Author Archives: SHG

The Dream Team Phenomenon

Among the many things that came about as a result of the OJ trial was the phenomenon of the Dream Team.  I’ve heard clients demand it a hundred times, as no doubt has every other real trial attorney.  Phil Spector, apparently, was paying attention and had his own dream team put together for his never ending murder trial.

The big news du jour was that Bruce Cutler, former house counsel to John Gotti, was replaced by San Francisco lawyer Dennis Riordin.  If Spector was going for an insanity defense, he should have left Bruce in place, but that’s neither here nor there.  I sat in the EDNY courtroom in support of Bruce when Judge I. Leo Glasser sentenced him for the contemptuous act of defending his client.  Bruce had guts.

But this isn’t about Bruce.  It’s about how defendant’s got their heads all twisted by the Dream Team concept, that worked once (barely) and is now the symbol of how a wealthy criminal defendant defends. 

Having more than one defense lawyer was nothing new when OJ went on trial.  But putting together a full team of lawyers, under the concept of getting top legal talents with specialized skills and knowledge was novel.  In the beginning, the team was put together by Bob Shapiro, a celebrity defense lawyer who specialized in plea bargains.  He put Barry Scheck in charge of DNA, F. Lee Bailey in charge of cross-examination and Johnny Cochran later came aboard as Dream Team preacher. 

It was only a matter of time before the egos clashed.  It had to happen; there could be no other outcome.  Bob Shapiro was the runt of the litter, and Johnny Cochran, who emerged as the star of the team, was not a good team player.  The message that came out of this trial to the public was very different than the one that many lawyers saw.  The Dream Team was as likely to implode at any moment as win the case.

Still, the idea of the Dream Team makes some sense.  Under any given set of circumstances, there are criminal defense lawyers with stronger skills in one area than another lawyer might possess, and why not use the strongest skills available?  The lawyers will need to work collegially, but they’re big boys and girls and can put their egos aside long enough to make it through a trial.  Right?

While I’ve been asked to put together the Dream Team many times, it has never actually happened.  First, there’s the bottom line.  It is exceptionally expensive.  Clients have argued that the cost for trial should be X, so therefore the Dream Team members should divide X between them.  Nice try.  No go.  The Dream Team is definitely a value-added service.  Each lawyer layers on an additional cost.  Whether you use the lawyer for one thing or everything, you pay for the preparation, appearance and service.  That’s not a starting point for negotiations, but a sad fact of life. 

A few years back I was asked to represent a rapper of some repute.  To this fellow, lawyers were like cars or jewelry.  He needed to put on a show of his wealth and importance by having a gaggle of lawyers (or is it a posse?) flanking him as he strutted into the court.  It was nothing personal, just appearance.  If OJ had a Dream Team, he needed a Dream Team too.

Besides the problem of actually finding lawyers with the skillsets that matched the needs of the case and trying to get them to agree to work together, the client quickly came to realize that this was tougher than deciding whether to order Cristal or Dom.  He ultimately realized that he was not so alluring to lawyers that they would flock to his defense for a palatable (to him) fee.  His bravado shrunk considerably and he decided that maybe he could do without.

Then there is the matter of strategy.  Ultimately, decisions have to be made.  While a group of criminal defense lawyers arguing strategy sounds like a great idea, they are not inclined to let go of their views easily.  Each one is quite certain that he is right, meaning that others are less right.  And no one wants to concede to the will of the group and be forever tainted by a losing defense.  Trial by consensus is not a strategy, but a cop out.  Ultimately, a leader must make a decision and the others must get on board.  But that’s not the dynamics of Dream Teams, as proven by the Johnny and Bob show, and it’s aftermath.

While many trial lawyers would love to be able to bring on board true specialists in specific fields, the best example of which was Professor Barry Scheck, who has forgotten more about DNA than the rest of us ever knew, this is not the Dream Team idea that follows from OJ and lives for Phil Spector today.  Two heads aren’t always better than one. 

Whether Dennis Riordin, reputed to be an appellate specialist, brings more to the table than Bruce Cutler is not the point.   Two lines from the story tell the real problem:



Riordon’s eleventh-hour appointment came after previous lead counsel Cutler abruptly left the case in a dispute with Spector over which attorney would deliver closing arguments.


Rachelle Spector said her husband decided to remove Cutler and that the music producer will now decide which attorney does closing arguments.



