Author Archives: SHG

Practical Blawgosphere: The World is Flatter

For most lawyers, there are only two jurisdictions with which we need to concern ourselves.  Our home state and our federal circuit.  We develop, of necessity, a detailed knowledge of how things work on our little piece of turf, with its local rules and, more importantly, its local unwritten rules. 

When I wrote about how budding lawyers need to know what “parts” were for what purposes, the Texas Tornado, Mark Bennett accused me of speaking Flemish.  To a Houston lawyer, I might as well have been.  These names are hardly universal, although they are basic stuff to the New York lawyer.  It’s just our local lingo, and we take it for granted though it bears no connection to the language used anywhere else.

This highlights one of the best/worst things about the practical blawgosphere.  We overcome all jurisdictional boundaries.  It allows us to compare and contrast, without even thinking about it.  At the same time, we find ourselves getting into some nuanced discussions about everyday issues without recognition that our frame of reference is our jurisdiction, not someone else’s.  We arguing apples and oranges.

Most of what we do is the same no matter where we go.  As for the details of crimes and procedures, we can do a little research and learn the differences in elements, structure and process fairly quickly.  Trying a case, meaning the skills needed to convince 12 people of your position, doesn’t really change much from place to place.   Or does it?

I often think of myself as “Paladin”.  You remember him, the lead character in an old TV show.  He had a card that said, “Have Gun, Will Travel.”  That image has always remained in my head  He was a gun for hire, and went where he was needed.  The scenery may change, but the job remained the same.

Haveguncard.gif

Over the years, I’ve done cases as far away from New York as Anchorage (the time change will kill you), Miami, Los Angeles.  But I’ve also gone to some lesser stars in the Pantheon of metropolitan life, like South Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Connecticut, New Jersey and Kentucky.  I’ve never been asked to represent anyone in Texas, though I’m looking forward to the day when I can wear my cowboy boots to court.

When you travel to another state, particularly one that is fairly distant from your own, there are some special concerns to address.  Obviously, you need local counsel when you’re not admitted in that jurisdiction, both to move your admission pro hoc vice and to show you the ropes.  Just as you would at home, you need to assess the judge, the prosecutor and the police.  You need to learn about how the police ordinarily function, and can never assume that they do things in Bowling Green just like they do in Manhattan.  That’s the quickest way to show you’re “not from around there.”

You also walk into the courtroom with a big sign on your back that says “I’m from New York.”  We tend to dress a little differently (everyone doesn’t ordinarily wear custom made suits, apparently).  They all have funny accents (unlike you, the lone foreigner in the room, who sounds perfectly normal).  But most of all, there’s a very strong chance that you have different sensibilities.  What appears right and normal to you, the obvious stuff, may not be shared by people everywhere.

The trick to all of this is to remember that you, not they, are the outsider.  It is up to the hired gun to blend (courtesy of My Cousin Vinny).  If you fail to recognize this, you are nothing but a carpetbagger.  A carpetbagger starts out in a deep hole, and the locals will silently relish watching you try to claw your way out and, time after time, lose your grip and fall back to the bottom.  When the case is over, they all have a good laugh at the carpetbagger’s expense, as it proved no fancy-pants New York lawyer is any better than them.

There are two ways to accomplish avoid being the carpetbagger.  The first way is to prove your worth.  You need to show everyone in that courtroom that there’s a reason why the defendant brought in a lawyer from out of town, itself an affront to all the locals including the judge.  After all, the judge used to be a local lawyer too, and when threatened by some hired gun, the locals will always circle the wagons.

But this doesn’t mean that you need to prove that you are better than any local.  Indeed, you may find that the “hick” small-town local lawyers are really quite excellent, and every bit as good a lawyer as you, if not better.  If you try to push the envelope to show that you’re the best lawyer in town, you are begging for the rest of them to cut you down to size.  And you can bet they will.  It’s their turf, not yours, and they have the home field advantage.

By “they”, I include your best new friend, your local counsel.  Don’t ever forget that while he’s on the payroll, and he’s helping you out and showing you a little local hospitality, he’s also wondering why the client decided that he’s not worthy of representing the defendant without the hired gun.  Remember, lawyers tend to be ego-bound, and we don’t defer to others easily. 

This cuts both ways with local counsel.  If you treat him poorly, the word will get around quickly and that deep hole you start out in will only get deeper and deeper until you can’t seek the light of day.  The local lawyer, if you’ve hired well, should be your equal at worst, and should be treated as such.  He can be one of your greatest assets, provided you haven’t put yourself on a pedestal.

