Author Archives: SHG

The New Alford Plea


Just when you thought it was safe to approach the defense table, comes this story from the New York Lawyer.  The defendant, Daniel Lynn Alford (*two points right off the top: first, I thought the middle name was used only in death penalty cases. Second, with a middle name like Lynn, what else could he be but a defendant?), was being sentenced in Knoxville, Tennessee, for possession of less than a gram of coke and about the same of crack.

His lawyer, James Bell, gave an impassioned plea for mercy before US District Judge Leon Jordon.  Then came Alford’s opportunity to seek mercy, which he spent castigating Bell for not fulfilling his expectations.  Judge Jordon, apparently unpersuaded by Alford’s plea, and noting his continuous involvement in the criminal justice system as a violent felon spanning 17 of his 31 years, whacked Alford upside the head with a 400 month sentence.

Alford then turned to his lawyer and punched him so hard that he went flying across the defense table.  The judge appeared confident that the criminal history points were appropriate in Alford’s case, and that no further fact-finding was warranted.

On the other hand, Alford still has a case of kidnapping, torture and murder to look forward to, where his co-defendants already pled to 25. 

Bell, though stunned by the punch, required no medical attention.  He did, however, have serious reservations about representing Mr. Alford at his upcoming trial.  Alford was heard muttering, “What?  No bail pending appeal,” as he was led from the courtroom.

Sen. Larry Craig, Caught Double Dipping

Yesterday, the toe-tapping Senator from Idaho was quitting.  Today, he’s fighting.  According to this story, a call from Senator Arlen Spector changed everything.

“Fight the guilty plea,” Republican former prosecutor Spector told his brother.  And Sen. Craig responded, hiring Billy Martin, crisis manager, and former House of Representatives counsel Stan Brand (imagine how busy he must be, criminal defense lawyer to Congress) to defend him.

But wait.  Didn’t he take a plea to disorderly conduct?  Wasn’t there a plea bargain?  Did the word “guilty” come out of his mouth, without the word “not” in front of it? 

Guys, this very impressive team of high powered legal clout aside, there’s a little problem here.  You see, once you take a plea bargain and plead guilty, that’s generally considered the end of the game.  You don’t get to take the plea, see how it shakes out, and then call a do-over.

So we have the brilliant minds that have a 1 in 100 vote on all those nasty criminal laws that the Senate likes to vote on, without a lot of regard to that silly State’s rights thing.  And you guys are unaware of how this whole guilty thing works?  Come on.  Somebody on your staff had to tell you.  I’m sure there was some discussion of how criminal law plays out when you were passing on all those Supreme Court nominees.

But Sen. Craig didn’t have a lawyer when he took the plea.  Doesn’t that matter?  Well, as the courts have informed defendants over and over again, you are the master of your own fate.  You had the right to a lawyer (and one would be appointed for the good Senator from Idaho if he couldn’t afford one on his government paycheck), but you also have the right to go it alone. 

There’s the “knowing, voluntary and intelligent waiver” thing happening.  Does the Senator, one of a mere 100 people entitled to vote in the United States Senate, claim that he’s so close to brain-dead that he was incapable of a waiver?  Well, that position may well play better in Idaho than being a closet queen.

Personally, I think Larry Craig deserves a second bite of the apple.  And so does every other defendant for whom the majesty of the law didn’t turn out as well as expected.  We all remember when that shy flower, Paris Hilton, went to jail to send a message to the rest of us that even popular people are not above the law.  Now would be the perfect time for Sen. Craig to send the message to his fellow convicts everywhere that if their idea of a really good deal didn’t pan out, you get a do-over.  Go for it Larry!   

What’s the Problem with Kids Today?

Skelly, over at Arbitrary & Capricious, informs us that kids don’t want to be criminal defenders anymore.  He learned about this from a first year law student at myspace called PaperChaser, who thinks the outlook is bleak for today’s law students filling the spots of today’s defense lawyers.

