Author Archives: SHG

Panic – The Larry Craig Defense

Those of us who spend some time dealing with the actual mechanics of criminal defense, as opposed to the big picture rhetorical stuff that is always fascinating but rarely viable, wondered how Sen. Larry Craig’s brilliant and expensive legal defense team would approach his motion to vacate his guilty plea.  The answer is in:  Panic.

The panic defense.  Well, we all know that one pretty well.  When the screws are put to the defendant to cop a plea now or forever lose any chance of getting the deal again.  Take it now or never.  So what if your entire life will hinge on the outcome of this decision, likely the biggest decision you will ever make.  You have 3 second to decide.  What’s it gonna be boy, yes or no?

The master of the panic plea was Judge Harold Rothwax in Supreme Court, New York County.  A former legal aid lawyer, something very horrible happened to his mind one day and he became angry, then mad.  Never had a judge become so jaded and cynical as Rothwax.  He went on to write a book, entitled “Guilty!” that reflected his hatred for the Constitution and defendants. 

Rothwax loved to dispose of cases, and he actually believed that he was doing defendant’s a favor by taking the prosecution’s plea offer, adding in some additional minor incentive, and giving the defendant 10 seconds to take it or, he would promise, the defendant could spend the rest of his life in jail. A little coercive?  Well, I can’t remember any appellate court smacking Harold’s hands.

But we digress.  Back to Larry Craig and his panic.  Does anyone in America doubt that he panicked?  If you were in his position, wouldn’t you have panicked too?  After all, a career built on conservative family values about to blow up based on what appears to be nothing more than one consensual dalliance in the men’s room?  It’s not like he was gay, ya know.

On the one hand, he had the expectation that this plea to an exceptionally minor offense would foreclose public access to the career-killer charge.  But panic doesn’t begin to cover the problem, since his options (like the options available to most defendants) ranged from bad to worse. 

Panic is a state in which many criminal defense decisions are made.  Lawyers are used to it, and use their detachment to swiftly analyze the possibilities and impact.  But ultimately, there are always unknown variables where the odds are played.  Larry Craig played the odds and lost.  He played them without benefit of counsel, though being a Senator makes it harder to claim that he was simply clueless.  Not that it wasn’t true, but just harder to claim.

Now I don’t mean to make fun of poor Sen. Craig’s situation.  The irony of his politics is another matter, but not his situation.  Courts and prosecutors have long enjoyed the ability to exploit panic to dispose of cases.  Indeed, prosecutors routinely overcharge so that the gun pointed at a defendant’s head is so big that the defendant is coerced into an inappropriate plea bargain.  It’s the grease that keeps the system moving.

But I have one nagging question that keeps bugging me before I cross that line and feel sorry for Larry Craig.  How many federal laws did he vote in favor of that were intended to do the same or similar harm to others as he complains of today?  If now, as a criminal defendant, he has had an epiphany, then let him first come clean about the error of his ways.  No, not about what he does in the airport bathroom, but what he does in the Senate bathroom. 

9/11 – To Each His Own

America has embraced 9/11.  But it’s different for people who it touched directly.  It touched me.  It also touched fellow blawger, Andrew Lavoott Bluestone, in almost the same way, only worse.

We were both in the Woolworth Building, essentially across the street from the WTC.  I wasn’t in my office on the 51st Floor when it happened.  I can’t explain why, but I just decided not to go in that day.  No particular reason, as I recall.  It was a beautiful September morning.  Andrew was there.

I know a lot of people who were touched.  Whether because they died, or knew people who died, or felt that, but for some bizarre luck, should have died. Or should have had something happen to them that was worse than what did.  There was a lot of survivor guilt flying around at the time.

My office was so close and had such a perfect view of the site (no one here ever called it Ground Zero.  That was for tourists) that Life Magazine took it’s grand 2-page spread photo from where my desk chair was.  I still have a duplicate original of the full size (really big) photo.  I’ve never looked at it.

Due to the Woolworth Building being in the red zone, we were locked out for many months, and had no phone service for even longer.  There was no one to argue about it with, and nothing to do.  Everyone cooperated, but we were out of business.  The only thing that continued was recurring bills, like Lexis and the phone company (even though there were no phones).  We would pick up the mail once a week.  It was all we could do.  In the beginning, we were allowed into the red zone after a few days, but there was nothing to do there but look.  And there was nothing anyone wanted to look at.  It was all just gray, like a black and white world.