So once you’ve established that you are not some goofball who has come to some backwater to teach them how it’s done, the next step is acknowledging why you are there.  While the client may retain you because of his fear that local lawyers aren’t good enough, the real reason is the relationship of trust established between lawyer and client.  The client feels comfortable putting his life in your hands.  He may be right, or he may be nuts, but that’s all it means.  And that’s a very good reason to retain an attorney, even if it means bringing in a lawyer from far away.

By so doing, the out-of-towner will be able to break through the resistance of local lawyers and judges to your presence.  They will not accept you because you look down on them.  They will accept you because of client trust.  Every lawyer understands and appreciates the relationship, and this is an acceptable reason for you to get a case that they should rightfully have gotten.  Remember, you’re taking money out of their pocket, and at least in their eyes, have no cause to do so by dint of skill.  Trust, on the other hand, will smooth ruffled feathers.  It won’t earn you their love and devotion, but it will overcome overt animosity and take you out of the carpetbagger status.

So what’s the upside of using a hired gun?  First, we don’t have to worry about the next case.  Getting along with others, in the sense that you fear pushing the envelope because the prosecutor or judge will pay back your next defendant for what happens in this case, is not an issue.  When you go out of town, it’s a one-shot deal.  You have one defendant to represent and you can go for broke without fear that you will harm a relationship that is best maintained.  While many lawyers deny that this happens, it not only does but can have an insidious impact on the level to which a lawyer will go on behalf of any individu
al defendant.  This is the “don’t burn your bridges” factor, and clients’ paranoia about it is well justified.

The second benefit is that you are able to think outside the box.  In fact, it’s likely that you can’t help but think outside the box, since the distinctions between the practice you are used to and the local practice offer little alternative.  When you try to do this in your home jurisdiction, judges will often show you the back of their hand, since you know better than to challenge custom and practice, and your efforts to do so make their life more difficult.   The routine is paramount to the efficient operation of a bureaucracy, and it will resist challenges at all costs.  But out-of-towners don’t know the routine, and hence are given a free pass.  Rather than resist, judges will often open their minds to the possibility that there is a different approach than what they have always done.  It’s really quite amazing how the undoable becomes doable when you’re not from around there.

The third benefit is that you are taken seriously.  You walk into court with a mix of dread and fear, because you are the unknown.  They know that they don’t want to like you, but at the same time they assume there’s something worthy about you or you wouldn’t be there.  A word of caution about this, however.  This benefit may be lost within the first 30 seconds if you open your mouth and stupid or offensive stuff comes out.  While they may assume you’re a killer lawyer, you can put that to rest immediately by conclusively proving that you’re a moron when it’s your turn to speak.  And believe me, there is nothing they would like better than to be able to laugh at you if you’re not up to snuff.

But there’s a downside to being a hired gun as well.  Beyond the obvious, being away from home, family and practice for an extended period of time, lousy hotels and food, abject boredom when the you’re done for the day, your primary job is to persuade people with whom you may have few shared experiences to see things your way.  Assuming that you can be charming enough, and capable of blending (without offending), that a jury won’t want to put you in jail, that does not mean that you can express your thoughts in a way that will connect and resonate with them.  The most brilliant summation from an urban lawyer given to a jury whose lifestyle is agrarian will flop.  Nor can an urban lawyer adopt agrarian sensibilities without coming across as false and condescending.  There are certain lines that are hard to cross.

So, the old adage that discretion is the better part of valor comes into play.  You need to be as harshly critical of yourself as you are of your case.  Can the hired gun pull off a credible and persuasive argument to a group of people he neither knows nor understands?  Sometimes the answer is that your local counsel is a better choice to sum up.  Sometimes the answer is that no matter how hard you try, or how much you want to serve your client, you shouldn’t be there.  But sometimes, you prove that you are up to the task and pull off a coup that could never have been accomplished by a local lawyer.  It can be a tough call, but that’s what we do every day.

Something to Think About As You Wait on the Tarmac

Numerous reports this morning about the delays plaguing our nations airports, combined with the near misses because of the overwhelming number of airplanes clogging our skies.  Scary stuff.  But why?

Well, the New York Times offers one answer:  Private corporate jets.  Those sleek Gulfstreams and cool Lears, where no one sits in coach and the word “stewardess” can still be heard, have become increasingly visible in a world of one size fits all flying.

