This entry was posted in Uncategorized on .$1000 Per Hour – Cheap At Half the Price
“We have viewed $1,000 an hour as a possible vomit point for clients,” a partner at one New York firm told the newspaper.
Out of a deep appreciation for my carpet, I have decided to put off the increase for the moment. In the meantime, I am willing to take on any major corporations who have decided that this Biglaw rate increase is unpalatable at the discounted rate of $979.95.
The real problem here is that Biglaw guys can’t keep pace with kiddies working on Wall Street, who are getting these multi-million dollar bonuses. Not that the Biglaw partners are going hungry, but they are paupers in the grand scheme of big money. Let’s face facts, why should the Wall Street Bonus Babies get all the really cool houses and cars?
Of course, this has little to do with your regular criminal defense lawyer. Maybe a few Biglaw white collar former AUSA types who do the march to their old office with the CEO on a regular basis, but not us working stiffs. We can charge whatever we want. We just won’t get it. Those $25M defense fees just don’t come our way that often. Hell, I wouldn’t even know how to charge that much. Maybe Morvillo Abramowitz could give a CLE about charging seven figures so the rest of us could learn the secret?
All that time learning how to try cases and win wasted when we could have learned how write more zeros after a number. Bummer.
Is 40 Years Long Enough?
It’s not like Barnes got away with it. He was convicted of attempted murder and sentenced to ten to twenty years. Barnes is now 71 years old.
Lest we feel too sorry for old man Barnes, he left Officer Barclay a paraplegic, with a life of misery ahead of him.
Since there is no statute of limitations for murder, and the final element, death, can take a while to occur, there is nothing conceptually out of line with the idea that William Barnes could be subject to prosecution. But there are some problems. First, as noted by lawyer Jeffrey Lindy in the article, it’s a little hard to establish a direct medical connection between a shot fired and death 40 years later. People eventually die. While under chaos theory there is a connection between everything in the world, the direct connection needed to prove a crime will be a little more difficult to prove (though, as noted here with disturbing frequency, the nexus between act and result is becoming increasingly distant for a conviction).
Second, there comes a point where it ends. No matter whether it is a legally viable prosecution, 40 years later is just too long. Had Barnes somehow evaded prosecution, I would come out on the other side of this argument, and there would be no period of time that would justify ignoring a murder (if murder it was). The message cannot be that if you can hide from a murder long enough, you get away with it.
But Barnes got caught. Barnes did his time. And soon enough, the 71 year old Barnes will answer for his conduct yet again, no matter what we do to him here on earth. I can see how a prosecutor might view this as a chance to take an old man and make the remainder of his life as miserable as possible. Vengeance, hatred and anger are powerful motivations, especially when they are felt by someone who believes that the are acting for the greater good. They know they got Barnes once, but they want to get him again. They want to end his life in as much pain as Officer Barclay. It’s not hard to understand.
But enough is enough. It won’t change the pain of Officer Barclay’s life, or bring him back from death. And it will not stop Barnes from meeting his maker soon enough.
When Cops Go Wrong, #32
The linked Newsday AP story talks about the New York State Police screwing around with discovery, by redacting names of witnesses, withholding information and tapes, and the other little niceties that can make the difference between the truth and the conviction. No reason to repost here what has already been written.
I can envision a few State Police officers having a beer and laughing as they take a black magic marker to cross out stuff in their reports that would provide responsive information to the defense. Maybe playing garbage can basketball with the videotape showing that some other guy was the perp. “Two points,” laughs cop one. “And another mutt bites the dust,” chuckles cop two.
But here’s the question. Over the past 20 years, we’ve had some great police scandals. Serpico, the Dirty 30, DEA Group 33, Abner Louima. Yet they have had negligible impact on the public psyche. They are viewed as isolated incidents rather than systemic flaws. They are compartmentalized, not only by regular folk but by judges and prosecutors, who persist in their blind faith that they would rather err on the side of the cops than find out the truth.
