Author Archives: SHG

Do You Wiki?

Scandal abrewing at Biglaw, according to Concurring Opinions and The Turk at New York Personal Injury Law.  It seems that Biglaw attorneys spend their days editing their firm’s Wikipedia listings to improve its marketing value, while playing with their competitors to mess with their heads.  Now, the CIA and Vatican are doing it too.  I’m not sure this means that the Vatican is editing Judaism to include the “Jews have horns” thing, but it certainly doesn’t sound right.

When Wikipedia first came on the scene, I wondered how it would  work, with a theoretical group of a zillion editors vying for supremacy.  The self-promotional opportunity was obvious, as was the tug of war to play with one’s adversary’s descriptions.  Would the self-monitoring model really work? 

Oddly, the fact that these various firms and entities all have an equal opportunity to help/hurt each other should be a deterrent.  It’s the nuclear option, which should theoretically result in a universal truce lest they all have to constantly monitor and edit and waste a ton of time just to keep things stable.  And posts like Co Op and Turk’s are here to keep them honest.

A few years ago, when I first went to look at Wikipedia, I found that it included a list of prominent lawyers known for litigation.  I was surprised to find that I was on the list.  And I admit it, I was flattered.  I went back from time to time, noting that my bio was edited by people I didn’t know to include things that were, well, unrecognizable.  Why did this happen?  My best guess was that people with too much time on their hands were just playing around.

Then one day, my name disappeared from the list, and was replaced by somebody I never heard of before. Well, he probably never heard of me either, and so it goes.  That’s the nature of the Wiki world.  But if anyone reading this feel neglected because they aren’t named in Wikipedia, go on over and put yourself in.  They say it’s against the rules, but if it’s good enough for Wachtel Lipton, it’s good enough for you.

The Law Belongs to Star

Lest we worry about poor Star Jones, former Brooklyn sex crimes assistant turned TV phenom during the OJ trial, when every attorney in the world was given a chance to do a stint as TV commentator, she’s landed on her feet.  Having gone from morbidly obese to morbidly peculiar, Star Jones will host a new daytime TV talk show on Court TV. 

After a nationwide contest for an imaginative, interest catching name, with a first prize of dinner with Star for 7 nights (second prize was 5 nights), the new show will be called “Star Jones” based on the single entry.  Seriously, Star tells whoever will listen that her live show will be about news, celebrity and the law.  Yes, the law.  Star remains deeply concerned about the state of the law in America, and believes that she will fulfill the need of educating a public that finds Nancy Grace too deep and demanding.

Although the show will be live, Star Jones says that there won’t be a studio audience.  The obvious reason is that the Court TV studios are large enough to hold three members of the public, provided two are very young children.  But Star says that there will be a fascinating interaction with members of the public via telephone, email and text messaging, provided that they have no way to throw things at her in person. 

“In the last year, not being on television every day, I found myself talking back to the TV, and the shows that kept my attention were the ones that engaged me.”  And that, kind readers, is as much as you need to know about Star Jones.  Anybody have the number for Bellevue handy?

Sleepless in New York

As reported in the New York Law Journal, Second Circuit Judge Rosemary Pooler went back to 1997 to decide whether a defendant, Alfonso Williams, was denied effective assistance of counsel when his lawyer, Syracuse attorney Stephen Lane Cimino, slept during his narcotics conspiracy trial. 

Judge Pooler found that Cimino “actively engaged in defending Mr. Williams, lodging objections and in cross-examination of witnesses making references to their direct testimony,” at the 11 week long trial.  The motion to vacate the conviction was denied.

Of course, Mr. Williams called 6 witnesses, all of whom testified that they observed Cimino sleeping for lengthy periods of time during the trial.  Mr. Cimino was also called as a witness, and testified that he remembered having a sinus headache during the trial and putting his head in his hands and squeezing to alleviate the pain.  He also remembered having an infection that caused loss of hearing in one ear.

And you thought things like this only happened in Texas.

A case like this reveals some disturbing problems with the criminal justice system.  First, as held by Judge Pooler, the level of representation necessary to provide effective assistance of counsel is so minimal that a sleeping lawyer can fulfill it.  Notably, it was not alleged that he slept every second of the trial, so there is nothing inconsistent about the fact that the lawyer engaged in cross and made an occasional objection and that his slept for lengthy period during the trial.  These are not mutually exclusive over the course of 11 weeks.