The inductive reasoning aside, he’s probably got a point.  Consider that the typical law student is between 23 and 25 years old, and was born between 1982 and 1985. The nation was led by President Ronald Reagan for the eight years following his election in 1984.  The Bush I.  Of course, there was Clinton, who was a Republican light when it came to law enforcement and crime.  And now eight years of Bush II.  Notice a theme developing?

The United States has been in a perpetual “war” against crime of one sort or another for the entire lives of these students, making the prosecution of others heroic and the protection of constitutional rights the last refuge of “fringe elements.” 

So it comes as no surprise to me that law students want to spend their legal careers “helping” others by prosecuting others.  It’s all they’ve ever heard.  When you pound a message into the minds of our youth, day after day, year after year, don’t be surprised that they heard it.

But I don’t really fear that there won’t be enough lawyers willing to defend.  The many prosecution offices across the country can’t absorb all the young lawyers who want to put people in jail in the name of freedom.  There’s just not enough jobs.  So those students who have decided that criminal law is the niche for them will have to find a job somewhere, and the alternative of necessity is the defense.

Once they become a PD, they will do what all young people do:  Associate themselves with their reference group.  They will absorb the new message that defending people is not treason or heresy, but a vital part of our system.  They will learn from those who came ahead of them about the worthiness of their work, and will pass along their youthful exuberance to their peers and, later, their disciples.  It’s a natural progression.

But what of the fear that the prosecution will get first dibs, picking out the best and brightest and leaving the second-stringers to defend the bad guys?  I can’t get too worked up about that possibility either.  The “best and brightest” coming out of law school does not necessarily correlate to the best and brightest in the courtroom.  Indeed, it’s been my experience that many of law school’s shining stars don’t turn out to be very good lawyers.  Great law clerks.  Lousy lawyers.  That’s the current nature of law school.

Moreover, learning our craft doesn’t end with passage of the bar exam.  Indeed, that’s a transition where we stop learning book law and start learning real law.  The learning process continues, and unless you’re just a total blockhead, continues throughout your career.  I’ve watched many young PDs develop into formidable lawyers after a few years in the trenches.  Prosecutors as well, but my point is that everyone starts fresh once they leave the ivory tower, and nobody on the jury ever asks what grade they got in torts.

Will we have the competition and zeal to defend that existed in the glory days of 1968, when young lawyers like Jerry Lefcourt were ready to go to jail to face down Judge Hoffman?  Perhaps not, but then those were unusual times.  My greatest fear for the future of criminal defense is not that there will be too few lawyers willing to represent the accused, but that there will be too little money to pay for the representation of defendants, and even public defenders have to feed their families.  The greatest threat to Gideon is not the will, but the pay.

“If I Represented bin Laden…”

Over at the ABA Journal, a peculiar piece consisting of what may be either monologues or questions posted to an odd assortment of criminal defense attorneys on the pressing subject, what if you represented Osama bin Laden?

The lines-up is
Ron Kuby, talk-radio star and former protégé of Bill Kuntsler
Greta Van Susteran; former defense lawyer, Court TV host and current Fox News hottie 
Alan Dershowitz, former radical Harvard law professor and current totally ordinary Harvard law professor
Roy Black, Miami criminal defense lawyer
Michael Tigar, former attorney for Terry Nichols and current American College of Law professor

Who is rip-roaring ready to defend the most hated man in America in homage to our most fundamental constitutional tradition of a fair trial before conviction?  Well, nobody claims that they want the gig, but the only one of the bunch who doesn’t start out with an explanation of why he doesn’t want it but would only do it if he was forced to is Michael Tigar. 

Besides his defense of the notorious Kansas City Bomber, Terry Nichols, whom he saved from the death penalty, Tigar defended New York criminal defense lawyer Lynne Stewart, maligned and convicted for her representation of the “Blind Shiek,” Omar Abdel Rahman.  His approach is thoughtful and without self-aggrandizing hyperbole.  Like a lawyer.

