary, New Yorker Desk Diary, Naked Cartoonist, Bob Mankoff, Robert Mankoff, Roz Chast, Saul Steinberg, Peter Arno, Jack Ziegler, Leo Cullum, Lee Lorenz, Charles Barsotti, Peter Steiner, Mick Stevens, Bruce Eric Kaplan, Charles Addams, Danny Shanahan, Golf Cartoons, Baseball Cartoons, Kids Cartoons, Technology Cartoons, Money Cartoons, Business Cartoons, Cartoon licensing, Thursday's out
 

A Better Class of Criminal

     I figure my stand will bring me fewer clients, but a better class of clients.

These words from Houston Lawyer Mark Bennett will strike most people as absurd.  After all, Mark is a criminal defense lawyer, and we’re talking about criminal defendants here.  No, Mark doesn’t mean innocent clients, or clients who pay their bills.  He means exactly what he says, a better class of client.

The subject of Mark’s quote is snitches.  Rats, cooperators, stool pigeons.  Call it what you will.  He’s talking about those defendants who, when faced with the consequences of their actions, would rather talk to the government then face the music. 

The primary weapon of the United States of America in its “war” on crime, to be distinguished from its “war” on whatever else is the flavor of the month, is not crime scene investigations, nor DNA, nor surveillance cameras.  It’s snitches.  It’s the willingness of our government to adopt a criminal as their own, regardless of what the criminal has done, how evil he may be or how many people he has harmed, as their own.

Ironically, the same individual that prosecutors and law enforcement would spit on, beat to pulp in the back room, and certainly never believe a word out of his mouth, is miraculously transformed into a near-saint when he is signed up as a Confidential Informant.  Picture Sammy “The Bull” Gravano saying, “but it was only 19 murders…”

You see, the government would never call this person a snitch or rat, since those terms are too pejorative.  No siree.  They go from the defendant scum-of-the-earth to Confidential Informant in the blink of an eye.  Confidential Informant sounds like an official title.  It is better than benign, it makes them sound almost clean.  They are now doing God’s work, informing the government of bad things being done by others.

We all remember the famous line from TV character Beretta, “If you can’t do the time, don’t do the crime.”  Hey, Robert Blake took his chances and beat the rap.  This embodied the manly view of how criminals behaved.  There are no atheists in a foxhole, and no rats in a jail cell.  At least not in Beretta’s world.

But the scenery changed after 1987 when the combination of the Federal Sentencing Guidelines and the percentage of beating the wrap combined to make a 30 year theoretical sentence a very large gun to the head of a federal defendant.  And so they blinked, ran to the United States Attorney’s office and started vomiting whatever information they possessed in the hope of saving their sorry lives.  It was pathetic, and I can picture AUSA and agents chuckling as each sad, broken defendant was removed from the conference room in cuffs.

This is important,so I’ll say this again:  Neither prosecutor nor agent would believe defendant scum-of-the-earth if he told them the time of day, but the second he turns into Confidential Informant, his every utterance is as true and perfect as if spoken by the Pope.  It’s not magic.  Its self-interest.

And so the split between snitches and defendants developed, with snitches quickly becoming the predominant breed.  In the scheme of honor amongst criminals (or anyone else for that matter), the snitch was the bottom of the pyramid.

Mark Bennett speaks of representing those defendants who, despite the availability of the easy route that involves merely the sacrifice of one’s soul, chose not to give up their brothers, and mothers, and friends, but to stand and fight.  These defendants test the government.  Through their fortitude, the conduct of the government is tested.  Because of these fights, the Constitution is defended. 

It is not that these are necessarily good people.  They may well be heinous criminals.  But without them, there would be no one to challenge unlawful searches, false confessions, governmental misconduct.  Without the stand-up client, law enforcement would have free rein to run roughshod over all of us. 

There is no great skill involved in representing a snitch.  It’s a baby-sitting job, helping government prosecutors to get the story they want in the way they want it.  For self-loathing criminal defense lawyers, it may make them feel that they are ridding society of criminals, which suits their inclinations better than defending the accused.  For others, it’s merely the mechanism by which their client gets less time, trading what little integrity they might have for the hope of a few months off the tail end of their sentence. 

So when Mark wrote of a better class of client, it was about those clients who, despite all the wrong they may have done in their lives, decided that it was better to go down as an honest criminal than to sell the only thing they had left for 30 pieces of silver.  Someday, the snitch apparatus upon which the government so conveniently relies will fall out of favor and will be seen as the blight on our system of justice that it is.  Then, those lawyers, like Mark Bennett (and like me), who rejected the path to the government’s door will be better understood as the ones who stood firm for the American system of criminal justice, and who refused to facilitate the death of the Constitution. 

What’s a Warmonger Like At Home?

My dear friend Lisa DePaulo did the first interview of Donald Rumsfeld since his resignation for GQ (or as we used to call it, Gentlemen’s Quarterly).  There’s no two ways about it, Rummy is a piece of work.

Imagine a throwback to some earlier day in America, when gentlemen lived by some code of chivalry, or is it noblesse oblige.  One can’t fault his sense of duty or intelligence, though his anal compulsiveness could probably be helped with pharmaceuticals.  But this man was like the last dinosaur, pleased with himself almost to the point of being smug, and having no concern whatsoever that us lesser mortals might not understand or appreciate his vision.

And he adheres to a philosophy that is at once endearing because it’s so quaint as to be almost archaic.  At the same time, he openly acknowledges that others by definition will challenge his decisions and disagree with him.  While at first it appears that he says this to recognize that reasonable people may differ, you realize immediately that his purpose is to justify ignoring every criticism and making him untouchable.  He knows what he knows, and you are just a known unknown. 

But home life at the Rummy’s is a hoot.  They bought a beloved mule off eBay.  EBAY?   What’s his feedback?  Can you imagine having a paypal dispute with Rummy?  When he offers Lisa lunch, the choice is chicken salad or tuna salad.  No foie gras at the Rummy’s.  These are down to earth people.

I don’t want to steal all the really good stuff from the story, but it’s a terrific story and, for anyone who wants to understand why Americans die in Iraq for a lost cause, it helps to understand who ran the show.