Second, the defendant produced 6 witnesses to testify that the lawyer was sleeping, and yet Judge Pooler sided with the lawyer (or circled the wagons might be a better description?).  This is the classic pissing match between lawyer and client, the one in which the client invariably loses, no matter how truthful he is or how much evidentiary support he can muster.  While we can talk about how this is all for the clients, notice how defensive lawyers and judges can be when the situation flips on its head and the lawyer comes under the microscope. 

So why would Judge Pooler ignore the 6 witnesses, ignore the impact of sleeping on the job, and deny the motion?  It might have something to do with the fact that she presided over the trial.  If the lawyer was asleep at her trial, shouldn’t she have notice?  Isn’t it the judge’s job to assure that every defendant’s 6th Amendment right to effective assistance of counsel is met?  Of course it is, and the fact that an attorney slept through large portions of a trial does not reflect well on the judge who allowed it, or worse yet, didn’t even notice.

Is it possible that the lawyer rendered effective assistant even though he slept?  it’s possible.  But it’s not good enough.  If he made 10 appropriate objections, what it he should have made 50?  If he asked 20 good questions on cross, what if he should have asked 100?  It’s not sufficient to speculate that the defendant received effective assistance.  It’s time to stop parsing the transcript to find a few good things the lawyer did to cover all the things that never happened because he was asleep.  Criminal defense lawyers should not sleep during trial.  Is that such a hard rule to follow?

And I don’t want to seem entirely unsympathetic to Mr. Cimino’s sinus headache problems.  I’m sure Mr. Williams would be happy to help him alleviate his pain by personally squeezing Cimino’s head.

An Interesting Choice by the New York Times

The Sunday Style section of the New York Times includes stories about the weddings of prominent New Yorkers.  It’s a throw back of sorts to the old society days, where the 400 needed to know what was happening with each others.  But this Sunday, the main wedding in the Times was a little different.

Instead of some socialite or celebrity, the Times wrote about the wedding of Donnie Andrews to Fran Boyd.  The names don’t sound familiar?  Well, Donnie was a convicted murderer, while Fran was a junkie.  As the Times noted, Donnie was “also a former heroin user,” so that we don’t miss a salient point.

Usually, these wedding announcements and stories talk about how the “groom attended Princeton” and the bride’s father is the “CEO of a major multinational conglomerate.”  Not this time.

The bride and groom have turned their lives around, and are now the models for characters in a new television show, which is the real reason why the Times notice them to begin with.  But it’s not a bad thing that a couple who came from such ignominious roots has made the Style Section.  They even made it big at  Gawker.com. Maybe there is hope.

Crawford’s Muddled Jurisprudence

Nicole Black at Sui Generis discusses the New York Court of Appeals decision in People v Nieves-Andino, 2007 NY Slip Op 05584, dealing with the evolving law surrounding the Supreme Court’s Crawford and Davis decisions.  Ironically, the decision comes from Judge Pigott, before whom I very recently argued for leave to appeal a Murder 1 and 2 case on Crawford grounds.  It appears from the Nieves Andino decision that leave was denied because the court was already inclined to go the expending exception route.  Darn activists.

In any event, the Nieves-Andino case uses the excited utterance hearsay exception to remove a victim’s statement to police identifying his attacker from the confrontation clause demands of Crawford.  Nicole opines that she agrees with the decision, since


It makes no sense to allow defendants to benefit from the death of their victim.  In other words, if the victim lives, the statement is admissible since the victim is available to be cross-examined, but if the defendant succeeds in the attempt to kill the victim, then the statement identifying the defendant.

From the perspective of result, one cannot argue with this point.  Rewarding a defendant for the death of a victim makes for a very poor incentive not to kill.  Clearly, the law should not provide incentives to kill victims rather than allow them to live.

But the good end result in one case often produces questionable law in others.  First, the Nieves-Andino rationale presumes the defendant’s guilt.  After all, it’s only a good result if the defendant is in fact guilty.  If he’s innocent, then it’s a very bad result. 

Consider a few facts changes:  The victim hated the defendant and would do anything to “get” him.  When the police inquire, the victim uses the opportunity to name his arch enemy. Bingo, intentional false ID.  But since this “excited utterance” of a now deceased victim come in without any Crawford issue, there’s no way for the defendant to challenge the victim’s deliberate misidentification.  Could this happen?