According to the FAA, the model for airport use is “first come, first served,” meaning that the private jets are just as likely to hold up a plane filled with hundreds of people as the other way around.  And why would the FAA allow this?

The users of corporate jets defend this practice, saying they deserve equal takeoff rights. “On a business flight, you might have people going to Wall Street from companies who are creating jobs and generating billions of dollars in commerce,” Mr. Brown [senior vice president for operations at the National Business Aviation Association, a group representing owners of private business aircraft] says. “People on a commercial flight might be going on vacation or going to New York to go to the theater.”


There you have it.  The people in those corporate jets are important.  You are not.  So if you find yourself sitting on the tarmac in the hermetically sealed cabin, wondering when the nuts are going to get passed around, ponder our Government’s view of how priorities should be set in the use of public facilities.  And if you can get a second bag of nuts, go for it.  You may be hungry again later.

The 3L Dilemma

Over at PrawfsBlawg, a blog dealing with that wonderful insular world of law schools, an interesting post asking what to do about 3rd year law students (or 3Ls as some of the really cool law schools prefer).  The problem is that first and second year students bring interest and enthusiasm to school.  Third year students use law school as a place to hang between job interviews.  What to do.

My 2 cents.  Use third year as a time to teach kids how to BE a lawyer. 

My first “assignment” when I went to work as a lawyer was to “do a motion.”  Now, I knew what a motion was in the conceptual sense.  But I was clueless as to the nuts and bolts.  As I sat there trying to put pen to paper, I had an epiphany.  Three years of law school and I knew nothing about how to be a lawyer.

I had, as do all law students, my moot court argument to fall back on, but not too many budding lawyers have the opportunity to argue before the Supreme Court on their first day on the job.  In retrospect (and having judged moot court competitions for decades), they bear so little resemblance to reality as to make them downright goofy.  More significantly, the “judges”, whether real lawyers or law students on the moot court boards who have deigned themselves experts in such matters, are more likely to have never seen the inside of any courtroom, whether appellate or trial. 

Granted, the harsh reality of the practice of law might conflict mightily with the beautiful theory taught in the first two years.  But that tough lesson will come regardless.  There is a day that law students turn into lawyers, and then must confront the demons of the law.  We can’t protect them forever.

One example of practical instruction that I found quite instructive is the Cardozo Law School Intensive Trial Advocacy Program (ITAP).  For two weeks in January, third year students are turned over to real lawyers by Professors Barry Scheck and Ellen Yaroshefsky.  The group of instructors they’ve assembled is comprised of men and women and judges (who are neutral by definition) who can talk about it because they do it. 

This is an immersion program in trials.  They come in as kids and leave as trial lawyers.  Well, not quite, but a whole lot more like a trial lawyer then they would have been without the program.  It’s amazing to watch the improvement as the two weeks goes along, as law students begin to understand what it means to try a case, to be up there in the spotlight with critical eyes waiting to rip your head off.  While we try very hard to be kind and positive, the students realize that it’s a very tough job to do well and that their delusions of brilliance in law school does little to help them when they stand up for cross.

But this is just one program, and only two weeks, and not real.  Close to real, but nobody goes to jail or loses their life savings if they mess up.  Sometimes, it’s hard to get the students, and even the judges, to stay in character.  They aren’t ready for the transition. 

What about learning how to draft a motion?  How about learning where the arraignment parts are as opposed to the trial parts?  They may know the purpose of bail, but can they argue a bail application?  There are a million nuts and bolts pieces to being a lawyer, and they leave law school without ever having been told.

The third year of law school should be about being a lawyer.  They should already know how to think like a lawyer, to write and research and to have some substantive knowledge of the law.  Let’s take them out of the warm, comforting hands of academia and put them into the hard, calloused hands of working lawyers, before we turn them loose on the world.

Store Policy and Crime

It’s Sunday morning, time for some thought about public policy.

The Consumerist reports of a fellow who purchased some items from a large tech retailer and decided to do the unthinkable, leave after paying for his purchase.  The problem was that the store, TigerDirect, had a policy to check receipt of customers on the way out the door.

Let us dispose of the obvious issue first.  Checking receipts on the way out the door has become a fairly common practice in big box type stores, with lots of people going in and out, to prevent theft.  There’s nothing wrong with stores doing what they can to prevent shoplifting (which costs us all) and showing your receipt to the security guard/retiree/former gang member just isn’t too much of a burden.  In other words, what’s the big deal?