Of course, bin Laden has yet to be found, no less alive, and brought to the United States for prosecution.  So why has the ABA Journal decided to interview lawyers on his behalf?  The post doesn’t offer a reason, and I can discern none.  But this hypothetical piece brings a few interesting bits of insight.

First, Ron Kuby is no Bill Kuntsler.  Bill would have been first on line to represent bin Laden, having pushed everyone else out of the way for the chance.  Ron’s idea is to flip bin Laden, under the premise that there is no one “too evil” or the government to make a deal with.  But who would he rat on?

Then Greta, her foremost concern is that he get a fair trial, as near a perfect trial as America can muster.  But not with her at the helm.  She would, no doubt, be happy to interview him for Fox.

Dershowitz, the law professor, ironically is mostly concerned about how he would be paid.  He would not take money form al-Qaida.  He would insist that the money be clean.

Roy Black wants to use a CIA agency defense, though his source of information appears a bit shaky.

What about me?  I don’t do advisory opinions.  If bin Laden wants to find out, he’ll have to call.

Student Speech Slides Further Downhill

Following the Supreme Court’s ill-conceived decision in Morse v. Frederick, discussed here, a fine example of the law in action comes to light via Crime & Federalism (from that old constitutional ne’er-do-well, Norm Pattis) and Cool Justice by Andy Thibault (who clearly has a better idea of what’s “cool” than I do).  It’s the story of Avery Doninger, a Connecticut High School Student who could well be a model for all of us with daughters.  She is the proverbial “good kid,” having done pretty much everything right.  Well, except one thing. 

Before relating the sorry tale of US District Judge Mark Kravitz’s decision in Doninger v. Neihoff, one thing should be firmly understood.  A year of high school lasts for a mere moment in law time, so the impact of delay, whether at the trial court level or due to appeal, results in an opportunity forever lost.  Whether you think the opportunity cost is significant, a few weeks lost is justice denied.

Now back to Avery.  Disturbed by an administration decision to not allow “Jamfest”, a concert that Avery organized, Avery went online and posted about how the school Superintendent and Principal were “douche bags,”  and urged parents and students to write and email the alleged “douche bags” to “piss them off even more.”  After the administration learned of Avery’s post, they punished her by refusing to allow her to run for school government secretary, give a speech with other student candidates and forbid students from wearing “Team Avery” shirts. 

Now I don’t care for the phrase “douche bags.”  Then again, I don’t care for the phrase “paternalistic pedagogy” either, although this phrase comes back to haunt me in this case.  What does it matter that a “vulgar” phrase was used to describe school officials?  Everything, apparently, to a district court judge, who views the particular words to be inconsistent with Avery’s role as a student leader, therefore justifying administrative punishment.

The decision by Judge Kravitz is rather long in words and short in substance.  It is one of those decision that goes on forever for no better reason than to self-justify it’s outcome.  If you call the words “douche bag” vulgar and offensive enough times, then it becomes easier to ignore the impact on free student speech as well as the utter abdication of responsibility to rule upon the constitutionality of the punishment.

Every decision about student speech must, by definition, include reference to the Supreme Court’s decision in Tinker v. Des Moines Indep. Sch. Dist., 393 U.S. 503 (1969), holding that students do not “shed their constitutional rights to freedom of speech or expression at the schoolhouse gates.”  Having made the obligatory quote, the next step is to find a way to circumvent  Tinker by reference to its counterpart, Bethel Sch. Dist No. 403 v. Frazer, 478 U.S. 675 (1986), where the Court held that students’ free speech is not co-extensive with adults.  Thus, the battleground falls between these two decisions.  In a perfect world.

What this means is remarkably unclear.  There’s no point to constitutional jurisprudence if not to clarify what is and what is not constitutionally protected.  So then came the Morse decision to really screw up the works.  To the extend that Morse stands for anything, it is that any student speech that can be rhetorically rationalized to negatively impact anything that theoretically fits within a school’s arguable sphere of interest is subject to school administrator’s disapproval.  The schoolhouse gates have been left behind as anachronism, and the speech is now only subject to the most fertile of imaginations.