We wouldn’t really talk much about it.  There wasn’t much to say.  It just was.  The dead were dead.  We were alive. The site was still smoking and that was all there was to know.

Then came the tourists.  From Kansas, or Minnesota, or wherever.  They wanted to see Ground Zero.  No one who worked around there would even look out their windows anymore, and they actually came to see it.  They  wore American flags on their heads.  They bought trinkets and NYPD and NYFD baseball caps from Nigerians.  They talked about what the terrorists did to “us”. 

This is where I diverge from many others.  I know most people who read this won’t understand why I write this, but it’s how I feel.  To you tourists from Kansas, the terrorists did nothing to you.  You didn’t suffer. Maybe you wanted to feel the pain, but you didn’t suffer.  You watched it on TV and then went to the fridge and ate something.  You eventually put on an NYPD cap and pretended you were involved.  You weren’t.

I’ve had this conversation with people before, so please don’t explain to me why 9/11 happened to people in St. Louis or Detroit.  I understand what you think, but it didn’t.  That’s my opinion and I have no plans on changing my mind.  The “affront” to America is not suffering.  Empathy is not suffering.  Be thankful that it didn’t, and that you can bear to watch a movie about it.

Since 9/11, I’ve never watched a movie about it or any of the TV specials.  I’ve represented some firefighters who are dying a slow death because of it, and sat there while they cry when asked to remember it.  It’s not an amusement park, or a tourist attraction.  It’s not a rallying cry or a patriotic symbol.  The twin towers aren’t hallowed ground or a memorial to death, destruction or the American way.  It was just a horrible disaster. 

Today will be a day when the nation remembers 9/11.  But it won’t be the same 9/11 that I remember.  And I just want to forget it.  When I finally got back into my office, about 6 months after it happened, I rarely looked out my window at the site.  There was nothing glorious about 9/11, and anyone who wants to do something to remember it should go home and hug their kids, because they never know when either they, or their kids, won’t come home again.

Someone Gets Forced To Pay

Frank Pasquale, whose posts at Concurring Opinions are always thought provoking, really caught me with this question:

When a health care infrastructure that has been heavily subsidized gets privatized, is there any provision for assuring that the public that paid for it actually gets some public service in return? (For one example of the subsidy: it is estimated that $500,000 to one million of the costs of educating each physician are public funds.) If 90% of doctors decided to serve the 3% of Americans with $1 million in disposable assets, leaving 10% for the other 97%, would that uncoerced market distribution be legitimate?

The point is the legitimacy of the government intervening in free markets for the general welfare, and to refute those whose argument is that they don’t like the government’s choices, so why should they be forced to accept the products of those choices.  The answer is that we all enjoy (and like) many of these choices, and can’t pick and chose. 

The flip side, per Ilya Somin at Volokh Conspiracy, is that we end up with the choices of the majority, which may prove unsatisfactory to a significant minority.  In a worst case scenario, the choices aren’t made by a majority, but by special interest groups that leave all us regular folk out of the picture. 

Interesting, but how does this apply to the law?  By demand of the Constitution (and as interpreted in Gideon), every criminal defense is entitled to a lawyer.  If he can’t afford one, then one must be provided to him.  We pay for that lawyer to be provided to that alleged criminal. 

Some (many?) may say that it’s fine if the case is “serious” (whatever that means) or if the defendant is innocent (which they are presumed to be up front), but not if we “know” they are guilty or if we don’t consider the crime or punishment to be worth the price.  Neither of these criteria pass muster under even cursory scrutiny.  Does anybody remember the tyranny of the majority? 

Still, many will be of the basic feeling that this is a huge waste of taxpayer money, providing lawyers to criminals.  If they didn’t do something, they wouldn’t have been arrested.  Even so, they just aren’t a group of people for whom many American’s feel much sympathy.  We have more important things to do with our tax dollars, like provide medicine to the poor (or nuclear weapons for the military), or even just keep the money in our own pockets, from whence it came.

If we put Gideon to a popular vote, I feel fairly confident that it would fail miserably.  But then, I doubt that American’s would support the Bill of Rights either.  And that’s the problem with leaving fundamental choices to the transitory whims of popularity.  The struggle for resources would result in an American that was unrecognizable. 