Here’s the big deal:  Stores and businesses are routinely imposing “policies” that conflict with the law and the legal rights of individuals, to the point where many are committing crimes.  If you or I commit a crime, perhaps we would be prosecuted and, perhaps, we would go to jail. 

In the Consumerist story, the individual was detained for failure to show receipt. Not for shoplifting, as there was no basis to believe he had done anything wrong except refuse to comply with the receipt showing policy.  Yet he was detained by the store security guard and publicly abused by the store manager.

What did the State’s attorney have to say about it?  “I called the States Attorney’s office for my county and spoke to a prosecutor who “said charges would not be forthcoming.” Basically, his explanation was that I wasn’t detained long enough for him to bother.”  Fair enough.  Allocation of scarce resources dictates that choices have to be made, and it was likely that this wasn’t the biggest crime in the county.

But the underlying problem is one of far larger magnitude that a brief detention.  While lawyers argue daily about overreaching by police and government, the overreaching that most impacts regular people is by stores and businesses that confuse their self-serving policy with the force of law.  They believe they are a law unto themselves, and have no responsibility to comport themselves in accordance with the rules that apply to everyone else.

What was remarkable about the TigerDirect incident is that it involved a physical detention.  This happens, though mostly to minority shoppers, with some regularity but fails to make anyone’s radar unless it results in a bust.  What of those who are detained and then released?  These are the forgotten folks, just like those nice people stopped for DWB on the New Jersey Turnpike who don’t happen to have drugs or guns in their car.  We never hear about these stops under the no harm, no foul rule.  Of course, you might feel differently about it if you are the person being stopped for no reason.

Many years ago, I shared an office with a firm that did corporate work.  One day, a lawyer came into my office to show me a “limited warranty” he had just drafted.  It was comical in that it was so egregiously in violation of a half dozen consumer protection laws (even back then, when consumer protection was a mere twinkle in a legislator’s eye).  So I said to him, “You have got to be kidding, This is awful.”  He laughed at me.  Stupid young lawyer.  Of course it breaks a half dozen laws, but 90% of the people who read it will accept it and that means we just cut our client’s refunds by 90%. 

He was right.  I was stupid.  I thought that businesses, like people, should try to do the right thing.  What was I thinking?

Since then, I have been attuned to abuse of the law by business, and it has bugged me ever since.  People at the top come up with “policies” that work for them and protect their interests.  They hand them down to the people at the bottom, who accept these policies as if they are the word of God.  Should we expect the security guard at TigerDirect to know the law on detention and false imprisonment?  What about kidnapping? 

It’s ridiculous to argue with the people at the bottom, the guards, the customer service reps, the cashiers, because they can’t possibly know right from wrong, and they are just doing their job.  If they want another paycheck next week, they will enforce the businesses’ policies to the death, regardless of whether they violate the law.

One of my personal favorite “policies” relates to returns and refunds at a store.  Often, the store’s policy is printed on the back of the receipt given upon completion of the transaction, meaning that you have no notice that you can’t return an item until after you’ve purchased it.  To add insult to policy, the receipts are often unreadable, but that’s an ink issue rather than a policy issue, unless it is done purposefully to make sure you never see the offending policy.  I wouldn’t put it beyond some stores to do exactly that.

Another “policy” fav is when the cashier asks for your name as you make a cash purchase.  If you say no, most stores today will just let it slide, but some still insist that they can’t sell you their goods unless you provide a name and address.  “The register won’t work unless you tell me,” I’ve been told.  So, I tell them I’m Richard Milhous Nixon.  The young ones don’t even blink.

The last time I ranted about matters such as this, someone commented (appropriately), “So, what do you propose we do about it?”  Good question.  One answer is that we all stop shopping at stores that violate the law, but then who can live without Victoria Secrets underwear?  I mean, really. 

But this time I do have an answer.  Isn’t this why states have attorneys general?  Are they not the peoples’ lawyer?  It’s time that the guys in the capital who are charged with enforcing all those great laws that legislatures pass to protect the consumer and control the dealings of businesses who enjoy the largesse of our states to earn their keep.  If they have a consumer protection bureau, call them and complain.  If they don’t, call them and complain that they need one. 

When some kid answers the phone there and opines that he doesn’t think enforcement of a particular law is worthy of his time, explain to him gently, using small words, that your $2, combined with everyone else’s $2, comes out to a lot of $2.  Would it be okay with him if you stole $2,000,000?  If not, why is it okay if a large retailer does it?