Adding insult to injury, the administration decided on a curious punishment for Avery.  Rather than direct their ire toward this “Jamfest”, the subject of her protest, they decided to punish her by not allowing her to run for student government secretary.  The theory was that her “vulgar” language was unbecoming of a student leader, according to the court.  If only that was true for Richard Nixon.  Clearly, the Puritans are hard at work in Connecticut to maintain those high standards of appropriate verbal abuse.

Consider the ramifications of this punishment:  On the Jamfest issue, Avery and the administration are in opposition.  The administration finds Avery’s methods offensive.  They therefore use their unilateral fiat to preclude Avery from employing the democratic process within their high school universe to vindicate her position by running for office.  If only Karl Rove had thought of this first, imagine the havoc that would have followed.  It is brilliant.  It is fundamentally inconsistent with any notion of democracy in action.

And so Judge Kravitz pounced on this flagrant abuse of power to undermine the very basic notion of democracy with a scathing denunciation of this governmental usurpation of governance by the people, right?  Nope.  Instead, he punted.  The court blithely deferred to the school administration, holding that who was he, a federal judge, to pass on the question of the propriety of punishment imposed upon an American by a government official.  Didn’t anyone ever give him the judge handbook?  If not a federal judge, then who?

Stepping back from this case, one has to wonder how it is possible that Avery Doninger is not viewed as the poster child for democracy.  She had a beef.  She took it to the People.  The People responded.  That is the American way.  Avery showed true leadership, not the type that appeases those in power. 

Avery used the weapons that all true Americans should use, the power of thought and ideas as disseminated through word and deed.  We don’t have to like her choice of words, but we can’t dismiss them because we would have preferred other words.  And when challenging those in power, we don’t ask their permission to use any particular language.  This goes to the heart of the free speech rights in Tinker, the oft-quoted and long ignored core decision on student free speech.

As much as I dislike the particular words used, I admire Avery’s moxie.  What she did was as American as any act I’ve heard about in a long time.  What the administration did in response was an act of cowardice, showing them as the petty bureaucrats that they are, beating up on a kid who out thought and out maneuvered them by using her rights as protected by the Constitution.  What Judge Kravitz did was hand over Avery’s, and every other student’s, right to challenge and question those whose decisions have the greatest impact on their lives to the very people who seek to eliminate those rights under the guise of “paternalistic pedagogy.” 

We seek to teach students to be good people and good Americans.  I give Avery Doninger an A+.

Consequences Clarified – ACD and YO

Andrew Bluestone at New York Attorney Malpractice Blog alerts us to a new law that expressly defines the impact of two often misunderstood dispositions in criminal law, an ACD and YO treatment.  Questions often arise when someone is filling out an application for a job or license, or worse yet, when an employer or licensing agency runs a criminal history check on an applicant.

An ACD, or adjournment in contemplation of dismissal (on Long Island, it’s called an ACOD for reasons that can only be explained by businesses that make extra money every time a pointless “O” is used) is a disposition where a case is adjourned for a period of 6 months (1 year in drug cases) to give the defendant an opportunity to show that he or she really isn’t such a bad sort.  If nothing happens in that period, the case is then dismissed.  As a practical matter, rarely does an ACD come back to bite someone in the butt even if they do get in trouble again, with the new case being prosecuted and the old case forgotten.

YO is youthful offender treatment, where a judge decides to treat a defendant between the ages of 16 and 19 as a youth, and the record of conviction is sealed.  There are criteria for youthful offender treatment in CPL 720.10, and the purpose is to allow a youth to make a mistake without carrying the stigma of a criminal conviction around for the rest of his or her life.

The new law, effective November 1st, precludes use of an ACD or YO for any purpose except an application to carry a handgun or to be a police officer (kinda Alice’s Restaurant-like).  In other words, if someone received either an ACD or YO, they can state with complete certainty that they have NOT been convicted of a crime on any application going forward, and the fact that this may be factually (as opposed to legally) untrue is a legal nullity.