The decision of which attorney’s skills are best suited to deliver the closing argument (a) should not be up in the air at the close of testimony and (b) is not a decision for the defendant.  Obviously, Spector’s Dream Team has turned into his nightmare. 

More Short Takes: Stuff You Should Know

From the Wall Street Journal, a story about Capt. Denny Flannagan, a United Airlines pilot, who exemplifies an approach to work, life and others that should inspire all of us.  Recently, in a piece I posted about corporate planes, a commenter responded that it was a product of how shoddy commercial flights have become.  Capt. Flannagan proves that one person may not be able to change an industry, but he can damn well try to do her personal best.  So can we all. 

From Jon Katz at Underdog Blog, a Maryland Court of Appeals decision holding that, while probable cause was not met in a search warrant application, the search was nonetheless approved under the good faith exception since it wasn’t so lacking probably cause as to render it entirely unreasonable.  Notably, former Maryland United States Attorney Judge Lynn Battaglia, joined by Chief Judge Murphy, in dissent rejected the “nice try” exception to the Constitution. 

Again from busy Jon at Underdog, a 4th Circuit decision separating Crawford’s confrontation clause implication from data input into a computer.  Somebody puts the data in, in this case about drug levels in a defendant’s blook, and a machine cranks out the testimony that the prosecution needs.  But the prosecution need only produce an expert rather than the individual who actually did the input.  And we all know machines never lie.  Nor do they respond to questions on cross.

Finally, a quote via Grits for Breakfast that applies to so much of what we do, and so many things in life, that it would be a crime not to pass it along:  “We’re tending the flowers around the house while the house is caving in.”  This should be carved into the granite blocks above the entry to every legislative body in America. 

The FBI’s New New Toy

I usually get a tad snarky when it comes to posts over at Concurring Opinions, due mostly to my sense that Ivory Tower types lack a certain connection to reality in the trenches, as evidenced by the devotion of time and resources to such critical issues as Due Process at the Ministry of Magic per the Harry Potter series.

But Daniel Solove brings us a very practical piece of information about the FBI today.  Their new toy used to be Carnivore, a computerized system to eat up our emails for stuff.  But that was yesterday.  Today it’s DCSNet (a/k/a Red Hook or Digital Storm, less ominous names but not nearly as cool).

DCSNet is a suite of software that collects, sifts and stores phone numbers, phone calls and text messages. The system directly connects FBI wiretapping outposts around the country to a far-reaching private communications network.

Many of the details of the system and its full capabilities were redacted from the documents acquired by the Electronic Frontier Foundation, but they show that DCSNet includes at least three collection components, each running on Windows-based computers.


The $10 million DCS-3000 client, also known as Red Hook, handles pen-registers and trap-and-traces, a type of surveillance that collects signaling information — primarily the numbers dialed from a telephone — but no communications content. (Pen registers record outgoing calls; trap-and-traces record incoming calls.)


DCS-6000, known as Digital Storm, captures and collects the content of phone calls and text messages for full wiretap orders.


A third, classified system, called DCS-5000, is used for wiretaps targeting spies or terrorists.



Remember the good old days when the FBI had to set up wire rooms with agents actually monitoring wiretaps?  It seems so archaic now, doesn’t it?

My favorite line is the last one quoted above, where DCS-5000 “is used for wiretaps targeting spies or terrorists.”  Because computer software knows spies and terrorists from those who are merely subversive administration-hating Americans.  Or mens-room toe-tapping senators, for that matter.  But the FBI says so, and if you can’t trust the FBI, who can you trust?  Right, Alberto?

Not being sufficiently versed at the outer limits of technology, I hesitate to offer an opinion on how intrusive law enforcement methodology has become in the private lives of every human being on this planet.  But that’s never stopped me before.  If Red Hook and Digital Storm (by the way, code names ending in Storm are so played) can’t cover every communication running through lines of any type today, it is only because there aren’t enough imaginative cops out there to make full use of them.

There are not enough courts, judges, lawyers, cops or jail cells to address the issues that arise with the Government having this much power.  The notion of self-policing by the police has been proven false so many times over that anyone entertaining this as a meaningful limitations is just silly, loopy or blind. 

The only potential good use of the Government’s new toy is that next time you wish you recorded a telephone conversation but forgot to hook up that little suction cup from Radio Shack, you can just call up the FBI and order a copy.  And at a dollar a pop, we can make a serious dent in the national debt, provided the funds aren’t dedicated to the FBI pension fund.