There are many complaints about class action lawyers who sue corporations for trivial offenses that affect millions of people.  The millions of people end up with squat, while the lawyers make a fortune (not that there’s anything wrong with that).  But they fill the void of consumer (or shareholder) protection by serving as private attorneys general.  If it offends you that they exist, then demand that your duly elected attorney general get off his butt and do his job. 

I bet that most business would change their policy after a nice phone call from the AG telling them that they can’t do whatever they are doing.  A reminder that their “policy” doesn’t trump the law is going to address a ton of these problems.  On the other hand, when government’s response to violations of the law is “it’s not worth our time,” the message to businesses is clear:  You’re the boss.  Do whatever works best for you and the law be damned.  Not the message I want sent.

Nanny Diaries: Reviewing the Review

From the New York Times :
But Ms. Johansson’s Annie, who narrates the movie in a glum, plodding voice, is a leaden screen presence, devoid of charm and humor. With her heavy-lidded eyes and plump lips, Ms. Johansson may smolder invitingly in certain roles, but “The Nanny Diaries” is the latest in a string of films that suggest that this somnolent actress confuses sullen attitudinizing with acting.


Oh my God!  Even former Judge Leslie Crocker Snyder, whose mouth has spewed such venom that defendants had to wait in line to threaten her life, was never that harsh.  Who did Scarlett Johansson kill?

To be frank, I didn’t even know who Scarlett Johansson was until last summer, when I got a call to rent my Austin Healey for a shoot with her.  I asked if she was the actress in the Swedish version of “Gone with the Wind.”  I was met with incredulity.  “You don’t know Scarlett Johansson?”  I mean, I’m hip, but who can keep track of every starlet, right?

Sullen attitudinizing.  As opposed to happy attitudinizing?  Is “attitudinizing” a word?  It must be if it’s in the New York Times.  But is it a crime that demands such severe public punishment?

Being a New Yorker, I have some passing familiarity with both nannies and the people who employ them.  First, let us be absolutely clear.  No matter what agency you use, you are not going to get Scarlett Johansson to be your nanny.  Second, decent (not to mention English speaking) nannies are in such demand that one wrong glance and she’d be out of there in a flash.  What, you don’t think Scarlett couldn’t get another nanny gig?  And third, what’s with the gratuitous slur of the West Side? 

But who cares about the movie.  It’s the critique that’s a killer.  Writer Stephen Holden needs to take the F train downtown to Centre Street and start teaching Morgenthau’s minions how to do some serious damage in their indictments.  And if you want to see sullen attitudinizing, spend an hour in an arraignment part. 

Sometimes The System Works

Hat tip to Ken Lammers at CrimLaw for picking up this Washington Post story about a former prosecutor, now Washington D.C. judge, testifying about two rogue homicide detectives who she caught fixing trials.  According to the article, federal prosecutors and cops have lined up on either side of the aisle over the “power struggle” between cops and prosecutors.

You’ve got to admit, a story like this restores your faith in the system.  This is what it’s supposed to be, where prosecutors don’t just love their cops so much that they believe every lie and scam out of their mouths.  Where judges are willing to put their lives and careers on the line to testify because it’s the right thing to do.  Where the people in whom the public reposes trust acts to earn that trust, even if it means telling the truth about the ugly underbelly of law enforcement. 

When I read this story, I just swelled with pride.  There is integrity left in the world.  All right, the feeling passed.

Now for our Abner Louima flashback.  So the cops have lined up to support one of their own, no matter that these mutts coached witnesses on how to finger the wrong person as the perp.  So when push comes to shove, cops will invariably circle the wagons, protect some of their own over honesty, integrity and justice.  Well, now we’re back to reality.  The blue wall of silence looms over all.  Isn’t that the way it’s supposed to be?

We, the People, give these men and women guns and shields upon their taking an oath to uphold the law and Constitution.  In return, they lie and cheat and violate our trust.  What’s wrong with this picture? 

So there’s a few bad apples out there in the cop bushel.  We pluck them out and we’re done, right?  Not exactly.  That’s the circling the wagons problem.  You see, if they were really the good guys, then those cops who were not in support of other cops lying and cheating and violating our trust would NOT stand behind their dirty brothers in blue.  They would pull out their weapons and cuffs and arrest a dirty detective, because that it their job.  More than a job, that is their oath.  When a crime is committed, it is their responsibility to act.  And by act, I do not mean throw them a fund-raising party to cover legal fees.