There are functions that the government may not do well, but still does better than any individual could.  We need the government for that.  Granted, they could do a whole lot better, but that’s not a reason to take it away from the government, but rather a reason to improve the functioning of the government in performing its job. 

Then, there are functions that the government must do simply because this is America, and it’s what we stand for.  Providing every person accused of a crime with a lawyer for his defense is one of those things.  There may well be more cost effective ways to do it, and I would certainly say that we need tighter controls on who receives these services as there are far too many defendants receiving free legal services who could afford to pay for them (and thus take away scarce dollars that would be available for those who truly need these services).  But that doesn’t change the fact that, in America, this is how we do things. 

So each of us, through our taxes, is forced to pay for the defense of the accused who are unable to afford their own lawyer.  If you don’t like being forced to pay for lawyers, consider this:  If we put more money into education, maybe we could save a bundle on criminal defense later.  And if we don’t pay for either, then we will pay the price in the loss of a fundamental component of America.  One way or the other, somebody will be forced to pay.

Hanging Out A Shingle

Mark Bennett, the Texas Tornado, got his ax gored by some lying lawyer.  Shawn Matlock was complaining about that earlier.  Gideon get all bent out of shape over it.  And I’ve posted about it a few times.  While criminal defense lawyers may quibble over what to call it, or what aspect is the most venal (mostly because criminal defense lawyers just tend to quibble about things more than others), we have all been there and it is, to be clear, a blight on our little corner of the profession.

The problem is lawyers who lie to get a case.  Lawyers making promises, whether it be success or bail or no jail, or even whether it be that the lawyer possesses the skills needed to represent the client.  I know criminal defense lawyers who have practiced for 25 years who have never tried a case.  They will puff their expertise, but within the biz, we know that the lawyer doesn’t have the chops for a fight.  But clients don’t know.

Sometimes lawyers make ridiculous promises.  Sometimes the deception is subtle.  But they’re still lawyers, professionals, theoretically highly-educated men and women who have been granted a license to hold people’s lives in their hands.  There is a sacred trust involved, and these people just don’t give a damn.  Why?

Law was once a profession.  Today it’s a business.  Lawyers need paying clients to feed their family.  They don’t give lawyers a BMW for free, you know.  Aren’t lawyers entitled to live a decent life after they’ve paid off all those student loans?  The truth is that lawyers, like clients, are told a story when they have to decide what to do with the rest of their lives, and believe that if they go to law school, study hard, they will be rewarded with a good income and a happy, comfortable life in a respected profession.  Young men and women are led down the garden path, only to find that its full of thorn bushes surrounded by poison ivy.

As we read about hos Biglaw associates with almost 7 minutes of experience are getting $190k plus a signing bonus, one has to laugh.  This isn’t the world of the criminal defense lawyer.  Whether the lawyer starts out as public defender or prosecutor, the only way out of the institution and into private practice in the criminal law world is to become a defense lawyer.  There’s no such thing as private prosecutors.

So there’s some kid who has had enough of a lousy salary, unbearable caseload and ridiculous hours.  The time has come to bid ado to your buddies, and go out into the wonderful world of private practice.  The “grass is always greener” delusion has clouded your judgment, and you see all those half-competent lawyers making big bucks, no one to boss them around and doing as they please.  You want to be one of them, and you know you can score big because you are so much better a lawyer than they are.  And all the judges love you and you’re brilliant.  Go for it!

So you rent a room, get a telephone number, buy a computer, order some letterhead and hang out a shingle.  And out of nowhere, clients start calling with heavy case and showing up at your door in need of you, right?  Each one of them is carrying a bulging suitcase, right?  Well, not exactly. 

The reality fails to meet the dream.  Six months in and you have yet to get a single retained client.  You’ve told all your friends, neighbors, family to send over anyone who’s been arrested, but it just doesn’t happen.  If it wasn’t for indigent defense work, you would have no work at all.  The bills are coming in and you’re barely making enough to pay the rent.  What the hell happened?

This is not an unusual scenario today.  Criminal defense lawyers never know where their next case is coming from, or whether there will be a next case.  And if a client doesn’t walk in the door, then you have no clients.  Whether you’re the best or the worst lawyer doesn’t seem to matter; you can’t defend if the defendant’s don’t come.  And you can’t make a living without them.