Texas: Where Decisions Are Decisions and Lawyers Are Nervous

One of the great complaints of New York appellate lawyers is that our courts write lousy decisions.  Boring hardly touches it.  They tend to be brief, with a few trite quotes, the odd misstated fact and a cursory conclusion.  While the lawyers can write all day long, the judges appear to be paid in direct inverse proportion to the number of words they use when summarily excusing the error.

But not Texas.  I’ve got to give them Texas lawyers their due on this one.  They have definitely got us beat by a country mile.

From that wag, David Lat, former federal prosecutor cum agent provocateur, at Above the Law, comes these two excerpts of decisions by Southern District of Texas Judge Sam Kent (who is my new hero).  You must read these.  I insist.  You’ll thank me later.


Bradshaw v. Unity Marine Corp., 147 F. Supp. 2d 668 (S.D. Tex. 2001)


“The Court notes that this case involves two extremely likable lawyers, who have together delivered some of the most amateurish pleadings ever to cross the hallowed causeway into Galveston, an effort which leads the Court to surmise but one plausible explanation. Both attorneys have obviously entered into a secret pact-complete with hats, handshakes and cryptic words-to draft their pleadings entirely in crayon on the back sides of gravy-stained paper place mats, in the hope that the Court would be so charmed by their child-like efforts that their utter dearth of legal authorities in their briefing would go unnoticed. Whatever actually occurred, the Court is now faced with the daunting task of deciphering their submissions. With Big Chief tablet readied, thick black pencil in hand, and a devil-may-care laugh in the face of death, life on the razor’s edge sense of exhilaration, the Court begins. . . .

After this remarkably long walk on a short legal pier, having received no useful guidance whatever from either party, the Court has endeavored, primarily based upon its affection for both counsel, but also out of its own sense of morbid curiosity, to resolve what it perceived to be the legal issue presented. Despite the waste of perfectly good crayon seen in both parties’ briefing (and the inexplicable odor of wet dog emanating from such) the Court believes it has satisfactorily resolved this matter. Defendant’s Motion for Summary Judgment is GRANTED.


At this juncture, Plaintiff retains, albeit seemingly to his befuddlement and/or consternation, a maritime law cause of action versus his alleged Jones Act employer, Defendant Unity Marine Corporation, Inc. However, it is well known around these parts that Unity Marine’s lawyer is equally likable and has been writing crisply in ink since the second grade. Some old-timers even spin yarns of an ability to type. The Court cannot speak to the veracity of such loose talk, but out of caution, the Court suggests that Plaintiff’s lovable counsel had best upgrade to a nice shiny No. 2 pencil or at least sharpen what’s left of the stubs of his crayons for what remains of this heart-stopping, spine-tingling action.FN4


FN4. In either case, the Court cautions Plaintiff’s counsel not to run with a sharpened writing utensil in hand-he could put his eye out.


Smith v. Colonial Penn. Ins. Co., 943 F. Supp. 782 (S.D. Tex. 1996)

“The Court, being somewhat familiar with the Northeast, notes that perceptions about travel are different in that part of the country than they are in Texas. A litigant in that part of the country could cross several states in a few hours and might be shocked at having to travel fifty miles to try a case, but in this vast state of Texas, such a travel distance would not be viewed with any surprise or consternation. FN1 Defendant should be assured that it is not embarking on a three-week-long trip via covered wagons when it travels to Galveston. Rather, Defendant will be pleased to discover that the highway is paved and lighted all the way to Galveston, and thanks to the efforts of this Court’s predecessor, Judge Roy Bean, the trip should be free of rustlers, hooligans, or vicious varmints of unsavory kind. Moreover, the speed limit was recently increased to seventy miles per hour on most of the road leading to Galveston, so Defendant should be able to hurtle to justice at lightning speed. . . . Alas, this Court’s kingdom for a commercial airport! FN2 The Court is unpersuaded by this argument because it is not this Court’s concern how Plaintiff gets here, whether it be by plane, train, automobile, horseback, foot, or on the back of a huge Texas jackrabbit, as long as Plaintiff is here at the proper date and time.”


FN1. “The sun is ‘rize, the sun is set, and we is still in Texas yet!”


FN2. Defendant will again be pleased to know that regular limousine service is available from Hobby Airport, even to the steps of this humble courthouse, which has got lights, indoor plummin’, ‘lectric doors, and all sorts of new stuff, almost like them big courthouses back East.