This new law really is a restatement of the existing law, but one that makes sense since there has been confusion in the past.  It had always been the law that dismissal of a case resulted in the legal nullity that the arrest and subsequent prosecution never happened.  But the distinction between legal nullity and factual occurrence confused many, and led to the unintended consequence of people who acted upon the belief that they were safe were dinged by employers (who didn’t realize that an ACD is a dismissal, or what the consequence of dismissal was) who believed that the applicant was lying.

Ironically, both the ACD and YO should never come into play in such decision making in the first place because of sealing provisions in the law.  When you get a rap sheet, it should not include anything about either the ACD or Yo since the former is dismissed and the latter is sealed.  Somehow, rap sheets often contain information they shouldn’t, or information that is false or incomplete (like it shows the arrest but no disposition).

So what does this all mean for the person who screwed up but received an ACD or YO disposition?  Well, it clarifies the right to not have it used against him or her, but if it still shows up when you’re being checked, you’re still going to suffer the stigma of a criminal conviction.  In other words, while lawyers may understand and appreciate the significance of the law, it’s hard to imagine that a potential employer who learns (even though he shouldn’t) of your conviction is going to be able to completely ignore it from the hiring decision.

On the other hand, if it comes about after hiring, it will no longer be a proper basis for termination, and will not constitute lying on an application, which is often deemed a more serious offense that whatever crime was committed.  The best solution would be for the State to put safeguards into place to assure that rap sheets were completely accurate, and that bad stuff that should not appear was removed timely and forever.  But it’s a lot easier for New York to pass a law directed towards others than to clean up its own act.  Hey, it’s better than nothing and does no particular harm.

The Cop Mind: Certainty in the Face of Ambiguity

While I lack the credentials to explain this phenomenon, I promise it nonetheless exists.  Cops are never wrong, as least in their own minds. 

Most of us reach conclusions based upon a weighing of facts, possibly combined with rumors, innuendo and other unfounded suggestion, relative to our vision of probability.  In other words, if the available information conforms to what we think is reasonable, then we believe it and make decisions. 

But our decisions are subject to revision when new information becomes available, particularly information that contradicts our already formed opinions.  We are open to being wrong.  We may fight to prove our position, but in the back of our heads, we come to realize that we may have jumped the gun.  Our reflexive defensiveness ultimately gives way to correction as soon as we can find a viable way to back off a conclusion without losing face. 

Not cops.  Once they make a decision, it’s written in stone.  It cannot be changed.  When logic fails, or stone cold fact gets in the way, they just wave their hand and state aloud that they don’t care.  Nothing, but nothing will change their mind.  Done.  They are right.  You are wrong.  Anyone who agrees with you is wrong. 

While my assertion is, of course, a generalization (which by definition means that there must be exceptions), it’s a darn good one.  Anyone who has tried to talk a cop down off the cliff knows it’s true.  There is an extra bone in their head that allows them to believe whatever they believe without any opening for doubt, even in the face of incontrovertible proof to the contrary. 

It’s wonderful to live in a world of such certainty, never having to rethink or revisit any decision.  Imagine the time savings alone.  Most of us waste a ton of time thinking about things we’ve already formed a belief about, considering other information and arguments that have substantial validity, yet don’t jive with our own thoughts. 

I’m not saying that police rush to conclusions necessarily.  They may very well take their time deciding, but once they’ve decided, that’s it. 

The other day, I had a nice friendly chat with a cop I’ve known for some time.  It was not adversarial at all.  In fact, it was quite pleasant and informative.  Then, he decided that he wanted to let me know that he “knew something.”  He went on to tell me what he knew, that related to something that only I knew.  I’m not telling you exactly what I’m talking about here, because it’s none of your business, but that doesn’t change the point of the story.