Finally, the call comes in from Joe Defendant’s baby mama.  She comes in for the appointment and tells you what little she knows about the case.  More importantly, she tells you what she wants you to tell her; the words that will make her take the money out of the paper bag she clutches and give it to you.  The rents due.  You darling wife, who deserves only the finest things in life, has lost her taste for hamburger helper.  And before you know it, the words slip out of you mouth.  “Oh yes, Baby Mama, of course I can get him out on bail. No problem.”  “Sure, I beaten cases just like your a dozen times. No problem.” 

Of course, seeing the future is not one of the skills you possess.  You don’t know if you can get him out or win his case.  No one knows whether he or she can do it.  But you said it.  You made the promise.  And she gave you the money.  You have just taken one giant step onto the slippery slope of being a lying lawyer.  And it was easy.  And you made money.  And you got the case.  And if it doesn’t happen, you can certainly make up some excuse about how it wasn’t your fault.  And they’ll believe you and you will still have the money.

It’s all about business.  And money.  And the promise that your mother made you when you decided to go to law school and believed, like the child you were, that the law owed you a good, comfortable living.  And about the disappointment when you learned that you’d been had.  So now you’re going to scam the client, just like you were scammed, because you deserve to live well as a lawyer.  Mother promised.

There are two abiding problems in criminal law that we rarely discuss, no less confront.  First, there are just too many lawyers.  If you split the pie too many ways, nobody gets a decent slice.  Second, there are too many lawyers who just aren’t very good.  But it’s almost impossible for a client to know whether a lawyer is great or incompetent.  Bennett will disagree with me about this, but I subscribe to “believing is seeing,” not the other way around.  It pains me that this is true.

So the only thing that inhibits a lawyer from telling a potential client what they want to hear is his own personal integrity.  For most of us, that’s reason enough.  For some it’s not.  We are all only as viable as a business as the next case that walks in the door, but what we’ll do to score the case is another matter. 

So when you hang out that shingle, you need to decide whether you are going to be the lying lawyer or the honest lawyer.  Chance are that if you lie through your teeth, make promises you can’t keep or give guarantees that are impossible, no one will know except you and your potential client.  You will have an advantage over a lawyer like me, because you’re going to tell the client what he or she wants to hear and I’m not.  But I’ve made my choice.  When you hang out your shingle, you have to make yours. 

Appellate Follies

From Kevin Underhill at  Lowering the Bar, this post about the appellate brief from the Biglaw firm of O’Melveny & Myers representing former Enron CEO Jeffrey Skilling.  Big law, big brief.  The brief weights in at a whopping 239 pages and 58,922 words.  Anybody want to guess at whether O & M charges by the word?

I’m sure the lawyers at O & M know lots of words, and want to use them all on behalf of their client.  But there is one word that apparently escapes them:  Brief. 

Clients love it when briefs are long and contain lots of arguments.  The more arguments, the better it must be as far as the client is concerned.  They feel like they are really getting their monies worth, and leaving no stone unturned.  But lawyers are supposed to know better.

The more words, pages and arguments, the more the strength of the appellant’s position is diluted.  It sends a message to the appellate court that you don’t think you have a winning argument (and therefore have to throw in everything, including the kitchen sink), or you can’t state your argument clearly and concisely.  Neither message works to the appellant’s benefit.

While Kevin Underhill has read the brief and says it’s actually quite good (I haven’t read the brief, and have no intention of doing so until Skilling’s people send me a check), he sums up the problem in far fewer words than Biglaw can mange:  It’s just way too goddamn long.  Nice touch.

And on the plagiarism front, Carolyn Elafont (by way of Volokh) bring us the saga of the bankruptcy brief submitted by lawyer Peter Cannon that was glommed wholesale from an article by some Morgan Lewis lawyers.  And so he’s sanctioned by the judge for having lifted it without attribution.

As Carolyn correctly notes, isn’t plagiarism something of the touchstone of the law?  The first thing we learn in law school is not to reinvent the wheel.  They we’re taught our first Latin phrase, stare decisis.  I can’t recall anyone mentioning anything about “giving credit where credit is due.” 