The 3L Dilemma, Part 2

One of my daily readers, who has conveniently called himself “Other Steve” to distinguish himself from “Steve”, posed a question : What can law students do to prepare themselves to be lawyers?

This is a little touchy, since being a lawyer is very different than getting a job as a lawyer.  Scoring the position, especially if it’s a Biglaw post, is an entirely different issue.  Becoming a Lawyer has nothing to do with getting a job.  In fact, what I propose is pretty much the antithesis of becoming a Biglaw associate (which similarly has nothing to do with being a lawyer).

So there you are, finishing up your first year of law school and feeling pretty good about yourself.  You’re going to make it through to year 2, law school doesn’t suck anywhere near as much as everyone told you and Aunt Gertrude tells you that you’re back in the will because you’re no longer a good-for-nothing bum.  Fair enough.

But you have this nagging sense that you’re just not going to land/like that job at Biglaw, LLP.  You have a life, and you’re not ready to give it up.  Or worse yet, you actually have to make some dough so that you can eat again tomorrow, precluding your spending too much time at the AC with Muffy and Buffy and sucking up to their corporate lawyer daddies.  What to do?

GET A JOB!  Back in the old days, a person became a lawyer by clerking.  Lawyers still need kids to help them, and that gives a law student a chance to be there, absorb what’s going on around her and see what happens for real.  Most lawyers who will take on a kid will payment a little something.  Not much.  Frankly, you’re more of a burden than a help.  But something.

Watch and listen.  Ask intelligent questions, but only after you’ve kept your mouth shut, watched and listened.  No lawyer has the time to answer questions constantly, especially questions that would be reasonably answered if you would keep your head down and pay attention.  Ask obvious questions and you’re an annoyance.  Lawyers work for a living, and they can’t babysit law students and work at the same time.

But what about law review?  Well, from my own biased standpoint, that prepares you to be a particularly excellent law clerk.  In perpetuity.  For Biglaw.  In a library. Sheopardizing caselaw.  For hour after hour after hour.  Preparing lengthy memos on obscure yet tangential points.  If that’s your gig, whether for the $190k it pays or because you get to tell your friends you work for Biglaw, go for it. 

Going to work in a one or two person shop will NOT impress Biglaw.  How do you keep them down on the farm, after they’ve see Paree?  Once you see what lawyers do, working for Biglaw loses a certain panache.  Of course, you may well make more at Biglaw in your first year than you will make 10 years out on your own.  Again, think about the trade-off.  Rich or poor, it’s good to have money.

But if you really want to be a lawyer, then get your butt out of the library and into the courtroom.  Small firms often send their clerks to run and fetch, which means you not only get to see the actual papers that lawyers use, but you get to see courthouses, courtrooms, clerks and the occasional judge as well.  The sounds, sights and smells (especially the smells) of the courtroom will become very familiar to you.  When the day comes that you step in there solo, you will feel like you’ve come home.

Granted, this will take much of the mystique out of being a lawyer.  You will no longer be a virgin when they hand you the diploma.  It becomes far more difficult to listen to law profs utter platitudes without giggling.  But if it’s a lawyer you really want to be, then knock on doors, find yourself some lawyer who needs an extra pair of body parts and offer up yours. 

3 Short Takes: Stuff You Should Know About

From Grits for Breakfast, a post about camera perspective bias.  Research shows that the appearance of voluntariness of videotaped confessions changes based upon camera perspective.  When the camera is on the defendant alone, the appearance of voluntariness is much strong than when the camera also shows the questioner’s body movements and facial expressions.  When the view sees the full picture, it tends to alter the impression.  Read Grits and put this tidbit away for your next video confession case.  This one will come in real handy.

From the Turk at New York Personal Injury Law, a post about Progressive Insurance sending its investigators into a church support group, worming their way into the private therapy sessions, where they recorded people disclosing their deepest, darkest secrets in the hopes of catching two members who were suing for damages resulting from an auto accident.  One of the most disgraceful examples I’ve seen in a long time. 

For the non-lawyers here, all that Constitution mumbo-jumbo that us lawyers like to spout about applies to government action, not action by private parties.  There may be some therapist-patient privilege issues when it comes to admissibility of evidence, but that’s really not the point.  It’s how our privacy has been sacrificed on the alter of expediency.  This is a really sick approach, which has gone way over the line of decency by anyone’s standards.  As Eric notes, the CEO of Progressive has issued an apology for the incident, but does “we’re sorry for the inconvenience” cut it for those people who spoke about their most private personal problems in the belief that they were safe?