Consider further that the Court, in deciding to hold that this statement was “non-testimonial” and thus outside of the purview of the Confrontation Clause and Crawford, was compelled to attribute “primary motivation” to the cop in asking the question “who did this?”  According to the Court,

Given the speed and sequence of events, the officer could not have been certain that the assailant posed no further danger to Millares or to the onlookers. His brief solicitation of pedigree information and information about the attacker’s identity was part of Officer Doyle’s reasonable efforts to assess what had happened to cause Millares’s injuries and whether there was any continuing danger to the others in the vicinity. In other words, the primary purpose of his inquiry was to find out the nature of the attack, “so that he could decide what, if any, action was necessary to prevent further harm.”

This is a prime example of a court indulging in sheer speculation to attribute a facile motive to a police officer, and thus circumvent the law.  Does anyone really believe that the cop needed the identity of the killer in order to determine whether there was still a threat?  Puhlease.  He wanted to ID the perp. Nothing wrong with that, but let’s call it what it is.  Of course, then it is clearly testimonial and hence subject to Crawford.

Now that the court has stepped onto the slippery slope where victim responses to police inquiries identifying the attacker fall into the excited utterance exception, a harsh blow has been dealt to Crawford.  We can litigate excited utterances, but it’s a very subjective determination.  The line drawn in the sand has become very wiggly.

But, you say, here the victim died.  In the next case, where the victim will live because of this decision, the prosecution will have its witness and you will have your chance to cross.  So what’s your beef?  There are many reasons why a witness never makes it to the stand; whether it’s disappearance, subsequent unrelated death or unavailability for a plethora of reasons.  True, it is more likely that the witness will testify, but there will be cases where he or she won’t, and defendant’s will be constrained to challenge the hearsay of a cop because of this case.  While these cases may not number in the thousands, they still matter, particularly if you happen to be the defendant or a loved one.  Also if you happen to be the defendant’s lawyer.

Crawford, like Booker and others, had the potential to bring about monumental change in the fairness and propriety of criminal trials.  It held such promise.  But like Booker, Crawford is being whittled away, chip by chip, until we end up right back where we started.  Rather than offer a challenge to the prosecution to convict based on good evidence after providing a defendant with the rights intended to be given by the Constitution, it offers a challenge to courts to come up with new, imaginative ways to circumvent a defendant’s right.  It’s a shame to watch this happen, and it happens all the time.

Can Scoundrels Steal Clients?

Following Shawn Matlock’s plaintive post about scoundrel lawyers, and my follow-up,  Mark Bennett jumped in to discuss an important tangent.  While Shawn bemoaned the existence of lawyers (who he calls “Weinsteins”) who will say or do anything to get client, then take their money and run as soon as he can get a plea, Mark notes that the flip side is that a case belongs to the client, not the lawyer, and the client is free to seek a different lawyer at any time.

The choice of who will defend someone belongs entirely to the defendant.  The lawyer has nothing whatsoever to say in the matter.  While the lawyer’s feelings may be hurt, or he may feel that the client has made a poor choice, clients are entitled to hurt the lawyer’s feelings and make poor choices.  It is, without reservation, a choice that belongs solely and exclusively to the client.  For better or worse, it is his or her life.  He or she will live with the consequences of the choice.  The only caveat here is that we’re talking about retained cases, not assigned or PD, where different rules apply.

There are any number of reasons why a client would decide to retain other counsel.  It could be about money or about a bad mix of personalities.  Perhaps there has been a loss of faith, whether justified or not.  A client’s trust is crucial to a lawyer’s ability to defend.  There must be meaningful communication between the two, and there must be a sufficient level of trust if the lawyer is to be effective.  When there is war between lawyer and client, the defense will inevitably suffer.

But Mark also seizes upon a sentence in Shawn’s post that he even known Weinstein to steal clients, and writes:

I am with Shawn most of the way. I’m hugely frustrated by the hacks who, to get hired, make promises they can’t keep. They are doing a huge disservice to the clients, to the bar, and to the profession. But I don’t believe that one lawyer can steal another’s clients.

I believe that Mark is referring to the fact that “stealing” suggests taking something that he has no right to take, and since the case belongs to the client and not the lawyer, it is something that cannot be stolen.  While certainly true in a definitional sense, I don’t know if Mark has seen some of the things that happen in New York from time to time.  I feel comfortable calling it stealing.