After he was done telling me what he “knew”, I told him he was wrong.  While I didn’t know how he came to “know” what he “knew” (he wasn’t giving up his source), I told him that since the information that he “knew” existed only in my head, whatever he thought he knew was baseless and he couldn’t “know” anything unless it came from me.  Since I didn’t give him the information that he “knew”, he didn’t “know” anything.

He told me that he knew what he knew and that there was nothing I could say that would change his mind, because he knew it. 

He was wrong.  His “source” had given him wrong information, and he relied on it to form a wrong decision.  But that was irrelevant.  He was certain and, as he openly stated, there was nothing that I could say that would change his mind.

I asked him if he would rather persist in his belief and be wrong forever, or consider the possibility that he was given bad information and reconsider.  He told me that his decision was firm.  There was no reason to reconsider as he knew.  His belief was unshakeable.

It didn’t really matter to me that he would persist in his wrong belief.  It didn’t change my life, or the lives of any clients.  It was purely academic at this point.  But the absolute persistence in maintaining a wrong belief was what fascinated me about the conversation. 

I use this example for two reasons.  First, because it is one where I knew that he was wrong, since I was the root of any belief.  Second, it was a friendly conversation, so there was no posturing involved for the purpose of playing cop versus defense lawyer. 

It isn’t easy being a cop.  They make decisions that have substantial impact on other people, far more so than almost any other occupation.  If cops were riddled with self-doubt, it would be impossible to do the job.  How can you aim a gun and pull the trigger if you are busy thinking, thinkiing, thinking about whether you should?  Then you would be a dead cop.  And so they form a protective shell around themselves, that won’t let them entertain extrinsic doubt that would just muddy their decisiveness. 

I have come to believe that this extra bone in their head that precludes cops from reconsidering is a Darwinian survival mutation.  Maybe it’s implanted in the academy.  I’m not sure how it gets in there, but it does.  And I’m equally certain that police officers believe, with all their hearts and souls, that no one who isn’t a cop can possibly understand them or why they must be the way they are.  But if you are trying to deal with them, it helps to have some idea of why reason, honesty and logic don’t work.

Labor Day, 2007

Labor history was rammed down my throat during my first year at Cornell University, School of Industrial and Labor Relations.  We learned in excruciating detail how labor relations developed, from the guilds to the Knights of Labor to Samuel Gompers (“short, fat and incredibly ugly”) and those merry anarcho-syndicalists.  It was a heady time, turning many an avaricious young person into a Seeger-singing Wobbly wannabe. (See, I can alliterate too!)

Labor day developed from Union-inspired recognition of the contributions of the working men and women to the strength of America in the face of management abuse.  These were times when the power of unionization was critical to the development of parity between the overwhelming strength of capital and the shocking weakness of the individual worker.  There’s nothing like a Triangle Shirtwaist Factory fire to clarify the issues.

But even then, I saw a problem that would eventually develop.  Unions, by definition, cannot exist unless they continually provide more and more for their members.  There had to be a tipping point where the relative balance between labor and management went the other way.  Capital eventually had to reach the point where it could no longer support the weight of labor.  But that was some day in the future, and for the time being, unions were needed.

Fast forward to today.  Ford is drowning in pension costs.  Airlines are renegotiating downward their contracts to survive.  Old industry is gone to cheaper labor markets, leaving America a land of service workers.  We have priced ourselves out of the labor market, as had to eventually happen.

So what are we celebrating this Labor Day?  Layoffs, outsourcing, plant closings?   What would Eugene V. Debs say if he were alive?  When goods and services cost more than anyone is willing to spend because the cost of labor exceeds the value of their efforts, we need to step back and rethink the problem. 

The arguments for ever-increasing wages and benefits can be heard publicly whenever public employees, the last bastion of dyed in the wool unionists, are due for a new contract.  They invariably talk about how hard they work, how difficult their job is and how they deserve more and better.  These arguments compel the comparison between public and private sector employees, with the latter countering that they work hard too, yet have been suffering wage compression, if they have a job at all, for years.  It’s a clash of ideology.