Robert Guest at I was the State blogs about Idaho Senator Larry Craig’s bathroom follies.  He notes that the GOP obsession with gay marriage is misguided, as gay bathroom foot-tapping presents a greater threat to the sanctity of marriage.  Has anyone questioned what the police officer was doing in that bathroom stall?  Was he on Senator watch or foot-tapping watch?  And how did he know what the indicia was for gay bathroom senatorial solicitation tricks?  I would have thought the guy was thinking of a catchy tune in his head and tapping to the beat.  But then, I’m not a cop.

Commentary: The Economics of Flash

From the Volokh Conspiracy, a very serious blawg written by very serious people with only an occasional lapse into sex obsession, comes this relatively random post about the tax deductibility of mortgages, which goes into the use of home equity loans to finance the purchase of consumables, like SUVs and vacations.  It’s this somewhat tangential point that caught my attention.

How much dumber can a social policy be than to encourage, through the tax code, individuals to risk title to their house so they can finance SUVs, cruises, and the like?

How much dumber indeed.  But blaming the tax code for its abuse by individuals is like blaming cars for being driven by drunk drivers.  I can’t help but wonder whether this fuzzy thinking belies the writer’s lack of contact with the world of people who need that SUV so badly that they will put their home on the line to get it.  So, I’m here to help.

We used to call this phenomenon “keeping up with the Joneses,” this compulsion to use material possessions to prove our standing in the game of life.  People need to prove that they’ve made it, and the need to prove it to their reference group to avoid being the laughingstock of whatever neighborhood they belong to.  There’s nothing new about this.

But there is something new about the understanding of what they are doing.  I spent many years riding the commuter train with a group of guys (and a couple of gals) who did pretty well for themselves.  They had good jobs and made good money.  Life was good.  And they had the toys to prove it.  Whatever the newest, shiniest toy, they had it.  Not only did it not occur to them that they were squandering their good fortune on baubles, but they scoffed at the notion that there could ever come a day when they would regret their choices.  The notion of the “rainy day” was foreign to them.

These weren’t children, but they were too young to remember the crash of ’87, and probably hadn’t paid enough attention in history to know anything about the crash of ’29.  As for the  dot.com crash of March 10, 2000, they had nothing invested, so nothing lost.   They actually looked pretty smart, not having thrown their money away on equities instead of the latest, greatest trinket du jour.

Life owed them whatever new car was “in”, and that was the reason why they went to work every morning.  It wasn’t that they weren’t hard working and dedicated, it was that they had no concept of durables versus consumables.  These were MTV watchers, if you’ve seen it at any point in the past 10 years.  you will know that it’s not about music videos anymore.

Let’s bottom line it: They had a ton of cool stuff and nothing of value.  But they were happy that way, and it’s hard to argue with happy.  This is the lifestyle of flash.

Cut to the issue of using home equity loans to finance the flash.  Once they lived the life of crass materiality, and liked it, the idea of reining in their consumerism was inconceivable.  It was akin to cutting off their arm, as the oversized Panarei was just as important to their well-being as their fingers. 

So when the money tightened, as it invariably does, or the cost of goodies increases, as they invariably do, the money has to come from somewhere.  The path that took it out of the house isn’t always as clear as in the Volokh post, but tapping the home equity line ultimately happens nonetheless.

To date, only two out of a group of about 20 well-intended people have been brought to the edge of despair because of their misguided choices.  I would be surprised if it ends there. 

For years, I’ve been arguing with these otherwise good people about stopping their profligate ways.  When the purchase, I would contend, at least buy things of lasting value so that someday, if necessary, you can divest yourselves and these objects will be worth something.  Hah, you fool, they would tell me.  These ARE worth something.  They are hottest/coolest/newest/shiniest things there are.  You, I was told, are an ignorant old man.  Perhaps.

You see, they have a point that I refuse to see, just as they refuse to see my point.  We will not allow them to crash and burn for their juvenile spending habits.  Society may not be willing to support them in the style to which they’ve become accustomed, but we won’t let them starve either.  I’m not suggesting that we should.  Starvation is too high a price to pay for poor consumer choices, particularly when we are bombarded with stimuli that pushes us to make these poor choices.