The real story in Supreme Court Justice Thomas McNamara’s decision is that he ruled against the State Police. How overt must that case have been to force a judge to openly smack the cops? Judges will do cartwheels to let lying cops get away with it. Sure, they know that they are lying, but it somehow still falls into the category of “cops will be cops.” As if this makes it okay.
No, I am not advocating for a blanket presumption that all cops are bad, or that a cop that may “modify” his testimony to nail one perp won’t risk his life to save a person from a burning building. But I am stumping for a healthy cynicism. When we put cops on a pedestal and make them immune from real scrutiny, we invite abuse. They don’t fear false testimony; it’s just part of the job. It’s their responsibility to put the bad guy in jail. And all of our efforts, and our platitudes, about justice and truth are a big joke. It’s only defense lawyers who seem to think that there’s supposed to be some element of honesty when someone testifies under oath. Does that make us the fools?
A while back, I posted about a series of appellate decisions that showed how cops are treated differently by the courts. Was it wrong, or is there a secret handshake that defense lawyers don’t know about that let’s them into a back door at the courthouse where honesty is neither expected nor required?
Murray Kempton, who wrote a column for the New York Post, used to have a saying: “There they go again, lying to convict the guilty.” He got it. It wasn’t about guilt or innocence, but about telling the truth and letting the chips fall where they may. Yet jurors will accept the testimony of a police officer over anyone else almost every time. Yes, there are rare exceptions, but even when they admit that the cops testimony smelled, or it was clear that the cop was making stuff up to cover the gaps in the case, they will assume that the cop is on the side of the angels and that the defendant wouldn’t be sitting there unless he had done something worthy of conviction. Forget the process, it’s the end that counts.
So instead of this story being another nail in the coffin of dishonest police work, or a process that encourages lies and deception to make sure that the bad guy goes down, it’s nothing more than a mere footnote in a minor story. I’m waiting for the day that they change the slogan above the courthouse from “Equal Justice For All” to “The Ends Justify The Means.” At least that would be honest.
Parting Words
When, after saving your client many months of freedom, your client’s parent tells you, “I don’t think you did a very good job representing my son,” you do not get to reply, “I don’t think you did a very good job raising him.”
Very funny retort, but the humor masks a truth. Two truths, in fact. First, the expectations of a criminal defense lawyer. Second, the denial of personal responsibility for what happened.
People don’t retain criminal defense lawyers because life is going swell. They come to us after the shit has hit the fan, and they need the services we provide. Despite my skill at stating the obvious, clients often don’t see it this way. Almost immediately, they demand that we explain and justify the system that brought them to us, as if we were personally responsible for their current problem.
Some lawyers try to soothe the client at this moment, speaking kind words in soft tones. It’s a way to calm their frayed nerves while deflecting their misdirected anger away from the lawyer. Others will sit them down and have a frank discussion of how they came to find themselves in a lawyer’s office. They will detail what they did wrong and how it was their conduct, not the lawyer’s, that brought them to this point.
This talk isn’t what the clients want to hear. Some already know it, but would rather deny it. Others have spent their entire lives in denial, seeing consequences as a product of bad luck or external failures. Most fall into the latter category.
The exception, of course, is the professional criminal. He is a businessperson, whose business happens to be against the law. He knows it and understands that there are risks involved. He sees the law and the lawyer as a cost of doing business, and has made a conscious decision that the benefits outweigh the risks. He has no immature vision of what the system offers him or what a lawyer can do for him. He wants the best result he can get, but realizes that there are no guarantees of outcome.
Getting back to Skelly, who deals in the painful underbelly of criminal law, the juvenile “justice” system, his “thoughtful” response to the parent’s unappreciative comment was left unsaid. In the comments to his post, Skelly explains further that his right to speak stopped “just before my client’s dad’s fist comes flying toward my nose.” That’s a pretty clear image, and certainly changes the calculus. No, a little dose of truth isn’t worth a good punch in the nose.