Enough kidding around.  What happened here was clearly over the top by any measure.  If nothing else, it was a fraud on the client who thought he was paying for his lawyer to produce work, not copy over someone else’s.  But if somebody had already done an excellent job dealing with an issue, and it addresses the identical issue presented in your case, what purpose is served by ignoring the existence of the earlier work and starting from scratch?  None, obviously, but the Judge’s point is not that Cannon should have ignored the Morgan Lewis article, but dealt with it honestly and not attempted to take credit for another lawyer’s work.

I have a hard time imagining that such a massive theft would actually work for Cannon, though Carolyn’s description of how the judge came upon the plagiarism suggests that it worked very well.  One would think that there would be substantial reworking to address the particulars of the individual case, particularly since there was so much time available because all the legal work had already been done. 

But here’s the question:  Had Cannon put a quotation mark at the beginning and another at the end, would that have sufficed? 

Losing By Winning

As we fight our way through a case, we sometimes find ourselves bumping our heads against a wall that wasn’t there a minute before.  While clients expect lawyers to “know” everything in advance, cases often play out in somewhat twisted and unforeseeable ways.  What to do?

This happened yesterday in the case in which I’m now on trial.  The cases started as a drug bust and developed into a bribery case later on.  Drugs suppressed for unconstitutional stop and count dismissed.  Not bad so far, but the Court does not suppress alleged evidence of bribery as “fruit” due to attenuation.

This rulings creates a structural problem.  How do you place a defendant in a jail cell to commence the bribery portion of the case?  To put him there without explanation invites speculation coupled with the obvious implication that he committed some crime which, for unknown reasons, is not before the jury.  To put him there with explanation undermines the exclusionary and suppression, allowing the government to use the product of an unlawful search and seizure to “explain” and “illuminate”.

Clearly, the government needs to show something to explain its case, and so it argues.  In opposition, I argue (among many other technical issues) that by giving the jury a smidgen of the underlying drug case to explain what the defendant is doing in a jail cell, the government is in better shape than it would have been had there been no constitutional violation.

How so?  Well, the proffer is to tell the jury that the defendant was arrested for drugs and that drugs were seized.  No mention of disposition, leaving the jury to engage in sheer speculation about the outcome of the case, though it is impossible to believe that the jury will not leap to the obvious conclusion that the defendant was in fact guilty. 

The Court granted the application under the guise of “motive”, meaning that the government is entitled to show the defendant’s motive for bribery.  It’s a better theory than the government offered, but it fails to address any of the defense concerns.

So what does this mean?  It places the defense in the position of having to try the drug case anyway or bear the consequences of the silent implication of guilt, along with its inherent taint and prejudice.  If it’s not disputed by the defense, then he is tacitly admitting guilt of a crime with which he is not charged and which has been dismissed. 

So the defendant won suppression and yet lost the ability to prevent the government from tarring and feathering him on the second count by use of the dismissed charge. 

Despite my arguments to the court that the answer to the structural problem presented by the suppression ruling, that sometimes the government doesn’t get to go through the back door when the front door has slammed shut due to unconstitutional police conduct, and sometimes they just don’t get to prosecute a charge even though it might otherwise be prosecutable, we’re moving ahead and I’m stuck (for now) with the ruling that the government can freely paint my client a criminal in advance of addressing its remaining charge.

When the rulings become this convoluted and prejudicial, it’s time to go to more extreme measures.  Once it became clear that the Court would neither change it’s ruling or do anything beyond a “cautionary instruction” to ameliorate the harm, it was time to become much more aggressive.

My next argument was that, given the ruling, it was now incumbent upon the defense to open with two points, and I sought an advance ruling on whether this would “open the door” to the prosecution.  Point one was that I intended to open to the jury that the defendant was “factually innocent” of the drug charges, which was the case as proven at the suppression hearing when we presented a defense witness who testified that he, not the defendant, was in possession of the drugs at the time of arrest. 

The Judge found that he was unable to conclude that the defense witness was more or less credible than the police witnesses, thus denying the prosecution the preponderance of the evidence. 

Second, I would tell the jury that the drug charge had been dismissed by the prosecution because it could not prove it’s case, and third that the Court held the police conduct to be unlawful.

But I wasn’t done yet.  I then announced my intention to call the prosecutor as a defense witness to testify that he had dismissed the charge against the defendant, unless he stipulated.  I was shocked when the prosecutor rose from his seat in opposition.