But why can’t public policy reward those who make sound choices?  For those who eschew the lifestyle of flash so that they can pay down their primary mortgage and live debt free, they are penalized by the loss of the only remaining personal deduction and given what in its place?  A sound night’s sleep.  Whoopdidoo!  To argue that they get to enjoy the stability of a solid financial position is to say that they got what they paid for.  While that’s fine, public policy offers incentives for the profligate and zilch for the frugal.  Something is wrong here.

Instead of home mortgage deductibility to theoretically encourage home ownership (a fallacy because the “value” is eaten up on the other end by the inflated cost of housing), why not a tax credit in proportion to the percentage of home equity to encourage owning a home while living within your means?  And if they want to spend their credit on a lifestyle of flash, that’s their business.  But then they will pay the price for their choices.  And those of us who choose not to go with flash won’t feel like we may be the fools.

Are Lawyers Protected?

Adam Liptack’s New York Times column, With the Bench Cozied Up to the Bar, the Lawyers Can’t Lose , tells us that Dennis Jacobs, Chief Judge of the Second Circuit Court of Appeals, gave a speech suggesting that judges are biased in favor of protecting lawyers and the legal process.  The speech found its way into the Fordham Law Review.

According to Liptack:

Perhaps unthinkingly but quite consistently, he said, judges can be counted on to rule in favor of anything that protects and empowers lawyers.


Maybe that’s so when it comes to civil practice, but I’m just not seeing it with criminal.  This is the sort of assertion that feeds the paranoia of the tort reformers and the lawyer-haters, who believe that there is some cabal to keep the honest man down while the lawyers take over the world.  If only…

To say that people who think like lawyers favor a lawyerly approach is hardly damning.  If we didn’t believe that there was something beneficial to thinking like a lawyer, we wouldn’t do it.  But non-lawyers have a gross misunderstanding of what thinking like a lawyer means.  It’s a systematic analysis of situations from a detached point of view.  Are most lawyers unnecessarily constrained by thoughts of precedent, with a good dose of stare decisis tightening around their neck?  Sure, but that’s a problem of vision that all people suffer.  They just can’t get beyond the box.  It’s true of lawyers, accountants, architects and especially engineers,

Other professions look for elegant solutions. It is the rare engineer, software designer or plumber who chooses an elaborate fix when a simple one will do.

What a load of crap.  A fix is a fix, and it’s as simple or complex as it needs to be do accomplish the task.  Plumbers fix things the way plumbers fix things.  Lawyers do the same.  Does this argument have more to do with a higher expectation of lawyers than plumbers?  Are we to overcome our training as lawyers to start thinking as plumbers?

Belying the point is Liptack’s consulting Lester Brickman, ethics professor at Cardozo Law School and someone who can ALWAYS be counted on the screw the lawyer no matter what.  I’ve always admired how good old Les, who gets a paycheck whether he does anything useful or not, can find a way to castrate the working lawyer and conclude that he’s unworthy of the ability to make a living.  Full Disclosure:  I don’t care for Lester Brickman.

But as I said earlier, don’t even begin to sweep the criminal defense lawyer into this mix.  I highly doubt that Judge Jacobs was thinking about us when he made his comments, since few Second Circuit judges give us much thought to begin with.  The only instance cited by Liptack in his column is that line in the Miranda warnings that informs arrestees that they have the right to an attorney.  Note to Adam:  Miranda was decided in 1966.  If you can’t come up with something more recent, there’s a reason.

So if judges have this bias in favor of lawyers and the legal process, as Judge Jacobs says, then I’ve got a list of things that they need to address:  How about we start with requiring the Government to disclose Brady (exculpatory evidence) and Giglio (impeachment evidence) up front.  Let’s allow Bills of Particulars in federal criminal prosecutions on a regular basis, even though it will “prejudice the Government” by disclosing the basis for the charges.  What about getting rid of the 412 exceptions to the 4th Amendment’s exclusionary rule and start applying the exclusionary rule.  Why not let lawyers voir dire federal jury panels instead of judges? 

There are a bunch more where these come from, but we can start small and eventually get to all the things you judges are biased in favor of.  What?  You’re not going to start making wholesale changes to help out criminal defense lawyers (not to mention the People) like Adam Liptack says?  But Your Honor, if you can’t trust the Times, who can you trust?

And in closing, let me say that Lester Brickman can bite me.  As far as I’m concerned, let him try to practice law before his venal attorney self-loathing should ever be given public airing. 