While I don’t specialize in juvenile delinquency, I’ve done my share of representing kids, some of whom were well down the road to a life of crime and misery. As anyone who reads this blawg regularly knows, I have a serious soft spot when it comes to children. I do not accept the “kids are just small, evil adults” theory. As a person, and as a society, we cannot give up on children that easily.
Many years ago, I had a mother and son come into my office. The kid was breaking into cars to see that he could steal. The mother, kind and distraught, worked to survive as a single parent, and lost control of her son to the streets. She knew it, but didn’t know what to do about it. When the mother looked at me, it was not just about helping her son out of his current mess, but about helping her son to survive. She knew that he needed someone to teach him how to fish.
I sat the kid down and started to tell him that he was a lousy thief. He just wasn’t good enough. He was a failure as a thief, as a criminal, and he would never amount to a big man on the street. I was gaining momentum, my voice getting louder. I reamed him good. He became a model client, though it by no means meant that I got through to him. They tend to listen for a while, then lapse back into their world once I become a distant memory, if they think of me at all. Later, I beat his case. Mom was very appreciative, but that was only a small battle in a bigger war. She sent me a thank you note, but I never heard from her again after that.
Cut to a few years ago. I step into the elevator in my building and a young black man gets in with me. The guy is staring at me. Intensely. He asks, “Are you Greenfield?” “Uh oh,” I think to myself. Here I am alone in an elevator with this guy, and I have no idea who he is or how he knows me. Every client isn’t satisfied, and some witnesses for the prosecution really, really hate me. “Yes, I’m Greenfield,” I respond. So much for glib replies.
He was the kid. The little kid who was a lousy thief. He told me that my “lecture” made him realize that he couldn’t go on being a thief and had to become something. He finished school and had gotten himself a job. Not a great job, but an honest job. He didn’t have a gold and diamond necklace or drive a BMW like the drug dealers, but he was happy and proud of himself. He never got into trouble again. He put out his hand in that elevator, and thanked me.
I guess the whole story could have ended with a punch in the nose as easily as a handshake. But it was not only one of those moments that make you feel that you haven’t wasted your life, but one that made you feel that it was worth the risk of a punch in the nose.
Role Reversal: The Law Review Shakedown
So it is with abject fascination that I read Professor Daniel Solove write about the law review season. First, I didn’t even know that there was such season. If there are no shoulder pads involved, the seasons all blend together for me. But apparently not only is there a season, but it is one where the professors are the players and the law students, hereinafter referred to as Your Royal Highness, Law Review Editor Sir, set the rules of the game.
Wow, the glee on those editors faces as the law professors scramble for position, jockeying their articles into place to be the first to get published by the Biglaw Schools. You know, the law reviews that really count because all the other law professors want to get published there.
My, how the playing field levels. The letter quoted in the post is downright casual, with some law review editor talking to a person who needs her far more than she needs him. The letter makes that pretty clear. Oh, to be a law review editor during the fall season. I wonder, do the professors send candy or cookies with their submission? It couldn’t hurt.
I’m not denigrating legal scholarship, unless it involves Harry Potter. Indeed, I love law review articles, particularly those demonstrating a deeper understanding of how appellate courts are influenced by totally extraneous factors so that their platitudes take on the fuller meaning of harsh reality and personality quirks. But given the publish or perish demands of higher education, it is a sweet irony that these third year students get to wrap their dirty little hands around the throats of accomplished professors and squeeze. Just a little.
And before anybody asks, I was never on law review. I worked for a living to make it through law school, and such unpaid endeavors left me with an unpleasant taste in my mouth. It was the taste of hunger, and I didn’t care for it.
These law review editors should enjoy this brief moment in the sun, when they have the opportunity for a little payback for the Socratic method. In a year, they will be trying to work 7200 billable hours into the year, with a lot of other lawyers telling them how high to jump. The bucolic summer intern days will be nothing more than a fond memory as the crack of the whip snaps them out of their reverie. Enjoy making those professors miserable now, Your Highnesses, as the glory fades quickly once you’re out in the real world.