Unlike private sector, where the tipping point has quietly happened and the jobs have wandered away to cheaper markets, the public sector is immune from market forces.  They have a never-ending well of available funding, from the pockets of adoring taxpayers who have only a vote with which to fight the battle. 

Today, the primary beneficiaries of the years of labor strife are police and teachers, both serving fundamental and critical public purposes.  Both enjoy a level of public support that could never be achieved by a steel worker in Pittsburgh, a rubber worker in Akron or an auto worker in Detroit. 

Are police and teachers more worthy than any other worker?  Sure, they provide crucial services.  But all workers contribute to the existence of our nation as we know it.  Think about America without transportation or heavy equipment.  Has there been a shortage of qualified people interested in jobs as cops or teachers, driving the price of labor up year after year?  If wages and benefits were frozen, would police and teachers flee their jobs in favor of some other? 

It’s hard to blame anyone, teachers and cops included, for wanting better wages and benefits.  Other than a few investment bankers I know, everyone thinks they should earn more than they do.  But that doesn’t mean that they are entitled to a never-ending spiral of increases, or that their labor is any more deserving than anyone else’s.  They are one part of a symbiotic system, but the rest of us are part of it too.  We could all use a boost, but scarce resources preclude that from happening. 

What should we celebrate this Labor Day?  Perhaps the day off is reason enough to celebrate.  We have young men and women in Iraq who will not have the day off, and may well die on this day.  Americans are struggling across the country to pay off the next mortgage bill that tripled from the year before with wages that still can’t keep pace with inflation.  People who should be tightening the lug nuts on new Chevys are asking if you want that “supersized”.  And a young woman named Sue in India is chatting with a young man named Bill in China to find out when the next shipment of laptops will go out.

This Labor Day could provide an opportunity to step back from our competition for scarce resources and consider how we could create a rising tide that lifts all boats.  It’s not that the problems confronting America are unsolvable, but that we lack the leadership and will to seek a comprehensive vision of how our economic welfare can be secured, how this symbiotic relationship can be improved.  We’re all in this together.  We’re all workers (other than those investment bankers), and we need to stop fighting each other for the scraps left on the American table.  Enjoy your barbecues.

Raging Law School Debate: Compulsory Attendance

At Simple Justice, we’ve been discussing how to turn law students into lawyers, a job that law schools have unfortunately neglected.  But what is the raging topic of debate amongst law professors?  According to Concurring Opinions, it is whether law students should show up for school at all.

Compulsory attendance is derided as “paternalism”.  Law Prof Dave Hoffman contends that “[i]t is much harder to see how missing class, unlike using a laptop or being unprepared, produces negative externalities for the remaining students.”  It is much harder for me to see why he needs to use words like “negative externalities,” but I digress.  

Is it just me, or does this debate strike others as absurd?  These students are going to law school.  Show up! Are we asking too much?  If you don’t want to go to law school, then don’t.  If they can’t be bothered to show up for law school, then send them off to med school or some other place that better suits their needs.  But why is this even a discussion?

The argument is that these students are purportedly adults and should be allowed to make their own choices.  Wrong.  They are students, whether they are adults or not, and attendance at school is one of the things that students do.  It is part of the game.  Assuming that some students will be capable of making it through law school despite non-attendance, what’s the lesson here?  Skating by is what makes Johnny a good lawyer?  Try that with a judge and see how well she takes to your missing a court appearance.  Tell that to the defendant who sits in jail another month because his lawyer had something better to do and appear and represent him. 

While the debate recognizes that class participation and discussion are critical components of law school, the argument then veers off by noting that students who don’t want to be there are unprepared and bring nothing to the discussion.  Yet again, there’s a disconnect with the primary point of law school.  If the student is unprepared and brings nothing to the discussion, then we should label him a former law student.  If law schools are holding on to those students who can’t be bothered to come to class for the tuition, I bet they could find some other kid who would be more than happy to take his seat. 