The Last Week In August

Probably the single deadest week of the year.  Nothing happens, and no one cares.  It’s the perfect week for Embattled Attorney General Alberto Gonzalez to resign.  If a story appears in the Times and there’s no one to read it, does it make a sound?

If one would conduct a flash survey across the courthouses of the nation, I doubt there’s a trial going on anywhere this week.  It used to be that no one ever tried cases in August.  Judges took vacations by going to judge school.  Jurors wouldn’t show up for duty, and nobody wanted to hold that many regular people in contempt.  The few who would show were miserable and desperate to find someone to convict.  Quickly.

This is when you want to do something that you want to blow over quickly enough that no one notices.  When Al Gonzalez put on the AG hat, there was a collective sigh of relief that John Ashcroft was out.  He brought a lot to the job.  It was all bad, but it was something.  You need to have something going for you to be despised.

AG was nothing more than a good soldier.  As a hatchet man for the Bush administration, he did what he was supposed to do.  But he was a small man holding a big job.  He wasn’t up to it.  Even now, I look at the complaints of AG and shrug.  So he fired some US Attorneys because they didn’t live up to the administration’s politics?  Well, you lay down with dogs, you wake up with fleas.  So what.  I can’t get all that upset that their internal squabbling cost a few federal pensions from folks who never, in their wildest dreams, would have thought twice about my view of the Constitution.

So in this lazy, hazy, crazy week of August, AG resigned.  Two weeks from now, we’ll have a hard time remembering his name.  The Congress will continue to banter about how he lied and used politics to guide his official duties.  And the People will become increasingly annoyed with what will become a political sideshow that does absolutely nothing to help anyone.  They guy’s out, get on to something that matters to people.  The Washington obsession with going after individuals who matter along the Beltway is not shared by everyone.

Who’s going to get the AG job for real.  We already know that the Solicitor General, Paul Clement, will sit in the big chair for a while, but not for too long.  Since it’s a given that a Bush AG must be a conservative, Clement would be a solid choice based upon his strength as a lawyer as well as his politics.  But he’s too much of lawyer to be counted on as a good soldier.  You may not agree with his vision of the law, but he’s got integrity in a Nino Scalia (for whom he clerked) sort of way.

There isn’t much time left before the next election, so it’s hard to imagine that anyone with a really good job now would be interested in taking over the helm.  Some of the names, like Ted Olsen, know better than to get involved now.  It would be the crashing end of a good career.  This is a dead end job, comprised mostly of holding up the house of cards left behind at Justice.  No glory.  No one will remember.  No one will care.

My guess is that Jim Comey will be the next AG.  Jim was a former AUSA in the Southern District of New York.  I had some cases with him when he was just a kid (as was I once) in the trenches.  He looked like an AUSA is supposed to look.  He was smart and tough, but that’s the norm in SDNY.  It’s a terrific office, if you are inclined to use the word “terrific” to describe such things, and had its pick of the litter with assistants. 

But Jim Comey was a real person.  There was nothing self-aggrandizing about him.  He wasn’t self-important or pompous.  He was just a smart, solid worker.  It’s been years since I’ve spoken to him, but I can’t imagine that he would be the type of person to be changed by Washington or power. 

More importantly, Jim Comey would be the person who would accept the dead end job because the President asked.  He would take it because he would see it as his duty to do so.  And he would execute it as best he could within the short time frame, and uncomfortable circumstances, that he found.  And whatever he said would be what he believed at all times, even if it didn’t turn out to be the best thing for the administration.  He would bring professionalism and integrity back to Justice in a firm but quiet way.

Don’t get me wrong.  I don’t see Jim Comey sending out a memo from Justice telling AUSAs to start cutting deals below the Guidelines.  He is not sympathetic to the cause of the defense.  He never cut me a break and I have no reason to expect that he will change.  But I don’t think anyone who might get the AG job would do that.  Ramsey Clark is not going to be asked to take the position.

But I think Jim Comey knows that torture is unAmerican.  I think Jim Comey understands due process.  And I think Jim Comey has a respect for the law, including that part that gives defendants a reasonably fair shot at defending themselves.  So President Bush, if you’re reading this (as I suspect you are), nominate Jim Comey to fill out the term.  He’s the best chance you’ve got to revive trust in the Department of Justice.