Junk Science and Little Black Boxes
And the funny part about it is, neither does anyone else in the courtroom. We all pretend otherwise, but the truth is that the witnesses (whether cop or expert) are just making noise about how things work and why they are valid. And not being experts ourselves, there’s little that we can do to stop them. Most of the time.
But there’s a lawyer in Minnesota named Jeffrey Sheridan who has decided that he’s had it. The little black box, affectionately known as the “breathalyzer”, tells us whether a driver has a blood alcohol content in excess of a tiny number that some legislator decided was the difference between going to jail and going home to sleep it off.
How does that little black box do it? I don’t know. Jeffrey doesn’t know. The judges of the Minnesota Supreme Court don’t know. And yet this pervasive ignorance hasn’t stopped anyone from locking people up because of it. That’s some powerful box.
Jeffrey has obtained a ruling allowing him to get the “source code” for some antiquated chip that makes the black box buzz. “Among other things, for example, their operation and computation of blood alcohol levels is controlled by an old Z-80 microprocessor — an historical antique that used to drive the original Pong computer game.” A Z-80 microprocessor? That sure sounds like an antique to me. I would have thought it would be a Z-97 microprocessor by now. Or maybe even a Z-342. There are so many numbers to chose from. But I remember pong. It’s such a quaint game.
The company that makes the breathalyzer, from Kentucky, won’t give up the source code. They say it’s proprietary. I guess all the other breathalyzer wannabe companies are dying to get their hands on the code that drives the pong chip. You can’t be too careful with your source code.
Now I don’t know exactly what a source code is, or how Jeffrey is going to gain a fuller insight into the accuracy or failing of the breathalyzer by having the source code. But I am willing to assume that he’s got his reasons. The fact that the Minnesota Supreme Court ruled in his favor after a full exploration of the matter tends to support his purpose, and the fact that the Kentucky company isn’t giving it up makes it even more imperative.
According to the Jeffrey Sheridan, however, while the Minnesota Supreme Court has ordered the state to hand it over, the state doesn’t have it and the company (not a party to the proceeding) isn’t about to do so. When will he get that source code in his grubby little lawyer hands? “I guess the answer is probably never.”
And so the Minnesota Supreme Court has forbidden the use of the breathalyzer until the source code is provided, competently and properly tested and shown to be legally adequate to put men and women in jail! And other states have fallen right in line, acknowledging for years that they have accepted the accuracy of this silly little box as a substitute for evidence and locked away their citizens day after day without having the slightest clue whether it is sufficiently scientifically reliable! And the jails have flung their doors open, apologizing to the thousand and thousand of people who were convicted upon the proof of nothing more than a little black box that nobody really knows what it does!
Oh, come on. Next week, how does someone know that he has 0.08% BAC rather than 0.07% so that he possesses the mens rea to commit a crime.
Zero Tolerance and Why Magic Bullets Miss Their Mark
Culled from the engineering lexicon, the slogan “zero tolerance” was trotted out in 1973 as Watergate’s noose tightened and Nixon Justice Department officials needed a tough-sounding anti-crime slogan. In the ’80s, the Navy adopted ZT to add rhetorical muscle to a purge of seagoing potheads.
This little bit of info provides a perfect starting point for a discussion of how magic bullet solutions are born and why they become a facile substitute for solutions to problems, whether real or fabricated.
I don’t know when public policy became an exercise in marketing rather than governance, but it was a glorious day for public officials and those who disparately sought power. While recognizing that every American was unable to adequately research and test every hypothesis on how to address societal problems, there was in inherent integrity amongst public officials that pushed them to try to provide a correct answer. It was boring and tedious, and few people cared enough to follow the lines of reasoning, considering the implications and parse the unintended consequences.