The Judge thoughtfully considered my approach, and stated that I was certainly entitled to challenge the evidence of motive, and that he could not see any reason why my position would open the door to anything.  He took my intention to call the prosecutor as a witness under advisement. 

At the end of the day, we not only have a spectacular and preserved issue for appeal, but more importantly we may have turned this position cum negative back into a positive for the defendant.  The case should have been tossed, but it wasn’t.  Rather than wring our hands and whine about it, we maintain focus and find a way to turn a negative into a positive.  There’s no other option.

A Prof’s View From Inside the Jury Room

Anne Reed at Deliberations brings us yet another gem from the jury room.  This time, the insights of an anonymous law professor who somehow made his way onto a criminal jury in a drunk driving case.  It’s one thing to engage in academic speculation about what happens in the minds of a jury, but another to be part of it, and thus an accepted member of that very special club deciding the fate of another.

Of course, we’re talking about a drunk driving case, not a murder or a massive drug conspiracy.  But from the comments, which I come as no surprise, they jurors are still as deadly serious about their duty as if it were the most serious case ever.

Of the four points made by the lawprof, 3 stand out.

1.  The jury instructions were “utterly useless.” 

2.  Bizarre logical leaps by some jurors.

3.  How deeply formalistic and legalistic most jurors were.

The first point, about jury instructions, come as no surprise at all.  While lawyers may argue the words, the nuance, the implications to death, they are pure crap to the normal juror.  This is one of the goofiest legal fictions we employ.  Indeed, if we wrote them down, spelled it all out and made jurors study them for a week before hand, my guess is they still wouldn’t have a clue what the instructions mean.  Bear in mind, nobody has ever come up with a viable instruction for beyond a reasonable doubt.

The second and third are related.  Jurors try their absolute best to fulfill their duty.  The solemn courtroom, serious lawyers, judge in robe and on bench, contribute to the atmosphere.  They shed the frivolity of everyday life for the “formalistic and legalistic” demeanor that they think is expected of them.  It’s like a funeral in the sense that they behave as they believe they should, though never quite clear on the expectations.

Part of pretending to be serious is to strive to think harder then the usually do.  This is the bizarre logical leaps part, where people who don’t ordinarily think much are forced into unfamiliar turf.  Try as they might, logic doesn not come easily or without practice.  It may be that they don’t grasp logic.  It may be that they are trying too hard, and stretching so far to show their brilliance that the bounds of logic have expanded beyond their breaking point. 

This is the lawyer’s worst nightmare, since we cannot anticipate where the minds of jurors may go once they are no longer trapped by fact or reason.  We can argue the logical permutations of the facts, but that serves as a mere starting point for those jurors who want to out-think us.  You didn’t think they trusted us to argue the case accurately, did you?

What does all this amount to?  A system that, for all its safeguards, is beyond the control of either lawyer or judge.  If they can’t make us of instructions, pretend to play serious juror to meet some unknown expectations and then leap off the logic train at will, there doesn’t seem to be much reason to bother with a trial since there is no causal connection between what we do and what they decide.  Hence, we engage legal fictions (the jurors followed the instructions) to overcome the obvious flaws.

Or, we engage in a system which, at its bottom line, provides rough justice as viewed through the eyes of 11 ordinary people and one lawprof.  You pick.

3 Short Takes: Stuff You Should Know About III

From the ABA Journal, it’s now universal.  The judge in an Australian criminal trial gave new meaning to “you snooze, you lose.”  Asleep and snoring, the appellate court upheld the conviction, holding that there is “no relevant distinction to be made between a judge who is asleep and one who is awake but inattentive.”  We wouldn’t want to expect too much from judges, now would we.  So now we’re 2 down, 1 to go.  Any sleeping prosecutor stories out there?

Davey Crocket, per Crime & Federalism, understood the true nature of fiscal conservatism.  After Congress (including Crocket) voted to give $20,000 to the victims of a Georgetown fire (aside: this was the public line, it was actually given to Halliburton to distribute, and only $12 actually made it to victims), he was ripped by a constituent for giving away other people’s money.  Doing something unheard of, Davey recognized the folly of using public money as a gift and changed his mind.  He later chastised Congress for its largess toward others with taxpayer money while they held their own tightly in their little grubby hands.