The Changing Face of Legal Research

Eric Turkewitz at New York Personal Injury Law writes that there’s a new kid in town when it comes to computerized legal research, Alt Law.  While not yet ready for a showdown with the old timers, Lexis and Westlaw, the idea that free options are becoming a reality certainly changes the landscape in legal research.

Does this mean that the Lexis and Westlaw are shaking in their boots?  I doubt it.  For those of us who used to use those archaic things called “lawbooks”, we’ve been down this road before.  In the olden days, lawyers had libraries.  Libraries were filled with these things called books.  Each month they would come, and somebody would put them on a shelf in the library in sequence.  This wasn’t all that difficult, because each book had a number on it.  The numbers saved us a lot of time.

Once a year, they would send out a big box full of pocket parts.  These were updates that went into this little sleeve in the back of the book.  You pulled out last year’s pocket part and put in this year’s pocket part.  This was not one of the more pleasant jobs in the office.  Plus, you ended up with a lot of worthless paper, even though it cost a lot of money only a year ago to buy them.

There are two things to bear in mind about these numbered books.  First, they were not cheap.  They represented a huge out of pocket expense, paid monthly as each new book would arrive, and once you started down “Library Road,” you couldn’t stop because that would leave you without the latest and greatest caselaw and would render your library worthless.  When the books have numbers on them, it’s pretty easy to tell if there are a few missing here and there.

Second, they ate up an ever increasing amount of real estate in your office.  When you built your library, it was only so big.  But the books kept coming.  And coming.  And imaginative ways were developed to place the books so that they didn’t take up as much space (such as putting every fifth book behind the others), but stop gap measures only worked for so long.  Eventually, room ran out and you had to do something.  Just toss them?  Are you nuts?  They cost a fortune, and it would tantamount to fiscal suicide to throw lawbooks away.

But then one day, a letter came touting something called a “CD”.  The law on “CD” was the savior to the ever-expanding law library.  The only problem at the time was that typical computers did not have CD drives (we were still using the big old floppies back then, and maybe had a diskettes drive if we were cutting edge).  So Westlaw was giving away free external CD drives if you subscribed to the CDs. 

Not to be outdone, Lexis pioneered its own dedicated user interface over some new-fangled thing called the “internet”.  All you needed was a contraption called a “modem”, which they were happy to give you for free if you subscribed.  It was slow, but it was erratic.  Ah, cutting edge technology. 

All the while, dinosaurs (like me) kept buying the books, because we just couldn’t let go of that damn library that we have been paying for month after month since we opened our doors.  Worse yet, West (this was before it was commonly referred to as Westlaw, which is really the computerized stepchild of West Publishing) not only refused to cut the CD subscribers a break on the book prices, but actually increased the price of the books.  They wanted to drive subscribers away from books into the CDs, which was FAR more profitable for them (like a gazillion-fold). 

Ultimately, they pried the books from the grasp of that handful of lawyers who simply refused to see the future coming.  Books were dead.  Long live computers.  Libraries became conference rooms.  Books became a backdrop for the benefit of clients, who wouldn’t know whether the latest New York Supplement 2d was book number 783 or 1049.

We tried to sell these books, but no one wanted them.  We tried to donate these books, but no one wanted them.  Overnight, they were worthless.

It’s been a long time since Lexis and Westlaw became the norm.  Our abilities at searching the database, and finding the law we’re looking for, varies, so it can often take an additional 30 or 40 nanoseconds to come up with the right decision.  Flipping back and forth between decisions isn’t what it used to be, but humans are nothing if not adaptable.  Old dogs learn new tricks everyday, especially when they have no choice.

But lawyers born in the computer age will never know the joys of carrying a dozen bound volumes, all open to the right page, and spreading them around the conference table so that you can compare the language used by Judge Breitel against the prose of Sol Wachtler.  The feel of paper in your hand as you leaf through the decision to find the perfect quote will never be replaced by the touch of the mouse as you scroll through a case.

The explanation of Alt Law, that the law belongs to everyone and we should not have to pay for access, is compelling.  It is our law, not Westlaw’s or Lexis’.  What right do they have to sell us back what we have given them?  But the mechanism of our access to the law was never ours, through its many permutations.  I don’t know if Alt Law, or any other newcomers, will be able to provide lawyers with the tools to do research that Westlaw and Lexis do.  But I do know that no computer research will ever be as satisfying as spreading out those dozen books on a desk and seeing the fruit of your labor laid out before you.