After Abner Louima was brutally anally raped with a toilet plunger, a precinct full of cops was made aware when this scum named Justin Volpe waved the plunger around like a prize.  Not one single man or woman in that precinct lifted a finger.  It is the paradigm of police failure. 

So here, the detectives didn’t use a toilet plunger, but merely subverted the system of justice by having their witness finger the wrong man.  From the cop perspective, my guess is that nobody get all that bent out of shape since this is in the finest of law enforcement tradition.  Except one former federal prosecutor, now judge, who has my humble appreciation.





“Well Settled Law” In Lieu of Balls

Gideon at A Public Defender has been keeping up with the bizarre saga of Philip Russell, a Connecticut attorney under federal indictment for violating SOX (if you can believe that) by having destroyed the kiddie porn photos on a church computer at a time when there was no investigation or prosecution pending or anticipated.

Russell’s client, the Greenwich Christ Church (not a bad client, I would say), did what any self-respecting church would do when it found child pornography on its church computer:  It turned to its lawyer for help.  No fed was knocking on the church door.  There was no hint of an investigation.  There was no reason to believe that anyone would ever know that some sick, disgusting human being using this computer purchased with monies from the tithing of its congregents (I’m making this part up, since I have no idea where the money came from to buy the computer and in Greenwich, they could just as easily live off the interest from the Church’s trust fund), would download photographs that would sicken any normal human being. 

So Russell finds himself in the position of having to decide what to do with this computer.  The Church no doubt wants its computer back, since it wouldn’t have gotten the computer if it didn’t have any need for it,  But the Church does not want this pics on it.  Russell, in the meantime, knows of the photos as a result of confidential communications (no argument from any source about whether this was as confidential as it comes) and has to decide what to do about it.  He can’t keep the kiddie porn pics, for then he would be violating the law. 

So Philip Russell does the only reasonable thing possible.  He deletes the horrific photos.  BAM, he’s indicted for obstruction, having destroyed evidence.  Up to now, there’s no factual dispute.

The Government, overreaching for the same reason that dogs’ tongues are perpetually busy, contends that under SOX, there need not be a federal investigation pending or specifically anticipated, but merely foreseeable.  There’s the rub.  You see, any time a lawyer becomes aware of a crime, is it not always foreseeable that an investigation or prosecution may follow?  It’s a definitional thing. 

So Russell moves to dismiss.  Motion denied, says federal Judge Alan Nevas:


“In sum, there is no merit to Russell’s arguments, which essentially ask the court to make a factual determination that the government cannot prove either a nexus or intent,” Nevas wrote. “It is well settled that such factual determinations are for a jury, not the court, to decide after hearing the government’s proof and being instructed on the law.”
The words “well settle” are the dead giveaway that Judge Nevas punted.  When a judge doesn’t want to take the heat for making the right decision, he falls back on platitudes that deflect responsibility for doing his job.  while it is obviously a truism that juries, not judges, make findings of fact, judges remain the gatekeeper of whether there really is an issue of fact to decide.  In other words, just because some federal prosecutor screams out the words “factual dispute” doesn’t divest the judge of all responsibility for filling out his robes.

Only legitimate and material factual disputes need go to a jury.  Rhetorical disputes must first pass muster as a matter of law to determine whether they are real.  In the Russell case, there is no real dispute.  The Government doesn’t contend that Philip Russell knew of any investigation that he was impeding, or got wind of a potential reason to belief that an investigation was coming.  But the Government position is legal, not factual.  If it was foreseeable, then he’s guilty.

But it’s always foreseeable, in the existential sense.  When wrong happens, prosecution is always possible.  The point of this is that under the Government’s theory of prosecution, lawyers (the guys who are ethically and legally obliged to maintain client confidences) would have no option but to turn the evidence over to the Government immediately.  They can’t hold it (crime), they can’t destroy it (crime) and they can’t return it (crime).

Assuming Judge Nevas didn’t manage to get himself a life appointment because he’s a dope, he has to understand this.  It’s not rocket science.  Is he really saying that a client availing oneself of the constitutional right to counsel creates a per se crime for the lawyer?  Well, yes, that’s apparently what he’s saying when he fails to use his gatekeeper function to reject this theory. 