There are lawyers roaming the hallways of New York’s citadels of justice trolling for clients.  There are lawyers who go into the jails, both state and federal, and bring down defendants with new cases whom they’ve never met before and who have never requested a meeting with them.  There are lawyers who pay defendants a bounty to convince new defendants, including those who are already represented, to hire them.  There are lawyers who pay the hot dog vendor outside the courthouse for referrals.  I call these lawyers the “vultures”.

New York lawyers can be very aggressive in their approach to getting new cases.  Perhaps (and I hope this is true) Houston lawyers don’t do these things.  But I call this type of conduct stealing clients.  Note, we’re not talking about lawyers who have received a phone call from the family or the defendant, asking for a visit.  We are talking about defendants being brought in cold, thinking that their lawyer would be there in the visiting room only to find someone they don’t know at the table, telling them tall tales about what they can do for them.

Again, Mark is correct when he writes that there is no ethical prohibition against meeting with a defendant who has sought a meeting, even though he is already represented by another lawyer.  It is the client’s right to change, even if he’s shopping for a bargain, testing the waters or just trying to get a second opinion.  But when a lawyer pro actively approaches another lawyer’s client without invitation, he’s crossed a huge ethical chasm.  It may not be “stealing” in a penal sense, but it is most definitely stealing in an ethical sense.  Perhaps “raiding” is a better word.  Regardless of what word you prefer, it’s wrong.

Like Mark, I generally find myself in the position of being the new lawyer rather than the old.  My experience is that this is due to the need to find a lawyer fast following an arrest, and that they’ve made an ill-advised choice.  After some research and discussion, they find out about me and give me a call.  There is also a tendency to go with an inexpensive lawyer to find out if the arrest is “serious” before going for the more serious, and more expensive, lawyer.  This second reason presents numerous problems due to lost opportunity, but we work with what we have and can’t make the past go away.  It’s better to move forward in the right direction than keep doing the wrong thing as a result of inertia.

When the clients comes, we don’t trash talk the old lawyer.  We don’t undercut his fees to get a case.  We don’t chastise the client for a foolish or knee-jerk decision.  We look at the case and offer the best advice we can as to what can be done to help.  Sometimes, the advice is to stay with the current lawyer, whether because we can’t do anything to help or because the client’s desire to change lawyers is based upon a misapprehension that the old lawyer “didn’t do anything.” 

The client’s expectations or perception of the old lawyer may have been wrong, and the lawyer has done, and is doing, exactly what he should be doing.  While I don’t turn this client away if he insists, I try to let him know that his unhappiness with the old lawyer is based on misperception, and that his lack of confidence in the old lawyer is based on misunderstanding, not poor lawyering.

Why tell a potential client to give his old lawyer another chance?  Because we live in a community of people who hope are honorable, and we choose to be honorable as well.  I choose not to be a vulture, even though it could put money in my pocket.  I won’t steal another lawyer’s client.  But if a client decides that I am a better fit for his needs, and I can do something to help, I will accept his case.

Is This Sexist?

While some people understood the point of the original post, in that the humor of an old cartoon was so blatantly sexist that it was funny because of its flagrant sexism, it has offended others and that was never its purpose.  So, it’s best that I remove it and apologize to those who were offended. 

Competing With Scoundrels

Shawn Matlock (long lost son of TV’s Matlock, his denials notwithstanding), posts about A Lawyer Known As Weinstein.  The name Weinstein comes from a TV show called “Entourage,” hailing back to Shawn’s childhood roots in television, where he watched passionately to see his father perform.  Weinstein is a scoundrel.  Matlock (the father) was not.

This particular post by Matlock appears driven by the fact that Weinstein stole a client.  Since Shawn has neglected to share all the particulars, I’ll take some literary license to fill in the blanks.  weinstein undercut the fee (He charged you what!  Are you kidding, nobody charges more than $1500 for a murder case!) and promised an outcome (It’s no big deal, I’ve beaten a hundred murder cases where the eyewitness was a priest).  The defendant, a ferverent believer in the fungibility of lawyers, decided to make a change based on these minor representations.

Shawn was sitting at his desk, pondering how exactly he’s going to impeach the credibility of this priest, when the telephone call (or letter, pick’em) arrived.  “I’ve been retained, send me the file.”  Ouch.  He thought he had established a good relationship with the client.  He put in his time, did his work, cared.  And still the defendant pulled out.  But he added insult to injury by going to Weinstein.  He left a guy who was prepared to fight for him for a guy who would glom the money, plead him out as soon as he could and run away.  it’s a blow to the ego, and every criminal defense lawyer has a bit of an ego thing going, since there’s no way you can stand up to every cop, prosecutor and judge telling you you’re wrong constantly unless you believe in yourself.