It appears most likely that the general population believed that there was someone, somewhere, who went through political proposals to determine whether they had merit of were totally full of it. So, if a proposal made it out to the public from an upstanding politician, it had to have merit. After that, it was merely a matter of choosing between competing meritorious ideas to find the one that best suited one’s views, biases and self-interest.
Now the idea of treating the public like idiots was nothing new. P.T. Barnum made a fortune off it (I swear the Dog-Faced Boy is really half dog, half boy!), so it couldn’t have been the fact that no one knew that the public couldn’t be fooled. Rather, it must have been some invisible hand over the mouths of public officials whenever they were about to spew something truly foolish.
Perhaps it was when Sen. Joseph McCarthy got such great mileage out of his commie witch hunt that planted the seed. But of course, after ruining as many lives as possible, McCarthy crashed and burned, which might have scared off the more timid in Washington from trying.
Still, the magic bullet approach was recognized by H.L. Mencken, who wrote, “For every complex problem, there is a solution that is clear, simple and absolutely wrong.” And so, we arrive at the Nixon Justice Department and the adaptation of “zero tolerance” to the law.
From a marketing standpoint, ZT is perfect. Two words, no waiting. Clear message. Zero, nada, zip. Nothing whatsoever. Tolerance; a weakness, a shortcoming, An affront to that prong of the Puritan ethic of “spare the rod and spoil the child” (when was the last time you heard that one!). It was, in short, brilliant.
ZT captured the American demand for action. A problem was perceived (rampant crime) and a cure was needed. Instead, we got a slogan. But it was a great slogan.
The initial reaction was precisely what was intended. Zero tolerance became a rallying cry for politicians who wanted to capture the public’s attention. The public had “enough already” and demanded a fix. They had a fix to offer. The public “got it.” They liked it. It was strong, firm and clear. Enough already.
ZT required no long-winded speech to explain. Two seconds and it was clearly embedded in the mind of the listener. And it made sense, since the listeners’ concern was this vague perception of bad things happening that needed to stop happening. It was particularly useful when some horrific tragedy occurred that captured the publics’ interest, like the image of a beautiful flower girl on the way home from a wedding having been decapitated by a drunk driver. This image demands action. And there’s always someone willing to fill the order.
But what happens a short while later, when ZTs flaws come to the surface. Consider the Oregon boys who were going to be prosecuted for “swatting” girls on the behinds, and charged with felony sexual assault. Their case was just dismissed, a hue and cry over the ridiculous outcome of turning two red-blooded American boys into sex offenders for the rest of their lives over such a silly incident.
What happened to zero tolerance of sex offenses? Well, it turns out that ZT is only as good as the public’s need to vent based on the particulars of the case and the desirability of the outcome. Wait a second. If that’s true, then it’s the opposite of ZT. It’s . . . it’s . . . it’s . . . oh my God, there’s no really catchy phrase.
So there is no public backlash against ZT, or its idiot cousin, “three strikes and you’re out,” even though the examples of why it fails miserably to answer the pressing public concerns are abundant. There’s no quick, easy phrase to promote its opposite. The poor public has nothing to grasp on to, to seize as a substitute for its next magic bullet, actual justice based upon the changing face of facts and circumstances. Sure, try putting that on a license plate.
Remarkably, few have put together the fact that the public doesn’t really want zero tolerance applied. Indeed, they want a sui generis review of each case for its propriety and proportionality based upon basic notions of right and wrong. They can tell when things get stupid, and they bristle like those of us who are, ahem, more sensitive to these issues. But they still love the marketing slogan. It’s that good.
So it’s time to fight fire with fire. What we need to start a return to reason is an even better marketing slogan than zero tolerance. Something that conveys the message in less than 3 second with strong, clear words that express the need for a deeper understanding and acceptance of complex ideas. Anybody?