And that’s the point: This is a theory, not a fact dispute.  It is a theory of criminal liability that tears at the fundamental function of a lawyer.  And the judge has covered up his refusal to do his job under the guise of “well settled” law. 

Perhaps there’s a lesson to be learned from the dog. Just follow his tongue to see what’s missing from this decision.

OT: Blawgosphere Trackbacks and Cialis

I’m far better with substance than I am with blogospherical sophistication.  There are these things called trackbacks, which allow blogs to talk to one another about their links.  I think.  Anyway, I get the occasional query from another blawg about why my trackbacks don’t recognize them, and can I please “open” my trackbacks to allow them to work automatically.

No. No, no, no.  Not happening.  I get about a thousand spam “trackbacks” a day for various pharmaceuticals, primarily cialis.  My program catches them and tosses them.  It’s one of the few things my program seem to get right. 

Apparently, there are a bunch of people on the web who think that lawyers, specifically criminal defense lawyers, are in desperate need of cialis.  Is there an epidemic erectile dysfunction that I’m not aware of?  What is it about lawyers that makes these sellers so bent on getting the availability of their product hooked up here?  Are we more likely flaccid then other lawyers?  Are lawyers more flaccid than non-lawyers?  Do they have this problem on prosecutor blawgs? 

Now I also get spam trackbacks for Ambien, which I believe helps one to sleep at night.  At least this makes more sense, since so many people think that criminal defense lawyers have trouble with that. 

The ones that I find most bizarre are spam trackbacks for naked Flintstones cartoons.  Yes, you read that right.  Naked Flintstones.  Also Jetsons.  Now, I have to ask this question.  Are there really people who want to see naked cartoons?  I mean, they’re cartoons!  They aren’t real.  Does the thought of a naked cartoon character really turn someone on?  That’s not sick; that’s pathetic.  This has got to be some goof that someone’s playing on me.  Bennett?  Gideon?  Judge Roberts?  Come on guys, fess up.

So if I was to allow open trackbacks, this place would be swamped with cialis ads.  Not that I have an issue with capitalism or entrepreneurship, but I don’t do this so spammers have a place to shill.  I apologize to the legitimate trackback folks who are stymied by my resolve to keep the spam out, but it’s what I’ve got to do.  But thanks for the links anyway.

The Fallacy of True Believers

Yesterday, I received an email from Steve Schmidt alerting me to a post at Missouri Criminal Defense Lawyer, a blawg by Randy England, a Jefferson City lawyer who spent 14 years as a prosecutor before turning over a new leaf for the past 3 years.  The post was about two sides of the same coin, cheating prosecutors and blind defense lawyers.

Zealots.  True believers.  Regardless of which side they associate themselves with, they do so with such fervor that they lose detachment.  As Randy points out, this is a bad thing no matter what side they are on, though for very different reasons.

The worst zealot I’ve ever had the pleasure of working with was Bill Kuntsler.  While he had his charming moments, he was more likely pedantic than anything else.  But then, he was Bill Kuntsler, and he had some right to lecture us kids who didn’t live the life he did or experience the law through the fights he had been through. 

But Bill was a scary guy.  Bill was a true believer in the cause, not that I was ever quite clear what the cause was because abject liberalism is an ever changing line.  Bill existed for the cause, not the client.  If the cause demanded that the client burn, so be it.  He took a long range view of the world, and the cause was far more important than any individual, with their petty problems.  So us stupid kids who found ourselves in his orbit learned quickly that our focus, the client, was mere canon fodder to Bill.  And he could be far more dangerous (because he was far smarter, quicker and stronger) than any prosecutor we had ever met.

His associate/partner, Ron Kuby (now of radio fame with Curtis Sliwa, who can’t hold a candle to Ron’s intelligence) was much more practical.  He understood that clients were people, and never sold out the client for the cause.  Mind you, it wouldn’t have hurt Ron to change his hair style over the 25 years I’ve known him, but tasteful grooming has nothing to do with his focus as an attorney.  He’s still the same lib, but not a slave to doctrine.

True believers usually end up having problems as a criminal defense lawyer.  When people push the “factual innocence” button, they almost always miss the boat.  We don’t defend because our client’s are innocent.  We defend because they are accused.  Our job is to test the government, not to do justice.  Many find this abhorrent.  If justice is the goal, then how can we claim the high ground while admitting that we don’t do it?