ABA Regulation 304-d requires law schools to make attendance mandatory.  Dave Hoffman believes that “[m]ost law professors probably would like to follow HLS’ model, not only to avoid charges of hypocrisy, but because they have grown less enchanted by a paternalistic pedagogy the more they’ve taught. But, being risk-averse rule-followers, they hold their noses and enforce strict attendance policies.”  Nice how even law professors devolve to name calling when someone disagrees with them.  So much for intellectual freedom, eh boys?

Accordingly, Dave proposes, “RESOLVED, THEREFORE, that Regulation 304-d be eliminated.”  

I humbly offer a counter-resolution:  RESOLVED, THEREFORE, that law professors teach their damned students, each and every one of them, and stop using the words “paternalistic pedagogy” or “negative externalities” except when they’re trying impress the opposite sex at cocktail parties.  They should also consider wearing low pants if they really want to get lucky.

The Real Fashion Police

My very fashionable daughter often jokes about how certain particular individuals should be arrested by the fashion police (and some punished severely) for combining stripes and plaids, or wearing last year’s ultra-hot style that is this year’s fashion faux pas.  We laugh.  But this is not always a joke or very funny.

In the 1960s, grown ups scoffed at the attire of youth, and signs went up at lunch counters across the country: No Shoes, No Shirt, No Service.  Today, this sounds almost quaint compared with the movement to criminalize undesirable modes of dress, as low-pants legislation is spreading across the country, per Lowering the Belt Bar.

Low-pants has been a curiosity to me, since I fail to understand how they stay up on active young men.  As a style, I find it ridiculous looking. Even worse than people who wear their baseball caps askew, unless they are over 30, this pretend-I’m-in-prison look just makes me think of how silly young men can be in their effort to be cool and cutting edge.   When I was a kid, having one’s underwear showing was a source of great embarrassment (“I see London, I see France…”).  Today, it is a sign of machismo.  I don’t want to see any boys underwear.  I’m not offended by it, but I have no desire to gaze upon it either. 

These legislative initiatives, tackling the difficult issues of the day, have decided that the low-pants problem is worth, at its most extreme, a 6 month jail sentence.  I would expect jail to be limited to the most hardened low-pants recidivists, though the irony of taking some kid who has adopted the prison-pants-look and putting him in prison to teach him to stop isn’t easy to ignore. 

What is the compelling social need to lock away yet more people? 

Council member Louis Marshall told reporters that “[w]e unanimously passed the legislation because we have had so many complaints from citizens who don’t want to see young men with pants hanging so low, showing their underwear and, in some cases, their posterior.” 

In Shreveport, council member Calvin Lester agreed, adding three other adjectives to the list: “unsightly, unseemly and disrespectful.” 

I’m shocked that no one said it offended the delicate sensibilities of fine young southern womanhood.  There are many things in life that fail to meet with the satisfaction of others.  I cannot argue that the low pants situation is one that meets my expectations.  It’s a damn stupid look, and the kids who dress that way let the rest of the world know that they are, well, dumb kids.  But that’s not a crime and shouldn’t be a crime.  What is fundamentally wrong here is that local legislatures believe that such trivial matters, not to mention matters that impact the right to free expression if we need to go that far, are worthy of their time and effort.

This is fashion.  It will change.  It always does.  And the offensive sight of tidy whities, or on the slip side, thongs as revealed by Scarlett in the Nanny Diaries movie commercials broadcast on the small screen even in Louisiana, should serve as a reminder that this is not a flattering look for anyone.  And if we ignore it, it will eventually go the way of bell-bottoms and Nehru jackets. 

To those legislators who agree with me that low-pants look foolish, let me say this:  There are serious problems afflicting every community across America.  Stop looking at kids butts and get to work on some of them.  And stop inventing crimes to rid yourself of every disagreeable taste.  Sure, these kids are immature, but they’re kids.  You legislators have no excuse. Grow up.