Here’s the rub.  Honest lawyers are at a severe disadvantage.  We can’t lie to our clients.  We can’t tell them stuff that’s just plain false to get their money.  We can’t stroke them to get their case.  Honesty is an article of faith, and we must tell the truth.  Clients don’t always like the truth.  Clients often like the lies much better, because the lies are what they want to hear.  And so, the lawyer with integrity is left holding the bag while the lying scoundrel lawyer, the Weinsteins, hold the money.

In quiet moments, I muse about the amount of money I could have stolen from clients and potential clients if I would only be willing to lie.  I know what they wanted to hear.  I know the sweet words, whispered in their ear, that would have made me fortunes.  It would be so easy.  Just say the words, Greenfield.  Just softly speak the words that the defendants, their wives or husbands, their mommies want to hear.  They sit there, on the edge of their seats, ready to give up every penny they have to save their loved one, if only you would say the words.

But of course, I can’t.  Some would call me foolish.  Weinstein would call me foolish.  But there are very few things I have that cannot be taken away.  One of those things is my integrity.  It’s mine and you can’t take it.  Telling the truth to my clients is simply what I do.  If it costs me a fee, so be it. 

I would like to think that the Weinsteins can’t sleep out night, tossing and turning out of guilt for the theft of people’s hopes and money through their lies.  But truthfully, I think they sleep like babies.  They feel no remorse at all, and will wake up the next day to do it all over again.  What did you expect Shawn?  A fairytale with a happy ending?  That’s the problem with the truth; it doesn’t always end up the way you want.

Conflict Aversion and Personality Traits

It’s a lazy Sunday morning, so why not take a few moments to reflect on this week’s lessons.

Over the past few days, Mark Bennett, Gideon and I have hosted a moving crap game on the issue of criminal defense lawyer ethics.  To many, the heated debate would be uncomfortable if not intolerable because most people are conflict averse.  They can’t stand conflict.  They can’t deal with conflict.  They do anything in their power to stay as far away from conflict as they possible can.

I have seen (as no doubt everyone else reading this) people give up their rights, their interests and their happiness in order to let someone else have their way, so that they do not become embroiled in conflict.  One of my dearest friends, who is a very smart and savvy person otherwise, will find almost any excuse to not go to war.  One of his favorite lines is “pick your battles.”  Of course, he’s yet to find a battle that’s worth the fight.

The consequence of conflict aversion is that whoever takes the first strong position tends to win the day, no matter whether he’s right or wrong.  Oftentimes, this produces some very weird and wrong results, making the conflict averse cringe privately but publicly non-committal.  Their problem is that there is no way to challenge the decision without asserting themselves and thereby creating a conflict.  And they will do anything to make that no happen.

Another consequence, however, is the conflict averse people tend to be well-liked.  This makes perfect sense, as the rarely if ever offend anyone by challenging or disputing others.  People like that.  They like people who they perceive as agreeing with them.  They attribute good characteristics to people who they believe agree with them.  Or at least, they don’t attribute negative traits.  Ironically, we often find conflict averse people in positions of higher authority, less as a result of their positives than lack of negatives. 

A great criminal defense lawyer, as shown by this week’s discussions, is rarely conflict averse.  It is not, as many assume, that we invite conflict or thrive on conflict.  While a simplistic understanding would tend to make that assumption appear likely, it’s inaccurate.  Conflict is like a busman’s holiday, we engage in it professionally, so it brings us little enjoyment as an advocation.  Indeed, when young people tell me that they want to be a lawyer because their friends tell them they like to argue too much, I tell them that the best lawyers only argue because they must, not because they derive amusement from it.

We avoid conflict when we can.  We search for mutual ground, things we can agree upon.  We know that there is far more to be accomplished through the mutuality of interests than through disagreements.  But, there is also some bone in our heads that won’t let us shy away from a fight.  When pushed, we push back if we believe it matters. 

This characteristic of criminal defense lawyers is misunderstood by the conflict averse.  For them, conflict is visceral and emotional.  They see it as a form of anger, perhaps even hatred.  It evokes a sort of adrenalin rush that clouds their reason.  To the averse, conflict is a creature of personal hostility.