There are two sides to this coin, as Randy well notes.  One side, the prosecution, has a different purpose in the system than the other.  The prosecution side, including the police, exist to do justice, and justice means both substantive and procedural.  They are equally responsible for keeping innocent people out of jail as putting the guilty in.  They are responsible for protecting people, but that goes beyond protecting people from crime and includes protecting people from the government. 

This is why the law demands that prosecutors and police disclose information that undermines their position.  If the system was purely adversary, such an obligation would be nuts.  Why require one side to cut its knees off?  Because the duty of the government goes far beyond putting any individual defendant in prison, and extends to providing an system that seeks a higher “truth”, both substantively and procedurally.  Due process and equal protection are the broad cornerstones of the legal system, and the government’s real calling is to assure both to everyone.  Sure, it’s naive, but that’s the theory.

The flip side is the role of criminal defense lawyer.  Whereas prosecutors have a duty to society, the defense lawyer’s duty is to one individual, and only one.  Not fair?  Of course it is.  The playing field is way out of level, with the prosecution having police, guns, access to information and unlimited finances.  The defense lawyer is supposed to level the field, because he (unlike the prosecutor) doesn’t have to concern himself with society’s needs, just his client’s.

When the prosecutor is a zealot, he wreaks havoc on the balance of the system.  If a cop arrests someone, then he MUST be guilty.  If he is absolutely, definitely, beyond any doubt guilty, then the prosecutor MUST do everything in his power to put the defendant away.  After all, in the scheme of competing prosecutorial priorities, putting the bad guy in jail and thus protecting the public from him is at the top.  Nothing else even comes close.

So what’s wrong with that?  Cops are wrong.  More than anyone wants to admit (we would like them to never be wrong, but that’s not life).  And prosecutorial zealots, when confronted with indications that the cops are wrong (or far worse, dirty), will deep six the proof so that the bad guy doesn’t get away. Usually, no one ever knows.  It’s almost impossible to know what happens in the deep, dark back office of the prosecutor.  Rarely does anyone come forward to mention it.

So the defense lawyers are better?  Not necessarily, but the impact is very different.  Most effective defense lawyers start with the assumption that their client is guilty.  Not because he necessarily is, but because it allows him to detach himself from the emotion of the case to step back and assess the case, the evidence, the jurisprudence, from a neutral perspective.  It matters far less what the defendant has to say about his case then what the prosecution has to say.  They put on their evidence, and we must determine what we can do about it. 

Sometimes defendants are innocent.  Far more often, they are guilty.  At least of something.  And sometimes they lie to their lawyers about it, and about the facts that surround it.  If we accept and adopt those lies, we end up the dumb guy in the room, operating from a position of ignorance.  This helps no one, especially our client.  Without knowing what we really have to confront, we cannot be effective. 

It’s difficult for many defendants to appreciate that their lawyer doesn’t care whether they are factually guilty or not.  Many believe that if they insist on their innocence, we will work harder or care more.  Not only is this wrong, but it’s dangerous.  The only real weapon a defense attorney has is information.  If the information is wrong, then he’s shooting blanks.   Feed your lawyer baloney and that’s what he will work with.  But at the end of the day, the client will have to live with the outcome. 

But Randy’s post takes the issue one giant step farther, with his story about defense supporters sitting on one side of the courtroom, like the bride’s friends at a wedding.  When it’s not our case, do defense lawyers invariably support the defendant?  Don’t we care about the fact that some defendants are guilty, and they may be a blight on society?  Yes, we do.

We live in this world too.  We don’t want our children molested, or sold drugs, or murdered.  Lawyers who can’t distinguish between the function of a criminal defense lawyer and the function of the system as a whole within our society are indeed blind.  While we may support a lawyer with whom we are friends (we’re only human), or a defendant with whom we side for a specific reason, we should not support crime.  We can step away from our defense lawyer mindset to appreciate that the cops and the prosecutors serve a vital role in protecting us from harm. 

When I witness wrongdoing, I want it stopped and the perp arrested.  This may sound like heresy, but I have no love of crime.  In fact, I am quite strong on law enforcement, hard as that may be to un
derstand given what I do and what I write.  My expectations of the police acting properly in the course of enforcing the law doesn’t change, but my demand that they do their job remains firm.  I want to see cops on the road.  I want to see cops investigate.  I want to see cops think hard so that they can protect us from crime and, when it happens anyway, find the criminal and bring him to justice.  But it is justice that I want him brought to, not just conviction. 

What stands in the way of this Utopian view?  True believers.