Forget Star Jones, Meet Star Polygraph
While I am not clear on what is meant by increasingly difficult personal questions (like, do you know your middle name? What size belt do you wear? Have you ever had bovine sex?) that the contestants don’t know the answers, I gather that this will be show designed to ask embarrassing questions to see if they can get truthful answers. And the poly proves it!
Is this a problem? Absolutely, according to Bluhn Blog. There’s the fear of the American Polygraph Association that this show will reinforce the stereotype that lie detectors are pseudoscience (or voodoo, as I prefer). Then there’s the polar extreme fear, that poly’s are infallible, since the show doesn’t work unless the lie detector is beyond challenge. Any way you look at it, this show has the potential of influencing the public’s perception of polygraphs one way or the other, but certainly not educating anyone on its potential for abuse in inducing false confessions.
Personally, I see no more harm in this show than in letting thousands (hundreds?) of potential members of jury pools watch Star Jones discuss the law. This world is replete with thoughtless, vapid and simplistic discussion of complex and important issues, mostly for the purpose of personal entertainment and amusement. So now we can add polygraphs to the mix.
Maybe one day they will have a game show where they will pick members of the public and let them decide whether another human being should live or die. Hey, we already have that. It’s called a jury trial.
Aside: A Commentary About Controversy
When posting an article on a blog, I’m caught between the need to explain myself within an inch of my life so that every reader understands my point and attributing to the reader a certain level of intelligence and understanding so that I don’t have to explain every nuance or detail. Obviously, different readers come here with different experiences, sensibilities and levels of comprehension. That’s life in general, and it doesn’t change here.
A few days ago, I posted a cartoon that caused an uproar among women, most notably the Feminist Law Professors. They were highly offended by the cartoon, and felt no qualms in letting me know it. A bit overly sensitive? On the look-out for things that offend them? Clearly, which is too bad because it blinded them from the point of my posting. As I say, I can’t accommodate the level of sensitivity versus intelligence of every reader.
But this particular post brought some other very interesting reactions that I didn’t anticipate. I receive emails from people who were appalled at the knee-jerk reactions. I received emails from people who were as flagrantly sexist as the cartoon posted, who encouraged me to stand up for sexism. I received emails from people who thought I should burn in hell for having maligned women. I received a lot of emails.
Having realized that my point was missed by so many, and that the wrong message was received, I decided to remove the cartoon. That generated yet more emails about my being a wimp for caving in to the feminists. Of all the reactions I received, this is the one that pissed me off the most, and gives rise to this aside.
I have absolutely no qualms about expressing my views on a subject of controversy, and taking the heat for my opinions. I suffer no delusion that my views are universal, or that I am right about everything and anyone who disagrees is either wrong or a blithering idiot. Reasonable people can differ.
My analogy would be to lawyer jokes. Many lawyers hate them and are highly offended. Personally, I think some are incredibly funny, not because they are true (although sometimes the jokes can be much truer than we want to admit), but because of the way they reflect people’s perception of lawyers. I can laugh at myself, my profession and all of our foibles. I hope I never take myself so seriously, or become so pompous, that I can’t appreciate the humor of life, at its many levels.
However, the purpose of my posting a flagrantly sexist cartoon was not to show that I was anti-woman or sexist. That would have been much too superficial. It was just the opposite, though obviously too subtle for some to grasp. So while I will happily take the heat for things I believe, I have no interest in “catching sh*t,” as Gideon so aptly put it, for things I do not believe. Since the post did not serve its intended purpose, and in fact did just the opposite of what I intended, it was clear to me that I screwed up by posting it. And so poof, it’s gone.
Will I now “catch sh*t” for saying that some people were too dense to get it? Probably, but I will happily take the heat for that one. They didn’t. Were they so blinded by their knee-jerk sensitivity to the perceived slight that they couldn’t muster the depth of thought necessary. I’m sure they will let me know. Hopefully, they won’t be as vulgar this time. It’s not lady-like (that’s a joke. Get a sense of humor and maybe you’ll find that I’m not your enemy).