Amongst criminal defense lawyers, conflict need not involve any emotional component at all.  It is just as likely, if not more likely, to be a purely intellectual exercise.  We disagree.  We challenge.  We dispute.  We do not hate the people with whom we disagree.  We can argue and debate all day long, and tell the each other that they’re absolutely wrong, while still liking and respecting them without reservation.  We simply disagree.

The conflict averse cannot comprehend how this could be possible.  It’s just not the way they feel, and like all people, project their understanding of the nature of people onto others.  Because of this, people who are willing to address conflict head on tend to be more difficult for the conflict averse to accept.  They attribute hostile traits to us because they can’t understand how we could be otherwise.  We make them uncomfortable.  They perceive us as always ready for a fight, rather than will to “pick our battles.” And we do tend to make enemies because we are not perceived as being “agreeable” sorts.

Mark, Gid and I are all on the same team, despite our heated debate on the nuances of ethical lawyering.  Our philosophies are very similar.  Our concerns and beliefs bolster one another.  We argued hard, but bear each other no anger.  If we didn’t exist in this blawgosphere, we would have had a beer after the argument and still told each other they were wrong.  And we would all be fine with it.

So if you’re looking for a pleasant dinner companion, or someone for support or with whom to commiserate, find a risk averse person.  They will tell you what you want to hear, and you will get the positive feedback that you seek.  But if you find yourself to be under the gun, the enemy of the state, the accused, get someone who will not hesitate to take up arms for your cause.  Even a moment’s hesitation in the face of conflict can mean the difference between success and failure. 

The ability and willingness to look conflict square in the face, from a rational and strategic perspective, may not always make us the most comfortable people to be around, but clearly makes us the type of lawyers you want to represent you when your life is on the line.

The Blight of the Jail House Lawyer

Malum in Se writes about how he finally met the “jailhouse lawyer.” 


He still thinks I don’t know what im talking about and left mumbling that he doesn’t know how I passed the bar.


This is funny stuff.  But representing the “jailhouse lawyer” falls into the category of A Little Knowledge is Dangerous, and learning how to explain things so that the client comes to the realization that a few weeks, even a few years, in the law library does not impart the level of understanding necessary to pretend you’re a lawyer.

But there’s another side of the “jailhouse lawyer” that Malum has yet to meet.  Inside (as people inside call it), being a jailhouse lawyer is a type of currency.  Inmates try to impress on another by their knowledge of the system, and their having “answers” to each others problems that creates a dependency.  I can’t remember how many times an inmate would tell me that some other guy inside told him about some magic way that he could cut his 25 year sentence to 366 days, and would I do it for him? 

This is a problem.  As we, lawyers try to advise our clients honestly and accurately, there’s some guy in a jail library somewhere whispering garbage into his ear.  We don’t know what’s being said, and thus can’t assess how it impacts on our advice and counsel.  We are fighting a battle, and don’t even know it.

There are times when our clients’ decisions seem detached from reality.  Are these just poor judgments, or is this the product of conflicted advice coming from multiple sources?  Sometimes our clients will tell us about what the jailhouse lawyer said.  Other times, it’s a big secret and the client doesn’t want us to know that he has somebody in the jail who is counseling him as to whether our representation is any good.

And why do inmates become jailhouse lawyers?  It gives them prestige with the institution; It provides them with a service to “sell”;  It offers them protection in a very dangerous place.  Truth be told, it’s not all negative, as other inmates who lack the resources to seek the advice of counsel turn to the jailhouse lawyers for lack of any other resource.  I’ve seen some who are actually pretty darn good, better than some real lawyers I’ve known.  Granted, these are very few and far between, but when the inmate has nowhere else to turn, what do you expect.  Nature abhors a vacuum, and there is a huge legal vacuum in prison where there just happens to be a whole lot of people obsessed with their legal rights.  Go figure.

But why would a client compare the advice of a lawyer with that of the jailhouse lawyer?  Because the latter frequently speaks to the client’s real desire.  The jailhouse lawyer offers simple answers to complex questions.  The jailhouse lawyer knows “secrets” that real lawyers conceal from all but their most important clients (and usually for a special fee).  The jailhouse lawyer tells the client what he wants to hear.  Real lawyers often have bad news to give.  Jailhouse lawyers tell others what they want to hear.

The response to most of this is fairly straightforward.  If the jailhouse lawyer really had these secrets, these magical “get out of jail free” cards, then why is he still there?