Robert Guest at I Was The State reminds us of that little prosecutorial detail of how the duty of a prosecutor is not to convict, but to see that justice is done.  Seizing a brief question from the Texas prosecutors’ message board about how to find a rationale to prosecute when the truth fails the constitutional sniff test, he asks why winning trumps everything.  This can’t be said enough (and especially to prosecutors), justice sometimes means adhering to the Constitution.  Of course, if they did that, all the other prosecutors at the bar would make fun of them.

Biglaw: The Prosecutor Myth Lives

And they believe in fairies too!  An announcement in the New York Lawyer yesterday that another Biglaw firm has hired another Assistant United States Attorney for its White Collar Litigation Group.  Well, it’s always good news when someone comes back from the dark side, but that’s not the point of this post.  You see, this Biglaw firm has a whole “white collar” defense group (don’t we all?) consisting exclusively of former prosecutors!

Well, isn’t that wonderful?  After all, who better to defend than someone who has spent their entire career putting miscreants away.  This is the myth that has been promoted and perpetuated for public consumption for as long as I can remember.  The only problem is that it’s a fiction.  They wrap these former prosecutors in whole cloth to cover up one indisputable fact.  They have zero experience in defense, and their entire understanding of criminal defense is losing.

This is not to say that a former prosecutor can’t make a good defense lawyer.  Indeed, many do, and some are exceptionally good.  But being a former prosecutor does not give one a leg up, nor prepare a lawyer to do criminal defense.  And the perpetuation of the myth is just shocking.

What’s worse is the quote from Chairman of the Biglaw firm:

Ballard Spahr Chairman Arthur Makadon said the firm identified Mann as a “superb trial lawyer,” and asked if she would be interested in joining the group.

“Let’s face it, lawyers who know how to try cases are few and far between at this point,” he said.



Artie, somebody needs to tell you this.  For every case tried by a prosecutor, there’s at least one defense lawyer on trial as well.  For the most part, they’re lawyers too. 

I won’t question whether the former prosecutor is a superb trial lawyer.  In fact, I’ll give them that one.  But then, she has a whole bunch of guys and gals we call “agents” working for her, all of whom have guns and shields.  She has the ear of the federal judiciary.  She has the bias in favor of law and order that has been beaten into the head of every American man, woman and child over the past 50 years.  Even a superb trial lawyer gains a little advantage with these.

The defense lawyer has nothing more than hard work, quick thinking and the will to face a government determined to take her client away.  Will she still be as superb when stripped of the accourtrements of an AUSA?  That has yet to be seen.

Not only does this former prosecutor get the gig as a criminal defense lawyer, but she comes in as partner.  What a great deal, since she can’t bring a single client to the firm (unless she’s been handing out cards while on the government dole) and is nothing more than a worker bee at this stage. 

Try as hard as you might, there is no Biglaw firm that I know of that wants to talk to anybody who doesn’t have business to bring in.  The first question is always, “What are your portables?”  Of course, in criminal defense, we don’t (and can’t) have portables.  Clients have to be arrested first.  It’s the nature of the biz.

So why doesn’t Biglaw turn to the public defenders or the private criminal bar to find their “superb trial lawyers?”  After all, they need someone amongst their thousands of lawyers who can find their way to a courtroom, right? 

I can’t say for sure why their heads are rarely turned in our direction, but I have a theory.  We don’t dress like them.  We don’t know what fork to use at state dinners.  Sometimes, we mix our metaphors.  Oh, the disgrace.  On the other hand, prosecutors wear regimental striped ties and sturdy lace-up shoes.  Their hair is always cut short and well-groomed.  They blend.

But most importantly, Biglaw doesn’t represent those dirty little criminals that we do.  Sure, we handle white collar criminals too, but our hands are dirty from those “others”.  And when we clean up and represent a better class of criminal, we do it all wrong.  Instead of trotting them over to the U.S Attorney’s office at the first possible opportunity to share a cup of tea and whatever information our client can give up, we actually defend them.  We come up with a strategy designed to win.  We fight. 

How low class of us.  Imagine the horror of white collar defense lawyers not sucking up to government prosecutors.  It’s downright undignified.  Biglaw guys don’t want to be around people like us.  They certainly don’t want to be around the people we represent.  Can you imagine our clients in the waiting room, sullying up the rich Corinthian leather chairs?

And so the myth continues, because Biglaw (and former prosecutors) needs to justify its choices without regard to how well it serves its clients.  The nice thing about believing in fairies is that their feet never get dirty as they flitter about the office.  I may not be able to fly, but I sure can defend.  And for the record, I look damn good in my school tie.

The Real Threat to Criminal Defense


Yesterday, we considered Skelly’s concern that young lawyers didn’t want to grow up to be criminal defense lawyers anymore.  It was my view that this would ultimately have little impact.  Today, let us consider what I believe to be the most significant threat to the constitutional right to effective representation that we face going forward.

The vast majority of lawyers practicing on the defense side of criminal law live off the largess of the government.  Public defenders are wholly supported by the government to provide legal services to those who are unable to afford private counsel.  This is the mandate of Gideon in its purest form. 

There are also private lawyers who provide alternative legal services to the indigent.  While there are a variety of methods by which these lawyers are appointed and paid (in New York, they are called 18b lawyers and federally they are called CJA lawyers), for many these appointments constitute a significant percentage of their practice and income.  It’s not that they make a killing off this work, but it pays the bills and keeps them afloat.

As for private lawyers who do not rely on indigent defense work to make ends meet, their numbers are dwindling, as are there incomes.  While there are some white collar defense firms making millions off the backs of disgraced CEOs, there aren’t enough of them to go around and it doesn’t do much good for the criminal defense lawyers in the trenches. 

Based upon my highly scientific personal observations, the private criminal defense bar is not doing very well.  Highly regarded lawyers are having an increasingly difficult time obtaining sufficient business to keep them going.  Newer, or less well regarded lawyers, are taking any case that walks in the door (i.e., felonies for $1000) just to make the rent.  These lawyers are branching out into more lucrative areas of law, such as personal injury, where the pickings are better.  Sure, there are plenty of interesting cases around.  Unfortunately, the defendants in these interesting cases can’t afford a lawyer.

Before anyone jumps to the conclusion that my observations are based on the high fees charged by lawyers, let us consider that a $10,000 legal fee at $200 per hour covers only 50 hours.  And $200 per hour is piddling compared with civil lawyers charging $1000 per hour, the new going rate for a competent litigator (or Biglaw partner, whichever comes first).

What does this portend?  The ongoing existence of a fully independent private criminal defense bar may be in jeopardy.   It’s not for lack of interest and desire, but everybody has to eat, and most like nice things as well.  The harsh truth is that criminal defense lawyers want to get paid for their efforts, and if they can’t get paid doing criminal defense, then they have to find an alternative.

That leaves the remaining criminal defense lawyers on the public teat.  Therein lies the problem.  If the corps of lawyers dedicated to the defense of the accused survives financially by the largess of the sovereign, it faces two fundamental problems:

1.  The government can decide to pay (or not pay) whatever it likes for criminal defense.   It took 17 years for 18b lawyers to get an increase in fees last time.  How long will it be again?  Moreover, the trend in New York is to move toward a state-wide defender model, and eliminate the use of private lawyers.  Any way you look at it, the future is bleak.

2.  The government can dictate how the people on its payroll perform their function.  Even now, there are “favored” lawyers in most courts that get the plum assignments because the judges know that they can be counted on not to make waves.  In other words, the judges are fairly-well assured that the case will end with a guilty plea, nice and tidy, at the lawyer’s urging.  While this is not a public defender phenomenon, once the government has the criminal defense bar by the balls, who knows how hard they will squeeze.  And even if they don’t squeeze at first, are you comfortable that another Guiliani won’t come along and decide to put an end to the misery?  Eventually, somebody will get elected who hates criminal defense enough to pull the plug.

What about Gideon?  Unfortunately, the wiggle room between Gideon and reality is large enough to drive the proverbial Mack truck though it.  No one is entitled to a perfect trial.  No one is entitled to the lawyer of their choice.  No one is entitled to a good lawyer, just one who isn’t incompetent.  And the standard for incompetence is shockingly low.  Note that this has nothing to do with the current quality of indigent representation, or the comparative quality (whether by PDs or 18bs), as they will all be under the same thumb when the time comes.

I’ve watched this trend happening for a few years now.  As most criminal defense lawyers have shifted their focus to the government for sustenance (a bird in the hand…), they failed to look ahead.  Once there are no meaningful options left, they will owe their souls to the government.  It will then be all over.  The government will own the criminal defense bar.  And that is, in my view, the real threat we face today.